Benjamin Morel says a ban would either repeat existing law or infringe free expression

Benjamin MorelConstitutional law scholar at Paris-Pantheon-Assas University, quoted by L'Opinion

Condemned

Asked by L'Opinion about Rabeh's proposal, Morel calls it a hasty statement that ignores legal realities. He says such a law is technically possible but likely to be found a disproportionate infringement on freedom of expression, and that its criminal scope is a problem either way.

Responding to

France's existing legal provisions against incitement to racial hatred are insufficient.

“This is the question that often comes up with memory laws: there is a need for recognition, for a symbol, and at the same time the criminal scope of the thing is a problem. Either because it already falls under the law, or because it is plainly an infringement of freedom of expression (Translated from French. Original: On est dans la question qui se pose souvent concernant les lois mémorielles : on a besoin d'une reconnaissance, d'un symbole, et en même temps la portée pénale de la chose pose problème. Soit parce que cela tombe déjà sous le coup de la loi, soit car c'est manifestement attentatoire à la liberté d'expression)”

Reporting

Open source (opens in a new tab)Peut-on interdire la théorie du « grand remplacement » comme le réclame le maire de Trappes ?Full article

Case updates

Want the next important update?

Follow this case and get an email when an important development changes the record.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

A neoclassical building with a long row of tall columns under a sculpted pediment inscribed Assemblée nationale, with French and European flags on poles in front of it and a stone bridge and quay wall in the foreground.
Credit: ZeusUpsistos / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Where this statement fits

Trappes mayor Ali Rabeh and Green lawmakers propose punishing "Great Replacement" rhetoric under France's press law; critics say it would curb free speech

On October 30, 2026, a week after the racist attack in Trappes and La Verriere, Trappes mayor Ali Rabeh said on France Inter that existing provisions against incitement to racial hatred were insufficient. He proposed amending Article 24 of France's 1881 press law to punish those who present a group, because of origin, religion, ethnicity or supposed race, as actors in a process of replacement. Green lawmakers filed bills along the same lines: Senator Akli Mellouli and twelve other senators on October 29, and deputies Sabrina Sebaihi and Steevy Gustave in the National Assembly, where the text was registered as bill No. 3458 on November 10. Both bills would state that provocation to discrimination, hatred or violence can result from remarks that invoke the replacement of one population by another or the need for remigration, present a group as a threat because of its origin, and incite its exclusion or discriminatory treatment. Penalties would rise to three years in prison and a 75,000 euro fine when the speaker holds elected office or is a declared candidate. Eric Zemmour likened the proposal to the gulag, Jordan Bardella said the left wanted to criminalize what most French people feel, and constitutional scholar Benjamin Morel said such a law would either repeat existing offenses or disproportionately restrict free expression.

Read the full case

Source and context

Reporting

Peut-on interdire la théorie du « grand remplacement » comme le réclame le maire de Trappes ? (opens in a new tab)Full article

About this source

L'Opinion article on whether the Great Replacement theory could be banned, as Ali Rabeh proposed, with comments from constitutional law scholar Benjamin Morel.

Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Before the quotation

Morel tells L'Opinion that a law of this kind could be written, like the Gayssot law on Holocaust denial, but that the Constitutional Council and the European Court of Human Rights would likely see it as disproportionate. He adds that a formal ban would give the theory wide publicity and would be completely counterproductive.

After the quotation

The remark closes L'Opinion's article.

How this statement is classified

Condemned

The label describes this statement's response within the context above.

Why this label?

Morel argues that a law against replacement rhetoric would either repeat offenses already in the law or infringe free expression, says the courts would likely see it as a disproportionate limit on that freedom, and calls a ban counterproductive, so we labeled it Condemned.

Recorded on
Published here
People and groups discussed
Ali Rabeh

More from this case

Read the full case

Gilles-William Goldnadel calls Ali Rabeh's proposal intellectual terrorism

Gilles-William Goldnadel

“A rerun of Ali Rabeh's intellectual terrorism in wanting to penalize "the ideology of the great replacement." The station has gone so far as to investigate whether the RN practices it. Only one solution: great-replace the odious public broadcaster with a private radio station. (Translated from French. Original: Reprise du terrorisme intellectuel d'Ali Rabeh de vouloir pénaliser « l'idéologie du grand remplacement » . La radio en est à enquêter pour savoir si le RN la pratique. Une seule solution : grand remplacer l'odieux visuel public par une radio privée.)”
Read statement

Jordan Bardella says the left wants to criminalize what most French people feel about demographic change

Jordan Bardella

“If I understand correctly, the left wants to criminalize the feeling of at least 60% of French people, who see a "profound demographic transformation." Unless it is to rejoice in it, of course. ... The freedom-killing left must never prevail in our country. (Translated from French. Original: Si je comprends bien, la gauche veut criminaliser le ressenti d'au moins 60% des Français, qui constatent une « transformation démographique profonde ». Sauf si c'est pour s'en réjouir, évidemment. ... Jamais la gauche liberticide ne doit l'emporter dans notre pays.)”
Read statement

Sabrina Sebaihi says the Great Replacement and remigration are ammunition, not opinions

Sabrina Sebaihi

“Words kill. In Trappes, they killed. With Akli Mellouli and Steevy Gustave, we are filing a bill against racist hate speech. "Great replacement," "remigration": these are not opinions, they are ammunition. Those who promote them must answer for it before the law. (Translated from French. Original: Les mots tuent. À Trappes, ils ont tué. Avec Akli Mellouli et Steevy Gustave, nous déposons une proposition de loi contre les discours de haine raciste. « Grand remplacement », « remigration » : ce ne sont pas des opinions, ce sont des munitions. Leurs promoteurs doivent en répondre devant la loi.)”
Read statement

Share or embed this statement

Quote card: Benjamin Morel, Benjamin Morel says a ban would either repeat existing law or infringe free expressionDownload image (PNG)

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Benjamin Morel says a ban would either repeat existing law or infringe free expression
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/events/9279-asked-by-l-opinion-about-rabeh-s-proposal

Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.

The Dispute Index. "Benjamin Morel says a ban would either repeat existing law or infringe free expression". First published: 2026-11-16. Last updated: 2026-11-16. https://disputeindex.com/events/9279-asked-by-l-opinion-about-rabeh-s-proposal