Haverhill cancels its Flock contract as councilors weigh new rules or a ban on license-plate readers

Haverhill, Massachusetts, is canceling its Flock camera contract over privacy safeguards. Councilor Devan Ferreira and a community group oppose the readers, while the deputy police chief and Mayor Melinda Barrett want to keep them under new rules.

Haverhill City Hall, a four-story tan brick building with rows of windows, under a blue sky.
Haverhill City Hall on Summer Street in Haverhill, Massachusetts.

Case period:

Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated

City of HaverhillFlock Safety

Overview

The city's November 5 announcement (opens in a new tab) said police had used Flock cameras since 2023 in investigations of homicides, shootings, armed robberies, stalking, stolen vehicles and other crimes. It said department audits, most recently in October 2026, found no evidence of misuse, unauthorized access or policy violations. A police department statement in the same announcement credited the cameras with helping solve crimes and cited public concern about Flock as a company.

WHAV reported (opens in a new tab) on November 11 that the Haverhill Police Patrolmen's Association backed continued use of the cameras, while the Merrimack Valley Project planned to seek a ban regardless of vendor. At the November 12 committee meeting (opens in a new tab), members said the city would not immediately replace the technology and would draft an ordinance, and most favored rules based on a proposal from City Solicitor Lisa Mead and on ordinances in Quincy and Somerville. Boston 25 News reported (opens in a new tab) that the cameras were still operating and that the ordinance was expected to go to the full City Council in the coming weeks.

Background: What are license-plate readers?

Timeline

3 timeline entries on this page. Dates: November 5, 2026 to November 12, 2026

  1. November 2026

    1. Haverhill announces it is canceling its Flock contract

      Source release

      The city says it has begun canceling the police department's Flock Safety contract and asked Flock to remove its cameras. It says audits found no misuse, but that Flock's technology does not provide enough privacy safeguards, and that it is drafting an ordinance and policy on license-plate readers.

      [01]City of Haverhill

      The city's November 5, 2026 announcement that it has begun canceling the police department's Flock Safety contract and asked Flock to remove its cameras. It says audits through October 2026 found no misuse, that Flock's technology lacks needed privacy safeguards and that an ordinance is being drafted, and it includes a statement from the Haverhill Police Department on the cameras' investigative value.

    2. Police union and the Merrimack Valley Project take opposing sides on the cameras

      Reaction

      The Haverhill Police Patrolmen's Association says it stands behind continued use of the cameras, while the Merrimack Valley Project says it will ask for a total ban on such cameras regardless of vendor.

      [02]WHAV

      Reports the Haverhill Police Patrolmen's Association statement backing continued use of the cameras, the Merrimack Valley Project's plan to seek a total ban regardless of vendor, and a statement from Councilor Devan Ferreira, ahead of the November 12 committee meeting.

    3. Public Safety Committee favors rules over an outright ban

      After 90 minutes of testimony, members of the City Council's Public Safety Committee say the city will not immediately replace the technology and will draft an ordinance. Most favor strict rules modeled on Quincy and Somerville over an outright ban, and the ordinance is expected to go to the full City Council.

      [03]WHAV

      Reports that the City Council's Public Safety Committee, after 90 minutes of testimony on November 12, favored strict rules on surveillance technology modeled on Quincy and Somerville rather than an outright ban, and summarizes speakers for and against the cameras.

      [04]Boston 25 News

      Reports on the November 12 Public Safety Committee meeting and the rally before it, with quotes from Councilor Devan Ferreira, Deputy Chief Meaghan Pare, Mayor Melinda Barrett, Annie Ryan of the Merrimack Valley Project and residents on both sides. It says the cameras were still operating and that a surveillance ordinance was expected before the full council.

Response record

Responses

Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.

6 responses. Newest first.

  1. Devan FerreiraHaverhill City Councilor for Ward 3, at a rally before the Public Safety Committee meeting

    Before this statement

    Boston 25 News reported that Ferreira joined residents at a rally outside City Hall before the November 12 Public Safety Committee meeting, as the city worked to cancel its Flock contract. On November 11, WHAV reported a statement attributed to Ferreira saying community members had made clear they did not want Flock or any other ALPR system in Haverhill.

    "I just don't believe license plate readers at this point that are cloud based have the safeguards in place to keep our data safe"
    Condemned

    Case context: Haverhill cancels its Flock contract as councilors weigh new rules or a ban on license-plate readers

    Full statement and sources

    Haverhill City Councilor Devan Ferreira said cloud-based license-plate readers do not, at this point, have the safeguards in place to keep residents' data safe.

