Announcing his 2027 presidential run on TF1, Éric Zemmour said his convictions for racial insult and incitement to hatred were for an opinion offense under a law he would abolish. Anchor Gilles Bouleau answered that racism is not an opinion.
Role at the time: Spokesperson for the Rassemblement national and for Marine Le Pen, in a post on X
Denied
Statement summary
In a post on X, Kotarac, a spokesperson for the RN and for Marine Le Pen, says Les Écologistes leader Marine Tondelier is covering herself in shame by directly accusing the RN over the attack, calls her claims fake news and says the party is bringing legal proceedings against her.
Quotation excerpt
“By directly accusing @RNational_off of the racist attack in #Trappes, Ms. Tondelier is covering herself in shame. I am informing you that we are bringing legal proceedings against this person and her fake news. (Translated from French.…”
Read full quotation
“By directly accusing @RNational_off of the racist attack in #Trappes, Ms. Tondelier is covering herself in shame. I am informing you that we are bringing legal proceedings against this person and her fake news. (Translated from French. Original: En accusant directement le @RNational_off de l'attentat raciste de #Trappes, Madame Tondelier se couvre de honte. Je vous informe que nous engageons une procédure judiciaire contre cette personne et ses fakenews.)”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Andréa Kotarac's post on X announcing legal action against Marine Tondelier · Andréa KotaracPost on X, November 12, 2026, 12:31 p.m. Paris time, with an 88-second clip of his interview on franceinfo's Le 7.40 that morning
What this label refers to
The reference point is the public rhetoric of Rassemblement national leaders and other far-right politicians about Trappes, Muslims and immigrants, which Trappes mayor Ali Rabeh holds responsible for the October 23, 2026 racist attack in Trappes and La Verrière. Kotarac calls the accusation that the RN is responsible for the attack fake news and announces legal action against the person making it, which denies that the party bears responsibility.
Role at the time: National secretary of Les Écologistes and presidential candidate, on franceinfo's Nos Services Publics
Condemned
Response to this claim
Rassemblement national leaders bear direct responsibility for the gunman's decision to carry out the October 23, 2026 racist attack in Trappes and La Verrière.
Quotation excerpt
“It is up to the Rassemblement national to explain itself rather than to take me to court ... They must draw the consequences (Translated from French. Original: C'est au Rassemblement national de s'expliquer plutôt que de m'attaquer en…”
Read full quotation
“It is up to the Rassemblement national to explain itself rather than to take me to court ... They must draw the consequences (Translated from French. Original: C'est au Rassemblement national de s'expliquer plutôt que de m'attaquer en justice ... Il faut qu'ils en tirent les conséquences)”
Open source (opens in a new tab)franceinfo report on Marine Tondelier's response to the RN's planned defamation complaintFull article
Why we used this label
The reference point is the public rhetoric of Rassemblement national leaders and other far-right politicians about Trappes, Muslims and immigrants, which Trappes mayor Ali Rabeh holds responsible for the October 23, 2026 racist attack in Trappes and La Verrière. Tondelier says the RN has failed to explain itself after the attack and must draw the consequences, and that evening says words spoken on television can precede acts and serve as ammunition, which condemns the party's rhetoric.
Role at the time: Mayor of Trappes, interviewed on franceinfo
Condemned
Response to this claim
Rassemblement national leaders bear direct responsibility for the gunman's decision to carry out the October 23, 2026 racist attack in Trappes and La Verrière.
Quotation excerpt
“Words always come before acts ... We cannot let our public debate be rotted by extremely violent words (Translated from French. Original: Les mots précèdent toujours les actes ... Nous ne pouvons pas laisser notre débat public pourri par…”
Read full quotation
“Words always come before acts ... We cannot let our public debate be rotted by extremely violent words (Translated from French. Original: Les mots précèdent toujours les actes ... Nous ne pouvons pas laisser notre débat public pourri par des mots extrêmement violents)”
Open source (opens in a new tab)franceinfo report on Ali Rabeh's November 12 interview after new details of the suspect's statementsFull article
Why we used this label
The reference point is the public rhetoric of Rassemblement national leaders and other far-right politicians about Trappes, Muslims and immigrants, which Trappes mayor Ali Rabeh holds responsible for the October 23, 2026 racist attack in Trappes and La Verrière. Rabeh says the rhetoric of RN officials and of CNews led to the attack and has continued since, which condemns that rhetoric.
