Did Israeli forces kill Israelis under the Hannibal Directive on October 7?
Haaretz reported that Israel's military used the Hannibal procedure on October 7, 2023, and a UN inquiry said Israeli fire likely killed at least 14 civilians in two incidents. The IDF defends its Be'eri tank fire. Mehdi Hasan says Western media ignored the question.
BackgroundWhat is the Hannibal Directive?

Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Overview
On October 7, 2023, Hamas-led attackers struck southern Israel. About 1,200 people were killed in Israel that day and about 250 were taken hostage into Gaza. In July 2024, Haaretz reported that documents and testimony show the Israeli military used the ExplainerHannibal DirectiveThe Hannibal Directive was an Israeli military order, drafted in the mid-1980s, that let troops use heavy force to stop a soldier from being captured, even if that force endangered the captive. Israel's military chief ordered it canceled in 2016.What is the Hannibal Directive?, which directs force to stop soldiers from being taken captive, at three army sites that day. The detailed findings of a UN commission of inquiry say Israeli fire likely killed at least 14 Israeli civilians in two incidents. The IDF has said a helicopter likely killed Efrat Katz of Kibbutz Nir Oz and that tank shrapnel highly likely killed one hostage outside a house in Kibbutz Be'eri, and it has defended the decisions of its commanders. Former defense minister Yoav Gallant said in February 2025 that he thinks an order to apply the procedure was given tactically in some places and not in others. The dispute is over whether, and how often, Israeli forces fired on Israeli captives that day, and how many Israelis that fire killed. The record also covers hostages later killed by Israeli fire in Gaza, including three who were shot in Shejaiya in December 2023 after escaping their captors.
Background: What is the Hannibal Directive?
Read the full background
Israeli forces fought Hamas-led attackers holding Israeli captives on October 7, 2023. Later military inquiries said a helicopter likely killed Efrat Katz near Kibbutz Nir Oz and tank shrapnel highly likely killed a hostage outside a house in Kibbutz Be'eri. The Nir Oz inquiry (opens in a new tab) and the Be'eri briefing (opens in a new tab) give the military's accounts of those deaths.
Haaretz and a UN commission of inquiry reported that Israeli forces used the Hannibal Directive, or orders to prevent capture at risk to captives, that day. The dispute concerns which orders were given, how forces acted on them and how many Israelis their fire killed. The commission and the military reached different conclusions about the Be'eri house; neither account provides a total for the day.
Orders to stop abductions
The Hannibal Directive permitted force to stop soldiers being taken captive, even if that force endangered them. The military canceled it in 2016 and said a new directive would replace it, the Times of Israel reported (opens in a new tab). The newspaper described the change, citing Haaretz, as a clarification rather than necessarily a full change in policy.
On July 7, 2024, Haaretz published Yaniv Kubovich's investigation (opens in a new tab), based on documents and testimony from soldiers and officers. It reports that divisional headquarters ordered "Hannibal at Erez" at 7:18 a.m. on October 7 after a kidnapping was reported at the crossing, and repeated the order at 7:41 a.m. According to information the newspaper says the army confirmed, the procedure was also used that morning at the Re'im army base and the Nahal Oz outpost.
Haaretz reports that at 11:22 a.m. the Gaza Division's network carried the order "Not a single vehicle can return to Gaza." It said it did not know whether or how many civilians and soldiers were hit because of these procedures. The IDF spokesman told the newspaper that internal investigations were underway and their results would be made public.
The inquiries and disputed counts
The UN commission's detailed findings (opens in a new tab), released on June 12, 2024, say it documented strong indications that the directive was used in several instances. Paragraphs 223-231 cite a tank commander's statement that his crew targeted two vehicles carrying militants and Israelis near Nir Oz. The commission concluded that in two cases at least 14 Israeli civilians were likely killed by Israeli fire: a woman taken from Nir Oz, killed by helicopter fire, and 13 hostages in Be'eri, killed by tank shelling and crossfire.
Its main report (opens in a new tab) uses "up to 14" in paragraph 36 and "at least 14" in paragraph 96. These are the commission's assessments of two incidents, not a count for all of October 7. It says Israeli officials refused to cooperate with its investigation and it could not confirm whether helicopters fired at targets in the Nova festival area.
The commission's detailed reconstruction (opens in a new tab) describes Brig. Gen. Barak Hiram authorizing tank fire at Pessi Cohen's home in Be'eri "even at the cost of civilian casualties." It says the tank fired two shells and recounts a survivor's statement that the shelling killed her husband.
Presenting the military's review on July 11, 2024, IDF spokesperson Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari said the army had failed to protect Be'eri. He defended the forces' decisions at the house as professional and responsible, saying tank fire followed exhausted negotiations. He said that, to the inquiry's best assessment, no civilians inside were hit by tank fire, most appeared to have been killed by the attackers, and one hostage outside was highly likely killed by tank shrapnel.
Relatives dispute the inquiry's findings or the decision to fire. Pessi Cohen's daughter-in-law, Sharon Cohen, told Israeli radio the finding was "not really true," ABC News in Australia reported (opens in a new tab). Omri Shifroni, whose relatives died at the house, told ABC that firing was "not moral," while saying he believed the forces did not intend to kill hostages. ABC reported in September 2024 that the IDF had not confirmed or denied whether a version of the directive was applied that day.
The April 2024 Air Force probe into Katz's death said a helicopter fired at a vehicle carrying attackers and hostages. The military said its surveillance systems could not distinguish them in moving vehicles. Air Force chief Tomer Bar found no fault with the crew, the Times of Israel reported.
In a January 10, 2025, statement (opens in a new tab), the IDF said it was highly likely its troops mistakenly killed Tomer Eliaz-Arava after he escaped his captors at Nahal Oz. It said there was a reasonable possibility that its fire killed Dikla Arava in a vehicle carrying abductees toward Gaza. The inquiry said neither cause of death could be determined with absolute certainty. It did not attribute either death to a Hannibal order.
Gallant's account and public responses
In a February 6, 2025, Channel 12 interview, Yoav Gallant, defense minister on October 7, said a defense minister's ability to give operational orders during events was limited. Asked whether an order to apply the directive was given, he said he thought it was given tactically in some places and not in others, "and that is a problem," in an excerpt with English subtitles added by The Electronic Intifada (opens in a new tab).
At a July 11, 2024, State Department briefing, a reporter asked whether the Haaretz findings changed the department's view and suggested Israel may have killed a majority of those who died. Matthew Miller rejected that suggestion, saying Hamas was responsible for the overwhelming number of deaths, the Algemeiner reported (opens in a new tab). In an October 2024 analysis (opens in a new tab), the Institute for Strategic Dialogue said the directive had been used to support false claims that Israeli forces killed as many civilians as Hamas or more.
On October 6, 2026, Mehdi Hasan published a Zeteo video (opens in a new tab) and article (opens in a new tab), saying the number killed by Israeli forces rather than Palestinian armed groups remained unknown. He accused mainstream Western outlets of ignoring the question and Gallant's remarks, and called for the Israeli military to answer for its actions. ABC published its investigation of the directive's use in September 2024.
We could not find an official count of Israelis killed by Israeli fire on October 7. The military inquiries reviewed here address particular incidents, and the UN figure covers two. Whether each death resulted from a capture-prevention order remains disputed.
People in this case
Yoav GallantDirectly involved
Timeline
33 timeline entries on this page. Dates: August 1, 2014 to October 7, 2026
August 2014
Israel reportedly invokes the Hannibal procedure in Rafah
The Associated Press reported that Israel's military used the Hannibal procedure in Rafah, Gaza, on August 1, 2014, after soldiers feared militants had captured Lt. Hadar Goldin, and that the heavy shelling that followed drew criticism. The AP said Hamas fire killed Goldin and two other soldiers.
June 2016
Israel's army says its chief of staff decided to cancel the Hannibal Protocol
The army's spokesperson said chief of staff Lt. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot had decided to cancel the Hannibal Protocol and that a new directive would replace it. The Times of Israel, citing Haaretz, described the move as not necessarily a full change in policy but a clarification of what the protocol entails.
October 2023
Haaretz: Gaza Division orders invoke the Hannibal procedure on October 7
Incident
According to Haaretz, at 7:18 a.m. on October 7, 2023, after a report of a kidnapping at the Erez crossing, divisional headquarters ordered "Hannibal at Erez" and the dispatch of an unmanned assault drone, and at 7:41 a.m. again ordered "Hannibal at Erez," with an assault on the crossing and the base. Haaretz reports that the procedure was also used that morning at the Re'im army base and the Nahal Oz outpost, and that at 11:22 a.m. the Gaza Division network carried the order "Not a single vehicle can return to Gaza."