    After the statement

    Boston 25 reported that Ferreira had proposed a city ordinance with rules for surveillance technology, including limits on who can use it and public input before future contracts. At the meeting, Ferreira said the Quincy and Somerville ordinances require justification, a public process and City Council approval before a purchase.

    Why this label?

    The case asks whether Haverhill should keep license-plate readers under new rules after canceling its Flock contract. Ferreira says cloud-based readers lack the safeguards to keep residents' data safe, an argument against keeping them, so we labeled it a condemnation. Ferreira also backs an ordinance that would require public input and City Council approval before any future surveillance purchase.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  2. Meaghan PareDeputy chief, Haverhill Police Department

    Before this statement

    Boston 25 News reported that Haverhill police described Flock as a valuable investigative tool that had helped officers track down suspects and locate a kidnapping victim, as the City Council's Public Safety Committee met on November 12 to consider what comes next.

    "Don't take away a tool that is so beneficial to law enforcement ... Let's discuss it, let's come up with solutions, let's come up with guardrails, but let's keep it."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Haverhill cancels its Flock contract as councilors weigh new rules or a ban on license-plate readers

    Full statement and sources

    Haverhill Deputy Police Chief Meaghan Pare urged the city not to take away a tool Pare called very beneficial to law enforcement, and proposed discussing solutions and guardrails while keeping it.

    After the statement

    Boston 25 reported that some residents also spoke in favor of keeping the cameras, arguing they could make a critical difference during an emergency.

    Why this label?

    The case asks whether Haverhill should keep license-plate readers under new rules after canceling its Flock contract. Pare asks the city not to take the tool away from police and proposes guardrails while keeping it, so we labeled it a defense.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  3. Melinda BarrettMayor of Haverhill

    Before this statement

    Boston 25 News reported that Haverhill's mayor hopes the city can find a compromise that addresses privacy concerns while preserving an important public safety tool. A week earlier, Barrett's office said the city had asked Flock to remove its automatic license plate readers, after finding that Flock's technology did not provide enough privacy safeguards.

    "I think this technology is too important to just walk away from"
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Haverhill cancels its Flock contract as councilors weigh new rules or a ban on license-plate readers

    Full statement and sources

    Haverhill Mayor Melinda Barrett said license-plate reader technology is too important for the city to walk away from. Boston 25 News reported that Barrett hopes for a compromise that addresses privacy concerns while keeping the tool.

    After the statement

    Boston 25 reported that the city was working to cancel its Flock contract while the City Council drafted a surveillance ordinance setting guidelines for this type of technology, expected to come before the full council in the coming weeks.

    Why this label?

    The case asks whether Haverhill should keep license-plate readers under new rules after canceling its Flock contract. Barrett says the technology is too important to walk away from and hopes for a compromise that addresses privacy concerns, which supports keeping the readers under new rules, so we labeled it a defense.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  4. Merrimack Valley ProjectAnnie Ryan, Merrimack Valley Project

    Before this statement

    Boston 25 News reported that some residents at the November 12 Public Safety Committee meeting urged city leaders to get rid of Flock cameras and ban automated license plate readers entirely. WHAV reported a day earlier that the Merrimack Valley Project planned to ask for a total ban on such cameras regardless of the company providing them.

    "We don't know what they're doing with the technology. The safeguards aren't there"
    Condemned

    Case context: Haverhill cancels its Flock contract as councilors weigh new rules or a ban on license-plate readers

    Full statement and sources

    Annie Ryan of the Merrimack Valley Project said "We don't know what they're doing with the technology" and that the safeguards are not there. The group planned to ask for a total ban on such cameras regardless of the company providing them.

    After the statement

    Boston 25 reported that Councilor Devan Ferreira shared those concerns and had joined residents at a rally outside City Hall before the meeting.

    Why this label?

    The case asks whether Haverhill should keep license-plate readers under new rules after canceling its Flock contract. Ryan says the safeguards are not there, and the group sought a ban on such cameras regardless of vendor, so we labeled it a condemnation.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  5. Haverhill Police Patrolmen's AssociationPolice officers' union, in a statement released by its president, Conor Clark

    Before this statement

    WHAV reported that the union, which represents the department's rank-and-file officers, said it stands behind continued use of the cameras, a week after the city said it had asked Flock to remove them and a day before the City Council's Public Safety Committee met to debate guardrails on such systems.

    "Flock Safety is a valuable law enforcement tool that assists officers in identifying stolen vehicles, locating wanted individuals, investigating serious crimes, and protecting the residents of Haverhill"
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Haverhill cancels its Flock contract as councilors weigh new rules or a ban on license-plate readers

    Full statement and sources

    The Haverhill Police Patrolmen's Association called Flock Safety a valuable law enforcement tool that helps officers identify stolen vehicles, locate wanted people, investigate serious crimes and protect residents, and said it stands behind continued use of the cameras.