The reference point is Michel Houellebecq's November 2022 remarks about Muslims in Front Populaire, now under judicial investigation. Schlott treats the remarks as legitimate criticism of Islam and immigration and describes Houellebecq as a man who defends his nation's spirit, which defends them. She goes beyond disputing the incitement label, so challenges the characterization does not fit.
Role at the time: French-Syrian writer and journalist, in an opinion column in Le Figaro
Challenged the characterization
Response to this claim
Houellebecq's 2022 remarks about Muslims contain no exhortation, even implicit, and therefore fall within freedom of opinion and expression.
“It was a forecast, the vision of a future in which such violence would take place (Translated from French. Original: C'était une prospective, la vision d'un avenir où de telles violences auraient lieu)”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Omar Youssef Souleimane : « L'affaire Houellebecq montre que les islamistes veulent retourner la démocratie contre elle-même »Opening paragraphs
Why we used this label
The reference point is Michel Houellebecq's November 2022 remarks about Muslims in Front Populaire, now under judicial investigation. Souleimane describes the passage on attacks against Muslims as a forecast rather than the provocation the complaints allege, which challenges the characterization. He does not argue that the remarks about Muslims were justified, so defends or excuses does not fit.
Role at the time: President of SOS Racisme, interviewed on RTL Matin
Condemned
Statement summary
On RTL the morning after Zemmour's announcement, Sopo calls his candidacy a republican problem, says Zemmour was convicted for remarks of incredible violence, including at the 2019 Convention de la droite, and argues that remarks portraying Black people, Arabs, Muslims and foreigners as existential dangers give license to serious violence.
Quotation excerpt
“These remarks give license to extremely serious acts. ... I am not saying that Éric Zemmour has blood on his hands: I am saying that he may have it on his conscience, if he has one (Translated from French. Original: Ces propos autorisent…”
Read full quotation
“These remarks give license to extremely serious acts. ... I am not saying that Éric Zemmour has blood on his hands: I am saying that he may have it on his conscience, if he has one (Translated from French. Original: Ces propos autorisent des passages à l'acte extrêmement graves. ... Je ne dis pas qu'Éric Zemmour a du sang sur les mains : je dis qu'il en a peut-être sur la conscience, si tant est qu'il en ait une)”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)RTL's clip of Dominique Sopo on RTL MatinPost on X, November 11, 2026, 7:54 a.m. CET, with a 2 minute 7 second excerpt of the interview
What this label refers to
The reference point is the remarks for which French courts have definitively convicted Éric Zemmour of racial insult and incitement to hatred. Sopo describes the remarks behind Zemmour's convictions, including his 2019 Convention de la droite speech, as very racist and incredibly violent, and says such remarks give license to serious acts of violence, which condemns them.
Mouvement contre le racisme et pour l'amitié entre les peuples
Role at the time: French anti-racism association and civil party in the case, commenting to Le Nouvel Obs
Condemned
Response to this claim
The wish of France's native-born population is not for Muslims to assimilate but for them to stop robbing and attacking them, or else, as another solution, for them to leave.
Quotation excerpt
“We never considered that these explanations held up; withdrawing our complaint was never in question (Translated from French. Original: Nous n'avons jamais considéré que ces explications tenaient la route, il n'a jamais été question de…”
Read full quotation
“We never considered that these explanations held up; withdrawing our complaint was never in question (Translated from French. Original: Nous n'avons jamais considéré que ces explications tenaient la route, il n'a jamais été question de retirer notre plainte)”
The reference point is Michel Houellebecq's November 2022 remarks about Muslims in Front Populaire, now under judicial investigation. The MRAP rejects the explanations Houellebecq gave for the remarks, maintains its criminal complaint over them and welcomes the investigation, which condemns them.
Role at the time: Lawyer for the Union des mosquées de France, a complainant in the case, speaking to AFP
Condemned
Response to this claim
Houellebecq's 2022 remarks about Muslims contain no exhortation, even implicit, and therefore fall within freedom of opinion and expression.
“Freedom of expression is fundamental, but it cannot justify everything (Translated from French. Original: La liberté d'expression est fondamentale mais elle ne saurait tout justifier)”
Open source (opens in a new tab)L'écrivain Michel Houellebecq mis en examen pour des propos hostiles envers les musulmans · Agence France-PresseFull article
Why we used this label
The reference point is Michel Houellebecq's November 2022 remarks about Muslims in Front Populaire, now under judicial investigation. Speaking for the federation whose complaint led to the investigation, El Haïté rejects the defense that the remarks are protected expression, which condemns them. She leaves the finding to the court and cites the presumption of innocence, but that is a legal caveat rather than a condition on her client's position, so mixed or conditional does not fit.
