Should Amazon be allowed to block Meta's Muse agent from shopping on its site?

Amazon blocked Meta's Muse AI agent from its store, saying the agent accessed customer accounts without authorization and does not identify itself. Meta disputes Amazon's description of how Muse handles credentials. The block remains in place.

Three phone screens show Meta's Muse shopping for a stroller and asking for purchase approval.
Meta's promotional images show Muse comparing strollers and asking for approval before placing an order.

Case period:

Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated

Meta PlatformsAmazon

Overview

On September 20, 2026, Amazon blocked Muse, the personal Meta launched on September 8, from shopping on Amazon.com. Users who tried to use Muse on the site saw a message that "continued access by an unauthorized AI agent violates Amazon's Conditions of Use." Amazon says Meta never sought permission, that Muse does not identify itself as an automated agent, and that it appears to capture and store customer credentials. Meta says Muse "has no visibility into people's passwords or payment methods" and that credentials go into secure storage the agent can use without seeing them. The dispute is whether a retailer can refuse service to an AI agent acting on a customer's behalf, and on what terms.

Background: What is an AI agent?
Read the full background

The fixed reference point for classification in this case is Amazon's decision, visible to users by September 20, 2026, to block Meta's Muse personal AI agent from shopping on Amazon.com. Responses are recorded against that block and the reasons Amazon gave for it. They are not recorded against Muse's privacy practices generally, other retailers' agent policies, or the wider debate over AI agents.

Meta launched Muse on September 8 as a free personal agent, with paid tiers, on iOS, Android, muse.ai and WhatsApp. It carries out multi-step tasks such as shopping, booking appointments and organizing calendars, using credentials the user provides. Meta says that where a service has no public API, the agent "can use the service through a browser the way you would," and that a separate monitoring agent called Sentinel must approve anything Muse sends to the internet. Muse reached the top of the U.S. iOS free app chart within days of launch.

GeekWire reported (opens in a new tab) that Amazon first asked Meta to voluntarily exclude Amazon.com from Muse's shopping features, that Meta did not do so, and that Amazon then deployed an anti-bot wall that stops Muse before it can load the search page. Amazon gave three reasons: it says it was not told in advance and never authorized the access, it says Muse does not identify itself as an automated agent while browsing, and it says the agent appears to capture and store customer login credentials. An Amazon spokesperson said that "third-party applications that offer to make purchases on behalf of customers from other businesses should operate openly and respect service provider decisions about whether or not to participate."

Meta disputes the credential claim. The company says Muse "has no visibility into people's passwords or payment methods" and that credentials "go into secure storage, so Muse can use them without seeing them." Meta announced a partnership with Shopify for some of Muse's shopping features. As of September 28, 2026, we could not locate a detailed public statement from Meta addressing the block itself, though Amazon said on September 21 that the two companies were in direct conversation.

The block follows a legal fight over the same question. Amazon sued Perplexity in November 2025 over its Comet browser shopping on Amazon. A federal judge granted Amazon a preliminary injunction in March 2026, but the Ninth Circuit vacated it on August 4 (opens in a new tab), ruling that the user, not the AI company, was the one accessing Amazon under federal anti-hacking law. The court denied Amazon's petition for rehearing on September 10, leaving contract and terms-of-service claims as Amazon's remaining avenue. The message Muse users now see cites Amazon's Conditions of Use rather than any hacking statute.

Other companies and executives have taken positions. Palo Alto Networks chief executive Nikesh Arora wrote on X (opens in a new tab) that every services, marketplace and commerce app will have to decide whether to open interfaces for consumer agents. Liat Ben-Zur, a former Microsoft vice president, told Fortune that the companies that control the rules of access will have enormous influence over whether agents actually work for the consumer. WION reported (opens in a new tab) that a researcher disclosed a vulnerability that could expose Muse's authentication system, which Amazon's defenders cite as support for the security rationale.

Silence is not a position. A refusal to comment, or a referral to an earlier statement, is recorded only where a source reports it.

People in this case

Timeline

10 timeline entries on this page. Dates: November 1, 2025 to September 28, 2026

  1. November 2025

    1. Amazon sues Perplexity over agent shopping on its store

      In November 2025, Amazon sued the AI search company Perplexity over its Comet browser letting users shop on Amazon, an early legal fight over third-party AI agents acting for customers.

