Was Steve Hilton's "Just Try It" campaign ad appropriate?

Republican Steve Hilton's Just Try It ad shows two young women, one guiding the other's hand to mark a ballot for him. Sonja Shaw and Michael Gates, who have campaigned with him, condemned it, while Hilton calls it satire.

Case period:

Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated

Overview

On October 1, 2026, Republican candidate for governor Steve Hilton posted a 53-second ad titled Just Try It, California. Two young women sit in a dimly lit bedroom, one coaxes the other to try something new, and the scene ends with a mail-in ballot marked for Hilton over Democrat Xavier Becerra. Sonja Shaw and Michael Gates, who have campaigned alongside Hilton, and the pastor Jack Hibbs criticized the ad, Democrats including Rep. Robert Garcia denounced it, and Hilton and Spencer Pratt defended it. Hilton said the campaign was trying to make a point in a provocative, satirical way and that it grieves him that some viewers were upset. The dispute is over whether the ad was an appropriate way to campaign.

Read the full background

Steve Hilton's October 1, 2026 campaign ad, Just Try It, California (opens in a new tab), begins with two young women in a dimly lit bedroom. One urges the other to try something new, then guides her hand to mark a mail-in ballot for Hilton, the Republican candidate for California governor, over Democrat Xavier Becerra.

The ad drew objections from Sonja Shaw and Michael Gates, two candidates who have campaigned alongside Hilton, and from pastor Jack Hibbs. Democrats criticized it too. Hilton defended the approach as satire, while saying it grieves him that viewers were upset. Spencer Pratt dismissed the criticism as a "fake moral panic." The dispute is over the ad's sexual suggestion and whether it was an appropriate way to reach voters.

The ad and Hilton's response

In the 53-second video (opens in a new tab), a Pride flag hangs behind the women. One asks, "Like, what if my dad finds out?" The other asks for her hand, tells her to close her eyes and says she will do the work. The reveal is a vote for Hilton. The final spoken line is "Now lick it," referring to the ballot envelope, the Los Angeles Times reports (opens in a new tab).

Hilton addressed the criticism in a video posted on October 3, Pacific time (opens in a new tab). He said the reaction had been overwhelmingly positive, acknowledged that many viewers were offended, and said the campaign was making its point "in a provocative way, in a satirical way." He denied intending to offend anyone, expressed regret about how viewers felt and asked for "grace" and understanding.

In an interview with the Times, Hilton described the ad as provocative and humorous. CalMatters reported on October 6 (opens in a new tab) that he stood by his tactics and regarded the backlash as a disagreement over strategy. He told the outlet he still had fellow Republicans' support and had just finished an event with Shaw. That is Hilton's account; CalMatters said Shaw did not return its call.

Objections from fellow Republicans

Shaw, a candidate for state superintendent of public instruction, replied to Hilton's original X post (opens in a new tab) on October 1, Pacific time. She faulted Hilton, the California Republican Party and chairwoman Corrin Rankin for promoting what she called "creepy, weird, disturbing garbage." Writing as a mother concerned about children's innocence, she said the ad crossed a line.

Gates, the Republican candidate for attorney general, said on October 2 (opens in a new tab) that he did not condone the video and that his campaign was not consulted. His attached press release objected to the sexualized portrayal of young women and to the suggestion of hiding something from a parent. The Times describes Gates as part of Hilton's "Golden Ticket" and reports that Shaw has occasionally campaigned alongside him.

Hibbs, pastor of Calvary Chapel Chino Hills, called the ad grotesque and insensitive (opens in a new tab), saying he was furious about the decision to make it. He nevertheless said he would still vote for Hilton because of his policies. His continued support for the candidate does not erase his criticism of the ad. CalMatters reports that Hibbs also criticized its portrayal of lesbianism among college and high school girls.

Other reactions and questions about its reach

Pratt, who ran for Los Angeles mayor in 2026, defended the ad in an X post (opens in a new tab). He argued that Republicans must speak to progressive Californians to win and treated the objections as a "fake moral panic."

The Times report (opens in a new tab) quotes former state Republican Party chair Jessica Millan Patterson as understanding the effort to reach people who would not normally consider voting Republican, though the ad did not speak to her. Republican Fred Karger called it clever but hypocritical and doubted that its intended audience would vote for Hilton. Republican ad maker Fred Davis told CalMatters that it succeeded in attracting attention but predicted it would not improve Hilton's support.