Role at the time: Lawyer for Michel Houellebecq, in a statement with his co-counsel Louis Cailliez to BFMTV and AFP
Challenged the characterization
Response to this claim
Houellebecq's 2022 remarks about Muslims contain no exhortation, even implicit, and therefore fall within freedom of opinion and expression.
Quotation excerpt
“Michel Houellebecq contests the criminal offense of which he is accused. The remarks at issue contain no element of exhortation, even implicit, and therefore fall within freedom of opinion and expression (Translated from French. Original:…”
Read full quotation
“Michel Houellebecq contests the criminal offense of which he is accused. The remarks at issue contain no element of exhortation, even implicit, and therefore fall within freedom of opinion and expression (Translated from French. Original: Michel Houellebecq conteste le délit pénal qui lui est reproché. Les propos incriminés ne contiennent pas de dimension d'exhortation, même implicite, et relèvent donc de la liberté d'opinion et d'expression)”
The reference point is Michel Houellebecq's November 2022 remarks about Muslims in Front Populaire, now under judicial investigation. His lawyers dispute that the remarks amount to incitement, saying they contain no exhortation and belong to free expression, which challenges the characterization. They do not argue that the content of the remarks was right, so defends or excuses does not fit.
Role at the time: President of the Rassemblement national, on BFMTV's Face à BFM
Defended or excused
Response to this claim
Rassemblement national leaders bear direct responsibility for the gunman's decision to carry out the October 23, 2026 racist attack in Trappes and La Verrière.
Quotation excerpt
“left-wing and far-left leaders putting fatwas and targets on the backs of political figures like the mayor of Trappes, and Mr. Mélenchon did it to us ... I have the right to point the finger at and to want to fight an ideology that,…”
Read full quotation
“left-wing and far-left leaders putting fatwas and targets on the backs of political figures like the mayor of Trappes, and Mr. Mélenchon did it to us ... I have the right to point the finger at and to want to fight an ideology that, precisely in Trappes, sent several dozen young people to fight in Syria in the name of the Islamic State (Translated from French. Original: des dirigeants de gauche et d'extrême gauche mettre des fatwas et des cibles sur le dos de responsable politiques comme le maire de Trappes, et Monsieur Mélenchon l'a fait avec nous ... J'ai le droit de pointer du doigt et de vouloir combattre une idéologie qui précisément à Trappes a envoyé plusieurs dizaines de jeunes combattre en Syrie au nom de l'État islamique)”
Open source (opens in a new tab)BFMTV report on Jordan Bardella's Face à BFM interview of November 10, as republished by Yahoo · BFMTVFull article
Why we used this label
The reference point is the public rhetoric of Rassemblement national leaders and other far-right politicians about Trappes, Muslims and immigrants, which Trappes mayor Ali Rabeh holds responsible for the October 23, 2026 racist attack in Trappes and La Verrière. Bardella says he has the right to point at the ideology he associates with Trappes and accuses his critics of putting targets on politicians' backs, which defends his rhetoric about the town.
Role at the time: National secretary of the French Communist Party (PCF) and its 2027 presidential candidate
Condemned
Statement summary
As Zemmour announced his candidacy on TF1, Roussel posted that Zemmour wants to lead the Republic after several convictions for racist remarks and repeated his call to make politicians convicted of racism ineligible.
Quotation excerpt
“Éric Zemmour wants to preside over the Republic after being convicted several times for racist remarks. I have been saying it for a long time: politicians convicted of racism should be made ineligible. (Translated from French. Original:…”
Read full quotation
“Éric Zemmour wants to preside over the Republic after being convicted several times for racist remarks. I have been saying it for a long time: politicians convicted of racism should be made ineligible. (Translated from French. Original: Éric Zemmour veut présider la République après avoir été condamné à plusieurs reprises pour propos racistes. Je le dis depuis longtemps : les responsables politiques condamnés pour racisme devraient être rendus inéligibles.)”
The reference point is the remarks for which French courts have definitively convicted Éric Zemmour of racial insult and incitement to hatred. Roussel describes the remarks behind Zemmour's convictions as racist and says politicians convicted of racism should be barred from office, which condemns the remarks. His call for ineligibility is a proposed remedy; the label rests on his description of the remarks as racist and his view that they disqualify a candidate.
