Family Foundation's legal arm asks a Tazewell judge to void Virginia's voter-approved reproductive freedom amendment; Spanberger says it will be sustained
The Founding Freedoms Law Center asks a Tazewell County judge to block certification of Virginia's voter-approved reproductive freedom amendment, saying the ballot question misled voters and a posting step was skipped. Gov. Abigail Spanberger says the amendment will be sustained.
BackgroundHow are U.S. election results certified?

Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Overview
Amending the Virginia Constitution takes a vote of the General Assembly, an intervening election for the House of Delegates, a second vote on the same language and then a statewide referendum. A state law required the House clerk to send proposed amendments to circuit court clerks to be posted at courthouses before the intervening election. Cardinal News (opens in a new tab) reports that a bill Spanberger signed in March retroactively removed that requirement. The challengers say the posting was never done before the 2025 elections.
Earlier in 2026, Judge Hurley ruled the General Assembly's mid-decade redistricting amendment unconstitutional and blocked Explainerelection certificationElection-night numbers are unofficial. Local officials finish the count, check it in a canvass and certify the results, and a state board or official then certifies the statewide result. Several states treat certifying as a required duty, and courts have ordered officials who refused or delayed to certify.How are U.S. election results certified? of its April referendum. The Supreme Court of Virginia overturned that referendum 4-3 in May. According to WTOP (opens in a new tab), the center is also challenging, on the same procedural grounds, the amendment that removes the same-sex marriage ban from the state constitution.
Background: How are U.S. election results certified?
People in this case
Abigail SpanbergerDirectly involved
Timeline
4 timeline entries on this page. Dates: April 30, 2026 to November 12, 2026
April 2026
Founding Freedoms Law Center sues in Tazewell County over the ballot question
Incident
The center files suit for the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons, the Virginia Medical Freedom Alliance and Meagan Kade, asking the court to declare the ballot question misleading and to bar certification if voters approve the amendment.
[01]Founding Freedoms Law Center
The complaint, filed for two physician groups and a Tazewell County resident, says the ballot question never mentions a fundamental right to reproductive freedom and fails to tell voters about effects such as ending parental consent for minors. It also says the House clerk did not send the amendment to circuit court clerks for posting before the 2025 election, and it asks the court to bar certification.
Complaint in Association of American Physicians and Surgeons v. Virginia State Board of Elections, Tazewell County Circuit Court · Founding Freedoms Law CenterComplaint filed April 30, 2026, paragraphs 1 to 3 and the prayer for relief[02]Founding Freedoms Law Center
The center announces its suit in Tazewell County Circuit Court, links the complaint and lists effects of the amendment that it says the ballot question leaves out, including parental consent for minors and limits on who may perform an abortion.
Founding Freedoms Law Center release on its lawsuit over the ballot question · Founding Freedoms Law CenterNews release, April 30, 2026
October 2026
Tazewell court denies the state's motions and sets a hearing after the election
The center says the court denied the state's motions to prevent a hearing the week after the election and set arguments for November 13 before Judge Jack Hurley.
[03]Founding Freedoms Law Center
The center says the Tazewell Circuit Court denied the state's motions to prevent a hearing the week after the election, set arguments for November 13 before Judge Jack Hurley, and that it will seek a preliminary injunction against certification.
Founding Freedoms Law Center release on the Tazewell court setting a post-election hearing · Founding Freedoms Law CenterNews release, October 26, 2026
November 2026
Virginia voters approve the reproductive freedom amendment
With 97 percent of the vote counted, the Associated Press records 2,195,088 votes for the amendment and 1,319,073 against, as reported by WTOP.
[04]WTOP
WTOP reports the vote count and interviews Josh Hetzler on the procedural and ballot-language claims, Gov. Abigail Spanberger on why she expects the amendments to be sustained, and House Majority Leader Charniele Herring.
