All topics

Women in Sports

Disputes concerning how women athletes and women’s sport are portrayed, marketed, or discussed publicly.

Published coverage on this page: 4 cases · 24+ statements. Statements are ordered newest first.

Topic updates

Follow this topic

Get free email updates about Women in Sports. We will email you when we add or correct a case in this topic.

Enable JavaScript to request email updates about this topic.

We will send a confirmation email first. Every update email has a link to stop. How we handle your email.

Related cases

Statements

Filter by response label

Labels describe a response to the linked claim or the action explained in the statement summary. Choose one or more.

40 matching statements

Logo of Nassau County

Nassau County

Role at the time: Nassau County Attorney Thomas Adams, in a statement reported by WABC-TV

Defended or excused

Response to this claim

Nassau County's ban on teams that include transgender women and girls in women's and girls' sports at county facilities protects the integrity and safety of women's sports.

“we are reviewing the decision with the intention to continue the appeals process.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Appeals court strikes down Nassau County transgender sports banFull article
Why we used this label

The reference point is Nassau County's law barring women's and girls' teams that include transgender women and girls from county parks and facilities, which the Second Department struck down on November 4, 2026. The county says it will keep appealing the ruling that struck down its law, which continues its defense of the ban.

Logo of New York Civil Liberties Union

New York Civil Liberties Union

Role at the time: Gabriella Larios, senior staff attorney at the New York Civil Liberties Union, which represents the Long Island Roller Rebels, speaking to WABC-TV

Condemned

Response to this claim

Nassau County's ban on teams that include transgender women and girls in women's and girls' sports at county facilities protects the integrity and safety of women's sports.

“I want people to understand that this ban is unjust, and it is aimed at excluding trans people from places they have grown up, from communities that they feel safe in”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Appeals court strikes down Nassau County transgender sports banFull article
Why we used this label

The reference point is Nassau County's law barring women's and girls' teams that include transgender women and girls from county parks and facilities, which the Second Department struck down on November 4, 2026. The NYCLU's lawyer calls the ban unjust and aimed at excluding transgender people, which condemns it.

Portrait of Letitia James

Letitia James

Role at the time: New York attorney general, in a statement after the ruling

Condemned

Response to this claim

Nassau County's ban on teams that include transgender women and girls in women's and girls' sports at county facilities protects the integrity and safety of women's sports.

“No one asked for this illegal and exclusionary policy. Bruce Blakeman was just trying to stop athletes from playing with their teammates. I am pleased the court saw right through it.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Attorney General James Wins Lawsuit Against Nassau County Over Illegal Trans Athlete BanFull press release
Why we used this label

The reference point is Nassau County's law barring women's and girls' teams that include transgender women and girls from county parks and facilities, which the Second Department struck down on November 4, 2026. James calls the law illegal and exclusionary and says Blakeman was trying to keep athletes from their teammates, which condemns it.

Josh Turek

Role at the time: Democratic U.S. Senate nominee, speaking to reporters after a Fort Dodge campaign event

Defended or excused

Statement summary

Turek says angering people on both sides of the aisle probably means he is in the right place.

“Honestly, I think if you got some folks angry with you on both sides of the aisle, you're probably in the right place”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Turek under fire from both sides for ad opposing transgender women playing in women's sportsOctober 29, 12:19 p.m. CDT entry: Turek under fire from both sides

What this label refers to

Relative to the ad's policy positions under scrutiny, Turek answers the bipartisan criticism by saying that angering people on both sides suggests he is in the right place.

Portrait of Aime Wichtendahl

Aime Wichtendahl

Role at the time: Iowa state representative for House District 80, in an interview with Gray Media Iowa

Condemned

Statement summary

Iowa state Rep. Aime Wichtendahl, a Democrat who served with Turek in the Iowa House, said his ad was disappointing and its talking points would not win votes, and that she would hold him accountable if he is elected.

Quotation excerpt

“You don’t need to throw people under the bus to win elections. The plain fact is that these talking points don’t win elections. These talking points aren’t going to gain you anything with the voters ... If he is elected, I will spend every…”
Read full quotation
“You don’t need to throw people under the bus to win elections. The plain fact is that these talking points don’t win elections. These talking points aren’t going to gain you anything with the voters ... If he is elected, I will spend every single day holding his feet to the fire, reminding him that equality is not negotiable”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)Iowa legislator criticizes Turek campaign ad on transgender issuesWichtendahl's interview remarks

What this label refers to

Wichtendahl says the ad's talking points throw people under the bus and will not win votes, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Ashley Hinson

Ashley Hinson

Role at the time: Republican U.S. representative and Senate nominee, at a Coralville rally

Challenged the characterization

Statement summary

Hinson says Turek is trying to act like a Republican and run away from his liberal record.

