Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

Sydney Sweeney, an equity holder in sports-prediction platform Novig, starred in a nude ad campaign that female athletes say sexualizes women's sport. Novig's CEO and a Guardian columnist publicly disputed that characterization.

Case period:

Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated

Overview

Sydney Sweeney is a strategic partner and equity holder in Novig, a sports prediction market. The campaign followed her 2025 American Eagle "great jeans" campaign, which drew separate, unrelated criticism over eugenics-adjacent wordplay; that earlier controversy is background only and is not part of this case. Novig launch press release (opens in a new tab) describes the campaign’s stated intent and Sweeney’s equity stake.

People in this case

Timeline

10 timeline entries on this page. Dates: September 9, 2026 to October 11, 2026

  1. September 2026

    1. Novig launches the “Just Sports” campaign with Sydney Sweeney

      Source release

      Novig publishes its announcement of the “Just Sports” campaign, in which Sweeney appears nude or minimally clothed while covering herself with sports equipment. The release names her as a strategic partner and equity holder and quotes her saying the campaign “was about embracing a fun idea” and was meant to “cut through the noise and put the focus entirely on sports.” Novig later declined to disclose the terms or size of her stake. Novig's chief executive later said Sweeney drove the campaign's visuals and that he had anticipated some people would object.

      [01]Novig

      Source excerpt

      “The campaign was about embracing a fun idea,” said Sweeney, who also joins Novig as a strategic partner and equity holder. “The concept is simple: cut through the noise and put the focus entirely on sports.”

      Novig’s own launch announcement, dated September 9, 2026 on the page. It is the primary record of the campaign’s launch date and of Sweeney’s role as strategic partner and equity holder. Novig later declined to disclose the terms or size of her stake when asked by Fortune.

      Novig: “Sydney Sweeney Teams Up With Novig For Bold New ‘Just Sports’ Campaign” · NovigCompany announcement, paragraph carrying Sweeney’s quotation.
      [02]Sydney Sweeney under fire for ‘sexualising women’s sport’ in sports prediction ad

      The Guardian’s report on the athlete-led backlash, directly quoting Ariarne Titmus’s Instagram Story and Skye Nicolson’s Instagram post.

      [03]Novig CEO says Sweeney drove the ad's visuals

      Source excerpt

      It really was Sydney who was driving a lot of the visuals and the messaging.

      Front Office Sports report on Novig CEO Jacob Fortinsky's September 15, 2026 remarks at the "Asset Class" event, attributing the ad's visuals and messaging to Sweeney.

    2. Athletes begin posting their own footage in response

      Reaction

      Former UCLA gymnast Gracie Kramer posts a TikTok video contrasting the advertisement with footage of women competing, which the Guardian credits with starting a trend of similar responses. The Australian Institute of Sport posts its own version the following day, captioned “THIS is sport.” Both dates were read from the platforms’ own metadata. Kramer’s post precedes by a day the earliest statement otherwise recorded in this case.

      [04]Gracie Kramer on TikTok: “Because it really is that deep.”

      Source excerpt

      Because it really is that deep.

      The video the Guardian credits with starting the trend of athletes posting their own footage in response to the advertisement. It was uploaded on September 12, 2026. That places it a day before any criticism currently recorded in this case. The Guardian renders an additional line, “idk what Sydney Sweeney was doing, but this is what a woman in sports looks like,” which does not appear in the video's caption and may be on-screen text; it is not reproduced here as a quotation. Kramer’s separately recorded statement of September 13 is a different artefact, made on Instagram and expanded in an NBC News interview.

      Gracie Kramer on TikTok: “Because it really is that deep.”Video post; caption as returned by the platform.
      [05]Australian Institute of Sport on Instagram: “THIS is sport.”

      Source excerpt

      THIS is sport.

      The Australian Institute of Sport’s contribution to the counter-trend, posting footage of archery, gymnastics, boxing and softball. It is the only national sporting institution found to have participated; it does not name Sweeney, Novig or the advertisement, so it is recorded as a dated development rather than as an institutional position on the dispute.

      Australian Institute of Sport on Instagram: “THIS is sport.”Instagram post; caption as returned by the platform.
    3. The backlash reaches a tipping point four days after launch

      Reaction

      Criticism of the advertisement, which had built gradually since launch, becomes widespread. Day-by-day analytics reported by Newsweek show Sweeney gaining followers from September 9 through 12, then losing 136,848 on September 13 and a further 66,446 on September 14, before regaining 102,936 across September 15 and 16. The figures date the point at which the reaction became general; they are a measure of attention rather than evidence about the advertisement itself.

      [06]Newsweek: Sweeney’s follower count drops then rebounds after the Novig ad

      Source excerpt

      On September 13, as the backlash to the advert began to go viral, she lost 136,848 followers. The following day, she lost 66,446 followers. That comes out to a loss of 203,294 followers in a 48-hour period.

      Dates the tipping point of the backlash to September 13 using day-by-day Social Blade figures: Sweeney gained followers on September 9 through 12, then lost 136,848 on September 13 and 66,446 on September 14, before regaining 102,936 across September 15 and 16. Useful as a dated measure of when the reaction became widespread, not as evidence about the ad’s merits.

      Newsweek: Sweeney’s follower count drops then rebounds after the Novig adSection headed “The Backlash Over the Ad,” giving day-by-day follower figures.
    4. Olympic and professional athletes begin criticising the campaign

      Reaction

      Athletes including Australian swimmer Ariarne Titmus, British sprinter Amy Hunt and gymnast Gracie Kramer publicly objected to the campaign, saying it sexualised women's sport. Criticism broadened over the following days to include surfer Felicity Palmateer, diver Molly Carlson and others, with some arguing the campaign risked becoming a barrier for women in sport. Boxer Skye Nicolson disputed how the campaign was being characterised.

      [02]Sydney Sweeney under fire for ‘sexualising women’s sport’ in sports prediction ad

      The Guardian’s report on the athlete-led backlash, directly quoting Ariarne Titmus’s Instagram Story and Skye Nicolson’s Instagram post.

