Scott Galloway calls Elon Musk "a traitor to the West" and invokes the Rosenbergs' execution; critics say he suggested Musk should be killed
Scott Galloway called Elon Musk a traitor to the West on Pivot and invoked the Rosenbergs' execution. Jason Calacanis, Blake Scholl, Megyn Kelly and Dave Rubin said he was suggesting Musk should be killed.
Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Where it stands
ActiveAs of
Established
- On a live Pivot episode released Nov. 3, Galloway called Musk a traitor to the West and said the Rosenbergs were lined up against a wall.Pivot: Hillary Clinton Warns About Trump's Next Move After the Midterms (opens in a new tab)
- On the Prof G Podcast, Galloway tied the charge to Musk's restriction of Starlink service in Ukraine and said he believed it while calling it incendiary.NYU professor and podcaster calls Elon Musk a 'traitor,' compares him to Soviet spies excuted during Cold War (opens in a new tab)
- Boom Supersonic chief executive Blake Scholl said Galloway is an investor in Boom and that he was working to buy out Galloway's shares.Blake Scholl X post on Scott Galloway's stake in Boom Supersonic (opens in a new tab)MUSK ATTACKED AS 'TRAITOR': CEO moves to OUST investor over INCENDIARY remark (opens in a new tab)
Disputed
- Calacanis, Scholl, Kelly and Rubin say the Rosenberg comparison amounts to saying Musk should be executed. Galloway's remarks do not say so outright.Jason Calacanis X post on Scott Galloway and Elon Musk (opens in a new tab)Blake Scholl X post on Scott Galloway's stake in Boom Supersonic (opens in a new tab)DISGUSTING: Scott Galloway Literally Wants Elon Musk Executed For Treason (opens in a new tab)Massive Outrage After Scott Galloway Makes Dangerous Threat to Elon Musk (opens in a new tab)Pivot: Hillary Clinton Warns About Trump's Next Move After the Midterms (opens in a new tab)See the claim
- Galloway says Musk's handling of Starlink in Ukraine makes him a traitor to the West. Musk says Ukraine's use of the civilian service for offensive drone strikes was never allowed.NYU professor and podcaster calls Elon Musk a 'traitor,' compares him to Soviet spies excuted during Cold War (opens in a new tab)See the claim
Not yet known
- Whether Galloway has answered critics who say he suggested Musk should be executed.
- Whether Galloway has sold his shares in Boom Supersonic, and on what terms.
- Whether Musk has responded publicly to Galloway's remarks.
Overview
Galloway co-hosts the Pivot podcast with Kara Swisher and hosts the Prof G Podcast. His remarks followed reports that SpaceX had restricted Starlink service used by Ukrainian forces; Musk said, "Using Starlink, a civilian commercial service, for offensive drone strikes to kill people has never been allowed." Julius and Ethel Rosenberg were executed in 1953 after their conviction for conspiring to commit espionage for the Soviet Union in a case involving U.S. atomic secrets. Galloway did not say in either remark that Musk should be put to death; his critics read the Rosenberg comparison as saying so.
People in this case
Scott GallowayDirectly involved
Elon MuskDirectly involved
Dave RubinCommented
Megyn KellyCommented
Timeline
5 timeline entries on this page. Dates: November 3, 2026 to November 14, 2026
November 2026
Galloway calls Musk a traitor to the West on a live Pivot episode
Claim
Pivot releases an episode recorded live at the Beacon Theatre in New York. In it, Galloway says the idolatry of innovators lets them live by a different standard, calls Musk a traitor to the West, and says, "We lined up the Rosenbergs against a wall."
Galloway repeats the comparison on the Prof G Podcast
Claim
On his Prof G Podcast, Galloway ties the charge to Musk's restriction of Starlink service in Ukraine, says the Rosenbergs were executed for being traitors, and says he believes Musk is a traitor to the West while acknowledging the statement is incendiary.
Boom Supersonic chief executive moves to buy out Galloway's shares
Reaction
Quoting Jason Calacanis's post that Galloway wants Musk executed, Blake Scholl says Galloway is an investor in Boom Supersonic, calls the remarks a step too far, and says he is working to arrange a buyout of Galloway's shares.