“He is trying to act like a Republican to win this election here in Iowa, and he has to run away from his liberal record”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Josh Turek ad on transgender issues draws bipartisan criticismAd text, organizational statement and Hinson's Coralville remarks

What this label refers to

Relative to the ad, Hinson disputes its presentation of Turek's record, rather than rejecting the restrictions it advocates.

One Iowa Action

Role at the time: Iowa LGBTQ advocacy organization

Condemned

Statement summary

One Iowa Action condemns Turek's ad and what it calls a policy shift on Medicaid coverage for gender-affirming care.

“We unequivocally condemn Josh Turek's recently released campaign ad and the policy shift it represents.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)One Iowa Action Statement on Anti-Trans Political Ads · One Iowa ActionOpening and Medicaid policy paragraphs

What this label refers to

Relative to Turek's ad and policy, the organization expressly condemns both.

League of Women Voters of Seattle King County

Role at the time: Civic organization, letter by Janet Lenart and Phillippa Kassover

Condemned

Statement summary

League representatives sign a letter urging a no vote on three initiatives, including I-638. Their I-638 argument is that requiring doctors to certify girl athletes' sex, without a similar requirement for boy athletes, violates privacy and equal protection.

“IL26-638 is likely unconstitutional because it violates Washingtonians' rights to privacy and equal protection by requiring doctors to certify a girl's sex while it has no similar requirements for boy athletes.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Seattle King County League urges rejection of I-638Signed opinion letter, I-638 paragraph

What this label refers to

The reference point is I-638. The organization opposes the requirement and urges a no vote.

Portrait of Marie Gluesenkamp Perez

Marie Gluesenkamp Perez

Role at the time: Member of Congress

Condemned

Statement summary

Gluesenkamp Perez opposes I-638 and favors decisions by schools, associations and families.

“What I won't support is a rule that forces girls to prove their sex to the state every year just to play sports”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Washington candidates and clinicians discuss I-638Original interviews and reported October 16 Braun appearance

What this label refers to

The statement criticizes the proposed sports-eligibility requirement.

Jose Flores-Rodarte

Role at the time: Family physician

Condemned

Statement summary

Flores-Rodarte calls the sex verification the measure requires extremely invasive and unnecessary, and says it is discriminatory because it applies only to girls. He warns that families who cannot afford hormone or genetic testing could face genital exams.

“extremely invasive and unnecessary”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Washington candidates and clinicians discuss I-638Original interviews and reported October 16 Braun appearance

What this label refers to

The statement criticizes the proposed sports-eligibility requirement.

Washington Academy of Family Physicians

Role at the time: State professional association of family physicians

Condemned

Statement summary

The campaign release reports that the Washington Academy of Family Physicians adopted opposition to I-638. The position recorded here is the academy's documented decision.

“Action: Adopted opposition to Initiative IL26-638.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Campaign announces Washington Academy of Family Physicians opposition to I-638Opening announcement of the academy position

What this label refers to

The reference point is I-638. The documented organizational action explicitly opposes the proposal.

Portrait of John Braun

John Braun

Role at the time: State senator and congressional candidate

Defended or excused

Statement summary

OPB reports that Braun urges support for I-638. Speaking on Fox News on October 16, he describes the sports issue as one of common sense, fairness and safety and says it is simple biology.

“It's a common sense issue, it's a fairness issue, it's a safety issue”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Washington candidates and clinicians discuss I-638Original interviews and reported October 16 Braun appearance

What this label refers to

The reference point is I-638's sex-verification requirement for girls' sports. Braun backs the measure and describes the issue it addresses as one of fairness and safety.

UFCW 3000

Role at the time: Labor union, statement by president Faye Guenther

Condemned

Statement summary

UFCW 3000 says its executive board voted unanimously to oppose I-638 and I-001. It cites medical testing, costs to families and access to school sports.

“Nobody should have to submit their daughter to an invasive exam just to join them.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)UFCW 3000 announces opposition to I-638 and I-001Board decision and statement by Faye Guenther

What this label refers to

The reference point is I-638. The union explicitly opposes the proposed requirement.

Samantha Jones

Role at the time: Western University psychology researcher, co-author with Jamie Hong Chow and Noah Eliot Vanderhoeven

Condemned

Statement summary

The authors say the ad captures two troubling trends: routine sexualization of women's bodies in digital media and gambling companies' use of sexual appeal to target young men.

“The ad captures two troubling trends: how routinely women’s bodies are sexualized in digital media and how gambling companies use sexual appeal, and the implied promise of romantic or sexual reward, to target young men.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Advertising like Sydney Sweeney's Novig campaign teach women to see themselves as objectsOpening argument and discussion of objectification

What this label refers to

The matter under scrutiny is Novig's sexualized sports campaign. The co-authors criticize its use of women's bodies and its appeal to young men.

