What did Trump mean when he said 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at a Nebraska rally?
Trump told a Nebraska rally "Let them take out Los Angeles. Let them take out San Diego." California officials say he called attacks on the cities a small price for the Iran war; the White House says he meant a nuclear Iran's threat.
BackgroundWhat is the War Powers Resolution?
Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Overview
At a campaign rally in Grand Island, Nebraska, on October 5, 2026, President Donald Trump called the costs of the Iran war "a small price to pay for keeping the world safe" and said, "They can take out a city. Let them take out Los Angeles. Let them take out San Diego." The passage followed remarks about the midterm elections and did not mention nuclear weapons; Trump had said earlier in the speech that Iran will not have one. California Gov. Gavin Newsom, the mayors of Los Angeles and San Diego and other critics said Trump was inviting attacks on the two cities or treating them as an acceptable price for the war. White House Communications Director Steven Cheung said Trump was stating that U.S. cities would have been threatened if a nuclear Iran had not been stopped. The dispute is over what Trump meant.
Background: What is the War Powers Resolution?
Read the full background
At his October 5, 2026 rally in Grand Island, Nebraska, President Donald Trump said, "Let them take out Los Angeles. Let them take out San Diego." California Gov. Gavin Newsom and the two cities' mayors read the remark as accepting or encouraging attacks on Americans. The White House said Trump meant that the war was preventing a nuclear Iran from threatening those cities. The dispute concerns the meaning of a passage that moved from the cost of war to the prospect of an attack, then back to prices. Full rally recording (opens in a new tab), Newsom's response (opens in a new tab), White House explanation (opens in a new tab).
The passage in the full speech
About 12 minutes into the speech, Trump returned to the war after urging supporters to vote in the midterm elections. He described a cost as artificially high and a small price for keeping the country and the world safe. He then said an unnamed "they" could take out a city, named Los Angeles and San Diego, repeated that the price was small and predicted that the war would end soon. The Los Angeles line contains several restarts. PolitiFact's transcription (opens in a new tab) preserves them; the full transcript (opens in a new tab) places the sequence in the section beginning at 11:37.
The immediate passage contains no reference to Iran or nuclear weapons. Earlier, around four to six minutes into the speech, Trump explicitly said Iran would not have a nuclear weapon and described preventing one as a reason for the war. He also predicted that oil prices would fall when the conflict ended. Several minutes of remarks about the media, his political future and the midterm elections separated that discussion from the city names. After the city remark, he again predicted an end to the war and turned to gasoline and Venezuelan oil. Full transcript, 04:28-06:26 and 11:37-13:23 (opens in a new tab).
This context supplies the war and price discussion behind the competing readings. The wording does not clearly identify every pronoun's referent or explain the transition to the cities. The officials' responses below attribute different meanings to that transition.
Newsom, the mayors and Desmond object
On October 5, Newsom wrote (opens in a new tab) that Trump was saying foreign enemies should attack the two cities and called him "deranged and dangerous." Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass (opens in a new tab) said he had suggested that a foreign government attack Los Angeles. She warned that the statement could compromise the city's safety and said a president's responsibility was to protect Americans.
San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria (opens in a new tab) replied that his city was not collateral damage or expendable. In an October 6 statement from his office (opens in a new tab), he pointed to San Diego's military families, shipbuilders and researchers, said Trump had dismissed residents' lives and asked him to retract the remarks and apologize. Gloria argued that a president's duty to protect American communities applies regardless of their politics or geography.
Jim Desmond (opens in a new tab), a Republican San Diego County supervisor running for Congress, also objected. He said he vehemently disagreed with Trump's comments and, as a Navy veteran, had served to protect Americans rather than treat cities as an acceptable cost of war. His post retained support for standing up to Iran and defending American interests. His objection was to the treatment of American cities in the remark.
The White House's explanation
On the morning of October 6, White House Communications Director Steven Cheung (opens in a new tab) rejected the critical interpretation. He said Trump meant that American cities would have been threatened if a nuclear Iran had not been stopped, and argued that the president had made the country safer.
About half an hour later, the White House's Rapid Response 47 account (opens in a new tab) disputed the Los Angeles Times headline describing Trump as suggesting that Iran attack the cities. It said the United States was fighting to stop Iran from gaining the ability to strike Los Angeles and San Diego with a nuclear weapon. These statements provide the administration's explanation of Trump's meaning; the rally wording and its surrounding context remain available for readers to compare with it.
People in this case
Donald TrumpDirectly involved
Gavin NewsomDirectly involved
Karen BassDirectly involved
Todd GloriaDirectly involved
Timeline
8 timeline entries on this page. Dates: October 5, 2026 to October 7, 2026
October 2026
Trump says 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at Nebraska rally
Incident
At a midterm campaign rally in Grand Island, Nebraska, President Trump called the war's costs "a small price to pay for keeping the world safe, keeping our country safe" and said, "They can take out a city. Let them take out Los Angeles. Let them take out San Diego." The passage followed remarks about the midterm elections and did not mention nuclear weapons. About six to seven minutes earlier, Trump had said Iran "will not have a nuclear weapon." The time is approximate, based on the remark's position in a live broadcast and on the earliest clips of it, posted at 23:44 and 23:45 UTC.
California officials and candidates condemn the remark
Reaction
Gov. Gavin Newsom wrote that Trump was "now saying our foreign enemies should 'take out' Los Angeles and San Diego" and called him "deranged and dangerous." Within the next two hours, Sen. Alex Padilla, Rep. Sara Jacobs, San Diego County Supervisor Jim Desmond (the Republican candidate in the 48th District), San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria, Sen. Adam Schiff, Xavier Becerra, Democratic House candidate Marni von Wilpert, Rep. Scott Peters and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass also criticized the remark on X.
