Was Bo French’s UT Austin post racist?

Bo French used an image of apparent South Asian UT fans to argue that foreigners were displacing Americans. Critics called the posts racist or xenophobic; French and supporters said they raised a legitimate immigration and admissions dispute.

The UT Austin Main Building and Tower, with students walking across the front plaza.
UT Austin’s Main Building and Tower in Austin, Texas.

Case period:

Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated

Bo FrenchThe University of Texas at Austin

Overview

The still image came from an official Texas Athletics video of fans celebrating a football comeback. The video and image do not identify the citizenship, residency, or immigration status of the people shown. French expanded his initial post into two explicit propositions: that Americans are being displaced by foreigners and that UT prioritizes foreigners over Texans. In a radio interview the following day, he said his objection concerned policy rather than race and that he had nothing against the pictured people specifically. Critics said French had treated apparent ancestry as evidence of foreign status and had demeaned students based on race or ethnicity. Defenders argued that demographic change, immigration levels, and university admissions priorities are legitimate policy subjects. UT’s published admissions materials state that 90 percent of first-time undergraduate spaces are reserved for Texas residents; the university’s separate automatic-admission percentage applies within those Texas-resident spaces.

People in this case

Timeline

13 timeline entries on this page. Dates: September 12, 2026 to October 6, 2026

  1. September 2026

    1. Texas Athletics publishes celebration video

      Source release

      The Texas Longhorns account posted a 17-second video of fans celebrating the football team’s comeback victory over Ohio State. A still from this video later became the focus of French’s posts.

      [01]Texas Longhorns post video of the Ohio State comeback celebration

      Source excerpt

      THAT'LL DO IT

      Official Texas Athletics post containing the stadium-celebration footage from which the still image used by Bo French was taken.

      Texas Longhorns post video of the Ohio State comeback celebrationX post 2098981262325170663 and attached 17-second video.
    2. French calls the crowd image evidence of a problem

      Claim

      French posted a still showing apparent South Asian fans and said he had heard UT graduation looked similar, adding that the problem was worse than imagined.

      [02]Bo French characterizes an image of UT fans as a demographic problem

      Source excerpt

      I heard UT graduation this year looked like this. I didn’t believe it. The problem is now obviously far worse than anyone imagined.

      French’s first post about the image. The attached still shows apparent South Asian fans in the student section; the post does not identify anyone’s citizenship, residency, or immigration status.

      [01]Texas Longhorns post video of the Ohio State comeback celebration

      Source excerpt

      THAT'LL DO IT

      Official Texas Athletics post containing the stadium-celebration footage from which the still image used by Bo French was taken.

      Texas Longhorns post video of the Ohio State comeback celebrationX post 2098981262325170663 and attached 17-second video.
    3. Cornyn calls the post intolerant and racist

      Reaction

      Cornyn asked other Republican officials to condemn what he called intolerance and racism, establishing a direct disagreement within the party over French’s post.

      [03]John Cornyn calls Bo French’s post intolerant and racist

      Source excerpt

      Are other Republican elected officials going to condemn the intolerance and racism, or look the other way while it becomes normalized.

      Cornyn’s direct response quote-posting French’s first post.

      [04]Texas Tribune reports Republican dispute over Bo French’s UT fan post

      Source excerpt

      The public backlash against French highlighted a growing divide among conservatives.

      State political reporting that documents the sequence of French’s posts and attributable responses from elected officials.

      Texas Tribune reports Republican dispute over Bo French’s UT fan postAccount of French’s posts and reactions from Texas officials.
    4. French expands the post into displacement and admissions claims

      Claim

      French said social media was showing Americans displaced by foreigners, rejected Cornyn’s criticism, and later accused UT of prioritizing foreigners over Texans.

      [05]Bo French says social media shows Americans displaced by foreigners

      Source excerpt

      Social media is exposing how many Americans have been displaced by foreigners.

      Follow-up post in which French connected the images to a broader displacement claim.

      [06]Bo French says UT prioritizes foreigners over Texans

      Source excerpt

      I weep for the families in Texas who can’t get into UT because they prioritize foreigners over Texans.

      French’s reply distinguishes his support for the football team from his allegation about UT admissions priorities.

      [07]Bo French responds to John Cornyn’s condemnation

      Source excerpt

      Our state’s institutions have been overrun by illegal aliens and foreign nationals.

      French’s direct response to Cornyn rejects the criticism and expands his argument to Texas institutions generally.

    5. Officials and commentators take opposing positions

      Reaction

      Republican and Democratic officials condemned the posts, while Savanah Hernandez, Jake Lloyd Colglazier, John Doyle, and others defended French or the demographic argument behind the posts.

      [08]Jared Patterson condemns Bo French’s post

      Source excerpt

      This is racist. It is wrong. And I condemn it without reservation.

      Patterson’s direct response argues that immigration-policy disagreement does not justify demeaning people by race or ethnicity.

      [09]Dustin Burrows says Bo French crossed the line

      Source excerpt

      You can oppose immigration policy without demeaning people because of their race or ethnicity.

      Burrows’s direct response asks French to delete the post while distinguishing immigration-policy opposition from racial or ethnic denigration.

