Judge upholds the NYPD's collection of DNA from discarded items for New York City's Suspect Index; Legal Aid appeals, backed by NYCLU, ACLU and Cato
Legal Aid is appealing a federal ruling that the NYPD lawfully took Shakira Leslie's DNA from a cup for the city's Suspect Index. Briefs from the NYCLU, ACLU, Cato and LDF call the database unlawful; the NYPD and medical examiner say it follows the law.

Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Overview
New York State's DNA databank, created under Article 49-B of the Executive Law, holds profiles of people convicted of crimes. Legal Aid and the amici argue that state law makes it the only DNA index allowed in New York; Judge Buchwald noted that state trial courts have reached differing results on whether the medical examiner's local index is permitted. In Maryland v. King (2013), the Supreme Court upheld taking DNA cheek swabs from people arrested for serious offenses without a warrant, and Buchwald relied on that decision. The NYCLU argues that King allowed DNA collection only under detailed statutes that limit police discretion.
People in this case
Naomi Reice BuchwaldCommented
Timeline
6 timeline entries on this page. Dates: March 22, 2022 to November 12, 2026
March 2022
Legal Aid Society sues the City over the Suspect Index
Incident
The Legal Aid Society filed a class action in the Southern District of New York against the City, the NYPD and the Office of Chief Medical Examiner, challenging the collection and storage of DNA from people police suspected of crimes without a warrant or court order.
March 2026
Judge Buchwald grants the City summary judgment
Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald granted the City's motion for summary judgment on Leslie's Fourth Amendment claim, denied Leslie's cross-motion, and dismissed her state law claim without prejudice to refiling in state court.
July 2026
Leslie files her opening brief in the Second Circuit
Leslie, represented by the Legal Aid Society and O'Melveny & Myers, filed her opening brief in the Second Circuit, asking the court to reverse the district court's judgment for the City.
ACLU, NYCLU and Cato file an amicus brief supporting Leslie
The ACLU, the New York Civil Liberties Union and the Cato Institute filed an amicus brief arguing that the Suspect Index violates state law and that warrantless collection of DNA from discarded items violates the Fourth Amendment.
Legal Defense Fund files an amicus brief supporting Leslie
The Legal Defense Fund filed an amicus brief urging the Second Circuit to reverse the district court and arguing that the NYPD's DNA collection practice disproportionately affects Black and Brown New Yorkers.
November 2026
NYCLU podcast episode examines the NYPD's DNA collection
Source release
The NYCLU released an episode of its Rights This Way podcast with NYU law professor Erin Murphy and NYCLU lawyer Beth Haroules. The episode says the NYPD has collected the genetic material of 34,000 people over more than a decade, generally without their consent.
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
The Legal Aid Society
The NYPD's practice of collecting DNA from items that suspects use or discard and adding the profiles to the Suspect Index without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment and New York State law.
What is disputed
In March 2026, Judge Buchwald ruled that collecting Leslie's DNA from a disposable cup was not a Fourth Amendment search and declined to decide the state law question. The medical examiner's office says the database complies with all applicable laws.
Sources (4)
- Legal Aid Files Class Action Civil Lawsuit Against the City's Illegal and Orwellian DNA Collection and Storage Practices · The Legal Aid SocietyPress release, March 22, 2022
- Leslie v. City of New York, Brief and Special Appendix for Plaintiff-Appellant · The Legal Aid SocietyNo. 26-950 (2d Cir.), docket entry 46.1, July 23, 2026
- Leslie v. City of New York, Memorandum and OrderNo. 22 Civ. 2305 (NRB), ECF No. 164, March 20, 2026
- NYPD accused of secretly collecting DNA from thousands of New Yorkers for "rogue" database · CBS NewsNews article, March 22, 2022
In their own words
Their own account
Statements from the person or group whose act or claim this case is about. They are listed apart from the responses, and each label says what the speaker did with their own act or claim.
New York City Police DepartmentNew York City's police department, in a statement by spokesperson Sgt. Edward Riley quoted by CBS News"The NYPD's investigations and tactics, including the collection of DNA, are guided by what is authorized by the law, the wealth of case law from the courts, and the best practices of the law enforcement community"
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
Stood by itResponding to: The NYPD's practice of collecting DNA from items that suspects use or discard and adding the profiles to the Suspect Index without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment and New York State law.
Full statement and sources
Responding to Legal Aid's lawsuit, the NYPD says its investigations and tactics, including collecting DNA, are guided by the law, case law and the best practices of law enforcement.
Before the statement
CBS News reported that the medical examiner's office said the local DNA database complies with all applicable laws.
After the statement
Riley said the department collects DNA to legally identify the correct perpetrator, build the strongest case possible and bring closure to victims and their families.
NYPD accused of secretly collecting DNA from thousands of New Yorkers for "rogue" database · CBS NewsNews article, March 22, 2022Why this label?
