Public disputes over how power is divided between the federal government and the states, including whether a state may regulate federal officers, agencies or programs.
Published coverage on this page: 4+ cases · 24+ statements. Statements are ordered newest first.
Topic updates
Follow this topic
Get free email updates about Federalism. We will email you when we add or correct a case in this topic.
Enable JavaScript to request email updates about this topic.
We will send a confirmation email first. Every update email has a link to stop. How we handle your email.
On November 9, 2026, the Ninth Circuit found California's climate-risk reporting law and its Scope 3 emissions rule likely unconstitutional but let direct-emissions reporting proceed. The U.S. Chamber called it a victory; Bonta's office and EDF defended the laws.
Role at the time: Professor of law at Lewis & Clark Law School, in an email to the Oregon Capital Chronicle
Mixed or conditional
Response to this claim
A state law barring immigration detention facilities in Oregon could not survive a challenge by the federal government.
“While it's understandable that Governor Kotek would want to pursue such a bill as a statement of Oregon's commitment to sanctuary status, I don't see any way in which this could survive a challenge by the federal government”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Gov. Kotek wants Oregon to ban immigration detention centers. Others have tried and failed.Oregon Capital Chronicle, November 10, 2026
Why we used this label
Yin calls Kotek's aim understandable but says the law could not survive a federal challenge, so we labeled it mixed.
Role at the time: Federal department, in a statement from an unnamed spokesperson quoted by the Oregon Capital Chronicle
Condemned
Response to this claim
A state law barring immigration detention facilities in Oregon could not survive a challenge by the federal government.
“makes it clear that sanctuary politicians do not control federal law enforcement”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Gov. Kotek wants Oregon to ban immigration detention centers. Others have tried and failed.Oregon Capital Chronicle, November 10, 2026
Why we used this label
Asked about Kotek's call, the department says the Supremacy Clause means sanctuary politicians do not control federal law enforcement, which disputes a state's power to bar federal detention, so we labeled it condemns.
Role at the time: Mayor of Houston, through a spokesperson in a written statement to Houston Public Media
Defended or excused
Statement summary
A spokesperson for Mayor John Whitmire says he stands by his executive order as the city's approach and that it accomplishes the city's goal. The spokesperson says adding its provisions to the city ordinance would put Houston at greater risk of violating state law, and calls the order and the proposed ordinance separate issues.
“The executive order accomplishes our goal ... One violates state law; one doesn't.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Houston Public Media: Houston Mayor Whitmire opposes effort to enshrine HPD-ICE executive order as an ordinanceArticle text
What this label refers to
Whitmire's office says the order achieves what the city wants and stands within state law, so we labeled it Defended or excused.
Role at the time: Attorney General of California and a defendant in the suit, in a statement from his office quoted by Reuters
Defended or excused
Statement summary
Bonta's office says it is pleased that part of the emissions disclosure law can be enforced, is evaluating its next steps, and is committed to protecting Californians' access to critical climate data.
“committed to protecting Californians' access to critical climate data in a changing world.”
The reference point is California's SB 253 and SB 261, which require large companies to disclose their greenhouse gas emissions and climate-related financial risks, and which the Ninth Circuit partly blocked on November 9, 2026. Bonta, who defends the laws in court, welcomes the part of the ruling that keeps emissions reporting in force and commits to protecting access to climate data, which defends the laws.
Role at the time: Business group and plaintiff, in a statement by Daryl Joseffer, president of the U.S. Chamber Litigation Center
Condemned
Response to this claim
California's SB 253 and SB 261 compel companies to speak on a contested subject and violate the First Amendment.
Quotation excerpt
“The injunction prevents the state from imposing massive compliance costs on companies, especially small businesses, and confirms that states cannot unilaterally impose sweeping, extraterritorial mandates. ... We look forward to securing a…”
Read full quotation
“The injunction prevents the state from imposing massive compliance costs on companies, especially small businesses, and confirms that states cannot unilaterally impose sweeping, extraterritorial mandates. ... We look forward to securing a permanent injunction against these laws.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)ESG Today: U.S. appeals court blocks key parts of California corporate climate reporting lawsArticle text
Why we used this label
The reference point is California's SB 253 and SB 261, which require large companies to disclose their greenhouse gas emissions and climate-related financial risks, and which the Ninth Circuit partly blocked on November 9, 2026. The Chamber, which sued to block both laws, describes them as costly, sweeping mandates and says it will seek to block them permanently, which condemns the laws.
