All topics

Health Care

Public disputes concerning medical treatment, screening, access to care, health services, insurance, and health-care policy.

Published coverage on this page: 4+ cases · 24+ statements. Statements are ordered newest first.

Topic updates

Follow this topic

Get free email updates about Health Care. We will email you when we add or correct a case in this topic.

Enable JavaScript to request email updates about this topic.

We will send a confirmation email first. Every update email has a link to stop. How we handle your email.

Related cases

More cases

Statements

Filter by response label

Labels describe a response to the linked claim or the action explained in the statement summary. Choose one or more.

165 matching statements

Portrait of Ron Wyden

Ron Wyden

Role at the time: U.S. senator from Oregon, in a post on X

Condemned

Response to this claim

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s time as health secretary has been a failure, with higher health care costs, more measles deaths, the loss of measles elimination status and no progress on processed foods, and President Trump should replace him.

Quotation excerpt

“RFK Jr. will be remembered as the HHS Secretary that lost America’s measles eradication status. Under his leadership, we have witnessed the unraveling of decades of lifesaving science and innovation, and America’s children have paid the…”
Read full quotation
“RFK Jr. will be remembered as the HHS Secretary that lost America’s measles eradication status. Under his leadership, we have witnessed the unraveling of decades of lifesaving science and innovation, and America’s children have paid the price. It’s time to hold him accountable.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Ron Wyden's X post on the loss of measles elimination status · Ron WydenQuote post of a Reuters report
Why we used this label

Wyden blames Kennedy for the loss of the measles status and says he should be held accountable, so we labeled it Condemned.

Logo of Israel Defense Forces

Israel Defense Forces

Role at the time: Israel's military, in a post on X

Defended or excused

Response to this claim

Hamas used Nasser Hospital as a headquarters, and the hospital's second floor served as a military command post for Khan Yunis Brigade commander Muhammad Abu Ismail.

“Hamas terrorists presented as civilians were among those eliminated in the strike at Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis, Gaza.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)IDF post naming Hamas members killed in the Nasser Hospital strike · Israel Defense ForcesPost on X
Why we used this label

The IDF says Hamas members were among the dead and that Hamas ignored warnings to stop using the hospital, which it presents as grounds for the strike, so we labeled it as defending or excusing the strike.

Portrait of Tammy Baldwin

Tammy Baldwin

Role at the time: U.S. senator from Wisconsin, in a post on X

Condemned

Response to this claim

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s time as health secretary has been a failure, with higher health care costs, more measles deaths, the loss of measles elimination status and no progress on processed foods, and President Trump should replace him.

“Having a conspiracy theorist lead our nation's largest health agency has real consequences for our families.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Tammy Baldwin's X post on Kennedy and the measles status · Tammy BaldwinPost linking to a New York Times report
Why we used this label

Baldwin calls the head of the country's largest health agency a conspiracy theorist and says that has real consequences for families, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Bill Cassidy

Bill Cassidy

Role at the time: U.S. senator from Louisiana and chair of the Senate health committee, in an interview on CBS's Face the Nation

Condemned

Response to this claim

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s time as health secretary has been a failure, with higher health care costs, more measles deaths, the loss of measles elimination status and no progress on processed foods, and President Trump should replace him.

“This has been a failure. If I were president, I would choose someone else because there needs to be accountability for higher healthcare costs, more measles deaths, losing elimination status, and no progress on processed foods.”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)Transcript: Sen. Bill Cassidy on "Face the Nation with Margaret Brennan," Nov. 15, 2026 · CBS NewsFull interview transcript
Why we used this label

Cassidy calls Kennedy's tenure a failure and says the president should replace him, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Elizabeth Warren

Elizabeth Warren

Role at the time: U.S. senator from Massachusetts, in a post on X

Condemned

Response to this claim

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s time as health secretary has been a failure, with higher health care costs, more measles deaths, the loss of measles elimination status and no progress on processed foods, and President Trump should replace him.

