All topics

Military and Defense

Public disputes concerning armed forces, defense departments, military policy, personnel standards, alliances, procurement, and civil-military institutions.

Related cases

Case

Did Pete Hegseth’s “this is real” post mock Canadian cadets?

On September 1, 2026, U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth reposted an image from the Vernon Cadet Training Centre showing a cadet receiving an award from an instructor, adding a Canadian flag and the words “this is real.” Canadian officials, a cadet organization, a Republican member of Congress, and George Clooney characterized the post as mocking, demeaning, or beneath the dignity of Hegseth’s office. The Pentagon stood by the post but did not specify what the caption meant.

SexismU.S. PoliticsUpdated

Statements

George Clooney

Role at the time: Actor speaking at the Venice Film Festival

Condemned

Responding to

Hegseth’s post mocked or invited mockery of the appearance and achievements of people shown in the Canadian cadet-program image.

"Where's the sense of decency in all of this? And I'm ashamed of all of that."
Why we used this label

The remarks clearly condemn Hegseth’s post on moral and professional grounds.

George Clooney criticizes Pete Hegseth over Canadian cadet post (opens in a new tab)Remarks reported from the Venice Film Festival press appearance.

Don Bacon

Role at the time: United States representative and retired Air Force brigadier general

Condemned

Responding to

Hegseth’s post mocked or invited mockery of the appearance and achievements of people shown in the Canadian cadet-program image.

"It's lowbrow. I think it's unprofessional… demeaning and uncalled for."
Why we used this label

The statement is an explicit condemnation from a U.S. lawmaker in Hegseth’s own party.

Garnett Genuis

Role at the time: Member of the Canadian Parliament

Challenged the characterization

Responding to

The people shown were participants in a youth cadet program, and the cadets themselves were not members of the Canadian military.

"Cadets do great work, and are not members of the military."
Why we used this label

The response challenges the factual characterization implied by using the cadet image to comment on Canadian military capability.

Pentagon defends Hegseth's post about Canadian cadet program (opens in a new tab)Paragraphs describing the original post, Pentagon response, and Garnett Genuis response.

Army Cadet League of Canada

Role at the time: Cadet-support organization

Condemned

Responding to

Hegseth’s post mocked or invited mockery of the appearance and achievements of people shown in the Canadian cadet-program image.

"We strongly condemn any online harassment, or mockery of cadets' achievements."
Why we used this label

The organization’s statement expressly condemns the interpretation of the post as mockery.

Hegseth draws Canadian backlash over post that appears to mock cadets (opens in a new tab)Opening section, including the Army Cadet League statement and David McGuinty's response.

David Eby

Role at the time: Premier of British Columbia

Condemned

Responding to

Hegseth’s post mocked or invited mockery of the appearance and achievements of people shown in the Canadian cadet-program image.

"What an embarrassment."
Why we used this label

The statement is a direct condemnation of Hegseth and the perceived target of the post.

Hegseth post about Canadian cadets called below the dignity of his office (opens in a new tab)Main article and embedded remarks from Mark Carney, David McGuinty, David Eby, and the Pentagon.

David McGuinty

Role at the time: Canadian minister of national defence

Condemned

Responding to

Hegseth’s post mocked or invited mockery of the appearance and achievements of people shown in the Canadian cadet-program image.

"Below the dignity of the office he holds."
Why we used this label

The statement unambiguously condemns the post as inappropriate for Hegseth’s office.

Hegseth post about Canadian cadets called below the dignity of his office (opens in a new tab)Main article and embedded remarks from Mark Carney, David McGuinty, David Eby, and the Pentagon.

Mark Carney

Role at the time: Prime Minister of Canada

Condemned

Responding to

Hegseth’s post mocked or invited mockery of the appearance and achievements of people shown in the Canadian cadet-program image.

"Beneath their office."
Why we used this label

The remark directly condemns the appropriateness of the post from a cabinet official.

Canadian leader Carney pushes back against Trump administration (opens in a new tab)Opening section discussing Hegseth's post, Carney's response, and the Pentagon statement.

People with useful coverage

Don Bacon

United States representative from Nebraska and retired Air Force brigadier general.

1 case and 1 statement

George Clooney

American actor, filmmaker, and political activist.

1 case and 1 statement

David Eby

Premier of British Columbia.

1 case and 1 statement

David McGuinty

Canadian politician serving as minister of national defence.

1 case and 1 statement

Mark Carney

Prime minister of Canada.

1 case and 1 statement

Pete Hegseth

United States secretary of defense and former television host.

1 case

Benjamin Netanyahu

Israeli politician serving as prime minister of Israel and leader of Likud.

1 case