Laurent Nuñez accuses La France insoumise of organizing 'la chienlit' after Pierre-Yves Cadalen challenges a Brest police seizure of student photos
Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez accused La France insoumise of organizing "la chienlit" in the high-school protests after LFI deputy Pierre-Yves Cadalen called a Brest police seizure of students' names and photos mass profiling. Brest's prosecutor says it was not profiling.
Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Where it stands
ActiveAs of
Established
- Police collected the names and photos of thousands of students at three high schools on Brest's Kerichen campus on November 4, under a judicial requisition.Un député LFI dénonce une démarche abusive après la saisie de trombinoscopes par la police dans des lycées à Brest (opens in a new tab)Trombinoscopes saisis dans des lycées de Brest: le parquet réfute tout "fichage" (opens in a new tab)
- The Brest prosecutor says the requisition belongs to an investigation into violence against police near the city's police station on October 17.Trombinoscopes saisis dans des lycées de Brest: le parquet réfute tout "fichage" (opens in a new tab)
- In the National Assembly on November 18, Nuñez told LFI deputies the French would never forgive them for the disorder he said they were organizing.Compte rendu intégral de la première séance du mercredi 18 novembre 2026, Assemblée nationale (questions au gouvernement) (opens in a new tab)Mouvement lycéen: Laurent Nuñez accuse les élus insoumis d'organiser "la chienlit", LFI dénonce les "pires foutaises" (opens in a new tab)
Disputed
- Whether LFI is organizing disorder in the high-school protests: Nuñez says it is, while Cadalen calls the government's portrayal of LFI false and says the minister is threatening the opposition.Compte rendu intégral de la première séance du mercredi 18 novembre 2026, Assemblée nationale (questions au gouvernement) (opens in a new tab)Pierre-Yves Cadalen on X: "Le ministre de l'intérieur nous menace sur la base d'enquêtes judiciaires en cours" (opens in a new tab)See the claim
- Whether the seizure amounts to profiling of students: Cadalen, students, parents and unions say it does, while the Brest prosecutor says it is a lawful investigative step.Un député LFI dénonce une démarche abusive après la saisie de trombinoscopes par la police dans des lycées à Brest (opens in a new tab)Trombinoscopes saisis dans des lycées de Brest: le parquet réfute tout "fichage" (opens in a new tab)See the claim
Not yet known
- Whether the CNIL will examine the seizure, and how long the students' data will be kept.Un député LFI dénonce une démarche abusive après la saisie de trombinoscopes par la police dans des lycées à Brest (opens in a new tab)
- Whether the judicial investigations Nuñez mentioned concern anyone connected to LFI.Compte rendu intégral de la première séance du mercredi 18 novembre 2026, Assemblée nationale (questions au gouvernement) (opens in a new tab)
Overview
"La chienlit" is the term Charles de Gaulle used for the May 1968 student unrest, and BFMTV notes that Emmanuel Macron used it in June 2024 when he dissolved the National Assembly. The Brest seizure came during a high-school protest movement in which the Kerichen campus was the center of protests in the city. According to the Brest prosecutor, about 200 mostly young people attacked police officers near the Brest police station on October 17, injuring 58 of them.
People in this case
Laurent NuñezDirectly involved
Pierre-Yves CadalenDirectly involved
Timeline
7 timeline entries on this page. Dates: October 17, 2026 to November 18, 2026
October 2026
Clashes near the Brest police station leave 58 officers injured
Incident
According to the Brest prosecutor, about 200 mostly young people attacked police officers near the city's police station during the October 17 protests. He said 58 officers were hurt, some with up to 45 days of incapacity for work.
November 2026
Police collect photo directories at three Brest high schools
Incident
Two plainclothes officers present a judicial requisition at the three high schools of Brest's Kerichen campus and collect the names and photos of their students, without warning the principals beforehand.
Students, parents and teachers rally against the seizure in Brest
Reaction
About 200 students, parents and teachers gather at the Kerichen campus to denounce what they call the profiling of high-school students.
Cadalen says he will take the seizure to France's data-protection authority
Reaction
Pierre-Yves Cadalen says the seizure is clearly abusive, raises the protection of minors' personal data and announces that he is referring it to the CNIL. A Brest lawyer from the Syndicat des avocats de France also questions whether it was necessary.