Rep. Robert Garcia told the Times that the ad was bizarre and desperate, criticizing Hilton's record on LGBTQ+ issues and support for Donald Trump. Jonathan Underland, speaking for Becerra's campaign, called it creepy and attacked Hilton's character. The statement is Underland's response on behalf of the campaign, not a personal quotation from Becerra.

CalMatters reports that filmmaker Gabriel Mann made the ad series for $125,000. Hilton told the outlet that it used real actors and was not generated with artificial intelligence. A second ad, Expand Your Mind (opens in a new tab), appeared on October 2; Hilton said more were coming. The reported cost covers the series, and the reactions reviewed here do not establish its effect on votes.

People in this case

Timeline

4 timeline entries on this page. Dates: October 1, 2026 to October 8, 2026

  1. October 2026

    1. Hilton posts the Just Try It, California ad

      Source release

      Steve Hilton posted a 53-second ad titled Just Try It, California to X at 2:21 p.m. Pacific on October 1, 2026, and the campaign uploaded it to YouTube about 33 minutes later. Two young women sit in a dimly lit bedroom, one coaxes the other to try something she has never done and guides her hand to mark a mail-in ballot for Hilton, and the ad ends with the line "Now lick it," which the Los Angeles Times reports refers to the ballot envelope.

    2. Hilton's campaign posts a second ad, Expand Your Mind

      Source release

      The Hilton campaign uploaded a second 53-second ad in the Just Try It series to YouTube on October 2, 2026. In it a woman guides a man at an outdoor retreat to let go of his fears and mark a ballot for Hilton. CalMatters reports that filmmaker Gabriel Mann made the ads for $125,000, that Hilton said they use real actors and are not AI-generated, and that more ads are coming.

    3. Hilton stands by his ad in a CalMatters interview

      Reaction

      Steve Hilton defended his campaign's ad in a Monday phone interview with CalMatters. The October 6 article reports that he stood by the tactics despite criticism from some Republicans.

    4. Starnes and Campbell weigh religious objections against Hilton's campaign strategy

      Source release

      Todd Starnes says he understands both Christian objections to the suggestive ad and Hilton's attempt to reach other voters. Guest Kyle Campbell calls the ad a misstep, says she raised concerns about coercive messaging with his team, and argues that the episode should not deter people from voting for him.

Claims

Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.

What's disputed

Response record

Responses

Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.

3 matching responses. Newest first.

  1. Xavier BecerraDemocratic candidate for governor, through campaign spokesman Jonathan Underland, in comments to the Los Angeles TimesDirectly involvedCopy link to this statement by Xavier Becerra
    "MAGA is melting down over Steve Hilton's creepy ad because they're finally seeing him for the sellout he really is, willing to abandon his own twisted values to get ahead."
    Condemned

    Case context: Was Steve Hilton's "Just Try It" campaign ad appropriate?

    Full statement and sources

    Jonathan Underland, a spokesman for Xavier Becerra's campaign for governor, told the Los Angeles Times that "MAGA is melting down over Steve Hilton's creepy ad." He said MAGA is "finally seeing him for the sellout he really is, willing to abandon his own twisted values to get ahead."

    Before the statement

    The Los Angeles Times reported that Republicans and several Democrats had denounced the ad. Becerra led Hilton 58% to 33% in a recent UC Berkeley and Los Angeles Times poll, the Times reports.

    After the statement

    The Times describes the Becerra spokesman as gleeful about the rift the ad was creating among Republicans.

    Los Angeles Times, October 3, 2026: Provocative, sexually suggestive ad by Hilton campaign condemned by political allies on the right · Los Angeles TimesParagraphs quoting Gates, Shaw, Garcia, Hilton, Underland, Patterson and Karger

    Why this label?

    Underland calls the ad creepy and uses it to attack Hilton's character. His words express Becerra's campaign's criticism through its spokesman; they are not a personal statement by Becerra.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  2. Michael GatesRepublican candidate for California attorney generalDirectly involvedCopy link to this statement by Michael Gates
    "I want to be clear: I do not condone Steve Hilton's "Just Try It" video. My campaign was not consulted, nor alerted to its release. I emphatically denounce the use of young women as a political tool. California families deserve better, and as AG, I will fight every day to protect our girls, young women, and parental rights. I guarantee it."
    Condemned

    Responding to: Michael Gates said Steve Hilton's Just Try It video is an example of the inappropriate sexualization of young people and that its portrayal of young women is out of touch with the values of California families.