      [07]Felicity Palmateer condemns the Sydney Sweeney/Novig ad

      Source excerpt

      Don't know what Sydney thinks sport looks like, but THIS is what sport looks like... not hypersexualized content designed to sell a gambling app.

      CNN report and Felicity Palmateer's own Instagram post condemning the Novig ad.

      [08]Sydney Sweeney’s ‘sexualized’ sports betting ad slammed by Canadian athletes

      CBC News report quoting Cassidy Gray’s TikTok video and Molly Carlson’s Instagram post, plus Jacob Fortinsky’s launch-day quote.

    5. Sweeney answers critics on Instagram and Novig's chief executive defends the campaign

      Reaction

      Sydney Sweeney responded to the criticism on Instagram, sharing images of ESPN magazine body-issue covers featuring athletes including Serena Williams. Novig's chief executive defended the campaign in interviews, saying Sweeney drove its visuals and that he had known some people would object to it. Commentary divided, with some writers defending the campaign as unremarkable and others treating the objections as serious.

      [09]Sydney Sweeney Addresses Sports Ad Controversy on Instagram Story

      TODAY.com report quoting Gracie Kramer’s Instagram post and her NBC News interview, and describing Sweeney’s Sept. 9 Complex interview quote.

      [10]Sydney Sweeney fires back at trolls after facing criticism online for provocative sports ad

      Fox News report directly quoting the caption ("It’s gamedayyyy") on Sweeney’s Sept. 13 Instagram response to the backlash.

      [11]Novig CEO defends Sydney Sweeney ad, knew people who ‘hate her’ would be ‘loud’

      Report on Jacob Fortinsky’s Front Office Sports interview defending the ad after the backlash, syndicated from USA Today’s For The Win.

      [12]Are you outraged by Sydney Sweeney – again? More fool you

      Marina Hyde’s signed Guardian opinion column arguing the backlash against Sweeney is disproportionate.

    6. Torossian publishes an analysis of the Novig campaign's reputational costs

      Source release

      In a public-relations column, Ronn Torossian argues that Novig gained attention while Sweeney bore reputational costs. He examines how celebrity advertising distributes benefits and backlash. The page records September 16 as its first publication date and October 21 as its update date.

      [13]Sydney Sweeney's Novig Ad Reveals a New Risk for Brands

      Torossian's signed analysis was published September 16 and updated October 21. This statement uses the updated version.

      Sydney Sweeney's Novig Ad Reveals a New Risk for BrandsOpening assessment and discussion of reputation risk
    7. Cunningham gives mixed assessment of Novig’s Sydney Sweeney ad

      Reaction

      In a September 17 podcast episode, Cunningham called the Novig ad inauthentic, said she did not like it and found it morally odd, while questioning the backlash and saying the ad was not directed at women’s sports. Hanlen gave separate later comments.

      [14]No Hesitation episode: Sophie Gets Real About the Sydney Sweeney Ad

      Source excerpt

      “Do I like the particular ad? Not really.”

      In a section about the Novig advertisement, Cunningham calls the ad inauthentic and morally odd, questions the backlash, and says it was not directed at women’s sports. Drew Hanlen’s later comments are distinct from Cunningham’s.

  2. October 2026

    1. Novig reports growth after the Sweeney campaign

      Source release

      Fortinsky tells CNBC that trading volume rose nearly 94% and first-time depositors more than 218% in the 20 days after launch compared with the 20 days before. These are company-reported figures. He says the ad and the start of the NFL season accompanied the growth and renews his defense of the campaign.

      [15]Novig credits Sydney Sweeney campaign for growth

      Fortinsky renews his defense of the ad and supplies company growth figures to CNBC. The comparisons cover the 20 days before and after launch, a period that also included the start of the NFL season.

      Novig credits Sydney Sweeney campaign for growthOctober 3 article, Backlash against Just Sports ad section and Fortinsky's before-and-after platform figures.
    2. Sweeney posts the second Just Sports commercial

      Source release

      Sweeney releases the second Novig commercial on Instagram. It retains the first ad's visual approach and emphasizes Novig's focus on sports rather than prediction markets involving politics or other subjects.

      [16]As Novig Unveils Sydney Sweeney Sequel, Powerade Bites Back

      Stewart reports that Sweeney posted the second commercial on October 11 and reproduces its opening words.

      As Novig Unveils Sydney Sweeney Sequel, Powerade Bites BackOctober 11 release of the second Just Sports ad
      [17]Novig expands controversial Sydney Sweeney campaign as trading volume triples

      Brian Bonilla reports Novig's expanded campaign and company-reported growth.

      Novig expands controversial Sydney Sweeney campaign as trading volume triplesCompany growth report and second campaign installment
      [18]Novig doubles down on Sydney Sweeney campaign amid criticism

      SBJ reproduces Novig's figures and quotations from Fortinsky's Ad Age interview. Fortinsky also credits the start of the NFL season.

      Novig doubles down on Sydney Sweeney campaign amid criticismReport of Fortinsky's October 11 Ad Age interview
    3. Novig reports updated growth figures as the campaign expands

      Source release

      Fortinsky tells Ad Age that Novig's trading volume has roughly tripled since the campaign began. The company also reports first-time depositors up 361.8% and downloads up 260.9%. These are company figures; Fortinsky also credits the start of the NFL season.

      [17]Novig expands controversial Sydney Sweeney campaign as trading volume triples

      Brian Bonilla reports Novig's expanded campaign and company-reported growth.

      Novig expands controversial Sydney Sweeney campaign as trading volume triplesCompany growth report and second campaign installment
      [18]Novig doubles down on Sydney Sweeney campaign amid criticism

      SBJ reproduces Novig's figures and quotations from Fortinsky's Ad Age interview. Fortinsky also credits the start of the NFL season.

      Novig doubles down on Sydney Sweeney campaign amid criticismReport of Fortinsky's October 11 Ad Age interview

Claims

Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.

What's disputed

Response record

Responses

Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.

24 responses. First 6 shown initially. Newest first.

  1. Samantha JonesWestern University psychology researcher, co-author with Jamie Hong Chow and Noah Eliot Vanderhoeven

    Before this statement

    The authors identify Sweeney as a Novig equity partner.

