New Jersey sues DHS, saying it has stonewalled a state subpoena on detainee care at Delaney Hall for three months; DHS says ICE is committed to transparency
New Jersey's attorney general says DHS has gone three months without deciding whether the operator of Delaney Hall may answer a state subpoena on detainees' medical care. GEO Group says ICE must approve; DHS says ICE is committed to transparency.

Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Where it stands
ActiveAs of
Established
- New Jersey sued DHS, ICE, Secretary Markwayne Mullin and ICE official David Venturella in federal court in Washington on November 17, 2026, under the Administrative Procedure Act.Complaint, Davenport v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-04064 (D.D.C.), with exhibits (opens in a new tab)New Jersey Office of the Attorney General: Attorney General Davenport Sues DHS For Failing to Respond to Subpoena in Delaney Hall Civil Rights Investigation (opens in a new tab)
- GEO Group declined the state's August 2026 subpoena, saying records from its work for ICE need the agency's review and approval.Complaint, Davenport v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-04064 (D.D.C.), with exhibits (opens in a new tab)
- New Jersey wrote to DHS on September 29 and October 20, 2026, asking it to decide whether GEO Group may produce the records.Complaint, Davenport v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-04064 (D.D.C.), with exhibits (opens in a new tab)Jersey Vindicator: NJ attorney general sues Department of Homeland Security over Delaney Hall records (opens in a new tab)
Disputed
- New Jersey says DHS's silence is stonewalling that unlawfully delays its investigation. A DHS spokesperson said ICE is committed to transparency and is regularly audited and inspected.New Jersey Office of the Attorney General: Attorney General Davenport Sues DHS For Failing to Respond to Subpoena in Delaney Hall Civil Rights Investigation (opens in a new tab)ABC News: NJ sues to compel ICE facility operator to comply with subpoena in medical probe (opens in a new tab)See the claim
- New Jersey cites reports of inadequate medical care and three deaths. DHS says detainees receive proper meals, water, blankets and medical treatment.Complaint, Davenport v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-04064 (D.D.C.), with exhibits (opens in a new tab)ABC News: NJ sues to compel ICE facility operator to comply with subpoena in medical probe (opens in a new tab)See the claim
- GEO Group calls the state's investigation unlawful and a breach of the Supremacy Clause. New Jersey says a private business on its own property can comply without federal approval.Complaint, Davenport v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-04064 (D.D.C.), with exhibits (opens in a new tab)New Jersey Office of the Attorney General: Attorney General Davenport Sues DHS For Failing to Respond to Subpoena in Delaney Hall Civil Rights Investigation (opens in a new tab)See the claim
Not yet known
- Whether DHS will authorize GEO Group to produce any of the subpoenaed records.
- How DHS will answer the lawsuit in court.
Overview
New Jersey opened its civil rights investigation on August 7, 2026, after at least three people died after being held at Delaney Hall, a detention center in Newark owned and run by GEO Group under an ICE contract (New Jersey Office of the Attorney General (opens in a new tab)). The complaint cites an internal ICE review that found medical staff failed to recognize signs of cardiac arrest in Jean Wilson Brutus, who died on December 12, 2025, less than a day after he arrived. It also describes the death of Edwin Jovanny Lopez-Cornejo on August 1, 2026, and the case of Jose Chajon-Raxon, who was taken from the facility to a hospital in July; a Homeland Security spokesperson told the Jersey Vindicator that ICE had released Chajon-Raxon before he died (Jersey Vindicator (opens in a new tab)).
The state asks the court to give DHS seven days to tell New Jersey and GEO Group whether the company may produce the records. According to the complaint, an ICE inspection in September found 22 deficiencies under federal detention standards. A separate state lawsuit, filed in June, seeks full access to the facility for state health inspectors and is still pending (Jersey Vindicator (opens in a new tab); ABC News (opens in a new tab)).
People in this case
Robert Menendez Jr.Commented
Timeline
6 timeline entries on this page. Dates: August 7, 2026 to November 17, 2026
August 2026
New Jersey opens a civil rights investigation of Delaney Hall and subpoenas GEO Group
The attorney general and the Division on Civil Rights open an investigation into the treatment of detainees at Delaney Hall and serve GEO Group with a subpoena for records on medical care, due August 21.
GEO Group declines service of the subpoena
Reaction
On the day the records were due, GEO Group's lawyers write that the requested documents are federal records covered by DHS rules and decline service of the subpoena.
September 2026
GEO Group's lawyer says the company is not the proper party
Reaction
A letter from GEO Group's lawyer says records on confinement and health care need ICE's review and approval and calls the state's investigation unlawful.
New Jersey asks DHS to decide on the records request
The state sends DHS and ICE a copy of the subpoena, asks whether GEO Group forwarded it and requests an answer by October 7.