Brest prosecutor says the seizure is not profiling
Reaction
Prosecutor Stéphane Kellenberger says the requisition belongs to an investigation into the October 17 violence against police, that it is a legal procedure and not profiling, and that only material linking specific people to those events will be kept.
Nuñez accuses LFI of organizing disorder during questions to the government
Claim
Asked by Cadalen about the Brest seizure, Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez tells him to be careful about ongoing judicial investigations into people who may have incited young people to violence, then says the French will never forgive LFI deputies for the disorder he says they are organizing.
Cadalen says the minister is threatening the opposition
Reaction
In a post on X, Cadalen says Nuñez threatened LFI on the basis of ongoing judicial investigations and calls it open political repression of the opposition.
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Laurent NuñezLa France insoumise is organizing disorder in the high-school protest movement.
What is disputed
Nuñez made the accusation in the National Assembly in answer to Cadalen, after saying that ongoing judicial investigations concern people who may have incited young people to violence or supplied them with equipment. Cadalen said the government was falsely portraying LFI as a supplier of firework mortars and that the minister was threatening the opposition with ongoing investigations.
Sources (3)
- Compte rendu intégral de la première séance du mercredi 18 novembre 2026, Assemblée nationale (questions au gouvernement)Questions to the government: "Mobilisation lycéenne et libertés publiques", Pierre-Yves Cadalen's question and Laurent Nuñez's answers
- Pierre-Yves Cadalen on X: "Le ministre de l'intérieur nous menace sur la base d'enquêtes judiciaires en cours"Post quoting LCP's clip of Nuñez's answer
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Pierre-Yves CadalenThe Brest police seizure of high-school students' names and photos amounts to mass profiling of students taking part in the protest movement.
What is disputed
Cadalen, along with students, parents and unions in Brest, describes the seizure as profiling and says the data of minors must be deleted. Brest prosecutor Stéphane Kellenberger says the judicial requisition belongs to a criminal investigation into the October 17 violence against police and that only material linking specific people to those events will be kept.
Sources (3)
- Compte rendu intégral de la première séance du mercredi 18 novembre 2026, Assemblée nationale (questions au gouvernement)Questions to the government: "Mobilisation lycéenne et libertés publiques", Pierre-Yves Cadalen's question and Laurent Nuñez's answers
- Trombinoscopes saisis dans des lycées de Brest: le parquet réfute tout "fichage" · BFMTVFull article
In their own words
Their own account
Statements from the person or group whose act or claim this case is about. They are listed apart from the responses, and each label says what the speaker did with their own act or claim.
Laurent NuñezFrench minister of the interior, answering a question in the National Assembly"The French will never forgive you for the mayhem you are organizing. They are attached to republican order, the very order that the government upholds despite your incessant provocations! (Translated from French. Original: Les Français ne vous pardonneront jamais la chienlit que vous organisez. Ils sont attachés à l'ordre républicain, celui-là même que le gouvernement fait régner en dépit de vos provocations incessantes !)"
Stood by itResponding to: La France insoumise is organizing disorder in the high-school protest movement.
Full statement and sources
Answering Cadalen in the National Assembly, Nuñez said he was not ashamed to enforce the principles of the Republic and public order. He told LFI deputies that the French would never forgive them for the disorder he said they were organizing, despite what he called their constant provocations.
Before the statement
Cadalen had asked about the Brest police seizure of students' names and photos and accused the government of lying about LFI. Nuñez first said students who declare their marches and keep to the agreed route can protest without incident, and that Cadalen should be careful about the outcome of ongoing judicial investigations into people who may have incited young people to violence or supplied them with equipment. When Cadalen asked whether he was ashamed, Nuñez said he was not ashamed to enforce the principles of the Republic and of public order.
After the statement
Deputies from the EPR, DR and Democrat groups applauded and LFI deputies protested, according to the official record. BFMTV noted that the word chienlit echoes Charles de Gaulle's term for the May 1968 student unrest.
