Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

Haley Stevens reversed her support for Abdul El-Sayed and endorsed Mike Rogers. Stevens and Rogers defended the choice; Chuck Schumer, Ken Martin and other Democrats condemned it. Her earlier endorsement and later reversal are documented in the timeline.

Rep. Haley Stevens announces that she is endorsing Mike Rogers for the U.S. Senate, in a video posted to X on Nov. 1, 2026.

DI added its logo in the corner.

Video: Haley Stevens (@HaleyforMI on X). Excerpt used for news reporting and commentary

Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: Post caption and video, 00:00-01:38; endorsement at 00:13.24-00:19.88)

Case period:

Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated

Overview

Haley Stevens endorsed Republican Mike Rogers (opens in a new tab) on November 1, 2026, reversing her August 5 endorsement of Abdul El-Sayed (opens in a new tab). El-Sayed had defeated her in Michigan's Democratic Senate primary.

Stevens cited her exclusion from El-Sayed's campaign and criticized his association with Hasan Piker and what she described as hate. She said she remained a proud Democrat. Rogers (opens in a new tab) and Donald Trump (opens in a new tab) praised her decision. Chuck Schumer (opens in a new tab) and Ken Martin (opens in a new tab) called it a betrayal.

Read the full background

On October 30, Stevens again demanded that El-Sayed condemn a Rebellion PAC ad that she called antisemitic. The ad tied U.S. aid to Israel to grocery prices. She also demanded an apology for his own remarks on Israel and costs and withdrawal of an ad featuring Tucker Carlson. El-Sayed accused her of relitigating the primary. He said his campaign did not make the outside ad and he disagreed with its contents. Roll Call (opens in a new tab).

The planned joint appearance did not take place. Stevens attributed her exclusion to El-Sayed; reports described a request from his campaign to stay away. Dingell told AP (opens in a new tab) she called off the joint appearance because it had become distracting. On November 1, Stevens attended Perfecting Church with Rogers, while El-Sayed appeared with Jim Clyburn at a different Detroit church.

Stevens had pledged support for El-Sayed on August 5 (opens in a new tab) and defended that support in an August 6 interview (opens in a new tab). The disagreement now concerns her decision to back Rogers instead.

Hertel (opens in a new tab) said Stevens was not a current member of the Michigan Democratic Party and would not be one in the future.

People in this case

Timeline

53 timeline entries on this page. Dates: August 5, 2026 to November 4, 2026

  1. August 2026

    1. El-Sayed defeats Stevens in the Democratic Senate primary

      The Associated Press calls the August 4 Michigan Democratic Senate primary for El-Sayed on August 5. He advances to face Rogers in the general election.

      [01]Abdul El-Sayed wins the Michigan Democratic Senate primary

      Roll Call reports the result of the August 4 primary, called on August 5.

      Abdul El-Sayed wins the Michigan Democratic Senate primaryPrimary result and Stevens's support for El-Sayed
      [02]Haley Stevens

      Stevens congratulates El-Sayed, endorses him and criticizes Rogers.

      Haley Stevens concedes and endorses Abdul El-Sayed · Haley StevensCampaign statement dated August 5, 2026
    2. Stevens concedes and endorses El-Sayed against Rogers

      Source release

      Stevens congratulates El-Sayed on the nomination and offers him her full support against Rogers. She urges electing Democrats up and down the ballot.

      [03]Haley Stevens

      Stevens says she spoke with El-Sayed to offer her full support against Rogers.

      [02]Haley Stevens

      Stevens congratulates El-Sayed, endorses him and criticizes Rogers.

      Haley Stevens concedes and endorses Abdul El-Sayed · Haley StevensCampaign statement dated August 5, 2026
    3. Stevens defends backing El-Sayed in a CBS interview

      Source release

      CBS releases an interview in which Stevens discusses supporting El-Sayed after the primary and criticizes Rogers's support for Trump.

      [04]Stevens discusses backing El-Sayed after her primary loss

      Stevens defends her support for El-Sayed in an interview released August 6.

      Stevens discusses backing El-Sayed after her primary lossCBS News, The Takeout; complete interview, 11:11
  2. October 2026

    1. El-Sayed says he disagrees with the outside ad's contents

      Reaction

      El-Sayed says the Rebellion PAC ad was not made by his campaign and he disagrees with its contents.

      [05]Haley Stevens endorses Republican Mike Rogers for Senate

      Roll Call reports the endorsement, the preceding dispute and the parties' responses.

      Haley Stevens endorses Republican Mike Rogers for SenateAccount of the preceding ad dispute, endorsement and named reactions
  3. November 2026

    1. DNC Black Caucus chair accuses Stevens of using Black voters

      Reaction

      Rollins accuses Stevens of using Black Michiganders for a political stunt. She says Michigan Democrats support El-Sayed and urges voters to elect him.

      [06]Statement from DNC Black Caucus Chair Virgie Rollins

      Rollins criticizes Stevens and urges electing El-Sayed.

    2. Trump welcomes Stevens joining the Republican Party

      Reaction

      Asked before a Dubuque rally about Stevens endorsing Rogers, Trump says Republicans would welcome her into their party. He makes the invitation while speaking alongside Johnson.

      [07]Trump and Johnson invite Stevens to join Republicans

      Trump welcomes a party switch; Johnson defends the endorsement and describes speaking with Stevens.

      Trump and Johnson invite Stevens to join RepublicansOriginal reporter questions before Dubuque rally; Johnson response
    3. Stevens chief of staff and other staff resign

      Reaction

      Chief of staff Justin German and other members of Stevens's team resign and endorse El-Sayed. Their statement expresses shock at Stevens endorsing Rogers and urges support for Democrats.

      [08]Haley Stevens Pulls Plug on Presser While Heckled as Traitor for Endorsing Mike Rogers

      TheWrap reports staff resignations and the end of the joint press availability.

    4. Bowman condemns Stevens's endorsement at unity roundtable

      Reaction

      At an El-Sayed campaign roundtable in Detroit, former representative Jamaal Bowman condemns Stevens endorsing Rogers. He connects the decision to racial division and urges voters not to let that division prevail.

      [09]Stevens endorsement criticized at Detroit unity roundtable

      The reporter records separate criticisms of the endorsement at a campaign roundtable.

      Stevens endorsement criticized at Detroit unity roundtableBowman and Alawieh comments at Haraz Coffee House
    5. Alawieh argues shared interests matter more than candidate identity

      Reaction

      At the same roundtable, state Senate candidate Abbas Alawieh argues voters should prioritize shared interests over a candidate matching their identity. He accuses Stevens of abandoning abortion, voting and health care rights by backing Rogers.

      [09]Stevens endorsement criticized at Detroit unity roundtable

      The reporter records separate criticisms of the endorsement at a campaign roundtable.

      Stevens endorsement criticized at Detroit unity roundtableBowman and Alawieh comments at Haraz Coffee House
    6. Kulinski urges voting for El-Sayed after Stevens appears with Rogers

      Source release

      Secular Talk releases Kulinski's response to Stevens campaigning with Rogers at a Detroit church. He criticizes her move as helping Republican and pro-Israel interests and urges Michigan Democrats to turn their anger into votes for El-Sayed. He says its electoral effect remains uncertain.

