Magistrate judge rules Kim Davis left her inheritance and 2025 property transfers out of sworn asset answers; Davis says she owned none of it and hid nothing
A federal magistrate judge ruled that Kim Davis left her inheritance and 2025 property transfers out of sworn asset answers while she owes a gay couple more than $565,000. Davis says she followed her mother's wishes and hid nothing.

Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Where it stands
ActiveAs of
Established
- A federal judgment entered December 28, 2023 ordered Davis to pay $360,084.70 to David Ermold and David Moore, and the court later added $205,201.21 in appeal fees and costs.Ermold v. Davis, Order on the plaintiffs' motion to compel and for sanctions (opens in a new tab)Ermold v. Davis, Plaintiffs' motion to hold Kim Davis in contempt and for sanctions (opens in a new tab)
- Davis's sworn answers said she owned no real property, had made no transfers above $2,000 and was not a beneficiary of any trust or estate.Ermold v. Davis, Order on the plaintiffs' motion to compel and for sanctions (opens in a new tab)Ermold v. Davis, Plaintiffs' motion to hold Kim Davis in contempt and for sanctions (opens in a new tab)
- Rowan County records show Davis inherited half of her mother's estate and conveyed her interests in three estate parcels to family members in April and May 2025.Ermold v. Davis, Order on the plaintiffs' motion to compel and for sanctions (opens in a new tab)
- On November 6, 2026, Magistrate Judge Edward B. Atkins ruled that Davis violated the discovery rules by not disclosing these assets and ordered her to show cause why she should not be sanctioned.Ermold v. Davis, Order on the plaintiffs' motion to compel and for sanctions (opens in a new tab)
Disputed
- Whether Davis knowingly gave false answers. The couple's lawyers say her answers are demonstrably false; Davis says she believed them true and had no intent to conceal anything.Ermold v. Davis, Plaintiffs' motion to hold Kim Davis in contempt and for sanctions (opens in a new tab)Ermold v. Davis, Declaration of Kim Davis in support of her response to the show cause order (opens in a new tab)See the claim
- Whether the 2025 transfers can be undone to pay the judgment. The couple's state suit seeks to void them; Davis says the properties were her mother's and went where her mother wanted.Ermold v. Davis, Plaintiffs' motion to hold Kim Davis in contempt and for sanctions (opens in a new tab)Ermold v. Davis, Declaration of Kim Davis in support of her response to the show cause order (opens in a new tab)
Not yet known
- Whether Judge Atkins will impose sanctions after Davis's November 16 response.
- How the Rowan Circuit Court will rule on the couple's suit to void the 2025 transfers.
Overview
Davis was the Rowan County clerk in June 2015, when the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that same-sex couples have a constitutional right to marry. She refused to issue licenses to same-sex couples, citing her religious beliefs, and U.S. District Judge David L. Bunning jailed her for several days for contempt of court. David Ermold and David Moore, one of the couples her office turned away, sued her. A jury awarded them $50,000 each, and on December 28, 2023 the court entered a judgment of $360,084.70 that included their lawyers' fees and expenses. The Sixth Circuit affirmed on March 6, 2025, the Supreme Court declined to hear her appeal on November 10, 2025, and the court added $205,201.21 in appeal fees and costs in May 2026. On July 15, 2026, the couple also sued in Rowan Circuit Court to void the 2025 property transfers. Davis is represented by Liberty Counsel.
People in this case
Hemant MehtaCommented
Timeline
8 timeline entries on this page. Dates: December 28, 2023 to November 16, 2026
December 2023
Federal court enters judgment against Davis
The court entered a judgment of $360,084.70 against Davis in the suit brought by David Ermold and David Moore: $50,000 in damages for each man plus their lawyers' fees and expenses.
March 2025
Sixth Circuit upholds the judgment
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed the judgment against Davis.
November 2025
Supreme Court declines to hear Davis's appeal
The U.S. Supreme Court denied Davis's petition for review, leaving the judgment in place.
December 2025
Davis gives sworn answers about her assets
Claim
In supplemental answers to the couple's post-judgment questions, signed by Davis, she said she owned no property and had no interest in any property, had made no personal transfers above $2,000 and was not the beneficiary of any trust.
July 2026
Couple sues in state court to void Davis's 2025 transfers
Ermold and Moore sued Davis, the relatives and family trust that received three parcels from her mother's estate, and the estate's co-administrators in Rowan Circuit Court, seeking to void the 2025 transfers, and recorded notices against the three parcels.
Couple asks the court to sanction Davis over her answers
Claim
The couple's lawyers asked the federal court to order Davis to show cause why she should not be held in contempt and sanctioned, citing certified deed and probate records from Rowan County.
November 2026
Magistrate judge orders Davis to show cause
Magistrate Judge Edward B. Atkins ruled that Davis violated the discovery rules by not disclosing her inheritance and the 2025 conveyances, ordered complete answers by November 16 and ordered her to show cause why she should not be sanctioned. He declined to hold her in contempt.