The NYPD says its investigations and tactics, including collecting DNA, follow the law, court rulings and law enforcement best practices, so we labeled it Stood by it.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
New York City Office of Chief Medical ExaminerNew York City agency that runs the city's DNA laboratory and local DNA database, in a statement quoted by CBS News "The local DNA database complies with all applicable laws and is managed and used in accordance with the highest scientific standards set by independent accrediting bodies that have regularly reapproved the existence of the database"
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
Stood by itResponding to: The NYPD's practice of collecting DNA from items that suspects use or discard and adding the profiles to the Suspect Index without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment and New York State law.
Full statement and sources
Responding to Legal Aid's lawsuit, the Office of Chief Medical Examiner says its local DNA database complies with all applicable laws and meets the scientific standards of independent accrediting bodies.
Before the statement
CBS News reported that Nicholas Paolucci, a spokesperson for the city Law Department, said the department would review the lawsuit.
After the statement
NYPD spokesperson Sgt. Edward Riley said the department's investigations and tactics, including DNA collection, are guided by the law, case law and law enforcement best practices.
NYPD accused of secretly collecting DNA from thousands of New Yorkers for "rogue" database · CBS NewsNews article, March 22, 2022Why this label?
The medical examiner's office says the local DNA database complies with all applicable laws and meets accrediting bodies' scientific standards, so we labeled it Stood by it.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
6 responses. Newest first.
Legal Defense FundCivil rights legal organization, in a statement by Emahunn Campbell, its assistant counsel, announcing its amicus brief"The NYPD secretively took Shakira Leslie's DNA and placed her on a list she could not know of and had no means to contest."
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
CondemnedResponding to: The NYPD's practice of collecting DNA from items that suspects use or discard and adding the profiles to the Suspect Index without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment and New York State law.
Full statement and sources
LDF's Emahunn Campbell says the NYPD secretly took Leslie's DNA and placed her on a list she could not know about or contest.
Before the statement
LDF said its brief urges the Second Circuit to reverse the district court's judgment, which relied on Maryland v. King, and argues that the NYPD's practice disproportionately affects Black and Brown New Yorkers.
After the statement
Campbell said placing Black people in a surveillance dragnet is not new but remains unconscionable and dangerous, and that LDF hopes the court makes clear that the NYPD's racial targeting is unlawful.
LDF Files Amicus Brief Challenging NYPD's Practice of Secretly Taking DNA from New Yorkers · Legal Defense FundPress release, July 31, 2026Why this label?
LDF says the NYPD secretly took Leslie's DNA, calls the practice unconscionable and dangerous, and asks the court to declare its racial targeting unlawful, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
New York Civil Liberties UnionCivil liberties group, in a statement by Beth Haroules, its director of disability justice litigation, announcing its amicus brief"No New Yorker should have their DNA taken illegally and stored in a secret database. This destructive practice disproportionately targets Black and brown New Yorkers and violates our Fourth Amendment rights. No court should allow this intrusion on our privacy."
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
CondemnedResponding to: The NYPD's practice of collecting DNA from items that suspects use or discard and adding the profiles to the Suspect Index without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment and New York State law.
Full statement and sources
The NYCLU's Beth Haroules says no New Yorker should have DNA taken illegally and stored in a secret database, that the practice disproportionately targets Black and brown New Yorkers and violates Fourth Amendment rights, and that no court should allow it.
Before the statement
The NYCLU said it filed an amicus brief with the ACLU and the Cato Institute in the Second Circuit supporting the Legal Aid Society's challenge. Haroules said the NYPD has operated a DNA database not authorized by law for more than a decade.
After the statement
In the same release, Vera Eidelman of the ACLU said the government cannot treat people's DNA like their garbage and seize, search and store it without a warrant.
Civil Liberties Groups File Amicus Brief Opposing NYPD's Illegal, Secret Seizure and Storage of DNA · New York Civil Liberties UnionPress release, July 30, 2026Why this label?
The NYCLU says the NYPD takes DNA illegally, stores it in a secret database and violates Fourth Amendment rights, and urges the courts not to allow it, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
American Civil Liberties UnionCivil liberties organization, in a statement by Vera Eidelman, senior staff attorney in its Speech, Privacy, and Technology Project"The government cannot treat our DNA like it treats our garbage, and seize, search, and store it without a warrant"
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
CondemnedResponding to: The NYPD's practice of collecting DNA from items that suspects use or discard and adding the profiles to the Suspect Index without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment and New York State law.
Full statement and sources
The ACLU's Vera Eidelman says the government cannot treat people's DNA like their garbage and seize, search and store it without a warrant.
Before the statement
In the same release, Beth Haroules of the NYCLU said no New Yorker should have DNA taken illegally and stored in a secret database.
