Kunkler says the ruling is a win for federal workers and an injunction could head off another breach
Abigail KunklerCounsel at the Electronic Privacy Information Center, in an email to Dispute Index
EPIC counsel Abigail Kunkler says Judge Cote's ruling is already a win for federal workers and that a preliminary injunction could help head off another breach. She says the ruling also matters for other federal agencies that had or have DOGE staffers.
“the court already delivered a win for federal workers by declaring that DOGE's access was unlawful. The court's ruling suggests a preliminary injunction, and that could be a strong option for trying to head off this massive breach happening again.”
Emailed statement
Read the full email
Hi Graham, I hope you're well. My name is Abigail Kunkler, I'm counsel at EPIC with expertise on government databases and a member of our litigation team. Happy to speak on the record regarding your questions. On your question regarding relief: the court already delivered a win for federal workers by declaring that DOGE's access was unlawful. The court's ruling suggests a preliminary injunction, and that could be a strong option for trying to head off this massive breach happening again. An injunction on OPM granting access to its databases without a demonstrated need that is narrowly defined (meaning limited in scope, ability, and duration) would go a long way in keeping people out of information systems they have no business accessing. Regarding the ruling's importance for other agencies, Judge Cote's ruling absolutely matters for other federal agencies that had or have DOGE staffers. Judge Cote discusses the privacy and information security violations that occurred because OPM moved so quickly and with reckless disregard to the law's protections for individuals' information. OPM was not the only agency to disregard policy in favor of speed when granting access. And, as the judge notes, the expiration of the DOGE TO doesn't discount the possibility that this harm reoccurs; that could be at OPM or other agencies. We aren't out of the woods yet. Best, Abigail Kunkler (she/her) EPIC Counsel Electronic Privacy Information Center

Where this statement fits
Judge Cote rules OPM's DOGE data access broke the Privacy Act; the government argues no relief is needed
Judge Denise Cote ruled on October 20, 2026 that the U.S. Office of Personnel Management violated the Privacy Act when it gave DOGE agents broad access to systems holding federal workers' personal records in early 2025. The government argued the access went to OPM employees and that no further relief is warranted. The court has not yet decided relief.
Source and context
Emailed statement
Emailed comment from Abigail Kunkler of EPIC to Dispute Index on Judge Cote's Privacy Act ruling on OPM and DOGE
Hi Graham, I hope you're well. My name is Abigail Kunkler, I'm counsel at EPIC with expertise on government databases and a member of our litigation team. Happy to speak on the record regarding your questions. On your question regarding relief: the court already delivered a win for federal workers by declaring that DOGE's access was unlawful. The court's ruling suggests a preliminary injunction, and that could be a strong option for trying to head off this massive breach happening again. An injunction on OPM granting access to its databases without a demonstrated need that is narrowly defined (meaning limited in scope, ability, and duration) would go a long way in keeping people out of information systems they have no business accessing. Regarding the ruling's importance for other agencies, Judge Cote's ruling absolutely matters for other federal agencies that had or have DOGE staffers. Judge Cote discusses the privacy and information security violations that occurred because OPM moved so quickly and with reckless disregard to the law's protections for individuals' information. OPM was not the only agency to disregard policy in favor of speed when granting access. And, as the judge notes, the expiration of the DOGE TO doesn't discount the possibility that this harm reoccurs; that could be at OPM or other agencies. We aren't out of the woods yet. Best, Abigail Kunkler (she/her) EPIC Counsel Electronic Privacy Information Center
About this source
Kunkler sent this reply by email on November 13, 2026, in answer to Dispute Index questions about what relief would help the federal workers whose records were exposed and whether Judge Cote's ruling matters for the other agencies DOGE worked inside. The questions went to her EPIC colleague Sara Geoghegan, who passed them on. Kunkler said she was speaking on the record. Dispute Index holds the email.
Before the quotation
Graham Weller of Dispute Index asked EPIC what relief would help the federal workers whose records were exposed, and whether the ruling matters for the other agencies DOGE worked inside. Kunkler answered on the record.
After the quotation
She said an injunction barring OPM from granting access to its databases without a narrowly defined, demonstrated need would help keep people out of systems they have no business accessing. She said the ruling matters for other agencies that had or have DOGE staffers, that OPM was not the only agency to put speed ahead of policy when granting access, and that, as the judge noted, the expiration of the temporary DOGE organization does not rule out the harm happening again at OPM or elsewhere.
How this statement is classified
The label describes this statement's response within the context above.
Why this label?
The case concerns OPM's decision to give DOGE agents access to federal personnel records. Kunkler calls the access unlawful and a massive breach and backs an injunction to stop it happening again, which condemns the conduct under scrutiny.
- Recorded on
- Published here
More from this case
Read the full caseEisen says the government had no business giving DOGE the personal data of tens of millions of people
“The federal government had no business handing the personal data of tens of millions of people to Elon Musk and DOGE”Read statement
EFF says OPM's disclosure to DOGE violated the Privacy Act
Electronic Frontier Foundation
“This disclosure violates the federal Privacy Act of 1974, a watershed anti-surveillance statute that prevents the federal government from abusing our personal information.”Read statement
Cote rules OPM's grant of DOGE access to personnel records was unlawful
“OPM’s decision to grant DOGE Agents broad access to its systems of records containing PII without a demonstrated need was unlawful”Read statement
Share or embed this statement
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Kunkler says the ruling is a win for federal workers and an injunction could head off another breach
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/events/8866-epic-counsel-abigail-kunkler-says-judge-cote-s
Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.
The Dispute Index. "Kunkler says the ruling is a win for federal workers and an injunction could head off another breach". First published: 2026-11-13. Last updated: 2026-11-13. https://disputeindex.com/events/8866-epic-counsel-abigail-kunkler-says-judge-cote-s