      [01]Amazon Blocks Meta's Muse Agent From Shopping, And Signals a New Tollgate for Agent Commerce

      Yahoo Finance analysis recounting the block, Amazon's stated reasons, Meta's response, and the procedural history of Amazon's lawsuit against Perplexity, including the March 2026 preliminary injunction and the Ninth Circuit's August 4, 2026 decision vacating it.

  2. March 2026

    1. Federal court grants Amazon a preliminary injunction against Perplexity

      In March 2026, a federal judge granted Amazon a preliminary injunction in the Perplexity case. The Ninth Circuit later vacated it.

      [01]Amazon Blocks Meta's Muse Agent From Shopping, And Signals a New Tollgate for Agent Commerce

      Yahoo Finance analysis recounting the block, Amazon's stated reasons, Meta's response, and the procedural history of Amazon's lawsuit against Perplexity, including the March 2026 preliminary injunction and the Ninth Circuit's August 4, 2026 decision vacating it.

  3. August 2026

    1. Ninth Circuit vacates the Perplexity injunction

      The Ninth Circuit vacated the preliminary injunction, ruling that it was the users, not Perplexity, who were technically accessing Amazon under federal anti-hacking law. Contract and terms-of-service claims remained open to Amazon.

      [01]Amazon Blocks Meta's Muse Agent From Shopping, And Signals a New Tollgate for Agent Commerce

      Yahoo Finance analysis recounting the block, Amazon's stated reasons, Meta's response, and the procedural history of Amazon's lawsuit against Perplexity, including the March 2026 preliminary injunction and the Ninth Circuit's August 4, 2026 decision vacating it.

  4. September 2026

    1. Meta launches the Muse personal AI agent

      Incident

      Meta launched Muse, a personal AI agent that carries out multi-step tasks such as shopping and booking appointments, on iOS, Android, muse.ai and WhatsApp. It reached the top of the U.S. iOS free app chart within days.

      [02]Meta's Muse AI is exploding in popularity, and drawing heated backlash

      Fortune report on Muse's rise to the top of the U.S. iOS free app chart, Amazon's block and statement, Meta's Shopify partnership, and reactions from Nikesh Arora on X and Liat Ben-Zur in an interview.

    2. Ninth Circuit denies Amazon's rehearing petition

      The Ninth Circuit denied Amazon's petition for rehearing in the Perplexity case, leaving terms-of-service enforcement as Amazon's main remaining lever against outside agents.

      [03]Amazon blocks Meta's Muse AI assistant in new standoff over agentic shopping

      GeekWire report that Amazon blocked Meta's Muse personal AI agent from shopping on Amazon.com, with Amazon's stated reasons (no advance notice, no self-identification, credential handling), the text of the popup shown to users, Meta's response about credential storage, and the companies' prior contacts before the block.

    3. Amazon blocks Muse from Amazon.com

      Incident

      Amazon deployed an anti-bot wall blocking Meta's Muse agent from shopping on Amazon.com. Users saw a message that continued access by an unauthorized AI agent violates Amazon's Conditions of Use. Amazon said it had first asked Meta to voluntarily exclude Amazon and Meta did not do so.

      [03]Amazon blocks Meta's Muse AI assistant in new standoff over agentic shopping

      GeekWire report that Amazon blocked Meta's Muse personal AI agent from shopping on Amazon.com, with Amazon's stated reasons (no advance notice, no self-identification, credential handling), the text of the popup shown to users, Meta's response about credential storage, and the companies' prior contacts before the block.

    4. Amazon defends the block and says it is talking with Meta

      Reaction

      An Amazon spokesperson said third-party buying agents should operate openly and respect service provider decisions, and said the company was in direct conversation with Meta. Meta had disputed Amazon's credential claims but had not issued a detailed public statement about the block.

      [03]Amazon blocks Meta's Muse AI assistant in new standoff over agentic shopping

      GeekWire report that Amazon blocked Meta's Muse personal AI agent from shopping on Amazon.com, with Amazon's stated reasons (no advance notice, no self-identification, credential handling), the text of the popup shown to users, Meta's response about credential storage, and the companies' prior contacts before the block.