      [10]Drew Darby condemns Bo French’s post and requests an apology

      Source excerpt

      This is racism, plain and simple.

      Darby’s direct response says French should delete the post and apologize, and argues the conduct is unbecoming of a Railroad Commission candidate.

      [11]Gina Hinojosa says Bo French is unfit to serve

      Source excerpt

      This man is unfit to serve.

      Hinojosa’s direct response quote-posting French’s first post.

      [12]Jon Rosenthal criticizes Bo French’s interpretation of the student-section image

      Source excerpt

      A man who can’t tell a Longhorn from a foreigner has no business regulating anything in TX.

      Rosenthal’s direct response criticizes French for inferring foreign status from the fans’ appearance.

      [13]Raja Krishnamoorthi condemns Bo French’s post as xenophobic

      Source excerpt

      These young people were cheering for their university, and you chose to demonize them based solely on how they look.

      Krishnamoorthi’s official congressional account directly responds to French’s displacement post.

      [14]Savanah Hernandez says Bo French is correct

      Source excerpt

      Bo is 1000% correct.

      Hernandez’s direct defense quote-posting French’s first post and arguing that critics misunderstand demographic change in Texas.

      [15]Jake Lloyd Colglazier defends Bo French’s post

      Source excerpt

      The backlash against this perfectly reasonable post demonstrates the deleterious effect of mass immigration on our democratic system.

      Colglazier’s direct defense quote-posting French’s first post.

      [16]John Doyle defends Bo French against John Cornyn’s criticism

      Source excerpt

      A Patriot acknowledging that Texans didn’t ask for their state to become a playground for the third world.

      Doyle’s direct response rejects Cornyn’s racism characterization and defends French’s demographic argument.

      [04]Texas Tribune reports Republican dispute over Bo French’s UT fan post

      Source excerpt

      The public backlash against French highlighted a growing divide among conservatives.

      State political reporting that documents the sequence of French’s posts and attributable responses from elected officials.

      Texas Tribune reports Republican dispute over Bo French’s UT fan postAccount of French’s posts and reactions from Texas officials.
      [17]CBS Texas reports on Bo French’s posts and responses from Greg Abbott and R.C. Damle

      Source excerpt

      That is not my message.

      Original local reporting that verified the still came from an official Texas Athletics video and published Abbott’s direct response.

      CBS Texas reports on Bo French’s posts and responses from Greg Abbott and R.C. DamleStatements attributed to Greg Abbott and R.C. Damle and verification of the image’s source.
    6. French defends the posts as a policy argument

      Reaction

      On The Mark Davis Show, French said the issue was policy rather than race and argued that institutions should prioritize Americans over non-Americans. Later reporting carried Abbott’s separate response rejecting French’s interpretation of the image while defending restrictive immigration policies.

      [18]Bo French defends his UT student post on The Mark Davis Show

      Source excerpt

      It’s not about race. It’s about policy, Mark.

      Full radio episode containing French’s direct defense. French said he had nothing against the pictured people specifically and framed the dispute as whether policy should prioritize Americans or foreigners.

      Bo French defends his UT student post on The Mark Davis ShowEpisode titled “MON SEP 14 9 AM TX RR commission candidate @BoFrench on his Indian student post.”
      [17]CBS Texas reports on Bo French’s posts and responses from Greg Abbott and R.C. Damle

      Source excerpt

      That is not my message.

      Original local reporting that verified the still came from an official Texas Athletics video and published Abbott’s direct response.

      CBS Texas reports on Bo French’s posts and responses from Greg Abbott and R.C. DamleStatements attributed to Greg Abbott and R.C. Damle and verification of the image’s source.
      [19]Texas Tribune reports Bo French’s radio defense and additional reactions

      Source excerpt

      It’s not about race. It’s about policy, Mark.

      Follow-up reporting that quotes French’s radio defense and documents additional attributable reactions.

      Texas Tribune reports Bo French’s radio defense and additional reactionsFrench’s Mark Davis interview and statements from political and industry figures.
    7. French fundraises off the backlash

      French posted a campaign fundraising appeal saying the radical left and its allies were attacking him, linking to his WinRed donation page. It marked a shift from defending the original post to soliciting money over the response to it. Senator John Cornyn quote-posted the appeal the following morning, citing it as evidence that French had neither removed the post nor apologised.

      [20]Bo French fundraising post on X following the backlash

      Source excerpt

      The radical left and their allies are attacking me.

      Posted 10:32 AM ET on September 14, 2026. It links to French's WinRed campaign donation page and is the post Cornyn quote-posted the following day.

      Bo French fundraising post on X following the backlashFull post text with campaign donation link.
    8. Additional Texas figures criticize French’s UT fan post

      Reaction

      Dan Crenshaw, Matt Shaheen, and Orlando Sanchez separately criticized French’s post. Their direct X statements rejected its characterization of the students and, in Shaheen’s and Sanchez’s words, condemned the post or its appearance-based inference.

      [21]Dan Crenshaw criticizes Bo French’s UT fan post

      Source excerpt

      Or was that a bunch of foreigners from UT who screwed over the widow of American Sniper?

      Crenshaw directly quote-posted French’s image-based UT fan post and criticized French’s framing.