Role at the time: Anchor and editor-in-chief of TF1's evening news, Le 20H, interviewing Zemmour on air
Condemned
Response to this claim
Éric Zemmour's convictions for racial insult and incitement to hatred are for opinion offenses, not racism, under a law that lets judges restrict freedom of expression.
Quotation excerpt
“It is the application of the law ... you committed punishable offenses ... Racism is not an opinion. (Translated from French. Original: C'est l'application du droit ... vous avez commis des délits répréhensibles ... Le racisme n'est pas une…”
Read full quotation
“It is the application of the law ... you committed punishable offenses ... Racism is not an opinion. (Translated from French. Original: C'est l'application du droit ... vous avez commis des délits répréhensibles ... Le racisme n'est pas une opinion.)”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)TF1Info's clip of Gilles Bouleau questioning Éric Zemmour about his convictions on Le 20HPost on X, November 10, 2026, 9:45 p.m. CET, with a 1 minute 52 second excerpt of TF1's Le 20H
Why we used this label
The reference point is the remarks for which French courts have definitively convicted Éric Zemmour of racial insult and incitement to hatred. Bouleau tells Zemmour he committed punishable offenses and answers his description of them as an opinion offense by saying racism is not an opinion, which criticizes the remarks themselves as racism. He does more than dispute a description: he presents the convictions as the law applied to racist remarks.
Role at the time: President of Reconquête and presidential candidate, interviewed on TF1's Le 20H
Defended or excused
Response to this claim
Éric Zemmour's convictions for racial insult and incitement to hatred are for opinion offenses, not racism, under a law that lets judges restrict freedom of expression.
Quotation excerpt
“I am the victim of judicial harassment ... This is not racism, it has nothing to do with it. That is how judges interpret a freedom-killing law that I will abolish if I am president, because it allows judges to ban freedom of expression…”
Read full quotation
“I am the victim of judicial harassment ... This is not racism, it has nothing to do with it. That is how judges interpret a freedom-killing law that I will abolish if I am president, because it allows judges to ban freedom of expression (Translated from French. Original: Je suis victime d'un harcèlement judiciaire ... Ce n'est pas du racisme, ça n'a rien à voir. Les juges interprètent ainsi une loi liberticide que j'abolirai si je suis président, parce que ça permet aux juges d'interdire la liberté d'expression)”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)TF1Info's clip of Gilles Bouleau questioning Éric Zemmour about his convictions on Le 20HPost on X, November 10, 2026, 9:45 p.m. CET, with a 1 minute 52 second excerpt of TF1's Le 20H
Why we used this label
The reference point is the remarks for which French courts have definitively convicted Éric Zemmour of racial insult and incitement to hatred. Zemmour says the remarks are not racism, calls his convictions an opinion offense and pledges to abolish the law under which judges punished them. Because he goes beyond rejecting the racism label and presents the remarks as acceptable speech that the law should not punish, this is a defense of the remarks rather than only a dispute over how they are described.
Role at the time: French human-rights organization, in a joint statement with the student unions Unef and USL
Condemned
Response to this claim
Laurent Nuñez is responsible for serious injuries to protesters because he ordered police to use weapons he knew could mutilate.
Quotation excerpt
“He even went so far as to argue that the first ones hurt by these mutilations would be the police themselves, those who use their weapons. Faced with young people who have lost an eye or been seriously injured, such a statement is indecent.…”
Read full quotation
“He even went so far as to argue that the first ones hurt by these mutilations would be the police themselves, those who use their weapons. Faced with young people who have lost an eye or been seriously injured, such a statement is indecent. (Translated from French. Original: Il est allé jusqu'à avancer que les premiers meurtris de ces mutilations seraient les forces de l'ordre elles-mêmes, celles qui font usage de leurs armes. Face à des jeunes qui ont perdu un œil ou ont été grièvement touchés, une telle déclaration est indécente.)”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Violences policières et attaques contre l'Etat de droit : face au déni du ministère de l'Intérieur, l'Unef, l'USL et la LDH saisissent à nouveau l'ONU · Ligue des droits de l'HommeJoint press release of November 9, 2026, full text
Why we used this label
The reference point is the use of crowd-control weapons such as grenades by French police and gendarmes, under Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez's orders, that seriously injured protesters since mid-September 2026. The LDH and the unions say the minister denies documented police violence, describe the injuries as resembling war wounds and call his remark indecent, which condemns the use of force under scrutiny.