    "The ad captures two troubling trends: how routinely women’s bodies are sexualized in digital media and how gambling companies use sexual appeal, and the implied promise of romantic or sexual reward, to target young men."
    Condemned

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    The authors say the ad captures two troubling trends: routine sexualization of women's bodies in digital media and gambling companies' use of sexual appeal to target young men.

    After the statement

    They connect their criticism to research on objectification, gambling and young people's well-being.

    Why this label?

    The matter under scrutiny is Novig's sexualized sports campaign. The co-authors criticize its use of women's bodies and its appeal to young men.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  2. Jacob FortinskyNovig co-founder, speaking in a CNBC interview

    Before this statement

    CNBC reports company growth figures following the campaign and summarizes female athletes' objections to the ad.

    "Ultimately, I think we have nothing to apologize for and are very proud of the work that we did,"
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Fortinsky says Novig has no reason to apologize and remains proud of the ad. He says its purpose was to explain the platform rather than represent women athletes.

    After the statement

    Fortinsky says the team respects others' opinions and supports women's sports. He also discusses responsible business risk-taking.

    Novig credits Sydney Sweeney campaign for growthOctober 3 article, Backlash against Just Sports ad section and Fortinsky's before-and-after platform figures.

    Why this label?

    He explicitly defends the disputed advertising campaign against the criticism that it harmed women's sport.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  3. Matt CalkinsSports columnist, writing for OutKick

    Before this statement

    Calkins compares the ad with ESPN Magazine's Body Issue.

    "It was an ad that used sex appeal to catch the eye of a mostly-male market — not a "kick in the face" to female athletes, as four-time Olympic swimming gold medalist Ariarne Titmus suggested."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Calkins says the ad used sex appeal to reach a mostly male market and rejects its description as a kick in the face to female athletes.

    After the statement

    He praises Sweeney's business choices and attributes critics' hostility to jealousy. Those are his judgments.

    Matt Calkins defends Sydney Sweeney's Novig sports adArgument distinguishing sex appeal from an attack on female athletes

    Why this label?

    The matter under scrutiny is Novig's sexualized sports campaign. Calkins defends that approach and rejects the claim that it insults female athletes.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  4. Laura Norton-CruzSocial worker and public health writer, in a signed column

    Before this statement

    Norton-Cruz argues that men should be angry about the ad, too.

    "So while sexist marketing like this is harmful to women and girls, it isn’t doing men any favors either."
    Condemned

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Norton-Cruz says sexist marketing like this ad harms women and girls and does men no favors.

    After the statement

    She also criticizes sports-betting companies for harming men.

    Why this label?

    The matter under scrutiny is Novig's sexualized use of sports imagery. Norton-Cruz explicitly criticizes it as harmful.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  5. Charley HullProfessional golfer, interviewed by Fox News

    Before this statement

    Hull discusses the ad during an OutKick interview promoting the on!vitational golf event.

    "So I think it's a great idea. I don't understand how it's turning back women's sports because it's not."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Hull endorses the ad and rejects the claim that it turns back women's sports.

    After the statement

    She also says she does not think there is anything wrong with the ad.

    Charley Hull responds to criticism of Sydney SweeneyOriginal 40-second interview clip and published description
    Star female golfer fires back at Sydney Sweeney critics: 'She's got sex ...Thursday, September 24 OutKick interview; directly attributed quotations

    Why this label?

    Hull's explicit praise of the advertisement as a great idea establishes approval, alongside her rejection of criticism about women's sports.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  6. Jen PsakiMS NOW television host and political commentator

    Before this statement

    Psaki says she does not object to Sydney Sweeney’s choice to use her body and says, “She looks great. Good for her.”

    "But the problem is the message an ad like this sends about women in sports."
    Condemned

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Jen Psaki said the message of Novig’s Sydney Sweeney ad was the problem and said it reinforced what she described as misogynistic sexualization of women’s sports.

    After the statement

    Psaki says female athletes have fought what she describes as misogynistic sexualization of women’s sports and says the ad reinforces it.

    Jen Psaki comments on Novig’s Sydney Sweeney sports adMS NOW video, 13:58–14:41. The video was uploaded September 17, 2026, to MS NOW’s official YouTube channel.

    Why this label?

    Case 39 concerns the criticism that the ad sexualizes women’s sport. Psaki explicitly calls the ad’s message a problem and says it reinforces misogynistic sexualization of women’s sports. That is a substantive criticism of the ad rather than a challenge to its characterization.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

View all 24 responsesShow fewer responses
  1. Sophie CunninghamWNBA player for the Indiana Fever, speaking on her podcast “No Hesitation”

    Before this statement

    Said on her podcast with co-host Drew Hanlen, in an episode released September 17, after named athletes including Ariarne Titmus, Amy Hunt and Skye Nicolson had criticised the campaign.

    "Why are girls mad? That is literally what she does… Men, sports, naked women. Of course that’s gonna draw attention… Go do your thing sis"
    Mixed or conditional

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    WNBA player Sophie Cunningham said on her podcast that she did not understand why the advertisement had angered women, that its combination of men, sports and nudity was obviously going to draw attention, and that Sweeney should carry on. She also said she did not really like the ad, called Sweeney’s involvement inauthentic and found it “morally… a little weird,” and said the ad was not directed at women’s sports.

    After the statement

    The ellipses in the quotation are the reporting outlet’s elisions from the podcast audio; the full episode, at 44:47 to 46:46, is the primary record. Drew Hanlen’s later comments in the episode are his own and are not attributed to Cunningham.

    Why this label?

    On whether the advertisement sexualizes women’s sport, Cunningham takes materially different positions in the same segment. She criticizes the ad, saying she does not really like it, calling Sweeney’s involvement inauthentic and calling it morally odd, while also questioning the backlash, asking why women were angry and saying the ad was not directed at women’s sports. That combination is “Mixed or conditional” rather than “Minimized,” because her criticism is a substantive objection, not only a qualification on a dismissal.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  2. Ron ElfenbeinPhysician; guest panelist, Timcast IRL

    Before this statement

    Said on the September 16, 2026 Timcast IRL livestream.

