The Dispute Index

Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

DHS says it will lead the investigation of an ICE officer's shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez in Austin. Read its statement, calls for an independent inquiry and the subsequent charge.

BackgroundWhen can federal immigration agents use deadly force?What is the Supremacy Clause?

Read the original post (opens in a new tab)
Editorial composite of the Austin skyline and an ICE agent viewed through a magnifying glass.
Editorial composite using a 2026 Austin skyline and a public-domain ICE enforcement photograph. It does not depict the September 2026 shooting or investigation.

Case period:

Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated

U.S. Department of Homeland SecurityU.S. Immigration and Customs EnforcementKirk Watson
Immigration PolicyLaw EnforcementGovernment TransparencyU.S. Politics

Overview

On September 20, 2026, according to Austin officials, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer shot and wounded Wilber Rafael Garces Perez, a 28-year-old Venezuelan DoorDash driver, in North Austin, Texas. DHS said Homeland Security Investigations, with FBI assistance, would lead the investigation and described him as an “illegal alien” with a final order of removal who is in federal custody pending removal. His attorney disputes that he entered illegally and says he has a valid work permit. Austin's mayor, Democratic members of Congress and the League of United Latin American Citizens question DHS's and ICE's credibility and have called for an independent investigation. Rep. Chip Roy, a Republican, repeated DHS's description of the man. On September 29, federal prosecutors charged him with assaulting and resisting a federal officer, and the U.S. Attorney's Office said ICE's Homeland Security Investigations is investigating that case.

Background: Terms in this case
Read the full background

This case classifies responses to DHS's public account of the shooting and its decision to have Homeland Security Investigations lead the investigation. In a late-Sunday post on X (opens in a new tab), DHS said HSI, with the FBI's assistance, is leading the investigation into an “officer involved shooting” of a man from Venezuela who “illegally entered our country under the Biden administration and had a final order of removal,” and that he is in federal custody pending removal. The post did not name him or say what led to the shooting. CBS News reported (opens in a new tab) that HSI is a component of ICE itself and has not traditionally been the principal investigator of officer-involved shootings.

Austin-Travis County EMS said the shooting was reported at about 12:56 p.m. on Sunday, September 20, in North Austin. CNN reported (opens in a new tab) that officials said the man was shot in the torso, that DoorDash confirmed he was working as a delivery driver at the time, and that a source familiar with the incident said ICE officers found a vehicle registered to him while conducting license-plate-based enforcement and that he had a deportation order. Austin police said they were not involved in the shooting.

Immigration attorney Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch, who represents his family, identified him as Wilber Rafael Garces Perez. She told CBS News (opens in a new tab) that, based on the information available to her team, he entered the United States lawfully, without commenting on his current legal status, and told CNN (opens in a new tab) that he entered on an asylum claim, had been protected by a parole program that the administration later ended, has a valid work permit, and received a removal order in absentia after his court date was changed without notice to him. She also disputes that there was a foot chase; Austin's police chief said there may have been a brief foot pursuit but called that information preliminary. NBC News reported (opens in a new tab) that a senior administration official said he had no criminal history beyond being in the country illegally.

Local and federal Democratic officials have challenged an investigation led by DHS. Mayor Kirk Watson told a news conference that ICE conducting an investigation by itself and excluding others would not be appropriate (KXAN (opens in a new tab)). The Travis County District Attorney's office asked to be a “co-equal partner” with the Austin Police Department, requested federal cooperation and access to evidence, and said the incident may have included violations of state law (FOX 7 Austin (opens in a new tab)). Rep. Greg Casar sent DHS a letter (opens in a new tab) demanding an independent investigation and a briefing by September 28, and LULAC called for independent oversight of immigration enforcement (CNN (opens in a new tab)).

On September 29, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Western District of Texas announced (opens in a new tab) that Garces Perez had been charged with one count of assaulting, resisting, interfering with and impeding a federal officer, and said ICE's Homeland Security Investigations is investigating that case. The Associated Press reported (opens in a new tab) that a nine-page affidavit from a DHS agent is the government's fullest public account of the shooting so far, and that the officer who fired was not wearing a body camera. The complaint describes a vehicle chase rather than a foot pursuit, and Austin's police chief said at a September 22 briefing that a vehicle pursuit followed the first encounter (KEYE (opens in a new tab)).

Rep. Chip Roy (R-TX) posted on X (opens in a new tab) that “we were told” the man is an illegal alien from Venezuela with a final order of removal; Fox News reported (opens in a new tab) that authorities had not publicly disclosed information indicating the man fired a weapon. As of September 22, we could not locate a public DHS response to the demands for an independent investigation or to the attorney's account. The dispute concerns DHS's description of events and who should investigate; it is not a finding on whether the shooting was justified.

People in this case

Timeline

12 timeline entries on this page. Dates: September 20, 2026 to October 7, 2026

  1. September 2026

    1. Travis County District Attorney asks to be a co-equal partner in the investigation

      Reaction

      The Travis County District Attorney's office said in a statement that an independent investigation must be completed and asked that the Austin Police Department and the District Attorney's office be “co-equal partners in the investigation.” It also requested federal cooperation in giving it access to the evidence and said it is possible the incident included violations of state law.

      [01]ICE shooting in North Austin: Texas leaders react

      Roundup that reproduces the full text of statements from Mayor Watson, the Travis County District Attorney, Rep. Casar and others on the day of the shooting.

      ICE shooting in North Austin: Texas leaders reactStatements section: Travis County District Attorney, Mayor Watson, Rep. Casar
      [02]KXAN

      Local report quoting Mayor Watson's news conference remarks and the District Attorney's statement. It notes the DHS post did not name the man.

      Austin officials condemn ICE shooting of Venezuelan man, call for independent investigation · KXANParagraphs quoting Mayor Watson on ICE's credibility, the Travis County District Attorney statement, and Rep. Doggett
      [03]CNN

      CNN report on the shooting, DHS's statement, the attorney's account, local officials' calls for an independent investigation, and LULAC's statement.

      Man shot by ICE moved from hospital to detention center 'with a bullet in his back,' lawyer tells CNN · CNNFull article: dispute over legal status; LULAC statement; attorney interview

    2. Garces Perez files habeas petition and emergency motion

      The public docket in Garces Perez v. Thompson, No. 5:26-cv-06038 (W.D. Tex.), records that Wilber Rafael Garces Perez filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus and a separate motion seeking a temporary restraining order, preliminary injunction, release, and a stay of removal. The docket records the filings; it does not resolve the petition’s allegations or requests.

      [04]Docket in Garces Perez v. Thompson, No. 5:26-cv-06038 (W.D. Tex.)

      Source excerpt

      Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus ... filed by Wilber Rafael Garces Perez; MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order AND PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ORDERING RELEASE AND A STAY OF REMOVAL PENDING FINAL JUDGMENT.

      Public docket mirror for Garces Perez v. Thompson, No. 5:26-cv-06038 in the Western District of Texas. It records the filing of a habeas petition and an emergency motion seeking release and a stay of removal; the underlying filings are not publicly available in the mirror, so this source does not establish their factual allegations or merits.

      Docket in Garces Perez v. Thompson, No. 5:26-cv-06038 (W.D. Tex.)Docket entries 1 and 2, entered September 21, 2026

    3. Garces Perez gives a phone account from ICE detention after the shooting

      Claim

      During a September 21 telephone statement from ICE detention, Garces Perez said hospital staff told him a bullet was too near his spine to remove and alleged that he had not received the medical care he needed after transfer. He also gave an account of the moments before the shooting that differed from preliminary descriptions. These are Garces Perez’s attributed statements; the reports do not independently establish the medical or shooting allegations.

      [05]Univision reports Wilber Garcés Pérez’s phone account from ICE detention

      Source excerpt

      Estoy un poco mal, tengo la bala ahí adentro todavía.

      Univision reports a September 21 telephone statement by Wilber Garcés Pérez from ICE detention. It attributes to him an account of his medical care and the moments before the shooting; the report does not independently establish those allegations.

      Univision reports Wilber Garcés Pérez’s phone account from ICE detentionParagraphs beginning “Desde un centro de procesamiento…,” “Estoy un poco mal…,” “Un día antes…,” and section “De la cama del hospital al piso de un centro de detención.”
      [06]Texas Tribune reports Wilber Garcés Pérez’s phone account after Austin ICE shooting

      Source excerpt

      I’m not doing very well. I have not received the medical attention that I require.

      The Texas Tribune reports Garcés Pérez’s September 21 telephone remarks from ICE detention and says the Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to a request for comment on his shooting account and medical-care complaint.

      Texas Tribune reports Wilber Garcés Pérez’s phone account after Austin ICE shootingOpening paragraphs describing the press conference, especially the paragraphs beginning “Garces Perez, who called into the news conference,” and “The Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond.”

    4. Rep. Joaquin Castro says Garcés Pérez is being taken to a hospital

      Reaction

      In a public Instagram reel, Rep. Joaquin Castro said Wilber Rafael Garcés Pérez was being taken to a hospital from the South Texas ICE Processing Center, was in severe pain, still had a bullet in his left side, and could not move the left side of his body. The post attributes those details to Pérez and is not an independent medical-provider or DHS confirmation.

      [07]Joaquin Castro

      Source excerpt

      He’s being taken to the hospital. He is in tremendous pain.

      In a verified public Instagram reel, Rep. Joaquin Castro said Garcés Pérez was being taken to a hospital from the South Texas ICE Processing Center, had a bullet still inside his left side, and could not move the left side of his body. The post is Castro’s account of Pérez’s reported condition; it is not an independent medical-provider or DHS confirmation.

      Rep. Joaquin Castro Instagram update on Wilber Rafael Garcés Pérez’s medical condition · Joaquin CastroVerified @joaquincastrotx reel caption, beginning “Update on the condition of Wilber Rafael Garcés Pérez”

    5. About 175 protesters rally at the Texas Capitol over the shooting

      Reaction

      Roughly 175 people gathered at the south gates of the Texas Capitol on the evening of September 21, organized by La Frontera Unidad, to protest Garces Perez's shooting. Speakers demanded his release from ICE custody, prosecution of the officer who shot him, and an independent investigation; several also called for broader changes to immigration enforcement, including abolishing ICE. Texas DPS troopers monitored the demonstration, which dispersed peacefully after the Capitol grounds closed at 8 p.m.