      [10]MAJOR BREAKING: HALEY STEVENS RATF*CKS ABDUL AT LAST SECOND

      Kulinski responds to Stevens campaigning with Rogers before her endorsement announcement.

    7. Berger argues church appearance uses religious identity against El-Sayed

      Reaction

      Berger argues Stevens's appearance at church with Rogers is more objectionable than an endorsement alone. He says the setting reminds voters El-Sayed is not Christian while helping Republican efforts to control the Senate.

      [11]Max Berger on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

      Max Berger on Stevens's endorsement of RogersComplete Bluesky post 3mzbdhxzeys23
    8. Stevens announces her endorsement of Rogers

      Source release

      Stevens posts a video backing Rogers after appearing with him at a Detroit church. She says she no longer belongs in El-Sayed's campaign and remains a proud Democrat.

      [12]Haley Stevens

      Stevens announces support for Rogers and explains her break with El-Sayed.

      Haley Stevens announces her endorsement of Mike Rogers · Haley StevensPost caption and video, 00:00-01:38; endorsement at 00:13.24-00:19.88
      [13]Haley Stevens endorses Mike Rogers over Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan Senate race

      WDIV reports the endorsement and comments from Stevens, Rogers and El-Sayed.

      Haley Stevens endorses Mike Rogers over Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan Senate raceChurch appearance, comments to reporters and named reactions
      [14]Dingell describes canceling the planned joint appearance

      AP reports Dingell's account of why the planned appearance did not go ahead.

      Dingell describes canceling the planned joint appearanceAssociated Press report; Dingell's account of the canceled appearance
    9. Tennessee Holler argues party loyalty is being applied unevenly

      Reaction

      The Tennessee Holler contrasts criticism of progressives for insufficient loyalty with Stevens joining a Republican near Election Day. It presents her action as a double standard for establishment-backed Democrats.

      [15]The Tennessee Holler on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

    10. Tenbarge compares the response with criticism directed at progressives

      Reaction

      Tenbarge argues Stevens deserves at least as much condemnation for backing the right as progressives received for opposing what Tenbarge calls genocide. Her post criticizes the endorsement and the different treatment of the party's left.

      [16]Kat Tenbarge on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

      Kat Tenbarge on Stevens's endorsement of RogersComplete Bluesky post 3mzbfuokfgk2c
    11. Wild criticizes the endorsement over abortion rights and Trump loyalty

      Reaction

      Wild argues Stevens's endorsement betrays positions she previously defended on abortion rights and other issues. Drawing on their personal friendship, Wild also criticizes Rogers's treatment of El-Sayed and says the decision has damaged Stevens's standing among Democratic colleagues.

      [17]Susan Wild responds to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The complete post includes Wild's account of their friendship, her policy criticism and a conditional speculation about Stevens's relationship.

      Susan Wild responds to Stevens's endorsement of RogersComplete original X post 2116958831326744866
    12. Polgreen criticizes the endorsement as prejudice and use of voters as props

      Reaction

      Polgreen criticizes Stevens's move as anti-Muslim prejudice combined with cynical appeals to Black and Jewish voters. She argues those communities are being used to justify the reversal.

      [18]Lydia Polgreen on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

      Lydia Polgreen on Stevens's endorsement of RogersComplete Bluesky post 3mzbgmixkg224
    13. Hertel says Stevens is not a state-party member and will not be one

      Reaction

      Hertel says Stevens is not a current member of the Michigan Democratic Party and will not be one in the future.

      [19]Curtis Hertel

      Hertel states that Stevens is not a current member and rejects future membership.

    14. Nellis urges Democrats to examine their choice of primary candidate after voting

      Reaction

      Nellis argues Democrats should later examine why so much of the party supported Stevens. He urges setting that debate aside until after the election and rallying behind El-Sayed in the meantime.

      [20]Mike Nellis on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

      Mike Nellis on Stevens's endorsement of RogersComplete Bluesky post 3mzbhstimz22j
    15. Tlaib urges voters to turn the endorsement dispute into support for El-Sayed

      Reaction

      Tlaib says Michigan Democrats should feel better about nominating El-Sayed to fight for working-class families. She urges voters to ignore the dispute and turn out, framing a Rogers defeat as a second loss for Stevens.

      [21]Rashida Tlaib responds to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      Tlaib connects her turnout appeal to Stevens and the Democratic primary result.

      Rashida Tlaib responds to Stevens's endorsement of RogersComplete original X post 2116972096890741049
    16. Filipkowski predicts the endorsement ends Stevens's electoral path

      Reaction

      Filipkowski argues the response from Democratic leaders leaves Stevens without a future in their party, while she would also struggle to win a Republican primary. He compares that predicament with John Fetterman's position.

      [22]Ron Filipkowski on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

      Ron Filipkowski on Stevens's endorsement of RogersComplete Bluesky post 3mzbjodus3c2m
    17. Ley challenges the argument that establishment candidates are more dependable

      Source release

      Ley argues Stevens's reversal undermines the Democratic establishment's preference for supposedly reliable moderates. He interprets the endorsement as a response to personal grievances and questions what coherent political path it leaves her.

      [23]Ley comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      Ley gives his interpretation of the reversal and its implications for candidate selection.

    18. Van Hollen criticizes Stevens while condemning anti-Muslim campaign attacks

      Reaction

      Van Hollen says Stevens has become a tool of hate and urges voters to support El-Sayed. He argues attacks on the Democratic nominee are especially troubling because senior federal officials are promoting them.

      [24]Chris Van Hollen responds to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The statement appears on Van Hollen's campaign account and names Trump, Vance and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as sources of anti-Muslim attacks.

      Chris Van Hollen responds to Stevens's endorsement of RogersComplete original X post 2116977613595922636
    19. Soave rejects branding Stevens a traitor for breaking party ranks

      Source release

      Soave argues absolute party loyalty is not a virtue and that Democrats should be free to reject nominees they find too far left. He also says Stevens appears motivated largely by personal spite, so he does not present her action as a model of political courage.

      [25]Soave comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The essay defends political independence while distinguishing that principle from the author's view of Stevens's motives.

    20. Sellers sees a possible mobilizing backlash to the endorsement

      Source release

      Sellers initially fears the endorsement could damage Democrats, but says the resulting backlash and a recovery in prediction-market odds make him less pessimistic. He suggests the reaction could motivate progressive voters while leaving its electoral effect uncertain.

      [26]Sellers comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The proposed event follows the author's concluding MS Note, including his uncertainty about voter response.

    21. Chait disputes the endorsement as a defense of religious tolerance

      Source release

      Chait shares concerns about El-Sayed and antisemitism, but argues endorsing Rogers fails the same religious-tolerance standard. He says Stevens overlooks anti-Muslim and anti-Arab prejudice while objecting to bigotry affecting Jews.

      [27]Chait on Stevens and religious tolerance

      The essay evaluates the endorsement against a consistent standard for religious tolerance.