A tank fires two shells at Pessi Cohen's house in Kibbutz Be'eri, where hostages were held
Incident
In the evening of October 7, 2023, after a standoff with attackers holding 14 hostages in Pessi Cohen's house, an Israeli tank fired two shells at the house on the orders of Brig. Gen. Barak Hiram, according to the New York Times and the UN Commission of Inquiry. Only two of the 14 hostages survived. Hadas Dagan told the Times that shrapnel from the second shell killed her husband, Adi Dagan.
November 2023
Hedges interviews Blumenthal about allegations of Israeli fire killing captives
Source release
The Chris Hedges Report publishes an interview about Israeli fire on October 7. Hedges introduces the allegation that forces targeted Hamas gunmen and Israeli captives together. The program appears before the later official investigations.
Palestinian Authority foreign ministry says Israeli helicopters killed Nova festivalgoers under the Hannibal Protocol
Claim
The Palestinian Authority's foreign ministry said Israeli helicopters killed people at the Supernova festival under the Hannibal Protocol. Netanyahu and opposition leader Yair Lapid condemned the statement, and it was later removed.
December 2023
Israeli soldiers shoot dead three escaped hostages in Shejaiya, one waving a white flag
Incident
During fighting in Shejaiya in Gaza City, IDF soldiers shot and killed hostages Yotam Haim, Samer Talalka and Alon Shamriz, who had escaped their captors; the IDF's investigation found they were shirtless and one was waving a white flag. IDF spokesperson Daniel Hagari said the IDF had mistakenly identified them as a threat and "bears responsibility for everything that happened."
The New York Times publishes Gen. Barak Hiram's account of the tank fire in Be'eri
Source release
A New York Times reconstruction of the Be'eri attack reported that Brig. Gen. Barak Hiram recalled telling the tank commander, "Break in, even at the cost of civilian casualties." On December 27 the Times reported that the account had stirred debate in Israel and that the military said it would review the battle.
January 2024
Be'eri families demand an immediate probe of the tank fire at Pessi Cohen's house
Reaction
The Associated Press reported that bereaved families of Kibbutz Be'eri wrote to the military that, "According to the evidence, the shooting of the tank was fatal and killed many hostages," and demanded a comprehensive and transparent investigation.
Yedioth Ahronoth reports a midday order to stop abductions to Gaza even at risk to hostages
Source release
A Yedioth Ahronoth investigation by Ronen Bergman and Yoav Zitun reported that at midday on October 7 the IDF in practice ordered all fighting units to apply the Hannibal procedure, without naming it, even at risk to the hostages, and that about 70 vehicles were hit on the way to Gaza by a helicopter, drone or tank.
February 2024
IDF says hostage Yossi Sharabi was likely killed by an IDF strike
Source release
The IDF told the family of Yossi Sharabi of Kibbutz Be'eri that he was likely killed inadvertently by an IDF strike in Gaza, after the military had earlier called Hamas's claim that it struck the building where he was held a lie, the Times of Israel reported.
March 2024
Al Jazeera publishes documentary findings on Israeli fire and October 7 deaths
Source release
Al Jazeera publishes a summary of its documentary, which documents abuses by Hamas and others and presents the filmmakers' account of Israeli fire. Its summary identifies 19 people it attributes to Israeli fire and 27 captives whose deaths it says remain unexplained. These figures are the investigation's findings, rather than a comprehensive agreed total.
April 2024
IDF probe finds Efrat Katz was likely killed by Israeli helicopter fire
Incident
The Israeli military said an Air Force probe found that Efrat Katz, 68, of Kibbutz Nir Oz, was likely killed on October 7 when a helicopter fired on a vehicle carrying attackers and Israeli hostages. It said its surveillance systems could not tell hostages from attackers in moving vehicles, and Air Force chief Maj. Gen. Tomer Bar said he did not find fault with the crew.
June 2024
UN Commission of Inquiry reports strong indications that Israeli forces used the Hannibal Directive
Source release
The UN Commission of Inquiry released its findings on the October 7 attacks and Israel's response. Its detailed paper says it documented strong indications that the Hannibal Directive was used in several instances and that in two cases at least 14 Israeli civilians were likely killed by Israeli fire, in Kibbutz Nir Oz and Kibbutz Be'eri. The commission's main report describes the same two cases as "resulting in the killing of up to 14 Israeli civilians." The commission says Israeli officials refused to cooperate with its investigation.
July 2024
Haaretz reports the IDF ordered the Hannibal procedure on October 7
Source release
Haaretz published an investigation by Yaniv Kubovich, based on documents and testimony, reporting that the Hannibal procedure was used at three army sites on October 7, 2023. Haaretz wrote that it does not know whether or how many civilians and soldiers were hit as a result. The IDF told Haaretz it was conducting internal investigations and would present the results to the public.
IDF presents its Be'eri inquiry and defends the tank fire at Pessi Cohen's house
Source release
The Israeli military presented its inquiry into the battle for Kibbutz Be'eri. It said the IDF failed to protect the kibbutz, that the forces at Pessi Cohen's house made professional and responsible decisions, that to the best of its assessment no civilians inside were hit by tank fire, and that one hostage outside was highly likely killed by tank shrapnel.
Human Rights Watch report says Israeli forces killed some civilians while responding to the attack
Source release
Human Rights Watch published its report on the October 7 attack, which says Israeli media reports indicate Israeli forces killed or injured some civilians while attacking Palestinian fighters and that Israeli authorities had not reported how many.
September 2024
ABC News in Australia publishes an investigation into the Hannibal Directive on October 7
Source release
ABC News in Australia published an investigation into accusations that Israeli forces killed their own citizens under the Hannibal Directive on October 7. It quotes Be'eri relatives, a former Air Force colonel, and an IDF statement that such questions would be looked into at a later stage.
UN Commission of Inquiry confirms three hostages were shot by Israeli forces and others died in Israeli operations
Source release
The UN Commission of Inquiry told the General Assembly that at least 70 hostages were no longer alive, that it had confirmed three were shot by Israeli forces while trying to hand themselves over, and that at least five others died during Israeli operations with the cause of death unclear.
IDF says hostages Nik Beizer, Ron Sherman and Elia Toledano were likely killed by an IDF airstrike
Source release
The IDF said its investigation found a high probability that Nik Beizer, Ron Sherman and Elia Toledano were killed as a byproduct of a November 10, 2023 airstrike that killed Hamas northern brigade commander Ahmed Ghandour, and that it had no information that hostages were in the compound.
January 2025
IDF inquiry finds a reasonable possibility that captive Dikla Arava was killed by IDF fire
Source release
An IDF inquiry into two deaths at Kibbutz Nahal Oz found it highly likely that Tomer Eliaz-Arava was killed by IDF fire through misidentification, and a reasonable possibility that his mother, Dikla Arava, was killed by IDF fire in a vehicle the forces identified as carrying fleeing attackers. The IDF said neither cause can be determined with absolute certainty.
February 2025
Yoav Gallant says he thinks a Hannibal order was given tactically in some places
Claim
In his first Israeli television interview since his dismissal, former defense minister Yoav Gallant told Channel 12 that a defense minister's ability to give operational orders while events unfold is very limited. Asked whether an order to apply the Hannibal procedure was given, he said he thinks it was given tactically in various places and not in others, and that this is a problem.
IDF Kfar Aza inquiry finds troops killed at least three civilians, one of them an abductee
Source release
Ynet reported that the IDF's inquiry into the battle for Kfar Aza found troops killed at least three civilians, including one abducted in his own vehicle whom soldiers mistook for an attacker. The families asked that the names be withheld.
IDF Air Force inquiry describes some 945 helicopter attacks on October 7
Source release
The Jerusalem Post reported that the Israeli Air Force's inquiry into October 7 found it carried out about 945 attacks with helicopters firing 11,000 times, and that many pilots were reluctant to hit potential hostages even after the Hannibal Directive was issued.
IDF General Staff inquiries into October 7 are released
Source release
The IDF released its General Staff inquiries into October 7. The Times of Israel reported that in a handful of cases officers on the ground implemented the Hannibal Protocol, and that hostage Efrat Katz was killed when an IAF helicopter fired at a vehicle carrying attackers and hostages.
March 2025
Lee Camp publishes satirical commentary on alleged Hannibal orders
Source release
In a Moment of Clarity video, Camp criticizes what he describes as a policy of firing on captives. He discusses Gallant's interview and press reports. His broader casualty claims are attributed assertions, rather than a verified total.
May 2025
IDF Kissufim inquiry finds Tom Godo was killed by IDF fire
Source release
The IDF's inquiry into the battle for Kibbutz Kissufim found that soldiers who believed attackers were in the Godo family's safe room on the morning of October 8, 2023 fired at its door and killed Tom Godo, and that in some cases forces acted wrongly, leading to two-sided fire and imprecise use of force.