      [08]Austin American-Statesman: Protesters rally at Texas Capitol over Garces Perez shooting

      Source excerpt

      Not one agency that fills the back of my people with bullets can ever be reformed.

      The Austin American-Statesman's report on a roughly 175-person protest at the Texas Capitol on September 21, organized by La Frontera Unidad, demanding Garces Perez's release, prosecution of the officer who shot him, and an independent investigation. It also reports a new statement from attorney Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch that Garces Perez's condition worsened in ICE custody.

      Austin American-Statesman: Protesters rally at Texas Capitol over Garces Perez shootingFull article, including quotes from Jesse Valdelamar, Selena Jurado and Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch.

    6. Lincoln-Goldfinch says Garces Perez's condition worsened in ICE custody

      Reaction

      Attorney Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch said Garces Perez was handled roughly by officers after being transferred to the South Texas ICE Processing Center in Pearsall, lost feeling in his left arm and leg, and was then taken to a hospital. She said he had not received pain medication and had been held in a cold room without a bed, and that a bullet remains lodged near his spine.

      [08]Austin American-Statesman: Protesters rally at Texas Capitol over Garces Perez shooting

      Source excerpt

      Not one agency that fills the back of my people with bullets can ever be reformed.

      The Austin American-Statesman's report on a roughly 175-person protest at the Texas Capitol on September 21, organized by La Frontera Unidad, demanding Garces Perez's release, prosecution of the officer who shot him, and an independent investigation. It also reports a new statement from attorney Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch that Garces Perez's condition worsened in ICE custody.

      Austin American-Statesman: Protesters rally at Texas Capitol over Garces Perez shootingFull article, including quotes from Jesse Valdelamar, Selena Jurado and Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch.

    7. Gina Hinojosa calls for medical attention for Garces Perez

      Reaction

      Texas House member Gina Hinojosa called for Wilber Rafael Garces Perez to receive urgent medical attention and criticized his reported detention by ICE after the shooting. Her statement presents the medical and detention circumstances as reported and does not independently establish them.

      [09]Gina Hinojosa statement calling for medical attention for Wilber Rafael Garces Perez

      Source excerpt

      Right now, a man is being held with a bullet lodged in his body at a federal facility in Pearsall, Texas. He needs urgent medical attention.

      Campaign statement from Texas House member Gina Hinojosa about Garces Perez's reported detention after the Austin shooting. It calls for urgent medical attention and criticizes the reported handling by ICE; it does not itself establish the medical or detention facts.

      Gina Hinojosa statement calling for medical attention for Wilber Rafael Garces PerezFull statement

    8. Austin police chief says APD SIU and Texas Rangers will take part in the investigation

      Austin Police Chief Lisa Davis released a video about the September 20 ICE incident. KVUE reported that Davis said the Austin Police Department’s Special Investigations Unit and the Texas Rangers would take part in the shooting investigation, asked the public not to speculate, and invited witnesses to provide evidence. The announcement does not resolve the disputed accounts of the shooting.

      [10]Austin Police Chief Lisa Davis video message about the September 20 ICE incident

      Source excerpt

      Message from Chief Davis regarding Sunday, Sept. 20th ICE Incident

      Official video statement from the Austin Police Department about the September 20, 2026 ICE shooting incident. The department's linked video addresses the ongoing investigation and requests public cooperation.

      Austin Police Chief Lisa Davis video message about the September 20 ICE incidentPost text and attached 3:01 video
      [11]Man shot by ICE agents in Austin gives phone interview during press conference

      Source excerpt

      APD’s Special Investigations Unit and the Texas Rangers will take part in the shooting investigation.

      Local report on a September 21 press conference and Chief Lisa Davis's video statement. It reports that the Austin Police Department’s Special Investigations Unit and the Texas Rangers will take part in the investigation, and that Davis asked witnesses to provide evidence.

      Man shot by ICE agents in Austin gives phone interview during press conferenceParagraph beginning “Davis and Austin Mayor Kirk Watson said”

    9. Rep. Joaquin Castro calls for an independent investigation into the Austin ICE shooting

      Reaction

      In an official statement about Wilber Rafael Garcés Pérez’s shooting, Rep. Joaquin Castro called for an independent investigation, immediate medical care, and for Pérez to remain in Texas. He also described ICE as “rogue, lawless, and deadly.”

      [12]Joaquin Castro

      Source excerpt

      Under Trump, ICE has become rogue, lawless, and deadly.

      An official House page hosting Castro’s video about the Austin shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez. The page says Castro is calling for an independent investigation, immediate medical care, and for Perez to remain in Texas; it also contains Castro’s attributed account of Perez’s detention and medical treatment. Embedded video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DhFBycT6Ups.

      Rep. Joaquin Castro: “The Austin ICE shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez” · Joaquin CastroOpening description beneath the embedded video.

    10. Travis County DA asks DHS and ICE to halt Garces Perez's removal

      Reaction

      The Travis County District Attorney's Office asks DHS and ICE to halt removal proceedings against Garces Perez while the office investigates his shooting during an attempted ICE traffic stop. The office said removal could hinder his ability to participate as a material witness in its investigation or a future prosecution. The request does not establish whether DHS, ICE, or a court will grant it.

      [13]Travis County District Attorney's Office sends letter to DHS and ICE to halt removal proceedings against Wilbur Rafael Garces Perez

      Source excerpt

      Mr. Garces Perez's ability to participate as a material witness will be severely hindered if he is removed from the United States.

      The Travis County District Attorney's Office said it asked DHS and ICE to halt removal proceedings against Garces Perez while the local investigation continues. The request seeks to preserve his ability to participate as a material witness; it does not represent a decision by DHS, ICE, or a court.

      Travis County District Attorney's Office sends letter to DHS and ICE to halt removal proceedings against Wilbur Rafael Garces PerezEntire official release and linked 9.22.26 TCDA Letter

    11. Casar visits Garces Perez in detention and requests a transparent investigation

      Reaction

      Rep. Greg Casar's office said he visited Wilber Rafael Garces Perez in ICE custody and requested a transparent investigation, release of body- and dash-camera footage, and federal cooperation with local law enforcement. The release states Casar's account and requests; it does not independently establish the medical or detention-condition assertions it describes.

      [14]Greg Casar

      Official release from Representative Greg Casar's office. It reports on his detention visit with Wilber Rafael Garces Perez and states Casar's requests for medical release, body- and dash-camera footage, and a transparent investigation. Medical and detention-condition assertions are attributed to Casar and Garces Perez; the release is not an independent investigation.

      Casar reports on Garces Perez after a detention visit and calls for medical release · Greg CasarSeptember 23, 2026 dateline; opening visit description; Casar quotation; paragraphs calling for an investigation, footage release, and DHS briefing.

  2. October 2026

    1. Austin police say requested DHS evidence has not arrived

      Reaction

      Austin police said on October 7 that they had not received requested federal reports and recordings concerning the September shooting of Luis Garces. They said their investigation was continuing while they awaited a response. The Statesman published the statement October 8; DHS did not comment for the article.

      [15]Austin American-Statesman

      The American-Statesman quotes a direct APD statement that requested federal material had not arrived. The statement concerns access to evidence and the ongoing local investigation; it does not resolve the justification for the shooting.

      Austin police say DHS has not shared evidence in ICE shooting investigation · Austin American-StatesmanAPD statement supplied Wednesday, October 7; paragraphs listing requested reports and recordings and describing continued independent investigation.

Claims

Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.

What's disputed

Response record

Responses

Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.

23 responses. First 6 shown initially. Newest first.

  1. Vanessa FuentesAustin City Council Member for District 2

    Before this statement

    An ICE agent shot DoorDash driver Wilber Rafael Garces Perez in North Austin on September 20. DHS said Homeland Security Investigations, with the assistance of the FBI, was leading the investigation.

    "ICE cannot investigate itself, and so it’s important that we have our local law enforcement agency involved in that investigation"
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Austin City Council Member Vanessa Fuentes said ICE cannot investigate itself and that local law enforcement should be involved in the investigation of the shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez. She said she was joining her colleagues in asking for a full, thorough, independent investigation.

    After the statement

    In the same report Fuentes called on Congress to stop funding ICE. She also said the council needs access to information, evidence and witness interviews to understand what happened.

    Austin Council Member calls for ICE accountability, independent investigation · CBS AustinFuentes quotation beginning "ICE cannot investigate itself," in the second half of the article
    Live updates: Attorney says man shot by ICE mistook unmarked vehicle for another driverEntries for 12:48 p.m. and 1:45 p.m. on September 21

    Why this label?

    The case asks whether DHS should lead the investigation of the shooting. Fuentes said ICE cannot investigate itself and that local law enforcement should be involved, and she joined her colleagues in asking for a full, thorough, independent investigation. That rejects an investigation led by the agency involved, so we labeled it Condemned.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  2. José GarzaTravis County District Attorney

    Before this statement

    On September 20, the Travis County District Attorney's Office said an independent investigation was critical and asked that Austin police and the district attorney be co-equal partners in the investigation. On September 22, it asked DHS and ICE to halt removal proceedings against Wilber Rafael Garces Perez while the investigation continues.

    "So far, the information has been flowing from the Austin Police Department to federal law enforcement officials, and as we sit here today, three days away from this shooting, it is incredibly important that the information start to flow both ways To my knowledge, at this point, the federal government has not shared any evidence with the Austin Police Department, and importantly, has not responded to a request from the Austin Police Department to be able to participate in or be allowed to interview the ICE agent who discharged his weapon here in Travis County this past Sunday"
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Travis County District Attorney José Garza said information had so far flowed from Austin police to federal law enforcement, and that it was incredibly important for it to flow both ways. He said that, to his knowledge, the federal government had not shared any evidence with Austin police or responded to Austin police's request to participate in or interview the ICE agent who fired.

    After the statement

    Garza said his office was seeking access to video evidence, including body-camera and vehicle-camera footage, and an interview with the ICE agent who fired.