Megyn Kelly plays both remarks on her show
Reaction
Kelly plays Galloway's Pivot and Prof G Podcast remarks, says his meaning was clear even though he did not say Musk should be killed, and says he has lost his mind.
Scholl tells Fox Business that Galloway is likely to leave Boom's shareholder list amicably
Reaction
In a Fox Business interview, Scholl says it looks like Galloway will be bought out amicably, says calling for Musk's death is not appropriate, and asks whether Galloway would say the same about him over a political decision.
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Scott GallowayElon Musk is a traitor to the West and should be held to the same standards as every other traitor in the West.
What is disputed
Galloway made the charge on Pivot and repeated it on the Prof G Podcast, where he tied it to SpaceX's restriction of Starlink service in Ukraine and compared that to a hypothetical in which Charles Lindbergh throttled the guidance systems of bombers lent to Britain. Musk has said Ukraine's use of the civilian Starlink service for offensive drone strikes was never allowed.
Sources (2)
- Pivot: Hillary Clinton Warns About Trump's Next Move After the Midterms50:09 to 53:06 of the 1:16:54 video
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Jason CalacanisBy invoking the Rosenbergs' execution, Scott Galloway was saying that Elon Musk should be executed.
What is disputed
Galloway's remarks compare Musk with Julius and Ethel Rosenberg, who were executed for espionage, but do not say outright that Musk should be put to death. Jason Calacanis wrote that Galloway "wants Elon executed," and Megyn Kelly said that although Galloway did not say so directly, his meaning was clear.
Sources (3)
- Jason Calacanis X post on Scott Galloway and Elon Musk · Jason CalacanisPost text
- Blake Scholl X post on Scott Galloway's stake in Boom Supersonic · Blake SchollPost text
- DISGUSTING: Scott Galloway Literally Wants Elon Musk Executed For Treason · Megyn Kelly0:23 to 2:32 of the 14:15 video
In their own words
Their own account
Statements from the person or group whose act or claim this case is about. They are listed apart from the responses, and each label says what the speaker did with their own act or claim.
Scott GallowayNYU professor and host of the Prof G Podcast, on his podcast"And my question is, or my thesis is, we took the Rosenbergs and put them up against a wall and executed them for being traitors. And I realize this is an incendiary statement, but I'll make it, and I believe it. I think Elon Musk is a traitor to the West."
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
Stood by itResponding to: Elon Musk is a traitor to the West and should be held to the same standards as every other traitor in the West.
Full statement and sources
On the Prof G Podcast on Election Day, Galloway describes a hypothetical in which Charles Lindbergh disabled the guidance systems of bombers lent to Britain and says it has almost exactly played out with Musk throttling back Starlink in Ukraine. He says the United States executed the Rosenbergs for being traitors, acknowledges the statement is incendiary, and calls Musk a traitor to the West.
Before the statement
Galloway had called Musk a traitor to the West at a live Pivot taping in New York. On the Prof G Podcast, he described a hypothetical in which Charles Lindbergh, opposing war with Germany, bought an aircraft maker and turned off the guidance systems of bombers lent to Britain, and said, "I believe that has almost exactly played out in the last few weeks with Elon Musk throttling back Starlink".
After the statement
Galloway added that the idolatry of innovators and money had created "a cloud cover such that traitors to the West are not seen as traitors to the West". Fox News Digital reported that it asked Musk for comment and did not immediately receive a response.
NYU professor and podcaster calls Elon Musk a 'traitor,' compares him to Soviet spies excuted during Cold War · Fox NewsArticle textPivot: Hillary Clinton Warns About Trump's Next Move After the Midterms50:09 to 53:06 of the 1:16:54 videoWhy this label?
Galloway repeats the Rosenberg comparison he made on Pivot, says he knows it is incendiary but believes it, and again calls Musk a traitor to the West, so we labeled it Stood by it.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
4 responses. Newest first.
Dave RubinHost of The Rubin Report, in a video posted to YouTube"He is a moderate, moderate, moderate who now you wanna paint as a right-wing maniac who you want to put up against the wall and have executed."
CondemnedResponding to: By invoking the Rosenbergs' execution, Scott Galloway was saying that Elon Musk should be executed.