Compte rendu intégral de la première séance du mercredi 18 novembre 2026, Assemblée nationale (questions au gouvernement)Questions to the government: "Mobilisation lycéenne et libertés publiques", Pierre-Yves Cadalen's question and Laurent Nuñez's answersWhy this label?
Nuñez rejects Cadalen's criticism of the police response to the high-school protests, says the government is keeping order and accuses LFI of organizing the disorder, so we labeled it Stands by.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Parquet de BrestPublic prosecutor's office in Brest, in a written statement by prosecutor Stéphane Kellenberger "It is therefore neither 'profiling' nor the compiling of any list whatsoever, but a legal procedure, within the framework of the law, gathering evidence for and against. At the end, only the material that links a specific person to the events in question will be kept in this procedure (Translated from French. Original: Il ne s'agit donc ni d'un 'fichage', ni de la constitution de quelque listing que ce soit, mais d'une voie de droit, dans le cadre de la loi, à charge et à décharge. À l'issue, seuls les éléments permettant de rapprocher telle personne déterminée, avec les faits ici en cause, auront vocation à être conservés dans le cadre de cette procédure)"
Original-language text checked word for word against a linked source on . We did not check the English translation.
Stood by itResponding to: The Brest police seizure of high-school students' names and photos amounts to mass profiling of students taking part in the protest movement.
Full statement and sources
In a statement, Brest prosecutor Stéphane Kellenberger said the requisition of the names and photos of nearly 4,500 students at three Brest high schools was part of an investigation into the October 17 violence near the city's police station, in which 58 officers were injured. He said it was neither profiling nor the compiling of a list, and that only material linking specific people to those events would be kept.
Before the statement
The week before, two plainclothes officers had collected the photo directories of three high schools on Brest's Kerichen campus, presenting a judicial requisition without warning the principals, according to BFMTV. Students, parents and unions had denounced it as profiling at a rally on November 9.
After the statement
Kellenberger said the investigation concerns aggravated group violence with weapons by people with covered faces, offenses punishable by up to ten years in prison. Several unions said they would take the seizure to the CNIL, France's data-protection authority.
Trombinoscopes saisis dans des lycées de Brest: le parquet réfute tout "fichage" · BFMTVFull articleWhy this label?
The prosecutor's office defends its investigation, rejects the profiling charge and says the seizure follows the law, so we labeled it Stands by.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
2 responses. Newest first.
Pierre-Yves CadalenMember of the National Assembly for Finistère, La France insoumise, in a post on XDirectly involved"The interior minister is threatening us on the basis of ongoing judicial investigations. Completely off track. Political repression of the opposition, said openly. What a disgrace, and to think these people dare to call themselves republicans. (Translated from French. Original: Le ministre de l'intérieur nous menace sur la base d'enquêtes judiciaires en cours. Hors piste complet. La répression politique de l'opposition à mots ouverts. Quelle déchéance, et dire que ces gens osent se prétendre républicains.)"
Original-language text checked word for word against a linked source on . We did not check the English translation.
CondemnedResponding to: La France insoumise is organizing disorder in the high-school protest movement.
Full statement and sources
Later on November 18, Cadalen wrote that the interior minister had threatened LFI on the basis of ongoing judicial investigations and called it open political repression of the opposition. He called it a disgrace and said such people dare to call themselves republicans.
Before the statement
Cadalen's post quotes the parliamentary channel LCP's clip of Nuñez telling him, during questions to the government, that he would be very careful about the outcome of ongoing judicial investigations into people who may have incited young people to commit violence.
After the statement
Earlier that day, in the National Assembly, Cadalen had asked the government about the Brest police seizure of high-school students' photo directories, and Nuñez had accused LFI deputies of organizing disorder in the high-school protest movement.
Pierre-Yves Cadalen on X: "Le ministre de l'intérieur nous menace sur la base d'enquêtes judiciaires en cours"Post quoting LCP's clip of Nuñez's answerWhy this label?