October 2026
New Jersey sends DHS a second letter
Investigators write to DHS again, describe evidence from witness statements and medical records, and ask for a decision by November 5.
November 2026
New Jersey sues DHS in federal court
The attorney general files suit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, asking the court to find that DHS unreasonably delayed its decision and to set a deadline for one.
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Jennifer DavenportThe Department of Homeland Security has unreasonably delayed deciding whether GEO Group may produce records subpoenaed in New Jersey's civil rights investigation of Delaney Hall, in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act.
What is disputed
New Jersey makes the claim in its November 17, 2026 complaint, which says DHS did not answer letters the state sent on September 29 and October 20. GEO Group says the records need ICE's review and approval and that it is not the proper party for the subpoena. A DHS spokesperson did not address the subpoena and said ICE is committed to transparency.
Sources (3)
- Complaint, Davenport v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-04064 (D.D.C.), with exhibitsComplaint paragraphs 76-104; Exhibit E (GEO Group letter of September 3, 2026)
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Jennifer DavenportDetainees at Delaney Hall have received inadequate medical care, including missed medication for chronic conditions and inadequate responses to medical emergencies.
What is disputed
New Jersey's complaint and press release describe reports gathered in the state's investigation and cite three deaths of people held at the facility. A DHS spokesperson said all detainees are provided with medical treatment and that the facility complies with all required state and local laws.
Sources (4)
- Complaint, Davenport v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-04064 (D.D.C.), with exhibitsComplaint paragraphs 76-104; Exhibit E (GEO Group letter of September 3, 2026)
In their own words
Their own account
Statements from the person or group whose act or claim this case is about. They are listed apart from the responses, and each label says what the speaker did with their own act or claim.
U.S. Department of Homeland SecurityFederal department that oversees ICE, in a statement from a spokesperson to ABC News"ICE is regularly audited and inspected by external agencies. ICE is committed to transparency, and the Delaney Hall detention facility complies with all required state and local laws. All detainees are provided with proper meals, quality water, blankets, medical treatment, and have opportunities to communicate with their family members and lawyers."
Stood by itResponding to: Detainees at Delaney Hall have received inadequate medical care, including missed medication for chronic conditions and inadequate responses to medical emergencies.
Full statement and sources
A Homeland Security spokesperson says ICE is regularly audited and inspected by outside agencies and is committed to transparency, and that Delaney Hall complies with all required state and local laws, with detainees given proper meals, water, blankets and medical treatment.
Before the statement
New Jersey's complaint says DHS has not authorized GEO Group to produce any information and has refused even to confirm whether it will.
After the statement
ABC News noted that a separate lawsuit by the attorney general's office, filed in June, accuses GEO Group of refusing to give state health inspectors full access to Delaney Hall.
Why this label?
The department defends ICE's record at Delaney Hall, saying the agency is committed to transparency and that detainees receive proper meals and medical treatment, so we labeled it Stood by.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
The GEO GroupPrivate prison company that runs Delaney Hall, in a September 3, 2026 letter from its lawyer Geoffrey S. Brounell of Davis Wright Tremaine "Further, requests for written documentation regarding confinement or healthcare services are not within GEO's immediate authority to approve and necessitate review and approval by ICE. GEO is not the proper party for this subpoena."
Stood by itResponding to: The Department of Homeland Security has unreasonably delayed deciding whether GEO Group may produce records subpoenaed in New Jersey's civil rights investigation of Delaney Hall, in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act.
Full statement and sources
In a letter from its lawyer, GEO Group says records on confinement or health care at Delaney Hall need ICE's review and approval, says the company is not the proper party for the subpoena and calls the state's investigation unlawful, discriminatory and a breach of the Supremacy Clause.
Before the statement
New Jersey's attorney general and civil rights director served GEO Group with a subpoena that was due on August 21, 2026. That day, GEO Group's lawyer wrote that the requested documents were federal records subject to DHS rules and declined service of the subpoena, and the state wrote back on August 27.
After the statement
In the same letter, GEO Group's lawyer confirmed that the company had complied with its obligations under section 5.43 of DHS's regulations and said it would preserve all information and documents in its possession.
Complaint, Davenport v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-04064 (D.D.C.), with exhibitsComplaint paragraphs 76-104; Exhibit E (GEO Group letter of September 3, 2026)Why this label?
GEO Group keeps to its refusal to produce the records without ICE's approval and calls the state's investigation unlawful, so we labeled it Stood by.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
2 responses. Newest first.
Robert Menendez Jr.Democratic U.S. representative from New Jersey's 8th District, in a post on Bluesky"I’m glad to see @NewJerseyOAG suing DHS over its delays in the Delaney Hall investigation. ICE’s obstruction comes as no surprise. After more than 20 visits inside, I’ve witnessed the severe medical neglect and unconscionable conditions firsthand."