“This didn’t have to happen. RFK Jr.’s anti vaccine agenda is a real threat to our public health.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Elizabeth Warren's X post on Kennedy and the measles status · Elizabeth WarrenPost with an image of a news headline
Why we used this label

Warren calls Kennedy's anti-vaccine agenda a real threat to public health, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Elizabeth Warren

Elizabeth Warren

Role at the time: U.S. senator from Massachusetts and co-sponsor of the Break Up Big Medicine Act, in a post on X

Condemned

Response to this claim

CVS Health's planned split is financial engineering that is great for shareholders but changes nothing for patients or anyone who pays for insurance or care.

“CVS says it’s breaking up. Don’t be fooled. CVS could still own your health insurance, pharmacy middleman, doctor’s office, and specialty pharmacy.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Elizabeth Warren's X post saying CVS could still own insurance, pharmacy middleman and doctor's office · Elizabeth WarrenPost
Why we used this label

Warren warns people not to be fooled by the breakup because CVS could still own their insurance, pharmacy middleman, doctor's office and specialty pharmacy, so we labeled it Condemned.

Shaiel Ben-Ephraim

Role at the time: Political commentator and author of The Grand Scheme newsletter, in a newsletter post

Condemned

Response to this claim

Advance warnings were issued to the civilian population before the strike on Nasser Hospital.

“Was the Israeli strike on Nasser Hospital a war crime? I think it was.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Shaiel Ben-Ephraim's newsletter post arguing the Nasser Hospital strike was a war crime · Shaiel Ben-EphraimPost in The Grand Scheme newsletter
Why we used this label

Ben-Ephraim says he believes the strike was a war crime and argues the IDF's own statements support that case, so we labeled it condemns.

Médecins Sans Frontières

Role at the time: Medical humanitarian organization that works at Nasser Hospital, in a statement

Condemned

Response to this claim

Advance warnings were issued to the civilian population before the strike on Nasser Hospital.

“In no conceivable circumstances can attacks on functioning hospitals in Gaza be treated as normal or acceptable.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Doctors Without Borders statement condemning the strike on Nasser Hospital · Médecins Sans FrontièresPress release
Why we used this label

MSF calls the strike unconscionable, says no warning was given and rejects attacks on working hospitals in any circumstances, so we labeled it condemns.

Portrait of Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

Role at the time: Director-general of the World Health Organization, in a post on X

Condemned

Response to this claim

Hamas used Nasser Hospital as a headquarters, and the hospital's second floor served as a military command post for Khan Yunis Brigade commander Muhammad Abu Ismail.

“Another deadly attack on health care in #Gaza: in the early morning hours, the surgery department of Nasser Medical Complex was hit, resulting in six deaths”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus X post on the strike on Nasser Medical Complex · Tedros Adhanom GhebreyesusPost on X with video
Why we used this label

Tedros describes the strike as another deadly attack on health care and says Gaza's health facilities must be protected, so we labeled it condemns.

Logo of Hamas

Hamas

Role at the time: Palestinian militant group that governs Gaza, as reported by NBC News

Condemned

Response to this claim

Hamas used Nasser Hospital as a headquarters, and the hospital's second floor served as a military command post for Khan Yunis Brigade commander Muhammad Abu Ismail.

“lies of the criminal enemy”
Open source (opens in a new tab)NBC News report on the Israeli strike on Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis · NBC NewsArticle, updated November 13, 2026
Why we used this label

Hamas denies using the hospital for military purposes and calls the strike a war crime, so we labeled it condemns.

Logo of Israel Defense Forces

Israel Defense Forces

Role at the time: Israel's military, in a post on X

Defended or excused

Response to this claim

Hamas used Nasser Hospital as a headquarters, and the hospital's second floor served as a military command post for Khan Yunis Brigade commander Muhammad Abu Ismail.

“Hamas turned the hospital complex into a headquarters to advance dozens of terrorist attacks and restore the brigade's terror capabilities.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Israel Defense Forces X post announcing the strike on Muhammad Abu Ismail at Nasser Hospital · Israel Defense ForcesPost on X
Why we used this label

The IDF justifies the strike by saying Hamas used the hospital as a headquarters for attacks, so we labeled it defends or excuses.

Portrait of Lateefah Simon

Lateefah Simon

Role at the time: U.S. representative from California's 12th District, in a Veterans Day press release

Condemned

Statement summary

Simon says it is abhorrent that the administration cancelled the clinic and columbarium after years of planning and more than $395 million in federal funding.