      Chait on Stevens and religious toleranceHaley Stevens Is Sending the Wrong Message, November 1, 2026
    22. Stein questions Stevens's rationale and selective objections

      Source release

      Stein argues that feeling unwelcome in El-Sayed's campaign does not require endorsing Rogers. He accepts concerns about El-Sayed's handling of antisemitism but says Stevens must also address anti-Muslim attacks and her policy disagreements with Rogers. He cautions against overstating the endorsement's electoral effect.

      [28]Haley Stevens Just Torched Her Political Career

      Stein and Egan separately evaluate the endorsement. They distinguish conjecture about motives from established facts.

      Haley Stevens Just Torched Her Political Career00:00-05:42; 11:02-14:23; 17:02-19:38
    23. Egan argues that Stevens risks her Democratic future

      Source release

      Egan argues that Stevens has no future in Democratic politics. She says an El-Sayed victory would leave Stevens without a place in the party, while a loss would bring blame for the defeat.

      [28]Haley Stevens Just Torched Her Political Career

      Stein and Egan separately evaluate the endorsement. They distinguish conjecture about motives from established facts.

      Haley Stevens Just Torched Her Political Career00:00-05:42; 11:02-14:23; 17:02-19:38
    24. Fitzgerald welcomes Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      Source release

      Actual Justice Warrior releases Fitzgerald's response to the endorsement. He welcomes Stevens's decision, argues that El-Sayed alienated her through his handling of the outside ad and campaign appearance, and urges Michigan voters to back Rogers.

      [29]Haley Stevens ENDORSES Mike Rogers

      Fitzgerald gives his own political commentary on the endorsement.

      Haley Stevens ENDORSES Mike Rogers00:43-01:51; 03:30-03:48; 09:10-09:51; 14:26-15:56
    25. Sirota sees the endorsement as a warning about corporate Democrats

      Source release

      Sirota argues Stevens's endorsement illustrates a corporate Democratic faction willing to help Republicans rather than lose influence to a progressive. He warns that this conflict would continue even after a Democratic midterm victory.

      [30]Sirota comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      Sirota attributes the endorsement to a struggle over influence and policy within the party. Those motives are his assessment.

    26. Carville criticizes Stevens's reversal and warns of isolation

      Source release

      Politicon releases Carville's response to the endorsement. He argues that Stevens has sacrificed her political future and cannot expect lasting Republican support. Using a sarcastic food comparison, he accuses her of abandoning her commitments and urges viewers to vote instead of dwelling on the dispute.

      [31]Carville: Haley Stevens' Political Career Is OVER

      Carville criticizes the endorsement and urges voters to reject the distraction.

    27. Jayapal predicts Democratic gains despite Stevens and urges a progressive agenda

      Reaction

      Jayapal predicts Democrats will regain the House and may also win the Senate despite Stevens's actions. She argues the progressive movement has the support needed to pass legislation improving working people's lives.

      [32]Pramila Jayapal responds to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The post links Jayapal's criticism of Stevens with her election forecast and legislative priorities.

      Pramila Jayapal responds to Stevens's endorsement of RogersComplete original X post 2117031012404269167
    28. Favreau challenges Stevens's reversal on El-Sayed's positions

      Source release

      Favreau argues that Stevens's personal grievance cannot explain abandoning her previous warnings about Rogers. He disputes her account of exclusion, interpreting El-Sayed's objection as limited to the planned event rather than her participation in the entire campaign.

      [33]Even Chuck Schumer Was Disgusted By Haley Stevens' Betrayal of Abdul El-Sayed

      Favreau and Pfeiffer criticize the reversal and discuss the Senate stakes and possible electoral effects.

    29. Pfeiffer contrasts Stevens's endorsement with her warnings about Rogers

      Source release

      Pfeiffer distinguishes withholding campaign help from actively backing a candidate Stevens had described as threatening abortion, labor and voting rights. He argues that her appearance with Rogers at a Detroit church makes the reversal especially divisive and damaging to her own political prospects.

      [33]Even Chuck Schumer Was Disgusted By Haley Stevens' Betrayal of Abdul El-Sayed

      Favreau and Pfeiffer criticize the reversal and discuss the Senate stakes and possible electoral effects.

    30. Khanna criticizes Newsom over Stevens's endorsement

      Reaction

      Khanna criticizes Newsom for not condemning Stevens's support for Rogers over El-Sayed. He argues that treating such a choice as part of a broad political coalition leaves the party without a clear principle.

      [34]Ro Khanna responds to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      Khanna responds to Newsom's assessment of the endorsement. The post also makes his own criticism of Newsom's positions on billionaires and health care.

      Ro Khanna responds to Stevens's endorsement of RogersComplete original X post 2117066889553650073
    31. Rogers presents Stevens's endorsement as broader crossover support

      Source release

      Fox 2 publishes Rogers saying Stevens called him that morning after being excluded from an El-Sayed event. He argues her backing reflects broader Democratic support for him, rather than an isolated endorsement.

      [35]Mike Rogers discusses surprise endorsement from Rep. Haley Stevens

      Rogers describes how the endorsement arose and argues it reflects broader crossover support.

      Mike Rogers discusses surprise endorsement from Rep. Haley StevensExclusive interview; endorsement background and Democrats for Rogers sections
    32. Dingell describes assurances before Stevens reversed course

      Source release

      Fox 2 publishes Dingell describing Stevens telling her at midnight that a Rogers endorsement was a false rumor. Dingell says she is upset but wants attention returned to the election.

      [36]Rep. Dingell and Sen. McMorrow on fallout from Stevens endorsement

      Fox 2 reports its interviews with Dingell and McMorrow.

      Rep. Dingell and Sen. McMorrow on fallout from Stevens endorsementDingell assurances and McMorrow constituent concerns sections
    33. McMorrow says constituent concerns outweigh the endorsement

      Source release

      Fox 2 publishes McMorrow saying her office is hearing about housing, prices, health care and voting rights rather than Stevens endorsing Rogers. She says calls about evictions have increased.

      [36]Rep. Dingell and Sen. McMorrow on fallout from Stevens endorsement

      Fox 2 reports its interviews with Dingell and McMorrow.

      Rep. Dingell and Sen. McMorrow on fallout from Stevens endorsementDingell assurances and McMorrow constituent concerns sections
    34. Sexton disputes explanations that reduce the endorsement to personal circumstances

      Reaction

      Sexton argues explanations focused on Stevens's mental state or her fiance obscure a struggle between corporate Democrats and the left. He criticizes those interpretations as excuses that divert attention from factional politics.

      [37]Jared Yates Sexton on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

    35. Malik criticizes Stevens

      Source release

      Malik portrays Stevens's endorsement as establishment Democrats resisting a left-wing victory.

      [38]Malik on Stevens

      Opinion essay.

      Malik on StevensEndorsement paragraph
    36. Hubbell argues Rogers endorsement abandons constituencies Stevens defended

      Source release

      Hubbell argues that endorsing Rogers betrays the voters whose rights Stevens previously defended against him. He says disagreement with El-Sayed over Israel could instead have led her to withdraw her endorsement or change her vote privately.

      [39]Hubbell comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The newsletter includes a section on Stevens and argues her public endorsement goes beyond disagreement over Israel.