      Dan Crenshaw criticizes Bo French’s UT fan postX post 2099252009366847920; quote-post of Bo French’s UT fan image post.
      [22]Matt Shaheen calls Bo French’s UT fan post disgusting

      Source excerpt

      This is disgusting & falls below conservative standards.

      Shaheen directly quote-posted French’s UT fan image post and condemned it.

      Matt Shaheen calls Bo French’s UT fan post disgustingX post 2099167181342716227; quote-post of Bo French’s UT fan image post.
      [23]Orlando Sanchez rejects Bo French’s characterization of UT fans

      Source excerpt

      Judging someone by their appearance and assuming they are foreigners is wrong, un-American, and has no place in our party or our state.

      Sanchez explicitly responds to French’s post and rejects inferring foreign status from the apparent appearance of people in the image.

      Orlando Sanchez rejects Bo French’s characterization of UT fansX post 2099522645939167409 responding to Bo French’s UT fan image post.
    9. The University of Texas responds for the first time

      Reaction

      The University of Texas System published a statement from Board of Regents chairman Kevin P. Eltife saying that when he looked at the stadium crowd he saw Longhorns, and UT Austin president Jim Davis endorsed it forty-four minutes later. Neither named Bo French. It was the university's first public response since the post appeared on September 13.

      [24]University of Texas System statement from Board of Regents chairman Kevin P. Eltife

      Source excerpt

      I saw Longhorns.

      Institutional statement posted 7:02 PM ET on September 14, 2026 by the UT System account, quoting Board of Regents chairman Kevin P. Eltife. It does not name Bo French.

      [25]UT Austin president Jim Davis post on X backing the chairman's statement

      Source excerpt

      Our students are exceptional. All of them are Longhorns.

      Posted 7:46 PM ET on September 14, 2026, forty-four minutes after the UT System statement it endorses.

    10. French again disputes racism characterization of his UT fan posts

      Reaction

      At a Grapevine conference, French said he had been shocked by the reaction and denied that his posts were racist, framing them as a concern about culture rather than origin or skin color.

      [26]Bo French defends his UT fan post at Grapevine conference

      Source excerpt

      “It’s not about people’s country of origin. It’s not about their skin color. It’s about the culture.”

      The Dallas Morning News reports that French said at a Grapevine conference that his posts were about culture rather than origin or skin color, while responding to criticism.

      Bo French defends his UT fan post at Grapevine conferenceOpening paragraphs and reported remarks at the Grapevine conference.
    11. Krishnamoorthi links Education Department football post to French controversy

      Reaction

      The U.S. Department of Education posted “MAKE COLLEGE FOOTBALL GREAT AGAIN” without naming Bo French or the UT Austin controversy. Representative Raja Krishnamoorthi said the Department seemed to be playing dog whistles to French’s tune and described French’s earlier post as a xenophobic attack. The claimed connection is Krishnamoorthi’s interpretation; the Department did not state one.

      [27]U.S. Department of Education post: “MAKE COLLEGE FOOTBALL GREAT AGAIN.”

      Source excerpt

      MAKE COLLEGE FOOTBALL GREAT AGAIN.

      The Department’s post does not name Bo French, the University of Texas, or the earlier UT fan-post controversy. Subsequent critics publicly linked it to that controversy; that interpretation is separately attributed.

      [28]Raja Krishnamoorthi links Education Department post to Bo French controversy

      Source excerpt

      The Department of Education seems to be playing dog whistles to Bo French’s tune just days after his xenophobic attack on South Asian students for cheering for their own college football team.

      Krishnamoorthi publicly interpreted the Department of Education’s football post as connected to French’s earlier UT fan-post controversy and described French’s post as xenophobic. The Department’s post itself did not name French.

    12. CNN reports earlier French posts calling for public executions, including of Obama

      CNN's KFile reported that Bo French, in posts from the past six years that have since been removed, repeatedly advocated public executions of political opponents. CNN quoted a May 2020 post in which French wrote, "The penalty for treason used to be death. Even for a former president. #HangEmHigh," in reply to a post that seemed to blame Barack Obama for the Russia investigation. CNN said French did not respond to its inquiries and that it was unclear whether he deleted the posts himself. The report concerns separate posts and does not address his University of Texas post. It also noted that Gov. Greg Abbott and Attorney General Ken Paxton had kept their endorsements of French.

      [29]CNN

      Source excerpt

      The penalty for treason used to be death. Even for a former president. #HangEmHigh

      CNN KFile report on posts by Bo French that CNN says were later removed or came from a since-suspended account. CNN reports that French did not respond to its inquiries and that it is unclear whether he deleted the posts himself. The original posts were not available to DI; the quotation comes from CNN's report.

      Texas GOP candidate Bo French has a history of calling for public executions · CNNParagraphs on French's May 2020 posts, beginning "In May 2020"
  2. October 2026

    1. New filings show Rosenthal ahead in fundraising

      Source release

      The Dallas Morning News and Texas Tribune reported that Jon Rosenthal raised about $488,000 and Bo French about $440,000 from July 1 through September 24. Rosenthal raised more than $349,000 in the 12 days after French's posts. French retained more cash on hand. Rosenthal described the donations as rejection of French's campaign.