After the statement
Eidelman said New York City's actual practice of amassing people's DNA without their knowledge, consent or court-ordered or legislative guardrails was more troubling than any hypothetical, and told New Yorkers to hold on to their trash if the Second Circuit does not intervene.
Civil Liberties Groups File Amicus Brief Opposing NYPD's Illegal, Secret Seizure and Storage of DNA · American Civil Liberties UnionPress release, July 30, 2026Why this label?
The ACLU says the government cannot treat people's DNA like garbage and seize, search and store it without a warrant, and calls New York City's practice troubling, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Matthew CavedonDirector of the Project on Criminal Justice at the Cato Institute, in a joint news release with the ACLU and the NYCLU "The secret, dragnet collection of DNA for inclusion on a 'Suspect Index' sounds dystopian. Yet it's an affront to privacy and the presumption of innocence tens of thousands of New Yorkers have already suffered."
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
CondemnedResponding to: The NYPD's practice of collecting DNA from items that suspects use or discard and adding the profiles to the Suspect Index without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment and New York State law.
Full statement and sources
Cavedon says the secret collection of DNA for the Suspect Index is an affront to privacy and the presumption of innocence that tens of thousands of New Yorkers have already suffered.
Before the statement
The release said the brief argues that the Suspect Index violates state law, and that the index includes people excluded as suspects, arrestees never convicted of a crime, and people who were exonerated or acquitted.
After the statement
Cavedon ends the statement by saying the Fourth Amendment protects against the collection and that he hopes the Second Circuit will too.
Civil Liberties Groups File Amicus Brief Opposing NYPD's Illegal, Secret Seizure and Storage of DNA · American Civil Liberties UnionPress release, July 30, 2026Why this label?
Cavedon calls the secret DNA collection for the Suspect Index dystopian and an affront to privacy and the presumption of innocence, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Naomi Reice BuchwaldSenior U.S. district judge for the Southern District of New York, in a written decision granting the City summary judgment"Accordingly, no Fourth Amendment search occurred because Leslie lacked both a subjective and an objectively reasonable expectation of privacy in the disposable cup from which she drank."
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
Defended or excusedResponding to: The NYPD's practice of collecting DNA from items that suspects use or discard and adding the profiles to the Suspect Index without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment and New York State law.
Full statement and sources
Buchwald rules that Leslie had neither a subjective nor an objectively reasonable expectation of privacy in the disposable cup she drank from, so collecting her DNA from it was not a Fourth Amendment search.
Before the statement
Buchwald found that Leslie drank from a cup offered by law enforcement, left it on the table when she exited the room and did not express a desire to keep the cup private.
After the statement
Buchwald declined to decide whether the Suspect Index violates New York's DNA databank law, calling it a novel question of state law, and dismissed that claim without prejudice to refiling in state court.
Leslie v. City of New York, Memorandum and OrderNo. 22 Civ. 2305 (NRB), ECF No. 164, March 20, 2026Why this label?
Buchwald rules that the NYPD's collection of Leslie's DNA from the cup was not a Fourth Amendment search and grants the City summary judgment, so we labeled it Defended or excused.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
The Legal Aid SocietyPublic defender organization, in a statement by Phil Desgranges, supervising attorney in its Special Litigation Unit, announcing its class actionDirectly involved"Thousands of New Yorkers, most of whom are Black and brown, and many of whom have never been convicted of any crime, are illegally in the City's rogue DNA database, which treats people as suspects in every crime involving DNA"
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
CondemnedResponding to: The NYPD's practice of collecting DNA from items that suspects use or discard and adding the profiles to the Suspect Index without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment and New York State law.
Full statement and sources
Announcing its class action, the Legal Aid Society's Phil Desgranges says thousands of New Yorkers, most of them Black and brown and many never convicted, are illegally in the city's DNA database, which treats them as suspects in every crime involving DNA.
Before the statement
Legal Aid said it sued the City, the NYPD and the medical examiner's office on behalf of two clients whose DNA was collected without their knowledge or consent and placed in the Suspect Index.
After the statement
Desgranges said the database operates virtually unchecked and has kept growing despite the City's promises to reduce its size, and that the NYPD cannot be trusted to police itself.
Legal Aid Files Class Action Civil Lawsuit Against the City's Illegal and Orwellian DNA Collection and Storage Practices · The Legal Aid SocietyPress release, March 22, 2022Why this label?
Legal Aid says the city holds thousands of New Yorkers illegally in a DNA database that treats them as suspects in every crime, and sues to end the practice, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(10)
Original text
Leslie v. City of New York, Memorandum and Order
Relevant passage: No. 22 Civ. 2305 (NRB), ECF No. 164, March 20, 2026
About this source
The district court's 44-page decision granting the City summary judgment on Shakira Leslie's Fourth Amendment claim over the collection, testing and indexing of her DNA from a cup, and declining jurisdiction over her claim under New York's DNA databank law. The copy is posted by the Juvenile Law Center.