Role at the time: French minister of the interior, at a press briefing at the Interior Ministry in Paris
Defended or excused
Response to this claim
Laurent Nuñez is responsible for serious injuries to protesters because he ordered police to use weapons he knew could mutilate.
Quotation excerpt
“I regret that there were these injuries, I truly and very sincerely regret it, but every time police officers or gendarmes use force, it is because they are acting within a legal and regulatory framework (Translated from French. Original:…”
Read full quotation
“I regret that there were these injuries, I truly and very sincerely regret it, but every time police officers or gendarmes use force, it is because they are acting within a legal and regulatory framework (Translated from French. Original: Je regrette qu'il y ait eu ces blessés, je regrette vraiment et très sincèrement, mais chaque fois que les policiers ou gendarmes engagent la force, c'est qu'ils sont dans un cadre légal et réglementaire)”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Manifestants blessés : des avocats annoncent saisir la CJR contre Laurent Nuñez · Agence France-PresseFull AFP dispatch, as published by Sud Radio
Why we used this label
The reference point is the use of crowd-control weapons such as grenades by French police and gendarmes, under Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez's orders, that seriously injured protesters since mid-September 2026. Nuñez expresses regret for the injuries but says every use of force by police and gendarmes stays within the legal framework and calls intermediate weapons indispensable, which defends the use of force under scrutiny.
Role at the time: Paris lawyer for injured protesters and LDH vice president, at a press conference in Paris
Condemned
Response to this claim
Laurent Nuñez is responsible for serious injuries to protesters because he ordered police to use weapons he knew could mutilate.
Quotation excerpt
“We now believe it is imperative to target the person responsible for the mutilations and the massive damage, namely the interior minister, Laurent Nuñez (Translated from French. Original: nous pensons aujourd'hui qu'il est impératif de…”
Read full quotation
“We now believe it is imperative to target the person responsible for the mutilations and the massive damage, namely the interior minister, Laurent Nuñez (Translated from French. Original: nous pensons aujourd'hui qu'il est impératif de viser celui qui est à l'origine des mutilations et des dégâts massifs, à savoir le ministre de l'Intérieur Laurent Nuñez)”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Manifestants blessés : des avocats annoncent saisir la CJR contre Laurent Nuñez · Agence France-PresseFull AFP dispatch, as published by Sud Radio
Why we used this label
The reference point is the use of crowd-control weapons such as grenades by French police and gendarmes, under Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez's orders, that seriously injured protesters since mid-September 2026. Alimi holds Nuñez personally responsible for the injuries and says the lawyers will seek his prosecution, which condemns the use of force under scrutiny.
Role at the time: Rassemblement national deputy for the Var and party spokesperson, in a post on X
Denied
Response to this claim
Rassemblement national leaders bear direct responsibility for the gunman's decision to carry out the October 23, 2026 racist attack in Trappes and La Verrière.
Quotation excerpt
“I denounced on @BFMTV the indecent lies of Ms. Tondelier, who is ready to do the worst in order to exist. The RN is totally innocent of the Trappes tragedy. (Translated from French. Original: J'ai dénoncé @BFMTV les mensonges indécents de…”
Read full quotation
“I denounced on @BFMTV the indecent lies of Ms. Tondelier, who is ready to do the worst in order to exist. The RN is totally innocent of the Trappes tragedy. (Translated from French. Original: J'ai dénoncé @BFMTV les mensonges indécents de Mme Tondelier, prête au pire pour exister. Le RN est totalement innocent de la tragédie de Trappes.)”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Laure Lavalette's post on X about Marine Tondelier and the Trappes attack · Laure LavalettePost on X, November 5, 2026, 9:31 p.m. Paris time, with a 1 minute 56 second clip of her BFMTV appearance
Why we used this label
The reference point is the public rhetoric of Rassemblement national leaders and other far-right politicians about Trappes, Muslims and immigrants, which Trappes mayor Ali Rabeh holds responsible for the October 23, 2026 racist attack in Trappes and La Verrière. Lavalette says the RN is totally innocent of the attack and calls the accusation against it lies, which denies that the party bears responsibility.
Role at the time: Lawyer and CNews commentator, posting on X
Condemned
Statement summary
Responding to France Inter's coverage of the proposal, Goldnadel calls Rabeh's wish to penalize the ideology of the Great Replacement intellectual terrorism and says the public broadcaster should be replaced by a private station.