    A Venezuelan man was shot by ICE in Austin while doing deliveries. Here’s what we know · CNNSection "Local district attorney demands independent investigation" (article updated September 24, 2026)
    Travis County District Attorney’s Office Releases Statement on Reported ICE Agent Shooting of a Community MemberEntire release, dated September 20, 2026
    Travis County District Attorney's Office sends letter to DHS and ICE to halt removal proceedings against Wilbur Rafael Garces PerezEntire official release and linked 9.22.26 TCDA Letter

    Why this label?

    The case asks whether DHS should lead the investigation of the shooting. Garza said information had so far flowed from Austin police to federal officials and that it was incredibly important for it to flow both ways. He said that, to his knowledge, federal officials had not shared any evidence or answered Austin police's request to participate in or interview the ICE agent. His office had also asked to be a co-equal partner in an independent investigation. That criticizes how the federal-led investigation was being handled, so we labeled it Condemned.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  3. Joaquin CastroU.S. representative for Texas's 20th District

    Before this statement

    Castro issued the statement after members of his staff and Rep. Greg Casar visited Wilber Rafael Garces Perez in federal detention.

    "There must be an independent investigation, and the ICE officers who shot Wilber in the back should be held accountable."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Joaquin Castro said DHS and ICE should not control the inquiry and called for an independent investigation.

    After the statement

    Castro said ICE had discredited itself and that the officers who shot Garces Perez should be held accountable.

    Castro Statement on Wilber Rafael Garces Perez · Joaquin CastroFinal paragraph beginning 'ICE has shot and killed people before'

    Why this label?

    The statement condemns DHS leadership of the investigation from the case's point of view because Castro explicitly demands an independent inquiry.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  4. Lloyd DoggettU.S. representative for Texas's 37th District

    Before this statement

    KXAN reported that questions remained about the circumstances of the September 20 shooting of Wilber Garces Perez and sought an ICE response about body-worn cameras.

    "We don’t know enough because ICE as usual is not providing the facts. They should’ve already released any body camera footage that they had."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Doggett said ICE had not provided enough facts about the Austin shooting and called for the release of any available body-camera footage.

    After the statement

    KXAN reported that ICE had not answered its question about whether the agents were wearing cameras as of publication. The report does not establish whether a camera was worn or activated.

    Austin lawmakers question ICE body-camera use after shooting of Wilber Garces Perez · KXANPassages quoting Rep. Lloyd Doggett about ICE's public account and any available body-camera footage; KXAN's report says ICE had not answered its question about whether agents wore cameras.

    Why this label?

    Relative to the case's oversight question, Doggett criticizes ICE's handling of information about the shooting and calls for available footage. He does not assert that a body camera was worn or activated.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  5. Alex PadillaMember of the United States Congress

    Before this statement

    The statement followed the September 20 Austin shooting, DHS’s announcement that Homeland Security Investigations would lead the inquiry, and public calls for an investigation outside DHS or ICE.

    "ICE can’t keep shooting people in our communities without any consequences. I’m calling for an independent and transparent investigation because this should have never happened to 28-year-old Wilber Rafael Garces Perez, a DoorDash driver who was trying to make a delivery."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Sen. Alex Padilla said ICE shootings cannot continue without consequences and called for an independent and transparent investigation into the Garces Perez shooting. His call rejects reliance on a DHS-led inquiry alone.

    After the statement

    The post calls for an independent or full investigation but does not itself resolve the disputed facts about the shooting or specify the full investigative structure.

    Sen. Alex Padilla calls for an independent investigation of the Garces Perez shooting · Alex PadillaFull X post, published September 21, 2026 at 9:18 p.m. UTC

    Why this label?

    DHS's account of the shooting and its choice to have HSI lead the investigation. Padilla says ICE "can't keep shooting people... without any consequences" and calls for an "independent and transparent investigation," rejecting a DHS/ICE-led inquiry as sufficient. That's a direct rejection of DHS's chosen investigative process, so condemns holds.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  6. Judy ChuMember of the United States Congress

    Before this statement

    The statement followed the September 20 Austin shooting, DHS’s announcement that Homeland Security Investigations would lead the inquiry, and public calls for an investigation outside DHS or ICE.

    "I have joined @RepCasar's letter demanding an independent investigation. This violence must end."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Rep. Judy Chu said she had joined Rep. Greg Casar’s letter demanding an independent investigation and called for the violence to end.

    After the statement

    The post calls for an independent or full investigation but does not itself resolve the disputed facts about the shooting or specify the full investigative structure.

    Rep. Judy Chu says the violence against Garces Perez must end · Judy ChuFull X post, published September 21, 2026 at 9:12 p.m. UTC

    Why this label?

    On whether DHS should lead its own investigation, Chu rejects that arrangement by joining Rep. Casar's letter "demanding an independent investigation" — an explicit call for oversight outside DHS/ICE.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
View all 23 responsesShow fewer responses
  1. Jesse ValdelamarPresident of La Frontera Unidad, speaking at a rally at the Texas Capitol

    Before this statement

    The rally followed Garces Perez's own account of the shooting given earlier that day.

    "Not one agency that fills the back of my people with bullets can ever be reformed."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Jesse Valdelamar, president of La Frontera Unidad, told a rally at the Texas Capitol that ICE cannot be reformed and said any investigation ICE conducts of itself cannot be trusted. Fellow organizer Selena Jurado called for Garces Perez's release, prosecution of the officer who shot him, and an independent investigation.

    After the statement

    Selena Jurado, also with La Frontera Unidad, outlined three demands: Garces Perez's release, prosecution of the officer who shot him, and an independent investigation.

    Austin American-Statesman: Protesters rally at Texas Capitol over Garces Perez shootingFull article, including quotes from Jesse Valdelamar, Selena Jurado and Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch.

    Why this label?

    Valdelamar directly rejects DHS/ICE's capacity to investigate itself, condemning the agency's leading role rather than merely disputing how the shooting has been characterized.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  2. Kate Lincoln-GoldfinchImmigration attorney for the man who was shot, in a post on X

    Before this statement

    DHS had said the man illegally entered the country under the Biden administration and had a final order of removal. The attorney also told CNN he entered on an asylum claim and received a removal order in absentia after his court date changed without notice.

    "Wilber entered legally and has a valid work permit."
    Challenged the characterization

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    In a post on X, the man's attorney wrote that he entered legally and has a valid work permit, disputing DHS's description of him as an illegal alien who illegally entered.

    After the statement

    The post begins by addressing “Chip” and adds that he needs to be released from detention immediately. The attorney also said there was no foot chase and that the man did not know the officers were ICE until he was shot. NBC News reported that DHS did not immediately respond to a request for comment on her statements.

    Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch's post on X about the man's status · Kate Lincoln-GoldfinchPost text
    ICE agent shoots and wounds man in Austin, Texas, sparking demands for full investigation · CBS NewsFull article: investigation lead; attorney quotes; Watson remarks
    Man shot by ICE moved from hospital to detention center 'with a bullet in his back,' lawyer tells CNN · CNNFull article: dispute over legal status; LULAC statement; attorney interview
    Live updates: Attorney says man shot by ICE mistook unmarked vehicle for another driverEntries for 12:48 p.m. and 1:45 p.m. on September 21
    ICE officer shoots Venezuelan man delivering food in Austin, lawyer says · NBC NewsFull article: DHS statement; senior administration official; Casar letter
    Who Is Wilber Rafael Garces Perez? DoorDash Worker Shot by ICE in Austin · NewsweekParagraphs quoting the attorney's X posts and DHS's statement

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's account, the attorney disputes DHS's description of the man's entry and status. She does not speak to the investigation in this quotation, so the response is a challenge to the description. Closest competing label: condemns loses because this passage disputes a characterization rather than criticizing DHS's conduct.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  3. Greg CasarU.S. Representative (D-TX 35), at a news conference with LULAC leaders

    Before this statement

    Casar spoke after DHS said HSI would lead the investigation and described the man as an illegal alien with a final order of removal. He had earlier said DHS's first statement was that it wanted to remove and deport the man, whom he described as a potential key witness to the shooting.

    "The reason we have all these cameras out here and all these people out here is because ICE has lied in virtually every single case."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    At a Monday news conference, Casar said ICE has lied in virtually every single case and, citing earlier shootings, said the public cannot believe what ICE says about the Austin shooting.

    After the statement

    He went on to list three demands sent to DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin: release of body-camera and dash-camera footage, accountability for any wrongdoing with local law enforcement allowed to continue its criminal investigation, and safety for the community.

    FOX 7 Austin broadcast of the September 21 news conference on the Austin ICE shooting (Casar remarks)Rep. Greg Casar remarks, 06:22-07:05 (on-screen label: Representative Greg Casar, D, Texas, District 35)
    Live updates: Attorney says man shot by ICE mistook unmarked vehicle for another driverEntries for 12:48 p.m. and 1:45 p.m. on September 21

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's account of the shooting, Casar states that ICE has lied in virtually every case and that its account of this one cannot be believed. That is a direct rejection of the account's reliability. Closest competing label: “Mixed or conditional” loses because he sets no condition on that conclusion.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  4. Lloyd DoggettU.S. Representative (D-TX 37), at a news conference with LULAC leaders and Rep. Greg Casar

    Before this statement

    Doggett spoke after LULAC leaders and the man's attorney presented calls for independent oversight of immigration-enforcement shootings. He said he offered “full and unqualified support” to LULAC's recommendations.

    "clearly ICE has no credibility anymore. It lies. We know it lies. We've seen it demonstrated again and again, and we need the kind of independent structure to demand some accountability."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    At a Monday news conference, Doggett said ICE has no credibility, that it lies, and that an independent structure is needed to demand accountability.

    After the statement

    He also said he wants ICE out of Austin and urged that protest be carried to the polls in 43 days. His written statement on September 20 said the lack of facts about the shooting results from ICE secrecy and non-responsiveness.

