Texas lawmakers file bills to ban or restrict government license-plate readers for the 2027 session

Rep. John Bucy filed a bill to bar Texas governments from using license-plate readers, calling them a violation of privacy. Other bills would limit their use or cut off state grant money. Houston's police union president calls the cameras one of officers' best tools.

The domed Texas State Capitol, built of pink stone, under a blue sky with white clouds, seen across a lawn and a planted flower bed, with two low stone pavilions at the sides and a Texas flag flying in front of the dome.
The north side of the Texas State Capitol in Austin, where the Texas Legislature meets, photographed on June 7, 2015. The photo predates the 2026 dispute and does not show its events.

Case period:

Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated

Overview

In 2023 the Legislature passed a bill by Alvarado that added a $1 annual fee to Texas auto insurance policies to fund programs against catalytic converter theft. An August 2026 Texas Tribune investigation found that the Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority had used more than $30 million of that money to help install at least 3,200 Flock cameras. Gov. Greg Abbott then froze state funding for the cameras, and several cities ended their Flock contracts. Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa made opposition to the cameras part of her campaign against Abbott. The 90th Legislature convenes on January 12, 2027, and each bill would need to pass the House and Senate before going to the governor.

Background: What are license-plate readers?

People in this case

Timeline

3 timeline entries on this page. Dates: November 9, 2026

  1. November 2026

    1. Bucy files a bill to bar Texas governments from using plate readers

      Rep. John Bucy files House Bill 331 as bill filing opens for the 2027 session. It would bar state and local government entities from using automatic license plate readers and let people harmed by a violation sue for damages.

      [01]H.B. 331, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text

      Rep. John Bucy's House Bill 331 would bar Texas government entities and their officers and employees from using automatic license plate readers and would let people harmed by a violation sue for damages.

      H.B. 331, 90th Legislature: introduced bill textSection 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 750.004, introduced version
      [02]The Texas Tribune

      The Texas Tribune reports Sen. Carol Alvarado's bill to end Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority grants for plate readers, the state funding behind thousands of Flock cameras, and the House bills by Bucy, González and Harrison.

      Lawmakers propose banning Flock camera grants by Texas agency · The Texas TribuneArticle text, Alvarado bill and related House bills
    2. Harrison and González file bills to restrict plate-reader use

      Rep. Brian Harrison files House Bill 847, requiring a warrant or court order for police use of plate readers, and Rep. Mary González files House Bill 763, limiting government use to listed purposes with 48-hour data destruction.

      [03]H.B. 847, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text

      Rep. Brian Harrison's House Bill 847 would allow law enforcement use of license plate readers only under a warrant or court order, for violent-offense investigations, with annual public reports.

      H.B. 847, 90th Legislature: introduced bill textSection 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 750.004(b), introduced version
      [04]H.B. 763, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text

      Rep. Mary González's House Bill 763 would limit government plate-reader use to listed purposes, restrict sharing of plate data, require most data to be destroyed within 48 hours and create a civil remedy.

      H.B. 763, 90th Legislature: introduced bill textSection 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 732.003(a), introduced version
      [05]Texas bills target Flock cameras, THC workplace rules, school funding and data center water use

      FOX 26 Houston reports that bill filing for the 2027 session opened November 9 and summarizes Rep. Brian Harrison's House Bill 847, with comments from a Harris County constable's office official on plate-reader data.

      [06]KPRC 2: Ban or restrict? Three Texas bills target Flock and other license plate cameras

      KPRC 2 describes House Bills 331, 847 and 763 and quotes Rep. John Bucy on his proposed ban and Houston Police Officers' Union president Douglas Griffith on the value of the cameras.

    3. Alvarado files a bill to end insurance-fee funding for plate readers

      Sen. Carol Alvarado files Senate Bill 232 with Sens. Roland Gutierrez, José Menéndez and Taylor Rehmet. It would bar the Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority's insurer fee from paying for automatic license plate readers.

      [07]S.B. 232, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text

      Sen. Carol Alvarado's Senate Bill 232 would bar money from the Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority's insurer fee from being used to buy, use or contract for automatic license plate readers.

      S.B. 232, 90th Legislature: introduced bill textSection 1, amended Transportation Code Sec. 1006.153(f), introduced version
      [02]The Texas Tribune

      The Texas Tribune reports Sen. Carol Alvarado's bill to end Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority grants for plate readers, the state funding behind thousands of Flock cameras, and the House bills by Bucy, González and Harrison.

      Lawmakers propose banning Flock camera grants by Texas agency · The Texas TribuneArticle text, Alvarado bill and related House bills

Response record

Responses

Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.

5 matching responses. Newest first.

  1. John Bucy IIITexas state representative for House District 136 and author of House Bill 331, in an interview with KPRC 2Directly involved

    Before this statement

    Bucy told KPRC 2 that lawmakers need to sit at the table and talk about whether there is ever a good reason to have the cameras. He said the technology's expansion has outpaced protections for Texans.