Los Angeles Times reports Trump suggested letting Iran 'take out' the two cities
Source release
The Los Angeles Times published a story headlined "Trump suggests letting Iran 'take out' Los Angeles and San Diego at campaign rally," saying the comment was possibly in jest. The White House's Rapid Response 47 account later responded to the Times' post of the story.
FactCheck.org publishes a contextual reading of the Nebraska remarks
Source release
Paul Cuno-Booth argues that the fuller passage more plausibly compares higher fuel prices with the danger of a nuclear Iran. His analysis also notes that experts dispute Trump's account of Iran's nuclear and missile capabilities.
Cheung says Trump meant the threat from a nuclear Iran
Claim
White House Communications Director Steven Cheung wrote that the reaction to Trump's comments was "not rooted in reality" and that Trump "was clearly stating U.S. cities would have been threatened if a nuclear Iran hadn't been stopped."
White House Rapid Response account says the U.S. is fighting to stop a nuclear attack on the cities
Claim
Quoting the Los Angeles Times post, the White House's Rapid Response 47 account wrote "No, he didn't, you buffoons" and said Trump "was saying the U.S. is fighting to STOP Iran from having the ability to take out LA and San Diego with a nuclear weapon."
Democratic National Committee calls the remark 'disgusting and dangerous'
Reaction
The Democratic National Committee posted the remark and wrote, "Disgusting and dangerous. End the war and hold him accountable."
Trump says the U.S. protects its cities at a San Antonio rally
Reaction
At his San Antonio rally, Trump revisits the Los Angeles and San Diego comparison and says the United States would not let attacks on its cities happen. NBC reports the remarks the following morning.
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Steven CheungTrump was clearly stating that U.S. cities would have been threatened if a nuclear Iran had not been stopped, and the media reaction to his comments is not rooted in reality.
Sources (2)
- Steven Cheung's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Steven CheungOriginal post
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Rapid Response 47Rapid Response 47
Trump was saying the United States is fighting to stop Iran from having the ability to attack Los Angeles and San Diego with a nuclear weapon, which Iran would do if it had the chance.
Sources (2)
- Rapid Response 47's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Rapid Response 47Original post
- 'You buffoons': Trump team defends remarks about Iran 'taking out' LA, San Diego · The National News DeskFull article
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Gavin NewsomTrump was saying that foreign enemies of the United States should "take out" Los Angeles and San Diego.
Sources (2)
- Gavin Newsom's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Gavin NewsomOriginal post
- Trump suggests allowing Iran to "take out" LA and San Diego during campaign rally · CBS News Los AngelesFull article, updated October 6, 2026, 8:55 a.m. Pacific
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Adam SchiffTrump accepts attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego as a cost of the Iran war: "if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost."
Sources (2)
- Adam Schiff's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Adam SchiffOriginal post
- California officials condemn Trump for saying Iran could 'take out' Los Angeles or San Diego · NBC NewsFull article
In their own words
Their own account
Statements from the person or group whose act or claim this case is about. They are listed apart from the responses, and each label says what the speaker did with their own act or claim.
Donald TrumpPresident of the United States"All I was doing was making a comparison between paying a little more, for a short time, for Gasoline, versus the bombing of our Major Cities."
Challenged the characterizationCase context: What did Trump mean when he said 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at a Nebraska rally?
Full statement and sources
Trump says he was comparing a temporary gasoline-price increase with the consequences of a nuclear attack on American cities.
Before the statement
The post responds to interpretations of his October 5 Nebraska rally remarks.
After the statement
He says he loves Los Angeles and San Diego and accuses news outlets of misrepresenting him.
Trump explains his Los Angeles and San Diego comparisonTruth Social post 117406823254412991, 2:59 p.m. EDT; archived by Trump's TruthWhy this label?
Trump says "All I was doing was making a comparison between paying a little more, for a short time, for Gasoline, versus the bombing of our Major Cities." That rejects the interpretation that he was inviting an attack on American cities and offers a different account of what he meant.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Rapid Response 47Official White House rapid response account on X "He was saying the U.S. is fighting to STOP Iran from having the ability to take out LA and San Diego with a nuclear weapon"
Challenged the characterizationResponding to: Trump was saying the United States is fighting to stop Iran from having the ability to attack Los Angeles and San Diego with a nuclear weapon, which Iran would do if it had the chance.
Full statement and sources
The White House's Rapid Response 47 account, quoting a Los Angeles Times post headlined "Trump suggests letting Iran 'take out' Los Angeles and San Diego at campaign rally," wrote: "No, he didn't, you buffoons," and said Trump "was saying the U.S. is fighting to STOP Iran from having the ability to take out LA and San Diego with a nuclear weapon," which it said Iran would do if it had the chance.
Before the statement
The post quotes a Los Angeles Times post linking its story "Trump suggests letting Iran 'take out' Los Angeles and San Diego at campaign rally" and opens: "No, he didn't, you buffoons."
After the statement
The post ends by saying Iran would carry out such an attack "if they had the chance."
Rapid Response 47's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Rapid Response 47Original postTrump suggests letting Iran 'take out' Los Angeles and San Diego at campaign rally · Los Angeles TimesFull articleWhy this label?
The reference point is whether Trump's remark meant Iranian attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego would be an acceptable price for the war, as critics read it, rather than that the war prevents a nuclear Iran from being able to attack them, as the White House says. The account rejects the Los Angeles Times' description, "No, he didn't," and offers another reading: that Trump was saying the United States is fighting to stop Iran from being able to attack the two cities with a nuclear weapon. That disputes the interpretation of the remark. The closest competing label is Defended or excused, but the post does not argue that an attack on the cities would be acceptable; it says the remark meant something else. Evidence: the account's own post on X.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Steven CheungWhite House communications director"He was clearly stating U.S. cities would have been threatened if a nuclear Iran hadn't been stopped."