Libby Loft

Role at the time: Family physician and co-author of the signed opinion

Condemned

Statement summary

Loft and Manriquez argue that I-638 would require invasive or expensive verification and discourage girls' participation. They urge a no vote.

“a medically unnecessary invasive genital exam or costly genetic testing”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Libby Loft and Luis Manriquez oppose I-638's verification requirementOpening paragraphs and discussion of medical examinations

What this label refers to

The reference is the initiative's verification requirement. The physicians expressly reject it as medically unnecessary and harmful.

Jacob Fortinsky

Role at the time: Novig co-founder, speaking in a CNBC interview

Defended or excused

Statement summary

Fortinsky says Novig has no reason to apologize and remains proud of the ad. He says its purpose was to explain the platform rather than represent women athletes.

“Ultimately, I think we have nothing to apologize for and are very proud of the work that we did,”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)Novig credits Sydney Sweeney campaign for growthOctober 3 article, Backlash against Just Sports ad section and Fortinsky's before-and-after platform figures.

What this label refers to

He explicitly defends the disputed advertising campaign against the criticism that it harmed women's sport.

Matt Calkins

Role at the time: Sports columnist, writing for OutKick

Defended or excused

Statement summary

Calkins says the ad used sex appeal to reach a mostly male market and rejects its description as a kick in the face to female athletes.

“It was an ad that used sex appeal to catch the eye of a mostly-male market — not a "kick in the face" to female athletes, as four-time Olympic swimming gold medalist Ariarne Titmus suggested.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Matt Calkins defends Sydney Sweeney's Novig sports adArgument distinguishing sex appeal from an attack on female athletes

What this label refers to

The matter under scrutiny is Novig's sexualized sports campaign. Calkins defends that approach and rejects the claim that it insults female athletes.

Laura Norton-Cruz

Role at the time: Social worker and public health writer, in a signed column

Condemned

Statement summary

Norton-Cruz says sexist marketing like this ad harms women and girls and does men no favors.

“So while sexist marketing like this is harmful to women and girls, it isn’t doing men any favors either.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)That Sydney Sweeney Novig Ad: What Harms Women Is Bad for Men, TooArgument concerning harms to women and men

What this label refers to

The matter under scrutiny is Novig's sexualized use of sports imagery. Norton-Cruz explicitly criticizes it as harmful.

Hallie Herzberg

Role at the time: Spokesperson, Let's Go Washington

Defended or excused

Statement summary

Herzberg argues that the initiative can use the sports-physical process to identify the league in which a student may participate.

“It would just add a checkbox back onto that sports physical form”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)Hallie Herzberg explains I-638's proposed sports-physical verificationHerzberg interview; checkbox explanation

What this label refers to

The reference is the proposed medical-verification requirement. Herzberg defends it as a simple addition to an existing form.

Portrait of Charley Hull

Charley Hull

Role at the time: Professional golfer, interviewed by Fox News

Defended or excused

Statement summary

Hull endorses the ad and rejects the claim that it turns back women's sports.

“So I think it's a great idea. I don't understand how it's turning back women's sports because it's not.”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)Charley Hull responds to criticism of Sydney SweeneyOriginal 40-second interview clip and published description

What this label refers to

Hull's explicit praise of the advertisement as a great idea establishes approval, alongside her rejection of criticism about women's sports.

Portrait of Jen Psaki

Jen Psaki

Role at the time: MS NOW television host and political commentator

Condemned

Statement summary

Jen Psaki said the message of Novig’s Sydney Sweeney ad was the problem and said it reinforced what she described as misogynistic sexualization of women’s sports.

“But the problem is the message an ad like this sends about women in sports.”
Watch the original video (opens in a new tab)Jen Psaki comments on Novig's Sydney Sweeney sports adMS NOW video, 13:58 to 14:41. The video was uploaded September 17, 2026, to MS NOW's official YouTube channel.

What this label refers to

Case 39 concerns the criticism that the ad sexualizes women’s sport. Psaki explicitly calls the ad’s message a problem and says it reinforces misogynistic sexualization of women’s sports. That is a substantive criticism of the ad rather than a challenge to its characterization.

Portrait of Sophie Cunningham

Sophie Cunningham

Role at the time: WNBA player for the Indiana Fever, speaking on her podcast “No Hesitation”

Mixed or conditional

Statement summary

WNBA player Sophie Cunningham said on her podcast that she did not understand why the advertisement had angered women, that its combination of men, sports and nudity was obviously going to draw attention, and that Sweeney should carry on. She also said she did not really like the ad, called Sweeney’s involvement inauthentic and found it “morally… a little weird,” and said the ad was not directed at women’s sports.

