Benjamin Morel
Role at the time: Constitutional law scholar at Paris-Pantheon-Assas University, quoted by L'Opinion
Response to this claim
France's existing legal provisions against incitement to racial hatred are insufficient.
“This is the question that often comes up with memory laws: there is a need for recognition, for a symbol, and at the same time the criminal scope of the thing is a problem. Either because it already falls under the law, or because it is plainly an infringement of freedom of expression (Translated from French. Original: On est dans la question qui se pose souvent concernant les lois mémorielles : on a besoin d'une reconnaissance, d'un symbole, et en même temps la portée pénale de la chose pose problème. Soit parce que cela tombe déjà sous le coup de la loi, soit car c'est manifestement attentatoire à la liberté d'expression)”
Why we used this label
Morel argues that a law against replacement rhetoric would either repeat offenses already in the law or infringe free expression, says the courts would likely see it as a disproportionate limit on that freedom, and calls a ban counterproductive, so we labeled it Condemned.