A crowd recites the Lord's Prayer over an imam invited to open a Bartow City Commission meeting; city officials stand by the invitation
People at a Bartow, Florida, City Commission meeting recited the Lord's Prayer and shouted over an imam invited to give the invocation. City officials say the opening prayer is open to all faiths; the Freedom From Religion Foundation says meetings should not include prayer.
People in the audience recite the Lord's Prayer and shout as Imam Sajid R. Bhuiya waits to give the invocation, then the start of his prayer, at the Bartow City Commission meeting, Nov. 16, 2026.
Two excerpts joined by a one-second black gap: 2:06 to 4:15 and 12:04 to 12:57 of the City of Bartow video. DI added its logo in the corner.
Video: City of Bartow, Florida
Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: 0:02:10 to 0:14:05)
Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Where it stands
ActiveAs of
Established
- Imam Sajid R. Bhuiya gave the invocation at the November 16 meeting after people in the audience recited the Lord's Prayer and shouted while he waited at the podium.City of Bartow video: City Commission meeting of November 16, 2026, invocation (opens in a new tab)WFLA: Imam's invocation at Bartow City Commission meeting disrupted by shouting crowd (opens in a new tab)
- The city says police escorted out of the chambers the people who refused to stay silent and that no one was arrested.WFLA: All faiths welcome in Bartow, city officials respond after prayer disruption (opens in a new tab)
- City Attorney Sean Parker says he suggested inviting the mosque after a member of a local Hindu temple asked to give an invocation on dates that did not work.City of Bartow video: City Commission meeting of November 16, 2026, City Attorney Sean Parker on the invitation (opens in a new tab)WTSP: Muslim prayer sparks backlash at Bartow City Commission meeting (opens in a new tab)
Disputed
- The city says opening its invocation to all faiths is consistent with the Constitution. Several speakers at the November 16 meeting objected to an Islamic prayer opening a city meeting.WFLA: All faiths welcome in Bartow, city officials respond after prayer disruption (opens in a new tab)WTSP: Muslim prayer sparks backlash at Bartow City Commission meeting (opens in a new tab)See the claim
- The Freedom From Religion Foundation says government meetings should not open with any prayer. City officials defend opening meetings with a prayer open to all faiths.Freedom From Religion Foundation Bluesky post on the Bartow invocation (opens in a new tab)WFLA: All faiths welcome in Bartow, city officials respond after prayer disruption (opens in a new tab)
Not yet known
- Whether the City Commission will change how it schedules or conducts its opening invocation.
- Who organized the people from other cities who, the city says, joined residents in trying to stop the imam from speaking.
Overview
At the start of the Bartow, Florida, City Commission meeting on November 16, 2026, Imam Sajid R. Bhuiya of the Masjid Al Nur mosque was called to give the invocation. People in the audience recited the Lord's Prayer and shouted while he waited at the podium, and one told him to go back where he came from. He delivered his prayer more than nine minutes after he was called. The city says police escorted out those who refused to stay silent and that no one was arrested. Commissioner Trish Pfeiffer said commissioners had received 214 emails about the invocation and that elected officials serve residents of every faith. City Attorney Sean Parker said he suggested inviting the mosque after a member of a local Hindu temple asked to give an invocation. In a statement on November 18, the city said its opening prayer has historically followed Christian traditions but is open to all faiths, which it called consistent with the U.S. Constitution.
Read the full background
Bartow opens its commission meetings with an invocation by a local faith leader or one of its elected officials. City Attorney Sean Parker told the November 16 meeting that in his 19 years in the job almost every prayer had been offered by a member of a Christian church. He said a member of a local Hindu temple had asked the clerk's office to give an invocation, that the dates offered did not work, and that he then suggested reaching out to the city's mosque. The imam accepted when an opening came up on the November 16 agenda (WTSP (opens in a new tab); Daily Ridge (opens in a new tab)).
In the city's recording of the meeting (opens in a new tab), people in the audience recite the Lord's Prayer, chant "USA" and tell the imam to go back where he came from while he waits at the podium. Mayor Tanya Tucker warned that people would be asked to leave, and commissioners told the audience they could speak during public comment (WFLA (opens in a new tab); Daily Ridge (opens in a new tab)). The city says those who refused to stay silent were escorted out by Bartow police and that no one was arrested (WFLA (opens in a new tab)).
More than 15 people spoke during public comment, most about the invocation. Several objected to an Islamic prayer opening a city meeting, and others spoke for religious inclusion (WTSP (opens in a new tab); Daily Ridge (opens in a new tab)). Commissioner Trish Pfeiffer, after speaking as a commissioner, said she wanted to speak as a Christian and then led those present in the Lord's Prayer.
Timeline
3 timeline entries on this page. Dates: November 16, 2026 to November 18, 2026
November 2026
People in the audience recite the Lord's Prayer as the imam is called to give the invocation
Incident
When Imam Sajid R. Bhuiya of the Masjid Al Nur mosque is called to the podium, people in the audience recite the Lord's Prayer, chant and shout over him, and one tells him to go back where he came from. He waits, then delivers a prayer asking for guidance for the commissioners and respect among people of different faiths.