      [30]Rosenthal responds to fundraising after French posts

      October 6 phone interview and reporting on July 1 to September 24 campaign filings. Rosenthal describes donations as rejection of French; the filings alone do not establish each donor's motive.

      Rosenthal responds to fundraising after French postsTuesday phone interview; paragraph beginning: The people are rejecting
      [31]The Texas Tribune

      Separate reporting on campaign filings. Totals cover July 1 through September 24; the entire reporting-period total was not raised after the posts.

      Texas Tribune reports Rosenthal and French fundraising · The Texas TribuneOpening fundraising totals and September 12 to 24 donations

Claims

Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.

What's disputed

Arguments

  1. Documented position

    Dustin Burrows, Jon Rosenthal, Raja Krishnamoorthi, and Conor Friedersdorf

    The image did not establish the fans’ status

    Critics argue that French treated apparent South Asian ancestry as evidence that the pictured fans were foreigners and that Americans had been displaced. The official video identifies the setting and event, but it does not establish the citizenship, residency, or immigration status of any person shown.

    Limit of this argument

    The same image also does not establish that every pictured person was a citizen or Texas resident. The narrower point is that it cannot bear the status inference French placed on it.

    Read sources and related claim

    Related claim

    The appearance of the fans in the image showed that Americans had been displaced by foreigners.

    Sources

  2. Editorial analysis

    UT Austin admissions materials and Texas Education Code

    UT’s published allocation favors Texas residents

    UT’s published rules reserve 90 percent of first-time undergraduate spaces for Texas residents. That allocation cuts against a broad claim that the university’s admissions structure prioritizes foreigners over Texans.

    Limit of this argument

    Texas residency is not identical to U.S. citizenship, and the policy does not answer every debate about international enrollment, H-1B programs, or competition within particular admissions categories.

    Read sources and related claim

    Related claim

    UT prioritizes foreigners over Texans in admissions.

    Sources

  3. Documented position

    Jared Patterson, Dustin Burrows, Drew Darby, and Raja Krishnamoorthi

    The criticism focused on the use of identifiable fans

    Critics argue that immigration and admissions policy can be debated without presenting a group of identifiable fans as the visual evidence of a racial or demographic problem. Their objection is directed at the connection French drew between appearance and foreign status, not at the existence of immigration-policy disagreement.

    Limit of this argument

    The fans appeared in footage posted by an official athletics account at a public event. The dispute concerns French’s interpretation and use of the image, not whether the original sports footage could be published.

    Read sources
  1. Documented position

    Bo French

    French says the target was policy, not race

    French says he did not object to the pictured people specifically. He describes the posts as criticism of institutions that, in his view, prioritize non-Americans and as an argument for giving Americans priority in admissions and immigration policy.

    Limit of this argument

    French’s initial post did not state an admissions policy or identify anyone’s status. His later posts supplied the explicit claims about foreigners, displacement, and UT priorities.

    Read sources and related claim

    Related claim

    UT prioritizes foreigners over Texans in admissions.

    Sources

  2. Documented position

    Savanah Hernandez, Jake Lloyd Colglazier, John Doyle, and Brandon Morse

    Defenders say demographic change is a legitimate policy subject

    Defenders argue that the pace and concentration of legal as well as illegal immigration, assimilation, and resulting cultural change are legitimate public-policy concerns. They interpret French’s post as a blunt illustration of that broader demographic argument.

    Limit of this argument

    A broader demographic concern does not by itself establish the status of the pictured fans, prove that any American was displaced by them, or show that UT gives them admissions priority.

    Read sources and related claim

    Related claim

    The appearance of the fans in the image showed that Americans had been displaced by foreigners.

    Sources

  3. Editorial analysis

    Synthesis of French’s defense and supporting statements

    Supporters interpret the image rhetorically

    A defense of the posts can treat the image as a rhetorical prompt about perceived demographic change rather than a formal claim about each individual shown. On that reading, the central intended target is immigration and institutional policy.

    Limit of this argument

    French’s follow-up wording moved beyond symbolism: he described Americans as displaced by foreigners and said UT prioritizes foreigners over Texans, making the evidentiary connection part of the dispute.

    Read sources and related claim

    Related claim

    The appearance of the fans in the image showed that Americans had been displaced by foreigners.

    Sources

Response record

Responses

Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.

3 matching responses. Newest first.

  1. Bo FrenchRepublican nominee for Texas Railroad CommissionerDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    At a conference in Grapevine, Texas, French addressed the backlash to his September posts about UT fans.

    "It’s fair to say that Texas doesn’t look and feel like it did when I was a kid, and that’s not racist."
    Challenged the characterization

    Case context: Was Bo French’s UT Austin post racist?

    Full statement and sources

    French denied that his posts about UT fans were racist and said his concern was culture rather than people’s origin or skin color.

    After the statement

    He said he was surprised by the reaction and described demographic change as a cultural issue.

    Bo French defends his UT fan post at Grapevine conferenceOpening paragraphs and reported remarks at the Grapevine conference.

    Why this label?