    "advertising being aspirational again... is a good thing... you want people to look at your product and say, I want to feel good."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Dr. Ron Elfenbein defended the Novig ad's aspirational advertising approach.

    After the statement

    Said as a guest panelist on Timcast IRL discussing the ad backlash.

    Why this label?

    Elfenbein argues that aspirational advertising is a legitimate and positive approach, defending the ad's style against the backlash.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  3. Tim PoolHost, Timcast IRL

    Before this statement

    Said on the September 16, 2026 Timcast IRL livestream discussing the ad backlash.

    "Sydney Sweeney is going massively viral again because she put up a commercial of herself and she's just basically naked... I've seen all of these viral trending Instagram and TikTok videos [where] women are complaining... And I, you know, jealous, I guess, whatever."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Tim Pool dismissed the backlash against the Novig ad as driven by jealousy.

    After the statement

    The discussion continued with guest Dr. Ron Elfenbein defending the ad's advertising approach.

    Why this label?

    Pool dismisses the athlete-led backlash as jealousy rather than a substantive objection to the ad, implicitly defending the ad against the criticism it drew.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  4. Matt VespaManaging editor, Townhall

    Before this statement

    Op-ed responding to the backlash over the Novig ad.

    "It's her body, her choice... Is it me, or are women just jealous of Sweeney?"
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Townhall managing editor Matt Vespa defended Sydney Sweeney's appearance in the Novig ad, writing "it's her body, her choice" and dismissing critics as jealous.

    After the statement

    The op-ed did not address Fortinsky's claim that Sweeney drove the ad's visuals.

    Why this label?

    Vespa explicitly defends Sweeney's choice to appear in the ad and dismisses the backlash as hypocritical jealousy, a direct defense of the ad against the criticism it drew.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  5. Russ LatinoFounder and CEO, Magnolia Tribune

    Before this statement

    Op-ed responding to the backlash over the Novig ad.

    "If women are supposed to be proud of their bodies, that principle has to include women whose bodies other people happen to find attractive."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Magnolia Tribune founder Russ Latino defended Sweeney's appearance in the ad, arguing that if body positivity is celebrated for other campaigns, "that principle has to include women whose bodies other people happen to find attractive."

    After the statement

    No further public follow-up had been reported as of this writing.

    Why this label?

    Latino explicitly defends Sweeney's choice to appear in the ad, arguing the backlash reveals a hypocritical double standard relative to other body-positivity campaigns.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  6. Amy HuntBritish sprinter; four-time European champion

    Before this statement

    Appearing on Good Morning Britain, September 15, 2026.

    "It's not anything personal against that actress... the reaction has almost outweighed the moment."
    Mixed or conditional

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Amy Hunt said on Good Morning Britain that her concern about the Novig ad was not personal against Sydney Sweeney, and that "the reaction has almost outweighed the moment," while maintaining the ad risks becoming a barrier to girls in sport.

    After the statement

    She cited a statistic that 64% of teenage girls drop out of sport as part of her concern.

    Why this label?

    Hunt maintains her substantive concern that the ad risks becoming a barrier to girls in sport, while explicitly softening her framing to say it isn't personal against Sweeney and that the reaction has 'almost outweighed the moment' -- a materially different, more conditional statement than her earlier condemnation.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  7. Jacob FortinskyCo-founder and CEO, Novig

    Before this statement

    Speaking at the Front Office Sports "Asset Class" event in New York, September 15, 2026.

    "It really was Sydney who was driving a lot of the visuals and the messaging."
    Mixed or conditional

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Novig CEO Jacob Fortinsky said Sydney Sweeney "was driving a lot of the visuals and the messaging" in the ad, shifting creative responsibility for its content toward her.

    After the statement

    The remark triggered its own follow-on coverage cycle, including outlets asking whether Novig was blaming Sweeney for the backlash.

    Why this label?

    Fortinsky shifts creative responsibility for the ad's content onto Sweeney rather than defending or condemning the ad's substance outright -- a distinct claim from his earlier 'never intended to portray female sports' statement, reframing the dispute over who is responsible without resolving whether the ad itself was appropriate.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  8. Marina HydeColumnist, The Guardian

    Before this statement

    Published as a signed opinion column in The Guardian.

    "Come on. With respect, I just don’t think it’s a kick in the face for any of those things... I can’t help feeling it would have been cooler for women’s sport to simply not even mention the naked gambling ad at all."
    Challenged the characterization

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Guardian columnist Marina Hyde argued in a signed opinion column that the backlash against the Novig ad is disproportionate.

    After the statement

    Hyde’s column was published the day after Fortinsky’s Front Office Sports defense and directly quotes Titmus’s statement to rebut it.

    Why this label?

    Hyde’s signed column directly disputes Titmus’s "kick in the face" characterization and argues the backlash is disproportionate, challenging how the ad has been characterized rather than defending its content on the merits.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  9. Jacob FortinskyCo-founder and CEO, Novig

    Before this statement

    Said in a Front Office Sports interview after the backlash had become widely reported.

    "We never intended to portray female sports. Sydney’s an actress, the biggest movie star in the world. We’re a prediction market that is focused on sports, and that is the story that she was communicating... It really was Sydney who was driving the visuals and the messaging."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Novig CEO Jacob Fortinsky said the campaign never intended to portray women’s sport and that Sweeney drove its creative direction.

    After the statement

    The interview was also republished with additional excerpts by TODAY.com and Yahoo/USA Today’s For The Win, from the same underlying Front Office Sports conversation.

    Why this label?

    Fortinsky defends the campaign as never having intended to portray women’s sport and frames the backlash as expected and not a fair reading of the ad’s purpose — an express defense of the conduct under scrutiny.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  10. Felicity PalmateerProfessional big-wave surfer; WSL commentator

    Before this statement

    CNN interview and Instagram post.

    "Don't know what Sydney thinks sport looks like, but THIS is what sport looks like... not hypersexualized content designed to sell a gambling app."
    Condemned

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Australian big-wave surfer Felicity Palmateer called the Novig ad "very damaging" for young women in sport, posting on Instagram that it was "hypersexualized content designed to sell a gambling app," not what sport looks like.

    After the statement

    No further public follow-up had been reported as of this writing.

    Why this label?