Quotation excerpt
“A rerun of Ali Rabeh's intellectual terrorism in wanting to penalize "the ideology of the great replacement." The station has gone so far as to investigate whether the RN practices it. Only one solution: great-replace the odious public…”
Read full quotation
“A rerun of Ali Rabeh's intellectual terrorism in wanting to penalize "the ideology of the great replacement." The station has gone so far as to investigate whether the RN practices it. Only one solution: great-replace the odious public broadcaster with a private radio station. (Translated from French. Original: Reprise du terrorisme intellectuel d'Ali Rabeh de vouloir pénaliser « l'idéologie du grand remplacement » . La radio en est à enquêter pour savoir si le RN la pratique. Une seule solution : grand remplacer l'odieux visuel public par une radio privée.)”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Gilles-William Goldnadel's post on X about Ali Rabeh's proposal · Gilles-William GoldnadelPost on X, November 2, 2026, 7:52 a.m. Paris time, quoting France Inter's October 30 post on the interview
What this label refers to
Goldnadel calls the plan to penalize Great Replacement ideology intellectual terrorism, so we labeled it Condemned.
Role at the time: President of the Rassemblement national, posting on X
Condemned
Statement summary
Quoting France Inter's post on Rabeh's proposal, Bardella writes that the left wants to criminalize the feeling of at least 60 percent of French people that the country is going through a profound demographic transformation, and that the freedom-killing left must never prevail.
Quotation excerpt
“If I understand correctly, the left wants to criminalize the feeling of at least 60% of French people, who see a "profound demographic transformation." Unless it is to rejoice in it, of course. ... The freedom-killing left must never…”
Read full quotation
“If I understand correctly, the left wants to criminalize the feeling of at least 60% of French people, who see a "profound demographic transformation." Unless it is to rejoice in it, of course. ... The freedom-killing left must never prevail in our country. (Translated from French. Original: Si je comprends bien, la gauche veut criminaliser le ressenti d'au moins 60% des Français, qui constatent une « transformation démographique profonde ». Sauf si c'est pour s'en réjouir, évidemment. ... Jamais la gauche liberticide ne doit l'emporter dans notre pays.)”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Jordan Bardella's post on X about Ali Rabeh's proposal · Jordan BardellaPost on X, October 30, 2026, 5:32 p.m. Paris time, quoting France Inter's post on the interview
What this label refers to
Bardella says the proposal would criminalize what a majority of French people feel and calls its backers a freedom-killing left, so we labeled it Condemned.
Role at the time: Ecologiste et Social deputy for Hauts-de-Seine, posting on X
Defended or excused
Statement summary
Announcing the bill she was filing with Steevy Gustave and Akli Mellouli, Sebaihi writes that words killed in Trappes, that the Great Replacement and remigration are ammunition rather than opinions, and that those who promote them must answer for it before the law.
Quotation excerpt
“Words kill. In Trappes, they killed. With Akli Mellouli and Steevy Gustave, we are filing a bill against racist hate speech. "Great replacement," "remigration": these are not opinions, they are ammunition. Those who promote them must answer…”
Read full quotation
“Words kill. In Trappes, they killed. With Akli Mellouli and Steevy Gustave, we are filing a bill against racist hate speech. "Great replacement," "remigration": these are not opinions, they are ammunition. Those who promote them must answer for it before the law. (Translated from French. Original: Les mots tuent. À Trappes, ils ont tué. Avec Akli Mellouli et Steevy Gustave, nous déposons une proposition de loi contre les discours de haine raciste. « Grand remplacement », « remigration » : ce ne sont pas des opinions, ce sont des munitions. Leurs promoteurs doivent en répondre devant la loi.)”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Sabrina Sebaihi's post on X announcing a bill against racist hate speech · Sabrina SebaihiPost on X, October 30, 2026, 2:08 p.m. Paris time, full text
What this label refers to
Sebaihi, a co-author of the National Assembly bill, says the people who promote these two ideas should be held to account under the law, so we labeled it Defended or excused.
Role at the time: President of Reconquete and presidential candidate, posting on X
Condemned
Statement summary
Quoting a post about Rabeh's proposal, Zemmour writes that the gulag is on the march and calls it the plan of a socialist-Islamic republic.
“The gulag is on the march. This is the plan of their socialist-Islamic Republic. (Translated from French. Original: Le goulag est en marche. Voilà le projet de leur République socialo-islamique.)”
Read the original post (opens in a new tab)Eric Zemmour's post on X about Ali Rabeh's proposal · Éric ZemmourPost on X, October 30, 2026, 9:09 a.m. Paris time, quoting a post by Destination Tele
What this label refers to
Zemmour compares the plan to punish replacement rhetoric to the gulag, so we labeled it Condemned.
