Intelligence Commissioner Simon Noël asks senators to add a proportionality test for Bill C-22's confidential orders
Simon NoëlIntelligence Commissioner of Canada, in opening remarks to the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs
Testifying on Bill C-22, Intelligence Commissioner Simon Noël, who would review the public safety minister's orders to service providers, welcomes the House amendments limiting orders to two years. He asks the Senate committee to consider requiring the minister to weigh proportionality and reasonable alternatives before issuing a confidential order.
“Nothing prevents the Minister from addressing these questions. But the Bill does not clearly require their consideration. If the intent of ministerial orders is to respond to situations where confidentiality is necessary, a clear proportionality factor that includes reasonable alternatives would ensure the Minister explains this need.”
Official statement
Reporting

Where this statement fits
Canada's Bill C-22: Dhillon backs lawful access; Simons warns of security risks
Senator Baltej Dhillon defends the lawful-access framework in Part 2 of Bill C-22. Senators Paula Simons and Yuen Pau Woo question its privacy, cybersecurity and oversight safeguards. The House-passed text lets the federal cabinet require designated providers to keep categories of metadata for up to six months. As of October 24, 2026, the bill was before a Senate committee and was not law.
Source and context
Official statement
About this source
The Intelligence Commissioner's prepared opening remarks to the Senate national security committee on Bill C-22, published by his office. He welcomes the House amendments that limit orders to two years and asks senators to consider requiring the minister to weigh proportionality and reasonable alternatives before making a confidential order.
Reporting
About this source
CBC News reports the first day of the Senate national security committee's study of Bill C-22, with testimony from Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne, Intelligence Commissioner Simon Noël and Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Before the quotation
Under Part 2 of the bill, the minister's orders to electronic service providers would not take effect until the Intelligence Commissioner approves them. Noël said subsection 7(3) requires the minister only to take the listed factors into account, without explicitly requiring an explanation of why the balance favours a confidential order or a look at reasonable alternatives.
After the quotation
He said his review is limited to the conclusions the minister reaches under subsection 7(3), so an explicit proportionality requirement would ensure that factor is part of his review. Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree, who sponsors the bill, testified before the same committee later that day.
How this statement is classified
The label describes this statement's response within the context above.
Why this label?
Noël accepts the role the bill gives him and welcomes the House changes, but says the bill should expressly require the minister to justify confidential orders as proportionate, so we labeled it Mixed or conditional.
- Recorded on
- Published here
More from this case
Read the full caseEFF urges Canadians to tell the Senate to stop Bill C-22
Electronic Frontier Foundation
“That’s a clear recipe for weakening the encryption we all rely on.”Read statement
Geist says secret orders could precede public regulations
“secret orders could be imposed on individual providers before public regulations are even established.”Read statement
Woo says the government has not justified the added risks
“I do not believe it has yet done so.”Read statement
Share or embed this statement
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Intelligence Commissioner Simon Noël asks senators to add a proportionality test for Bill C-22's confidential orders
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/events/9177-testifying-on-bill-c-22-intelligence-commissioner-simon
Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.
The Dispute Index. "Intelligence Commissioner Simon Noël asks senators to add a proportionality test for Bill C-22's confidential orders". First published: 2026-11-15. Last updated: 2026-11-15. https://disputeindex.com/events/9177-testifying-on-bill-c-22-intelligence-commissioner-simon