    Palmateer directly condemns the ad as hypersexualized content misrepresenting what sport looks like, calling it damaging for young women in sport.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  11. Krystal BallCo-host, Breaking Points

    Before this statement

    Discussing the Novig ad controversy on Breaking Points, co-hosted with Saagar Enjeti, as part of broader criticism of the gambling industry.

    "softcore pornography"
    Condemned

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Breaking Points co-host Krystal Ball called the Sydney Sweeney/Novig ad "softcore pornography" shilling for the gambling industry.

    After the statement

    No further follow-up on this specific point had been reported as of this writing.

    Why this label?

    Ball calls the ad 'softcore pornography' shilling for the gambling industry, a direct condemnation of the ad.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  12. Molly CarlsonCanadian high diver

    Before this statement

    Posted to Instagram on or around September 14, 2026.

    "This one hits close to home... because I didn’t think I looked like the athlete I was ‘supposed’ to be. Young girls deserve to grow up seeing female athletes celebrated for their strength, courage, talent and what their bodies are capable of."
    Condemned

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Molly Carlson said the Novig ad clashed with her own experience of body image in sport and argued athletes deserve to be celebrated for capability, not appearance.

    After the statement

    Quoted and described directly by CBC News.

    Why this label?

    Carlson frames the ad against her own history of body-image struggles in sport and argues athletes should be celebrated for capability rather than appearance, a clear denunciation of the ad’s approach.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  13. Skye NicolsonProfessional boxer; world champion

    Before this statement

    Posted to an Instagram story on or around September 14, 2026.

    "There’s a big difference between looking ‘sexy’ because you do sport compared to use sex to sell ‘sport’. There is nothing wrong with looking good and doing sport and there’s nothing wrong with embracing your femininity while also being a badass athlete."
    Challenged the characterization

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Skye Nicolson argued the objection to the Novig ad is about using sex to sell sport, not about athletes looking attractive.

    After the statement

    Quoted directly by The Guardian.

    Why this label?

    Nicolson distinguishes "looking sexy because you do sport" from "using sex to sell sport," disputing how the ad’s critics and defenders alike are framing the issue rather than issuing a blanket condemnation or defense.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  14. Cassidy GrayCanadian alpine skier; 2026 Winter Olympian

    Before this statement

    Posted in a TikTok video on or around September 14, 2026, after Sweeney responded to the backlash on Instagram with magazine covers of athletes posing in little clothing.

    "It’s not a joke when your life is actually you being a female athlete, and you being sexualized or not taken seriously and not given the same opportunities, and then you see one of the most famous actresses in the world going and completely wiping away all the work that you have done to be taken seriously... I fear you’re just out of touch, because it really is that deep."
    Condemned

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    In a TikTok video, Cassidy Gray said the ad was not a joke for female athletes who are sexualized or not taken seriously, and that it wiped away their work to be taken seriously. CBC reports she called Sweeney's Instagram response to the backlash "idiotic" and "senseless."

    After the statement

    Quoted and described directly by CBC News.

    Why this label?

    Gray says the ad wipes away female athletes' work to be taken seriously and rejects the framing of it as a harmless joke, an express denunciation of the ad.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  15. Sydney SweeneyActor; strategic partner and equity holder, NovigDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    Posted to Instagram on September 13, 2026, as the athlete-led backlash was building.

    "it’s gamedayyy @novig #novigpartner"
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Sydney Sweeney posted images from the Novig ad on Instagram on September 13 with the caption "it's gamedayyy @novig #novigpartner." Fox News reported that she also shared ESPN "Body Issue" photographs of athletes, which TheWrap described as Instagram Stories.

    After the statement

    Sweeney did not otherwise give a verbal, on-record response addressing the athletes’ specific objections as of this record.

    Why this label?

    DI reads the reported juxtaposition of campaign and athlete photographs as an implicit defense of the ad. The caption itself does not explain the comparison.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  16. Gracie KramerAmerican gymnast

    Before this statement

    Posted to Instagram, then expanded on in an NBC News interview.

    "When sexualization is used as a way to get men interested in women’s sports, it reinforces the exact narrative we’ve been trying to dismantle. This isn’t celebrity drama to me. It’s about the culture we’re creating for the next generation of girls in sports and making sure they grow up believing their talent is enough to deserve attention and respect."
    Condemned

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Gracie Kramer told NBC News the Novig ad reinforces the sexualization of women’s sports rather than dismantling it.

    After the statement

    Kramer’s Instagram post is widely credited as helping start the athlete response trend.

    Why this label?

    Kramer expressly argues the ad "reinforces the exact narrative we’ve been trying to dismantle," a direct denunciation of the campaign’s approach.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  17. Amy HuntBritish sprinter; four-time European champion

    Before this statement

    Said in a post-race interview after finishing fourth in the 200m final at the World Athletics Ultimate Championship in Budapest on September 13, 2026.

    "Sydney Sweeney, this is what women in sport look like... when you’re a woman in sport, it’s not pretty. It’s not glamorous. It’s not sexy all the time, definitely."
    Condemned

    Case context: Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport

    Full statement and sources

    Amy Hunt told the BBC after a race that the Novig ad does not reflect what women in sport actually look like.

    After the statement

    Hunt gave a further, more extended interview on Good Morning Britain on September 15, 2026, reiterating the concern in terms of role models for young girls.

    Why this label?

    Hunt directly contrasts the ad’s portrayal with what she says women in sport actually look like ("muscles, hard work, sweat, blood, tears"), condemning the ad’s depiction. She separately notes the criticism "isn’t anything personal" toward Sweeney as an individual, which qualifies any personal animus toward Sweeney but does not soften her criticism of the ad’s portrayal itself.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  18. Ariarne TitmusRetired Olympic swimmer; four-time Olympic gold medallist

    Before this statement

    Posted to Instagram Stories as the athlete-led backlash against the ad was building over the weekend of September 13–14, 2026.

    "I can’t describe how infuriated I feel when I watch this. Not only is it a kick in the face to every woman who had dedicated her life to perfecting her craft, but every women who enjoys sports for what it really is – teamwork, friendship, dedication, excellent, unity... How do we live in a world where monetising a women’s body and sexualising women’s sport is still a thing?"
    Condemned

    Responding to: The Novig "Just Sports" ad campaign sexualizes women’s sport and demeans the work of women who compete in it, rather than showcasing athletic skill.

