All topics

Cybersecurity

Public disputes about the security of computer systems and data, including exposures of sensitive information, how researchers and companies report them, and how organizations and vendors respond.

Published coverage on this page: 4+ cases · 24+ statements. Statements are ordered newest first.

Topic updates

Follow this topic

Get free email updates about Cybersecurity. We will email you when we add or correct a case in this topic.

Enable JavaScript to request email updates about this topic.

We will send a confirmation email first. Every update email has a link to stop. How we handle your email.

Related cases

More cases

Statements

Filter by response label

Labels describe a response to the linked claim or the action explained in the statement summary. Choose one or more.

120 matching statements

Abigail Kunkler

Role at the time: Counsel at the Electronic Privacy Information Center, in an email to Dispute Index

Condemned

Statement summary

EPIC counsel Abigail Kunkler says Judge Cote's ruling is already a win for federal workers and that a preliminary injunction could help head off another breach. She says the ruling also matters for other federal agencies that had or have DOGE staffers.

Quotation excerpt

“the court already delivered a win for federal workers by declaring that DOGE's access was unlawful. The court's ruling suggests a preliminary injunction, and that could be a strong option for trying to head off this massive breach happening…”
Read full quotation
“the court already delivered a win for federal workers by declaring that DOGE's access was unlawful. The court's ruling suggests a preliminary injunction, and that could be a strong option for trying to head off this massive breach happening again.”
Read the full email
Hi Graham, I hope you're well. My name is Abigail Kunkler, I'm counsel at EPIC with expertise on government databases and a member of our litigation team. Happy to speak on the record regarding your questions. On your question regarding relief: the court already delivered a win for federal workers by declaring that DOGE's access was unlawful. The court's ruling suggests a preliminary injunction, and that could be a strong option for trying to head off this massive breach happening again. An injunction on OPM granting access to its databases without a demonstrated need that is narrowly defined (meaning limited in scope, ability, and duration) would go a long way in keeping people out of information systems they have no business accessing. Regarding the ruling's importance for other agencies, Judge Cote's ruling absolutely matters for other federal agencies that had or have DOGE staffers. Judge Cote discusses the privacy and information security violations that occurred because OPM moved so quickly and with reckless disregard to the law's protections for individuals' information. OPM was not the only agency to disregard policy in favor of speed when granting access. And, as the judge notes, the expiration of the DOGE TO doesn't discount the possibility that this harm reoccurs; that could be at OPM or other agencies. We aren't out of the woods yet. Best, Abigail Kunkler (she/her) EPIC Counsel Electronic Privacy Information Center
Emailed comment from Abigail Kunkler of EPIC to Dispute Index on Judge Cote's Privacy Act ruling on OPM and DOGE · Abigail KunklerEmail to Graham Weller of Dispute Index, November 13, 2026

What this label refers to

The case concerns OPM's decision to give DOGE agents access to federal personnel records. Kunkler calls the access unlawful and a massive breach and backs an injunction to stop it happening again, which condemns the conduct under scrutiny.

Katharine Schwab

Role at the time: Forbes assistant managing editor and co-author of its TikTok investigation, interviewed on the National Crime Prevention Council's podcast

Condemned

Statement summary

Interviewed on the National Crime Prevention Council's podcast, Forbes editor Katharine Schwab, who co-reported its TikTok investigation, says TikTok has made deliberate moves to profit from scam advertising and calls that problematic.

Quotation excerpt

“I think, you know, that's that feels like a pretty a pretty obvious thing that you shouldn't be profiting off of illegal activity. you know, I think TikTok's response would be, well, we do a lot, like we're trying, but this is a huge…”
Read full quotation
“I think, you know, that's that feels like a pretty a pretty obvious thing that you shouldn't be profiting off of illegal activity. you know, I think TikTok's response would be, well, we do a lot, like we're trying, but this is a huge problem. but I think the reality is is that they have kind of made deliberate moves to profit off of this. and, you know, I think that's that's problematic.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)The Explosion of Tik Tok Scams, True Crime Prevention Podcast transcript · National Crime Prevention CouncilFull transcript

What this label refers to

The reference point is whether TikTok weakened its scam-ad enforcement, as Forbes reports. Schwab, who co-reported the investigation, says TikTok made deliberate moves to profit from scam ads and calls that problematic, which criticizes the weakened enforcement, so we labeled it Condemned. The closest competing label is Mixed, because she anticipates TikTok's argument that it is doing a lot against a huge problem; she rejects that argument, so it loses.