    After the statement

    The association said it rejects any suggestion that its members misuse the technology without credible evidence, and said Flock Safety is intended to serve legitimate law enforcement purposes, not personal interests or unauthorized surveillance.

    Why this label?

    The case asks whether Haverhill should keep license-plate readers under new rules after canceling its Flock contract. The union calls the cameras a valuable tool and says it stands behind their continued use, so we labeled it a defense.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  6. City of HaverhillMunicipal government, in a city announcementDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    The city said the police department had used Flock cameras since 2023 under strict internal controls, and that audits, including the most recent review in October 2026, found no evidence of misuse, unauthorized access or policy violations. It said it had begun canceling the contract and asked Flock to remove its cameras.

    "the City found that Flock's technology itself does not provide enough necessary safeguards to protect residents' privacy and is currently establishing an ordinance and internal policy regarding the use of ALPRs in Haverhill"
    Mixed or conditional

    Case context: Haverhill cancels its Flock contract as councilors weigh new rules or a ban on license-plate readers

    Full statement and sources

    The City of Haverhill said Flock's technology does not provide enough safeguards to protect residents' privacy, and that it is drafting an ordinance and internal policy on the use of automated license-plate readers in Haverhill.

    After the statement

    The city said it would continue reviewing law enforcement tools and guardrails with the City Council, and invited the public to the November 12 Public Safety Committee meeting to discuss guardrails and oversight requirements for any future license-plate readers.

    Why this label?

    The case asks whether Haverhill should keep license-plate readers under new rules after canceling its Flock contract. The city drops Flock over privacy safeguards while preparing rules and oversight requirements for any future readers, which rejects the current system but leaves room to keep the technology under new conditions, so we labeled it mixed.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

Sources

(4)

Official statement

City of Haverhill: City of Haverhill canceling Flock Safety contract

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Announcement text

About this source

The city's November 5, 2026 announcement that it has begun canceling the police department's Flock Safety contract and asked Flock to remove its cameras. It says audits through October 2026 found no misuse, that Flock's technology lacks needed privacy safeguards and that an ordinance is being drafted, and it includes a statement from the Haverhill Police Department on the cameras' investigative value.

Author
City of Haverhill
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

WHAV: Haverhill Committee Recommends Controls on Surveillance Cameras

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Article text

About this source

Reports that the City Council's Public Safety Committee, after 90 minutes of testimony on November 12, favored strict rules on surveillance technology modeled on Quincy and Somerville rather than an outright ban, and summarizes speakers for and against the cameras.

Author
Tim Coco
Published
Accessed

Reporting

WHAV: Haverhill Patrolmen, Merrimack Valley Project Stake Out Opposing Sides on Cameras

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Article text

About this source

Reports the Haverhill Police Patrolmen's Association statement backing continued use of the cameras, the Merrimack Valley Project's plan to seek a total ban regardless of vendor, and a statement from Councilor Devan Ferreira, ahead of the November 12 committee meeting.

Author
Tim Coco
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Boston 25 News: Haverhill debates future of license plate reader cameras amid privacy, public safety concerns

Haverhill residents, city councilors and supporters of the police debate the city's license plate reader cameras at a Public Safety Committee meeting on Nov. 12, 2026, in a Boston 25 News report.

Taken from Boston 25 News's own video, which plays on the article cited for this source. DI added its logo in the corner.

Video: Boston 25 News (WFXT). Excerpt used for news reporting and commentary

Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: Article text)

About this source

Reports on the November 12 Public Safety Committee meeting and the rally before it, with quotes from Councilor Devan Ferreira, Deputy Chief Meaghan Pare, Mayor Melinda Barrett, Annie Ryan of the Merrimack Valley Project and residents on both sides. It says the cameras were still operating and that a surveillance ordinance was expected before the full council.

Author
Litsa Pappas
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Case updates

Want the next important update?

Follow this case and get an email when an important development changes the record.

9 updates added in the last 14 days.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

The newsletter

Follow disputes like this one.

New cases and significant updates to the record, in your inbox. Free.

You’ll confirm your subscription on Substack.

Share or embed this case

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Haverhill cancels its Flock contract as councilors weigh new rules or a ban on license-plate readers
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/cases/haverhill-flock-cancellation-license-plate-reader-rules

The Dispute Index. "Haverhill cancels its Flock contract as councilors weigh new rules or a ban on license-plate readers". First published: 2026-11-16. Last updated: 2026-11-16. https://disputeindex.com/cases/haverhill-flock-cancellation-license-plate-reader-rules