Challenged the characterizationResponding to: Trump was clearly stating that U.S. cities would have been threatened if a nuclear Iran had not been stopped, and the media reaction to his comments is not rooted in reality.
Full statement and sources
White House Communications Director Steven Cheung wrote on X that "The media freakout over President Trump's comments is not rooted in reality," that Trump "was clearly stating U.S. cities would have been threatened if a nuclear Iran hadn't been stopped," and that "America is safer because of the President."
Before the statement
Cheung posted the morning after the rally, quoting a video clip of the rally remark. The post opens: "The media freakout over President Trump's comments is not rooted in reality."
After the statement
It continues: "America is safer because of the President. Iran has no nuclear, no navy, no air force, and no money."
Steven Cheung's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Steven CheungOriginal postWhy this label?
Cheung, the White House communications director, calls the media reaction a freakout not rooted in reality and says Trump was "clearly stating U.S. cities would have been threatened if a nuclear Iran hadn't been stopped." He says the remark meant something else, not that an attack on the cities would be acceptable, so we labeled it Challenged the characterization.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
19 responses. First 6 shown initially. Newest first.
The Daily Record Editorial Advisory BoardIndependent volunteer editorial advisory board of legal professionals "His language, his disregard for the lives of millions, is very very distressing."
CondemnedCase context: What did Trump mean when he said 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at a Nebraska rally?
Full statement and sources
The Daily Record's independent Editorial Advisory Board criticizes Trump's language as showing disregard for millions of people and calls for his cabinet to remove him.
Before the statement
The opinion considers both Trump's nuclear-threat argument and the possibility that his words could be read as permission for an attack.
After the statement
The board identifies two members who did not participate in the opinion.
Presidential words carry more meaningEditorial Advisory Board opinion; paragraphs on presidential language and removalWhy this label?
The Daily Record's Editorial Advisory Board says Trump's "language, his disregard for the lives of millions, is very very distressing" and calls for his cabinet to remove him. It criticizes his language about the two cities directly, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Karen BassMayor of Los AngelesDirectly involved"To do that makes us look ridiculous on the world stage, but it also gives a green light to Iran, the nation that he chose to attack, the green light to attack our cities"
CondemnedCase context: What did Trump mean when he said 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at a Nebraska rally?
Full statement and sources
Bass criticizes Trump's language after his San Antonio rally and says it could encourage Iran to attack American cities. NBC reports she may seek a congressional investigation.
Before the statement
NBC interviews Bass after Trump says the United States protects its cities and would not allow such attacks.
After the statement
Her response calls for an apology to Los Angeles and San Diego.
Trump says the U.S. protects its cities after Los Angeles and San Diego remarksOctober 7 San Antonio rally and Karen Bass interview after the rallyWhy this label?
Relative to Trump's remarks about the two cities, Bass criticizes their danger and their effect on how Iran could interpret U.S. policy.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Nicole RussellUSA TODAY opinion columnist "But to suggest Trump was goading Iran into attacking LA or San Diego is asinine."
Challenged the characterizationCase context: What did Trump mean when he said 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at a Nebraska rally?
Full statement and sources
Russell calls Trump's wording clumsy and rambling but argues that the full passage concerned gasoline prices and preventing a nuclear threat.
Before the statement
The column quotes the Nebraska passage and compares it with earlier remarks about fuel prices and Iran.
After the statement
Russell criticizes Democrats and news coverage for what she sees as omitting that context.
The media is losing it over Trump's 'take out' LA remark | OpinionOpinion column, sections on the full rally passage and media coverageWhy this label?
Russell, a USA TODAY opinion columnist, grants that Trump's wording was clumsy but writes that "to suggest Trump was goading Iran into attacking LA or San Diego is asinine." In her reading the remark was about gas prices and stopping a nuclear Iran, which rejects the critics' interpretation.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
John SextonHotAir commentator "Admittedly, this is not a picture of rhetorical clarity, but Trump has been sending this message about higher gas prices being a small price to pay for defeating Iran for weeks now, and this is obviously just a variation on that theme. His point is the same one he's been saying for 20 years: Iran must not be allowed to have a nuclear weapon. His reference to them taking out LA or San Diego is meant to recall that threat."
Challenged the characterizationCase context: What did Trump mean when he said 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at a Nebraska rally?
Full statement and sources
John Sexton argues that Trump was invoking the threat of a nuclear Iran and describing higher gas prices as a cost of preventing it. He criticizes reporting that treated the remarks as an invitation to attack American cities.
Before the statement
In a HotAir post the day after the rally, titled "Dumb Media Freakout of the Day", Sexton opens by describing the coverage as the latest "bad faith misreading of something President Trump said". He then reproduces the rally passage, from "I want to see a tremendous victory" through "it's going to end very soon".
After the statement
He goes on to say many media outlets chose to frame the remark "as an invitation, as if Trump is asking Iran (the country we're currently fighting) to blow up a major American city". He then collects posts from news outlets and Democrats, including Pelosi and Newsom, and says Democrats are misrepresenting the remark for partisan advantage in the midterms.
John Sexton on reporting of Trump's Los Angeles remarkParagraph beginning "Admittedly, this is not a picture of rhetorical clarity"Why this label?