December 2025
Amnesty International says some Israeli civilians were killed under the Hannibal Directive
Source release
Amnesty International published its report on crimes by Palestinian armed groups on October 7, which says some Israeli civilians were killed by Israeli forces through mistaken identification or the Hannibal Directive, and that Palestinian fighters killed the vast majority.
June 2026
Johnstone calls for scrutiny of unresolved October 7 casualty questions
Source release
In a signed column, Johnstone argues that public discussion should examine Israeli fire and accounts of Hannibal orders. She says the number killed by Israeli forces is unknown and criticizes resistance to questioning the accepted narrative. Her other allegations are not established by the column.
August 2026
Sheen accuses journalists and officials of concealing Hannibal actions
Source release
In an X post and thread, Sheen alleges that journalists and officials repeated false accounts to conceal Israeli actions on October 7. The post states his accusation; it is not an independent finding that a coordinated cover-up occurred.
October 2026
Yaakov Godo, whose son was killed by Israeli fire, heckles Netanyahu at the October 7 memorial
Reaction
At the state ceremony on Mount Herzl marking three years since the attack, Yaakov Godo interrupted Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's speech, saying Netanyahu had not protected his son. Tom Godo was killed in his family's safe room in Kibbutz Kissufim. According to Kan, as reported by the Jerusalem Post, the IDF told the family in 2025 that soldiers who took control of the house on October 8, 2023 fired on the safe room door, mistaking the family for attackers, and killed him.
Mehdi Hasan's Zeteo video asks how many Israelis Israeli forces killed on October 7
Reaction
Zeteo published a video monologue and article by Mehdi Hasan on the Hannibal Directive. Hasan says the number of people killed on October 7 by Israel rather than by Palestinian armed groups is unknown, says mainstream Western outlets have ignored the question and Gallant's remarks, and backs calls by Israeli families for an independent investigation.
Democracy Now interviews Bishara on the Hannibal allegations
Source release
Marwan Bishara discusses the Hannibal doctrine in an interview about his book on the first twelve days after October 7. He argues that Israeli forces invoked the doctrine during the attack and gives his own casualty estimate. The interview records his assessment, rather than establishing an agreed total.
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by HaaretzHaaretz
Haaretz reported that documents and testimony show the Israeli military used the Hannibal procedure on October 7, 2023 at the Erez crossing, the Re'im army base and the Nahal Oz outpost, and that at 11:22 a.m. the Gaza Division's network carried the order "Not a single vehicle can return to Gaza."
Sources (1)
- Haaretz, July 7, 2024: IDF ordered Hannibal directive on October 7 to prevent Hamas taking soldiers captive · HaaretzParagraphs on the 11:22 a.m. order, the Erez crossing orders at 7:18 and 7:41 a.m., the Re'im base and Nahal Oz outpost, and the IDF spokesman's response
Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel
The UN Commission of Inquiry said it documented strong indications that Israeli forces used the Hannibal Directive in several instances on October 7, 2023, and that in two cases at least 14 Israeli civilians were likely killed by Israeli fire: one woman taken from Kibbutz Nir Oz, killed by helicopter fire, and 13 hostages in Kibbutz Be'eri, killed by tank shelling and crossfire.
Sources (1)
- UN Commission of Inquiry, A/HRC/56/CRP.3: detailed findings on the attacks of October 7, 2023 in Israel · Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and IsraelSection on the Israeli Security Forces counter-offensive and the application of the Hannibal Directive, paragraphs 223 to 231, pages 44 to 46
Israel Defense Forces
The IDF said its inquiry found that, to the best of its assessment, no civilians inside Pessi Cohen's house in Kibbutz Be'eri were hit by tank fire, that most of the hostages inside were apparently killed by the attackers, and that one hostage outside the house was highly likely killed by tank shrapnel.
Sources (1)
- IDF press briefing by spokesperson Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari on the Kibbutz Be'eri inquiry, July 11, 2024 · Israel Defense ForcesParagraphs on the hostage event at the home of Pessi Cohen and on the conduct of the senior commanders
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Yoav GallantYoav Gallant, Israel's defense minister on October 7, 2023, said on Channel 12 that he thinks the order to apply the Hannibal Directive was given tactically in various places and was not given in others, and that this is a problem.
Sources (2)
- Defense minister confirms army orders to kill Israelis on 7 October (The Electronic Intifada, YouTube excerpt of Yoav Gallant's Channel 12 interview) · The Electronic IntifadaFull clip, 0:00 to 0:39
- The Electronic Intifada, February 7, 2025: Army was ordered to kill Israelis on 7 October, defense minister confirms · The Electronic IntifadaOpening paragraphs
Disputed claim
Copy link to this disputed claim by Mehdi HasanMehdi Hasan said mainstream Western media outlets have ignored the question of how many people Israel killed on October 7, and that the New York Times, the Washington Post, CNN, the BBC and most other mainstream Western outlets ignored Yoav Gallant's February 2025 remarks.
Sources (2)
- The Hannibal Directive: Mehdi Hasan Asks 'Why the October 7 Media Cover-Up?' (Zeteo, YouTube) · ZeteoFull video, 0:00 to 3:27
- Zeteo, October 6, 2026: What Is the Hannibal Directive and How Many Israelis Did It Kill on October 7? · ZeteoArticle text accompanying the video
In their own words
Their own account
Statements from the person or group whose act or claim this case is about. They are listed apart from the responses, and each label says what the speaker did with their own act or claim.
Israel Defense ForcesIsrael Defense Forces Spokesperson's Unit, Foreign Media Desk, in an email to Dispute Index"The IDF has published investigations concerning its conduct on October 7th, and beyond that, we will not comment."
Explicitly stayed outCase context: Did Israeli forces kill Israelis under the Hannibal Directive on October 7?
Full statement and sources
The IDF Spokesperson's Unit told Dispute Index that it has published investigations concerning its conduct on October 7 and would not comment beyond them. Dispute Index had asked about the Hannibal procedure, the number of Israelis killed by Israeli fire, and commentators who say Israel killed large numbers of its own citizens.
Before the statement
Dispute Index asked the IDF Spokesperson's Unit whether the IDF acknowledges that the Hannibal procedure was applied in some places on October 7 and where, whether it has established or will publish how many Israelis were killed by Israeli fire that day, and how it responds to commentators who say Israel killed large numbers of its own citizens. The unit's Foreign Media Desk replied by email.
After the statement
This case records the IDF's published inquiry findings separately, alongside its other statements.
Emailed statement from the IDF Spokesperson's Unit to Dispute Index on the Hannibal Directive and October 7 · Israel Defense ForcesEmailed reply from the IDF Spokesperson's Unit, October 7, 2026 (UTC).Why this label?
The IDF says it has published investigations concerning its conduct on October 7 and that "beyond that, we will not comment." It points to those findings and declines to answer further, so we labeled it Explicitly stayed out.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Israel Defense ForcesIsraeli military, through spokesperson Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari"The inquiry team determined that under the complex and harsh circumstances, the Yamam, ISA, and IDF personnel operated professionally and orderly, making professional and responsible decisions. They exhausted all negotiation efforts with the terrorists. Only after the situation deteriorated and negotiation attempts were exhausted – attempts to negotiate the rescue of the civilians – did the forces carry out tank fire, in a joint decision to try to apply pressure to the terrorists. The decision to attempt a rescue under fire was made after all negotiation attempts to rescue the hostages had been exhausted, and after a long burst of gunfire from inside the house that raised suspicions that the hostages were being executed. We conducted a thorough and joint inquiry with the Israel Police, Yamam, and the ISA, after which we presented our assessment of the circumstances of the hostages' deaths to the families. The team determined that from the information examined so far and to the best of our assessment, no civilians inside the building were hit by tank fire. The team noted that it appears that most of the hostages inside the house were murdered by the terrorists. Additionally, one incident involved hostages outside the building being hit by tank shrapnel, and it is highly likely that one of them was killed as a result."
Stood by itResponding to: The IDF said its inquiry found that, to the best of its assessment, no civilians inside Pessi Cohen's house in Kibbutz Be'eri were hit by tank fire, that most of the hostages inside were apparently killed by the attackers, and that one hostage outside the house was highly likely killed by tank shrapnel.
Full statement and sources
Presenting the military's inquiry into the battle for Kibbutz Be'eri, IDF spokesperson Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari said the police, Shin Bet and army personnel at Pessi Cohen's house "operated professionally and orderly" and fired tank shells only after negotiations were exhausted and gunfire from inside raised fears that hostages were being executed. He said the inquiry found that, to the best of its assessment, no civilians inside the house were hit by tank fire, and that it is highly likely one hostage outside was killed by tank shrapnel.
Before the statement
The briefing presented the first of the military's October 7 inquiries, into the battle for Kibbutz Be'eri, where 101 members of the kibbutz were killed. Hagari said the IDF "failed in its mission to protect the residents of Kibbutz Be'eri" and that residents fought almost alone for the first seven hours. A UN commission of inquiry had concluded a month earlier that 13 hostages in Be'eri were likely killed by tank shelling and crossfire.