Quotation excerpt

“That's why it is abhorrent that the Trump Administration has cancelled the planned construction of a new clinic and columbarium at Alameda Point, despite years of planning and more than $395 million in federal funding already invested in…”
Read full quotation
“That's why it is abhorrent that the Trump Administration has cancelled the planned construction of a new clinic and columbarium at Alameda Point, despite years of planning and more than $395 million in federal funding already invested in the project.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)On Veterans Day, Congresswoman Simon Demands Answers for East Bay Veterans on the Status of Alameda Point Veterans Affairs Clinic and Columbarium ProjectPress release, November 11, 2026

What this label refers to

Simon calls the cancellation abhorrent and vows to keep fighting for the funding, so we labeled it condemns.

Logo of U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

Role at the time: HHS spokesperson, in a statement to news outlets

Defended or excused

Response to this claim

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s time as health secretary has been a failure, with higher health care costs, more measles deaths, the loss of measles elimination status and no progress on processed foods, and President Trump should replace him.

“He will continue to put prevention at the center of health care to end the chronic disease epidemic and Make America Healthy Again. Threats of impeachment will not distract him from delivering for the American people.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)RFK Jr. Says Big Developments Coming in Wake of MidtermsArticle, November 10, 2026
Why we used this label

The department says Kennedy has delivered the most sweeping public health reforms in modern history and will not be distracted by threats of impeachment, so we labeled it Defended or excused.

Stacy Mitchell

Role at the time: Co-executive director of the Institute for Local Self-Reliance, in a post on X

Condemned

Response to this claim

CVS Health's planned split is financial engineering that is great for shareholders but changes nothing for patients or anyone who pays for insurance or care.

“But here's the thing: CVS's breakup has two major loopholes. Both are designed to preserve its power.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Stacy Mitchell's X post on the CVS split · Stacy MitchellQuote post of a CNN post
Why we used this label

Mitchell says the plan's loopholes are designed to preserve CVS's power and that policymakers, not CVS, should decide what counts as an effective breakup, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Mark Cuban

Mark Cuban

Role at the time: Businessman and co-founder of the Mark Cuban Cost Plus Drug Company, in a post on X

Condemned

Response to this claim

CVS Health's planned split is financial engineering that is great for shareholders but changes nothing for patients or anyone who pays for insurance or care.

“He is a genius financial engineer. The split is great for shareholders. Changes nothing for patients or anyone who pays for insurance or care.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Mark Cuban's X post on the CVS split · Mark CubanQuote post of Matt Stoller's post
Why we used this label

Cuban says the split serves shareholders, changes nothing for patients and should not fool anyone, so we labeled it Condemned.

Portrait of Elizabeth Warren

Elizabeth Warren

Role at the time: U.S. senator from Massachusetts and co-sponsor of the Break Up Big Medicine Act, in a post on X

Condemned

Response to this claim

CVS Health's planned split is financial engineering that is great for shareholders but changes nothing for patients or anyone who pays for insurance or care.

“CVS sees the writing on the wall: Americans want to break up the giant corporations dominating health care. But this CEO is not fooling us—this lets CVS continue to own a massive conglomerate and rip people off.”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Elizabeth Warren's X post on the CVS split announcement · Elizabeth WarrenQuote post of the American Economic Liberties Project's post
Why we used this label

Warren says the split lets CVS keep a massive conglomerate and rip people off, so we labeled it Condemned.

Logo of Institute for Justice

Institute for Justice

Role at the time: Institute for Justice, through its attorney Daniel Woislaw in the firm's own release

Condemned

Statement summary

Institute for Justice attorney Daniel Woislaw rejects retaining newborn blood without parental consent.

“But the state doesn’t own your blood and DNA simply because it took that blood, without your consent, from your veins”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Institute for Justice announces intended appeal of newborn blood-spot dismissalOctober 30 release and statements by counsel and Erica Jedynak

What this label refers to

IJ's release challenges retention without consent through its attorney, who rejects state ownership of blood and genetic material.

Portrait of Rob Bonta

Rob Bonta

Role at the time: California attorney general

Condemned

Statement summary

Bonta calls the ruling a major victory and calls the administration's efforts to take away healthcare cruel.