Sexton concedes the passage "is not a picture of rhetorical clarity" but says Trump has been sending the message for weeks that higher gas prices are a small price to pay for defeating Iran, and that his reference to them taking out LA or San Diego "is meant to recall that threat" of a nuclear Iran. That rejects the critics' reading in favor of a nuclear-threat explanation, rather than arguing that attacks on the cities would be acceptable.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Nancy PelosiU.S. representative for California's 11th District and former House speaker"The words of an American President weigh a ton. He must not be frivolous with the weight of his office. Donald Trump has gone beyond the pale saying Iran can “take out” Los Angeles and San Diego. How could he say the slaughter of Americans is a "small price to pay"? The American people expect much more of a U.S. President."
CondemnedCase context: What did Trump mean when he said 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at a Nebraska rally?
Full statement and sources
Nancy Pelosi says Trump has gone beyond acceptable presidential language and objects to describing the slaughter of Americans as a small price to pay.
Before the statement
Pelosi posted on X on October 6, 2026, the day after Trump's rally in Grand Island, Nebraska, where he said an unnamed "they" could take out a city and named Los Angeles and San Diego.
After the statement
The post ends there.
Nancy Pelosi's response to Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remarkOriginal post 2107543698284146911, complete textWhy this label?
Pelosi says "The words of an American President weigh a ton" and that Trump "has gone beyond the pale" in saying Iran can take out Los Angeles and San Diego, then asks how he could call the slaughter of Americans a small price to pay. She reads the remark as accepting attacks on the cities and objects to it, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Ramin EkhtiarCalifornia political commentator, host of the Ramin RealTalk YouTube channel "HE DID NOT SAY BOMB LOS ANGELES. Gavin cut the clip in half and told 10 million people the President just offered their city to Iran. Play it. He said the price is small next to a nuclear Iran actually taking out LA and San Diego. They deleted the first half so they could call him deranged before breakfast."
Challenged the characterizationResponding to: Trump was clearly stating that U.S. cities would have been threatened if a nuclear Iran had not been stopped, and the media reaction to his comments is not rooted in reality.
Full statement and sources
Commentator Ramin Ekhtiar said Trump did not tell Iran to bomb Los Angeles and that Newsom cut the clip, arguing Trump meant the war's costs were small next to a nuclear Iran attacking Los Angeles and San Diego.
Before the statement
Ekhtiar posted on X the afternoon after the rally, with a 33-second video of the rally passage. The post responds to Gov. Gavin Newsom, whose post the night before quoted a 35-second clip of the same passage posted by the commentator Acyn.
After the statement
The post goes on to cite San Jose gas prices and ends: "Turn the sound on." The video attached to the post begins at "The war is just artificial" and runs through "it'll end one way or the other"; it contains no reference to nuclear weapons.
Ramin Ekhtiar's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Ramin EkhtiarOriginal post and attached 33-second videoWhy this label?
The reference point is whether Trump's remark meant Iranian attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego would be an acceptable price for the war, as critics read it. Ekhtiar rejects that reading and says Trump meant the costs were small compared with a nuclear Iran attacking the cities. That disputes the interpretation of the remark, matching the White House's account. The closest competing label is Defended or excused, but the post does not argue an attack would be acceptable; it says the remark meant something else.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Show fewer responses
Democratic National CommitteeDemocratic National Committee, official X accountDirectly involved"Disgusting and dangerous. End the war and hold him accountable."
CondemnedCase context: What did Trump mean when he said 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at a Nebraska rally?
Full statement and sources
The Democratic National Committee wrote on X, "Trump's new message on his Iran war: 'Let them take out Los Angeles. Let them take out San Diego.' Disgusting and dangerous. End the war and hold him accountable."
Before the statement
The post, quoting a video clip of the rally remark, opens: "Trump's new message on his Iran war: 'Let them take out Los Angeles. Let them take out San Diego.'"
After the statement
This is the end of the post.
Democratic National Committee's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Democratic National CommitteeOriginal postWhy this label?
The Democratic National Committee posts the remark as Trump's new message on the Iran war and calls it "Disgusting and dangerous," adding "End the war and hold him accountable." It condemns the remark itself without spelling out a reading of it.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Todd GloriaMayor of San Diego, in a statement issued by his officeDirectly involved"No American city, regardless of its politics or geography, should ever be described as expendable or an acceptable price to pay."
CondemnedResponding to: Trump accepts attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego as a cost of the Iran war: "if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost."
Full statement and sources
In a statement issued by his office on October 6, 2026, San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria said Trump "so casually dismissed" the lives of San Diego's nearly 1.4 million residents, that no American city "should ever be described as expendable or an acceptable price to pay," and that Trump should retract the remarks and apologize to the people of San Diego.
Before the statement
The statement was issued the morning after the rally, and its introduction says it followed Trump's suggestion "that a foreign adversary could 'take out' San Diego" and his calling it a "small price to pay." Gloria opened by describing San Diego as "an anchor of our nation's security in the Pacific" and home to servicemembers, shipbuilders and researchers.
After the statement
Gloria continued, "San Diegans deserve a President who values their lives, honors the service and sacrifice of our military families, and takes seriously his responsibility as Commander in Chief. President Trump should retract these remarks and apologize to the people of San Diego." He closed, "A President does not get to decide which American communities are worth protecting. His duty is to all of us."
Mayor Gloria statement on President Trump's remarks about San DiegoThird paragraph of the statement.Why this label?
The reference point is whether Trump's remark meant Iranian attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego would be an acceptable price for the war, as critics read it, rather than that the war prevents a nuclear Iran from being able to attack them, as the White House says. Gloria's statement treats the remark as describing San Diego as expendable and asks for a retraction and an apology, which adopts the critics' reading and criticizes the remark. The closest competing label is Challenged the characterization, but he objects to what he takes Trump to have said rather than disputing how others described it. This is a separate occasion from his October 5 post on X. Evidence: the statement as published by the Mayor's office.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Bernie SandersU.S. senator from Vermont"the annihilation of two major American cities — more than 5 million people — is not a “small price to pay” for Trump's illegal war."