- Author
- Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
How Police Hoard Our DNA in Rogue Databases
Relevant passage: Rights This Way podcast, season 5, episode 10, November 12, 2026
About this source
An NYCLU podcast episode and transcript with NYU law professor Erin Murphy and NYCLU lawyer Beth Haroules on the NYPD's DNA collection practices, with links to the NYCLU's amicus brief in the Second Circuit appeal.
- Author
- New York Civil Liberties Union
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Leslie v. City of New York, Brief and Special Appendix for Plaintiff-Appellant
Relevant passage: No. 26-950 (2d Cir.), docket entry 46.1, July 23, 2026
About this source
Leslie's opening brief in the Second Circuit asks the court to reverse the district court's judgment for the City, arguing that the Suspect Index exists outside any statute and that collecting and indexing her DNA were Fourth Amendment searches. The copy is posted by the Juvenile Law Center.
- Author
- The Legal Aid Society, Special Litigation Unit
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Legal Aid Files Class Action Civil Lawsuit Against the City's Illegal and Orwellian DNA Collection and Storage Practices
Relevant passage: Press release, March 22, 2022
About this source
The Legal Aid Society announces its class action against the City, the NYPD and the Office of Chief Medical Examiner over the Suspect Index and quotes attorneys Phil Desgranges, Lisa Freeman and Dave Pollock.
- Author
- The Legal Aid Society
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
NYPD accused of secretly collecting DNA from thousands of New Yorkers for "rogue" database
Relevant passage: News article, March 22, 2022
About this source
CBS News reports the filing of the Legal Aid Society's class action and carries statements from the city Law Department, the Office of Chief Medical Examiner and NYPD spokesperson Sgt. Edward Riley defending the database and the department's DNA collection.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Legal Aid, NYCLU issue briefs in appeals case that NYPD's DNA database is unconstitutional
Relevant passage: News article, July 31, 2026
About this source
amNewYork reports on Leslie's opening brief and the NYCLU amicus brief in the Second Circuit, summarizes the City's arguments and Judge Buchwald's ruling, and says the NYPD did not respond to a request for comment before publication.
- Author
- Max Parrott
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
LDF Files Amicus Brief Challenging NYPD's Practice of Secretly Taking DNA from New Yorkers
Relevant passage: Press release, July 31, 2026
About this source
The Legal Defense Fund announces its amicus brief urging the Second Circuit to reverse the district court, arguing that the NYPD's discretion in choosing whose DNA to collect falls most heavily on Black New Yorkers, and quotes assistant counsel Emahunn Campbell and fellow Mide Odunsi.
- Author
- Legal Defense Fund
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Brief of Amici Curiae American Civil Liberties Union, New York Civil Liberties Union, and Cato Institute in Support of Plaintiff-Appellant and Reversal
Relevant passage: Leslie v. City of New York, No. 26-950 (2d Cir.), docket entry 52, July 30, 2026
About this source
The amicus brief argues that the Suspect Index violates New York's DNA databank law and that the warrantless collection, analysis and indexing of DNA from discarded items violates the Fourth Amendment, and disputes the district court's reliance on Maryland v. King.
- Author
- American Civil Liberties Union, New York Civil Liberties Union and Cato Institute
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Civil Liberties Groups File Amicus Brief Opposing NYPD's Illegal, Secret Seizure and Storage of DNA
Relevant passage: Press release, July 30, 2026
About this source
The ACLU's release on the joint amicus brief says the Suspect Index holds DNA samples from more than 34,000 people and quotes Vera Eidelman of the ACLU's Speech, Privacy, and Technology Project and Matthew Cavedon of the Cato Institute.
- Author
- American Civil Liberties Union
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Civil Liberties Groups File Amicus Brief Opposing NYPD's Illegal, Secret Seizure and Storage of DNA
Relevant passage: Press release, July 30, 2026
About this source
The NYCLU announces the amicus brief it filed with the ACLU and the Cato Institute in the Second Circuit appeal, describes how the NYPD collects DNA from items used in interview rooms, and quotes Beth Haroules, its director of disability justice litigation.
- Author
- New York Civil Liberties Union
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Judge upholds the NYPD's collection of DNA from discarded items for New York City's Suspect Index; Legal Aid appeals, backed by NYCLU, ACLU and Cato
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/nypd-suspect-index-dna-database-leslie-appeal
The Dispute Index. "Judge upholds the NYPD's collection of DNA from discarded items for New York City's Suspect Index; Legal Aid appeals, backed by NYCLU, ACLU and Cato". First published: 2026-11-18. Last updated: 2026-11-18. https://disputeindex.com/cases/nypd-suspect-index-dna-database-leslie-appeal