Cato's Matthew Cavedon calls the NYPD's DNA collection for the Suspect Index an affront to privacy
Matthew CavedonDirector of the Project on Criminal Justice at the Cato Institute, in a joint news release with the ACLU and the NYCLU
Cavedon says the secret collection of DNA for the Suspect Index is an affront to privacy and the presumption of innocence that tens of thousands of New Yorkers have already suffered.
Responding to
The NYPD's practice of collecting DNA from items that suspects use or discard and adding the profiles to the Suspect Index without a warrant violates the Fourth Amendment and New York State law.
“The secret, dragnet collection of DNA for inclusion on a 'Suspect Index' sounds dystopian. Yet it's an affront to privacy and the presumption of innocence tens of thousands of New Yorkers have already suffered.”
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
Official statement

Where this statement fits
Judge upholds the NYPD's collection of DNA from discarded items for New York City's Suspect Index; Legal Aid appeals, backed by NYCLU, ACLU and Cato
New York City's Office of Chief Medical Examiner keeps a local DNA database known as the Suspect Index, built from DNA that the NYPD collects from people it suspects of crimes, often from cups, cigarettes or other items they use during police interviews. The ACLU says the index holds DNA samples from more than 34,000 people, including children and people who have never been charged with a crime. In March 2022, the Legal Aid Society filed a class action on behalf of Shakira Leslie, whose DNA, according to court papers, police took from a cup of water she was given after waiting 12 hours for food or water in custody. On March 20, 2026, Judge Naomi Reice Buchwald of the Southern District of New York granted the City summary judgment, ruling that Leslie had no reasonable expectation of privacy in the disposable cup, so no Fourth Amendment search occurred. She declined to decide whether the index violates New York's DNA databank law. Leslie's lawyers appealed to the Second Circuit and filed their opening brief on July 23, 2026. The ACLU, the New York Civil Liberties Union and the Cato Institute filed an amicus brief on July 30, and the Legal Defense Fund filed one on July 31. In 2022, the medical examiner's office said the database complies with all applicable laws, and the NYPD said its DNA collection is guided by what the law authorizes.
Source and context
Official statement
About this source
The ACLU's release on the joint amicus brief says the Suspect Index holds DNA samples from more than 34,000 people and quotes Vera Eidelman of the ACLU's Speech, Privacy, and Technology Project and Matthew Cavedon of the Cato Institute.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Before the quotation
The release said the brief argues that the Suspect Index violates state law, and that the index includes people excluded as suspects, arrestees never convicted of a crime, and people who were exonerated or acquitted.
After the quotation
Cavedon ends the statement by saying the Fourth Amendment protects against the collection and that he hopes the Second Circuit will too.
How this statement is classified
The label describes this statement's response within the context above.
Why this label?
Cavedon calls the secret DNA collection for the Suspect Index dystopian and an affront to privacy and the presumption of innocence, so we labeled it Condemned.
- Recorded on
- Published here
- People and groups discussed
- New York City Police Department
More from this case
Read the full caseLegal Defense Fund says the NYPD secretly put Shakira Leslie on a list she could not contest
Legal Defense Fund
“The NYPD secretively took Shakira Leslie's DNA and placed her on a list she could not know of and had no means to contest.”Read statement
NYCLU says the NYPD's DNA database targets Black and brown New Yorkers and violates the Fourth Amendment
New York Civil Liberties Union
“No New Yorker should have their DNA taken illegally and stored in a secret database. This destructive practice disproportionately targets Black and brown New Yorkers and violates our Fourth Amendment rights. No court should allow this intrusion on our privacy.”Read statement
ACLU's Vera Eidelman says the government cannot seize, search and store people's DNA without a warrant
American Civil Liberties Union
“The government cannot treat our DNA like it treats our garbage, and seize, search, and store it without a warrant”Read statement
Share or embed this statement
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Cato's Matthew Cavedon calls the NYPD's DNA collection for the Suspect Index an affront to privacy
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/events/9666-cavedon-says-the-secret-collection-of-dna-for
Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.
The Dispute Index. "Cato's Matthew Cavedon calls the NYPD's DNA collection for the Suspect Index an affront to privacy". First published: 2026-11-18. Last updated: 2026-11-18. https://disputeindex.com/events/9666-cavedon-says-the-secret-collection-of-dna-for