Role at the time: California attorney general, in a comment letter filed with 17 other states, the District of Columbia, Harris County, Texas, and the City of New York
Condemned
Response to this claim
The repeal of the Council on Environmental Quality's NEPA regulations, Congress's amendments to NEPA and the Supreme Court's Seven County decision require the Postal Service to revise its NEPA regulations and streamline its environmental review process.
Quotation excerpt
“The Rule would harm these State interests by curtailing environmental review and opportunities for public participation in a manner and to an extent not warranted by law. These comments describe how the Rule harms the States and is contrary…”
Read full quotation
“The Rule would harm these State interests by curtailing environmental review and opportunities for public participation in a manner and to an extent not warranted by law. These comments describe how the Rule harms the States and is contrary to NEPA. In sum, the Rule is unlawful. For the reasons stated below, the Attorneys General strongly oppose the Rule and request that it be withdrawn in its entirety.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Comments of the attorneys general of California, New York and other states opposing the Postal Service's NEPA interim final rule33-page comment letter dated November 9, 2026, sent to Postal Service environmental counsel Thomas Shepherd
Why we used this label
The attorneys general call the rule unlawful, say it harms their states and ask USPS to withdraw it entirely, so we labeled it condemns.
Role at the time: Environmental group that filed a brief supporting the laws, in a statement by senior attorney Stephanie Jones
Defended or excused
Response to this claim
California's climate disclosure laws are consistent with the First Amendment.
Quotation excerpt
“California’s climate disclosure laws are firmly consistent with the First Amendment and will provide information that Californians need to make sound financial decisions as businesses advance clean, affordable energy solutions and…”
Read full quotation
“California’s climate disclosure laws are firmly consistent with the First Amendment and will provide information that Californians need to make sound financial decisions as businesses advance clean, affordable energy solutions and climate-fueled disasters grow more costly and disruptive. As the case moves forward we will continue to vigorously defend these vitally important laws.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Environmental Defense Fund: Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals allows some California climate disclosure requirements to proceed · Environmental Defense FundPress release text
Why we used this label
The reference point is California's SB 253 and SB 261, which require large companies to disclose their greenhouse gas emissions and climate-related financial risks, and which the Ninth Circuit partly blocked on November 9, 2026. EDF says the laws are constitutional and vitally important and that it will keep defending them, which defends the laws.
Role at the time: Robinhood Derivatives, LLC, the company's futures commission merchant subsidiary and plaintiff, in its complaint filed by its lawyers
Condemned
Statement summary
Robinhood's derivatives subsidiary asks a federal court to stop Missouri's attorney general and gaming officials from regulating or prohibiting the event contracts it offers. It says those contracts trade on federally regulated markets and that Missouri is improperly asserting jurisdiction over them.
Quotation excerpt
“Robinhood seeks declaratory and injunctive relief to restrain the Attorney General of Missouri and the senior officials of the Missouri Gaming Commission (the "Commission") from improperly and under color of Missouri state law assuming…”
Read full quotation
“Robinhood seeks declaratory and injunctive relief to restrain the Attorney General of Missouri and the senior officials of the Missouri Gaming Commission (the "Commission") from improperly and under color of Missouri state law assuming jurisdiction over, regulating and prohibiting Robinhood's offering and facilitation of lawful event contracts traded on federally regulated derivatives markets.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Complaint, Robinhood Derivatives, LLC v. Hanaway, No. 4:26-cv-01932 (E.D. Mo. filed Nov. 9, 2026), ECF 1ECF 1, nature of the action (paragraphs 1 to 6)
What this label refers to
Robinhood calls Missouri's effort to regulate and prohibit its event contracts an improper assertion of state jurisdiction over lawful, federally regulated trading, so we labeled it Condemned.