Quotation excerpt

“People with serious illnesses or disabilities should not have to worry about losing their healthcare because of work requirements or related barriers. That’s not what Congress intended, and despite the Trump Administration’s cruel attempts…”
Read full quotation
“People with serious illnesses or disabilities should not have to worry about losing their healthcare because of work requirements or related barriers. That’s not what Congress intended, and despite the Trump Administration’s cruel attempts to rip away healthcare from those in need, that’s not what the court held today.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Bonta responds to ruling on Medicaid medical-frailty definition · Rob BontaBonta quotation and account of relief

What this label refers to

Regarding CMS's medical-frailty policy, Bonta condemns the administration's efforts as cruel.

Logo of Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services

Role at the time: Federal agency litigation position documented in the October 29 opinion

Defended or excused

Statement summary

CMS argues that the statute leaves room to exclude some people within the listed subcategories from the medical-frailty exemption.

“Action: Defended the additional impairment test, arguing that the term medically frail need not cover every person within the statutory subcategories.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Massachusetts v. Oz: opinion on medically frail Medicaid exemptionDoc. 147, pp. 6-16; No. 1:26-cv-12962-RGS

What this label refers to

The case concerns CMS's added exemption condition. The government defends it.

Josh Turek

Role at the time: Democratic U.S. Senate nominee, speaking to reporters after a Fort Dodge campaign event

Defended or excused

Statement summary

Turek says angering people on both sides of the aisle probably means he is in the right place.

“Honestly, I think if you got some folks angry with you on both sides of the aisle, you're probably in the right place”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Turek under fire from both sides for ad opposing transgender women playing in women's sportsOctober 29, 12:19 p.m. CDT entry: Turek under fire from both sides

What this label refers to

Relative to the ad's policy positions under scrutiny, Turek answers the bipartisan criticism by saying that angering people on both sides suggests he is in the right place.

Logo of OpenAI

OpenAI

Role at the time: Company, in a statement by spokesman Drew Pusateri

Mixed or conditional

Statement summary

OpenAI spokesman Drew Pusateri calls Wan's death incredibly heartbreaking and says that while ChatGPT is not a substitute for medical care, the company believes AI can play a role in helping people make sense of health information.

“While ChatGPT is not a substitute for medical care, we believe A.I. can play a role in helping people make sense of health information”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Bowen Wan: How 31-Year-Old Woman Died After Following ChatGPT AdviceFull article

What this label refers to

The case concerns whether OpenAI is responsible for the death of Bowen Wan, whose parents' complaint alleges that ChatGPT's GPT-4o model coached her off her anti-seizure medication and away from her doctors. OpenAI calls the case heartbreaking and concedes that ChatGPT is not a substitute for medical care, while defending a role for AI in health information and noting that the model Wan used is no longer available. It neither accepts nor disputes the complaint's account, so the response is mixed.

Social Media Victims Law Center

Role at the time: Law firm representing Bowen Wan's parents, in a statement by founding attorney Matthew P. Bergman

Condemned

Statement summary

The Social Media Victims Law Center, in a statement by founding attorney Matthew P. Bergman, says OpenAI built a product that spoke with a medical professional's confidence but had none of the training, oversight or responsibility of real doctors.

“OpenAI built a product that spoke with the confidence of a medical professional but carried none of the training, oversight, or responsibility that real doctors have.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Wan, et al. v. OpenAI, Inc., et al.: complaint and media materials · The Schenk Law FirmPress release and statements of counsel

What this label refers to

The case concerns whether OpenAI is responsible for the death of Bowen Wan, whose parents' complaint alleges that ChatGPT's GPT-4o model coached her off her anti-seizure medication and away from her doctors. The firm says ChatGPT spoke with a doctor's confidence and none of a doctor's training or responsibility, and that a human doctor who gave the same advice would be liable for malpractice, which condemns OpenAI's conduct as the complaint describes it.

The Schenk Law Firm

Role at the time: Law firm representing Bowen Wan's parents, in a statement by partner Benjamin S. Schenk

Condemned

Statement summary

Benjamin S. Schenk, a partner at the firm representing Wan's parents, says the complaint alleges ChatGPT diagnosed her, wrote her a dose-by-dose taper schedule and revised it when she had seizures, and that this is practicing medicine, which requires a license in California.