CondemnedCase context: What did Trump mean when he said 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at a Nebraska rally?
Full statement and sources
Sanders condemns what he reads as Trump treating the destruction of Los Angeles and San Diego as an acceptable cost of the Iran war.
Before the statement
The post follows Trump's Nebraska rally passage about the war and its costs.
After the statement
Sanders also refers to military deaths and Iranian deaths and calls Trump unhinged.
Sanders criticizes Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remarksX post 2107512014436258297, 16:43:14 UTCWhy this label?
Sanders says "the annihilation of two major American cities" is not a small price to pay for "Trump's illegal war." He rejects the cost comparison he attributes to the president, which he reads as writing off two cities for the sake of the war.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Karen BassMayor of Los AngelesDirectly involved"The President of the United States suggested that a foreign government attack Los Angeles. His statements against our city are dangerous and could potentially compromise our safety."
CondemnedResponding to: Trump was saying that foreign enemies of the United States should "take out" Los Angeles and San Diego.
Full statement and sources
Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass wrote on X that the president "suggested that a foreign government attack Los Angeles," that his statements were dangerous and could compromise the city's safety, and that "The role of a president is to protect the country, not to actively threaten it and encourage attacks on American lives."
Before the statement
Bass posted later that evening, quoting a video clip of the rally remark.
After the statement
She added, "In the face of irresponsible threats, as Angelenos, we know how to stand together and protect our city."
Karen Bass's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Karen BassOriginal postWhy this label?
The reference point is whether Trump's remark meant Iranian attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego would be an acceptable price for the war, as critics read it, rather than that the war prevents a nuclear Iran from being able to attack them, as the White House says. Bass says Trump suggested that a foreign government attack the city and that he encouraged attacks on Americans, which asserts and condemns the critics' reading. The closest competing label is Challenged the characterization, but she states her own reading of the remark and criticizes it rather than only disputing a description. Evidence: Bass's own post on X.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Scott PetersU.S. representative from California's 50th DistrictDirectly involved"America knows San Diego is not a “small price to pay” for his inability to resolve it."
CondemnedResponding to: Trump accepts attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego as a cost of the Iran war: "if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost."
Full statement and sources
Rep. Scott Peters wrote on X that San Diego is a military town awaiting the return of sailors and Marines from the USS Lincoln, and that "America knows San Diego is not a 'small price to pay' for his inability to resolve" the war.
Before the statement
Peters's post, quoting a video clip of the rally remark, opens: "San Diego is a proud military town, home to 115,000 courageous active duty servicemembers and their families. Military service is at the root of our community and culture. This month we await the return home of the sailors and marines still stranded on the USS Lincoln for months thanks to Donald Trump's reckless war in Iran."
After the statement
This sentence ends the post.
Scott Peters's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Scott PetersOriginal postWhy this label?
The reference point is whether Trump's remark meant Iranian attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego would be an acceptable price for the war, as critics read it, rather than that the war prevents a nuclear Iran from being able to attack them, as the White House says. Peters rejects the idea that San Diego could be a "small price to pay" for the war, which treats the remark as accepting harm to the city and criticizes Trump. The closest competing label is Challenged the characterization, but Peters objects to what he takes Trump to have said rather than disputing how others described it. Evidence: Peters's own post on X.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Marni von WilpertDemocratic candidate for U.S. House in California's 48th DistrictDirectly involved"Donald Trump says Los Angeles and San Diego being attacked would be ‘a small price to pay’ for his reckless Iran war. That is appalling and terrifying."
CondemnedResponding to: Trump accepts attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego as a cost of the Iran war: "if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost."
Full statement and sources
Marni von Wilpert, the Democratic candidate in California's 48th Congressional District, wrote on X that Trump says an attack on Los Angeles and San Diego "would be 'a small price to pay'" for the war, called that "appalling and terrifying" and called the remark "an impeachable offense." She also criticized her Republican opponent, Jim Desmond, for supporting the war.
Before the statement
Von Wilpert posted later that evening. FOX 5 San Diego reported that she also issued the statement in a news release.
After the statement
She goes on to call the remark "an impeachable offense by the Commander in Chief" and says it is indefensible that Desmond "continues to support Trump's war."
Marni von Wilpert's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Marni von WilpertOriginal postSan Diego officials condemn Trump's rhetoric on U.S.-Iran war costs · FOX 5 San DiegoFull article, updated October 5, 2026, 11:01 p.m. PacificWhy this label?
The reference point is whether Trump's remark meant Iranian attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego would be an acceptable price for the war, as critics read it, rather than that the war prevents a nuclear Iran from being able to attack them, as the White House says. Von Wilpert states the critics' reading directly, that Trump called an attack on the two cities a small price to pay, and condemns it. The closest competing label is Challenged the characterization, but she adopts and criticizes that reading rather than disputing a description. Evidence: von Wilpert's own campaign post on X.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Xavier BecerraDemocratic candidate for governor of CaliforniaDirectly involved"Their lives are not a “small price to pay” or a punchline for Donald Trump."
CondemnedResponding to: Trump accepts attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego as a cost of the Iran war: "if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost."
Full statement and sources
Xavier Becerra, a Democratic candidate for governor of California, wrote on X that 13 million Californians live in Los Angeles and San Diego counties and that "Their lives are not a 'small price to pay' or a punchline for Donald Trump."