    Full statement and sources

    Ariarne Titmus condemned the Novig ad on Instagram as sexualizing women’s sport and monetizing a woman’s body.

    After the statement

    The quote was independently reported and corroborated by The Guardian and CBC (via ABC News Australia).

    Why this label?

    Titmus expressly denounces the campaign as sexualizing women’s sport and monetizing a woman’s body, calling it a "kick in the face" to women in sport, with no qualifying condition.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

Sources

(34)

Original video

Novig is Just Sports (campaign video)

About this source

Novig’s "Just Sports" campaign video featuring Sydney Sweeney, posted to Novig’s YouTube channel on the campaign launch date. The primary material at the center of this dispute.

Published
Accessed

Interview

Star female golfer fires back at Sydney Sweeney critics: 'She's got sex ...

Star female golfer fires back at Sydney Sweeney critics: 'She's got sex ... (opens in a new tab)Thursday, September 24 OutKick interview; directly attributed quotations
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Thursday, September 24 OutKick interview; directly attributed quotations

About this source

OutKick's original interviewer reports Hull's own words about the advertisement.

Author
Joe Kinsey
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Novig doubles down on Sydney Sweeney campaign amid criticism

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Report of Fortinsky's October 11 Ad Age interview

About this source

SBJ reproduces Novig's figures and quotations from Fortinsky's Ad Age interview. Fortinsky also credits the start of the NFL season.

Author
Sports Business Journal
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Interview

Novig expands controversial Sydney Sweeney campaign as trading volume triples

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Company growth report and second campaign installment

About this source

Brian Bonilla reports Novig's expanded campaign and company-reported growth.

Author
Brian Bonilla
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

As Novig Unveils Sydney Sweeney Sequel, Powerade Bites Back

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: October 11 release of the second Just Sports ad

About this source

Stewart reports that Sweeney posted the second commercial on October 11 and reproduces its opening words.

Author
Rebecca Stewart
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Analysis

Advertising like Sydney Sweeney's Novig campaign teach women to see themselves as objects

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Opening argument and discussion of objectification

About this source

The article is jointly written by Samantha Jones, Jamie Hong Chow and Noah Eliot Vanderhoeven. They discuss research on objectification and gambling promotion.

Author
Samantha Jones; Jamie Hong Chow; Noah Eliot Vanderhoeven
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Analysis

Sydney Sweeney's Novig Ad Reveals a New Risk for Brands

Sydney Sweeney's Novig Ad Reveals a New Risk for Brands (opens in a new tab)Opening assessment and discussion of reputation risk
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Opening assessment and discussion of reputation risk

About this source

Torossian's signed analysis was published September 16 and updated October 21. This statement uses the updated version.

Author
Ronn Torossian
Published
Accessed

Interview

Charley Hull responds to criticism of Sydney Sweeney

Charley Hull responds to criticism of Sydney Sweeney (opens in a new tab)Original 40-second interview clip and published description

Golfer Charley Hull responds to criticism of Sydney Sweeney, in an OutKick interview published by Fox News, Sept. 24, 2026.

DI added its logo in the corner.

Video: Fox News (OutKick). Excerpt used for news reporting and commentary

Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: Original 40-second interview clip and published description)

About this source

Fox publishes its interview with Hull, who dismisses the controversy over the Novig campaign. The recording date is not specified.

Author
Fox News
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Analysis

Matt Calkins defends Sydney Sweeney's Novig sports ad

Matt Calkins defends Sydney Sweeney's Novig sports ad (opens in a new tab)Argument distinguishing sex appeal from an attack on female athletes
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Argument distinguishing sex appeal from an attack on female athletes

About this source

Calkins defends the ad as marketing and criticizes its detractors. His claims about the campaign's financial effect are his assessment.

Author
Matt Calkins
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Analysis

That Sydney Sweeney Novig Ad: What Harms Women Is Bad for Men, Too

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Argument concerning harms to women and men

About this source

Norton-Cruz argues that the campaign sexualizes women and promotes harmful expectations among men.

Author
Laura Norton-Cruz
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Interview

Novig credits Sydney Sweeney campaign for growth

Novig credits Sydney Sweeney campaign for growth (opens in a new tab)October 3 article, Backlash against Just Sports ad section and Fortinsky's before-and-after platform figures.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: October 3 article, Backlash against Just Sports ad section and Fortinsky's before-and-after platform figures.

About this source

Fortinsky renews his defense of the ad and supplies company growth figures to CNBC. The comparisons cover the 20 days before and after launch, a period that also included the start of the NFL season.

Author
Ananya Chetia
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Female Athletes Call Out Sydney Sweeney’s Nude Ad: ‘Can’t Describe How Infuriated I Feel’

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Closing two paragraphs, immediately after Amy Hunt quotation

About this source

TheWrap reports that Sweeney posted ESPN Body Issue covers in her Instagram Story. It separately quotes her campaign statement on the Novig website. The report corroborates the image context, rather than supplying the feed caption.

Author
Andi Ortiz
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Sydney Sweeney's September 13 Novig Instagram post

Sydney Sweeney's September 13 Novig Instagram post (opens in a new tab) · Sydney SweeneyPost DdOv62FkQnv, feed caption and publication date
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Post DdOv62FkQnv, feed caption and publication date

Excerpt

"it’s gamedayyy @novig #novigpartner"

About this source

Original caption on the verified Sydney Sweeney account, co-posted with Novig. The feed post promotes the Novig campaign. The caption supplies no explanation of the separately reported ESPN athlete photographs.

Author
Sydney Sweeney
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

No Hesitation episode: Sophie Gets Real About the Sydney Sweeney Ad

Excerpt

"“Do I like the particular ad? Not really.”"

About this source

In a section about the Novig advertisement, Cunningham calls the ad inauthentic and morally odd, questions the backlash, and says it was not directed at women’s sports. Drew Hanlen’s later comments are distinct from Cunningham’s.

