Tina Peters' lawyer says her midterm plan would seize counted ballots for a hand recount; Colorado Democrats object
Tina Peters' lawyer says her plan for the midterms is to take control of ballots after machines count them and recount them by hand. Polis says any talk of seizing ballot boxes, if it happened, is dangerous, and other Colorado Democrats criticize Peters.
Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Overview
Peters was convicted in 2024 over unauthorized access to Mesa County's election equipment and was released on parole in June 2026 after Polis commuted her sentence. Her website presents a plan asking DHS and CISA to declare a public election-infrastructure risk and to support hand-marked paper ballots and manual checks before certification. A Brennan Center analysis cited by Newsweek concludes that neither the president nor the federal government has blanket authority to seize ballots or election equipment.
Timeline
5 timeline entries on this page. Dates: August 26, 2026 to October 25, 2026
August 2026
Peters publishes her election plan
Source release
Tina Peters' website publishes The Tina Peters Plan, which asks DHS and CISA to declare a public election-infrastructure risk within 48 hours and to support hand-marked paper ballots and manual checks before certification of the November 3 election.
[01]Tina Peters
Tina Peters' website presents her plan for the November 3, 2026 federal election, based on a document titled 2026 Election Infrastructure: Immediate Federal Risk-Mitigation Roadmap. It calls for a public federal risk declaration by DHS and CISA, a Commerce Department review of election equipment, hand-marked paper ballots and manual verification before certification.
The Tina Peters Plan (tinapeters.us) · Tina PetersArticle text
October 2026
Ed Martin says Peters met Trump in the Oval Office
Incident
Former Justice Department official Ed Martin tells Real America's Voice that Peters was in the Oval Office that day talking with President Trump about federal involvement in the midterms. The White House says it does not comment on private meetings that may or may not have happened.
[02]Tina Peters met with Trump to discuss election plans, former Trump administration attorney says (Colorado Newsline)
Colorado Newsline reports Ed Martin's account that Tina Peters met President Trump at the White House on October 5 to discuss election integrity, the White House's refusal to comment on the meeting, and a statement by Colorado Secretary of State Jena Griswold.
Ticktin's description of the plan is reported
Claim
Mediaite reports that Peters' lawyer, Peter Ticktin, told podcaster Joe Oltmann that her idea is to take control of ballots as soon as machines count them and recount them by hand. Ticktin later tells Mediaite he does not see how such a plan could be orchestrated.
[03]Mediaite
Mediaite reports what Peter Ticktin, a lawyer for Tina Peters, told podcaster Joe Oltmann about her plan for the November 3 elections, quotes his later comments to Mediaite, and quotes White House statements about the reported Peters meeting and about the Constitution.
Mediaite report on Peter Ticktin's podcast account of Tina Peters' election plan · MediaiteArticle textNewsweek compares the lawyer's account with the published plan
Newsweek reports there is no evidence Peters asked Trump directly to seize ballots and that her written plan calls for independent hand counts only where feasible.
[04]Newsweek
Newsweek compares Peter Ticktin's podcast description of Tina Peters' proposal with the plan published on her website, and reports that the White House would neither confirm nor deny the reported meeting.
Tina Peters, Seizing Ballots and 'Civil War' Claims Assessed (Newsweek) · NewsweekArticle textPeters appears on 60 Minutes
CBS's 60 Minutes airs an interview with Peters, recorded in August, in which KUNC reports she refused to take accountability for the crimes that put her in prison.
[05]Tina Peters appears on '60 Minutes', part of media blitz in the weeks prior to midterm elections (KUNC)
KUNC, in a story by the Colorado Capitol News Alliance, reports on Tina Peters' 60 Minutes interview, her travel and public appearances since her release, and her parole terms.
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Tina Peters' idea for the November 3 midterms is to take control of ballots as soon as voting machines count them and recount them by hand before certification, and something like that is probably going to happen.
What is disputed
Newsweek found no evidence that Peters asked President Trump directly to seize ballots and notes that her published plan calls for independent hand counts only where feasible. Ticktin later told Mediaite he did not see how such a plan could be orchestrated in time.
Sources (3)
- Mediaite report on Peter Ticktin's podcast account of Tina Peters' election plan · MediaiteArticle text
- Tina Peters, Seizing Ballots and 'Civil War' Claims Assessed (Newsweek) · NewsweekArticle text
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
1 matching response. Newest first.