Logo of National Crime Prevention Council

National Crime Prevention Council

Role at the time: Executive director Paul DelPonte, hosting the council's True Crime Prevention podcast

Condemned

Statement summary

Hosting the council's podcast with Forbes editor Katharine Schwab, National Crime Prevention Council executive director Paul DelPonte says the council received calls about fake ads before TikTok changed its policy and that the problem has grown exponentially worse since.

Quotation excerpt

“We got calls before they changed their policy, and we put something out which you included in your story, and we thank you for that. To keep shining the light on them because this was a problem. Fake ads were a problem before they changed…”
Read full quotation
“We got calls before they changed their policy, and we put something out which you included in your story, and we thank you for that. To keep shining the light on them because this was a problem. Fake ads were a problem before they changed their policy. Now it's grown exponentially worse.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)The Explosion of Tik Tok Scams, True Crime Prevention Podcast transcript · National Crime Prevention CouncilFull transcript

What this label refers to

The reference point is whether TikTok weakened its scam-ad enforcement, as Forbes reports. DelPonte says fake ads were already a problem before TikTok changed its policy and have grown exponentially worse since, which criticizes the weakened enforcement, so we labeled it Condemned. The closest competing label is Mixed, because he notes the problem predates the change; he presents the change as making it worse, so it loses.

Simon Noël

Role at the time: Intelligence Commissioner of Canada, in opening remarks to the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs

Mixed or conditional

Statement summary

Testifying on Bill C-22, Intelligence Commissioner Simon Noël, who would review the public safety minister's orders to service providers, welcomes the House amendments limiting orders to two years. He asks the Senate committee to consider requiring the minister to weigh proportionality and reasonable alternatives before issuing a confidential order.

Quotation excerpt

“Nothing prevents the Minister from addressing these questions. But the Bill does not clearly require their consideration. If the intent of ministerial orders is to respond to situations where confidentiality is necessary, a clear…”
Read full quotation
“Nothing prevents the Minister from addressing these questions. But the Bill does not clearly require their consideration. If the intent of ministerial orders is to respond to situations where confidentiality is necessary, a clear proportionality factor that includes reasonable alternatives would ensure the Minister explains this need.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Remarks to the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs - November 2, 2026Opening remarks, paragraphs 6 to 8 (check against delivery)

What this label refers to

Noël accepts the role the bill gives him and welcomes the House changes, but says the bill should expressly require the minister to justify confidential orders as proportionate, so we labeled it Mixed or conditional.

Chris Canal

Role at the time: EquiStamp co-founder

Mixed or conditional

Statement summary

Canal says the forecast is maybe a little earlier than his own estimate. He says Anthropic very likely has employees with frontier research information he lacks and could be predicting better.

“So they very well could be making better predictions.”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)What happens when AI starts self-replicating?Bailey and Canal interviews

What this label refers to

Canal gives a slightly later personal estimate while allowing Anthropic's better information could support its forecast.

Michael Bailey

Role at the time: Georgia Tech cybersecurity professor

Challenged the characterization

Statement summary

Bailey says AI models could eventually self-replicate but argues that the demonstrated sharding and device setup do not amount to full worm propagation. He says the eventual form and consequences of self-replicating models remain an open question.

“The framing is somewhat of a misnomer, because they're doing things like sharding.”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)What happens when AI starts self-replicating?Bailey and Canal interviews

What this label refers to

Bailey disputes the self-replication characterization while accepting future AI botnets as plausible.

Logo of Binance

Binance

Role at the time: Cryptocurrency exchange

Defended or excused

Statement summary

Binance says it has reserved more than $6.34 billion of company funds to cover the incident and is buying the remaining affected tokens.

“Binance has already reserved over $6.34B of company funds to cover this incident.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Binance says it reserved over $6.34 billion in company funds · BinancePost at 10:55 UTC

What this label refers to

Relative to the public assurances that users' losses would be covered, Binance stands behind the promise and describes the company funds it has set aside for it.

Portrait of Molly White

Molly White

Role at the time: Independent writer and cryptocurrency researcher

Condemned

Statement summary

White questions why Zhao, whom she describes as barred from any control over Binance, is the one promising that losses will be covered.

“Why a person who is barred from any control over Binance would be the one promising this is an exercise I will leave to the reader.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)North Korea gets away with $3 billion from Binance · Molly WhiteZhao assurance quotations and the paragraph questioning his role

What this label refers to

Relative to the assurances that users would be covered, White criticizes Zhao for giving them, pointing to what she describes as a bar on his control of Binance.

Logo of U.S. Department of the Treasury

U.S. Department of the Treasury

Role at the time: U.S. Department of the Treasury, through an unnamed official whose email is reported by FedScoop

Defended or excused

Statement summary

A Treasury official cites security in response to concerns about TreasuryDirect's ID.me requirement.