      [02]Meta's Muse AI is exploding in popularity, and drawing heated backlash

      Fortune report on Muse's rise to the top of the U.S. iOS free app chart, Amazon's block and statement, Meta's Shopify partnership, and reactions from Nikesh Arora on X and Liat Ben-Zur in an interview.

    5. Amazon adds a contract-interference claim in the Comet lawsuit

      Source release

      Amazon filed a first amended complaint against Perplexity, adding a claim that Comet induced customers to breach Amazon's Conditions of Use. The separate lawsuit tests the agent-access rules underlying Amazon's block of Meta's Muse. The amended claim is an allegation awaiting adjudication.

      [04]Amazon's first amended complaint against Perplexity

      Amazon's allegations and requested relief in its Comet lawsuit. The filing supplies legal context for the company's separate block of Meta's Muse.

      Amazon's first amended complaint against PerplexityECF 122, page 2 paragraphs 1-2; page 33 paragraph 94; pages 35-39, Count Three.
    6. Executives publicly frame the stakes of agent access

      Reaction

      Palo Alto Networks chief executive Nikesh Arora wrote on X that every services, marketplace and commerce app will have to decide whether to open interfaces to consumer agents. Former Microsoft corporate vice president Liat Ben-Zur told Fortune that whoever controls the rules of access will influence whether agents work for consumers.

      [02]Meta's Muse AI is exploding in popularity, and drawing heated backlash

      Fortune report on Muse's rise to the top of the U.S. iOS free app chart, Amazon's block and statement, Meta's Shopify partnership, and reactions from Nikesh Arora on X and Liat Ben-Zur in an interview.

    7. Researcher reports a Muse authentication vulnerability

      Claim

      WION reported that a researcher had disclosed a vulnerability said to be capable of exposing Muse's authentication system, adding a security claim to the dispute over Amazon's block.

      [05]Meta Muse AI agent: Why Amazon blocked it and why hackers are now a concern

      WION report on the Amazon block and on a researcher's disclosure of a vulnerability said to be capable of exposing Muse's authentication system.

Response record

Responses

Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.

7 responses. First 6 shown initially. Newest first.

  1. James BorowAdvertising technology executive commenting personally

    Before this statement

    Borow described his experience of Amazon blocking Muse.

    "I 100% get why Amazon can’t play ball"
    Mixed or conditional

    Case context: Should Amazon be allowed to block Meta's Muse agent from shopping on its site?

    Full statement and sources

    Borow criticizes his experience of Amazon blocking Muse but says he understands Amazon's position. He argues that Meta needs more control over its shopping service's future.

    After the statement

    He criticized the block but said he understood Amazon's position.

    James Borow's response to the disputeOriginal post, October 1 at 1:57 a.m.

    Why this label?

    He expresses both criticism and acceptance of Amazon's decision.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  2. Arav MathurGrayPass founder and chief executive

    Before this statement

    Mathur discussed Amazon's block while describing GrayPass's approach to agent access.

    "idt the solution is to block AI agents from internet services completely."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should Amazon be allowed to block Meta's Muse agent from shopping on its site?

    Full statement and sources

    Mathur opposes blanket blocks on shopping agents and proposes distinguishing human control, agent control and transitions between them. He cites Amazon's Muse block while promoting GrayPass.

    After the statement

    He proposed distinguishing human and agent control instead of blocking agents outright.

    Arav Mathur's response to the disputeFull original post, October 1 at 7:08 a.m.

    Why this label?

    He rejects blanket blocking and proposes an alternative.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  3. Liat Ben-ZurFormer Microsoft corporate vice president, in an interview with Fortune

    Before this statement

    Amazon had blocked Meta's Muse agent from its store, citing unauthorized access, and Meta had disputed Amazon's description of Muse's credential handling.

    "This is bigger than a dispute over bot detection or website access. We are moving toward a world where agents will increasingly act as our representatives online. The companies that control the rules of access will have enormous influence over whether those agents actually work for the consumer."
    Mixed or conditional

    Case context: Should Amazon be allowed to block Meta's Muse agent from shopping on its site?

    Full statement and sources

    Liat Ben-Zur, a former Microsoft corporate vice president, told Fortune that the standoff is bigger than bot detection or website access, and that the companies controlling the rules of access will have enormous influence over whether AI agents actually work for the consumer.