After the statement
Hagari said the families asked tough questions and raised other incidents that the military would examine with them, and that the senior commanders at the scene acted in a coordinated and professional manner and "did everything" to save civilians.
IDF press briefing by spokesperson Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari on the Kibbutz Be'eri inquiry, July 11, 2024 · Israel Defense ForcesParagraphs on the hostage event at the home of Pessi Cohen and on the conduct of the senior commandersUN Commission of Inquiry, A/HRC/56/CRP.3: detailed findings on the attacks of October 7, 2023 in Israel · Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and IsraelSection on the Israeli Security Forces counter-offensive and the application of the Hannibal Directive, paragraphs 223 to 231, pages 44 to 46Why this label?
The Israel Defense Forces, presenting its Be'eri inquiry, says the forces at the house acted professionally and fired tank shells only after negotiations failed. It says tank fire did not hit the civilians inside, while finding that one hostage outside was likely killed by shrapnel, so we labeled it Stood by it.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
2 matching responses. Newest first.
Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and IsraelUN Human Rights Council commission of inquiryDirectly involved "The Commission considers that such incidents clearly indicate the permissive practice of shooting to kill without first ascertaining who the targets are and whether they pose a threat."
CondemnedCase context: Did Israeli forces kill Israelis under the Hannibal Directive on October 7?
Full statement and sources
The UN Commission of Inquiry said the Israeli shooting of three hostages in Gaza, one holding a white flag, and similar incidents indicate a permissive practice of shooting to kill without identifying targets.
Before the statement
Paragraph 46 of the Commission's June 2024 report to the Human Rights Council describes Israeli forces shooting three Israeli hostages, one holding a white flag. The report dates the incident to November 15; it took place on December 15, 2023, the date given in the Commission's detailed paper A/HRC/56/CRP.4.
After the statement
In CRP.4 (para. 217) the Commission adds that Israeli forces "may have carried out a unique comprehensive investigation in this case but, if so, only because those who were shot were Israeli hostages."
UN Commission of Inquiry, A/HRC/56/26: report to the Human Rights Council, 56th session · Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and IsraelParagraph 36 (Israeli security forces and the Hannibal Directive) and paragraph 96UN Commission of Inquiry, A/HRC/56/CRP.4: detailed findings on the military operations and attacks carried out in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (June 10, 2024) · Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and IsraelParas. 215-217, p. 50Why this label?
The Commission of Inquiry says incidents such as the shooting of three hostages in Gaza, one holding a white flag, "clearly indicate the permissive practice of shooting to kill" without first ascertaining who the targets are. It treats the killing of the hostages as evidence of that practice, which is a finding against the conduct.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
HaaretzNewspaper (editorial)Directly involved"There is no demand more justified than that of relatives of people killed in the hostage incident at Kibbutz Be'eri to investigate the army's actions and to receive answers about the circumstances of their loved ones' deaths."
Mixed or conditionalCase context: Did Israeli forces kill Israelis under the Hannibal Directive on October 7?
Full statement and sources
A Haaretz editorial backed the demand of Be'eri families for an immediate investigation of the army's actions in the hostage standoff at Pessi Cohen's house.
Before the statement
The editorial followed a letter from relatives of those killed in the house asking the military to investigate the decision to fire tank shells at it.
After the statement
The editorial's headline reads: "The IDF Must Investigate the Kibbutz Be'eri Tank Fire Incident – Right Now." The rest of the text is behind a paywall.
Why this label?
The Haaretz editorial says there is "no demand more justified" than that of relatives of people killed at Be'eri to investigate the army's actions. It calls for an immediate investigation of the tank fire without concluding what killed the hostages, so its judgment depends on what that investigation finds.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(95)
Reporting
Haaretz, July 7, 2024: IDF ordered Hannibal directive on October 7 to prevent Hamas taking soldiers captive
Relevant passage: Paragraphs on the 11:22 a.m. order, the Erez crossing orders at 7:18 and 7:41 a.m., the Re'im base and Nahal Oz outpost, and the IDF spokesman's response
Excerpt
""Not a single vehicle can return to Gaza" was the order."
About this source
An investigation by Haaretz military correspondent Yaniv Kubovich, based on documents and on testimony from soldiers and from mid-level and senior officers. It reports that the Gaza Division's network carried the order "Not a single vehicle can return to Gaza" at 11:22 a.m. on October 7, 2023, that the command "Hannibal at Erez" was given at 7:18 a.m. and again at 7:41 a.m., and that, according to information confirmed by the army, the procedure was also used at the Re'im army base and the Nahal Oz outpost. Haaretz writes that it does not know whether or how many civilians and soldiers were hit as a result. The article sits behind a paywall; we read the full text in Portside's republication of July 11, 2024 (https://portside.org/2024-07-11/idf-ordered-hannibal-directive-october-7-prevent-hamas-taking-soldiers-captive).
- Author
- Yaniv Kubovich
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
October 7: Al Jazeera Investigations
About this source
Al Jazeera's original film presents its reconstruction of the attack, including allegations of Israeli fire killing captives. It also documents abuses by Hamas and others.
- Author
- Al Jazeera English
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
October 7: Forensic analysis shows Hamas abuses, many false Israeli ...
Relevant passage: Section: Cannot tell whether they are gunmen or hostages
About this source
The filmmakers summarize their investigation of Israeli fire and distinguish identified victims from deaths they could not explain. Their account is an investigative conclusion, rather than a judicial finding.
- Author
- Richard Sanders and Al Jazeera Investigative Unit
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
David Sheen on coverage of alleged Hannibal actions
About this source
Sheen alleges that journalists and officials repeated false accounts to conceal Israeli actions on October 7. This is his accusation.
- Author
- David Sheen
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
We're Expected To Remember October 7 But Never Ask Questions About It
Relevant passage: Discussion of Israeli fire and unresolved deaths
About this source
Johnstone argues that public discussion should examine Israeli fire and unresolved casualty questions. Her article includes allegations and inferences rather than an agreed casualty finding.
- Author
- Caitlin Johnstone
- Published
- Accessed
Interview
The Chris Hedges Report with reporter Max Blumenthal
Relevant passage: Episode introduction
About this source
Hedges introduces an interview about allegations that Israeli fire targeted gunmen and captives together. The episode predates subsequent official inquiries.
- Author
- Chris Hedges
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
SHOCK: Here's How Many Israel Killed On Oct 7th!
About this source
Camp uses sarcasm to criticize the alleged policy. The published captions contain transcription errors, and his casualty claims are not verified totals.
- Author
- Lee Camp
- Published
- Accessed
Interview
"Origins of a Genocide": Al Jazeera's Marwan Bishara on "Twelve Days ..."
Relevant passage: Interview transcript: question about the Hannibal doctrine
About this source
Democracy Now publishes the interview and transcript. Bishara's casualty estimate is his assessment, rather than an established total.
- Author
- Democracy Now
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
Israel's still killing Israeli hostages with the Hannibal directive
Relevant passage: Paragraph beginning It was exactly the same reckless approach
About this source
Cook presents a critical interpretation of Israeli fire and the risk to captives. His claims about intent are attributed assessments.
- Author
- Jonathan Cook
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Statement from PolitiFact editor-in-chief Katie Sanders to Dispute Index on the Nova video fact check
Relevant passage: Emailed reply from Katie Sanders, October 8, 2026 (UTC).
Excerpt
"We have not gone back and looked at related claims, and the rating stands."
About this source
Reply from Katie Sanders, editor-in-chief of PolitiFact, to a Dispute Index request for comment on PolitiFact's November 2023 fact check of a video Stew Peters posted. The link goes to her PolitiFact staff page because the reply is not posted there.
- Author
- Katie Sanders
- Published
- Accessed
Emailed statement
Emailed statement from the IDF Spokesperson's Unit to Dispute Index on the Hannibal Directive and October 7
Emailed statement from the IDF Spokesperson's Unit to Dispute Index on the Hannibal Directive and October 7
The IDF has published investigations concerning its conduct on October 7th, and beyond that, we will not comment.
Full email
The IDF has published investigations concerning its conduct on October 7th, and beyond that, we will not comment.
Relevant passage: Emailed reply from the IDF Spokesperson's Unit, October 7, 2026 (UTC).
Excerpt
"The IDF has published investigations concerning its conduct on October 7th, and beyond that, we will not comment."
About this source
Email from the Israel Defense Forces Spokesperson's Unit (Foreign Media Desk) to Dispute Index in reply to a request for comment on the Hannibal Directive and October 7. The link goes to the IDF's English website because the reply is not posted there.