Commissioner Pfeiffer and City Attorney Parker address the invocation before public comment
Reaction
Pfeiffer says commissioners received 214 emails about the invocation and that officials serve residents of every faith. Parker says he suggested inviting the mosque after a member of a local Hindu temple asked to give an invocation. More than 15 people then speak during public comment, most about the prayer.
City of Bartow says its opening prayer is open to all faiths
Reaction
In a written statement, the city says its invocation has historically followed Christian traditions but is open to all faiths, that people who refused to stay silent were escorted out by police without arrests, and that city officials want Bartow to stay welcoming to everyone.
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by City of BartowCity of Bartow
Opening the Bartow City Commission's invocation to leaders of all faiths, including an imam, is consistent with the U.S. Constitution.
What is disputed
The City of Bartow made this argument in its November 18 statement after people at the November 16 meeting tried to stop the imam from praying. Several speakers during public comment objected to an Islamic prayer opening a city meeting, and the Freedom From Religion Foundation says government meetings should not include prayer at all.
Sources (3)
- Freedom From Religion Foundation Bluesky post on the Bartow invocation · Freedom From Religion FoundationPost text
In their own words
Their own account
Statements from the person or group whose act or claim this case is about. They are listed apart from the responses, and each label says what the speaker did with their own act or claim.
City of BartowMunicipal government of Bartow, Florida, in a written statement "While historically the opening invocation/prayer is one based on Christian traditions, the opportunity is open to all faiths. This is consistent with the United States Constitution."
Stood by itResponding to: Opening the Bartow City Commission's invocation to leaders of all faiths, including an imam, is consistent with the U.S. Constitution.
Full statement and sources
The city says its meetings have opened with a prayer by a faith leader or an elected official for years and that the opportunity is open to all faiths. It says people who tried to stop the imam from speaking and refused to stay silent were escorted out by police, and that no arrests were made.
Before the statement
At the November 16 commission meeting, people in the audience recited the Lord's Prayer and shouted while Imam Sajid R. Bhuiya of the Masjid Al Nur Mosque waited to give the invocation.
After the statement
The statement says City Manager Mike Herr and other city officials encourage residents and religious leaders of all faiths to keep Bartow a welcoming place.
Why this label?
The city says its opening prayer is open to all faiths, including the imam who gave Monday's prayer, and that this is consistent with the Constitution, so we labeled it Stood by.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
City of BartowCity Attorney Sean Parker, speaking for the city at the November 16 commission meeting "But if they ever did, we should welcome that. Because remember, this is a government meeting, not a religious forum."
ExplainedResponding to: Opening the Bartow City Commission's invocation to leaders of all faiths, including an imam, is consistent with the U.S. Constitution.
Full statement and sources
Parker tells the audience he had the most to do with the imam's invitation, says the city should welcome a leader of another faith who asks to give the invocation, and describes how the mosque came to be invited.
Before the statement
Before public comment began, Parker said he had the most to do with the imam's presence at the meeting and that people who wanted to be mad at somebody could be mad at him. He said he could not recall a person from another faith ever being asked to participate.
After the statement
Parker said a member of a local Hindu temple had asked to give an invocation, that the dates offered did not work, and that he then suggested the clerk's office reach out to the mosque.
City of Bartow video: City Commission meeting of November 16, 2026, City Attorney Sean Parker on the invitation · City of Bartow0:37:04 to 0:41:20Why this label?
Parker takes responsibility for suggesting the invitation and explains how it came about, saying the meeting is a government meeting rather than a religious forum, so we labeled it Explained.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Trish PfeifferBartow city commissioner, speaking at the November 16 commission meeting "We govern a city of people, not a congregation of faith. As elected officials, we have a responsibility to uphold those principles, even when doing so may be unpopular. We do not have to share someone's faith to respect their right to practice it."
Stood by itResponding to: Opening the Bartow City Commission's invocation to leaders of all faiths, including an imam, is consistent with the U.S. Constitution.
Full statement and sources
Pfeiffer says commissioners received 214 emails about the invocation, that officials commit to serving all the people of Bartow, including those who do not share their beliefs, and that allowing someone of any faith to offer an invocation does not diminish anyone's Christianity.
Before the statement
Pfeiffer opened general public comment by saying that, as of 5:16 that evening, commissioners had received 214 emails about the invocation. She said allowing someone of any faith to offer an invocation does not diminish their Christianity.
After the statement
Pfeiffer then said she wanted to speak as a Christian rather than as a commissioner, said respecting another person's religious freedom is not abandoning her own, and invited those present to join her in the Lord's Prayer.
City of Bartow video: City Commission meeting of November 16, 2026, Commissioner Pfeiffer's remarks · City of Bartow0:28:30 to 0:34:05Why this label?
Pfeiffer backs letting a leader of any faith give the invocation and says officials must uphold that principle even when it is unpopular, so we labeled it Stood by.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
1 response. Newest first.
Freedom From Religion FoundationOrganization advocating separation of state and church, on Bluesky"Nothing says "Christian love" quite like shouting down a Muslim prayer and telling the imam to "go back where you came from." They demand religious freedom for themselves while denying it to everyone else. This is exactly why government meetings shouldn't include prayer at all."