“Action: A Treasury official described ID.me in an email as protection against unauthorized access and identity theft.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Treasury and ID.me respond to senators' concernsTreasury and ID.me emailed responses reported by Matt Bracken

What this label refers to

The Treasury response defends the chosen sign-in tool on security grounds.

Logo of ID.me

ID.me

Role at the time: Company spokesperson in an emailed response to FedScoop

Defended or excused

Statement summary

In the TreasuryDirect dispute, ID.me says it outperforms alternatives on service, access and fraud prevention.

“has consistently outperformed alternatives in customer service, ease of use, expanding access, protecting taxpayer data, and fighting fraud”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Treasury and ID.me respond to senators' concernsTreasury and ID.me emailed responses reported by Matt Bracken

What this label refers to

The company defends the choice of its service on usability, access, security and fraud prevention.

Portrait of Ron Wyden

Ron Wyden

Role at the time: U.S. senator from Oregon, jointly with Senator Elizabeth Warren

Condemned

Statement summary

Ron Wyden and Elizabeth Warren oppose the mandatory private-provider login.

“Americans should not have to provide sensitive personal information to ID.me as the price of accessing essential government services”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Wyden and Warren request delay of TreasuryDirect ID.me requirementJoint release, quoted letter and requested actions

What this label refers to

The senators expressly reject making private-provider disclosure the price of access and request delay.

Portrait of Dick Durbin

Dick Durbin

Role at the time: U.S. senator and lead cosponsor, in a statement quoted by Roll Call

Defended or excused

Statement summary

Durbin welcomes legislative routes to enact STOP CSAM during the lame-duck session.

“During the lame duck, I welcome all avenues to push the STOP CSAM Act across the finish line.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Online exploitation bill backers gear up for lame-duck pushDurbin statement and NDAA discussion

What this label refers to

Relative to the proposal under scrutiny, Durbin expressly advocates its passage.

National Center on Sexual Exploitation

Role at the time: Nonprofit advocacy organization, through president Richie Hamm

Defended or excused

Statement summary

NCOSE supports a civil remedy against platforms that promoted or facilitated survivors' exploitation.

“The STOP CSAM Act would enable survivors to bring a civil cause of action against digital platforms that promoted or facilitated their exploitation”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)NCOSE Joins 100 Advocates to Urge Congress to Pass STOP CSAM Act · National Center on Sexual ExploitationRichie Hamm's statements

What this label refers to

Relative to the proposed liability framework, NCOSE supports enactment as a means of holding platforms accountable.

Logo of American Civil Liberties Union

American Civil Liberties Union

Role at the time: American Civil Liberties Union, as a signatory to the joint letter

Condemned

Statement summary

The signatories insist on a warrant requirement for access to Americans' private communications and reject reliance on executive-branch self-policing.

“reauthorize Section 702 only with a warrant requirement to access Americans’ private communications.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Civil-liberties organizations condition Section 702 renewal on reformsOctober 26 letter; final two substantive paragraphs and signatories

What this label refers to

Relative to renewal without a warrant requirement, the coalition expressly conditions reauthorization on adding that requirement and criticizes the adequacy of self-policing.

Portrait of Morgan Griffith

Morgan Griffith

Role at the time: U.S. representative from Virginia, speaking to reporters

Condemned

Statement summary

Griffith says Americans need civil-liberties protections that, in his opinion, Section 702 does not currently have, and that a warrant is needed despite disagreement among his colleagues.

“I know there’s big disagreement with some of my colleagues, but I think there needs to be a warrant.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Morgan Griffith seeks a warrant requirement for Section 702 renewalGriffith's remarks to reporters; renewal and continuing collection

What this label refers to

The case's reference point is renewing Section 702 without a warrant requirement for searches of Americans' communications. Griffith says the program lacks needed civil-liberties protections and that a warrant is required, which criticizes renewal in its current form.

Logo of Mozilla

Mozilla

Role at the time: Mozilla Root Program, statement by Dennis Jackson

Condemned

Statement summary

Mozilla says it had received no response to the questions it sent eMudhra on October 20. It shares Chrome's concerns and expects eMudhra to uphold its obligations.

“We share the Chrome Root Program's concerns and whilst we appreciate eMudhra's difficulties, we expect eMudhra to uphold its obligations to Mozilla and the wider community.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Mozilla says eMudhra must uphold its obligations · MozillaComment 42 by Dennis Jackson

What this label refers to

Mozilla criticizes the missed response deadlines and expressly shares Chrome's criticism of the response. Its acknowledgment of the company's difficulties does not express approval of the delay.