    37. Suderman sees the Michigan dispute as a preview of Democratic factional conflict

      Source release

      Suderman argues Stevens's switch illustrates divisions between Democratic moderates and the party's left that an election victory would not resolve. He treats the Michigan race as a preview of further internal conflict after the midterms.

      [40]Suderman comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The opening section uses the Michigan endorsement dispute to assess divisions within the Democratic Party.

    38. Heer argues Stevens reveals a broader establishment problem

      Source release

      Heer argues Stevens's endorsement follows months of establishment efforts to constrain El-Sayed. He says condemning Stevens alone leaves unresolved the pro-Israel lobbying influence that, in his view, helped produce the confrontation.

      [41]Heer comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      Heer separates his explanation of Stevens's decision from his criticism of the wider party establishment.

    39. Granger criticizes Stevens's reversal on her stated priorities

      Source release

      Granger argues that backing Rogers contradicts Stevens's earlier criticism of his positions on health care, abortion and LGBTQ rights. She also objects to using a Detroit church appearance to suggest that Black voters' support transfers with Stevens without explaining policy benefits.

      [42]'DESPICABLE': Haley Stevens BLASTED by DEMS after ENDORSING Mike Rogers: Lindsey Granger | RISING

      Granger criticizes the endorsement while her co-host defends crossing party lines despite personal motives.

    40. Soave defends backing Rogers despite Stevens's personal motives

      Source release

      Soave agrees that personal resentment appears to influence Stevens but defends her decision. He argues that Democrats may reject a nominee they consider too far left and should not treat party loyalty as overriding their objections to a candidate.

      [42]'DESPICABLE': Haley Stevens BLASTED by DEMS after ENDORSING Mike Rogers: Lindsey Granger | RISING

      Granger criticizes the endorsement while her co-host defends crossing party lines despite personal motives.

    41. Uygur criticizes Stevens's explanation in her CNN interview

      Source release

      Uygur argues that Stevens's explanation for backing Rogers conflicts with her professed commitment to Democrats. He praises Cooper's questioning, rejects the accusation that Rebellion PAC's ad is antisemitic and says El-Sayed need not defend the ad to earn his support. He also alleges donor pressure, presenting his own interpretation of her motives.

      [43]Cenk Breaks Down Haley Stevens DISASTROUS Appearance on CNN

      Uygur criticizes Stevens and distinguishes his own commentary from replayed CNN footage.

      Cenk Breaks Down Haley Stevens DISASTROUS Appearance on CNN00:00-00:49; 02:38-03:50; 07:15-09:29; 16:38-17:47; 19:09-23:10
    42. Beutler argues defeating Republicans remains the immediate priority

      Reaction

      Beutler suggests the fallout from Stevens's endorsement could benefit the pro-democracy movement over time. He argues the immediate task remains unity to defeat Republicans, while expressing concern about whether that unity will hold.

      [44]Brian Beutler on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

      The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

      Brian Beutler on Stevens's endorsement of RogersComplete Bluesky post 3mzdwgjqmtc2o
    43. Griffin defends Stevens's right to switch

      Source release

      Griffin says crossing parties can reflect principle and argues that Democrats should extend the independence they celebrate in Cheney to Stevens.

      [45]ABC: The View endorsement debate

      Hosts debate Stevens's endorsement.

    44. Navarro challenges Stevens's reason for switching

      Source release

      Navarro argues that Stevens acted from personal rejection rather than principle, contrasting her appeal for kindness with Republican attacks on El-Sayed.

      [45]ABC: The View endorsement debate

      Hosts debate Stevens's endorsement.

    45. Hostin criticizes Stevens's priorities

      Source release

      Hostin criticizes Stevens for prioritizing personal disappointment over Democratic Senate oversight and points to anti-Muslim attacks from Republicans she now supports.

      [45]ABC: The View endorsement debate

      Hosts debate Stevens's endorsement.

    46. Haines defends Stevens's decision

      Source release

      Haines defends Stevens's choice as a principled break, citing El-Sayed's ties to Piker and exclusion of Stevens from a campaign appearance.

      [45]ABC: The View endorsement debate

      Hosts debate Stevens's endorsement.

    47. Clinton urges voting despite the dispute

      Source release

      Clinton calls the endorsement a distraction, urges voters to consider Rogers's tariff positions and warns against letting the controversy discourage voting.

      [46]ABC: Clinton and Swisher interview

      Clinton and Swisher respond.

    48. Swisher warns against dismissing online attention

      Source release

      Swisher agrees the controversy distracts from issues but warns that online attention means its potential impact cannot simply be dismissed.

      [46]ABC: Clinton and Swisher interview

      Clinton and Swisher respond.

    49. El-Sayed defeats Rogers two days after Stevens's endorsement

      The Associated Press called Michigan's U.S. Senate race for Democrat Abdul El-Sayed at 2:27 a.m. Eastern time on November 4, with 85% of ballots counted and El-Sayed ahead of Republican Mike Rogers by nearly 6 percentage points. Stevens had endorsed Rogers two days before the election. El-Sayed will be the first Muslim American to serve in the Senate.

      [47]NPR

      NPR report on the Associated Press call of Michigan's U.S. Senate race for El-Sayed. It notes Stevens's late endorsement of Rogers.

      [48]Bridge Michigan: Abdul El-Sayed beats Mike Rogers in U.S. Senate race

      Bridge Michigan report giving the time of the Associated Press race call and El-Sayed's margin with 85% of ballots counted.

Claims

Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.

What's disputed

Disputed claim

Ken Martin

Haley Stevens's endorsement of Mike Rogers is inconsistent with Democratic Party values.

What is disputed

Stevens says her choice reflects Michigan's values and that she remains a proud Democrat. Rogers praises the decision as courageous. Stevens (opens in a new tab); Rogers (opens in a new tab).

Sources (3)

Response record

Responses

Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.

17 responses. First 6 shown initially. Newest first.

  1. John SextonContributing editor at HotAir

    Before this statement

    Sexton wrote on Election Day, before results were known, after Sunny Hostin and Sara Haines disagreed about the endorsement on ABC's The View.

    "Why is it a heroic "act of conscience" for a Republican to step away from his or her party because of Trump, but it's a shameful "betrayal" for a Democrat to do the same because of El-Sayed?"
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Sexton argues that Democrats and the media praised Republicans who broke with Trump as acting on conscience but call Stevens's break with El-Sayed a betrayal. He presents the question as a point Sara Haines made on The View and says Stevens echoed it in her own statement.

    After the statement

    He also quotes Fox News analyst Brit Hume describing the reaction as "vicious hypocrisy".

    HotAir: Betrayal or Bravery? It Depends on the PartyOpening section on The View discussion

    Why this label?

    Sexton defends Stevens's endorsement by arguing that the criticism of it applies a double standard.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  2. Haley StevensU.S. representative and former Democratic Senate primary candidateDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    Stevens posted the statement on X the evening of November 2, Eastern time, the day after she endorsed Rogers at a Detroit church and the day before the election. It opens by acknowledging that the decision angered many Democrats.

    "But it was not impulsive, and it was not made for me by anyone else. It was a decision of conscience."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Stevens says her decision to withdraw her endorsement of El-Sayed and back Rogers was her own and was not impulsive. She cites being shut out of his campaign, ads she says hurt Black and Jewish voters, and his campaigning with Hasan Piker, and she rejects suggestions that her fiance made the decision for her.