- Author
- IDF Spokesperson's Unit, Foreign Media Desk
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Double Down News on X, October 7, 2026: "Former UN Chief Absolutely Demolishes October 7 Lies"
Excerpt
"Former UN Chief Absolutely Demolishes October 7 Lies"
About this source
Double Down News reposted its September 2025 interview with Chris Gunness on X on October 7, 2026, the third anniversary of the attack, under the caption "Former UN Chief Absolutely Demolishes October 7 Lies."
- Author
- Double Down News
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
Double Down News: "Former UN Chief DEMOLISHES October 7 Lies" (interview with Chris Gunness)
Excerpt
"There were at least three areas where the Hannibal directive was invoked."
About this source
Double Down News video interview with Chris Gunness, former chief spokesperson for UNRWA, posted to YouTube on September 1, 2025. In the opening section he discusses October 7 and the Hannibal Directive. YouTube offers no captions for this video; quotations are from our transcription of the audio.
- Author
- Chris Gunness
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
Breaking Points: LEAKED Oct 7 Tapes ORDERING HANNIBAL DIRECTIVE (July 1, 2026)
About this source
Breaking Points segment in which Ryan Grim and Emily Jashinsky discuss footage from an Israeli command room on October 7. Quotations were transcribed from the video, with repeated words removed.
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
The Tucker Carlson Show: Max Blumenthal: I Went to Iran and Was Detained by the Trump Admin (September 21, 2026)
About this source
Tucker Carlson's interview with Max Blumenthal on his YouTube show; the exchange about the Hannibal Directive begins about 29 minutes in.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Jerusalem Post: IDF Air Force probe into October 7 (February 27, 2025)
About this source
Jerusalem Post report on the Israeli Air Force's inquiry into its response on October 7.
- Author
- Yonah Jeremy Bob
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
Haaretz HaShavua podcast, episode 321, with Nof Erez (November 9, 2023)
Relevant passage: About 17:29 to 17:52 (Nof Erez segment runs 01:17 to 24:31)
About this source
Hebrew Haaretz podcast hosted by Lior Kodner; Nof Erez discusses the Air Force's response on October 7.
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
Piers Morgan Uncensored: 'You Want The World To Think It Was ISRAEL?' Piers Morgan vs Bassem Youssef (September 16, 2025)
About this source
Piers Morgan Uncensored debate with Bassem Youssef.
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
Piers Morgan Uncensored: 'Israel Has More Enemies Than EVER Before' Lowkey vs Piers Morgan (October 1, 2024)
About this source
Piers Morgan Uncensored debate with Lowkey and Brigitte Gabriel.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Hasan Piker's post on the Shejaiya hostages (December 16, 2023)
About this source
Hasan Piker's post on his X account, quoting a post by Bethany Mandel.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Hen Mazzig's post on a Northwestern professor's remark (November 30, 2025)
About this source
Hen Mazzig's post on his X account.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Shayan Sardarizadeh's post on the helicopter claim (August 7, 2025)
About this source
Shayan Sardarizadeh's post on his X account, quoting his earlier posts about a viral helicopter video.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Lowkey's post to Piers Morgan on Yoav Gallant's remarks (February 7, 2025)
About this source
Lowkey's post on his X account, quoting an Al Jazeera Arabic post about Yoav Gallant's Channel 12 interview.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Glenn Greenwald's post responding to Mike Huckabee (May 3, 2026)
About this source
Glenn Greenwald's post on his X account, part of a thread responding to Mike Huckabee.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Jackson Hinkle's post on October 7 (July 24, 2024)
About this source
Jackson Hinkle's post on his X account.
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
Candace, Episode 23: SMACKDOWN! My Heated Debate With Don Lemon (July 11, 2024)
About this source
Episode of Candace Owens's YouTube show; the opening and a later monologue segment discuss the Hannibal Directive.
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
NBC News: NSC Spokesman: Israeli hostages mistakenly killed by IDF 'tragic, heartbreaking event' (December 15, 2023)
National Security Council spokesman John Kirby on the Israeli hostages mistakenly killed by the IDF, NBC News, Dec. 15, 2023.
Excerpt from 0:35 to 1:10 of the NBC News video. DI added its logo in the corner.
Video: NBC News. Excerpt used for news reporting and commentary
Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: 00:38 to 01:07)
About this source
NBC News interview of John Kirby by Kristen Welker on the day the IDF said its soldiers shot three hostages in Shejaiya.
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Hamas Media Office: Our Narrative, Al-Aqsa Flood: Two Years of Steadfastness and the Will for Liberation (December 25, 2025)
Relevant passage: English PDF, pp. 14-15
About this source
Hamas's second "Our Narrative" document, read from the English PDF mirrored on archive.org because Hamas's own sites are offline.
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
NRK: Yama utfordrer Hamas (interview with Osama Hamdan, February 9, 2026)
Relevant passage: 05:34 to 05:59 (interview in English)
About this source
NRK program in which reporter Yama Wolasmal interviews Hamas official Osama Hamdan in Istanbul.
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
Al-Manar video: كلمة السيد حسن - تأبين شهداء على طريق القدس (November 3, 2023)
Relevant passage: 28:50 to 29:52
About this source
Al-Manar's video of Nasrallah's November 3, 2023 speech.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Al-Manar: نص كلمة السيد نصرالله خلال الاحتفال التكريمي للشهداء الذين ارتقوا على طريق القدس (text of Nasrallah's speech, November 3, 2023)
Relevant passage: Section on how the enemy acted after October 7
About this source
Arabic text of Hassan Nasrallah's November 3, 2023 speech, his first after October 7, as published by Al-Manar.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
JDN: IDF responds to New York Times report on Barak Hiram; Yasmin Porat on Kan (December 24, 2023)
About this source
Hebrew JDN report quoting the IDF Spokesperson's response to the New York Times account of the Be'eri standoff, and Yasmin Porat's remarks to Kan News.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Kenneth Roth's post on the Hannibal Directive (July 7, 2024)
About this source
Kenneth Roth's post on his X account, quoting Haaretz's July 7, 2024 report.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
The Jerusalem Post editorial: Palestinian conspiracy theories (November 22, 2023)
About this source
Editorial by The Jerusalem Post on the Palestinian Authority's claim about the Nova festival killings.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
FactCheck.org: Social Media Posts Misrepresent Video of IDF Aircraft Attack (November 28, 2023)
About this source
FactCheck.org article on posts claiming an IDF video proves many people at the Nova festival were killed by Israeli fire.
- Author
- Sean Christensen and Alan Jaffe
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
PolitiFact: No, this video doesn't show Israeli military killing people at Oct. 7 concert in Israel (November 17, 2023)
About this source
PolitiFact fact check, rated False, of a November 9, 2023 post by Stew Peters claiming Israel admitted it killed its own people at the Nova festival.
- Author
- Madison Czopek
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
JNS: Countering the Oct. 7 deniers (March 21, 2025)
About this source
Ben Cohen's JNS column on the Roberts Report and claims he describes as October 7 denial.
- Author
- Ben Cohen
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
Fathom: 7 October and the Alt-Media: a critical examination (July 19, 2024)
Relevant passage: Section "The Alt-Media, the 'Hannibal Directive' and 7 October"
About this source
Long-form essay by John Ware examining how alternative media outlets, including The Electronic Intifada and The Grayzone, covered October 7.
- Author
- John Ware
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
UN Watch: Legal Analysis of Pillay Commission's 2024 Report to the Human Rights Council (June 13, 2024)
Relevant passage: Section 9, "Conclusions Based on Misinformation", first paragraph
About this source
UN Watch's legal analysis of the UN Commission of Inquiry's June 2024 report.
- Author
- Dina Rovner
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Ynet News: Palestinian Foreign Ministry claims Israel killed Nova festivalgoers (November 19, 2023)
About this source
Ynet News report on the Palestinian Authority foreign ministry's claim about the Nova festival and the Hannibal Protocol, with responses from Netanyahu and Yair Lapid.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Ynet News: IDF spokesperson on Hamas hostage video (January 15, 2024)
About this source
Ynet News report quoting IDF spokesperson Daniel Hagari's response to a Hamas video about hostages Itay Svirsky, Noa Argamani and Yossi Sharabi.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Ynet: tank commander Bar Zonschein on Reshet 13's HaMakor (March 20, 2024)
About this source
Hebrew Ynet report, with an embedded clip from Reshet 13's investigative program HaMakor, in which tank company commander Bar Zonschein describes firing on vehicles near Kissufim on October 7.
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
IDF: Summary of the Investigation Into the Circumstances of the Deaths of the Hostages Corporal Nik Beizer, Sergeant Ron Sherman, and Elia Toledano (September 15, 2024)
About this source
IDF press release on its investigation into the deaths of three hostages whose bodies were recovered in northern Gaza.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Times of Israel: IDF: Hostage Yossi Sharabi was likely killed as a result of IDF strike (February 9, 2024)
About this source
Times of Israel report on the IDF's investigation into the death of hostage Yossi Sharabi of Kibbutz Be'eri.