Before the statement
Becerra's post, quoting a video clip of the rally remark, opens: "Thirteen million Californians call LA and San Diego counties home."
After the statement
This sentence ends the post.
Xavier Becerra's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Xavier BecerraOriginal postWhy this label?
The reference point is whether Trump's remark meant Iranian attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego would be an acceptable price for the war, as critics read it, rather than that the war prevents a nuclear Iran from being able to attack them, as the White House says. Becerra rejects the idea that the residents of the two counties are a "small price to pay," which treats the remark as accepting harm to them, and he criticizes Trump for it. The closest competing label is Challenged the characterization. His line that Californians' lives are not "a punchline for Donald Trump" accuses Trump of joking about them, which is a criticism of the remark rather than a dispute over how others described it. Evidence: Becerra's own post on X.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Adam SchiffU.S. senator from CaliforniaDirectly involved"And if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost."
CondemnedResponding to: Trump accepts attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego as a cost of the Iran war: "if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost."
Full statement and sources
Sen. Adam Schiff wrote on X that Trump says the Iran war will end "very soon," asked how many times that promise has been made, and said, "if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost."
Before the statement
Schiff's post, quoting a video clip of the rally remark, opens: "The President says the Iran war will end 'very soon.' How many times have we heard that promise?"
After the statement
This sentence ends the post.
Adam Schiff's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Adam SchiffOriginal postWhy this label?
Schiff writes that "if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost." The sentence opens with "if," but that restates what Schiff takes Trump to have said; his conclusion about Trump is not conditional. He reads the remark as Trump accepting attacks on two cities as a cost of the war and criticizes him for it.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Todd GloriaMayor of San DiegoDirectly involved"San Diego is not collateral damage."
CondemnedResponding to: Trump accepts attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego as a cost of the Iran war: "if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost."
Full statement and sources
San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria wrote on X, "San Diego is not collateral damage. We are not expendable. And we are never a 'small price to pay.' Keep our city out of your reckless war talk."
Before the statement
Gloria posted later that evening, quoting a video clip of the rally remark.
After the statement
The post continues: "We are not expendable. And we are never a 'small price to pay.' Keep our city out of your reckless war talk."
Todd Gloria's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Todd GloriaOriginal postWhy this label?
The reference point is whether Trump's remark meant Iranian attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego would be an acceptable price for the war, as critics read it, rather than that the war prevents a nuclear Iran from being able to attack them, as the White House says. Gloria answers the remark by rejecting the idea that his city could be a "small price to pay" or collateral damage of the war, which treats the remark as accepting harm to San Diego and criticizes it. The closest competing label is Challenged the characterization, but his post objects to what he takes Trump to have said rather than disputing how others described it. Evidence: Gloria's own post on X.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Jim DesmondSan Diego County supervisor and Republican candidate for U.S. House in California's 48th DistrictDirectly involved"As a Navy veteran, I served to protect Americans, not write off American cities as an acceptable price of war."
CondemnedResponding to: Trump accepts attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego as a cost of the Iran war: "if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost."
Full statement and sources
Jim Desmond, a Republican San Diego County supervisor running in California's 48th Congressional District, wrote on X that he "vehemently" disagreed with Trump's comments, that the commander in chief's first responsibility is to protect Americans, and that as a Navy veteran he "served to protect Americans, not write off American cities as an acceptable price of war."
Before the statement
The post opens: "I vehemently disagree with President Trump's comments. America must stand up to Iran and defend our interests, but the first responsibility of our Commander in Chief is to protect the American people and our homeland."
After the statement
It continues: "No American city is expendable, and no American family should ever be treated as collateral damage."
Jim Desmond's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Jim DesmondOriginal postWhy this label?
The reference point is whether Trump's remark meant Iranian attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego would be an acceptable price for the war, as critics read it, rather than that the war prevents a nuclear Iran from being able to attack them, as the White House says. Desmond reads the remark as writing off American cities as an acceptable price of war and says he vehemently disagrees, which asserts and condemns the critics' reading. The closest competing label is Mixed or conditional, because he also says America must stand up to Iran; but that is support for the war's aims, not a defense of the remark. Evidence: Desmond's own campaign post on X.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sara JacobsU.S. representative from California's 51st DistrictDirectly involved"not acceptable collateral damage in Trump’s stupid war."
CondemnedResponding to: Trump accepts attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego as a cost of the Iran war: "if it means attacks on two major American cities in the process, he is not troubled by the cost."
Full statement and sources
Rep. Sara Jacobs, whose district is in San Diego, wrote on X that her constituents, including many active-duty service members, veterans and their families, "are not acceptable collateral damage in Trump's stupid war."
Before the statement
Jacobs's post quotes a video clip of the rally remark. It opens with "My constituents" and the phrase "including many active duty service members, veterans, and their families," followed by "are" and the words quoted here.
After the statement
This sentence ends the post.
Sara Jacobs's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Sara JacobsOriginal postWhy this label?
Jacobs, whose district is in San Diego, writes that her constituents are "not acceptable collateral damage in Trump's stupid war." She rejects the idea that they could be acceptable losses, which treats the remark as accepting harm to San Diego, and objects to what she takes Trump to have said rather than to how others described it.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Alex PadillaU.S. senator from CaliforniaDirectly involved"Now Trump is in Nebraska inviting an attack on U.S. soil, putting millions of Americans and hundreds of thousands of our servicemembers at risk while trying to get Americans to cheer for an attack on our own country."
CondemnedResponding to: Trump was saying that foreign enemies of the United States should "take out" Los Angeles and San Diego.