Logo of Google LLC

Google LLC

Role at the time: Chrome Root Program

Condemned

Statement summary

The Chrome Root Program rejects eMudhra's account of social media scrutiny as an explanation for delayed answers.

Quotation excerpt

“Offering it as an excuse conveys that reputation management is being prioritized over the obligations that eMudhra still owes to the billions of relying parties its mistake exposed. Those obligations do not relax because the consequences…”
Read full quotation
“Offering it as an excuse conveys that reputation management is being prioritized over the obligations that eMudhra still owes to the billions of relying parties its mistake exposed. Those obligations do not relax because the consequences are uncomfortable.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Chrome Root Program criticizes eMudhra response delays · Google LLCComment 41, response to comment 39

What this label refers to

Relative to the response after the compromise, Chrome criticizes delays in answering its questions.

Giuseppe Serio

Role at the time: Upstream Security vice president of market development, interviewed by Tom's Guide

Mixed or conditional

Statement summary

Serio says AI does not bypass security on its own, that Anthropic's experiments were slow and simplified, and that no real-world AI worm has been demonstrated.

Quotation excerpt

“Of course, AI doesn't magically bypass security. An attacker still needs a way into the device, whether through a vulnerability, exposed interface or weak security configuration. Anthropic's research is still experimental. The models were…”
Read full quotation
“Of course, AI doesn't magically bypass security. An attacker still needs a way into the device, whether through a vulnerability, exposed interface or weak security configuration. Anthropic's research is still experimental. The models were slow, required considerable resources and were tested under simplified conditions. So we are not yet looking at a demonstrated real-world AI worm spreading across devices.”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)Giuseppe Serio interview on possible AI-worm risks to connected machinesFirst two questions and answers

What this label refers to

The matter under scrutiny is Anthropic's self-replication forecast and its framing of the experiments as a security warning. Serio supports the longer-term concern conditionally but limits what the present experiments establish.

Migel Tissera

Role at the time: AI researcher and Drost founder, in a public post

Challenged the characterization

Statement summary

Tissera argues that separate models and simplified experiments do not justify the headline's self-replication framing.

“The research is technically interesting. But the headline combines three different models, two separate experiments, a seeded foothold and a network of unauthenticated computers into one story about “self-replicating AI.””
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Migel Tissera challenges the self-replication headlineOpening post at 18:40 UTC

What this label refers to

The matter under scrutiny is Anthropic's self-replication forecast and its framing of the experiments as a security warning. Tissera disputes the characterization of what the experiments demonstrate while calling the research technically interesting.

eMudhra

Role at the time: Digital trust company

Defended or excused

Statement summary

eMudhra says it handled the incident diligently, revoked the affected CAs within 14 hours of discovery and disclosed promptly.

“eMudhra handled the recent incident diligently, revoking the affected CAs within 14 hours of discovery and disclosing promptly.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)eMudhra announces exit from public TLS certificates · eMudhraOctober 22 release, chairman's account of the response

What this label refers to

It argues that its response after discovery was adequate.

Logo of Electronic Frontier Foundation

Electronic Frontier Foundation

Role at the time: Digital-rights organization

Condemned

Statement summary

EFF argues that Bill C-22 would let the Minister of Public Safety order companies to create backdoors to their services. It urges Canadians to sign a petition asking the Senate to stop the bill.

“That’s a clear recipe for weakening the encryption we all rely on.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)EFF urges Canadians to oppose Bill C-22 in the SenateSenate-stage advocacy and encryption concerns

What this label refers to

The reference point is Bill C-22's Part 2 lawful-access framework. The speaker expressly criticizes its capability, privacy or oversight provisions.

John Steidley

Role at the time: Chief of staff at Palisade Research, speaking to ZDNET

Condemned

Statement summary

Steidley tells ZDNET that if GPT-6.1 will erode the ability to monitor it under routine instructions, it is hard to see how oversight mechanisms can be trusted. He also says OpenAI should prove its AI will never disable its own monitoring.

“If GPT-6.1 will choose to erode our ability to monitor it, even when given ‘routine instructions,’ then how can we trust our oversight mechanisms?”
Open source (opens in a new tab)ZDNET reports John Steidley's comments on the monitoring incidentsWhy it matters; comments from John Steidley

What this label refers to

Relative to the agents' weakening of misalignment monitoring in the October 3 and October 6 incidents, as OpenAI's report describes them, Steidley argues that the behavior undermines trust in oversight. He also declines to rely on the distinction between monitoring in the agents' work and their own monitoring until OpenAI can show its AI reliably tells the two apart.