    Full statement and sources

    In an X post, Gates wrote that he does not condone the video, that his campaign "was not consulted, nor alerted to its release," and "I emphatically denounce the use of young women as a political tool." He added that "California families deserve better." A campaign press release attached to the post describes the video's portrayal of young women as sexualized and out of touch with the values of California families.

    Before the statement

    The ad had been posted the day before and, according to the Los Angeles Times, had been viewed by millions of people. The Times describes Gates as a member of Hilton's "Golden Ticket" on the November 3 ballot and says he has frequently appeared alongside Hilton at campaign events.

    After the statement

    The attached release quotes Gates as saying the video's "sexualized portrayal of young women," including the "what if my dad finds out" line, "is deeply out of touch with the values and expectations of California families," and that he also denounces "the undermining of the sanctity of the relationship between parents and their children." It describes his lawsuit as Huntington Beach city attorney over AB 1955 as action to protect the parent-child relationship.

    Michael Gates's X post and press release on Steve Hilton's Just Try It video · Michael GatesPost text, and three attached images showing the campaign press release dated October 2, 2026
    Los Angeles Times, October 3, 2026: Provocative, sexually suggestive ad by Hilton campaign condemned by political allies on the right · Los Angeles TimesParagraphs quoting Gates, Shaw, Garcia, Hilton, Underland, Patterson and Karger
    CalMatters, October 6, 2026: Republican Hilton's 'Just try it' ad courts liberals, and angers his own base · CalMattersParagraphs on Shaw, Hibbs, Gates, the Hilton paragraph beginning 'In an interview, he brushed off the backlash', Fred Davis and the cost of the ads

    Why this label?

    Gates rejects the use of young women as a political tool and objects to their sexualized portrayal. His objection to the content supports this label; the lack of consultation separately explains his distance from its release.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  3. Sonja ShawChino Valley school board member and candidate for California superintendent of public instructionDirectly involvedCopy link to this statement by Sonja Shaw
    "Shame on you, @SteveHiltonx , @CAGOP and @CorrinRankin , for reposting and cheering this creepy, weird, disturbing garbage on. This is a clear example of exactly why good people are walking away from the Republican Party. As a mother and someone who has fought to protect the innocence of children, this crosses a line. We have lost our way. Embarrassing."
    Condemned

    Case context: Was Steve Hilton's "Just Try It" campaign ad appropriate?

    Full statement and sources

    Replying on X to Hilton's post of the ad, Shaw told Hilton, the California Republican Party and its chairwoman Corrin Rankin that they should be ashamed for "reposting and cheering this creepy, weird, disturbing garbage." She wrote that the ad is "exactly why good people are walking away from the Republican Party" and that, as a mother, "this crosses a line."

    Before the statement

    Hilton posted the ad on X about nine hours earlier. Shaw is on the November ballot as a candidate for state superintendent of public instruction, and the Los Angeles Times reports that she has occasionally campaigned alongside Hilton.

    After the statement

    CalMatters reports that Hilton said he had just finished a campaign event with Shaw and still has the support of fellow Republicans, and that Shaw did not return a call from the outlet seeking comment.

    Sonja Shaw's X post replying to Steve Hilton's Just Try It ad · Sonja ShawOriginal post, a reply to Hilton's video post
    Los Angeles Times, October 3, 2026: Provocative, sexually suggestive ad by Hilton campaign condemned by political allies on the right · Los Angeles TimesParagraphs quoting Gates, Shaw, Garcia, Hilton, Underland, Patterson and Karger
    CalMatters, October 6, 2026: Republican Hilton's 'Just try it' ad courts liberals, and angers his own base · CalMattersParagraphs on Shaw, Hibbs, Gates, the Hilton paragraph beginning 'In an interview, he brushed off the backlash', Fred Davis and the cost of the ads

    Why this label?

    Shaw calls the ad creepy, weird and disturbing, says it crosses a line, and faults Hilton and the state party for promoting it. Her objection is to the ad's content.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

Sources

(13)

Original video

Just Try It, California. (Steve Hilton, YouTube video)

Excerpt

"Like, what if my dad finds out? Just try it. Look, give me your hand. Close your eyes. And I'll do all the work."

About this source

The campaign's own upload of the 53-second ad. Two young women sit facing each other in a dimly lit bedroom with a progress pride flag on the wall behind them. One coaxes the other to try something she has never done, guides her hand to a mail-in ballot that lists Steve Hilton and Xavier Becerra for governor, and the ad ends with the line "Now lick it" and a closing card that reads "Just try it! Steve Hilton for Governor." The video description reads "California has voted the same way for years, and it's not working. Wanna be a real rebel? Vote different this time around. Just try it. You'll like it ;)". Hilton first posted the ad on X about 33 minutes before this upload.