    FOX 7 Austin broadcast of the September 21 news conference on the Austin ICE shooting (Doggett remarks)Rep. Lloyd Doggett remarks, 00:27-00:47 (on-screen label: Representative Lloyd Doggett, D, Texas, District 37)
    Doggett Reacts to Today's ICE Shooting in the District He Represents in Austin · Lloyd DoggettFull statement
    Live updates: Attorney says man shot by ICE mistook unmarked vehicle for another driverEntries for 12:48 p.m. and 1:45 p.m. on September 21

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's account and DHS-led investigation, Doggett rejects ICE's credibility and calls for an independent structure. Closest competing label: “Challenged the characterization” loses because the statement denounces ICE's honesty rather than disputing one description.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  5. James WalkinshawMember of the United States Congress

    Before this statement

    The statement followed the September 20 Austin shooting, DHS’s announcement that Homeland Security Investigations would lead the inquiry, and public calls for an investigation outside DHS or ICE.

    "ICE shot Wilber Rafael Garces Perez, 28, while he was making a DoorDash delivery in Austin. Now he’s in ICE custody & they’re trying to quickly deport him before the public has a full account of what happened. We need a full, independent investigation and the body cam footage."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Rep. James Walkinshaw called for a full, independent investigation and release of body-camera footage, saying the public needed a full account before Garces Perez could be deported.

    After the statement

    The post calls for an independent or full investigation but does not itself resolve the disputed facts about the shooting or specify the full investigative structure.

    Rep. James Walkinshaw calls for an independent investigation and body-camera footage · James WalkinshawFull X post, published September 21, 2026 at 5:45 p.m. UTC

    Why this label?

    On whether DHS should lead its own investigation, Walkinshaw rejects that arrangement: he notes ICE is "trying to quickly deport him before the public has a full account of what happened" and calls for "a full, independent investigation and the body cam footage" — an explicit demand for an inquiry outside DHS/ICE's control.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  6. Adam SmithMember of the United States Congress

    Before this statement

    The statement followed the September 20 Austin shooting, DHS’s announcement that Homeland Security Investigations would lead the inquiry, and public calls for an investigation outside DHS or ICE.

    "ICE continues to violently target individuals in this country, without any transparency or accountability. We need a full investigation into the shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez and answers before this rogue police force continues to target more people in our country's streets."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Rep. Adam Smith called for a full investigation and answers, saying ICE was targeting people violently without transparency or accountability.

    After the statement

    The post calls for an independent or full investigation but does not itself resolve the disputed facts about the shooting or specify the full investigative structure.

    Rep. Adam Smith calls for a full investigation of the Garces Perez shooting · Adam SmithFull X post, published September 21, 2026 at 2:00 p.m. UTC

    Why this label?

    On whether DHS should lead its own investigation, Smith rejects that arrangement: he says ICE acts "without any transparency or accountability", calls it a "rogue police force", and demands "a full investigation into the shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez and answers" — an explicit call for outside scrutiny rather than a DHS-led inquiry.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  7. U.S. Department of Homeland SecurityOfficial DHS account on XDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    Austin officials said an ICE officer shot and wounded a man in North Austin at about 12:56 p.m. on September 20. Rep. Greg Casar and Mayor Kirk Watson had already called for an independent investigation before the post appeared late that night.

    "Homeland Security Investigations, with the assistance of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, is leading the investigation into the officer involved shooting of an illegal alien from Venezuela, who illegally entered our country under the Biden administration and had a final order of removal, during a law enforcement operation today in Austin, TX. The illegal alien’s condition is stable, and he is in federal custody pending removal. This is a developing situation, and we will update the public when more information becomes available."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    DHS said HSI, assisted by the FBI, is leading the investigation into the shooting, described the man as an illegal alien from Venezuela with a final order of removal, and said he is in federal custody pending removal.

    After the statement

    The post did not name the man or say what led to the shooting. His attorney later disputed that he entered illegally, and NBC News reported that DHS did not immediately respond to a request for comment on her statements.

    DHS post on X about the Austin officer-involved shooting · U.S. Department of Homeland SecurityPost text
    Man shot by ICE moved from hospital to detention center 'with a bullet in his back,' lawyer tells CNN · CNNFull article: dispute over legal status; LULAC statement; attorney interview
    ICE officer shoots Venezuelan man delivering food in Austin, lawyer says · NBC NewsFull article: DHS statement; senior administration official; Casar letter
    Austin officials condemn ICE shooting of Venezuelan man, call for independent investigation · KXANParagraphs quoting Mayor Watson on ICE's credibility, the Travis County District Attorney statement, and Rep. Doggett
    ICE shooting in North Austin: Texas leaders reactStatements section: Travis County District Attorney, Mayor Watson, Rep. Casar

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's account of the shooting and its decision to have HSI lead the investigation, DHS itself states the account and assigns the inquiry to its own component. Its only qualification is that the situation is developing. Closest competing label: none; the post makes no concession.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  8. James TalaricoTexas state representative and Democratic nominee for U.S. Senate

    Before this statement

    A federal immigration officer shot Wilber Rafael Garces Perez in North Austin on Sunday, September 20. DHS said Homeland Security Investigations, with assistance from the FBI, was leading the investigation.

    "Previous incidents have shown that this agency cannot be trusted to report all the facts We need a full, independent investigation that includes the release of any and all available footage."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    James Talarico, the Democratic nominee for U.S. Senate in Texas, said in a statement on the Austin shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez that previous incidents have shown that "this agency" cannot be trusted to report all the facts. He called for a full, independent investigation that includes the release of any and all available footage.

    After the statement

    The San Antonio Current reported that Austin Mayor Kirk Watson and other Texas Democrats also called for an independent and transparent investigation.

    After Austin ICE shooting, officials demand body-camera footage and outside investigation · Austin American-StatesmanSection headed "James Talarico calls for independent investigation, sends prayers"
    Texas Democrats demand independent investigation of Austin ICE shootingParagraph beginning "U.S. Rep. James Talarico" and the quotation that follows

    Why this label?

    The case asks whether DHS should lead the investigation of the shooting. Talarico said previous incidents have shown that "this agency" cannot be trusted to report all the facts, and that the shooting needs a full, independent investigation with any available footage released. That calls for an investigation independent of the agency involved, so we labeled it Condemned.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  9. Austin American-StatesmanNewspaper editorial board, in a published editorial

    Before this statement

    The editorial recounts that DHS's first public acknowledgment came about 11:33 p.m. Sunday, roughly 11 hours after the shooting, and that Mayor Kirk Watson said he was "extremely unhappy."

    "DHS offered no account of why he was shot. That is not transparency. It is an effort to frame Garces Perez before providing the public with the facts. A full, independent investigation — alarmingly absent in other ICE-related shootings — is essential here. Yet the first DHS statement offers no such assurance. It says Homeland Security Investigations, an ICE component, is leading the investigation with help from the FBI. That is not the independent inquiry Austin residents need. The Texas Rangers must have a role. So must the Austin Police Department's Special Investigations Unit, which examines officer-involved shootings and ultimately answers to the residents of this city."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    In an editorial, the Austin American-Statesman’s editorial board wrote that DHS’s initial silence about why Garces Perez was shot "is not transparency" but "an effort to frame" him before releasing facts, and said a "full, independent investigation" was essential, but that DHS’s plan to have its own component, Homeland Security Investigations, lead the inquiry "is not the independent inquiry Austin residents need," and that the Texas Rangers and the Austin Police Department’s Special Investigations Unit "must have a role."

    After the statement

    The editorial also notes attorney Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch's dispute of DHS's account that Garces Perez entered the country illegally.

    ICE brought gunfire to Austin. It owes the public answers (Austin American-Statesman editorial) · Austin American-StatesmanFull editorial

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's decision to have its own component lead the investigation into the shooting, The editorial board directly characterizes DHS's silence as concealment rather than transparency and states that an HSI-led inquiry is not the independent investigation the situation requires. That is an institutional condemnation of DHS's handling, not merely a report of others' criticism.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  10. Mi Familia VotaNational civic-engagement organization, in a statement from its president and CEO, Hector Sanchez Barba

    Before this statement

    The statement followed the shooting and preceded confirmation of DHS's plan to have Homeland Security Investigations lead the inquiry.

    "What happened in Austin demands answers. Once again, a person has been shot during ICE's extreme immigration enforcement operations, and once again, a family and community are left in fear and with questions over what happened. There must be a full, independent and transparent investigation, including the release of all available footage and evidence. No federal agency should be allowed to police itself when someone is shot."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Mi Familia Vota's president and CEO, Hector Sanchez Barba, said in a statement that "what happened in Austin demands answers," described ICE as an "out-of-control rogue agency," and said "there must be a full, independent and transparent investigation" because "no federal agency should be allowed to police itself when someone is shot."

    After the statement

    Sanchez Barba separately said Texans "should not have to fear that an encounter with federal immigration agents may mean life or death."

    Mi Familia Vota Demands Independent Investigation Into Austin ICE Shooting (Texas Border Business)Paragraphs quoting Mi Familia Vota President and CEO Hector Sanchez Barba

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's decision to have its own component lead the investigation into the shooting, Mi Familia Vota expressly rejects DHS-led self-investigation, calling it improper for a federal agency to "police itself," and characterizes ICE's broader conduct as that of an "out-of-control rogue agency." That is a direct condemnation, not merely a request or a disputed description.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  11. Anna Paulina LunaU.S. Representative for Florida's 13th congressional district, on her official X account and in a Fox News interview

    Before this statement

    Luna's remarks followed the shooting and DHS's account describing Garces Perez as an "illegal alien" with a final removal order.

    "This unfortunate situation was completely avoidable. In many sanctuary cities there is a refusal to work with ICE, which, if you are concerned for residents safety, don't you think you should have LEO interfacing? I will continue to obviously ensure that there is oversight and accountability – I sit on that committee – and I'm sure this will be brought up as soon as we return from the elections. But, again, ICE does go after – a majority of the time – some of the worst of the worst, and so we just don't know enough facts to really determine what really happened right here."
    Mixed or conditional

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Rep. Anna Paulina Luna (R-Fla.) posted on X that the situation was "completely avoidable" because sanctuary cities refuse to work with ICE. In a separate Fox News interview the same day, she said she would "continue to obviously ensure that there is oversight and accountability" as a member of a relevant committee, while also saying ICE "does go after... some of the worst of the worst" and that "we just don't know enough facts to really determine what really happened right here."

    After the statement

    Her office did not address the specific facts of the Austin shooting beyond these remarks in the cited source.

