Bernie Moreno asks an appeals court to end Cleveland's police consent decree after a judge refused the city and Justice Department's request

Cleveland and the Justice Department asked a federal judge to end the city's 2015 police consent decree, and Judge Solomon Oliver Jr. refused. Sen. Bernie Moreno now urges the appeals court to end it; the city's police commission says the reforms are unfinished.

Case period:

Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated

Justin BibbUnited States Department of JusticeBernie Moreno

Where it stands

Active

As of

Established

Overview

The 2015 settlement agreement, known as the consent decree, followed a Justice Department investigation that found Cleveland police officers used unnecessary and unreasonable force at a significant rate. A court-appointed monitoring team assesses the city's progress. Under its terms, the decree ends once the city has been in substantial and effective compliance for two consecutive years (one year for the search and seizure provisions). In 2025, President Donald Trump's administration ordered a review of police consent decrees nationwide.

People in this case

Timeline

6 timeline entries on this page. Dates: June 12, 2015 to November 10, 2026

  1. June 2015

    1. Judge approves Cleveland's police settlement agreement

      After a hearing on the joint motion of the Justice Department and the City of Cleveland, Judge Solomon Oliver Jr. found the settlement agreement's terms fair and entered it. The agreement followed a Justice Department investigation that found Cleveland officers used unnecessary and unreasonable force at a significant rate.

  2. February 2026

    1. Cleveland and the Justice Department ask the court to end the decree

      Claim

      The city and the department filed a joint motion to terminate the settlement agreement, arguing that the city and its police division had achieved substantial compliance and a durable remedy. Mayor Justin Bibb announced the request at a City Hall news conference.

  3. May 2026

    1. Oliver denies the request to end the decree

      In a 74-page order, Oliver called the motion premature. He found that 53 of the 174 paragraphs the monitor had formally assessed (30%) had reached substantial and effective compliance, and that the city had not shown the changed circumstances needed for relief.

  4. July 2026

  5. November 2026

    1. Moreno files a brief urging the appeals court to end the decree

      Reaction

      Sen. Bernie Moreno's attorney, Philip Williamson, filed a friend-of-the-court brief asking the 6th Circuit to vacate Oliver's ruling. It argues that the decree is too costly for the city and that the judge overstepped by keeping in place a settlement both parties want to end.

Claims

Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.

What's disputed

United States Department of Justice

Cleveland and its police division have achieved substantial compliance with the 2015 settlement agreement and a durable remedy, so the agreement should end.

What is disputed

The city and the Justice Department made this argument in their joint motion of February 19, 2026. Oliver found that 53 of the 174 paragraphs the monitor had formally assessed (30%) had reached substantial and effective compliance, and that none of the 152 paragraphs not yet formally assessed had. Bibb said the city had not met every requirement of the decree but had reached a milestone that justified local control. The Community Police Commission says reform is measured by whether it lasts, not by benchmarks met for a time.

Sources (3)

Bernie Moreno

The district court exceeded its authority by refusing to end a settlement agreement that both the Justice Department and the City of Cleveland want to end.

What is disputed

Moreno's friend-of-the-court brief, filed by his attorney Philip Williamson in the 6th Circuit, makes this argument and adds that the decree is too costly for the city. In his order, Oliver wrote that the city had not carried the heavy burden required for relief from a consent decree and that the parties had not shown changed circumstances that would warrant it. Attorney Lisa Blatt is to file the brief defending the order in January.

Sources (2)

Response record

Responses

Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.

No responses match these filters.

Clear response filters

Sources

(8)

Original text

Order denying the joint motion to terminate the settlement agreement, United States v. City of Cleveland, No. 1:15-cv-1046 (N.D. Ohio)

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: ECF No. 708, pages 71 to 73

About this source

Judge Solomon Oliver Jr.'s 74-page order denying the motion filed jointly by the City of Cleveland and the U.S. Justice Department in February 2026 to end the 2015 police settlement agreement. It finds that 53 of the 174 formally assessed paragraphs (30%) had reached substantial and effective compliance and calls the motion premature. The copy was posted by Signal Cleveland.

Author
Judge Solomon Oliver Jr., U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Ohio
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

U.S. Department of Justice to appeal ruling that kept Cleveland police reforms in place

About this source

News 5 Cleveland report that Assistant Attorney General Harmeet Dhillon filed a one-page notice of appeal to the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals challenging Judge Oliver's May ruling. The notice gives no reasons.

Author
Sarah Buduson, News 5 Cleveland
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Official statement

CPC Calls for Strong Local Accountability as Consent Decree Appeal Moves Forward

About this source

Statement posted by the Cleveland Community Police Commission after the Justice Department appealed Judge Oliver's ruling. The commission quotes the order, says it shares the judge's concern about areas without sustained compliance and calls for local accountability systems that last after federal oversight ends.

Author
Cleveland Community Police Commission
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Federal judge denies request to end police consent decree, calling it 'premature'

About this source

Signal Cleveland report on Judge Oliver's May 8, 2026 order, with a statement from Mayor Justin Bibb and a comment from Community Police Commission co-chair John Adams.

Author
Frank W. Lewis, Signal Cleveland
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Federal judge surprised by Cleveland and Justice Department move to end police consent decree, won't rule on it yet

About this source

Signal Cleveland report on the February 20, 2026 status hearing, the day after the joint motion. It quotes Judge Oliver, monitor Christine Cole, Justice Department attorney Jonas Geissler and city ethics officer Delante Thomas.

Author
Nick Castele and Frank W. Lewis, Signal Cleveland
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Cleveland moves to end federal oversight of police after more than a decade

About this source

Signal Cleveland report on the joint motion and Mayor Justin Bibb's City Hall news conference, where he said the city had not met every requirement of the decree but should take back local control. It quotes former Cleveland law director Subodh Chandra's open letter opposing the move and other police reform advocates.

Author
Nick Castele and Frank W. Lewis, Signal Cleveland
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

US Sen. Bernie Moreno urges appeals court to end Cleveland police consent decree

About this source

Cleveland.com report on the friend-of-the-court brief Moreno's attorney, Philip Williamson, filed in the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. It quotes the brief's argument that the consent decree is too costly and that the district judge overstepped by keeping in place a settlement both parties want to end, and notes the briefing schedule for the city and for Lisa Blatt, who will defend the judge's order.

Author
Adam Ferrise, cleveland.com
Published
Accessed

Official statement

Moreno Applauds Trump Administration for Filing to End Cleveland Consent Decree

About this source

Press release from Sen. Bernie Moreno's office issued the day the city and the Justice Department asked the court to end the consent decree. It quotes Moreno and lists his earlier letters to Attorney General Pam Bondi and his 2025 bar complaint against the former monitor, Karl Racine.

Author
Office of Sen. Bernie Moreno
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Case updates

Want the next important update?

Follow this case and get an email when an important development changes the record.

14 updates added in the last 7 days.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

The newsletter

Follow disputes like this one.

New cases and significant updates to the record, in your inbox. Free.

You’ll confirm your subscription on Substack.

Share or embed this case

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Bernie Moreno asks an appeals court to end Cleveland's police consent decree after a judge refused the city and Justice Department's request
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/cases/cleveland-police-consent-decree-appeal

The Dispute Index. "Bernie Moreno asks an appeals court to end Cleveland's police consent decree after a judge refused the city and Justice Department's request". First published: 2026-11-20. Last updated: 2026-11-20. https://disputeindex.com/cases/cleveland-police-consent-decree-appeal