Author
Steve Hilton
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Interview

Starnes and Campbell discuss objections to Hilton's Just Try It ad

Starnes and Campbell discuss objections to Hilton's Just Try It ad (opens in a new tab)October 8 episode; exchange with Kyle Campbell on Hilton advertising
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: October 8 episode; exchange with Kyle Campbell on Hilton advertising

About this source

Starnes and Campbell discuss religious objections to the ad and Hilton's campaign strategy. The publisher supplies the episode transcript.

Author
Todd Starnes Show, Truth Network
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Spencer Pratt on the media response to Hilton's ad

Spencer Pratt on the media response to Hilton's ad (opens in a new tab)Original post 2107305851350376787, complete text

About this source

Pratt's follow-up argues that coverage of conservative criticism helped Hilton communicate with progressive voters.

Author
Spencer Pratt
Published
Accessed

Analysis

Mark Z. Barabak on Hilton's campaign ad, with Davis and Spillane interviews

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Opening assessment; "What do the pros say?"; final paragraph

About this source

Barabak's original column includes his assessment and direct interviews with Republican consultants Fred Davis and Kevin Spillane. The interview dates are not separately stated.

Author
Mark Z. Barabak
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

CalMatters, October 6, 2026: Republican Hilton's 'Just try it' ad courts liberals, and angers his own base

CalMatters, October 6, 2026: Republican Hilton's 'Just try it' ad courts liberals, and angers his own base (opens in a new tab) · CalMattersParagraphs on Shaw, Hibbs, Gates, the Hilton paragraph beginning 'In an interview, he brushed off the backlash', Fred Davis and the cost of the ads
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Paragraphs on Shaw, Hibbs, Gates, the Hilton paragraph beginning 'In an interview, he brushed off the backlash', Fred Davis and the cost of the ads

Excerpt

""Anything that's strong has a strong reaction," Hilton said. "You see that in art, you see that in everything.""

About this source

CalMatters report by Jeanne Kuang. It quotes Shaw's post, Gates's statement and Jack Hibbs's remarks, a Monday phone interview with Hilton, and Republican ad maker Fred Davis. It reports that filmmaker Gabriel Mann made the ads for $125,000, that Hilton said the series uses real actors and is not AI-generated, and that more ads are coming.

Author
Jeanne Kuang
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Los Angeles Times, October 3, 2026: Provocative, sexually suggestive ad by Hilton campaign condemned by political allies on the right

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Paragraphs quoting Gates, Shaw, Garcia, Hilton, Underland, Patterson and Karger

Excerpt

""This is a bizarre and desperate ad from a person who has attacked the LGBTQ+ community and stands with Donald Trump," Garcia said."

About this source

A Los Angeles Times report by Seema Mehta, published October 3, 2026 and updated October 4. It quotes Gates, Shaw, Rep. Robert Garcia, Hilton in an interview, Becerra campaign spokesman Jonathan Underland, former California Republican Party chair Jessica Millan Patterson and Fred Karger, describes Hibbs's Facebook Live post, and reports that Democratic Party chairman Rusty Hicks also condemned the ad without quoting him. It describes Gates as a member of Hilton's "Golden Ticket" on the November 3 ballot and says Shaw has occasionally campaigned alongside Hilton.

Author
Seema Mehta
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Spencer Pratt's X post on the criticism of Steve Hilton's Just Try It ad

Excerpt

"This fake moral panic is why republicans lose."

About this source

Pratt's post quotes an October 2 post by another X user that tells critics of the ad to stop complaining and says ads like it speak to Californians who hide that they vote Republican.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Jack Hibbs's X post and video on Steve Hilton's Just Try It ad

Jack Hibbs's X post and video on Steve Hilton's Just Try It ad (opens in a new tab) · Jack HibbsPost text; video 4:17 to 7:13 and 9:27 to 10:35 (on the ad), 11:18 to 12:00 (on his vote)

Excerpt

"Steve Hilton's "Try It" ad? Grotesque. Insensitive."

About this source

Hibbs's post carries a 15-minute video in which he says he is speaking on Saturday morning, October 3, 2026; the Los Angeles Times describes that remark as a Facebook Live post. The first part of the video covers church ballot collection. He turns to the ad at about 2:25.