Role at the time: Mayor of San Antonio, on Texas Public Radio's The Source
Condemned
Statement summary
Mayor Gina Ortiz Jones says DHS has told the city it will comply with environmental review requirements, which she calls the crux of the lawsuit. She says the city will keep watching the project and could take further legal action, and that its ultimate goal is no ICE detention facility in San Antonio.
“DHS has said that they will comply and do an environmental review, and so that was the whole crux of the case ... Obviously, the ultimate effect is no ICE detention facility in San Antonio.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Texas Public Radio: Mayor says feds agree to environmental review of planned ICE detention facilityArticle text
What this label refers to
Jones credits the lawsuit with getting DHS to agree to the environmental review it had skipped and says the city still aims to keep the facility from opening, so we labeled it Condemned.
Role at the time: Underdog Exchange DCM, Inc. and UDM, LLC, doing business as Underdog Predict, plaintiffs, in their complaint filed by their lawyers
Condemned
Statement summary
Underdog's exchange and brokerage companies ask a federal court to prevent Missouri's attorney general and gaming officials from regulating or shutting down the event contracts they offer. They say federal law gives the Commodity Futures Trading Commission sole authority over contracts traded on designated markets.
Quotation excerpt
“This action seeks to prevent the Attorney General of Missouri ("Attorney General"), the Executive Director ("Executive Director") of the Missouri Gaming Commission ("Gaming Commission"), and the Chairman and Commissioners of the Gaming…”
Read full quotation
“This action seeks to prevent the Attorney General of Missouri ("Attorney General"), the Executive Director ("Executive Director") of the Missouri Gaming Commission ("Gaming Commission"), and the Chairman and Commissioners of the Gaming Commission (collectively, "Defendants") from unlawfully exercising jurisdiction over, regulating, or terminating Underdog's offering of lawful derivatives contracts on federally regulated markets.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Complaint, Underdog Exchange DCM, Inc. v. Hanaway, No. 2:26-cv-04300 (W.D. Mo. filed Nov. 8, 2026), ECF 1ECF 1, introduction (paragraphs 1 to 4)
What this label refers to
Underdog says Missouri officials would be unlawfully exercising jurisdiction over its federally regulated event contracts, so we labeled it Condemned.
The reference point is Mayor John Whitmire's November 6, 2026 executive order directing Houston police to stop contacting ICE over nonviolent offenses. Mullin, quoting the Times report on the order, says limiting cooperation with ICE fails constituents, which condemns it.
The reference point is Mayor John Whitmire's November 6, 2026 executive order directing Houston police to stop contacting ICE over nonviolent offenses. ICE says the order protects some of the worst criminals in America, which condemns it.
Role at the time: Mayor of Houston, at the news conference announcing the order
Defended or excused
Statement summary
Mayor John Whitmire says he signed the executive order to begin a healing process and reduce fear and anxiety across Houston, and that he did so knowing that elections matter. He says he understands the change carries risk and that he is doing right.
“I do this to begin a healing process ... I also do this knowing that elections matter.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)The Texas Tribune (via KSAT): Houston mayor limits police cooperation with ICE after Democratic wins · The Texas TribuneArticle text
What this label refers to
Whitmire says the order will ease fear in Houston and that he is right to accept the risk that comes with it, so we labeled it Defended or excused.
Role at the time: Houston immigrant rights group; executive director Cesar Espinosa, speaking to the Associated Press
Defended or excused
Response to this claim
Limiting Houston police contact with ICE to people arrested on jailable offenses will improve public safety and reduce fear among immigrant residents.
“It means that the mom taking her kid to school is not going to have a panic attack every time she sees HPD”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Houston will limit ICE cooperation in response to Democrats taking power in Texas, mayor says · Associated PressFull article
Why we used this label
The reference point is Mayor John Whitmire's November 6, 2026 executive order directing Houston police to stop contacting ICE over nonviolent offenses. FIEL welcomes the order as easing immigrants' fear of the police, which defends it.