    "It's been a total violation of our privacy and security and liberty"
    Condemned

    Case context: Texas lawmakers file bills to ban or restrict government license-plate readers for the 2027 session

    Full statement and sources

    Bucy, whose House Bill 331 would bar Texas government entities from using license-plate readers, told KPRC 2 that the technology's spread has been a total violation of Texans' privacy, security and liberty.

    After the statement

    Bucy said he is open to compromise and to talks with lawmakers from both parties about possible safeguards, including strict rules on how the cameras could be used for safety without restricting liberty.

    H.B. 331, 90th Legislature: introduced bill textSection 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 750.004, introduced version

    Why this label?

    Bucy says the spread of plate-reader cameras has violated Texans' privacy, security and liberty, and his bill would bar every Texas government entity from using them. He says he is open to talks about strict limits, but his statement rejects the cameras as they are used now.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  2. Douglas GriffithPresident of the Houston Police Officers' Union, in an interview with KPRC 2Directly involved

    Before this statement

    Griffith said removing the cameras would hurt officers' ability to identify and apprehend suspects.

    "They're one of the best tools that we have for law enforcement"
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Texas lawmakers file bills to ban or restrict government license-plate readers for the 2027 session

    Full statement and sources

    Griffith, president of the Houston Police Officers' Union, told KPRC 2 that removing license-plate cameras would hurt officers' ability to identify and arrest suspects, and called them one of the best tools law enforcement has.

    After the statement

    He described a shooting during FIFA events in Houston, when an officer with Flock access helped locate a suspect's vehicle within minutes. He said the cameras should be used strictly for law enforcement purposes and that misuse should bring strict penalties.

    Why this label?

    Griffith argues against removing the cameras, saying they are one of the best tools police have for finding suspects. He backs strict penalties for searches made without a law enforcement purpose instead of a ban.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  3. Brian HarrisonTexas state representative for House District 10 and author of House Bill 847Directly involved

    Before this statement

    Harrison, a Republican from Midlothian, filed House Bill 847 as bill filing opened for the 2027 session. The Texas Tribune reported that he filed similar legislation in the previous two sessions.

    "A law enforcement agency may use an automatic license plate reader only as authorized by a warrant or court order."
    Mixed or conditional

    Case context: Texas lawmakers file bills to ban or restrict government license-plate readers for the 2027 session

    Full statement and sources

    Harrison's House Bill 847 would let Texas law enforcement agencies use license-plate readers only under a warrant or court order, limit the images and data to violent-crime investigations and require other data to be destroyed promptly.

    After the statement

    The bill would limit images and related data to investigations of violent offenses, require other data to be destroyed promptly after collection, bar data-sharing agreements for other purposes and require agencies to publish a use policy and an annual report.

    H.B. 847, 90th Legislature: introduced bill textSection 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 750.004(b), introduced version
    Lawmakers propose banning Flock camera grants by Texas agency · The Texas TribuneArticle text, Alvarado bill and related House bills

    Why this label?

    Harrison's bill would keep plate readers available to police only when a warrant or court order authorizes them and only for violent-crime investigations. It would neither ban the cameras nor leave their current use in place.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  4. Mary GonzálezTexas state representative for House District 75 and author of House Bill 763Directly involved

    Before this statement

    González, a Democrat from Clint, filed House Bill 763, which would bar Texas government entities from operating plate-reader systems or using their data except for the purposes the bill lists.

    "Subject to Subsection (b), a governmental entity may operate an automatic license plate reader system or use captured plate data produced by the system only for the following purposes: (1) detecting or investigating a criminal offense punishable as a felony; (2) identifying unregistered or uninsured motor vehicles; (3) investigating a report of a missing person; (4) identifying or recovering a stolen motor vehicle; (5) collecting or enforcing tolls or enforcing parking requirements; or (6) controlling access to a secured area."
    Mixed or conditional

    Case context: Texas lawmakers file bills to ban or restrict government license-plate readers for the 2027 session

    Full statement and sources

    González's House Bill 763 would let Texas government entities operate license-plate readers only for listed purposes, including felony investigations, missing-person cases and stolen-vehicle recovery, and would require most plate data to be destroyed within 48 hours.

    After the statement

    The bill would bar sharing captured plate data with private parties and the federal government, require most data to be destroyed within 48 hours unless it is evidence or covered by a preservation request, court order or warrant, and let people harmed by a violation sue for damages.

    H.B. 763, 90th Legislature: introduced bill textSection 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 732.003(a), introduced version
    Lawmakers propose banning Flock camera grants by Texas agency · The Texas TribuneArticle text, Alvarado bill and related House bills

    Why this label?

    González's bill would keep plate readers in government hands for felony investigations, missing persons, stolen vehicles, tolls and a few other listed uses, while barring other uses and most data sharing. It would neither ban the cameras nor leave their current use unchanged.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  5. Carol AlvaradoTexas state senator for District 6 and author of Senate Bill 232Directly involved

    Before this statement

    Alvarado's 2023 law added a $1 annual fee to Texas auto insurance policies to fight catalytic converter theft. The Texas Tribune found that the Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority used more than $30 million of that money to help install at least 3,200 Flock cameras, which Alvarado said were never discussed as her bill passed.