Full statement and sources
Sen. Alex Padilla wrote on X that at least 19 service members, including Noah Tietjens of Nebraska, have died in the war, and that Trump was in Nebraska "inviting an attack on U.S. soil" while trying to get Americans to cheer for it. "What kind of Commander in Chief does that?" he asked.
Before the statement
Padilla's post, quoting a video clip of the rally remark, begins by saying at least 19 service members have died in the war, including Noah Tietjens of Nebraska.
After the statement
It ends: "What kind of Commander in Chief does that?"
Alex Padilla's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Alex PadillaOriginal postWhy this label?
The reference point is whether Trump's remark meant Iranian attacks on Los Angeles and San Diego would be an acceptable price for the war, as critics read it, rather than that the war prevents a nuclear Iran from being able to attack them, as the White House says. Padilla reads the remark as inviting an attack on the United States and criticizes Trump for it, which asserts and condemns the critics' reading. The closest competing label is Challenged the characterization, but Padilla states his own reading and condemns the conduct. Evidence: Padilla's own post on X.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Gavin NewsomGovernor of CaliforniaDirectly involved"After sending the National Guard and Marines to occupy California, Donald Trump is now saying our foreign enemies should “take out” Los Angeles and San Diego."
CondemnedResponding to: Trump was saying that foreign enemies of the United States should "take out" Los Angeles and San Diego.
Full statement and sources
California Gov. Gavin Newsom wrote on X that after sending the National Guard and Marines to California, Trump "is now saying our foreign enemies should 'take out' Los Angeles and San Diego," and added, "He is deranged and dangerous."
Before the statement
Newsom posted about two hours after the remark, quoting a 34-second clip of it posted by the commentator Acyn.
After the statement
His post ends: "He is deranged and dangerous." Newsom's official governor's account later called the remark "Disgusting and disqualifying."
Gavin Newsom's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark · Gavin NewsomOriginal postWhy this label?
Newsom writes that, after sending the National Guard and Marines to occupy California, Donald Trump "is now saying our foreign enemies should" take out Los Angeles and San Diego, and he calls Trump dangerous. He goes beyond disputing a description: he states what he says Trump meant and criticizes it.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(30)
Original video
FULL SPEECH: President Trump Holds Massive Rally in Grand Island, NE - 10/05/26
About this source
Right Side Broadcasting Network's unedited video of President Trump's full speech at the Pinnacle Bank Expo Center in Grand Island, Nebraska, on October 5, 2026, posted to YouTube after the live broadcast. The Los Angeles and San Diego remark comes about 12 minutes into the speech, after a passage on the midterm elections. Trump's earlier statements that Iran will not have a nuclear weapon come about six to seven minutes before it.
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
Presidential words carry more meaning
Relevant passage: Editorial Advisory Board opinion; paragraphs on presidential language and removal
About this source
The independent advisory board criticizes the remarks and calls on Trump's cabinet to remove him. Arthur F. Fergenson and Debra G. Schubert did not participate.
- Author
- The Daily Record Editorial Advisory Board
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
The Context for Trump's 'Take Out' Los Angeles, San Diego Remarks
Relevant passage: Opening interpretation; October 8 update
About this source
Paul Cuno-Booth compares the Nebraska passage with earlier remarks and later explanations. The article was corrected October 7 and updated October 8.
- Author
- Paul Cuno-Booth
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
The media is losing it over Trump's 'take out' LA remark | Opinion
Relevant passage: Opinion column, sections on the full rally passage and media coverage
About this source
Russell argues that Trump was comparing fuel costs with the danger of a nuclear Iran.
- Author
- Nicole Russell
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Sanders criticizes Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remarks
About this source
Sanders rejects describing the destruction of American cities as a small price for the Iran war.
- Author
- Bernie Sanders
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Trump explains his Los Angeles and San Diego comparison
Relevant passage: Truth Social post 117406823254412991, 2:59 p.m. EDT; archived by Trump's Truth
About this source
Trump says his comparison concerned higher gasoline prices and the prospect of a nuclear attack.
- Author
- Donald Trump
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Trump says the U.S. protects its cities after Los Angeles and San Diego remarks
Relevant passage: October 7 San Antonio rally and Karen Bass interview after the rally
About this source
NBC News reports the follow-up rally remarks and interviews Mayor Karen Bass after the event.
- Author
- Natasha Korecki and Kyla Guilfoil
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Nancy Pelosi's response to Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
Pelosi's original post criticizes the president's language and his treatment of American cities.
- Author
- Nancy Pelosi
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
John Sexton on reporting of Trump's Los Angeles remark
Relevant passage: Paragraph beginning "Admittedly, this is not a picture of rhetorical clarity"
About this source
Sexton's original commentary argues that Trump's remarks referred to the threat of a nuclear Iran and the costs of the war. The article reproduces the surrounding rally remarks.
- Author
- John Sexton
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Mayor Gloria statement on President Trump's remarks about San Diego
Relevant passage: Third paragraph of the statement.
Excerpt
"No American city, regardless of its politics or geography, should ever be described as expendable or an acceptable price to pay. … President Trump should retract these remarks and apologize to the people of San Diego."
About this source
Statement issued by San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria's office on October 6, 2026, responding to Trump's October 5 rally remark. The office also distributed it by email to media, including Dispute Index.
- Author
- Office of Mayor Todd Gloria
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
San Diego officials condemn Trump's rhetoric on U.S.-Iran war costs
Relevant passage: Full article, updated October 5, 2026, 11:01 p.m. Pacific
About this source
FOX 5 San Diego report on reactions from San Diego officials. It reports that Marni von Wilpert issued her statement in a news release and identifies Jim Desmond as a San Diego County supervisor.