Role at the time: Constitutional law scholar at Paris-Pantheon-Assas University, quoted by L'Opinion
Condemned
Response to this claim
France's existing legal provisions against incitement to racial hatred are insufficient.
Quotation excerpt
“This is the question that often comes up with memory laws: there is a need for recognition, for a symbol, and at the same time the criminal scope of the thing is a problem. Either because it already falls under the law, or because it is…”
Read full quotation
“This is the question that often comes up with memory laws: there is a need for recognition, for a symbol, and at the same time the criminal scope of the thing is a problem. Either because it already falls under the law, or because it is plainly an infringement of freedom of expression (Translated from French. Original: On est dans la question qui se pose souvent concernant les lois mémorielles : on a besoin d'une reconnaissance, d'un symbole, et en même temps la portée pénale de la chose pose problème. Soit parce que cela tombe déjà sous le coup de la loi, soit car c'est manifestement attentatoire à la liberté d'expression)”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Peut-on interdire la théorie du « grand remplacement » comme le réclame le maire de Trappes ?Full article
Why we used this label
Morel argues that a law against replacement rhetoric would either repeat offenses already in the law or infringe free expression, says the courts would likely see it as a disproportionate limit on that freedom, and calls a ban counterproductive, so we labeled it Condemned.
Role at the time: Ecologiste et Social deputy for Essonne, co-author with Sabrina Sebaihi of bill No. 3458
Defended or excused
Statement summary
In the explanatory statement of their bill, Gustave and Sabrina Sebaihi write that the text would not deprive citizens of their freedom of opinion, and that its aim is to keep public debate from resting on the denial of equality and dignity and to preserve civil peace.
Quotation excerpt
“The aim is not to deprive citizens of their freedom of opinion by creating an offense of opinion. The aim is to ensure that the expression of opinions in public debate does not rest on the systematic denial of the republican principles of…”
Read full quotation
“The aim is not to deprive citizens of their freedom of opinion by creating an offense of opinion. The aim is to ensure that the expression of opinions in public debate does not rest on the systematic denial of the republican principles of equality and dignity, and thereby to preserve civil peace. (Translated from French. Original: Il ne s'agit pas de priver les citoyens de leur liberté d'opinion en créant un délit d'opinion. Il s'agit de garantir que l'expression des opinions dans le débat public ne repose pas sur la négation systématique des principes républicains d'égalité et de dignité, et de préserver ainsi la paix civile.)”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Proposition de loi n° 3458 visant à renforcer la lutte contre les discours incitant à la haine et aux actes racistes et xénophobesFull text of the bill as registered, explanatory statement and articles 1 to 4
What this label refers to
Gustave co-wrote the bill and answers the free-speech objection in its explanatory statement, saying it protects civil peace rather than punishing opinions, so we labeled it Defended or excused.
Role at the time: Mayor of Trappes, interviewed on France Inter
Defended or excused
Response to this claim
France's existing legal provisions against incitement to racial hatred are insufficient.
Quotation excerpt
“There are provisions that prevent incitement to racial hatred. We can see that these provisions are insufficient ... We can perfectly well insert into Article 24 of the 1881 law on freedom of the press a provision stating that from now on…”
Read full quotation
“There are provisions that prevent incitement to racial hatred. We can see that these provisions are insufficient ... We can perfectly well insert into Article 24 of the 1881 law on freedom of the press a provision stating that from now on we will make illegal, and punish with the penalties set out precisely in Article 23 of the same law, those who have presented a group of people, because of their origin, their membership of a religion, an ethnic group, a supposed race or a particular religion, as actors of an instrument, of a process of replacement (Translated from French. Original: Il y a des dispositions qui empêchent l'incitation à la haine raciale. On voit que ces dispositions sont insuffisantes ... On peut tout à fait insérer à l'article 24 de la loi de 1881 sur la liberté de la presse un élément qui indique que nous rendrons dorénavant illégal et nous punirons de peines prévues précisément par l'article 23 de la même loi ceux qui auront présenté un groupe de personnes, à raison de leur origine, de leur appartenance à une religion, à une ethnie, à une prétendue race ou une religion déterminée comme des acteurs d'un instrument, d'un processus de remplacement)”
Open the original interview (opens in a new tab)Attentat dans les Yvelines : le maire de Trappes veut "rendre illégale" la diffusion de la théorie du grand remplacementWritten account of Ali Rabeh's interview on L'invite de 7h50, October 30, 2026, with his quoted remarks
Why we used this label
Rabeh puts forward the change to the press law himself and argues that current rules against incitement to racial hatred fall short, so we labeled it Defended or excused.