    French explicitly disputes the characterization of his posts as racist and frames them as a cultural concern. The classification records his stated response to the case question, not an editorial determination of whether the posts were racist.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  2. Bo FrenchRepublican nominee for Texas Railroad Commissioner speaking in a radio interview.Directly involved

    Before this statement

    French had posted an image of apparent South Asian UT fans, called what it showed a problem, and then connected the image to foreign displacement and UT admissions.

    "It’s not about race. It’s about policy, Mark. I believe we should be prioritizing Americans, not foreigners. The problem, as I see, that there are, and I think a lot of people agree with this, too many of our institutions are prioritizing people who are not Americans."
    Defended or excused

    Responding to: UT prioritizes foreigners over Texans in admissions.

    Full statement and sources

    French said the post concerned admissions and immigration policy rather than race. He defended prioritizing Americans over non-Americans and said institutions were giving preference to people who are not American.

    After the statement

    French said he had nothing against the pictured people specifically and continued to frame the dispute as whether policy should prioritize Americans or foreigners.

    Bo French defends his UT student post on The Mark Davis ShowEpisode titled “MON SEP 14 9 AM TX RR commission candidate @BoFrench on his Indian student post.”
    CBS Texas reports on Bo French’s posts and responses from Greg Abbott and R.C. DamleStatements attributed to Greg Abbott and R.C. Damle and verification of the image’s source.
    Texas Tribune reports Bo French’s radio defense and additional reactionsFrench’s Mark Davis interview and statements from political and industry figures.

    Why this label?

    French affirmatively defends the conduct under scrutiny as a legitimate policy argument and rejects the allegation that it was race-based.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  3. Bo FrenchRepublican nominee for the Texas Railroad Commission in a radio interviewDirectly involved

    Before this statement

    French was asked about the post on The Mark Davis Show on the Monday morning after it was published. He had already stood by it publicly.

    "We’ve talked about this in terms of DEI [diversity, equity, and inclusion]. Well, that’s what DEI was. DEI was discriminating against deserving people, so that these liberal bureaucrat administrators at University of Texas and places like that could select their preferred groups of people. Well, that is what is racism."
    Defended or excused

    Case context: Was Bo French’s UT Austin post racist?

    Full statement and sources

    In a radio interview, French recast the dispute as one about diversity, equity and inclusion, arguing that university admissions preferences are the real racism.

    After the statement

    Politico separately reported that in a radio appearance that day French said he had no personal animosity toward the students and that it is not racist to favour Texans over foreigners. The bracketed expansion of DEI comes from the Houston Public Media report, not from us.

    Faced with condemnation over alleged racism, Texas Republican Bo French doubles downPassage quoting French's remarks on The Mark Davis Show.

    Why this label?

    The conduct under scrutiny is French's own post. He defends it here by reframing it as a criticism of admissions policy and turning the charge of racism back on university administrators.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

Sources

(55)

Original post

Bo French characterizes an image of UT fans as a demographic problem

Excerpt

"I heard UT graduation this year looked like this. I didn’t believe it. The problem is now obviously far worse than anyone imagined."

About this source

French’s first post about the image. The attached still shows apparent South Asian fans in the student section; the post does not identify anyone’s citizenship, residency, or immigration status.

Author
Bo French
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Texas Tribune reports Rosenthal and French fundraising

Texas Tribune reports Rosenthal and French fundraising (opens in a new tab) · The Texas TribuneOpening fundraising totals and September 12 to 24 donations
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Opening fundraising totals and September 12 to 24 donations

About this source

Separate reporting on campaign filings. Totals cover July 1 through September 24; the entire reporting-period total was not raised after the posts.

Author
Carlos Nogueras Ramos
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Interview

Rosenthal responds to fundraising after French posts

Rosenthal responds to fundraising after French posts (opens in a new tab)Tuesday phone interview; paragraph beginning: The people are rejecting
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Tuesday phone interview; paragraph beginning: The people are rejecting

About this source

October 6 phone interview and reporting on July 1 to September 24 campaign filings. Rosenthal describes donations as rejection of French; the filings alone do not establish each donor's motive.

Author
Aarón Torres
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Texas GOP candidate Bo French has a history of calling for public executions

Texas GOP candidate Bo French has a history of calling for public executions (opens in a new tab) · CNNParagraphs on French's May 2020 posts, beginning "In May 2020"
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Paragraphs on French's May 2020 posts, beginning "In May 2020"

Excerpt

"The penalty for treason used to be death. Even for a former president. #HangEmHigh"

About this source

CNN KFile report on posts by Bo French that CNN says were later removed or came from a since-suspended account. CNN reports that French did not respond to its inquiries and that it is unclear whether he deleted the posts himself. The original posts were not available to DI; the quotation comes from CNN's report.

Author
Andrew Kaczynski
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Texas Republican accused of racism over comments on South Asian students

Texas Republican accused of racism over comments on South Asian students (opens in a new tab)Paragraphs quoting posts on X by the Hindu American Foundation, the Indian American Advocacy Council and state Rep. Lacey Hull
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Paragraphs quoting posts on X by the Hindu American Foundation, the Indian American Advocacy Council and state Rep. Lacey Hull

Excerpt

"Please delete this. This post breaks my heart. I see college kids cheering on their football team. I see Texans"

About this source

The American Bazaar's report on the criticism that followed Bo French's posts about South Asian students at a University of Texas football game. It quotes Indian American advocacy groups and elected officials from both parties, including posts on X that the article quotes.