Davis answers the show cause order
Reaction
Davis's lawyers asked the court not to impose sanctions and filed her sworn declaration saying she owned none of the properties, acted as administrator of her mother's estate and had no intent to conceal anything.
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Joseph D. BucklesKim Davis's sworn post-judgment answers, which said she owned no real property, had made no transfers above $2,000 and was not a beneficiary of any trust or estate, were false because she had inherited half of her mother's estate and conveyed her interests in three estate parcels in 2025.
What is disputed
On November 6, 2026, Magistrate Judge Edward B. Atkins ruled that the answers left out assets within the scope of the couple's requests and violated the discovery rules; he did not decide whether Davis acted on purpose. Davis says the properties were her mother's, that she acted only as administrator of the estate and that she believed her answers were true.
Sources (3)
- Ermold v. Davis, Plaintiffs' motion to hold Kim Davis in contempt and for sanctionsNo. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB, ECF No. 201, July 28, 2026
- Ermold v. Davis, Order on the plaintiffs' motion to compel and for sanctionsNo. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB-EBA, ECF No. 204, November 6, 2026
- Ermold v. Davis, Declaration of Kim Davis in support of her response to the show cause orderNo. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB, ECF No. 205-1, November 16, 2026
In their own words
Their own account
Statements from the person or group whose act or claim this case is about. They are listed apart from the responses, and each label says what the speaker did with their own act or claim.
Liberty CounselChristian legal organization representing Kim Davis, in a response filed in federal court and signed by its lawyer Daniel J. Schmid "If she was incorrect, or the Court finds that her answers were not in conformance with the operations of laws in the Commonwealth of Kentucky, Davis's answers were at best an honest mistake and should not be sanctionable."
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
ExplainedResponding to: Kim Davis's sworn post-judgment answers, which said she owned no real property, had made no transfers above $2,000 and was not a beneficiary of any trust or estate, were false because she had inherited half of her mother's estate and conveyed her interests in three estate parcels in 2025.
Full statement and sources
Answering the show cause order, Davis's lawyers at Liberty Counsel say she answered the discovery requests truthfully as she understood them, that any error was at most an honest mistake and not bad faith, and that sanctions are unwarranted.
Before the statement
On November 6, 2026, Magistrate Judge Edward B. Atkins ruled that Davis violated the discovery rules by not disclosing her inheritance and the 2025 conveyances, and gave her until November 16 to show cause why she should not be sanctioned.
After the statement
In a declaration filed with the response, Davis says her mother wanted the properties placed in a trust for later generations, that she received nothing from the estate and that she had no intent to conceal anything.
Ermold v. Davis, Defendant Kim Davis's response to the show cause orderNo. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB, ECF No. 205, November 16, 2026Ermold v. Davis, Declaration of Kim Davis in support of her response to the show cause orderNo. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB, ECF No. 205-1, November 16, 2026Ermold v. Davis, Order on the plaintiffs' motion to compel and for sanctionsNo. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB-EBA, ECF No. 204, November 6, 2026Why this label?
Davis's lawyers say she answered the questions as she understood them and that any error was at most an honest mistake, not bad faith, so we labeled it Explained.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
3 responses. Newest first.
Michael J. GartlandLexington lawyer for David Ermold and David Moore, quoted by the Kentucky Lantern "This is all made up to try to get out of trouble now"
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
CondemnedResponding to: Kim Davis's sworn post-judgment answers, which said she owned no real property, had made no transfers above $2,000 and was not a beneficiary of any trust or estate, were false because she had inherited half of her mother's estate and conveyed her interests in three estate parcels in 2025.
Full statement and sources
Michael J. Gartland, a lawyer for David Ermold and David Moore, says Davis's latest responses to the court were made up to get her out of trouble.
Before the statement
In a declaration filed November 16, Davis said the property transfers were done to honor her late mother's wishes, that she received nothing from the estate and that any error in her answers was a mistake, not intent.
After the statement
Court sanctions against Davis could include an order for her to pay attorney fees for the couple trying to collect from her, according to the Kentucky Lantern.
Why this label?
Gartland says Davis's explanation that she owned nothing and meant no concealment was made up to get out of trouble, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Hemant MehtaWriter and founder of Friendly Atheist, in a Friendly Atheist article"It seemed pretty obvious she was deliberately lying about what she had done."
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
CondemnedResponding to: Kim Davis's sworn post-judgment answers, which said she owned no real property, had made no transfers above $2,000 and was not a beneficiary of any trust or estate, were false because she had inherited half of her mother's estate and conveyed her interests in three estate parcels in 2025.
Full statement and sources
Writing in Friendly Atheist, Hemant Mehta says Davis was deliberately lying in her sworn answers about her inheritance and property transfers, and rejects Liberty Counsel's argument that she answered the questions as worded.
Before the statement
Mehta quotes Liberty Counsel's Mat Staver as saying Davis did not lie because the couple's lawyers asked what property she owns now, in the present tense.
After the statement
Later in the article, Mehta cites Magistrate Judge Edward B. Atkins's order giving Davis until November 16 to provide complete responses and explain why she should not be sanctioned.
Why this label?