- Author
- Emanuel Fabian
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
UN Commission of Inquiry, A/79/232: report to the General Assembly (September 11, 2024)
Relevant passage: Paras. 85-87, pp. 17-18
About this source
Commission of Inquiry report to the General Assembly's 79th session; paragraphs 85-87 cover hostages who died in captivity.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese, A/79/384: Genocide as colonial erasure (October 1, 2024)
Relevant passage: Para. 74, p. 26
About this source
Report of the Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967 to the UN General Assembly's 79th session.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
UN Commission of Inquiry, A/HRC/56/CRP.4: detailed findings on the military operations and attacks carried out in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (June 10, 2024)
Relevant passage: Paras. 215-217, p. 50
About this source
Conference room paper of the UN Commission of Inquiry on Gaza; paragraphs 215-217 cover the December 15, 2023 shooting of three hostages in Shuja'iyya.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
+972 Magazine: A hostage’s mother says toxic gas from Israeli bombs killed her son. Is she right? (January 31, 2024)
About this source
+972 Magazine and Local Call report quoting Maayan Sherman and the IDF Spokesperson's response.
- Author
- Yuval Abraham
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Maayan Sherman's Facebook post on the findings about her son Ron Sherman (January 16, 2024)
Relevant passage: Original post
About this source
Maayan Sherman's public Facebook post, in Hebrew, after the IDF told the family the results of an examination of Ron Sherman's body.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
JNS: 'What happened is not your fault' (December 21, 2023)
About this source
JNS report quoting Iris Haim's audio message to the soldiers who shot her son, distributed on social media.
- Author
- Sveta Listratov
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
IDF: Press Briefing by IDF Spokesperson Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari, December 15, 2023, 20:15
About this source
Transcript of the IDF spokesperson's briefing announcing that soldiers had mistakenly shot three hostages in Shejaiya.
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
IDF: The Findings of the Investigation into the Circumstances of the Deaths of 3 Hostages from IDF Fire (December 28, 2023)
About this source
IDF press release on its investigation into the December 15, 2023 shooting of three hostages in Shejaiya, with Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi's conclusions.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Times of Israel: 767 troops faced 5,000 terrorists; Gaza Division was overrun for hours: IDF Oct. 7 probe (February 27, 2025)
About this source
Times of Israel report on the IDF General Staff's October 7 inquiries released on February 27, 2025.
- Author
- Emanuel Fabian
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Ynet News: Kfar Aza probe findings (February 16, 2025)
About this source
Ynet report on the IDF's inquiry into the battle for Kibbutz Kfar Aza ahead of its presentation to residents.
- Author
- Matan Tzuri
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
IDF: Summary of findings from the inquiry into the deaths of Tomer Eliaz-Arava and Dikla Arava on October 7th at Kibbutz Nahal Oz (January 10, 2025)
About this source
IDF press release summarizing an inquiry led by Col. (res.) Yaron Sitbon into two deaths at Kibbutz Nahal Oz on October 7, 2023.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Associated Press: Friendly fire may have killed their relatives on Oct. 7. These Israeli families want answers now (January 11, 2024)
About this source
Associated Press report, read from its syndicated copy on KVIA, on Be'eri families' letter to the military about the tank fire at Pessi Cohen's house.
- Author
- Julia Frankel and Alon Bernstein
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Yedioth Ahronoth, 7 Days: השעות הראשונות של השבת השחורה (The first hours of Black Saturday) (January 12, 2024)
Relevant passage: Section beginning "אבל בינתיים מגיעים כבר סרטוני החטופים הראשונים"
About this source
Hebrew-language investigation by Ronen Bergman and Yoav Zitun in Yedioth Ahronoth's weekend supplement reconstructing the IDF's first hours on October 7.
- Author
- Ronen Bergman and Yoav Zitun
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Haaretz editorial: The IDF Must Investigate the Kibbutz Be'eri Tank Fire Incident – Right Now (January 8, 2024)
About this source
Haaretz editorial. The headline and opening sentence were read; the rest is behind a paywall.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Times of Israel: Controversial commander Barak Hiram named next Gaza Division chief (July 31, 2024)
About this source
Times of Israel report on Brig. Gen. Barak Hiram's appointment and reactions from Kibbutz Be'eri residents, including Shai Cohen's social media post.
- Author
- Emanuel Fabian and ToI Staff
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Times of Israel: IDF rushed to Kibbutz Kissufim as Hamas invaded, but some attackers stayed for days (May 22, 2025)
About this source
Times of Israel report on the IDF's Kissufim inquiry, including the friendly-fire death of Tom Godo on the morning of October 8, 2023.
- Author
- Emanuel Fabian
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
N12: IDF Kissufim battle inquiry and Kibbutz Kissufim's response (May 22, 2025)
Relevant passage: Probe findings ("שגיאה טקטית טרגית"; "ליל 7.10/בוקר 8.10") and the section "תגובת קיבוץ כיסופים"
About this source
N12 publication of the IDF's inquiry into the battle for Kibbutz Kissufim, in Hebrew, followed by the kibbutz's official response.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Times of Israel liveblog: Israel Police slams 'Haaretz' claim IDF helicopter may have harmed civilians on Oct. 7 (November 19, 2023)
About this source
Times of Israel liveblog entry quoting an Israel Police statement responding to a Haaretz Hebrew report that cited an unnamed police official.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Times of Israel: PA falsely says Oct. 7 rave massacre was committed by IDF; Netanyahu: 'Preposterous' (November 19, 2023)
About this source
Times of Israel report on a since-deleted Palestinian Authority foreign ministry statement saying Israeli helicopters killed partygoers at the Supernova festival under the Hannibal Protocol, and on Netanyahu's response.
- Author
- Gianluca Pacchiani
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Statement by PM Netanyahu, November 19, 2023 (Prime Minister's Office)
Relevant passage: Full statement
About this source
Text of Netanyahu's November 19, 2023 video statement as released by the Prime Minister's Office, read from the GlobalSecurity.org copy, which is labeled Israel - Prime Minister's Office, 19.11.2023.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Times of Israel, June 28, 2016: Israeli army cancels controversial Hannibal Protocol
Relevant passage: Paragraphs on Eisenkot's decision, the replacement directive, the State Comptroller report and the 2014 Rafah fighting
Excerpt
""The directive allows soldiers to use potentially massive amounts of force to prevent a soldier from falling into the hands of the enemy.""
About this source
A report by Judah Ari Gross that IDF chief of staff Lt. Gen. Gadi Eisenkot decided to cancel the Hannibal Protocol and that, according to a military spokesperson, a new directive would replace it to better match the situations soldiers are likely to face. It describes the directive as allowing potentially massive force to prevent a soldier's capture, including force that could endanger that soldier, and describes the move as not necessarily a full change in policy but a clarification. Citing Haaretz, it reports that a forthcoming State Comptroller report found that officers had differing understandings of the directive. It also describes the protocol's use in Gaza in August 2014, citing Palestinian reports of 150 dead and an IDF estimate closer to 40.
- Author
- Judah Ari Gross
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Associated Press, August 13, 2014: Israeli tactic to stop soldier capture criticized
Relevant passage: Paragraphs on the procedure's origin, Yaakov Amidror's comments and the Rafah shelling
Excerpt
""The order is that you cannot kill the soldier, but you can endanger him.""
About this source
An Associated Press report by Aron Heller, read in the Portland Press Herald's republication, on the Hannibal Procedure after its reported use in Rafah, Gaza, on August 1, 2014. It reports that Yossi Peled, then head of Israel's Northern Command, designed the procedure in the mid-1980s after Hezbollah captured two soldiers in southern Lebanon, and drafted it with Col. Gabi Ashkenazi and Col. Yaakov Amidror. It quotes Amidror saying the order does not allow troops to kill the captured soldier but allows them to endanger him. It reports that the military would not officially confirm the order was enacted after Lt. Hadar Goldin's disappearance, that multiple officials said it was given, and that Palestinian health officials said the shelling killed some 100 Palestinians.
- Author
- Aron Heller
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Zeteo, October 6, 2026: What Is the Hannibal Directive and How Many Israelis Did It Kill on October 7?
Relevant passage: Article text accompanying the video
Excerpt
"The Israeli military, however, should also have to answer for its actions on that chaotic and bloody day"
About this source
Hasan's written introduction to his video monologue, published on Zeteo on October 6, 2026. It says Western media outlets have ignored Israeli reporting on deaths caused by the Hannibal Directive, says Hasan agrees with Israeli families who want an independent investigation, and says the full 22-minute video is for paid subscribers while a 3-minute preview is free.