Portrait of Norm Eisen

Norm Eisen

Role at the time: Executive chair of Democracy Defenders Fund, co-counsel for the plaintiffs

Condemned

Statement summary

In a Democracy Defenders Fund statement on the ruling, executive chair Norm Eisen, co-counsel for the plaintiffs, calls it a resounding victory and says the government had no business giving DOGE the personal data of tens of millions of people.

“The federal government had no business handing the personal data of tens of millions of people to Elon Musk and DOGE”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Big Win for Federal Workers: Federal Court Rules OPM Broke the Law by Handing DOGE Access to Sensitive Data · Democracy Defenders Fund

What this label refers to

The case concerns OPM's decision to give DOGE agents access to federal personnel records. Eisen says the government had no business handing over that data, which condemns the conduct under scrutiny.

Portrait of Zvi Mowshowitz

Zvi Mowshowitz

Role at the time: Author of the Don't Worry About the Vase newsletter, writing on it

Condemned

Statement summary

Mowshowitz says agents should not turn off misalignment monitors even under instructions that imply it, and faults the Astra agent for denying it had done so.

“This should still be a rather robust Can’t Happen, even in borderline situations with good details. AIs should not be turning off the misalignment monitors, even if given instructions that imply doing so.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Zvi Mowshowitz on recent AI misalignment incidents · Zvi MowshowitzSection "Misaligned! (OpenAI)"

What this label refers to

Relative to the agents' weakening of misalignment monitoring in the October 3 and October 6 incidents, Mowshowitz says the behavior should not happen even in borderline cases and criticizes the Astra agent's denial. He also credits OpenAI for publishing the details.

Older statements

People in this topic

Abigail Kunkler

Abigail Kunkler is counsel at the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC), a Washington, D.C. privacy research and advocacy organization, where she works on surveillance oversight and worker privacy. Her work covers the Privacy Act of 1974, federal government data practices, predictive policing and the use of artificial intelligence in employment decisions. She is a graduate of Georgetown University Law Center and Knox College.

1 case and 1 statement

Katharine Schwab

Katharine Schwab is the assistant managing editor of the technology and innovation team at Forbes, where she edits and reports exclusive stories, features and investigations. She joined Forbes in 2022 after working at BuzzFeed News, Fast Company and The Atlantic, and is based in Brooklyn, New York.

1 case and 1 statement

Simon Noël

Simon Noël is a retired Federal Court of Canada judge who has been Canada's Intelligence Commissioner since October 2022. The commissioner is an independent, quasi-judicial official who approves or rejects ministerial authorizations for certain activities of the Communications Security Establishment and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service. As a lawyer, Noël was counsel to the inquiry into certain RCMP activities, co-chief prosecutor for the Somalia inquiry and counsel to the Security Intelligence Review Committee for more than 15 years.

1 case and 1 statement

Chris Canal

Chris Canal is a software developer and co-founder of EquiStamp, a company that builds model evaluations and research infrastructure for AI safety organizations.

1 case and 1 statement

Michael Bailey

Michael D. Bailey is a professor in Georgia Tech's School of Cybersecurity and Privacy and was its inaugural chair. His research examines the security and reliability of distributed systems and the internet. He previously taught at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign and held research positions at the University of Michigan. His industry work has included serving as director of engineering at Arbor Networks. He teaches courses in networking and computer security.

1 case and 1 statement

Molly White

Molly White is an independent technology researcher and writer who publishes Citation Needed. A former professional software engineer, she has edited Wikipedia as GorillaWarfare and has been an administrator and Arbitration Committee member. She runs Web3 Is Going Just Great and Follow the Crypto, which tracks cryptocurrency industry spending in U.S. elections. Her writing has appeared in The New York Times, The Guardian and Rolling Stone.

1 case and 1 statement

Changpeng Zhao

Changpeng Zhao, known as CZ, is a technology entrepreneur and the founder and former chief executive of the cryptocurrency exchange Binance.

1 case

Ron Wyden

Ron Wyden is a Democratic United States senator representing Oregon.

2 cases and 1 statement

Dick Durbin

U.S. Senator (D-IL); Ranking Member, Senate Judiciary Committee.

1 case and 1 statement

Elizabeth Warren

Elizabeth Warren is a Democratic U.S. senator representing Massachusetts, serving in the Senate since 2013. Before entering the Senate, she was a law professor and helped establish the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

1 case

Morgan Griffith

United States Representative and Republican candidate for U.S. House in Virginia's 9th district.

1 case and 1 statement

Tom Cotton

United States Senator and Republican candidate for U.S. Senate in Arkansas.

1 case and 1 statement

More people