Loading record
Loading record
Background
Background explainers on terms, laws and procedures that come up in Dispute Index cases.
Defamation is a false statement of fact that harms someone's reputation, governed mainly by state law. Under New York Times Co. v. Sullivan (1964) and later cases, public officials and public figures must also prove actual malice: that the speaker knew the statement was false or recklessly disregarded whether it was.
10 casesAn AI agent is software built on an AI model that pursues a goal by taking actions, such as browsing websites, writing code or making purchases, rather than only answering questions. Because agents act with less human oversight, mistakes can cause harm before a person steps in.
5 casesArctic Frost is the FBI's name for an investigation opened in April 2022 into efforts to overturn the 2020 presidential election. Special counsel Jack Smith took it over that November. Republicans in Congress have challenged how it collected records, including members' phone records.
2 casesA conviction integrity unit is a team inside a prosecutor's office that re-examines convictions the office already won, mainly claims that an innocent person was convicted. Dallas County created the first in 2007, and the National Registry of Exonerations now lists more than 100.
1 caseUnder a 2023 Homeland Security policy, immigration agents may use deadly force only when they reasonably believe someone poses an imminent threat of death or serious injury. The policy bars shooting at a driver unless deadly force against that driver is itself justified.
22 casesA deepfake is AI-generated or altered audio, video or imagery that makes real people appear to say or do things they did not. No single U.S. law covers them. Many states regulate political deepfakes, federal rules reach AI robocalls and intimate images, and platforms set their own labels.
6 casesUnder the Constitution, state legislatures set the rules for congressional elections and Congress can change them. State and local officials, usually in counties, run the voting. Federal law adds some national rules, including limits on armed federal agents at polling places.
19 casesElection-night numbers are unofficial. Local officials finish the count, check it in a canvass and certify the results, and a state board or official then certifies the statewide result. Several states treat certifying as a required duty, and courts have ordered officials who refused or delayed to certify.
13 casesThe Epstein files are the Justice Department's and FBI's records on Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. A 2025 law ordered them released, with exceptions such as victims' privacy. The department says it complied; some lawmakers say it over-redacted, and a judge ordered it to review records it had set aside.
8 casesFair use is a defense in U.S. copyright law that permits some unlicensed uses of protected works, such as criticism, news reporting, teaching and research. Courts decide it case by case, weighing factors set out in the Copyright Act, including the purpose of the use and its effect on the market for the original.
8 casesA federal criminal law bars executive branch officials from taking part in government matters that affect their own finances or those of close family. Senior officials must also publicly report their assets and trades. The President and Vice President are exempt from that law but must still file the reports.
6 casesThe First Amendment bars the government from abridging the freedom of speech or of the press. It limits government, not private companies. Courts presume content-based laws and prior restraints unconstitutional, and only a few narrow categories, such as incitement, true threats and obscenity, fall outside it.
16 casesA U.S. terrorist designation is a State or Treasury Department finding that a group or person engages in or supports terrorism. It can freeze U.S. assets, bar non-citizen members from entry and, for a Foreign Terrorist Organization, make knowingly supporting it a federal crime.
7 casesThe Fourth Amendment protects people against unreasonable searches and seizures by the government. Courts generally require a warrant from a judge, based on probable cause, before officers search a home, with exceptions such as consent and emergencies.
12 casesFrontier AI safety means testing and limiting the most severe risks from the most capable general-purpose AI models. Safeguards include company commitments and legal requirements; their reach and enforcement remain disputed.
7 casesThe Hannibal Directive was an Israeli military order, drafted in the mid-1980s, that let troops use heavy force to stop a soldier from being captured, even if that force endangered the captive. Israel's military chief ordered it canceled in 2016.
1 caseThe 1939 Hatch Act limits partisan political activity by federal executive branch employees. They may not use their office to sway an election, seek political donations or campaign on duty. The President and Vice President are exempt. The Office of Special Counsel enforces it; the President disciplines top appointees.
6 casesEach chamber of Congress polices its own members. In the House, a bipartisan Ethics Committee investigates, including matters referred by the independent Office of Congressional Conduct. In the Senate, the Select Committee on Ethics does. Only the full chamber can expel or censure a member.
4 casesThe International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) is a 1977 law that lets the president block assets and bar transactions with foreign countries, groups and people after declaring a national emergency. It is central to U.S. sanctions. In February 2026 the Supreme Court ruled that it does not authorize tariffs.
4 casesImmigration detention is civil, not criminal. Federal law requires ICE to detain some noncitizens and lets it release others on bond. Since 2025 ICE has treated people who entered without inspection as ineligible for bond; most appeals courts have rejected that reading, and the Supreme Court has agreed to decide it.
13 casesAutomated license-plate readers are cameras that photograph passing vehicles, read their plates and log the time and place. Police check the reads against lists of wanted vehicles and can search the stored records later. No federal law governs their use, and state rules vary widely.
16 casesPickaxe Mountain is the nickname for Kuh-e Kolang Gaz La, a mountain about 2 km from Iran's Natanz enrichment site where Iran began a large tunnel complex in 2020. Iran has said it is for assembling centrifuges; some Western governments and analysts suspect it could hold enrichment. The IAEA has never inspected it.
1 caseThe Constitution gives Congress the power to impose duties, but Congress has passed laws letting the executive branch impose tariffs in set cases, such as national-security threats (Section 232), unfair foreign practices (Section 301) and discrimination against U.S. commerce (Section 338). Each sets its own conditions.
3 casesA sanctuary policy is a state or local rule that limits how police, jails or other agencies help federal immigration enforcement, such as declining ICE detainer requests or limiting data sharing. No federal law defines the term, and governments and advocates apply it differently.
8 casesThe Supremacy Clause in Article VI of the Constitution makes federal law the supreme law of the land. Courts read it to bar states from regulating the federal government directly or discriminating against it, though states may refuse to help enforce federal law.
8 casesThe War Powers Resolution is a 1973 law that requires the president to report to Congress within 48 hours of sending U.S. forces into hostilities and to end their use within 60 days unless Congress authorizes it. Presidents of both parties have called parts of it unconstitutional.
8 cases