Author
Nileena Sunil
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Raja Krishnamoorthi links Education Department post to Bo French controversy

Excerpt

"The Department of Education seems to be playing dog whistles to Bo French’s tune just days after his xenophobic attack on South Asian students for cheering for their own college football team."

About this source

Krishnamoorthi publicly interpreted the Department of Education’s football post as connected to French’s earlier UT fan-post controversy and described French’s post as xenophobic. The Department’s post itself did not name French.

Author
Raja Krishnamoorthi
Published
Accessed

Original post

U.S. Department of Education post: “MAKE COLLEGE FOOTBALL GREAT AGAIN.”

Excerpt

"MAKE COLLEGE FOOTBALL GREAT AGAIN."

About this source

The Department’s post does not name Bo French, the University of Texas, or the earlier UT fan-post controversy. Subsequent critics publicly linked it to that controversy; that interpretation is separately attributed.

Author
U.S. Department of Education
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Bo French defends his UT fan post at Grapevine conference

Bo French defends his UT fan post at Grapevine conference (opens in a new tab)Opening paragraphs and reported remarks at the Grapevine conference.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Opening paragraphs and reported remarks at the Grapevine conference.

Excerpt

"“It’s not about people’s country of origin. It’s not about their skin color. It’s about the culture.”"

About this source

The Dallas Morning News reports that French said at a Grapevine conference that his posts were about culture rather than origin or skin color, while responding to criticism.

Author
Sarah Bahari and Aarón Torres
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Top Texas Republicans knew Bo French's history of racist comments. They supported him anyway.

Top Texas Republicans knew Bo French's history of racist comments. They supported him anyway. (opens in a new tab) · The Texas TribuneSection beginning "No less, an abundance of supporters have emerged to defend French," which identifies Hall as a State Board of Education member and reproduces his post.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Section beginning "No less, an abundance of supporters have emerged to defend French," which identifies Hall as a State Board of Education member and reproduces his post.

About this source

The Texas Tribune's report identifies Hall as a State Board of Education member and quotes his post supporting French. It is used for attribution and context alongside Hall's original post.

Author
Alejandro Serrano
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Brandon Hall supports Bo French's response to the UT Austin controversy

Brandon Hall supports Bo French's response to the UT Austin controversy (opens in a new tab)X post 2099214662474621439, published September 13, 2026 at 19:12:31 UTC.

Excerpt

"I stand with Bo. It has nothing to do with skin color. It's about preserving our Texas way of life."

About this source

Hall's public post responds to criticism of Bo French's post about UT Austin fans. The account's public bio identifies Hall as a Texas State Board of Education member.

Author
Brandon Hall
Published
Accessed

Original post

Eric Columbus asks whether Texas Republicans will follow Cornyn in condemning Bo French

Eric Columbus asks whether Texas Republicans will follow Cornyn in condemning Bo French (opens in a new tab) · Eric ColumbusBluesky post by @ericcolumbus.bsky.social, 2026-09-13 16:09 UTC, and his follow-up in the same thread at 17:04.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Bluesky post by @ericcolumbus.bsky.social, 2026-09-13 16:09 UTC, and his follow-up in the same thread at 17:04.

Excerpt

"Will any GOP electeds who didn't just lose their primary speak up?"

About this source

The speaker's own post on Bluesky. His opening line paraphrases Cornyn in language Cornyn did not use: Cornyn's own post asked whether other Republicans would "condemn the intolerance and racism," and he did not use the phrase Columbus attributes to him. The colourful paraphrase is Columbus's characterisation, not a quotation of Cornyn.

Author
Eric Columbus
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Robert Downen on Texas Republicans condemning Bo French's post

Robert Downen on Texas Republicans condemning Bo French's post (opens in a new tab) · Robert DownenBluesky post by @robertdownen.bsky.social, 2026-09-13 22:07 UTC.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Bluesky post by @robertdownen.bsky.social, 2026-09-13 22:07 UTC.

Excerpt

"After months of staying quiet on his gutter racism, top Texas Republicans are now condemning a post in which Bo French, candidate for Texas Railroad Commission, posted a photo of brown UT students at yesterday's game"

About this source

The speaker's own post on Bluesky. In a second post fourteen minutes later he wrote that French "has a long history of posting fascist and white supremacist rhetoric" and that Republicans had by and large stayed quiet about it, referring to his own outlet's reporting in July.

Author
Robert Downen
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Cornyn says he won't vote for Texas Republican Bo French after candidate's controversial post

Cornyn says he won't vote for Texas Republican Bo French after candidate's controversial post (opens in a new tab) · ABC NewsABC News, September 17, 2026, 5:51 PM. Reports Cornyn's comments to the Washington Examiner and his social media posts.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: ABC News, September 17, 2026, 5:51 PM. Reports Cornyn's comments to the Washington Examiner and his social media posts.

Excerpt

"He's an embarrassment to the Republican Party, and he's going to drag the whole ticket down because of his racist comments."