Cadalen calls Nuñez's warning about ongoing investigations a threat and open political repression of the opposition, so we labeled it Condemns.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Pierre-Yves CadalenMember of the National Assembly for Finistère, La France insoumise, asking a question in the chamberDirectly involved"You come up with the worst nonsense, recasting us as suppliers of firework mortars and accusing teachers of being accomplices. You are poisoning the press. (Translated from French. Original: Vous inventez les pires foutaises, en nous repeignant en fournisseurs de mortiers d'artifice et en accusant les enseignants d'être complices. Vous intoxiquez la presse.)"
DeniedResponding to: La France insoumise is organizing disorder in the high-school protest movement.
Full statement and sources
In his question to the government, Cadalen said the government invents an enemy within to hide its incompetence, falsely portrays LFI as a supplier of firework mortars, accuses teachers of complicity and misleads the press.
Before the statement
Cadalen opened his question by saying police in Brest had seized the names and photos of thousands of high-school students, called it mass profiling meant to deter the student protests, and said the data of minors must be deleted. He said the government spends its time inventing an enemy within to hide its incompetence.
After the statement
Cadalen asked whether the government acknowledged the profiling and condemned it. Nuñez answered that Cadalen should be careful about ongoing judicial investigations, and later told LFI deputies that the French would never forgive them for the disorder he said they were organizing.
Compte rendu intégral de la première séance du mercredi 18 novembre 2026, Assemblée nationale (questions au gouvernement)Questions to the government: "Mobilisation lycéenne et libertés publiques", Pierre-Yves Cadalen's question and Laurent Nuñez's answersWhy this label?
Cadalen calls the government's portrayal of LFI as a supplier of firework mortars nonsense and says it is misleading the press, so we labeled it Denies.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(5)
Original text
Compte rendu intégral de la première séance du mercredi 18 novembre 2026, Assemblée nationale (questions au gouvernement)
Relevant passage: Questions to the government: "Mobilisation lycéenne et libertés publiques", Pierre-Yves Cadalen's question and Laurent Nuñez's answers
About this source
The National Assembly's official record of the November 18, 2026 sitting. In the question titled "Mobilisation lycéenne et libertés publiques", Cadalen asks about a police seizure of students' names and photos at Brest high schools, and Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez answers twice.
- Author
- Assemblée nationale
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Un député LFI dénonce une démarche abusive après la saisie de trombinoscopes par la police dans des lycées à Brest
Relevant passage: Full article
About this source
Franceinfo reports that two plainclothes officers collected the photo directories of three high schools at Brest's Kerichen campus on November 4 under a judicial requisition, and that Cadalen said he would refer the matter to France's data-protection authority, the CNIL.
- Author
- franceinfo, with ICI Breizh Izel
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Trombinoscopes saisis dans des lycées de Brest: le parquet réfute tout "fichage"
Relevant passage: Full article
About this source
BFMTV quotes a statement by Brest prosecutor Stéphane Kellenberger on the seizure of student photo directories at the Kerichen high-school campus, which he links to an investigation into violence against police near the Brest police station on October 17.
- Author
- BFMTV
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Pierre-Yves Cadalen on X: "Le ministre de l'intérieur nous menace sur la base d'enquêtes judiciaires en cours"
About this source
Cadalen's post on the evening of November 18 quotes the parliamentary channel LCP's clip of Nuñez warning him about ongoing judicial investigations.
- Author
- Pierre-Yves Cadalen
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Mouvement lycéen: Laurent Nuñez accuse les élus insoumis d'organiser "la chienlit", LFI dénonce les "pires foutaises"
Relevant passage: Full article
About this source
BFMTV's report on the November 18 exchange quotes Nuñez and Cadalen as they spoke in the chamber. It notes that "la chienlit" echoes Charles de Gaulle's phrase about the May 1968 student movement.
- Author
- BFMTV
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Laurent Nuñez accuses La France insoumise of organizing 'la chienlit' after Pierre-Yves Cadalen challenges a Brest police seizure of student photos
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/nunez-lfi-chienlit-brest-student-photo-seizure
The Dispute Index. "Laurent Nuñez accuses La France insoumise of organizing 'la chienlit' after Pierre-Yves Cadalen challenges a Brest police seizure of student photos". First published: 2026-11-20. Last updated: 2026-11-20. https://disputeindex.com/cases/nunez-lfi-chienlit-brest-student-photo-seizure