Author
No Hesitation with Sophie Cunningham & Drew Hanlen
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

Jen Psaki comments on Novig’s Sydney Sweeney sports ad

Jen Psaki comments on Novig’s Sydney Sweeney sports ad (opens in a new tab)MS NOW video, 13:58–14:41. The video was uploaded September 17, 2026, to MS NOW’s official YouTube channel.

Excerpt

"But the problem is the message an ad like this sends about women in sports."

About this source

In this MS NOW video, Jen Psaki says she does not object to Sydney Sweeney’s choice to use her body, then argues that the Novig ad’s message reinforces what she describes as misogynistic sexualization of women’s sports.

Author
MS NOW
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Australian Institute of Sport on Instagram: “THIS is sport.”

Watch original video (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Instagram post; caption as returned by the platform.

Excerpt

"THIS is sport."

About this source

The Australian Institute of Sport’s contribution to the counter-trend, posting footage of archery, gymnastics, boxing and softball. It is the only national sporting institution found to have participated; it does not name Sweeney, Novig or the advertisement, so it is recorded as a dated development rather than as an institutional position on the dispute.

Author
Australian Institute of Sport
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

Gracie Kramer on TikTok: “Because it really is that deep.”

Watch original video (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Video post; caption as returned by the platform.

Excerpt

"Because it really is that deep."

About this source

The video the Guardian credits with starting the trend of athletes posting their own footage in response to the advertisement. It was uploaded on September 12, 2026. That places it a day before any criticism currently recorded in this case. The Guardian renders an additional line, “idk what Sydney Sweeney was doing, but this is what a woman in sports looks like,” which does not appear in the video's caption and may be on-screen text; it is not reproduced here as a quotation. Kramer’s separately recorded statement of September 13 is a different artefact, made on Instagram and expanded in an NBC News interview.

Author
Gracie Kramer
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

The Sporting News: Sophie Cunningham on the Sydney Sweeney Novig ad

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Section carrying Cunningham’s remarks from her podcast.

Excerpt

"“Why are girls mad? That is literally what she does… Men, sports, naked women. Of course that’s gonna draw attention… Go do your thing sis,” Cunningham said."

About this source

Reports remarks by WNBA player Sophie Cunningham on her podcast “No Hesitation” with co-host Drew Hanlen. The ellipses are the outlet’s elisions from the podcast audio; the underlying episode is the primary record and has not been reviewed for this case. The same report notes Sweeney has not commented on the ad but shared Instagram Stories of female athletes from ESPN’s Body issue. This is the Yahoo syndication of The Sporting News article.

Author
Autumn Hawkins
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Newsweek: Sweeney’s follower count drops then rebounds after the Novig ad

Newsweek: Sweeney’s follower count drops then rebounds after the Novig ad (opens in a new tab)Section headed “The Backlash Over the Ad,” giving day-by-day follower figures.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Section headed “The Backlash Over the Ad,” giving day-by-day follower figures.

Excerpt

"On September 13, as the backlash to the advert began to go viral, she lost 136,848 followers. The following day, she lost 66,446 followers. That comes out to a loss of 203,294 followers in a 48-hour period."

About this source

Dates the tipping point of the backlash to September 13 using day-by-day Social Blade figures: Sweeney gained followers on September 9 through 12, then lost 136,848 on September 13 and 66,446 on September 14, before regaining 102,936 across September 15 and 16. Useful as a dated measure of when the reaction became widespread, not as evidence about the ad’s merits.

Author
Marni Rose McFall
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Official statement

Novig: “Sydney Sweeney Teams Up With Novig For Bold New ‘Just Sports’ Campaign”

Novig: “Sydney Sweeney Teams Up With Novig For Bold New ‘Just Sports’ Campaign” (opens in a new tab) · NovigCompany announcement, paragraph carrying Sweeney’s quotation.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Company announcement, paragraph carrying Sweeney’s quotation.

Excerpt

"“The campaign was about embracing a fun idea,” said Sweeney, who also joins Novig as a strategic partner and equity holder. “The concept is simple: cut through the noise and put the focus entirely on sports.”"

About this source

Novig’s own launch announcement, dated September 9, 2026 on the page. It is the primary record of the campaign’s launch date and of Sweeney’s role as strategic partner and equity holder. Novig later declined to disclose the terms or size of her stake when asked by Fortune.

Author
Novig
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original text

Sydney Sweeney ATTACKED For Doing Naked Advertisement, Loses Followers w/ Dr. Ron Elfenbein (Timcast IRL)

About this source

Transcript of the September 16, 2026 Timcast IRL livestream, featuring Tim Pool and guest Dr. Ron Elfenbein discussing the Novig ad backlash.

Published
Accessed

Analysis

Sydney Sweeney, Novig ad, and body positivity's double standard

Excerpt

"If women are supposed to be proud of their bodies, that principle has to include women whose bodies other people happen to find attractive."

About this source

Magnolia Tribune op-ed by Russ Latino defending Sweeney via a body-positivity double-standard argument.

Published
Accessed

Interview

Felicity Palmateer condemns the Sydney Sweeney/Novig ad

Excerpt

"Don't know what Sydney thinks sport looks like, but THIS is what sport looks like... not hypersexualized content designed to sell a gambling app."

About this source

CNN report and Felicity Palmateer's own Instagram post condemning the Novig ad.

Published
Accessed

Analysis

Townhall: "Meltdown Over Sydney Sweeney Novig Ad"

Excerpt

"It's her body, her choice... Is it me, or are women just jealous of Sweeney?"

About this source

Townhall op-ed by managing editor Matt Vespa defending Sweeney against the backlash over the Novig ad.

Published
Accessed

Interview

Amy Hunt discusses the Novig ad on Good Morning Britain

Excerpt

"It's not anything personal against that actress... the reaction has almost outweighed the moment."

About this source

The Independent report on Amy Hunt's September 15, 2026 Good Morning Britain appearance discussing the Novig ad.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Novig CEO says Sweeney drove the ad's visuals

Excerpt

"It really was Sydney who was driving a lot of the visuals and the messaging."