    Post by Anna Paulina Luna (@RepLuna) on X, September 21, 2026Complete post 2102015983841923143, 7:43 AM CDT (12:43:58 UTC)
    Anna Paulina Luna Reacts To ICE Shooting Of Venezuelan National (The Floridian)Section "Rep. Luna Says She Will Ensure There Is Oversight," quoting her Fox News interview

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's decision to have its own component lead the investigation into the shooting, Luna combines an argument that sanctuary-city policy, not ICE conduct, caused the shooting with a statement that she will personally ensure oversight and that too few facts are known to judge what happened. Those are materially different positions — excusing ICE's role while also reserving judgment and committing to accountability — which fits “Mixed or conditional”. The closest competing label, “Defended or excused”, loses because she does not conclude the shooting itself was justified; “Challenged the characterization” loses because she does not dispute a specific DHS description.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  12. Jasmine CrockettU.S. Representative for Texas's 30th congressional district, on her official X account

    Before this statement

    Crockett posted the evening of the shooting, before DHS's first public statement on the incident.

    "Just two months after ICE murdered Lorenzo Salgado Araujo, these unqualified ICE agents shot another man in Texas. This rogue agency continues to show no regard for human life, shooting people in the middle of the street and getting away with it. We will not look the other way. We deserve a full, independent, and transparent investigation."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    On X, Rep. Jasmine Crockett (D-Texas) linked the shooting of Garces Perez to the July fatal ICE shooting of Lorenzo Salgado Araujo, called ICE a "rogue agency" that "continues to show no regard for human life," and said "we will not look the other way" and "we deserve a full, independent, and transparent investigation."

    After the statement

    Salgado Araujo is the subject of a separate case of ours concerning a July 7, 2026 ICE shooting in a different Texas incident.

    Post by Jasmine Crockett (@RepJasmine) on X, September 21, 2026Complete post 2101837120792859021, 8:53 PM CDT Sept 20 / 12:53 AM UTC Sept 21 (00:53:14 UTC); all three paragraphs

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's decision to have its own component lead the investigation into the shooting, Crockett directly denounces ICE as a "rogue agency" showing "no regard for human life" and rejects an ICE-led inquiry by demanding an independent one. Closest competing label: “Challenged the characterization” loses because she condemns ICE's conduct broadly, not merely a description of this incident.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  13. League of United Latin American CitizensStatement by LULAC national president Roman Palomares

    Before this statement

    LULAC responded to the shooting by calling on Congress to establish independent oversight of immigration enforcement and to guarantee that any DHS or ICE official who violates a person's constitutional rights is investigated and prosecuted.

    "No agency should be the sole judge of its own conduct"
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    LULAC's national president said no agency should be the sole judge of its own conduct and called on Congress to establish independent oversight of immigration enforcement.

    After the statement

    At Monday's news conference, LULAC leaders urged Congress to create an independent body outside DHS, ICE and the Justice Department to investigate use-of-force incidents, according to the Austin American-Statesman.

    Man shot by ICE moved from hospital to detention center 'with a bullet in his back,' lawyer tells CNN · CNNFull article: dispute over legal status; LULAC statement; attorney interview
    Live updates: Attorney says man shot by ICE mistook unmarked vehicle for another driverEntries for 12:48 p.m. and 1:45 p.m. on September 21

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS leading the investigation of its own agent's shooting, LULAC states a principle against self-investigation and calls for independent oversight. Closest competing label: “Mixed or conditional” loses because the principle is stated without qualification.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  14. Chip RoyU.S. Representative from Texas (R), in a post on X

    Before this statement

    Roy posted the evening of the shooting, after Rep. Greg Casar had called for an independent investigation. His post quotes another user's post saying Casar compares immigration enforcement to “war”.

    "We were told the shooter is a foreign national, an illegal alien from Venezuela with a final order of removal. The war is the one being waged against Americans through mass legal & illegal immigration."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    In a post on X, Rep. Chip Roy wrote that “we were told” the shooter is a foreign national, an illegal alien from Venezuela with a final order of removal, and that the war is the one being waged against Americans through mass legal and illegal immigration.

    After the statement

    Fox News reported that authorities had not publicly disclosed information indicating the man fired a weapon; DHS's post described an “officer involved shooting” of the man. Fox News described Roy's reaction as sharply different from the Democrats' calls for a bodycam release and an independent investigation.

    Rep. Chip Roy's post on X about the Austin shooting · Chip RoyPost text
    ICE shooting rocks Austin as Democrat demands bodycam video, independent probe · Fox NewsParagraphs on Rep. Chip Roy and on authorities not disclosing that the man fired a weapon
    DHS post on X about the Austin officer-involved shooting · U.S. Department of Homeland SecurityPost text

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's public account of the shooting, Roy repeats DHS's description of the man's status as the account he was given and frames the episode as part of a wider conflict over immigration; he does not question it or call for an independent investigation. Borderline: the post is attributed (“We were told”), quotes another user's post about Rep. Casar, and calls the Venezuelan man “the shooter”. Closest competing label: “Challenged the characterization” loses because he adopts, rather than disputes, DHS's description.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  15. Greg CasarU.S. Representative (D-TX 35), in a letter to DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin and Acting ICE Director David Venturella

    Before this statement

    An ICE officer shot and wounded a man in Austin on September 20. Casar addressed the letter to DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin and Acting ICE Director David Venturella the same day.

    "As a result, any narrative from DHS regarding this shooting must be viewed with deep skepticism and an independent investigation must be conducted."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Casar wrote that DHS has repeatedly lied about the facts after violent encounters involving agents and blamed victims, and that any DHS narrative about the Austin shooting must be viewed with deep skepticism and an independent investigation conducted.

    After the statement

    The letter also demands that the agent be suspended and remain in Austin, that ICE release complete and unedited footage and preserve evidence, and that DHS brief Congress by Monday, September 28.

    Letter from Rep. Greg Casar to DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin and Acting ICE Director David Venturella · Greg CasarPage 2, paragraph beginning "ICE and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents have shot"
    ICE officer shoots Venezuelan man delivering food in Austin, lawyer says · NBC NewsFull article: DHS statement; senior administration official; Casar letter
    RELEASE: Congressman Casar Demands Immediate, Independent Investigation Into ICE Shooting in Austin · Greg CasarPress release text

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's handling of the shooting, including its account and the question of who investigates, Casar expressly rejects the reliability of any DHS narrative and demands an independent inquiry. Closest competing label: “Challenged the characterization” loses because he criticizes DHS's conduct and credibility, not one description.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  16. Kirk WatsonMayor of Austin, in a statement posted on X and FacebookDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    Watson wrote after an ICE officer shot and wounded a man in North Austin. He began by saying he was “very angry and extremely disappointed” and not surprised.

    "With the rogue nature of ICE and the chaos we’re seeing fomented by ICE, there’s no reason to be surprised. Austinites have a right to know what happened and they have a right to feel safe in their community. Though APD was not involved in the shooting, I believe that there needs to be an investigation that APD assures is clear-eyed, as complete as possible, and independent."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    Watson said that, given the rogue nature of ICE and the chaos he says ICE is fomenting, there is no reason to be surprised, that Austinites have a right to know what happened, and that, although Austin police were not involved, there needs to be an investigation that APD assures is clear-eyed, as complete as possible, and independent.

    After the statement

    He said Austin police's Special Investigation Unit was on scene and that Chief Lisa Davis had asked the Texas Rangers to assist. At a news conference, he said the credibility of ICE conducting an investigation by itself and excluding others would not be appropriate.

    Mayor Kirk Watson's post on X on the ICE shooting in Austin · Kirk WatsonPost text
    Mayor Kirk Watson's Facebook statement on the ICE shooting in Austin · Kirk WatsonPost text
    ICE shooting in North Austin: Texas leaders reactStatements section: Travis County District Attorney, Mayor Watson, Rep. Casar
    Austin officials condemn ICE shooting of Venezuelan man, call for independent investigation · KXANParagraphs quoting Mayor Watson on ICE's credibility, the Travis County District Attorney statement, and Rep. Doggett
    ICE agent shoots and wounds man in Austin, Texas, sparking demands for full investigation · CBS NewsFull article: investigation lead; attorney quotes; Watson remarks

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's decision to have its own component lead the investigation, Watson criticizes ICE's conduct and insists on an investigation that Austin police can assure is independent; in remarks to reporters he said an ICE-only investigation would not be appropriate. Closest competing label: “Mixed or conditional” loses because the request is a rejection of ICE-only control, not a conditional acceptance.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement
  17. Henry CuellarU.S. Representative for Texas's 28th congressional district and Ranking Member, House Appropriations Subcommittee on Homeland Security, on his official X account

    Before this statement

    Cuellar posted the evening of the shooting, linking a New York Times report on the incident.

    "I am very concerned about reports of an ICE-involved shooting in Austin, Texas. There needs to be a thorough and independent investigation into this incident. As Ranking Member of the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Homeland Security, I have made it a priority to ensure transparency within DHS. I look forward to receiving answers in a timely manner on this situation."
    Condemned

    Case context: Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?

    Full statement and sources

    On X, Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-Texas) said he was "very concerned" about the shooting, called for "a thorough and independent investigation," and, citing his role as Ranking Member of the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Homeland Security, said he has made DHS transparency a priority.

    After the statement

    Cuellar represents a South Texas border district and has taken more moderate positions on immigration enforcement than some Democratic colleagues.

    Post by Henry Cuellar (@RepCuellar) on X, September 20, 2026Complete post 2101807619191050652, 5:56 PM CDT (22:56:00 UTC); all paragraphs

    Why this label?

    Relative to DHS's decision to have its own component lead the investigation into the shooting, Cuellar calls for an investigation that is independent of DHS rather than accepting DHS's own component leading it, and frames DHS transparency as something he must press for. This tracks the case's existing convention for measured calls against self-investigation (see LULAC's statement, similarly recorded as condemns), even though Cuellar's tone does not criticize ICE's credibility directly.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

    Read statementLink to this statement

Sources

(47)

Original post

DHS post on X about the Austin officer-involved shooting

DHS post on X about the Austin officer-involved shooting (opens in a new tab) · U.S. Department of Homeland SecurityPost text

Excerpt

"Homeland Security Investigations, with the assistance of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, is leading the investigation"

About this source

Official DHS account on X, posted at 11:33 p.m. Central on September 20, 2026. The post does not name the man or say what led to the shooting.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Austin police say DHS has not shared evidence in ICE shooting investigation

Austin police say DHS has not shared evidence in ICE shooting investigation (opens in a new tab) · Austin American-StatesmanAPD statement supplied Wednesday, October 7; paragraphs listing requested reports and recordings and describing continued independent investigation.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: APD statement supplied Wednesday, October 7; paragraphs listing requested reports and recordings and describing continued independent investigation.