    After the statement

    Later in the statement she says she hopes Rogers can serve "in the tradition of John McCain" and criticizes Democratic leaders who "rushed to condemn me" instead of asking why she reached her decision.

    Haley Stevens X article: The Decisions We MakeX article posted the evening of November 2, Eastern time
    WDIV: Haley Stevens defends decision to endorse Mike RogersReport on Stevens's November 2 statement on X

    Why this label?

    Stevens defends her endorsement of Rogers as a principled decision she made herself.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  3. Philip DeFrancoHost of The Philip DeFranco Show, delivering his own commentary

    Before this statement

    After summarizing the endorsement and a New York Times and Siena poll showing El-Sayed ahead, DeFranco said that in his opinion Stevens was a traitor, not to the Democratic Party but to her own professed ideals and to voters who oppose another senator aligned with Trump. He said she came across as extremely unwell, easily manipulated or driven by ego.

    "This is going to be kind of a short lived cope for her. She's exposed herself as a useful idiot that neither party can ever really trust."
    Condemned

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    On his show the day before the election, DeFranco said Stevens had betrayed her own professed ideals by endorsing Mike Rogers, and that the move exposed her as someone neither party could trust.

    After the statement

    He said she had tried to undercut the Democratic candidate key to flipping the Senate and asked whether Republicans would trust her, then joked that she might be secretly helping El-Sayed. The segment closed with his interview with Maryland Gov. Wes Moore, who called her reversal disappointing.

    The Philip DeFranco Show: The Haley Stevens Meltdown is Worse Than You Think · Philip DeFranco10:59-12:44: DeFranco gives his own view of Stevens's endorsement of Mike Rogers
    ClippingWings on X: DeFranco on Haley StevensX post with an 87-second excerpt of the November 2 episode and a transcription of DeFranco's remarks

    Why this label?

    Relative to Stevens endorsing Rogers over El-Sayed, DeFranco calls the move a short-lived cope and says it shows her to be a useful idiot neither party can trust. That condemns the endorsement.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  4. Mike RogersRepublican nominee for U.S. Senate in MichiganDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    Rogers says he is honored by the endorsement and accuses El-Sayed of anger and dismissiveness.

    "Congresswoman Stevens showed courage and bravery in putting Michigan first."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Rogers praises Stevens's decision and says they share priorities for Michigan.

    After the statement

    He describes their agreement on business, education and Michigan's future.

    Mike Rogers welcomes Haley Stevens's endorsement · Mike RogersPost 2117032241452720190

    Why this label?

    Relative to Stevens's endorsement, Rogers calls her decision courageous and says it puts Michigan first.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  5. Bernie SandersU.S. senator from Vermont

    Before this statement

    Sanders posted on the afternoon of November 1, after Stevens's chief of staff, Justin German, and other staff members resigned and endorsed El-Sayed.

    "Rep. Haley Stevens' staff is right to resign in disgust. They understand that the election in Michigan is far more important than Haley's fragile ego and that all of us must stand together to elect Abdul, defeat Rogers and end the Republican rubber-stamp control of the Senate."
    Condemned

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Sanders says Stevens's staff were right to resign over her endorsement of Rogers. He attributes the endorsement to her ego and urges Democrats to unite behind El-Sayed to defeat Rogers and end Republican control of the Senate.

    After the statement

    Sanders had endorsed El-Sayed in the primary.

    Why this label?

    Sanders condemns the endorsement and supports the staff who resigned over it.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  6. Nancy PelosiFormer House speaker and U.S. representative from California

    Before this statement

    Pelosi addresses Stevens endorsing Rogers.

    "Haley Stevens has chosen to dangerously betray Michigan families’ healthcare, freedoms and future with her horrific endorsement of Mike Rogers."
    Condemned

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Pelosi calls Stevens's endorsement of Rogers a betrayal of Michigan families and says El-Sayed must win.

    After the statement

    Pelosi calls for an El-Sayed victory.

    Why this label?

    Relative to Stevens endorsing Rogers, Pelosi explicitly condemns the decision as a betrayal.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

View all 17 responsesShow fewer responses
  1. Elissa SlotkinU.S. senator from Michigan

    Before this statement

    Slotkin discusses voters' worries about prices and says she had avoided commenting on Stevens until this post.

    "should think hard about whether they are serving the greater good."
    Condemned

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Slotkin criticizes making the election about an individual and urges electing El-Sayed.

    After the statement

    She says the election is bigger than one person and urges electing El-Sayed.

    Elissa Slotkin responds to Haley Stevens's endorsement · Elissa SlotkinPost 2116975974751346743

    Why this label?

    Addressing Stevens's actions, Slotkin criticizes making the election about oneself and urges electing El-Sayed.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  2. J StreetU.S. advocacy organization focused on Israel and Palestinian peace

    Before this statement

    J Street describes Rogers as a candidate who would rubber-stamp Trump's agenda.

    "Haley Stevens has betrayed everything she purported to stand for throughout her campaign and her time in Congress."
    Condemned

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    J Street says Stevens betrayed what she claimed to stand for by endorsing Rogers.

    After the statement

    The organization states it has not endorsed El-Sayed and has substantive policy disagreements with him.

    J Street statement on Stevens endorsementComplete original statement, including non-endorsement qualification

    Why this label?

    Relative to Stevens endorsing Rogers, the organization explicitly condemns her decision as betraying her stated commitments.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  3. Chuck SchumerSenate Democratic leader

    Before this statement

    Schumer responds to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers.

    "This is a despicable betrayal from Rep. Stevens."
    Condemned

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Schumer condemns Stevens's decision and reaffirms support for El-Sayed.

    After the statement

    He contrasts El-Sayed's economic priorities with Rogers's support for Trump.

    Chuck Schumer condemns Haley Stevens's endorsement · Chuck SchumerPost 2116969707425468536

    Why this label?

    Relative to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers, Schumer expressly calls it a betrayal.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  4. Donald TrumpPresident of the United States

    Before this statement

    Trump announces that Stevens has endorsed Rogers.

    "It’s a thing called bravery, and few people have it like just displayed by Congresswoman Haley Stevens!"
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Trump praises Stevens's support for Rogers as an act of bravery.

    After the statement

    He closes the post with his name and title.

    Donald Trump praises Haley Stevens's endorsement · Donald TrumpTruth Social post 117542639036452664

    Why this label?

    Relative to Stevens's endorsement, Trump praises her decision as brave and loyal to Michigan.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  5. Hasan PikerPolitical commentator responding to Stevens on X

    Before this statement

    Piker attacks Stevens's motives and denies she speaks for Democrats or Jewish and Black people.

    "haley and mike rogers serve trump, and trump serves the epstein class."
    Condemned

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Piker says Stevens and Rogers serve Trump, whom he accuses of serving the Epstein class.

    After the statement

    He closes by saying the choice is clear.

    Hasan Piker criticizes Stevens's endorsement of Rogers · Hasan PikerQuote post of Stevens, post 2116949171399971107

    Why this label?