    After the statement

    Amazon operates its own shopping agent, Buy for Me, and has said brands can opt out of it; critics note that outside agents get no equivalent path on Amazon.

    Why this label?

    Ben-Zur identifies what is at stake in Amazon's decision and warns about gatekeeping power, but does not expressly say the block is right or wrong.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  4. Nikesh AroraPalo Alto Networks chief executive, posting on X

    Before this statement

    Amazon had blocked Meta's Muse agent from shopping on Amazon.com two days earlier, and Muse had reached the top of the U.S. iOS free app chart.

    "It is only a matter of time before there is an Apple and Google version of Muse and possibly TikTok, in addition to the frontier LLM agents. Every app that is a services, marketplace or commerce app will need to existentially decide to open [Application Programming Interfaces] for consumer agents to interact. Smaller players have no choice. Either the consumer benefits or distribution aggregators will demand a higher transaction fare."
    Mixed or conditional

    Case context: Should Amazon be allowed to block Meta's Muse agent from shopping on its site?

    Full statement and sources

    Palo Alto Networks chief executive Nikesh Arora wrote on X that every services, marketplace and commerce app will have to decide whether to open interfaces to consumer AI agents, and that smaller players have no choice. He framed the choice as either benefiting consumers or paying distribution aggregators a higher fare, without endorsing or condemning Amazon's block.

    After the statement

    Fortune quoted the post in coverage of the block. Arora did not address Amazon or Meta by name in the quoted portion.

    Why this label?

    Arora addresses the dispute's central question, whether platforms must open to outside agents, but predicts a decision rather than taking Amazon's or Meta's side.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  5. AmazonAmazon, through counsel in a federal complaintDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    Amazon filed an amended complaint in its separate lawsuit against Perplexity over its Comet browser. The complaint relies on Amazon's Conditions of Use, which the Muse block message also cites.

    "Whatever permission an individual customer may give Perplexity to operate within that customer's own account, such permission cannot supply the separate authorization Perplexity requires from Amazon, which owns and operates the computers on which those accounts reside and which has withheld that authorization."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Should Amazon be allowed to block Meta's Muse agent from shopping on its site?

    Full statement and sources

    In its September 21 amended complaint against Perplexity over the Comet browser, Amazon argued that whatever permission a customer gives Perplexity to operate within the customer's account cannot supply the separate authorization Perplexity requires from Amazon. The complaint also adds a claim of tortious interference with contract based on Amazon's Conditions of Use.

    After the statement

    The complaint asks for preliminary, interim and permanent injunctive relief and for monetary damages.

    Amazon's first amended complaint against PerplexityECF 122, page 2 paragraphs 1-2; page 33 paragraph 94; pages 35-39, Count Three.

    Why this label?

    The case asks whether Amazon should be allowed to block Meta's Muse agent from shopping on its site. This filing is Amazon's pleading in a different lawsuit, against Perplexity, so it does not address Muse. It is recorded because it states Amazon's position that an outside shopping agent needs Amazon's own authorization and that a customer's permission does not supply it, which is the same question the Muse block raises. We labeled it Defended or excused because Amazon is defending its right to control agent access to its site. Challenged the characterization is the closest competing label; it loses because Amazon is not disputing a description.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  6. Meta PlatformsMeta, in its public description of Muse's security modelDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    Amazon told reporters that Muse appears to capture and store customer login credentials and does not identify itself as an automated agent. Meta's statement about credential handling predates the block; GeekWire republished it in coverage of the dispute.

    "Muse "has no visibility into people's passwords or payment methods," and credentials a user shares "go into secure storage, so Muse can use them without seeing them, including passwords a person types into the browser themselves.""
    Denied

    Case context: Should Amazon be allowed to block Meta's Muse agent from shopping on its site?

    Full statement and sources

    Meta denied Amazon's suggestion that Muse captures customer credentials, saying the agent has no visibility into passwords or payment methods and that credentials are kept in secure storage the agent can use without seeing them.

    After the statement

    As of September 28, 2026, we could not locate a detailed public statement from Meta addressing the block itself. Meta announced a partnership with Shopify for some of Muse's shopping features.

    Why this label?