“The complaint alleges ChatGPT diagnosed Bowen, wrote her a dose-by-dose taper schedule, and revised it when she had seizures. That is practicing medicine. And in California you need a license to do so.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Wan, et al. v. OpenAI, Inc., et al.: complaint and media materials · The Schenk Law FirmPress release and statements of counsel

What this label refers to

The case concerns whether OpenAI is responsible for ChatGPT's GPT-4o model coaching Bowen Wan off her anti-seizure medication and away from her doctors before her death, as her parents' complaint alleges. Schenk says ChatGPT practiced medicine without a license by writing and revising her taper schedule, which condemns OpenAI's product for the conduct the complaint describes.

Logo of Electronic Frontier Foundation

Electronic Frontier Foundation

Role at the time: Electronic Frontier Foundation, in its published analysis

Condemned

Statement summary

EFF criticizes the transparency, testing and legal limits governing WISeR and asks Congress to intervene.

Quotation excerpt

“By outsourcing decision-making to private AI companies without sufficient transparency, testing, or legal limits, WISeR jeopardizes seniors’ access to medical care. Congress should step in to place greater legal limits on the use of…”
Read full quotation
“By outsourcing decision-making to private AI companies without sufficient transparency, testing, or legal limits, WISeR jeopardizes seniors’ access to medical care. Congress should step in to place greater legal limits on the use of automated decision-making in Medicare.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)EFF challenges WISeR safeguards after new records releaseIntroduction and discussion of clinician review

What this label refers to

Relative to WISeR's safeguards, EFF expressly criticizes their adequacy and the risks of outsourcing consequential decisions.

Older statements

People in this topic

Ron Wyden

Ron Wyden is a Democratic United States senator representing Oregon.

1 case and 1 statement

Tammy Baldwin

Democratic U.S. Senator from Wisconsin since 2013. She represented Wisconsin's 2nd congressional district in the U.S. House from 1999 to 2013.

3 cases and 3 statements

Bill Cassidy

United States Senator (Republican) from Louisiana.

2 cases and 2 statements

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is the U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services, confirmed by the Senate in February 2025. He previously worked as an environmental lawyer, chaired the nonprofit Children's Health Defense, and ran for president in 2024, first as a Democrat and then as an independent, before suspending his campaign and endorsing Donald Trump.

2 cases

Elizabeth Warren

Elizabeth Warren is a Democratic U.S. senator representing Massachusetts, serving in the Senate since 2013. Before entering the Senate, she was a law professor and helped establish the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

3 cases and 5 statements

Shaiel Ben-Ephraim

Shaiel Ben-Ephraim is a political commentator, writer and podcast host. He writes The Grand Scheme newsletter and produces videos on Israeli politics and international affairs.

1 case and 1 statement

Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus is an Ethiopian public health official who has been director-general of the World Health Organization since 2017 and was elected to a second term in 2022. He was Ethiopia's minister of health from 2005 to 2012 and its minister of foreign affairs from 2012 to 2016. He holds a doctorate in community health from the University of Nottingham.

1 case and 1 statement

Lateefah Simon

United States Representative and Democratic candidate for U.S. House in California's 12th district.

1 case and 2 statements

Stacy Mitchell

Stacy Mitchell is an American author and antimonopoly advocate. She is co-executive director of the Institute for Local Self-Reliance, a research and advocacy group she joined in 1997, and runs its office in Portland, Maine. She wrote the book Big-Box Swindle and co-wrote the 2016 report Amazon's Stranglehold.

1 case and 1 statement

Mark Cuban

Mark Cuban is an American businessman and investor. He is the former principal owner and a current minority owner of the NBA's Dallas Mavericks, was an investor on ABC's Shark Tank from 2012 to 2025, and co-founded the Mark Cuban Cost Plus Drug Company, an online pharmacy that sells generic drugs at a fixed markup over cost.

1 case and 1 statement

Rob Bonta

Rob Bonta is California’s attorney general.

1 case and 1 statement

Josh Turek

Josh Turek is an Iowa state representative, former professional wheelchair-basketball player and Democratic candidate for the U.S. Senate. He competed for the United States in four Paralympic Games and won two gold medals. He graduated from Southwest Minnesota State University in 2002 and later earned an MBA. His work has included youth adaptive-sports programs and mobility equipment.

1 case and 1 statement

More people