About this source

The American-Statesman quotes a direct APD statement that requested federal material had not arrived. The statement concerns access to evidence and the ongoing local investigation; it does not resolve the justification for the shooting.

Author
Tony Plohetski
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Austin Council Member calls for ICE accountability, independent investigation

Austin Council Member calls for ICE accountability, independent investigation (opens in a new tab) · CBS AustinFuentes quotation beginning "ICE cannot investigate itself," in the second half of the article
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Fuentes quotation beginning "ICE cannot investigate itself," in the second half of the article

Excerpt

"“ICE cannot investigate itself, and so it’s important that we have our local law enforcement agency involved in that investigation," she said."

About this source

CBS Austin report on Council Member Fuentes's remarks after the September 20 ICE shooting. It quotes her call for an independent investigation with local law enforcement involved and her call on Congress to stop funding ICE.

Author
Anika Engler
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Texas Democrats demand independent investigation of Austin ICE shooting

Texas Democrats demand independent investigation of Austin ICE shooting (opens in a new tab)Paragraph beginning "U.S. Rep. James Talarico" and the quotation that follows
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Paragraph beginning "U.S. Rep. James Talarico" and the quotation that follows

Excerpt

"“Previous incidents have shown that this agency cannot be trusted to report all the facts,” Talarico said. “We need a full, independent investigation that includes the release of any and all available footage."

About this source

San Antonio Current report on Texas Democrats' reactions to the shooting. It says Talarico released a statement calling for an independent investigation and that Austin Mayor Kirk Watson joined that call.

Author
Michael Karlis
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

After Austin ICE shooting, officials demand body-camera footage and outside investigation

After Austin ICE shooting, officials demand body-camera footage and outside investigation (opens in a new tab) · Austin American-StatesmanSection headed "James Talarico calls for independent investigation, sends prayers"
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Section headed "James Talarico calls for independent investigation, sends prayers"

Excerpt

"“Previous incidents have shown that this agency cannot be trusted to report all the facts,” Talarico said. “We need a full, independent investigation that includes the release of any and all available footage."

About this source

Austin American-Statesman report published the day after the shooting, collecting reactions from elected officials and advocacy groups. Its section on Talarico quotes his call for an independent investigation.

Author
Julianna Duennes Russ
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Official statement

Travis County District Attorney’s Office Releases Statement on Reported ICE Agent Shooting of a Community Member

Travis County District Attorney’s Office Releases Statement on Reported ICE Agent Shooting of a Community Member (opens in a new tab)Entire release, dated September 20, 2026
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Entire release, dated September 20, 2026

Excerpt

"It is critical that all the facts come to light and that an independent investigation be completed. We are requesting that the Austin Police Department and our office, the Travis County District Attorney, be co-equal partners in the investigation."

About this source

Official statement from the Travis County District Attorney's Office, issued the day of the shooting. It asks for an independent investigation and for federal cooperation in giving local investigators access to the evidence.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

A Venezuelan man was shot by ICE in Austin while doing deliveries. Here’s what we know

A Venezuelan man was shot by ICE in Austin while doing deliveries. Here’s what we know (opens in a new tab) · CNNSection "Local district attorney demands independent investigation" (article updated September 24, 2026)
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Section "Local district attorney demands independent investigation" (article updated September 24, 2026)

Excerpt

"So far, the information has been flowing from the Austin Police Department to federal law enforcement officials, and as we sit here today, three days away from this shooting, it is incredibly important that the information start to flow both ways"

About this source

CNN's running account of the shooting, first published September 22, 2026 and updated September 24. The section on the district attorney reports what Garza told CNN on September 23 about evidence sharing between federal and local investigators.

Author
Taylor Romine, Priscilla Alvarez and Andy Rose
Published
Accessed

Official statement

Travis County District Attorney's Office sends letter to DHS and ICE to halt removal proceedings against Wilbur Rafael Garces Perez

Travis County District Attorney's Office sends letter to DHS and ICE to halt removal proceedings against Wilbur Rafael Garces Perez (opens in a new tab)Entire official release and linked 9.22.26 TCDA Letter
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Entire official release and linked 9.22.26 TCDA Letter

Excerpt

"Mr. Garces Perez's ability to participate as a material witness will be severely hindered if he is removed from the United States."

About this source

The Travis County District Attorney's Office said it asked DHS and ICE to halt removal proceedings against Garces Perez while the local investigation continues. The request seeks to preserve his ability to participate as a material witness; it does not represent a decision by DHS, ICE, or a court.

Author
Travis County District Attorney's Office
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Official statement

Castro Statement on Wilber Rafael Garces Perez

Castro Statement on Wilber Rafael Garces Perez (opens in a new tab) · Joaquin CastroFinal paragraph beginning 'ICE has shot and killed people before'
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Final paragraph beginning 'ICE has shot and killed people before'

Excerpt

"There must be an independent investigation, and the ICE officers who shot Wilber in the back should be held accountable."

About this source

Official statement from Joaquin Castro calling for an independent investigation into the ICE shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez.

Author
Office of Congressman Joaquin Castro
Published
Accessed

Official statement

Casar reports on Garces Perez after a detention visit and calls for medical release

Casar reports on Garces Perez after a detention visit and calls for medical release (opens in a new tab) · Greg CasarSeptember 23, 2026 dateline; opening visit description; Casar quotation; paragraphs calling for an investigation, footage release, and DHS briefing.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: September 23, 2026 dateline; opening visit description; Casar quotation; paragraphs calling for an investigation, footage release, and DHS briefing.

About this source

Official release from Representative Greg Casar's office. It reports on his detention visit with Wilber Rafael Garces Perez and states Casar's requests for medical release, body- and dash-camera footage, and a transparent investigation. Medical and detention-condition assertions are attributed to Casar and Garces Perez; the release is not an independent investigation.

Author
Office of Representative Greg Casar
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Austin lawmakers question ICE body-camera use after shooting of Wilber Garces Perez

Austin lawmakers question ICE body-camera use after shooting of Wilber Garces Perez (opens in a new tab) · KXANPassages quoting Rep. Lloyd Doggett about ICE's public account and any available body-camera footage; KXAN's report says ICE had not answered its question about whether agents wore cameras.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Passages quoting Rep. Lloyd Doggett about ICE's public account and any available body-camera footage; KXAN's report says ICE had not answered its question about whether agents wore cameras.

Excerpt

"“We don’t know enough because ICE as usual is not providing the facts.”"

About this source

KXAN's September 23 report attributes these remarks to U.S. Rep. Lloyd Doggett. It says KXAN had asked ICE whether the agents involved wore body-worn cameras and had not received a response as of publication; the report does not establish whether a camera was worn or activated.

Author
Sydney Gray
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Austin American-Statesman: Protesters rally at Texas Capitol over Garces Perez shooting

Austin American-Statesman: Protesters rally at Texas Capitol over Garces Perez shooting (opens in a new tab)Full article, including quotes from Jesse Valdelamar, Selena Jurado and Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Full article, including quotes from Jesse Valdelamar, Selena Jurado and Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch.

Excerpt

"Not one agency that fills the back of my people with bullets can ever be reformed."

About this source

The Austin American-Statesman's report on a roughly 175-person protest at the Texas Capitol on September 21, organized by La Frontera Unidad, demanding Garces Perez's release, prosecution of the officer who shot him, and an independent investigation. It also reports a new statement from attorney Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch that Garces Perez's condition worsened in ICE custody.

Author
Lily Kepner, Dante Motley
Published
Accessed

Original post

Rep. Adam Smith calls for a full investigation of the Garces Perez shooting

Rep. Adam Smith calls for a full investigation of the Garces Perez shooting (opens in a new tab) · Adam SmithFull X post, published September 21, 2026 at 2:00 p.m. UTC

Excerpt

"We need a full investigation into the shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez and answers before this rogue police force continues to target more people in our country's streets."

About this source

In a direct post, Rep. Adam Smith called for a full investigation and characterized ICE as violently targeting people without transparency or accountability. This is Smith’s assessment; the post does not independently establish the broader characterization.

Author
Adam Smith
Published
Accessed

Original post

Rep. James Walkinshaw calls for an independent investigation and body-camera footage

Rep. James Walkinshaw calls for an independent investigation and body-camera footage (opens in a new tab) · James WalkinshawFull X post, published September 21, 2026 at 5:45 p.m. UTC

Excerpt

"We need a full, independent investigation and the body cam footage."

About this source

In a direct post, Rep. James Walkinshaw said Garces Perez was shot while delivering for DoorDash, warned that ICE might deport him before a full public account, and called for an independent investigation and release of body-camera footage. The post is Walkinshaw’s statement and does not independently establish the underlying facts.

Author
James Walkinshaw
Published
Accessed

Original post

Rep. Judy Chu says the violence against Garces Perez must end

Rep. Judy Chu says the violence against Garces Perez must end (opens in a new tab) · Judy ChuFull X post, published September 21, 2026 at 9:12 p.m. UTC

Excerpt

"I have joined @RepCasar's letter demanding an independent investigation. This violence must end."

About this source

In a direct post, Rep. Judy Chu said she joined Rep. Greg Casar’s letter demanding an independent investigation and called for the violence to end. Her statements about Garces Perez’s detention and medical condition are attributed to her and are not treated as independently verified by this source.

Author
Judy Chu
Published
Accessed

Original post

Sen. Alex Padilla calls for an independent investigation of the Garces Perez shooting

Sen. Alex Padilla calls for an independent investigation of the Garces Perez shooting (opens in a new tab) · Alex PadillaFull X post, published September 21, 2026 at 9:18 p.m. UTC

Excerpt

"ICE can’t keep shooting people in our communities without any consequences."