Mehta says Davis was deliberately lying about what she had done with her inheritance and calls on her to pay what she owes, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Joseph D. BucklesLexington lawyer for David Ermold and David Moore, in a motion filed in federal court "Davis's sworn responses to Plaintiffs' post-judgment interrogatories and requests for production are demonstrably false on the face of the certified public records of the Rowan County Clerk and the Rowan District Court"
Checked word for word against a linked source on .
CondemnedResponding to: Kim Davis's sworn post-judgment answers, which said she owned no real property, had made no transfers above $2,000 and was not a beneficiary of any trust or estate, were false because she had inherited half of her mother's estate and conveyed her interests in three estate parcels in 2025.
Full statement and sources
In a motion for David Ermold and David Moore, Joseph D. Buckles says Davis's sworn answers about her property are contradicted by certified Rowan County deed and probate records, and asks the court to order her to show cause and to impose sanctions.
Before the statement
In December 2025 and January 2026, Davis gave sworn answers saying she owned no property, had made no transfers above $2,000 and was not a beneficiary of any trust or estate. On July 13, 2026, Buckles retrieved certified deed and probate records in Morehead, and on July 15 the couple sued in Rowan Circuit Court to void three 2025 transfers.
After the statement
On November 6, 2026, the court granted the motion in part and denied it in part.
Ermold v. Davis, Plaintiffs' motion to hold Kim Davis in contempt and for sanctionsNo. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB, ECF No. 201, July 28, 2026Ermold v. Davis, Order on the plaintiffs' motion to compel and for sanctionsNo. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB-EBA, ECF No. 204, November 6, 2026Why this label?
Buckles says Davis's sworn answers about her property and transfers are demonstrably false on the face of the county's certified records and asks for sanctions, so we labeled it Condemned.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(6)
Original text
Ermold v. Davis, Order on the plaintiffs' motion to compel and for sanctions
Relevant passage: No. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB-EBA, ECF No. 204, November 6, 2026
About this source
Six-page order by Magistrate Judge Edward B. Atkins. It finds that Kim Davis did not disclose her inheritance from her mother's estate or her 2025 conveyances in her post-judgment discovery answers, orders full answers by November 16, 2026, and orders her to show cause why she should not be sanctioned, while declining to hold her in contempt.
- Author
- Magistrate Judge Edward B. Atkins, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Ermold v. Davis, Defendant Kim Davis's response to the show cause order
Relevant passage: No. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB, ECF No. 205, November 16, 2026
About this source
Fifteen-page response filed by Davis's lawyers to the November 6 show cause order. It argues that Davis answered the discovery requests truthfully as she understood them, that any error was an honest mistake rather than bad faith, and that sanctions are unwarranted.
- Author
- Daniel J. Schmid, Mathew D. Staver and Horatio G. Mihet of Liberty Counsel, and A.C. Donahue, lawyers for Kim Davis
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Friendly Atheist: Kim Davis owes a gay couple $565,000. A federal judge wants her to stop lying about her assets.
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Friendly Atheist article of November 12, 2026 by Hemant Mehta about the couple's effort to collect the judgment against Davis. It quotes Michael J. Gartland on the 2025 property transfers and links to the court's November 6 order.
- Author
- Hemant Mehta
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Kim Davis violated rule on disclosing her assets in decade-long case
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Kentucky Lantern report by Bill Estep, republished by Yahoo News. It summarizes Judge Atkins's ruling and Davis's November 16 declaration, and quotes Michael J. Gartland, a lawyer for David Ermold and David Moore, on her response.
- Author
- Bill Estep, Kentucky Lantern
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Ermold v. Davis, Plaintiffs' motion to hold Kim Davis in contempt and for sanctions
Relevant passage: No. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB, ECF No. 201, July 28, 2026
About this source
Eleven-page motion filed for David Ermold and David Moore. It quotes Davis's sworn post-judgment discovery answers, lists the probate records and deeds the couple's lawyers obtained in Rowan County, and asks the court to order Davis to show cause and to impose sanctions.
- Author
- Joseph D. Buckles and Michael J. Gartland, lawyers for David Ermold and David Moore
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Ermold v. Davis, Declaration of Kim Davis in support of her response to the show cause order
Relevant passage: No. 0:15-cv-00046-DLB, ECF No. 205-1, November 16, 2026
About this source
Five-page declaration signed by Kim Davis under penalty of perjury and filed with her lawyers' response to the November 6 show cause order. In it she says her discovery answers were true to the best of her knowledge and that she transferred the properties as administrator of her late mother's estate.
- Author
- Kim Davis
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Magistrate judge rules Kim Davis left her inheritance and 2025 property transfers out of sworn asset answers; Davis says she owned none of it and hid nothing
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/kim-davis-asset-disclosure-ermold-moore-judgment
The Dispute Index. "Magistrate judge rules Kim Davis left her inheritance and 2025 property transfers out of sworn asset answers; Davis says she owned none of it and hid nothing". First published: 2026-11-18. Last updated: 2026-11-18. https://disputeindex.com/cases/kim-davis-asset-disclosure-ermold-moore-judgment