Virginians approve reproductive freedom amendment. It will be challenged in court next week. · WTOPArticle, November 4, 2026Judge Hurley says he will rule before he retires; the hearing is set for November 24
Hurley, who plans to retire December 31, tells Cardinal News he intends to make a final ruling on the challenge before he leaves the bench. Cardinal News reports the hearing is slated for November 24.
[05]Tazewell County Judge Hurley to retire, but not before ruling on a challenge to a constitutional amendment recently approved by voters
Cardinal News reports that Judge Jack Hurley plans to retire December 31, is slated to hear the challenge November 24 and intends to rule before he retires, and that a law Spanberger signed in March retroactively removed the posting requirement.
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Founding Freedoms Law Center
Virginia's reproductive freedom amendment cannot be certified because its ballot question misled voters and the required courthouse posting was not done before the 2025 election.
What is disputed
Gov. Abigail Spanberger says the amendment will be sustained because the General Assembly followed the multistep process with a full intervening election. WTOP reports that the posting requirement was repealed after the amendments had begun moving through the process.
Sources (4)
- Complaint in Association of American Physicians and Surgeons v. Virginia State Board of Elections, Tazewell County Circuit Court · Founding Freedoms Law CenterComplaint filed April 30, 2026, paragraphs 1 to 3 and the prayer for relief
- Founding Freedoms Law Center release on its lawsuit over the ballot question · Founding Freedoms Law CenterNews release, April 30, 2026
- Virginians approve reproductive freedom amendment. It will be challenged in court next week. · WTOPArticle, November 4, 2026
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
3 matching responses. Newest first.
Josh HetzlerExecutive director and chief counsel of the Founding Freedoms Law Center, speaking to WTOPDirectly involved Before this statement
WTOP reports that voters approved the amendment and that the center's challenge will be heard in a Tazewell County court.
"We believe that if you’re going to amend the constitution, you must first follow the constitution, and we believe that did not occur"
CondemnedResponding to: Virginia's reproductive freedom amendment cannot be certified because its ballot question misled voters and the required courthouse posting was not done before the 2025 election.
Full statement and sources
Hetzler tells WTOP that the amendment was not adopted according to the constitution's rules, citing both the procedure and what he calls a deceptive ballot question.
After the statement
Hetzler tells WTOP that copies of the amendment were not posted at courthouses as required and that the Supreme Court of Virginia has demanded strict compliance with the rules for changing the constitution.
Virginians approve reproductive freedom amendment. It will be challenged in court next week. · WTOPArticle, November 4, 2026Why this label?
Hetzler says the state skipped constitutional steps and put a deceptive question on the ballot, so we labeled it condemns.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Abigail SpanbergerGovernor of Virginia, as quoted by WTOPDirectly involvedBefore this statement
WTOP asks Spanberger about the challenge. She says the redistricting amendment in the spring was overturned on the basis of its timeline.
"will be sustained, because here, the General Assembly clearly had a full intervening election to include a full time frame of early voting, and it went through the multistep process in order to have a vote before the people."
Defended or excusedResponding to: Virginia's reproductive freedom amendment cannot be certified because its ballot question misled voters and the required courthouse posting was not done before the 2025 election.
Full statement and sources
Asked about the legal challenge, Spanberger says she is confident the amendment will be upheld, and she contrasts it with the spring redistricting amendment, which she says was overturned over its timeline.
After the statement
WTOP also quotes House Majority Leader Charniele Herring, who says she is hopeful about the outcome and expects the amendment to be defended vigorously.
Virginians approve reproductive freedom amendment. It will be challenged in court next week. · WTOPArticle, November 4, 2026Why this label?
Spanberger says the General Assembly followed the required process and the amendments will stand, which defends how the amendment was adopted, so we labeled it a defense.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Founding Freedoms Law CenterLegal arm of The Family Foundation, in a news release announcing its lawsuitDirectly involved Before this statement
The release lists effects the center says the amendment would have and the ballot question omits, including ending parental notification and consent before a minor obtains an abortion and allowing any person to perform an abortion.
"A voter reading the ballot question would not know about any of these major impacts. But we believe that if voters knew about any one of these outcomes, many Virginians would vote differently."