About this source

Records the point at which Cornyn moved from condemning French's post to refusing to vote for him. Asked whether he would instead vote for the Democratic nominee Jon Rosenthal, Cornyn said "I may just leave it blank." The article notes the Republican Party of Texas did not respond to a request for comment and that French's campaign also did not respond. Karl Rove separately said he would not vote for French.

Author
Nathan Lee and Diana Paulsen
Published
Accessed

Reporting

One group has stayed mostly mum on Bo French's racist post — Texas' oil and gas industry

One group has stayed mostly mum on Bo French's racist post — Texas' oil and gas industry (opens in a new tab) · The Texas TribuneThe Texas Tribune, September 17, 2026. Reporting on the oil and gas industry's response to Bo French's post.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: The Texas Tribune, September 17, 2026. Reporting on the oil and gas industry's response to Bo French's post.

Excerpt

"TXOGA PAC unequivocally and without reservation condemns the recent tweet posted September 13th on X by Bo French. Respect is a cornerstone of our industry's core values."

About this source

Reports that the industry French would regulate has largely stayed silent: ExxonMobil, Chevron and Occidental did not respond to the Tribune's questions. The exception is the Texas Oil and Gas Association's political action committee, which had endorsed French days before the post and then condemned it. The article notes TXOGA's initial preferred candidate was incumbent Jim Wright, whom it backed with about $100,000, and quotes political scientists on why major operators may not want public association with French given their Middle East operations and South Asian workforces.

Author
Carlos Nogueras Ramos
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original video

The "Racist" UT Austin Photo Everyone Was Supposed To Ignore (Sara Gonzales Unfiltered)

About this source

Sara Gonzales Unfiltered segment on Bo French's UT Austin post.

Published
Accessed

Interview

UT Austin students respond to Bo French's post

Excerpt

"When I look at that picture, I don't see a problem."

About this source

CBS News Texas report with on-record reactions from three UT Austin students pictured in or affected by Bo French's post.

Published
Accessed

Analysis

The Charlie Kirk Show: "The Indian Immigration Debate + New Butler Shooting Mysteries"

Excerpt

"real... maybe [an] unfortunate tweet"

About this source

The Charlie Kirk Show episode with host Andrew Kolvet and guest Auron MacIntyre (Blaze Media), defending Bo French against Cornyn and Rove's condemnation.

Published
Accessed

Interview

UT Austin students pictured in Bo French post speak out

Excerpt

"especially disturbing ... narrow-minded"

About this source

FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth report in which Rahul Kodali, a UT Austin student pictured in Bo French's post, responds on the record.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Karl Rove says he'll vote for French's Democratic opponent, calls him a "bigot"

Excerpt

"bigot"

About this source

Texas Tribune report on Karl Rove telling a private Headliners Club lunch he will vote for French's Democratic opponent, and Trump's subsequent Truth Social response.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Ted Cruz comments on Bo French UT Austin post

About this source

Reports Cruz's first public comment on French's post, made outside a Senate Judiciary hearing; corroborated by Mediaite.

Published
Accessed

Reporting

Texas Republicans are scrambling after Bo French's outburst

Texas Republicans are scrambling after Bo French's outburst (opens in a new tab)Report quoting De La Cruz, Nehls, Kim and Republican strategists.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Report quoting De La Cruz, Nehls, Kim and Republican strategists.

Excerpt

"All I see in that photograph is a group of kids celebrating a Longhorns win."

About this source

Politico report timestamped 5:00 AM ET on September 15, 2026. It states that no Republican explicitly called for French to drop out, that Dan Patrick did not respond to a request for comment, and that two students in the photo told the Dallas Morning News they are US citizens.

Author
Samuel Benson and Mike Lee
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Faced with condemnation over alleged racism, Texas Republican Bo French doubles down

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Passage quoting French's remarks on The Mark Davis Show.

Excerpt

"DEI was discriminating against deserving people"

About this source

Houston Public Media report by Andrew Schneider, republished by KUT, on French's Monday, September 14 appearance on The Mark Davis Show. We could not locate a recording of the broadcast, so the quotation is taken from this report.

Author
Andrew Schneider
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Bo French fundraising post on X following the backlash

Excerpt

"The radical left and their allies are attacking me."

About this source

Posted 10:32 AM ET on September 14, 2026. It links to French's WinRed campaign donation page and is the post Cornyn quote-posted the following day.

Author
Bo French
Published
Accessed

Original post

UT Austin president Jim Davis post on X backing the chairman's statement

Excerpt

"Our students are exceptional. All of them are Longhorns."

About this source

Posted 7:46 PM ET on September 14, 2026, forty-four minutes after the UT System statement it endorses.

Author
Jim Davis
Published
Accessed

Original post

University of Texas System statement from Board of Regents chairman Kevin P. Eltife

Excerpt

"I saw Longhorns."

About this source

Institutional statement posted 7:02 PM ET on September 14, 2026 by the UT System account, quoting Board of Regents chairman Kevin P. Eltife. It does not name Bo French.

Author
University of Texas System
Published
Accessed

Original post

James Talarico post on X challenging Ken Paxton to condemn the post

Excerpt

"Racism has no place in Texas."