Full statement and sources
After playing Galloway's Pivot remark, Rubin lists Musk's companies and projects, says Musk was a Democrat until a few years ago, and says Galloway now wants to paint him as a right-wing maniac to be put up against a wall and executed.
Before the statement
The video opens with Galloway's Pivot remark that Musk is a traitor to the West and that the Rosenbergs were lined up against a wall.
After the statement
Rubin's remark ends the video.
Massive Outrage After Scott Galloway Makes Dangerous Threat to Elon Musk · Dave RubinFull 54-second videoWhy this label?
Rubin rejects Galloway's remark, calling Musk a moderate and saying Galloway wants him put up against a wall and executed, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Megyn KellyHost of The Megyn Kelly Show, in a segment posted to YouTube"He didn't say let's kill him. But once again, it's a I want the food product that has red sauce and cheese on top and dough underneath. We know what that is. We know exactly what you're saying. We know what happened to the Rosenbergs."
CondemnedResponding to: By invoking the Rosenbergs' execution, Scott Galloway was saying that Elon Musk should be executed.
Full statement and sources
After playing Galloway's Pivot remark, Kelly says he did not say outright that Musk should be killed but compares his wording to describing a pizza without naming it, and says the audience knows what happened to the Rosenbergs. She says Galloway has lost his mind.
Before the statement
Kelly introduced Galloway as Kara Swisher's podcast co-host, said he "used to be kind of normal" and had lost his mind, and played his Pivot remark about Musk and the Rosenbergs.
After the statement
Kelly then played Galloway's Prof G Podcast remark from the same day and discussed both with her guest, journalist Matt Taibbi.
DISGUSTING: Scott Galloway Literally Wants Elon Musk Executed For Treason · Megyn Kelly0:23 to 2:32 of the 14:15 videoWhy this label?
Kelly says Galloway's Rosenberg comparison plainly pointed to Musk's death and that he has lost his mind, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Blake SchollFounder and chief executive of Boom Supersonic, in a post on X"Sad to say @profgalloway is an investor in Boom. I don't mind disagreements but calling for an execution of a non-criminal (worse, an actual hero!) is a step too far. Working to arrange a buy-out of his shares."
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
CondemnedResponding to: By invoking the Rosenbergs' execution, Scott Galloway was saying that Elon Musk should be executed.
Full statement and sources
Quoting Calacanis's post that Galloway wants Musk executed, Scholl says Galloway is an investor in Boom Supersonic and that calling for the execution of "a non-criminal (worse, an actual hero!)" is a step too far. He says he is working to arrange a buyout of Galloway's shares.
Before the statement
Scholl was quoting a post by investor Jason Calacanis that said Galloway was doubling down and wanted Musk executed.
After the statement
In a Fox Business interview, Scholl said it looked like Galloway would leave Boom's list of shareholders amicably and said that "calling for his death is not appropriate."
Blake Scholl X post on Scott Galloway's stake in Boom Supersonic · Blake SchollPost textMUSK ATTACKED AS 'TRAITOR': CEO moves to OUST investor over INCENDIARY remark · Fox Business0:38 to 3:40 of the 4:16 videoWhy this label?
Scholl reads Galloway's remarks as calling for Musk's execution, says that is a step too far, and moves to buy out Galloway's shares in his company, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Jason CalacanisInvestor and co-host of the All-In podcast, in a post on X".@profgalloway of @ProfGMarkets, @PivotPod, @voxdotcom and @NYMag is doubling down: he wants Elon executed. There is no justification for calling for murder in civil society. You support this @Bankoff?"
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
CondemnedResponding to: By invoking the Rosenbergs' execution, Scott Galloway was saying that Elon Musk should be executed.
Full statement and sources
Calacanis, quoting a clip of Galloway's remarks, says Galloway is doubling down and wants Musk executed. He says there is no justification for calling for murder in civil society and asks the account he tags, @Bankoff, whether he supports it.
Before the statement
Calacanis quoted a post by The Vigilant Fox account that shared a clip of Galloway saying the Rosenbergs were executed for being traitors and calling Musk a traitor to the West.