- Author
- Mehdi Hasan
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
The Hannibal Directive: Mehdi Hasan Asks 'Why the October 7 Media Cover-Up?' (Zeteo, YouTube)
Excerpt
"It's really kind of outrageous that mainstream Western media outlets have totally ignored this question, when the truth is that the Israeli media has not."
About this source
A 3 minute 27 second preview of Mehdi Hasan's 22-minute Zeteo monologue on the Hannibal Directive, posted to Zeteo's YouTube channel on October 6, 2026. Hasan sets out the October 7 death toll, says the number killed by Israel rather than by Palestinian armed groups is unknown, names outlets he says have covered the question, plays a subtitled clip of Yoav Gallant's February 2025 Channel 12 interview, and says major Western outlets ignored Gallant's remarks. The quotations are our transcription of the audio.
- Author
- Mehdi Hasan
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
Institute for Strategic Dialogue: Mis- and disinformation and conspiracy theories about the October 7 Hamas attack on Israel
Relevant passage: Section "Conspiracy theories about October 7 and related reporting"
Excerpt
"The Hannibal Directive has been central to false claims that Israeli security forces killed as many or more civilians than Hamas"
About this source
An ISD analysis of posts on X about the October 7 attack, collected between October 1, 2023 and July 31, 2024. It finds that the Haaretz article on the Hannibal Directive was the most shared URL in its dataset and that misrepresented findings from media investigations were used to suggest the Israeli military killed more of its own civilians than Hamas did. The page was last updated on September 3, 2026.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Video of Matthew Miller at the State Department press briefing, July 11, 2024 (posted on X)
State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller answers a reporter's question about who was responsible for the deaths on Oct. 7, 2023, at a State Department press briefing, July 11, 2024.
DI added its logo in the corner.
Video: U.S. Department of State briefing video (posted on X by @EYakoby). Excerpt used for news reporting and commentary
Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: Full clip, 0:00 to 0:24)
Excerpt
"I don't think it's any question it's Hamas that is responsible for the overwhelming number of deaths on October 7th."
About this source
A 24-second clip of the State Department's televised press briefing of July 11, 2024, posted on X by Eyal Yakoby and embedded in the Algemeiner's report on the exchange. It shows spokesperson Matthew Miller at the department's podium answering Said Arikat of Al Quds, whose question is heard at the start. The quotation is our transcription of the audio.
- Author
- Eyal Yakoby
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Algemeiner, July 12, 2024: US State Department spokesperson shuts down suggestion Israel responsible for majority of Oct. 7 casualties
Relevant passage: Article text and the embedded 24-second video of the July 11, 2024 State Department briefing
Excerpt
""I don't think that there's any question that it was Hamas that was responsible for the overwhelming number of deaths on Oct. 7," Miller responded."
About this source
Report on an exchange at the State Department press briefing on Thursday, July 11, 2024, in which Said Arikat, Washington bureau chief of the Palestinian daily Al Quds, cited the Haaretz report on the Hannibal Directive and asked whether it changed the department's view of what happened that day, suggesting Israel may have been responsible for killing a majority of those who died. The article embeds a 24-second video of the exchange posted on X. Our quotation of spokesperson Matthew Miller is a transcription of that video; the article's own rendering of his answer is slightly shorter.
- Author
- Corey Walker
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Electronic Intifada, February 7, 2025: Army was ordered to kill Israelis on 7 October, defense minister confirms
Relevant passage: Opening paragraphs
Excerpt
""In other places it was not given, and that is a problem," he continued."
About this source
A post by Asa Winstanley reporting Gallant's remarks, which it says Gallant made to Channel 12 on Thursday, February 6, 2025, in his first Israeli television interview since being dismissed in November 2024. It links the full Hebrew interview on the Channel 12 website and the subtitled clip.
- Author
- Asa Winstanley
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
Defense minister confirms army orders to kill Israelis on 7 October (The Electronic Intifada, YouTube excerpt of Yoav Gallant's Channel 12 interview)
Excerpt
"אני חושב שבאופן טקטי במקומות שונים ניתנה"
About this source
A 39-second excerpt, with English subtitles added by The Electronic Intifada, from Yoav Gallant's interview with Yonit Levi and Amit Segal on Channel 12 News, published by N12 on February 6, 2025 (https://www.mako.co.il/news-n12_magazine/2025_q1/Article-f0dc39bc717d491027.htm). Segal tells viewers the Hannibal Directive says to shoot to kill when a vehicle carries an Israeli hostage. Gallant says a defense minister's ability to give operational orders while events unfold is very limited, and, asked whether an order was given, answers in Hebrew that he thinks it was given tactically in various places, was not given in others, and that this is a problem. The Hebrew is our transcription of the audio, checked against the clip's subtitles.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
ABC News (Australia): Israeli forces accused of killing their own citizens under the 'Hannibal Directive' during October 7 chaos
Relevant passage: Paragraphs quoting Omri Shifroni, Sharon Cohen and the IDF's statement to the ABC
Excerpt
"I think it was not the right decision, not a good decision and not moral."
About this source
An ABC investigation by its Middle East correspondents. It quotes Kibbutz Be'eri resident Omri Shifroni, whose aunt and her grand-niece and grand-nephew were killed in Pessi Cohen's house, Pessi Cohen's daughter-in-law Sharon Cohen, former Air Force colonel Nof Erez, and an IDF statement saying questions of this kind would be looked into at a later stage. The ABC corrected the story on September 10, 2024 to say a reported order was given at midday on October 7, not midnight.
- Author
- Eric Tlozek, Orly Halpern and Allyson Horn
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Times of Israel, April 5, 2024: Efrat Katz likely killed by IAF helicopter fire during Oct. 7 abduction attempt, probe finds
Relevant passage: Full article
Excerpt
""As a result of the shooting, most of the terrorists in the vehicle were killed, and apparently also the late Efrat Katz," the Israel Defense Forces said."
About this source
Report on an Israeli Air Force probe into the death of Efrat Katz, 68, of Kibbutz Nir Oz. The IDF said a helicopter fired on a car carrying several attackers, that the car also held Israeli hostages, and that its surveillance systems could not distinguish hostages from attackers in moving vehicles. Air Force chief Maj. Gen. Tomer Bar said he did not find fault with the helicopter crew.
- Author
- Emanuel Fabian
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The New York Times, December 27, 2023: A General's Account of Oct. 7 Battle for Be'eri Stirs Debate in Israel
Relevant passage: Opening paragraphs
Excerpt
"Only two out of the 14 hostages in the house survived that day; it was not clear how many died by tank fire."
About this source
A follow-up report saying the Israeli military would review the circumstances of the battle for Be'eri after the Times's December 22 reconstruction, which included Brig. Gen. Barak Hiram's account of authorizing tank fire on a house where hostages were held, stirred debate in Israel. It reports that some people defended Hiram and that critics said he recklessly endangered the hostages.
- Author
- Aaron Boxerman, Natan Odenheimer and Ronen Bergman
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The New York Times, December 22, 2023: The Day Hamas Came (what happened in the Hamas attack on Be'eri)
Relevant passage: Sections "3:25 p.m.: 'Take Them All to Gaza'" and "4 p.m.: A General's Dilemma"
Excerpt
""The negotiations are over," General Hiram recalled telling the tank commander. "Break in, even at the cost of civilian casualties.""
About this source
A 10-week New York Times reconstruction of the attack on Kibbutz Be'eri. It reports Brig. Gen. Barak Hiram's account of ordering a tank to fire on Pessi Cohen's house, where 14 hostages were held, and reports that, according to his wife Hadas Dagan, shrapnel from the second shell killed Adi Dagan. Only two of the 14 hostages survived.
- Author
- Patrick Kingsley, Aaron Boxerman, Natan Odenheimer, Ronen Bergman and Marco Hernandez
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
IDF press briefing by spokesperson Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari on the Kibbutz Be'eri inquiry, July 11, 2024
Relevant passage: Paragraphs on the hostage event at the home of Pessi Cohen and on the conduct of the senior commanders
Excerpt
"The team determined that from the information examined so far and to the best of our assessment, no civilians inside the building were hit by tank fire."
About this source
The IDF's English text of an evening briefing in which its spokesperson presented the military's inquiry into the battle for Kibbutz Be'eri, led by Maj. Gen. (res.) Mickey Edelstein. The briefing says the IDF failed in its mission to protect Be'eri, defends the decision to fire tank shells at Pessi Cohen's house, and gives the inquiry's assessment of how the hostages held there died.
- Author
- Daniel Hagari
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
UN Commission of Inquiry, A/HRC/56/26: report to the Human Rights Council, 56th session
Relevant passage: Paragraph 36 (Israeli security forces and the Hannibal Directive) and paragraph 96
Excerpt
"Israeli security forces had likely applied the Hannibal Directive, resulting in the killing of up to 14 Israeli civilians."