    Relative to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers, Piker criticizes her and Rogers as serving Trump.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  6. Tommy VietorCo-host of Pod Save America and Pod Save the World

    Before this statement

    Vietor replies directly to Stevens's endorsement announcement.

    "Congrats on being the saddest sore loser in politics since Trump 2020! Historic stuff."
    Condemned

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Vietor criticizes Stevens's decision by comparing it with Trump's response to losing in 2020.

    After the statement

    He closes the reply with a sarcastic description of the decision as historic.

    Tommy Vietor criticizes Haley Stevens's endorsement · Tommy VietorReply to Stevens, post 2116947435578867976

    Why this label?

    Relative to Stevens's endorsement, Vietor condemns her response to losing the primary through a sarcastic comparison with Trump.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  7. Haley StevensU.S. representative and former Democratic Senate primary candidateDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    Stevens says El-Sayed told her she was no longer welcome in his campaign.

    "I am endorsing Mike Rogers for the United States Senate today."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Stevens endorses Rogers, saying El-Sayed told her she was no longer welcome in his campaign.

    After the statement

    She says she is still a very proud Democrat.

    Haley Stevens announces her endorsement of Mike Rogers · Haley StevensPost caption and video, 00:00-01:38; endorsement at 00:13.24-00:19.88

    Why this label?

    Relative to her endorsement of Rogers over El-Sayed, Stevens explicitly supports Rogers and explains her choice.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  8. Jamie RaskinU.S. representative from Maryland

    Before this statement

    The report says Raskin left their Saturday conversation expecting Stevens would not support Rogers.

    "I’m dumbfounded that Haley would tell me one thing last night and then change her mind today"
    Condemned

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Raskin says Stevens reversed her position after their conversation the previous evening.

    After the statement

    The article also reports that Stevens signaled continued support for El-Sayed in Saturday messages to friends.

    Haley Stevens's Sabotage MissionRaskin interview in second paragraph; final paragraph

    Why this label?

    Relative to the endorsement, Raskin criticizes Stevens reversing her assurance.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  9. Mike JohnsonHouse speaker

    Before this statement

    Johnson speaks to reporters before a rally in Dubuque, Iowa.

    "I sent her a note, spoke to Haley, and told her how great she was"
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Johnson praises the endorsement and says he contacted Stevens to express appreciation.

    After the statement

    Johnson calls Stevens thoughtful and says he told her to stay safe.

    Trump and Johnson invite Stevens to join RepublicansOriginal reporter questions before Dubuque rally; Johnson response

    Why this label?

    The conduct under scrutiny is Stevens endorsing Rogers. Johnson supports that endorsement, calling it heroic and important for the country.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  10. Ken MartinChair of the Democratic National Committee

    Before this statement

    Martin addresses Stevens's decision to endorse Rogers and describes him as a Trump ally.

    "is a betrayal of the values of the Democratic Party."
    Condemned

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Martin says Stevens's support for Rogers violates Democratic values and urges electing El-Sayed.

    After the statement

    He rejects division within the party and promises greater efforts to elect El-Sayed.

    Ken Martin responds to Haley Stevens's endorsement · Democratic National CommitteeStatement released in the name of DNC Chair Ken Martin

    Why this label?

    Relative to Stevens's endorsement, Martin condemns the choice as a betrayal of Democratic values.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  11. Curtis HertelMichigan Democratic Party chair, quoted by Roll Call

    Before this statement

    Hertel addresses Stevens's decision to campaign with Rogers.

    "shows that she has abandoned everything she claims to care about"
    Condemned

    Case context: Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal

    Full statement and sources

    Hertel says Stevens's support for Rogers abandons her priorities.

    After the statement

    Schumer also criticizes the endorsement.

    Haley Stevens endorses Republican Mike Rogers for SenateAccount of the preceding ad dispute, endorsement and named reactions

    Why this label?

    Relative to Stevens's support for Rogers, Hertel criticizes it as abandoning her priorities.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

Sources

(64)

Original post

Haley Stevens announces her endorsement of Mike Rogers

Haley Stevens announces her endorsement of Mike Rogers (opens in a new tab) · Haley StevensPost caption and video, 00:00-01:38; endorsement at 00:13.24-00:19.88

Rep. Haley Stevens announces that she is endorsing Mike Rogers for the U.S. Senate, in a video posted to X on Nov. 1, 2026.

DI added its logo in the corner.

Video: Haley Stevens (@HaleyforMI on X). Excerpt used for news reporting and commentary

Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: Post caption and video, 00:00-01:38; endorsement at 00:13.24-00:19.88)

About this source

Stevens announces support for Rogers and explains her break with El-Sayed.

Published
Accessed

Original post

ClippingWings on X: DeFranco on Haley Stevens

ClippingWings on X: DeFranco on Haley Stevens (opens in a new tab)X post with an 87-second excerpt of the November 2 episode and a transcription of DeFranco's remarks

About this source

A clip account posted an excerpt of DeFranco's November 2 segment on Haley Stevens with a written transcription of part of his remarks. The transcribed words match the audio of the full episode.

Author
ClippingWings (@ClippingWings)
Published
Accessed

Original video

The Philip DeFranco Show: The Haley Stevens Meltdown is Worse Than You Think

The Philip DeFranco Show: The Haley Stevens Meltdown is Worse Than You Think (opens in a new tab) · Philip DeFranco10:59-12:44: DeFranco gives his own view of Stevens's endorsement of Mike Rogers

About this source

Episode of The Philip DeFranco Show released November 2, 2026, the day before the election. The opening segment covers Rep. Haley Stevens's endorsement of Republican Mike Rogers over Democrat Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan's Senate race, then DeFranco gives his own view.

Author
Philip DeFranco
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Bridge Michigan: Abdul El-Sayed beats Mike Rogers in U.S. Senate race

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Time and margin of the AP race call

About this source

Bridge Michigan report giving the time of the Associated Press race call and El-Sayed's margin with 85% of ballots counted.

Author
Lauren Gibbons
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

NPR: Democrat Abdul El-Sayed defeats Republican Mike Rogers in Michigan Senate race

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Race call by the Associated Press

About this source

NPR report on the Associated Press call of Michigan's U.S. Senate race for El-Sayed. It notes Stevens's late endorsement of Rogers.

Author
Sam Gringlas
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Analysis

HotAir: Betrayal or Bravery? It Depends on the Party

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Opening section on The View discussion

About this source

Opinion post by HotAir contributing editor John Sexton, published on Election Day before results were known. It responds to a discussion of Stevens's endorsement on ABC's The View and cites remarks by Fox News analyst Brit Hume.

Author
John Sexton
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Bernie Sanders X post on Stevens's staff resignations

About this source

Sanders's own post on his verified X account, responding to the resignations of Stevens's chief of staff and other staff members.

Author
Bernie Sanders
Published
Accessed

Reporting

WDIV: Haley Stevens defends decision to endorse Mike Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Report on Stevens's November 2 statement on X

About this source

WDIV Local 4 report summarizing and quoting the statement Stevens posted on X on Monday, November 2.