- Author
- Chris Ponce
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
'You buffoons': Trump team defends remarks about Iran 'taking out' LA, San Diego
Relevant passage: Full article
About this source
Report by The National News Desk, carried by Fox 17 and other Sinclair stations, on the Rapid Response 47 post. It notes that Trump did not mention nuclear weapons in the rally remarks.
- Author
- Alexx Altman-DeVilbiss, The National News Desk
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Trump suggests letting Iran 'take out' Los Angeles and San Diego at campaign rally
Relevant passage: Full article
About this source
Los Angeles Times report on the remark, which says it was possibly in jest. The White House's Rapid Response 47 account replied to the Times post that linked this story.
- Author
- Iris Kwok, Richard Winton and Ana Ceballos
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
California officials condemn Trump for saying Iran could 'take out' Los Angeles or San Diego
Relevant passage: Full article
About this source
NBC News report quoting the remark, Cheung's response and reactions from Newsom, Bass, Gloria, Sen. Alex Padilla and Sen. Adam Schiff.
- Author
- Megan Brand
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Trump suggests allowing Iran to "take out" LA and San Diego during campaign rally
Relevant passage: Full article, updated October 6, 2026, 8:55 a.m. Pacific
About this source
CBS News Los Angeles report on the remark and reactions. Its lede describes the remark as being about Iran developing a nuclear weapon, its transcription includes both restarts before "Los Angeles," and it says it was not immediately clear what Trump meant.
- Author
- Tom Wait
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Trump draws backlash after he suggests Iran could 'take out' Los Angeles or San Diego
Relevant passage: Full article
About this source
CNN report on the remark, Steven Cheung's response and reactions from California officials. CNN says Trump appeared to contrast high gas prices with a far higher price, an attack on a U.S. city.
- Author
- Lauren Chadwick
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Democratic National Committee's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
Post by the Democratic National Committee's X account, quoting a clip of the rally remark.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Rapid Response 47's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
Post by the White House's Rapid Response 47 account on X, quoting a Los Angeles Times post that linked its story headlined "Trump suggests letting Iran 'take out' Los Angeles and San Diego at campaign rally."
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Steven Cheung's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
White House Communications Director Steven Cheung's post on X, quoting a clip of the rally remark.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Marni von Wilpert's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
Post on the X account of Marni von Wilpert's congressional campaign. Von Wilpert is the Democratic candidate in California's 48th District.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Jim Desmond's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
Post on the X account of Jim Desmond's congressional campaign. Desmond, a San Diego County supervisor, is the Republican candidate in California's 48th District.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Xavier Becerra's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
Xavier Becerra's post on his X account, quoting a clip of the rally remark. Becerra is a Democratic candidate for governor of California.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Scott Peters's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
Rep. Scott Peters's post on his congressional X account, quoting a clip of the rally remark.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Sara Jacobs's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
Rep. Sara Jacobs's post on her congressional X account, quoting a clip of the rally remark.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Adam Schiff's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
Sen. Adam Schiff's post on his Senate X account, quoting a clip of the rally remark.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Alex Padilla's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
Sen. Alex Padilla's post on his Senate X account, quoting a clip of the rally remark.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Todd Gloria's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
San Diego Mayor Todd Gloria's post on his official X account, quoting a clip of the rally remark.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Karen Bass's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass's post on her official X account, quoting a clip of the rally remark.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Gavin Newsom's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
About this source
California Gov. Gavin Newsom's post on his personal X account, quoting a clip of the rally remark posted by the commentator Acyn.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Ramin Ekhtiar's post on Trump's Los Angeles and San Diego remark
Excerpt
"HE DID NOT SAY BOMB LOS ANGELES."
About this source
Ramin Ekhtiar's post on his X account, with a 33-second video of Trump's October 5 rally remark.
- Published
- Accessed
Corrections
(2)
Corrections address errors in our reporting or labels. When a speaker changes their position, we add a separate statement and link it to the earlier one.
Classification correction
Correction to: Statement by Rapid Response 47
- Previous classification
- Position Event #4890 classified the Rapid Response 47 post as "Defended or excused."
- Corrected classification
- The statement disputes the critics' reading of the remark and offers a different one, so the classification is "Challenged the characterization."
In this case Defended or excused would mean arguing that an Iranian attack on Los Angeles or San Diego would be acceptable. The statement does not argue that; it rejects the critics' interpretation and gives the White House's. The rationale was revised to match.
This corrects an editorial classification.
Post by the White House's Rapid Response 47 account on X, quoting a Los Angeles Times post that linked its story headlined "Trump suggests letting Iran 'take out' Los Angeles and San Diego at campaign rally."
Los Angeles Times report on the remark, which says it was possibly in jest. The White House's Rapid Response 47 account replied to the Times post that linked this story.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Classification correction
Correction to: Statement by Steven Cheung
- Previous classification
- Position Event #4889 classified Steven Cheung's statement as "Defended or excused."
- Corrected classification
- The statement disputes the critics' reading of the remark and offers a different one, so the classification is "Challenged the characterization."
In this case Defended or excused would mean arguing that an Iranian attack on Los Angeles or San Diego would be acceptable. The statement does not argue that; it rejects the critics' interpretation and gives the White House's. The rationale was revised to match.
This corrects an editorial classification.
White House Communications Director Steven Cheung's post on X, quoting a clip of the rally remark.
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- What did Trump mean when he said 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at a Nebraska rally?
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/what-did-trump-mean-let-them-take-out-los-angeles
The Dispute Index. "What did Trump mean when he said 'Let them take out Los Angeles' at a Nebraska rally?". First published: 2026-10-06. Last updated: 2026-10-07. https://disputeindex.com/cases/what-did-trump-mean-let-them-take-out-los-angeles