Times reports DHS bought five marked-up planes from a donor's firm on Kristi Noem's last day; Noem demands a retraction and says Mullin finalized the deal
The New York Times reported that on Kristi Noem's last day as homeland security secretary, DHS bought five planes at a markup from a firm whose chairman gave to a PAC backing her. Noem demanded a retraction; the Times stands by its report.

Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Where it stands
ActiveAs of
Established
- Contracting records cited by The New York Times show DHS bought 10 airplanes from Daedalus Aviation under a $464 million no-bid contract that grew by $303 million on the day Mullin was sworn in.The Boston Globe (The New York Times): Homeland Security paid $464 million for airplanes. Then it parked them. (opens in a new tab)
- Daedalus chairman William Walters gave $10,000 to American Resolve, a political action committee that supported Noem. The company says he did not know the group was tied to her.The Daily Wire: Kristi Noem Accused Of Giving Bloated Contract To Donor In Final Hours Running DHS (opens in a new tab)Mediaite: Kristi Noem Seethes After NY Times Expose on a Plum Contract DHS Gave to a Political Donor on Her Last Day as Secretary (opens in a new tab)
Disputed
- The Times reports DHS bought five planes from Daedalus at a substantial markup on Noem's last day and calls Walters her donor. Noem says that description is materially misleading.The Daily Wire: Kristi Noem Accused Of Giving Bloated Contract To Donor In Final Hours Running DHS (opens in a new tab)Kristi Noem on X: request that The New York Times retract or correct its article (opens in a new tab)Mediaite: Kristi Noem Seethes After NY Times Expose on a Plum Contract DHS Gave to a Political Donor on Her Last Day as Secretary (opens in a new tab)
- Noem says the purchase was finalized under Secretary Mullin. DHS says the contract was made and approved by department leadership before he was sworn in.The Boston Globe (The New York Times): Homeland Security paid $464 million for airplanes. Then it parked them. (opens in a new tab)The Daily Wire: Kristi Noem Accused Of Giving Bloated Contract To Donor In Final Hours Running DHS (opens in a new tab)See the claim
Not yet known
- Whether the DHS inspector general is examining the aircraft purchases, as Senators Murray and Murphy asked in August.
- What House Democrats will investigate about the purchases after they take control of the House in January.
Overview
The New York Times reported on August 13, 2026 that the Department of Homeland Security spent $464 million on a no-bid contract with Daedalus Aviation for 10 used airplanes, and that its seven Boeing 737s had sat parked in Lake Charles, Louisiana, for months at a time. DHS said the contract was made and approved before Secretary Markwayne Mullin was sworn in, while a spokesperson for his predecessor, Kristi Noem, said the purchase was finalized under Mullin. On October 4, the Times reported that on Noem's last day as secretary, DHS agreed to buy five planes from Daedalus at a markup, including $108 million for a converted Boeing 737 that the firm had bought months earlier for less than $90 million, and that Daedalus chairman William Walters had given $10,000 to American Resolve, a political action committee that supported Noem. Noem asked the Times to retract or correct the article and said Walters was not her donor. A Times spokesperson said the paper stands by its description of Walters and his firm. Senators Patty Murray and Chris Murphy have asked DHS for a full accounting, and in November, American Federation of Teachers president Randi Weingarten called for a full investigation.
Read the full background
DHS bought the planes from Daedalus Aviation Corp., a firm in northern Virginia, under a contract it awarded without competing bids by invoking an exemption for cases of "unusual and compelling urgency", according to the Times. Three of the 10 aircraft are luxury business jets and seven are older Boeing 737 passenger jets. An internal government document obtained by the Times said the department did not have the staff to operate the 737s (The Boston Globe, republishing the Times (opens in a new tab)).
Contracting records cited by the Times show the contract grew by $303 million on the day Mullin was sworn in. In its October report, the Times said Mullin explored backing out of the purchase and consulted White House chief of staff Susie Wiles, who shared his concerns about financial penalties, and that the deal went ahead. Mullin's team told the Times the planes were purchased before he arrived at DHS. Daedalus said its prices reflected a market with a limited inventory of suitable planes, and the company said Walters did not know the committee was tied to Noem when he gave (The Daily Wire (opens in a new tab); Mediaite (opens in a new tab)).
Murray and Murphy's letter of August 12, copied to the DHS inspector general, says DHS acquired 12 aircraft in all without authorization from Congress and was providing jet service to officials including FBI Director Kash Patel and border czar Tom Homan (letter (opens in a new tab)). In November, after Democrats won control of the House, Rep. Bennie Thompson, the top Democrat on the House Homeland Security Committee, said the questions Noem refused to answer are still open (KOTA (opens in a new tab)).
People in this case
Kristi NoemDirectly involved
Markwayne MullinDirectly involved
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Kristi NoemThe purchase of the planes was not completed during Noem's tenure at DHS and was finalized under Secretary Markwayne Mullin's leadership.
What is disputed
Noem said this in a statement to The New York Times published on October 4, 2026, and a spokesperson for her made the same point in August. DHS said the Daedalus contract was made and approved by department leadership before Mullin was sworn in, and Mullin's team said the planes were purchased before he arrived.
Sources (2)
- The Boston Globe (The New York Times): Homeland Security paid $464 million for airplanes. Then it parked them. · The Boston GlobeArticle text
Sources
(2)
Reporting
The Boston Globe (The New York Times): Homeland Security paid $464 million for airplanes. Then it parked them.
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
New York Times investigation republished by The Boston Globe on August 13, 2026. It reports that DHS spent $464 million on a no-bid contract with Daedalus Aviation for 10 used airplanes, that the seven Boeing 737s sat parked in Lake Charles, Louisiana, for months at a time, and that the department and a spokesperson for Kristi Noem each placed responsibility for the contract on the other.
- Author
- David A. Fahrenthold, Andrea Fuller, Julie Tate, Nicholas Nehamas and Hamed Aleaziz, The New York Times
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Daily Wire: Kristi Noem Accused Of Giving Bloated Contract To Donor In Final Hours Running DHS
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Daily Wire report of October 5, 2026 on the New York Times story about DHS buying five planes from Daedalus Aviation on Noem's last day as secretary. It quotes Noem's statement to the Times, her request for a retraction, a line from Mullin's team and Daedalus's defense of its prices.
- Author
- Jennie Taer
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Times reports DHS bought five marked-up planes from a donor's firm on Kristi Noem's last day; Noem demands a retraction and says Mullin finalized the deal
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/noem-dhs-daedalus-planes-donor-retraction
The Dispute Index. "Times reports DHS bought five marked-up planes from a donor's firm on Kristi Noem's last day; Noem demands a retraction and says Mullin finalized the deal". First published: 2026-11-18. Last updated: 2026-11-18. https://disputeindex.com/cases/noem-dhs-daedalus-planes-donor-retraction