Author
Brandon Carr
Published
Accessed

Original post

Haley Stevens X article: The Decisions We Make

Haley Stevens X article: The Decisions We Make (opens in a new tab)X article posted the evening of November 2, Eastern time

About this source

Stevens's own statement, published as an X article on her campaign account, explaining why she withdrew her endorsement of Abdul El-Sayed and endorsed Mike Rogers.

Author
Haley Stevens
Published
Accessed

Original post

Chris Van Hollen responds to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

About this source

The statement appears on Van Hollen's campaign account and names Trump, Vance and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as sources of anti-Muslim attacks.

Author
Chris Van Hollen (@VanHollenForMD)
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Pramila Jayapal responds to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

About this source

The post links Jayapal's criticism of Stevens with her election forecast and legislative priorities.

Author
Pramila Jayapal (@PramilaJayapal)
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Ro Khanna responds to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

About this source

Khanna responds to Newsom's assessment of the endorsement. The post also makes his own criticism of Newsom's positions on billionaires and health care.

Author
Ro Khanna (@RoKhanna)
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Rashida Tlaib responds to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

About this source

Tlaib connects her turnout appeal to Stevens and the Democratic primary result.

Author
Rashida Tlaib (@RashidaTlaib)
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Susan Wild responds to Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

About this source

The complete post includes Wild's account of their friendship, her policy criticism and a conditional speculation about Stevens's relationship.

Author
Susan Wild (@wildforcongress)
Published
Accessed

Original post

J Street statement on Stevens endorsement

J Street statement on Stevens endorsement (opens in a new tab)Complete original statement, including non-endorsement qualification

About this source

J Street condemns the endorsement while stating it has not endorsed El-Sayed and disagrees with some of his policies.

Author
J Street
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Stevens endorsement criticized at Detroit unity roundtable

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Bowman and Alawieh comments at Haraz Coffee House

About this source

The reporter records separate criticisms of the endorsement at a campaign roundtable.

Author
Minnah Arshad
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Haley Stevens Pulls Plug on Presser While Heckled as Traitor for Endorsing Mike Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Staff resignation report and church press availability

About this source

TheWrap reports staff resignations and the end of the joint press availability.

Author
Benjamin Lindsay
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Trump and Johnson invite Stevens to join Republicans

Trump and Johnson invite Stevens to join Republicans (opens in a new tab)Original reporter questions before Dubuque rally; Johnson response
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Original reporter questions before Dubuque rally; Johnson response

About this source

Trump welcomes a party switch; Johnson defends the endorsement and describes speaking with Stevens.

Author
Thomas Catenacci
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Mike Rogers discusses surprise endorsement from Rep. Haley Stevens

Mike Rogers discusses surprise endorsement from Rep. Haley Stevens (opens in a new tab)Exclusive interview; endorsement background and Democrats for Rogers sections
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Exclusive interview; endorsement background and Democrats for Rogers sections

About this source

Rogers describes how the endorsement arose and argues it reflects broader crossover support.

Author
Nick Jachim
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Rep. Dingell and Sen. McMorrow on fallout from Stevens endorsement

Rep. Dingell and Sen. McMorrow on fallout from Stevens endorsement (opens in a new tab)Dingell assurances and McMorrow constituent concerns sections
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Dingell assurances and McMorrow constituent concerns sections

About this source

Fox 2 reports its interviews with Dingell and McMorrow.

Author
Nick Jachim
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Official statement

Statement from DNC Black Caucus Chair Virgie Rollins

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Complete statement

About this source

Rollins criticizes Stevens and urges electing El-Sayed.

Author
Virgie Rollins
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Haley Stevens's Sabotage Mission

Haley Stevens's Sabotage Mission (opens in a new tab)Raskin interview in second paragraph; final paragraph
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Raskin interview in second paragraph; final paragraph

About this source

Raskin contrasts Sunday with Saturday assurances.

Author
Daniel Strauss
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Pelosi responds to Stevens endorsement

About this source

Pelosi criticizes Stevens and urges electing El-Sayed.

Author
Nancy Pelosi
Published
Accessed

Original post

Mike Nellis on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Complete Bluesky post 3mzbhstimz22j

About this source

The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

Author
Mike Nellis (@mikenellis.bsky.social)
Published
Accessed

Original post

Brian Beutler on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Complete Bluesky post 3mzdwgjqmtc2o

About this source

The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

Author
Brian Beutler (@brianbeutler.bsky.social)
Published
Accessed

Original post

Ron Filipkowski on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Complete Bluesky post 3mzbjodus3c2m

About this source

The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

Author
Ron Filipkowski (@ronfilipkowski.bsky.social)
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

The Tennessee Holler on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Complete Bluesky post 3mzbe4643t22d

About this source

The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

Author
The Tennessee Holler (@thetnholler.bsky.social)
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Jared Yates Sexton on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Complete Bluesky post 3mzc75hn7sk2v

About this source

The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

Author
Jared Yates Sexton (@jysexton.bsky.social)
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Kat Tenbarge on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Complete Bluesky post 3mzbfuokfgk2c

About this source

The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

Author
Kat Tenbarge (@kattenbarge.bsky.social)
Published
Accessed

Original post

Lydia Polgreen on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Complete Bluesky post 3mzbgmixkg224

About this source

The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

Author
Lydia Polgreen (@polgreen.bsky.social)
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Max Berger on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Complete Bluesky post 3mzbdhxzeys23

About this source

The author gives an assessment of Stevens's support for Rogers.

Author
Max Berger (@maxberger.bsky.social)
Published
Accessed

Analysis

Suderman comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Author essay, 2026-11-02

About this source

The opening section uses the Michigan endorsement dispute to assess divisions within the Democratic Party.

Author
Peter Suderman
Published
Accessed

Analysis

Heer comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Author essay, 2026-11-02

About this source

Heer separates his explanation of Stevens's decision from his criticism of the wider party establishment.

Author
Jeet Heer
Published
Accessed

Analysis

Soave comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Author essay, 2026-11-01

About this source

The essay defends political independence while distinguishing that principle from the author's view of Stevens's motives.

Author
Robby Soave
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Analysis

Sirota comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Author essay, 2026-11-01

About this source

Sirota attributes the endorsement to a struggle over influence and policy within the party. Those motives are his assessment.

Author
David Sirota
Published
Accessed

Analysis

Ley comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Author essay, 2026-11-01

About this source

Ley gives his interpretation of the reversal and its implications for candidate selection.

Author
Tom Ley
Published
Accessed

Analysis

Sellers comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Author essay, 2026-11-01

About this source

The proposed event follows the author's concluding MS Note, including his uncertainty about voter response.

Author
Michael Sellers
Published
Accessed

Analysis

Hubbell comments on Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Author essay, 2026-11-02

About this source

The newsletter includes a section on Stevens and argues her public endorsement goes beyond disagreement over Israel.

Author
Robert B. Hubbell
Published
Accessed

Analysis

Malik on Stevens

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Endorsement paragraph

About this source

Opinion essay.

Author
Nesrine Malik
Published
Accessed

Analysis

Chait on Stevens and religious tolerance

Chait on Stevens and religious tolerance (opens in a new tab)Haley Stevens Is Sending the Wrong Message, November 1, 2026
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Haley Stevens Is Sending the Wrong Message, November 1, 2026

About this source

The essay evaluates the endorsement against a consistent standard for religious tolerance.