Published
Accessed

Original post

Michael Gates's X post and press release on Steve Hilton's Just Try It video

Michael Gates's X post and press release on Steve Hilton's Just Try It video (opens in a new tab) · Michael GatesPost text, and three attached images showing the campaign press release dated October 2, 2026

Excerpt

"I emphatically denounce the use of young women as a political tool. California families deserve better."

About this source

Gates posted this statement at 2:14 p.m. Pacific on October 2, 2026, and attached his campaign's press release, titled "Gates Condemns Hilton Ad: Fighting for Families Means Respecting Women," with Lana Clay, campaign manager, as the contact. The quotation in the statement is the post's own text. The release is longer and calls the video's portrayal of young women sexualized.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Sonja Shaw's X post replying to Steve Hilton's Just Try It ad

Sonja Shaw's X post replying to Steve Hilton's Just Try It ad (opens in a new tab) · Sonja ShawOriginal post, a reply to Hilton's video post

Excerpt

"This is a clear example of exactly why good people are walking away from the Republican Party."

About this source

Posted at 11:28 p.m. Pacific on October 1, 2026, as a reply to Hilton's post of the ad. It tags Hilton, the California Republican Party (@CAGOP) and its chairwoman Corrin Rankin. The post ends with a nauseated-face emoji. CalMatters reports that Shaw did not return a call seeking comment.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Steve Hilton's X video on the Just Try It campaign and the reaction to it

Steve Hilton's X video on the Just Try It campaign and the reaction to it (opens in a new tab) · Steve HiltonVideo, 1:01 to 2:15 (the first ad's reception, offense, and the request for grace)

Steve Hilton addresses the reaction to his "Just Try It" campaign ad, in a video posted to X on Oct. 4, 2026.

Excerpt from 1:01 to 2:15 of the video in the X post. DI added its logo in the corner.

Video: Steve Hilton (@SteveHiltonx on X). Excerpt used for news reporting and commentary

Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: Video, 1:01 to 2:15 (the first ad's reception, offense, and the request for grace))

Excerpt

"We were trying to make a point in a provocative way, in a satirical way. No one was ever trying to offend anyone."

About this source

A 4 minute 37 second video posted at 5:01 p.m. Pacific on Saturday, October 3, 2026 (00:01 UTC on October 4), under the text "A word on our new campaign, 'Just Try It!', and the reaction to it:". Hilton speaks to the camera about the campaign, the reaction to the first ad, and the choice between him and Becerra. The quotation is our transcription of the audio.

Author
Steve Hilton
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

Expand Your Mind | Steve Hilton for Governor (YouTube video)

Expand Your Mind | Steve Hilton for Governor (YouTube video) (opens in a new tab) · Steve HiltonVideo description; the ad runs 0:00 to 0:53

Excerpt

"Why not try something new and groovy? JUST TRY IT!"

About this source

The second ad in the campaign's Just Try It series. A woman guides a bearded man in white clothes at an outdoor retreat, talks him through letting go of his fears, and helps him mark a ballot for Steve Hilton. It ends on the same closing card as the first ad. The video description reads "California has voted the same way for years. And now Sacramento is FAR OUT, man. Why not try something new and groovy? JUST TRY IT!"

Author
Steve Hilton
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Steve Hilton's X post of the Just Try It, California ad

Steve Hilton's X post of the Just Try It, California ad (opens in a new tab) · Steve HiltonOriginal post with the 53-second video attached

Excerpt

"Just try it, California."

About this source

Hilton's first public post of the ad, at 2:21 p.m. Pacific on October 1, 2026. The post's only text is "Just try it, California." It had about 5.6 million views when we checked on October 6. Sonja Shaw's reply is aimed at this video.

Author
Steve Hilton
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Case updates

Following the backlash to Steve Hilton's Just Try It ad?

Get an email if Hilton releases more ads in the series, or if Hilton, Shaw, Gates or Becerra's campaign say more about the ad.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

The newsletter

Follow disputes like this one.

New cases and significant updates to the record, in your inbox. Free.

You’ll confirm your subscription on Substack.

Share or embed this case

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Was Steve Hilton's "Just Try It" campaign ad appropriate?
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/cases/was-steve-hiltons-just-try-it-campaign-ad-appropriate

The Dispute Index. "Was Steve Hilton's "Just Try It" campaign ad appropriate?". First published: 2026-10-06. Last updated: 2026-10-06. https://disputeindex.com/cases/was-steve-hiltons-just-try-it-campaign-ad-appropriate