About this source

In a direct post, Sen. Alex Padilla called for an independent and transparent investigation into the shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez and said it should not have happened.

Author
Alex Padilla
Published
Accessed

Original post

Rep. Joaquin Castro Instagram update on Wilber Rafael Garcés Pérez’s medical condition

Rep. Joaquin Castro Instagram update on Wilber Rafael Garcés Pérez’s medical condition (opens in a new tab) · Joaquin CastroVerified @joaquincastrotx reel caption, beginning “Update on the condition of Wilber Rafael Garcés Pérez”
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Verified @joaquincastrotx reel caption, beginning “Update on the condition of Wilber Rafael Garcés Pérez”

Excerpt

"He’s being taken to the hospital. He is in tremendous pain."

About this source

In a verified public Instagram reel, Rep. Joaquin Castro said Garcés Pérez was being taken to a hospital from the South Texas ICE Processing Center, had a bullet still inside his left side, and could not move the left side of his body. The post is Castro’s account of Pérez’s reported condition; it is not an independent medical-provider or DHS confirmation.

Author
Joaquin Castro
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Texas Tribune reports Wilber Garcés Pérez’s phone account after Austin ICE shooting

Texas Tribune reports Wilber Garcés Pérez’s phone account after Austin ICE shooting (opens in a new tab)Opening paragraphs describing the press conference, especially the paragraphs beginning “Garces Perez, who called into the news conference,” and “The Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond.”
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Opening paragraphs describing the press conference, especially the paragraphs beginning “Garces Perez, who called into the news conference,” and “The Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond.”

Excerpt

"I’m not doing very well. I have not received the medical attention that I require."

About this source

The Texas Tribune reports Garcés Pérez’s September 21 telephone remarks from ICE detention and says the Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to a request for comment on his shooting account and medical-care complaint.

Author
Uriel J. García, Alex Nguyen and Zach Leggio
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Univision reports Wilber Garcés Pérez’s phone account from ICE detention

Univision reports Wilber Garcés Pérez’s phone account from ICE detention (opens in a new tab)Paragraphs beginning “Desde un centro de procesamiento…,” “Estoy un poco mal…,” “Un día antes…,” and section “De la cama del hospital al piso de un centro de detención.”
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Paragraphs beginning “Desde un centro de procesamiento…,” “Estoy un poco mal…,” “Un día antes…,” and section “De la cama del hospital al piso de un centro de detención.”

Excerpt

"Estoy un poco mal, tengo la bala ahí adentro todavía."

About this source

Univision reports a September 21 telephone statement by Wilber Garcés Pérez from ICE detention. It attributes to him an account of his medical care and the moments before the shooting; the report does not independently establish those allegations.

Author
N+ Univision
Published
Accessed

Official statement

Rep. Joaquin Castro: “The Austin ICE shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez”

Rep. Joaquin Castro: “The Austin ICE shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez” (opens in a new tab) · Joaquin CastroOpening description beneath the embedded video.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Opening description beneath the embedded video.

Excerpt

"Under Trump, ICE has become rogue, lawless, and deadly."

About this source

An official House page hosting Castro’s video about the Austin shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez. The page says Castro is calling for an independent investigation, immediate medical care, and for Perez to remain in Texas; it also contains Castro’s attributed account of Perez’s detention and medical treatment. Embedded video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DhFBycT6Ups.

Author
Rep. Joaquin Castro
Published
Accessed

Official statement

ICE brought gunfire to Austin. It owes the public answers (Austin American-Statesman editorial)

ICE brought gunfire to Austin. It owes the public answers (Austin American-Statesman editorial) (opens in a new tab) · Austin American-StatesmanFull editorial
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Full editorial

Excerpt

"DHS offered no account of why he was shot. That is not transparency. It is an effort to frame Garces Perez before providing the public with the facts."

About this source

The Austin American-Statesman's editorial. It reports that DHS's first public acknowledgment came about 11 hours after the shooting, that Mayor Kirk Watson said he was 'extremely unhappy,' and that attorney Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch disputed DHS's account of Garces Perez's immigration status.

Author
Austin American-Statesman Editorial Board
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Mi Familia Vota Demands Independent Investigation Into Austin ICE Shooting (Texas Border Business)

Mi Familia Vota Demands Independent Investigation Into Austin ICE Shooting (Texas Border Business) (opens in a new tab)Paragraphs quoting Mi Familia Vota President and CEO Hector Sanchez Barba
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Paragraphs quoting Mi Familia Vota President and CEO Hector Sanchez Barba

Excerpt

"What happened in Austin demands answers."

About this source

Texas Border Business's report carrying a statement from Mi Familia Vota's president and CEO Hector Sanchez Barba responding to the shooting of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez.

Author
Texas Border Business
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Anna Paulina Luna Reacts To ICE Shooting Of Venezuelan National (The Floridian)

Anna Paulina Luna Reacts To ICE Shooting Of Venezuelan National (The Floridian) (opens in a new tab)Section "Rep. Luna Says She Will Ensure There Is Oversight," quoting her Fox News interview
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Section "Rep. Luna Says She Will Ensure There Is Oversight," quoting her Fox News interview

Excerpt

"we just don't know enough facts to really determine what really happened right here."

About this source

The Floridian's report, which also embeds Luna's X post and reports that she made these further remarks in a Fox News interview.

Author
The Floridian
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Post by Anna Paulina Luna (@RepLuna) on X, September 21, 2026

Post by Anna Paulina Luna (@RepLuna) on X, September 21, 2026 (opens in a new tab)Complete post 2102015983841923143, 7:43 AM CDT (12:43:58 UTC)

Excerpt

"This unfortunate situation was completely avoidable."

About this source

Luna's post on her official X account (@RepLuna). The post is timestamped 12:43:58 UTC.

Author
Anna Paulina Luna (@RepLuna)
Published
Accessed

Original post

Post by Henry Cuellar (@RepCuellar) on X, September 20, 2026

Post by Henry Cuellar (@RepCuellar) on X, September 20, 2026 (opens in a new tab)Complete post 2101807619191050652, 5:56 PM CDT (22:56:00 UTC); all paragraphs

Excerpt

"There needs to be a thorough and independent investigation into this incident."

About this source

Cuellar's post on his official X account (@RepCuellar), linking a New York Times report. The post is timestamped 22:56:00 UTC.

Author
Henry Cuellar (@RepCuellar)
Published
Accessed

Original post

Post by Jasmine Crockett (@RepJasmine) on X, September 21, 2026

Post by Jasmine Crockett (@RepJasmine) on X, September 21, 2026 (opens in a new tab)Complete post 2101837120792859021, 8:53 PM CDT Sept 20 / 12:53 AM UTC Sept 21 (00:53:14 UTC); all three paragraphs

Excerpt

"This rogue agency continues to show no regard for human life, shooting people in the middle of the street and getting away with it."

About this source

Crockett's post on her official X account (@RepJasmine). The post is timestamped 00:53:14 UTC. We did not save an archive copy of the post.

Author
Jasmine Crockett (@RepJasmine)
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Man shot by ICE agents in Austin gives phone interview during press conference

Man shot by ICE agents in Austin gives phone interview during press conference (opens in a new tab)Paragraph beginning “Davis and Austin Mayor Kirk Watson said”
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Paragraph beginning “Davis and Austin Mayor Kirk Watson said”

Excerpt

"APD’s Special Investigations Unit and the Texas Rangers will take part in the shooting investigation."

About this source

Local report on a September 21 press conference and Chief Lisa Davis's video statement. It reports that the Austin Police Department’s Special Investigations Unit and the Texas Rangers will take part in the investigation, and that Davis asked witnesses to provide evidence.

Published
Accessed

Official statement

Gina Hinojosa statement calling for medical attention for Wilber Rafael Garces Perez

Gina Hinojosa statement calling for medical attention for Wilber Rafael Garces Perez (opens in a new tab)Full statement
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Full statement

Excerpt

"Right now, a man is being held with a bullet lodged in his body at a federal facility in Pearsall, Texas. He needs urgent medical attention."

About this source

Campaign statement from Texas House member Gina Hinojosa about Garces Perez's reported detention after the Austin shooting. It calls for urgent medical attention and criticizes the reported handling by ICE; it does not itself establish the medical or detention facts.

Published
Accessed

Original post

Austin Police Chief Lisa Davis video message about the September 20 ICE incident

Austin Police Chief Lisa Davis video message about the September 20 ICE incident (opens in a new tab)Post text and attached 3:01 video

Excerpt

"Message from Chief Davis regarding Sunday, Sept. 20th ICE Incident"

About this source

Official video statement from the Austin Police Department about the September 20, 2026 ICE shooting incident. The department's linked video addresses the ongoing investigation and requests public cooperation.

Published
Accessed

Archived source

Docket in Garces Perez v. Thompson, No. 5:26-cv-06038 (W.D. Tex.)

Docket in Garces Perez v. Thompson, No. 5:26-cv-06038 (W.D. Tex.) (opens in a new tab)Docket entries 1 and 2, entered September 21, 2026
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Docket entries 1 and 2, entered September 21, 2026

Excerpt

"Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus ... filed by Wilber Rafael Garces Perez; MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order AND PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ORDERING RELEASE AND A STAY OF REMOVAL PENDING FINAL JUDGMENT."

About this source

Public docket mirror for Garces Perez v. Thompson, No. 5:26-cv-06038 in the Western District of Texas. It records the filing of a habeas petition and an emergency motion seeking release and a stay of removal; the underlying filings are not publicly available in the mirror, so this source does not establish their factual allegations or merits.

Accessed

Official statement

RELEASE: Congressman Casar Demands Immediate, Independent Investigation Into ICE Shooting in Austin

RELEASE: Congressman Casar Demands Immediate, Independent Investigation Into ICE Shooting in Austin (opens in a new tab) · Greg CasarPress release text
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Press release text

About this source

Casar's press release announcing the September 20, 2026 letter to DHS and ICE. Published 7:23 p.m. Eastern on September 20.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

ICE shooting rocks Austin as Democrat demands bodycam video, independent probe

ICE shooting rocks Austin as Democrat demands bodycam video, independent probe (opens in a new tab) · Fox NewsParagraphs on Rep. Chip Roy and on authorities not disclosing that the man fired a weapon
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Paragraphs on Rep. Chip Roy and on authorities not disclosing that the man fired a weapon

About this source

Fox News report, syndicated on Yahoo, that describes Rep. Roy's post and notes that authorities had not publicly disclosed information indicating the man fired a weapon.