Andréa Kotarac is a French politician of the Rassemblement national who presides over the party's group on the Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes regional council and is a spokesperson for the RN and for Marine Le Pen. Born in 1989 in Thonon-les-Bains, he began on the left, in the Socialist Party, the Parti de gauche and La France insoumise, before backing the RN in the 2019 European elections. He led the RN's list in the 2021 regional elections.
Marine Tondelier is a French politician who has been national secretary of Les Écologistes, the party formerly called Europe Écologie Les Verts, since 2022. Born in 1986, she grew up in Hénin-Beaumont, where she has sat on the municipal council in opposition since 2014, and she has been a regional councillor in Hauts-de-France since 2021. She is the party's candidate in the 2027 presidential election.
Ali Rabeh is a French politician who has been mayor of Trappes, a town in the Yvelines department west of Paris, since 2020. A member of the left-wing party Génération.s, he was its national co-coordinator from 2024 to 2025, and he is a vice president of the Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines agglomeration community. Born in Poissy in 1984 to a family from Morocco, he holds French and Moroccan citizenship and came into politics through the student union UNEF and the Socialist youth movement. He was first elected mayor in July 2020. After France's highest administrative court annulled that election over campaign irregularities, he won the October 2021 rerun in the first round, and he was re-elected in the first round in March 2026 with 55.6 percent of the vote.
Rikki Schlott is an American journalist and author. She writes a column for the New York Post, is a fellow at the Cato Institute, co-wrote The Canceling of the American Mind with Greg Lukianoff and wrote Nothing Serious, a book about dating and relationships among young people.
Omar Youssef Souleimane is a Syrian-born French journalist, poet and writer, born in 1987 near Damascus. His books, published by Flammarion and Plon, include Le Petit Terroriste, Le Dernier Syrien, Être français, Les Complices du mal and Les Héritiers de la haine.
Dominique Sopo is a French teacher and anti-racism activist who has been president of SOS Racisme, the anti-racism association founded in 1984, from 2003 to 2012 and again since 2014. Born in Valenciennes in 1976, he teaches at a high school and at Sciences Po and is a former member of the Socialist Party. He has written books on racism, including Le racisme tue toujours (2026).
Najwa El Haïté is a French lawyer at the Paris bar whose practice covers criminal, business and family law as well as discrimination and secularism cases. She comments on legal and political questions on French television and in 2026 published Maître, sortez-moi de là !, a book about her work.
Thibault de Montbrial is a French lawyer at the Paris bar. He is the president of the Centre de réflexion sur la sécurité intérieure (CRSI), a think tank on domestic security, and a reserve lieutenant colonel in the Gendarmerie.
Jordan Bardella is a French politician who has led the Rassemblement national, France's main far-right party, since 2021, first as acting president and, since November 2022, as its elected president. Born in 1995 in Drancy, he joined the Front national in 2012 and was its spokesperson from 2017 to 2019. He has been a member of the European Parliament since 2019 and has led the Patriots for Europe group there since 2024.
Fabien Roussel is a French politician who has been national secretary of the French Communist Party (PCF) since 2018. Born in Béthune in 1969, he represented the Nord department's 20th constituency in the National Assembly from 2017 to 2024. He was the PCF's candidate in the 2022 presidential election, finishing eighth with 2.28 percent of the vote, and is the party's candidate for the 2027 election.
Gilles Bouleau is a French television journalist who has presented TF1's weekday evening news, Le 20H, since June 2012 and is its editor-in-chief. Born in Paris in 1962, he worked for years as a reporter for TF1 and LCI and spent a decade abroad as a correspondent in London and then Washington. He headed TF1's special operations from 2011 before succeeding Laurence Ferrari as the evening news anchor.
Éric Zemmour is a French writer, former journalist and politician who founded the far-right party Reconquête in 2021 and is its president. Born in 1958 in Montreuil, he worked as a political journalist at Le Quotidien de Paris and Le Figaro, then became a widely followed radio and television commentator on outlets including RTL, Paris Première and CNews. He has written several best-selling essays, among them Le Suicide français (2014). He ran for president in 2022 and finished fourth in the first round with 7.07 percent of the vote. He has been prosecuted many times over his public remarks and has been convicted of offenses including racial insult and incitement to hatred.