    Amazon's stated reasons include an apparent capture and storage of customer credentials; Meta's statement directly denies that characterization of how Muse works.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

View all 7 responsesShow fewer responses
  1. AmazonAmazon spokesperson, in a statement to reportersDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    Users attempting to shop on Amazon.com with Meta's Muse agent began seeing a popup that said continued access by an unauthorized AI agent violates Amazon's Conditions of Use.

    "We think it's fairly straightforward that third-party applications that offer to make purchases on behalf of customers from other businesses should operate openly and respect service provider decisions about whether or not to participate."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Should Amazon be allowed to block Meta's Muse agent from shopping on its site?

    Full statement and sources

    An Amazon spokesperson defended the block of Meta's Muse agent, saying third-party applications that buy on behalf of customers should operate openly and respect a service provider's decision about whether to participate. Amazon said Meta never notified it or sought authorization, that Muse does not identify itself as an automated agent, and that the agent appears to capture and store customer credentials.

    After the statement

    Meta disputes the credential claim, saying Muse has no visibility into passwords or payment methods. Amazon said it was in direct conversation with Meta and declined to comment on possible legal action.

    Why this label?

    Amazon is the party that imposed the block and gives its reasons for it, which we record as defending the action.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

Sources

(7)

Reporting

Amazon blocks Meta's Muse AI assistant in new standoff over agentic shopping

About this source

GeekWire report that Amazon blocked Meta's Muse personal AI agent from shopping on Amazon.com, with Amazon's stated reasons (no advance notice, no self-identification, credential handling), the text of the popup shown to users, Meta's response about credential storage, and the companies' prior contacts before the block.

Author
GeekWire
Published
Accessed

Original text

Amazon's first amended complaint against Perplexity

Amazon's first amended complaint against Perplexity (opens in a new tab)ECF 122, page 2 paragraphs 1-2; page 33 paragraph 94; pages 35-39, Count Three.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: ECF 122, page 2 paragraphs 1-2; page 33 paragraph 94; pages 35-39, Count Three.

About this source

Amazon's allegations and requested relief in its Comet lawsuit. The filing supplies legal context for the company's separate block of Meta's Muse.

Author
Amazon.com Services LLC, through Hueston Hennigan LLP
Published
Accessed

Original post

Arav Mathur's response to the dispute

Arav Mathur's response to the dispute (opens in a new tab)Full original post, October 1 at 7:08 a.m.

About this source

The speaker's own post responding to the dispute.

Author
Arav Mathur
Published
Accessed

Original post

James Borow's response to the dispute

About this source

The speaker's own post responding to the dispute.

Author
James Borow
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Meta Muse AI agent: Why Amazon blocked it and why hackers are now a concern

About this source

WION report on the Amazon block and on a researcher's disclosure of a vulnerability said to be capable of exposing Muse's authentication system.

Author
WION
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Analysis

Amazon Blocks Meta's Muse Agent From Shopping, And Signals a New Tollgate for Agent Commerce

About this source

Yahoo Finance analysis recounting the block, Amazon's stated reasons, Meta's response, and the procedural history of Amazon's lawsuit against Perplexity, including the March 2026 preliminary injunction and the Ninth Circuit's August 4, 2026 decision vacating it.

Author
Yahoo Finance
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Meta's Muse AI is exploding in popularity, and drawing heated backlash

About this source

Fortune report on Muse's rise to the top of the U.S. iOS free app chart, Amazon's block and statement, Meta's Shopify partnership, and reactions from Nikesh Arora on X and Liat Ben-Zur in an interview.

Author
Fortune
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Case updates

Amazon, Meta and the Muse block: what happens next?

We'll email you if Amazon lifts or changes the block, if Meta addresses it in detail, or if a court rules in Amazon's related lawsuit over another shopping agent.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

The newsletter

Follow disputes like this one.

New cases and significant updates to the record, in your inbox. Free.

You’ll confirm your subscription on Substack.

Share or embed this case

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Should Amazon be allowed to block Meta's Muse agent from shopping on its site?
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/cases/amazon-block-meta-muse-ai-agent-shopping

The Dispute Index. "Should Amazon be allowed to block Meta's Muse agent from shopping on its site?". First published: 2026-09-29. Last updated: 2026-10-06. https://disputeindex.com/cases/amazon-block-meta-muse-ai-agent-shopping