“Why are girls mad? That is literally what she does… Men, sports, naked women. Of course that’s gonna draw attention… Go do your thing sis”
Open source (opens in a new tab)The Sporting News: Sophie Cunningham on the Sydney Sweeney Novig adSection carrying Cunningham’s remarks from her podcast.

What this label refers to

On whether the advertisement sexualizes women’s sport, Cunningham takes materially different positions in the same segment. She criticizes the ad, saying she does not really like it, calling Sweeney’s involvement inauthentic and calling it morally odd, while also questioning the backlash, asking why women were angry and saying the ad was not directed at women’s sports. That combination is “Mixed or conditional” rather than “Minimized,” because her criticism is a substantive objection, not only a qualification on a dismissal.

Ron Elfenbein

Role at the time: Physician; guest panelist, Timcast IRL

Defended or excused

Statement summary

Dr. Ron Elfenbein defended the Novig ad's aspirational advertising approach.

“advertising being aspirational again... is a good thing... you want people to look at your product and say, I want to feel good.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Sydney Sweeney ATTACKED For Doing Naked Advertisement, Loses Followers w/ Dr. Ron Elfenbein (Timcast IRL)

What this label refers to

Elfenbein argues that aspirational advertising is a legitimate and positive approach, defending the ad's style against the backlash.

Portrait of Tim Pool

Tim Pool

Role at the time: Host, Timcast IRL

Defended or excused

Statement summary

Tim Pool dismissed the backlash against the Novig ad as driven by jealousy.

Quotation excerpt

“Sydney Sweeney is going massively viral again because she put up a commercial of herself and she's just basically naked... I've seen all of these viral trending Instagram and TikTok videos [where] women are complaining... And I, you know,…”
Read full quotation
“Sydney Sweeney is going massively viral again because she put up a commercial of herself and she's just basically naked... I've seen all of these viral trending Instagram and TikTok videos [where] women are complaining... And I, you know, jealous, I guess, whatever.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Sydney Sweeney ATTACKED For Doing Naked Advertisement, Loses Followers w/ Dr. Ron Elfenbein (Timcast IRL)

What this label refers to

Pool dismisses the athlete-led backlash as jealousy rather than a substantive objection to the ad, implicitly defending the ad against the criticism it drew.

Older statements

People in this topic

Letitia James

Letitia James is a Democrat who has been New York's attorney general since 2019. She was the first woman elected to the office and the first woman of color to hold statewide office in New York, and she was re-elected in 2022 and 2026. Before that she was New York City public advocate and, for ten years, a New York City Council member for Brooklyn's 35th district. She began her career as a public defender at the Legal Aid Society.

1 case and 1 statement

Josh Turek

Josh Turek is an Iowa state representative, former professional wheelchair-basketball player and Democratic candidate for the U.S. Senate. He competed for the United States in four Paralympic Games and won two gold medals. He graduated from Southwest Minnesota State University in 2002 and later earned an MBA. His work has included youth adaptive-sports programs and mobility equipment.

1 case and 1 statement

Aime Wichtendahl

Aime Wichtendahl is a Democratic member of the Iowa House of Representatives for District 80 in the Cedar Rapids area. Elected in 2024, she is the first transgender person to serve in the Iowa Legislature. She served on the Hiawatha City Council from 2015.

1 case and 1 statement

Ashley Hinson

Republican candidate for U.S. Senate in Iowa.

1 case and 1 statement

Jose Flores-Rodarte

Jose Flores-Rodarte is a family physician at HealthPoint SeaTac in Washington. His professional interests include refugee and Latino health, LGBTQ+ health, public health and medical education.

1 case and 1 statement

Marie Gluesenkamp Perez

United States Representative and Democratic candidate for U.S. House in Washington's 3rd district.

1 case and 1 statement

John Braun

Republican candidate for U.S. House in Washington's 3rd district.

1 case and 1 statement

Samantha Jones

Samantha Jones is a psychology researcher at Western University in Canada. Her research examines social media, mood and well-being. She earned her doctorate in social developmental psychology at Western.

1 case and 1 statement

Libby Loft

Libby Loft is a family physician in Spokane, Washington. She writes publicly about medical care and health policy.

1 case and 1 statement

Jacob Fortinsky

Co-founder and CEO of Novig, a U.S. sports prediction market.

1 case and 3 statements

Matt Calkins

Matt Calkins is a sports journalist and columnist for OutKick who also publishes on Substack. He previously wrote for The Seattle Times and the San Diego Union-Tribune and covered the Portland Trail Blazers for The Columbian. He began his newspaper career at the Riverside Press-Enterprise in 2004.

1 case and 1 statement

Laura Norton-Cruz

Laura Norton-Cruz is an Alaska-based social worker, public health professional and writer. Her work includes health equity, violence prevention and family well-being.

1 case and 1 statement

More people