CondemnedResponding to: The Department of Homeland Security has unreasonably delayed deciding whether GEO Group may produce records subpoenaed in New Jersey's civil rights investigation of Delaney Hall, in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act.
Full statement and sources
Menendez says he is glad New Jersey is suing DHS over its delays in the Delaney Hall investigation, calls ICE's obstruction no surprise and says that in more than 20 visits he has seen severe medical neglect and unconscionable conditions.
Before the statement
New Jersey sued DHS on Tuesday, November 17. In August, Menendez made public the death of Jose Chajon-Raxon, who had been taken from Delaney Hall to a hospital in July.
After the statement
In a second post in the same thread, Menendez said he would keep working in Congress to end private detention and shut down facilities like Delaney Hall.
Why this label?
Menendez calls ICE's response to the state's investigation obstruction and says he has seen severe medical neglect at the facility, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Jennifer DavenportAttorney General of New Jersey, in a press release announcing the lawsuit "There are far too many reports of inhumane treatment of the people held at Delaney Hall. But what we have received for months from both GEO Group and DHS is plain stonewalling"
CondemnedResponding to: The Department of Homeland Security has unreasonably delayed deciding whether GEO Group may produce records subpoenaed in New Jersey's civil rights investigation of Delaney Hall, in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act.
Full statement and sources
Davenport says there are far too many reports of inhumane treatment of people held at Delaney Hall and that what New Jersey has received from GEO Group and DHS for months is plain stonewalling. She says the state will keep working to see that the detainees are treated with dignity and decency.
Before the statement
New Jersey's Division on Civil Rights issued an investigative subpoena to GEO Group in August. GEO Group has said it cannot respond without DHS's permission, and the state says DHS has failed to respond for over three months.
After the statement
Division on Civil Rights Director Yolanda N. Melville said in the same release that the federal government's silence in response to the state's requests for information speaks volumes.
Why this label?
Davenport says DHS and GEO Group have stonewalled the state's requests for months and points to reports of inhumane treatment at the facility, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(5)
Original text
Complaint, Davenport v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security, No. 1:26-cv-04064 (D.D.C.), with exhibits
Relevant passage: Complaint paragraphs 76-104; Exhibit E (GEO Group letter of September 3, 2026)
About this source
Complaint filed on November 17, 2026 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia by New Jersey's attorney general and civil rights director against DHS, ICE, Secretary Markwayne Mullin and ICE official David Venturella. The exhibits include the state's subpoena, letters from GEO Group's lawyers dated August 21 and September 3, 2026, and the state's letters to DHS.
- Author
- New Jersey Office of the Attorney General
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Rep. Rob Menendez on Bluesky: New Jersey's lawsuit over the Delaney Hall investigation
Relevant passage: Post text
About this source
Post by Rep. Rob Menendez on the night New Jersey filed its lawsuit, followed in the same thread by a post saying he will keep working in Congress to end private detention and shut down facilities like Delaney Hall.
- Author
- Rob Menendez
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Jersey Vindicator: NJ attorney general sues Department of Homeland Security over Delaney Hall records
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Jersey Vindicator report on the lawsuit, the state's August subpoena and its September and October letters to DHS, the three deaths described in the complaint, and an ICE inspection in September that found 22 deficiencies under federal detention standards.
- Author
- Krystal Knapp
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
ABC News: NJ sues to compel ICE facility operator to comply with subpoena in medical probe
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
ABC News report, carried by the Everett Post, quoting the complaint and giving the full text of a Department of Homeland Security spokesperson's statement on Delaney Hall.
- Author
- ABC News
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
New Jersey Office of the Attorney General: Attorney General Davenport Sues DHS For Failing to Respond to Subpoena in Delaney Hall Civil Rights Investigation
Relevant passage: Press release text
About this source
Press release of November 17, 2026 announcing New Jersey's federal lawsuit against DHS, with statements from Attorney General Jennifer Davenport and Division on Civil Rights Director Yolanda N. Melville and a summary of the state's subpoena to GEO Group.
- Author
- New Jersey Office of the Attorney General
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- New Jersey sues DHS, saying it has stonewalled a state subpoena on detainee care at Delaney Hall for three months; DHS says ICE is committed to transparency
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/new-jersey-dhs-delaney-hall-subpoena-lawsuit
The Dispute Index. "New Jersey sues DHS, saying it has stonewalled a state subpoena on detainee care at Delaney Hall for three months; DHS says ICE is committed to transparency". First published: 2026-11-18. Last updated: 2026-11-18. https://disputeindex.com/cases/new-jersey-dhs-delaney-hall-subpoena-lawsuit