CondemnedResponding to: Virginia's reproductive freedom amendment cannot be certified because its ballot question misled voters and the required courthouse posting was not done before the 2025 election.
Full statement and sources
Announcing its lawsuit, the center says the ballot question does not tell voters about effects it attributes to the amendment and that many voters would decide differently if they knew them.
After the statement
The release adds that the ballot question implies tighter limits on third-trimester abortions and does not use the terms fundamental right or reproductive freedom.
Founding Freedoms Law Center release on its lawsuit over the ballot question · Founding Freedoms Law CenterNews release, April 30, 2026Complaint in Association of American Physicians and Surgeons v. Virginia State Board of Elections, Tazewell County Circuit Court · Founding Freedoms Law CenterComplaint filed April 30, 2026, paragraphs 1 to 3 and the prayer for reliefWhy this label?
The center says the ballot question hides major effects of the amendment from voters, so we labeled it condemns.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(6)
Original text
Complaint in Association of American Physicians and Surgeons v. Virginia State Board of Elections, Tazewell County Circuit Court
Relevant passage: Complaint filed April 30, 2026, paragraphs 1 to 3 and the prayer for relief
About this source
The complaint, filed for two physician groups and a Tazewell County resident, says the ballot question never mentions a fundamental right to reproductive freedom and fails to tell voters about effects such as ending parental consent for minors. It also says the House clerk did not send the amendment to circuit court clerks for posting before the 2025 election, and it asks the court to bar certification.
- Author
- Joshua A. Hetzler and Michael B. Sylvester
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Tazewell County Judge Hurley to retire, but not before ruling on a challenge to a constitutional amendment recently approved by voters
Relevant passage: Article, November 13, 2026
About this source
Cardinal News reports that Judge Jack Hurley plans to retire December 31, is slated to hear the challenge November 24 and intends to rule before he retires, and that a law Spanberger signed in March retroactively removed the posting requirement.
- Author
- Elizabeth Beyer
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Virginia reproductive freedom amendment faces legal challenge over procedural violations, misleading ballot language
Relevant passage: Article, November 6, 2026
About this source
WSLS reports that the suit was filed April 30, that the center will ask for a preliminary injunction against certification, and Hetzler's account of the posting requirement and the ballot question.
- Author
- Jack Doherty
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Virginians approve reproductive freedom amendment. It will be challenged in court next week.
Relevant passage: Article, November 4, 2026
About this source
WTOP reports the vote count and interviews Josh Hetzler on the procedural and ballot-language claims, Gov. Abigail Spanberger on why she expects the amendments to be sustained, and House Majority Leader Charniele Herring.
- Author
- Scott Gelman
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Founding Freedoms Law Center release on the Tazewell court setting a post-election hearing
Relevant passage: News release, October 26, 2026
About this source
The center says the Tazewell Circuit Court denied the state's motions to prevent a hearing the week after the election, set arguments for November 13 before Judge Jack Hurley, and that it will seek a preliminary injunction against certification.
- Author
- Josh Hetzler
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Founding Freedoms Law Center release on its lawsuit over the ballot question
Relevant passage: News release, April 30, 2026
About this source
The center announces its suit in Tazewell County Circuit Court, links the complaint and lists effects of the amendment that it says the ballot question leaves out, including parental consent for minors and limits on who may perform an abortion.
- Author
- Victoria Cobb
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Family Foundation's legal arm asks a Tazewell judge to void Virginia's voter-approved reproductive freedom amendment; Spanberger says it will be sustained
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/founding-freedoms-lawsuit-virginia-reproductive-freedom-amendment
The Dispute Index. "Family Foundation's legal arm asks a Tazewell judge to void Virginia's voter-approved reproductive freedom amendment; Spanberger says it will be sustained". First published: 2026-11-16. Last updated: 2026-11-17. https://disputeindex.com/cases/founding-freedoms-lawsuit-virginia-reproductive-freedom-amendment