After the statement
Boom Supersonic chief executive Blake Scholl quoted Calacanis's post and said he was working to buy out Galloway's shares in his company.
Jason Calacanis X post on Scott Galloway and Elon Musk · Jason CalacanisPost textBlake Scholl X post on Scott Galloway's stake in Boom Supersonic · Blake SchollPost textWhy this label?
Calacanis says Galloway wants Musk executed and that there is no justification for calling for murder, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(7)
Original video
Pivot: Hillary Clinton Warns About Trump's Next Move After the Midterms
About this source
Pivot episode recorded live at the Beacon Theatre in New York to open the show's 2026 tour and posted to its YouTube channel on November 3, 2026. In the wins-and-fails segment near the end, Scott Galloway says the idolatry of innovators lets them live by a different standard, calls Elon Musk a traitor to the West, and poses a hypothetical about Charles Lindbergh throttling the guidance systems of bombers lent to Britain. He then says Musk should be held to the same standards as every other traitor in the West.
- Author
- Pivot with Kara Swisher and Scott Galloway
- Published
- Accessed
Interview
MUSK ATTACKED AS 'TRAITOR': CEO moves to OUST investor over INCENDIARY remark
About this source
Fox Business interview with Boom Supersonic chief executive Blake Scholl, posted to the network's YouTube channel on November 14, 2026. Scholl says it looks like Galloway will leave Boom's list of shareholders amicably, says calling for Musk's death is not appropriate, and asks whether Galloway would say the same about him if he made a political decision Galloway disliked.
- Author
- Fox Business
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
Massive Outrage After Scott Galloway Makes Dangerous Threat to Elon Musk
About this source
Short video posted by The Rubin Report on November 15, 2026. It plays Galloway's Pivot remark about Musk and the Rosenbergs, then Dave Rubin responds, describing Musk as a moderate and saying Galloway wants him put against a wall and executed.
- Author
- The Rubin Report
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
DISGUSTING: Scott Galloway Literally Wants Elon Musk Executed For Treason
About this source
Segment of The Megyn Kelly Show posted to Kelly's YouTube channel on November 10, 2026, with journalist Matt Taibbi as guest. Kelly plays Galloway's Pivot and Prof G Podcast remarks about Musk and the Rosenbergs, says Galloway did not say outright that Musk should be killed but that his meaning was clear, and then discusses the remarks with Taibbi.
- Author
- Megyn Kelly
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Blake Scholl X post on Scott Galloway's stake in Boom Supersonic
About this source
X post by Boom Supersonic founder and chief executive Blake Scholl, quoting Calacanis's post. Scholl says Galloway is an investor in Boom and that he is working to arrange a buyout of Galloway's shares.
- Author
- Blake Scholl (@bscholl)
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Jason Calacanis X post on Scott Galloway and Elon Musk
About this source
X post by investor and podcast host Jason Calacanis, quoting another account's clip of Galloway's Prof G Podcast remarks about Musk and the Rosenbergs. Calacanis lists the outlets Galloway works with and tags Jim Bankoff.
- Author
- @jason (@Jason)
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
NYU professor and podcaster calls Elon Musk a 'traitor,' compares him to Soviet spies excuted during Cold War
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Fox News Digital report on Galloway's Election Day remarks on the Prof G Podcast, where he compared Musk's handling of Starlink service in Ukraine to a Charles Lindbergh hypothetical and called Musk a traitor to the West. It also quotes his earlier Pivot remark, Musk's explanation of the Starlink restriction, and a statement from Theo Wold, a former White House domestic policy aide.
- Author
- Alexander Hall
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Scott Galloway calls Elon Musk "a traitor to the West" and invokes the Rosenbergs' execution; critics say he suggested Musk should be killed
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/scott-galloway-calls-elon-musk-a-traitor-and-invokes-the-rosenbergs
The Dispute Index. "Scott Galloway calls Elon Musk "a traitor to the West" and invokes the Rosenbergs' execution; critics say he suggested Musk should be killed". First published: 2026-11-19. Last updated: 2026-11-19. https://disputeindex.com/cases/scott-galloway-calls-elon-musk-a-traitor-and-invokes-the-rosenbergs