Author
Jonathan Chait
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

'DESPICABLE': Haley Stevens BLASTED by DEMS after ENDORSING Mike Rogers: Lindsey Granger | RISING

About this source

Granger criticizes the endorsement while her co-host defends crossing party lines despite personal motives.

Author
Lindsey Granger and Robby Soave, Rising, The Hill
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

Even Chuck Schumer Was Disgusted By Haley Stevens' Betrayal of Abdul El-Sayed

About this source

Favreau and Pfeiffer criticize the reversal and discuss the Senate stakes and possible electoral effects.

Author
Jon Favreau and Dan Pfeiffer, Pod Save America
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

Haley Stevens Just Torched Her Political Career

About this source

Stein and Egan separately evaluate the endorsement. They distinguish conjecture about motives from established facts.

Author
Sam Stein and Lauren Egan, The Bulwark
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

ABC: Clinton and Swisher interview

About this source

Clinton and Swisher respond.

Author
ABC
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

ABC: The View endorsement debate

About this source

Hosts debate Stevens's endorsement.

Author
ABC
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

Haley Stevens ENDORSES Mike Rogers

Haley Stevens ENDORSES Mike Rogers (opens in a new tab)00:43-01:51; 03:30-03:48; 09:10-09:51; 14:26-15:56

About this source

Fitzgerald gives his own political commentary on the endorsement.

Author
Sean Fitzgerald, Actual Justice Warrior
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

Cenk Breaks Down Haley Stevens DISASTROUS Appearance on CNN

Cenk Breaks Down Haley Stevens DISASTROUS Appearance on CNN (opens in a new tab)00:00-00:49; 02:38-03:50; 07:15-09:29; 16:38-17:47; 19:09-23:10

About this source

Uygur criticizes Stevens and distinguishes his own commentary from replayed CNN footage.

Author
Cenk Uygur, The Young Turks
Published
Accessed

Original video

MAJOR BREAKING: HALEY STEVENS RATF*CKS ABDUL AT LAST SECOND

About this source

Kulinski responds to Stevens campaigning with Rogers before her endorsement announcement.

Author
Kyle Kulinski, Secular Talk
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

Carville: Haley Stevens' Political Career Is OVER

About this source

Carville criticizes the endorsement and urges voters to reject the distraction.

Author
James Carville, Politicon
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Dingell describes canceling the planned joint appearance

Dingell describes canceling the planned joint appearance (opens in a new tab)Associated Press report; Dingell's account of the canceled appearance
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Associated Press report; Dingell's account of the canceled appearance

About this source

AP reports Dingell's account of why the planned appearance did not go ahead.

Published
Accessed

Interview

Stevens discusses backing El-Sayed after her primary loss

Rep. Haley Stevens tells Major Garrett why she now backs Abdul El-Sayed and criticizes Mike Rogers, on CBS News 24/7's "The Takeout," Aug. 6, 2026.

Excerpt from 0:43 to 2:48 of the CBS News video. Taken from CBS News's own video page. The CBS News YouTube upload cited for this source shows the same interview. DI added its logo in the corner.

Video: CBS News. Excerpt used for news reporting and commentary

Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: CBS News, The Takeout; complete interview, 11:11)

About this source

Stevens defends her support for El-Sayed in an interview released August 6.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Official statement

Haley Stevens concedes and endorses Abdul El-Sayed

Haley Stevens concedes and endorses Abdul El-Sayed (opens in a new tab) · Haley StevensCampaign statement dated August 5, 2026
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Campaign statement dated August 5, 2026

About this source

Stevens congratulates El-Sayed, endorses him and criticizes Rogers.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Haley Stevens offers Abdul El-Sayed her support after the primary

About this source

Stevens says she spoke with El-Sayed to offer her full support against Rogers.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Abdul El-Sayed wins the Michigan Democratic Senate primary

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Primary result and Stevens's support for El-Sayed

About this source

Roll Call reports the result of the August 4 primary, called on August 5.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Hasan Piker criticizes Stevens's endorsement of Rogers

Hasan Piker criticizes Stevens's endorsement of Rogers (opens in a new tab) · Hasan PikerQuote post of Stevens, post 2116949171399971107

About this source

Piker responds to Stevens's endorsement and argues that the election should focus on affordability and democracy.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Haley Stevens endorses Mike Rogers over Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan Senate race

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Church appearance, comments to reporters and named reactions

About this source

WDIV reports the endorsement and comments from Stevens, Rogers and El-Sayed.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Haley Stevens endorses Republican Mike Rogers for Senate

Haley Stevens endorses Republican Mike Rogers for Senate (opens in a new tab)Account of the preceding ad dispute, endorsement and named reactions
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Account of the preceding ad dispute, endorsement and named reactions

About this source

Roll Call reports the endorsement, the preceding dispute and the parties' responses.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Elissa Slotkin responds to Haley Stevens's endorsement

About this source

Slotkin criticizes the focus on individual politicians and calls for electing El-Sayed.

Published
Accessed

Original post

Tommy Vietor criticizes Haley Stevens's endorsement

Tommy Vietor criticizes Haley Stevens's endorsement (opens in a new tab) · Tommy VietorReply to Stevens, post 2116947435578867976

About this source

Vietor replies to Stevens's endorsement announcement.

Published
Accessed

Original text

Donald Trump praises Haley Stevens's endorsement

Donald Trump praises Haley Stevens's endorsement (opens in a new tab) · Donald TrumpTruth Social post 117542639036452664
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Truth Social post 117542639036452664

About this source

Trump praises Stevens for supporting Rogers.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Curtis Hertel states Haley Stevens's Michigan Democratic Party membership status

About this source

Hertel states that Stevens is not a current member and rejects future membership.

Published
Accessed

Official statement

Ken Martin responds to Haley Stevens's endorsement

Ken Martin responds to Haley Stevens's endorsement (opens in a new tab) · Democratic National CommitteeStatement released in the name of DNC Chair Ken Martin
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Statement released in the name of DNC Chair Ken Martin

About this source

Martin criticizes the endorsement and calls for intensified support for El-Sayed.

Author
Ken Martin
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Chuck Schumer condemns Haley Stevens's endorsement

About this source

Schumer criticizes the endorsement and reaffirms support for El-Sayed.

Published
Accessed

Original post

Mike Rogers welcomes Haley Stevens's endorsement

About this source

Rogers welcomes the endorsement and explains his stated agreement with Stevens.

Published
Accessed

Case updates

Want the next important update?

Follow this case and get an email when an important development changes the record.

5 updates added in the last 14 days.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

The newsletter

Follow disputes like this one.

New cases and significant updates to the record, in your inbox. Free.

You’ll confirm your subscription on Substack.

Share or embed this case

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/cases/haley-stevens-mike-rogers-endorsement-abdul-el-sayed

The Dispute Index. "Haley Stevens defends endorsing Mike Rogers; Schumer calls it a betrayal". First published: 2026-11-02. Last updated: 2026-11-02. https://disputeindex.com/cases/haley-stevens-mike-rogers-endorsement-abdul-el-sayed