Role at the time: Justice Department, through its appellate lawyers, in a motion for a stay pending appeal filed in the D.C. Circuit
Defended or excused
Response to this claim
Federal law authorizes DOJ to obtain statewide voter registration lists and permits specified sharing with DHS.
“The government is likely to succeed on appeal. The APA authorizes review of discrete, final agency action, not a programmatic challenge to related activities that a court has grouped under a common label.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Motion for stay pending appeal, Common Cause v. Department of Justice, D.C. Cir. No. 26-5362Introduction, pages 1 and 2 of the motion filed November 4, 2026 (133 pages with addendum), as posted by Democracy Docket
Why we used this label
The department argues that the court could not vacate its voter-data activities as a single policy and that those activities are lawful, so we labeled it Defended or excused.
Role at the time: Governor of California, in a statement from a spokesperson to Ars Technica
Challenged the characterization
Statement summary
A spokesperson for Gov. Gavin Newsom says California is accepting federal broadband funding for homes and businesses and that the state's laws, including its net neutrality protections, remain in force.
Quotation excerpt
“California is accepting federal broadband funding to bring high-speed Internet to hundreds of thousands of homes and businesses, many of them in rural and underserved communities
We’re ready to get these projects built with our local and…”
Read full quotation
“California is accepting federal broadband funding to bring high-speed Internet to hundreds of thousands of homes and businesses, many of them in rural and underserved communities
We’re ready to get these projects built with our local and federal partners. Connecting these communities is the goal, and so is protecting them. California’s laws, including our net neutrality protections, still stand.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)California fights 'preposterous' Trump admin demand to scrap state broadband lawsStatement from a spokesperson for Gov. Gavin Newsom
What this label refers to
The reference point is Condition 50, NTIA's requirement that California not enforce specified broadband rules against funded providers. The governor's office says California is taking the funding while its net neutrality protections remain, which disputes the reading that accepting the award gives up those laws. It does not call the condition unlawful or criticize it directly.
National Telecommunications and Information Administration
Role at the time: NTIA spokesperson responding to Ars Technica
Defended or excused
Statement summary
NTIA says California's reservation letter does not alter the award agreement. Its published terms argue that the restrictions protect broadband deployment.
“the terms and conditions of the award constitute the entire agreement between NTIA and CPUC.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)California challenges NTIA's broadband grant conditionsNTIA spokesperson response to Ars Technica
What this label refers to
NTIA defends the continued force of the challenged condition and its deployment rationale.
Role at the time: Chief judge of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, in the memorandum opinion denying the plaintiffs' motion
Mixed or conditional
Response to this claim
The executive branch has no authority to direct states to remove registered voters from their rolls, to withhold ballots from registered voters, or to set aside or refuse to count the ballots they cast.
Quotation excerpt
“The demand letters issued to the state elections officials may indeed be unlawful. ... Had state officials capitulated in the face of the Administration’s browbeating, this may well have been a different case. At this stage in the…”
Read full quotation
“The demand letters issued to the state elections officials may indeed be unlawful. ... Had state officials capitulated in the face of the Administration’s browbeating, this may well have been a different case. At this stage in the litigation, however, Plaintiffs present no evidence demonstrating that any state has acquiesced and removed a voter from the rolls or segregated her ballot based on the Government’s letters.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Memorandum opinion denying the motion for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction, DSCC v. Trump, No. 1:26-cv-03674 (D.D.C. Nov. 2, 2026), ECF 34 · United States District Court for the District of ColumbiaDocument 34, pages 1-2 and 24-25
Why we used this label
Boasberg says the letters may be unlawful and calls them browbeating, but he leaves their lawfulness undecided and denies relief because no state has acted on them, so we labeled it Mixed or conditional.
Role at the time: District judge, writing the opinion denying a stay
Condemned
Statement summary
Sooknanan rejects DOJ's claim that the vacatur irreparably harms enforcement. She says the department can still take lawful steps to help states maintain accurate rolls and denies a stay.
“A stay applicant cannot show irreparable harm from an inability to engage in unlawful activity.”
Role at the time: Former U.S. attorney and author of Civil Discourse
Condemned
Statement summary
Vance says DOJ's October 29 letters suggested that officials could be prosecuted over records they are already required to keep.