Published
Accessed

Original post

Rep. Chip Roy's post on X about the Austin shooting

Rep. Chip Roy's post on X about the Austin shooting (opens in a new tab) · Chip RoyPost text

Excerpt

"We were told the shooter is a foreign national, an illegal alien from Venezuela with a final order of removal."

About this source

Rep. Roy's post on X, which quotes another user's post about Rep. Casar's remarks. The post calls the Venezuelan man “the shooter”; his own attribution is “We were told.”

Published
Accessed

Original post

Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch's post on X about the man's status

Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch's post on X about the man's status (opens in a new tab) · Kate Lincoln-GoldfinchPost text

Excerpt

"Wilber entered legally and has a valid work permit."

About this source

The man's attorney's post on X, in which she states his entry and work-permit status and calls for his release. The post is no longer available on X; the Internet Archive holds a copy that shows its full text. An Austin PBS Austin InSight segment aired September 24, 2026, which introduces her, carries the same account: that he entered through CBP One in 2024 and had a work permit.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)
Text of the X post by Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch (@AttorneyKateLG) of Sept. 21, 2026, quoting a post by Rep. Chip Roy (opens in a new tab)
Source image

Kate Lincoln-Goldfinch's X post of Sept. 21, 2026, no longer on X, as saved by the Internet Archive.

Original post

Mayor Kirk Watson's post on X on the ICE shooting in Austin

Mayor Kirk Watson's post on X on the ICE shooting in Austin (opens in a new tab) · Kirk WatsonPost text

Excerpt

"there needs to be an investigation that APD assures is clear-eyed, as complete as possible, and independent"

About this source

Mayor Watson's own post on X, the same statement he posted to Facebook the day of the shooting.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Who Is Wilber Rafael Garces Perez? DoorDash Worker Shot by ICE in Austin

Who Is Wilber Rafael Garces Perez? DoorDash Worker Shot by ICE in Austin (opens in a new tab) · NewsweekParagraphs quoting the attorney's X posts and DHS's statement
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Paragraphs quoting the attorney's X posts and DHS's statement

About this source

Newsweek report quoting the attorney's posts on X and the DHS spokesperson's statement.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Live updates: Attorney says man shot by ICE mistook unmarked vehicle for another driver

Live updates: Attorney says man shot by ICE mistook unmarked vehicle for another driver (opens in a new tab)Entries for 12:48 p.m. and 1:45 p.m. on September 21
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Entries for 12:48 p.m. and 1:45 p.m. on September 21

About this source

Austin American-Statesman live coverage of Monday's news conference with Rep. Doggett, Rep. Casar, LULAC and the man's attorney.

Author
Austin American-Statesman
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

ICE officer shoots Venezuelan man delivering food in Austin, lawyer says

ICE officer shoots Venezuelan man delivering food in Austin, lawyer says (opens in a new tab) · NBC NewsFull article: DHS statement; senior administration official; Casar letter
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Full article: DHS statement; senior administration official; Casar letter

About this source

NBC News report on DHS's statement, the attorney's account, and a senior administration official's statement that the man had no criminal history beyond being in the country illegally.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

ICE agent shoots and wounds man in Austin, Texas, sparking demands for full investigation

ICE agent shoots and wounds man in Austin, Texas, sparking demands for full investigation (opens in a new tab) · CBS NewsFull article: investigation lead; attorney quotes; Watson remarks
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Full article: investigation lead; attorney quotes; Watson remarks

About this source

CBS News/AP report noting that HSI will lead the investigation with FBI assistance and quoting Mayor Watson on ICE's credibility to investigate.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Man shot by ICE moved from hospital to detention center 'with a bullet in his back,' lawyer tells CNN

Man shot by ICE moved from hospital to detention center 'with a bullet in his back,' lawyer tells CNN (opens in a new tab) · CNNFull article: dispute over legal status; LULAC statement; attorney interview
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Full article: dispute over legal status; LULAC statement; attorney interview

About this source

CNN report on the shooting, DHS's statement, the attorney's account, local officials' calls for an independent investigation, and LULAC's statement.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Austin officials condemn ICE shooting of Venezuelan man, call for independent investigation

Austin officials condemn ICE shooting of Venezuelan man, call for independent investigation (opens in a new tab) · KXANParagraphs quoting Mayor Watson on ICE's credibility, the Travis County District Attorney statement, and Rep. Doggett
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Paragraphs quoting Mayor Watson on ICE's credibility, the Travis County District Attorney statement, and Rep. Doggett

About this source

Local report quoting Mayor Watson's news conference remarks and the District Attorney's statement. It notes the DHS post did not name the man.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

ICE shooting in North Austin: Texas leaders react

ICE shooting in North Austin: Texas leaders react (opens in a new tab)Statements section: Travis County District Attorney, Mayor Watson, Rep. Casar
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Statements section: Travis County District Attorney, Mayor Watson, Rep. Casar

About this source

Roundup that reproduces the full text of statements from Mayor Watson, the Travis County District Attorney, Rep. Casar and others on the day of the shooting.

Author
FOX 7 Austin
Published
Accessed

Original post

Mayor Kirk Watson's Facebook statement on the ICE shooting in Austin

Mayor Kirk Watson's Facebook statement on the ICE shooting in Austin (opens in a new tab) · Kirk WatsonPost text
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Post text

Excerpt

"there needs to be an investigation that APD assures is clear-eyed, as complete as possible, and independent"

About this source

Mayor Watson's own statement posted the day of the shooting. The public page shows only the opening lines without sign-in; the full text is reproduced verbatim in FOX 7 Austin's roundup of official reactions.

Published
Accessed

Official statement

Doggett Reacts to Today's ICE Shooting in the District He Represents in Austin

Doggett Reacts to Today's ICE Shooting in the District He Represents in Austin (opens in a new tab) · Lloyd DoggettFull statement
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Full statement

About this source

Rep. Lloyd Doggett's written statement on the day of the shooting.

Published
Accessed

Original video

FOX 7 Austin broadcast of the September 21 news conference on the Austin ICE shooting (Casar remarks)

FOX 7 Austin broadcast of the September 21 news conference on the Austin ICE shooting (Casar remarks) (opens in a new tab)Rep. Greg Casar remarks, 06:22-07:05 (on-screen label: Representative Greg Casar, D, Texas, District 35)

Rep. Greg Casar speaks about an ICE shooting in Austin at a news conference, in FOX 7 Austin video, Sept. 21, 2026.

Excerpt from 6:10 to 6:40 of the FOX 7 Austin video. Taken from FOX 7 Austin's own video page. The FOX 7 Austin YouTube upload cited for this source shows the same video. DI added its logo in the corner.

Video: FOX 7 Austin. Excerpt used for news reporting and commentary

Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: Rep. Greg Casar remarks, 06:22-07:05 (on-screen label: Representative Greg Casar, D, Texas, District 35))

About this source

Live FOX 7 Austin broadcast of the Monday news conference held with LULAC leaders and Rep. Lloyd Doggett. Speaker identified by the on-screen label and the host's introduction.

Author
FOX 7 Austin
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

FOX 7 Austin broadcast of the September 21 news conference on the Austin ICE shooting (Doggett remarks)

FOX 7 Austin broadcast of the September 21 news conference on the Austin ICE shooting (Doggett remarks) (opens in a new tab)Rep. Lloyd Doggett remarks, 00:27-00:47 (on-screen label: Representative Lloyd Doggett, D, Texas, District 37)

Rep. Lloyd Doggett speaks about an ICE shooting in Austin at a news conference, in FOX 7 Austin video, Sept. 21, 2026.

Excerpt from 0:27 to 0:47 of the FOX 7 Austin video. Taken from FOX 7 Austin's own video page. The FOX 7 Austin YouTube upload cited for this source shows the same video. DI added its logo in the corner.

Video: FOX 7 Austin. Excerpt used for news reporting and commentary

Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: Rep. Lloyd Doggett remarks, 00:27-00:47 (on-screen label: Representative Lloyd Doggett, D, Texas, District 37))

Excerpt

"clearly ICE has no credibility anymore"

About this source

Live FOX 7 Austin broadcast of the Monday news conference held with LULAC leaders and Rep. Greg Casar. The broadcast begins during Doggett's remarks. Speaker identified by the on-screen label and the host's introductions.

Author
FOX 7 Austin
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Official statement

Letter from Rep. Greg Casar to DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin and Acting ICE Director David Venturella

Letter from Rep. Greg Casar to DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin and Acting ICE Director David Venturella (opens in a new tab) · Greg CasarPage 2, paragraph beginning "ICE and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents have shot"
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Page 2, paragraph beginning "ICE and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents have shot"

Excerpt

"any narrative from DHS regarding this shooting must be viewed with deep skepticism"

About this source

Casar's September 20, 2026 letter demanding an independent investigation of the Austin shooting, release of footage, and a congressional briefing by September 28.

Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)
Optional assessment

The claim

Any DHS narrative about the Austin shooting must be viewed with deep skepticism, and an independent investigation of the shooting must be conducted.

Review the excerpt
Homeland Security Investigations, with the assistance of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, is leading the investigation

Location in the source: Post text

Read the source entry
How strongly does the evidence shown support this claim?

Based on the case you read.

Case updates

Who should investigate the Austin ICE shooting?

Get an email if DHS answers calls for an independent inquiry, if Travis County or Austin police report findings, or if footage of the shooting is released.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

The newsletter

Follow disputes like this one.

New cases and significant updates to the record, in your inbox. Free.

You’ll confirm your subscription on Substack.

Share or embed this case

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/cases/dhs-led-investigation-ice-shooting-delivery-driver-austin

The Dispute Index. "Should DHS lead the investigation of the ICE shooting of a delivery driver in Austin?". First published: 2026-09-21. Last updated: 2026-10-06. https://disputeindex.com/cases/dhs-led-investigation-ice-shooting-delivery-driver-austin