Case history
Recent changes
Read additions and corrections to published cases, newest first.
Added to the site
Statement from U.S. Department of Homeland Security
DHS says detainees have several ways to communicate with their family members and lawyers and that the appropriate process for people with final deportation orders is removal.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Jacquelynne J. Bowman
Bowman says no one should lose a meaningful chance to defend their rights because the government has made it impossible for their lawyer to find them, and calls the change arbitrary.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Michelle Mendez
Mendez calls the change another iteration of disappearing people and asks why the United States would do something that would raise concern about rights and due process in another country.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Greg Chen
Chen says families fear their relatives have been deported and that the change has serious implications for lawyers' ability to contact clients and will interfere with the attorney-client relationship.
Statement made
Added to the site
Claim from U.S. Department of Homeland Security
Detainees with final deportation orders have several ways to communicate with their family members and lawyers, and the appropriate process for them is removal.
Claim made
Added to the site
Statement from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement
ICE says allegations that it took a third grader into custody to be placed in detention are false and calls any such suggestion a depraved attempt to smear its officers. It says the man who brought the boy could not establish legal guardianship, so ICE placed him with the Office of Refugee Resettlement to ensure his safety.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Alex Padilla
In a letter to Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Padilla and five other California Democrats say video footage appears to show restraints used on a child who seemed to pose no threat, raising serious questions about the handling of the incident. They ask where the boy is and how he will be reunited with his family.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Juan Vargas
Vargas says he is grateful the boy is home but that the custody should never have happened, that he has serious questions about how it was handled and that he will press the administration for answers.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Guerline Jozef
Jozef says the boy's custody is not child protection but state-inflicted trauma disguised as immigration enforcement, and that an 8-year-old should be in a classroom rather than taken away by armed federal agents.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Sean Elo-Rivera
Elo-Rivera says national attention makes it less likely the boy will fall through the cracks and calls the case a flashing red light about the inhumanity of how immigration enforcement is being carried out.
Statement made
Added to the site
Claim from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement
Because the man who brought the boy to his ICE check-in could not establish legal guardianship under the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act, the boy was an unaccompanied alien child, and ICE placed him in the care of the Office of Refugee Resettlement to ensure his safety.
Claim made
Added to the site
Statement from Eric Croft
Alaska Democratic Party chair Eric Croft says Sullivan voted to write himself a $500,000 check with taxpayer funds and is ready to do it again, in a party release about a proposed federal fund of nearly $2 billion.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Dermot Cole
Alaska columnist Dermot Cole writes that Sullivan voted to accept a $500,000 gift to himself and questions his office's account of when Sullivan learned of the provision.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Daniel S. Sullivan
Sullivan's spokesperson says he first learned of the provision while he and his staff were reading the bill to reopen the government, that he does not plan to sue and that he supports the House bill to repeal it.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Anna Paulina Luna
Rep. Anna Paulina Luna says the senators on a list she attaches, which includes Sullivan, slipped a provision into the bill to reopen the government that guarantees them $500,000 if the Justice Department settles their lawsuits, and she calls it self-dealing.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from John Thune
Senate Majority Leader John Thune says the provision letting senators sue over their phone data was never meant to enrich senators, that members would not keep damages under Senate rules, and that the measure is about accountability, not profit.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Martin Heinrich
Sen. Martin Heinrich says Republicans passed a funding bill that denies affordable health care to millions of Americans and also voted to provide millions of dollars to a few Republican senators in a taxpayer-funded cash grab.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Ron Wyden
Sen. Ron Wyden says the provision would give a windfall to a handful of Republican senators investigated in connection with January 6, 2021, and calls it a corrupt giveaway of taxpayer dollars.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from U.S. Department of Homeland Security
Asked by Dispute Index about the inspector general's referral, the Justice Department's review of Corey Lewandowski and whether it had reviewed contracts he worked on, a Department of Homeland Security spokesperson said the department does not comment on matters regarding personnel who are no longer with the agency.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Michael McFaul
In Trump waives the Graham Act's Russia sanctions
In an essay first published in The Dispatch and posted to his Substack on October 23, McFaul writes that Trump eased sanctions on Russian diesel and then waived most of the new sanctions and tariffs on Russia under the Graham Act. He argues that these moves will encourage Putin to keep fighting.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Rosie Zilifyan
Zilifyan says the suit concerns discrimination, harassment and retaliation in the workplace, that calling it lawfare is no defense, and that PragerU's statement does not address any allegation in the complaint and the company will have to answer the claims in court.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Xaviaer DuRousseau
Opening an interview with The Bulwark, DuRousseau says he faced discrimination at PragerU, that security threats against him were not taken seriously and were mocked, and that he was sent a video depicting his assassination.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Cam Newton
On his podcast, Newton asks why Arenas and Young said things that forced them to apologize, and whether they apologized because they meant it, because Curry called them out or because of Curry's standing in the game, asking whether they would have apologized to a less famous player.
Statement made
Added to the site
Statement from Stephen A. Smith
Smith says Arenas and other former athletes crossed the line in criticizing Ayesha Curry, that some people are special enough that their families deserve consideration before anyone criticizes them, and that Curry is such a person, while crediting Young and Acho for apologizing.
Statement made