    "Notwithstanding Subsection (e), a fee deposited to the credit of the general revenue fund under that subsection may not be used to purchase or use, or contract with a person to purchase or use, an automatic license plate reader."
    Mixed or conditional

    Case context: Texas lawmakers file bills to ban or restrict government license-plate readers for the 2027 session

    Full statement and sources

    Alvarado's Senate Bill 232 would bar money from the Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority's insurer fee, created by her 2023 law, from being used to buy, use or contract for license-plate readers.

    After the statement

    Democratic Sens. Roland Gutierrez, José Menéndez and Taylor Rehmet joined the bill as co-authors. The Texas Tribune reported that Alvarado's office said the bill aims to end the authority's grants for automatic license plate readers.

    S.B. 232, 90th Legislature: introduced bill textSection 1, amended Transportation Code Sec. 1006.153(f), introduced version
    Lawmakers propose banning Flock camera grants by Texas agency · The Texas TribuneArticle text, Alvarado bill and related House bills

    Why this label?

    Alvarado's bill would cut off the insurance-fee money that paid for thousands of Flock cameras along Texas roads. It would not bar governments from using plate readers paid for in other ways.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

Sources

(7)

Original text

H.B. 331, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text

H.B. 331, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text (opens in a new tab)Section 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 750.004, introduced version
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Section 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 750.004, introduced version

About this source

Rep. John Bucy's House Bill 331 would bar Texas government entities and their officers and employees from using automatic license plate readers and would let people harmed by a violation sue for damages.

Author
Texas Legislature Online
Published
Accessed

Original text

S.B. 232, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text

S.B. 232, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text (opens in a new tab)Section 1, amended Transportation Code Sec. 1006.153(f), introduced version
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Section 1, amended Transportation Code Sec. 1006.153(f), introduced version

About this source

Sen. Carol Alvarado's Senate Bill 232 would bar money from the Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority's insurer fee from being used to buy, use or contract for automatic license plate readers.

Author
Texas Legislature Online
Published
Accessed

Original text

H.B. 763, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text

H.B. 763, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text (opens in a new tab)Section 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 732.003(a), introduced version
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Section 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 732.003(a), introduced version

About this source

Rep. Mary González's House Bill 763 would limit government plate-reader use to listed purposes, restrict sharing of plate data, require most data to be destroyed within 48 hours and create a civil remedy.

Author
Texas Legislature Online
Published
Accessed

Original text

H.B. 847, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text

H.B. 847, 90th Legislature: introduced bill text (opens in a new tab)Section 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 750.004(b), introduced version
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Section 1, proposed Transportation Code Sec. 750.004(b), introduced version

About this source

Rep. Brian Harrison's House Bill 847 would allow law enforcement use of license plate readers only under a warrant or court order, for violent-offense investigations, with annual public reports.

Author
Texas Legislature Online
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Texas bills target Flock cameras, THC workplace rules, school funding and data center water use

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Article text, House Bill 847 section

About this source

FOX 26 Houston reports that bill filing for the 2027 session opened November 9 and summarizes Rep. Brian Harrison's House Bill 847, with comments from a Harris County constable's office official on plate-reader data.

Author
Karys Belger
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Lawmakers propose banning Flock camera grants by Texas agency

Lawmakers propose banning Flock camera grants by Texas agency (opens in a new tab) · The Texas TribuneArticle text, Alvarado bill and related House bills
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Article text, Alvarado bill and related House bills

About this source

The Texas Tribune reports Sen. Carol Alvarado's bill to end Motor Vehicle Crime Prevention Authority grants for plate readers, the state funding behind thousands of Flock cameras, and the House bills by Bucy, González and Harrison.

Author
Ayden Runnels
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

KPRC 2: Ban or restrict? Three Texas bills target Flock and other license plate cameras

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Article text, Bucy and Griffith interview quotes

About this source

KPRC 2 describes House Bills 331, 847 and 763 and quotes Rep. John Bucy on his proposed ban and Houston Police Officers' Union president Douglas Griffith on the value of the cameras.

Author
Jaewon Jung
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Case updates

Want the next important update?

Follow this case and get an email when an important development changes the record.

8 updates added in the last 14 days.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

The newsletter

Follow disputes like this one.

New cases and significant updates to the record, in your inbox. Free.

You’ll confirm your subscription on Substack.

Share or embed this case

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Texas lawmakers file bills to ban or restrict government license-plate readers for the 2027 session
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/cases/texas-2027-bills-ban-or-restrict-license-plate-readers

The Dispute Index. "Texas lawmakers file bills to ban or restrict government license-plate readers for the 2027 session". First published: 2026-11-16. Last updated: 2026-11-17. https://disputeindex.com/cases/texas-2027-bills-ban-or-restrict-license-plate-readers