Mixed or conditionalResponding to: Opening the Bartow City Commission's invocation to leaders of all faiths, including an imam, is consistent with the U.S. Constitution.
Full statement and sources
FFRF faults the people who shouted down the imam's prayer and told him to go back where he came from, and says the episode shows why government meetings should not open with prayer of any kind.
Before the statement
WFLA reported that people at the Bartow meeting recited the Lord's Prayer as the imam waited to speak and that one of them told him to go back where he came from.
After the statement
FFRF posted the comment while quoting a JoeMyGod post that linked the Lakeland Ledger's report on the meeting.
Freedom From Religion Foundation Bluesky post on the Bartow invocation · Freedom From Religion FoundationPost textWhy this label?
FFRF criticizes the crowd for shouting down a Muslim prayer and says government meetings should not include prayer at all, so we labeled it Mixed or conditional.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(8)
Original video
City of Bartow video: City Commission meeting of November 16, 2026, invocation
People in the audience recite the Lord's Prayer and shout as Imam Sajid R. Bhuiya waits to give the invocation, then the start of his prayer, at the Bartow City Commission meeting, Nov. 16, 2026.
Two excerpts joined by a one-second black gap: 2:06 to 4:15 and 12:04 to 12:57 of the City of Bartow video. DI added its logo in the corner.
Video: City of Bartow, Florida
Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: 0:02:10 to 0:14:05)
About this source
The city's recording of its November 16, 2026 commission meeting. In this part, Imam Sajid R. Bhuiya is called to give the invocation, people in the audience recite the Lord's Prayer and shout while he waits at the podium, and he then delivers his prayer.
- Author
- City of Bartow
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Freedom From Religion Foundation Bluesky post on the Bartow invocation
Relevant passage: Post text
About this source
Bluesky post by the Freedom From Religion Foundation on November 18, 2026, quoting a JoeMyGod post that linked the Lakeland Ledger's report on the Bartow meeting.
- Author
- Freedom From Religion Foundation (@ffrf.org)
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Daily Ridge: Bartow Commission Ratifies $9 Million Deal for S&P Mobile Home Park; Imam's Invocation Draws Crowd, Disruption
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Daily Ridge summary of the November 16 meeting. It reports that the imam began about eight minutes after being called, that more than 15 people spoke in public comment, mostly about the invocation, and that a police official said no one was arrested.
- Author
- Ridge Events
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
WTSP: Muslim prayer sparks backlash at Bartow City Commission meeting
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
WTSP 10 Tampa Bay report on the meeting, quoting Commissioner Trish Pfeiffer on serving people of all faiths and City Attorney Sean Parker on how the imam was invited, and describing an hour of divided public comment.
- Author
- Jennifer Stanton
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
WFLA: All faiths welcome in Bartow, city officials respond after prayer disruption
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
WFLA report of November 18, 2026 that prints the City of Bartow's full written statement on the disrupted invocation, including that residents who refused to stay silent were escorted out and no arrests were made.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
WFLA: Imam's invocation at Bartow City Commission meeting disrupted by shouting crowd
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
WFLA News Channel 8 account of the November 16 meeting, based on the meeting video, including the crowd reciting the Lord's Prayer as the imam waited and a person in the crowd telling him to go back where he came from.
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
City of Bartow video: City Commission meeting of November 16, 2026, City Attorney Sean Parker on the invitation
City Attorney Sean Parker on how the imam was invited to give the invocation, at the Bartow City Commission meeting, Nov. 16, 2026.
Excerpt from 37:11 to 38:25 of the City of Bartow video. DI added its logo in the corner.
Video: City of Bartow, Florida
Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: 0:37:04 to 0:41:20)
About this source
City Attorney Sean Parker tells the audience at the November 16, 2026 meeting how the imam came to give the invocation, after a request from a member of a local Hindu temple, and says he suggested inviting the mosque.
- Author
- City of Bartow
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
City of Bartow video: City Commission meeting of November 16, 2026, Commissioner Pfeiffer's remarks
Commissioner Trish Pfeiffer on the invocation and serving residents of all faiths, at the Bartow City Commission meeting, Nov. 16, 2026.
Excerpt from 28:44 to 30:22 of the City of Bartow video. DI added its logo in the corner.
Video: City of Bartow, Florida
Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: 0:28:30 to 0:34:05)
About this source
Commissioner Trish Pfeiffer opens general public comment at the November 16, 2026 meeting by saying commissioners received 214 emails about the invocation, speaks about serving residents of all faiths, and then leads those present in the Lord's Prayer.
- Author
- City of Bartow
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- A crowd recites the Lord's Prayer over an imam invited to open a Bartow City Commission meeting; city officials stand by the invitation
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/bartow-city-commission-imam-invocation-disrupted
The Dispute Index. "A crowd recites the Lord's Prayer over an imam invited to open a Bartow City Commission meeting; city officials stand by the invitation". First published: 2026-11-19. Last updated: 2026-11-19. https://disputeindex.com/cases/bartow-city-commission-imam-invocation-disrupted