About this source
The commission's report to the Human Rights Council on the October 7 attacks and Israel's military operations, released on June 12, 2024 and issued in its final form dated June 14, 2024. Paragraph 36 says that in at least two cases Israeli forces had likely applied the Hannibal Directive, "resulting in the killing of up to 14 Israeli civilians," and that some or all of the 13 hostages held in a house in Be'eri were killed by Israeli tank fire. Paragraph 96 says the forces applied the directive in several locations, "killing at least 14 Israeli civilians." The detailed findings are in the accompanying paper A/HRC/56/CRP.3.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
UN Commission of Inquiry, A/HRC/56/CRP.3: detailed findings on the attacks of October 7, 2023 in Israel
Relevant passage: Section on the Israeli Security Forces counter-offensive and the application of the Hannibal Directive, paragraphs 223 to 231, pages 44 to 46
Excerpt
"According to the Commission's investigation, in these two cases at least 14 Israeli civilians were likely killed as a result of Israeli Security Forces fire"
About this source
A conference room paper dated June 10, 2024 and released with the commission's report on June 12, 2024. It says the commission documented strong indications that the Hannibal Directive was used in several instances on October 7, cites a tank commander's statement to an Israeli news channel that his crew targeted two vehicles carrying militants and Israelis near Kibbutz Nir Oz, and concludes that in two cases at least 14 Israeli civilians were likely killed by Israeli fire: one woman by helicopter fire as she was taken from Nir Oz, and 13 by tank shelling and crossfire in Kibbutz Be'eri. The commission says it could not confirm whether helicopters fired at targets in the Nova festival area. The commission says Israeli officials refused to cooperate with its investigation.
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Hamas response letter to Human Rights Watch, April 14, 2024 (English translation, annex to HRW report)
Relevant passage: Annex: English Translation of Hamas's Response Letter, April 14, 2024, answer 7, p. 242
Excerpt
"it is important to point out that the Israeli army bears great responsibility for the killing of many settlers, as noted in Israel’s own reports, either during the targeting of the Spring Festival with planes and artillery shells or the bombing of homes where there were Israeli civilians on suspicio"
About this source
Hamas's written answers to Human Rights Watch's questions, published by HRW in English translation as an annex to its July 17, 2024 report.
- Published
- Accessed
Interview
Haaretz: 'Unlawful, Unethical, Horrifying': IDF Ethics Code Author on Alleged Use of 'Hannibal Directive' During Hamas Attack (January 17, 2024)
Excerpt
"There is absolutely nothing [in the code] to allow someone to kill an Israeli citizen, in uniform or not"
About this source
Haaretz interview with Asa Kasher. The headline and subtitle were read; the body is behind a paywall.
- Author
- Rachel Fink
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
FAIR: Shielding US Public From Israeli Reports of Friendly Fire on October 7 (February 23, 2024)
Excerpt
"While it is indisputable that the Hamas-led attackers were responsible for many Israeli civilian deaths that day, reports from Israel indicate that the IDF in multiple cases fired on and killed Israeli civilians."
About this source
Media criticism article by FAIR on U.S. coverage of Israeli reports of friendly fire on October 7.
- Author
- Bryce Greene
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
Check Your Fact: FACT CHECK: Did Israel Kill Most Of The Israeli Civilians On Oct. 7? (November 8, 2023)
Excerpt
"The majority of the civilians were killed by Hamas. Visual evidence also shows Hamas terrorists killing civilians."
About this source
Check Your Fact fact check of Hassan Nasrallah's November 3, 2023 claim. The live page loads its text by script; the text was read from the Wayback Machine capture of January 16, 2025.
- Author
- Elias Atienza
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
The Dispatch Fact Check: Misleading Post Claims the IDF Killed Israelis Intentionally on October 7 (July 10, 2024)
Excerpt
"ZafraMedia post’s claim that Israel “intentionally killed its own citizens” is exaggerated."
About this source
Fact check by The Dispatch of a social media post about Haaretz's Hannibal Directive report.
- Author
- Max Whalen
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Amnesty International, Targeting Civilians: Murder, Hostage-taking and Other Violations by Palestinian Armed Groups in Israel and Gaza (MDE 15/0282/2025, December 11, 2025)
Relevant passage: Executive summary, pp. 8 and 10; section 5.1, pp. 47 and 50; Be'eri p. 55; Nahal Oz p. 67
Excerpt
"In some cases, Israeli civilians were indeed killed by Israeli forces in cases of mistaken identification and/or in application of the Hannibal Directive."
About this source
Amnesty International report on crimes by Palestinian armed groups during and after the October 7 attack. Read in full from the PDF on amnesty.org.
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Human Rights Watch, "I Can't Erase All the Blood from My Mind": Palestinian Armed Groups' October 7 Assault on Israel (July 17, 2024)
Relevant passage: Summary, "Civilian Deaths in Crossfire", p. 13; Kfar Aza section, p. 99
Excerpt
"Israeli media reports indicate that Israeli forces responding to the assault injured or killed some civilians during attacks on Palestinian fighters in and around the fences separating Gaza and Israel."
About this source
Human Rights Watch report on the October 7 attack, based on interviews and analysis of videos and photographs. Read in full from the PDF on hrw.org.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Netanyahu speaks at ceremony marking 3 years since Oct. 7, bereaved father shouts: 'You didn't protect my son'
Excerpt
"During his speech, he was interrupted from the audience by Yaakov Godo, whose son Tom was murdered in the safe room in Kissufim during the October 7 massacre, who said: "You didn't protect my son.""
About this source
Ynet News report on Netanyahu's speech at the state civilian ceremony on Mount Herzl and Yaakov Godo's interruption.
- Author
- Idan Bloemhof
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
‘Blood of my son on his hands’: Netanyahu’s October 7 speech interrupted by bereaved father
Excerpt
"Once IDF soldiers took control of the house on October 8, 2023, they fired upon the door of the shelter after mistaking the occupants for terrorists, fatally striking Tom Godo."
About this source
Jerusalem Post report on Yaakov Godo's interruption of Netanyahu's speech at the October 5, 2026 state ceremony, citing Kan News for the IDF's finding on how Tom Godo was killed.
- Author
- Jerusalem Post Staff
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Michael Starr's post on Mehdi Hasan's Hannibal Directive video
Excerpt
"The directive is a removal of safeties that come with the use of live fire, as Americans may be familiar with danger close mortar or artillery strikes. Fire is directed at hostiles, not at hostages, but the safety protocols are essentially removed. You are shooting at risk to friendlies, not at frie"
About this source
Michael Starr's post on his X account on October 6, 2026, quoting a Zeteo post about Mehdi Hasan's video.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Kyle Orton's post on Zack Polanski and the Hannibal Directive
Excerpt
"When Zack Polanski spoke of Israel having "definitely" engaged in "false flag" operations, he specifically mentioned the "Hannibal Directive", this zombie meme from the aftermath of October 7 claiming the Israelis killed themselves."
About this source
Kyle Orton's post on his X account on October 3, 2026, linking a Telegraph report.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Susan Abulhawa's post on October 7 deaths
Excerpt
"It is now an uncontested fact—supported by video evidence, victim and eyewitness testimonies, and journalist investigations—that Israel deployed their Hannibal Directive, killing an unknown "hundreds" of Israelis."
About this source
Susan Abulhawa's post on her X account on March 3, 2025.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Ali Abunimah's post on the Haaretz Hannibal Directive report
Excerpt
"On 7 October, "Israeli" forces were ordered to fire at *every single vehicle* moving towards Gaza. There is no doubt the Zionists deliberately murdered large numbers of their own people that day."
About this source
Ali Abunimah's post on his X account on July 8, 2024, linking Haaretz's July 7, 2024 report.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Max Blumenthal's post on Hannibal Directive orders
Excerpt
"Israel targeted hundreds of its own citizens on Oct 7 with "mass Hannibal" orders"
About this source
Max Blumenthal's post on his X account on June 26, 2026, with images of Defense Ministry log excerpts.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Aaron Maté's post on Israelis killed on October 7
Excerpt
"It's important to be factual. Hamas did not kill "more than 1,100 Israelis." Israel killed some of those Israelis by enacting the Hannibal Directive, which says that Israel would rather kill its own people than have to negotiate for their release (by releasing some of the thousands more Palestinian "
About this source
Aaron Maté's post on his X account on October 7, 2025, quoting a statement by Zohran Mamdani.
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Did Israeli forces kill Israelis under the Hannibal Directive on October 7?
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/did-israeli-forces-kill-israelis-under-the-hannibal-directive-on-october-7
The Dispute Index. "Did Israeli forces kill Israelis under the Hannibal Directive on October 7?". First published: 2026-10-06. Last updated: 2026-10-07. https://disputeindex.com/cases/did-israeli-forces-kill-israelis-under-the-hannibal-directive-on-october-7