About this source

Front Office Sports report on Novig CEO Jacob Fortinsky's September 15, 2026 remarks at the "Asset Class" event, attributing the ad's visuals and messaging to Sweeney.

Published
Accessed

Analysis

Breaking Points on the Sydney Sweeney/Novig ad

Excerpt

"softcore pornography"

About this source

Breaking Points (Krystal Ball and Saagar Enjeti) segment on the Sydney Sweeney/Novig ad controversy.

Published
Accessed

Analysis

Are you outraged by Sydney Sweeney – again? More fool you

About this source

Marina Hyde’s signed Guardian opinion column arguing the backlash against Sweeney is disproportionate.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Novig CEO defends Sydney Sweeney ad, knew people who ‘hate her’ would be ‘loud’

About this source

Report on Jacob Fortinsky’s Front Office Sports interview defending the ad after the backlash, syndicated from USA Today’s For The Win.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Sydney Sweeney fires back at trolls after facing criticism online for provocative sports ad

About this source

Fox News report directly quoting the caption ("It’s gamedayyyy") on Sweeney’s Sept. 13 Instagram response to the backlash.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Sydney Sweeney Addresses Sports Ad Controversy on Instagram Story

About this source

TODAY.com report quoting Gracie Kramer’s Instagram post and her NBC News interview, and describing Sweeney’s Sept. 9 Complex interview quote.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Sydney Sweeney’s ‘sexualized’ sports betting ad slammed by Canadian athletes

About this source

CBC News report quoting Cassidy Gray’s TikTok video and Molly Carlson’s Instagram post, plus Jacob Fortinsky’s launch-day quote.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Amy Hunt: Sydney Sweeney betting ad risks being a ‘barrier’ to girls in sport

About this source

ESPN report quoting Amy Hunt’s Good Morning Britain interview about the ad, including her caveat that her criticism is not personal toward Sweeney.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Sydney Sweeney under fire for ‘sexualising women’s sport’ in sports prediction ad

About this source

The Guardian’s report on the athlete-led backlash, directly quoting Ariarne Titmus’s Instagram Story and Skye Nicolson’s Instagram post.

Published
Accessed

Corrections

(2)

Corrections address errors in our reporting or labels. When a speaker changes their position, we add a separate statement and link it to the earlier one.

Reporting correction

Correction to: Statement by Sydney Sweeney

Previous language
It’s gamedayyyy [caption on a carousel pairing an image from the Novig ad with ESPN "Body Issue" photos of athletes including Serena Williams, Ronda Rousey, Sue Bird, Megan Rapinoe, Caroline Wozniacki, Myles Garrett, Rob Gronkowski, Karl-Anthony Towns, and Jason Kelce]
Corrected language
it’s gamedayyy @novig #novigpartner Sydney Sweeney posted images from the Novig ad on Instagram on September 13 with the caption "it's gamedayyy @novig #novigpartner." Fox News reported that she also shared ESPN "Body Issue" photographs of athletes, which TheWrap described as Instagram Stories.

We removed an editorial image description from Sweeney's quotation and restored the caption as displayed in her September 13 Instagram post. The earlier description merged the feed post with separately reported Instagram Stories. The image context now appears outside the quotation with attribution to Fox News and TheWrap. The Fox News report's publication date is September 13, 2026, rather than the previously listed September 15.

This corrects our account of what happened.

Sydney Sweeney's September 13 Novig Instagram post (opens in a new tab) · Sydney SweeneyPost DdOv62FkQnv, feed caption and publication date

Original caption on the verified Sydney Sweeney account, co-posted with Novig. The feed post promotes the Novig campaign. The caption supplies no explanation of the separately reported ESPN athlete photographs.

Archived copy (opens in a new tab)
Sydney Sweeney fires back at trolls after facing criticism online for provocative sports ad (opens in a new tab)

Fox News report directly quoting the caption ("It’s gamedayyyy") on Sweeney’s Sept. 13 Instagram response to the backlash.

Archived copy (opens in a new tab)
Female Athletes Call Out Sydney Sweeney’s Nude Ad: ‘Can’t Describe How Infuriated I Feel’ (opens in a new tab)Closing two paragraphs, immediately after Amy Hunt quotation

TheWrap reports that Sweeney posted ESPN Body Issue covers in her Instagram Story. It separately quotes her campaign statement on the Novig website. The report corroborates the image context, rather than supplying the feed caption.

Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Classification correction

Correction to: Statement by Sophie Cunningham

Previous classification
Position Event #1080 classifies Sophie Cunningham’s remarks as “minimizes,” says the primary episode had not been reviewed, and dates the statement September 18, 2026.
Corrected classification
Review of the original September 17 episode shows that Cunningham both criticized the advertisement—calling it inauthentic, saying she did not like it, and calling it morally odd—and questioned the backlash, saying it was not directed at women’s sports. Her classification should be “mixed or conditional.” Supporting copy should identify September 17 as the episode’s release date and distinguish Cunningham’s remarks from Drew Hanlen’s later comments.

The published record relied on a reported excerpt. The full episode at 44:47–46:46 provides broader context and resolves the earlier source-status and date statement. This correction preserves the historical record rather than silently revising it.

This corrects an editorial classification.

No Hesitation episode: Sophie Gets Real About the Sydney Sweeney Ad (opens in a new tab)44:47–46:46 in the episode.

In a section about the Novig advertisement, Cunningham calls the ad inauthentic and morally odd, questions the backlash, and says it was not directed at women’s sports. Drew Hanlen’s later comments are distinct from Cunningham’s.

Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Case updates

Want updates on the Sweeney Novig ad backlash?

Get an email if Novig changes or extends the campaign, or if Sweeney, Novig's chief executive or the athletes who objected say more.

7 updates added in the last 14 days.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

The newsletter

Follow disputes like this one.

New cases and significant updates to the record, in your inbox. Free.

You’ll confirm your subscription on Substack.

Share or embed this case

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/cases/sydney-sweeney-novig-just-sports-ad

The Dispute Index. "Sydney Sweeney’s Novig "Just Sports" ad draws backlash over sexualizing women’s sport". First published: 2026-09-16. Last updated: 2026-09-16. https://disputeindex.com/cases/sydney-sweeney-novig-just-sports-ad