“Thursday, DOJ sent letters to elections officials in all 50 states, suggesting, none too subtly, that they could be prosecuted if they didn’t preserve election records—which they’re already required to do.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Joyce Vance reviews election litigation in the days before the midterms · Joyce VanceSection on the Northern District of California order and the DOJ letters
What this label refers to
Relative to DOJ's warnings of prosecution to election officials, Vance describes the latest letters as an implied threat over a duty officials already meet, which criticizes the warnings.
Role at the time: Department of Homeland Security spokesperson, in a statement to amNewYork
Defended or excused
Response to this claim
ICE's use of New York City-owned parking lots to stage immigration enforcement operations without the city's authorization is illegal.
“ICE's presence in public parking lots is fully authorized under federal law and is a standard practice for law enforcement agencies nationwide”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Mamdani threatens to sue ICE over reported use of NYC park lots as staging grounds · amNewYorkFull article
Why we used this label
The reference point is ICE agents' reported use of unstaffed New York City-owned parking lots in the Bronx and Queens to stage immigration enforcement operations. DHS says that use is fully authorized under federal law and standard practice, which defends it.
The reference point is ICE agents' reported use of unstaffed New York City-owned parking lots in the Bronx and Queens to stage immigration enforcement operations. Hochul says the reported use disturbs her and joins the demand that it end, which condemns it.
Tung Yin is a professor of law at Lewis & Clark Law School in Portland, Oregon, where he has taught since 2009 after seven years on the faculty of the University of Iowa College of Law. He writes on national security law, criminal procedure and constitutional law.
John Whitmire is the Mayor of Houston, Texas, sworn in on January 2, 2024. He served in the Texas Legislature for about five decades, first as a state representative for 10 years and then as a state senator for 40, and chaired the Senate Criminal Justice Committee.
Gina Ortiz Jones is the mayor of San Antonio, Texas, and took office on June 18, 2025. A former U.S. Air Force intelligence officer and Iraq War veteran, she later worked in the Executive Office of the President and served as the 27th under secretary of the Air Force after Senate confirmation in 2021. She was the Democratic nominee for Texas's 23rd congressional district in 2018 and 2020.
Markwayne Mullin is an American Republican politician and businessman who serves as the 9th U.S. Secretary of Homeland Security, sworn in on March 24, 2026. He previously represented Oklahoma in the U.S. House of Representatives and then in the U.S. Senate, for a combined 13 years, and before entering Congress ran his family’s plumbing business, Mullin Plumbing.
Tina Kotek is the Democratic governor of Oregon. She previously held office in the Oregon House of Representatives, including as speaker. Before entering the legislature, she worked for organizations focused on hunger and children's welfare.
Gavin Newsom is the Democratic governor of California. He previously held office as California lieutenant governor and mayor of San Francisco. Before entering public office, he worked in the hospitality business.
James E. Boasberg is a judge of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, commissioned in March 2011, and has been its chief judge since 2023. He previously was a judge of the Superior Court of the District of Columbia from 2002 to 2011 and an assistant U.S. attorney in the District of Columbia. He served on the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court from 2014 to 2021, the last two years as its presiding judge. He graduated from Yale College and Yale Law School and holds a master's degree from the University of Oxford.
Sparkle L. Sooknanan is a judge on the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. She previously worked in private practice and at the Justice Department, including as principal deputy assistant attorney general in its Civil Rights Division. She clerked for Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor.
Joyce Vance is a law professor at the University of Alabama and a former U.S. attorney for the Northern District of Alabama. She writes Civil Discourse and co-hosts the SistersInLaw and CAFE Insider podcasts.
Kathy Hochul is the Democratic governor of New York and the first woman to hold the office. She became governor in August 2021 after holding office as lieutenant governor. Hochul previously represented New York's 26th Congressional District in the U.S. House, was Erie County clerk, and held local office on the Hamburg Town Board. A lawyer, she has worked in local, state and federal government. She graduated from Syracuse University in 1980 and earned her law degree from the Catholic University of America.