Tina PetersFormer Mesa County clerk and recorderDirectly involved Before this statement
Peters' website presents a plan calling on DHS and CISA to declare a public election-infrastructure risk and to apply compensating controls before the November 3 federal election.
"Protect the critical infrastructure of our nation's elections before its too late"
Defended or excusedCase context: Tina Peters' lawyer says her midterm plan would seize counted ballots for a hand recount; Colorado Democrats object
Full statement and sources
Peters calls on federal officials, whose accounts she tags, to protect the critical infrastructure of the nation's elections before it is too late.
After the statement
The post tags the accounts of Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency and the Department of Homeland Security, among others.
Tina Peters' October 26 post calling on federal officials to protect election infrastructure · Tina PetersPost textThe Tina Peters Plan (tinapeters.us) · Tina PetersArticle textWhy this label?
The case concerns the federal action Peters has sought for the midterms, including the ballot plan her lawyer describes. In this post she repeats her call for federal officials to act on election infrastructure, a defense of that push.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(8)
Reporting
Mediaite report on Peter Ticktin's podcast account of Tina Peters' election plan
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Mediaite reports what Peter Ticktin, a lawyer for Tina Peters, told podcaster Joe Oltmann about her plan for the November 3 elections, quotes his later comments to Mediaite, and quotes White House statements about the reported Peters meeting and about the Constitution.
- Author
- Kathianne Boniello
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
Tina Peters, Seizing Ballots and 'Civil War' Claims Assessed (Newsweek)
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Newsweek compares Peter Ticktin's podcast description of Tina Peters' proposal with the plan published on her website, and reports that the White House would neither confirm nor deny the reported meeting.
- Author
- James Bickerton
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Tina Peters appears on '60 Minutes', part of media blitz in the weeks prior to midterm elections (KUNC)
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
KUNC, in a story by the Colorado Capitol News Alliance, reports on Tina Peters' 60 Minutes interview, her travel and public appearances since her release, and her parole terms.
- Author
- Bente Birkeland, Nicole Vap, Tom Hesse
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Tina Peters' October 26 post calling on federal officials to protect election infrastructure
About this source
Tina Peters posted this on X on the night of October 25, 2026 (Mountain Time), tagging accounts of Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency and the Department of Homeland Security.
- Author
- Tina Peters
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
The Tina Peters Plan (tinapeters.us)
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Tina Peters' website presents her plan for the November 3, 2026 federal election, based on a document titled 2026 Election Infrastructure: Immediate Federal Risk-Mitigation Roadmap. It calls for a public federal risk declaration by DHS and CISA, a Commerce Department review of election equipment, hand-marked paper ballots and manual verification before certification.
- Author
- Tina Peters
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
John Hickenlooper's October 26 post on Tina Peters
About this source
Sen. John Hickenlooper of Colorado posted this statement about Tina Peters on his Senate account on X on October 26, 2026.
- Author
- John Hickenlooper
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Tina Peters met with Trump to discuss election plans, former Trump administration attorney says (Colorado Newsline)
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Colorado Newsline reports Ed Martin's account that Tina Peters met President Trump at the White House on October 5 to discuss election integrity, the White House's refusal to comment on the meeting, and a statement by Colorado Secretary of State Jena Griswold.
- Author
- Lindsey Toomer
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Without mentioning Tina Peters, Polis calls election interference pitch 'dangerous' (CPR News)
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
CPR News reports Gov. Jared Polis's October 8 statement after reports that Tina Peters spoke with President Trump about a plan to seize ballots after they are counted, along with comments by Peter Ticktin and Colorado County Clerks Association head Matt Crane.
- Author
- Tom Hesse
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Tina Peters' lawyer says her midterm plan would seize counted ballots for a hand recount; Colorado Democrats object
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/tina-peters-lawyer-says-her-midterm-plan-would-seize-counted-ballots-for-a-hand-recount-colorado-democrats-object
The Dispute Index. "Tina Peters' lawyer says her midterm plan would seize counted ballots for a hand recount; Colorado Democrats object". First published: 2026-11-01. Last updated: 2026-11-01. https://disputeindex.com/cases/tina-peters-lawyer-says-her-midterm-plan-would-seize-counted-ballots-for-a-hand-recount-colorado-democrats-object