About this source

Post published 12:10 PM ET on September 13, 2026, thanking Cornyn and challenging Paxton directly. Paxton replied later the same day.

Author
James Talarico
Published
Accessed

Original post

Attorney General Ken Paxton post on X replying to James Talarico

Excerpt

"I condemn racism in all its forms"

About this source

Post published 5:48 PM ET on September 13, 2026, quote-posting James Talarico's direct challenge to condemn French's post. Paxton does not characterize French's post.

Author
Ken Paxton
Published
Accessed

Original post

Senator John Cornyn post on X responding to Bo French's fundraising appeal

Excerpt

"No takedown of offensive post, no apology. Just doubles down and raises $ using it."

About this source

Post published 9:36 AM ET on September 15, 2026. It quote-posts Bo French's September 14 fundraising appeal, which is the conduct Cornyn is describing.

Author
John Cornyn
Published
Accessed

Original video

Pod Save America: frontier-AI safeguards and Bo French’s UT Austin post — September 15, 2026

Pod Save America: frontier-AI safeguards and Bo French’s UT Austin post — September 15, 2026 (opens in a new tab)AI: 04:26–06:12 (Vietor), 06:16–07:32 and 16:48–19:21 (Lovett), 16:08–16:47 (Favreau). Bo French: 55:55–59:16; Vietor at 58:17–58:31 and Lovett at 58:34–58:45.

About this source

Original Pod Save America video, titled Trump’s Response to DIRE Warning is Completely INSANE, published September 15, 2026; shown as a collaboration with The Bulwark. Speaker attribution is supported by host introductions and on-screen speakers, including Vietor in the French discussion, Lovett at 58:43, and Favreau at 16:42. The hosts evaluate federal AI oversight and pacing proposals and later French’s inference of foreign status from a UT fan image. Embedded Trump and Ossoff clips are quotations of those speakers. Publication date establishes the calendar day, not an exact recording time.

Author
Jon Favreau, Jon Lovett, and Tommy Vietor
Published
Accessed

Original post

Orlando Sanchez rejects Bo French’s characterization of UT fans

Orlando Sanchez rejects Bo French’s characterization of UT fans (opens in a new tab)X post 2099522645939167409 responding to Bo French’s UT fan image post.

Excerpt

"Judging someone by their appearance and assuming they are foreigners is wrong, un-American, and has no place in our party or our state."

About this source

Sanchez explicitly responds to French’s post and rejects inferring foreign status from the apparent appearance of people in the image.

Author
Orlando Sanchez (@orlando_sanchez)
Published
Accessed

Original post

Matt Shaheen calls Bo French’s UT fan post disgusting

Matt Shaheen calls Bo French’s UT fan post disgusting (opens in a new tab)X post 2099167181342716227; quote-post of Bo French’s UT fan image post.

Excerpt

"This is disgusting & falls below conservative standards."

About this source

Shaheen directly quote-posted French’s UT fan image post and condemned it.

Author
Matt Shaheen (@MattShaheen)
Published
Accessed

Original post

Dan Crenshaw criticizes Bo French’s UT fan post

Dan Crenshaw criticizes Bo French’s UT fan post (opens in a new tab)X post 2099252009366847920; quote-post of Bo French’s UT fan image post.

Excerpt

"Or was that a bunch of foreigners from UT who screwed over the widow of American Sniper?"

About this source

Crenshaw directly quote-posted French’s image-based UT fan post and criticized French’s framing.

Author
Dan Crenshaw (@DanCrenshaw)
Published
Accessed

Original text

Texas Education Code Section 51.803

Texas Education Code Section 51.803 (opens in a new tab)Section 51.803(j), nonresident first-time undergraduate cap.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Section 51.803(j), nonresident first-time undergraduate cap.

Excerpt

"may not offer admission to nonresident applicants for undergraduate studies who exceed 10 percent"

About this source

Texas statute governing the nonresident share of first-time undergraduate enrollment when UT uses the modified automatic-admission percentage.

Author
Texas Legislature
Accessed

Reporting

Texas Tribune reports Bo French’s radio defense and additional reactions

Texas Tribune reports Bo French’s radio defense and additional reactions (opens in a new tab)French’s Mark Davis interview and statements from political and industry figures.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: French’s Mark Davis interview and statements from political and industry figures.

Excerpt

"It’s not about race. It’s about policy, Mark."

About this source

Follow-up reporting that quotes French’s radio defense and documents additional attributable reactions.

Author
The Texas Tribune
Published
Accessed

Official statement

UT Austin undergraduate admission catalog

UT Austin undergraduate admission catalog (opens in a new tab)Residency allocation for first-time undergraduate admissions.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Residency allocation for first-time undergraduate admissions.

Excerpt

"The university reserves 90 percent of all available spaces for Texas residents."

About this source

Official university catalog describing the statutory residency allocation for first-time undergraduate admission.

Author
The University of Texas at Austin
Accessed

Official statement

UT Austin admissions review and decision process

UT Austin admissions review and decision process (opens in a new tab)Automatic admission section describing the share of available Texas-resident spaces.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Automatic admission section describing the share of available Texas-resident spaces.

Excerpt

"75% of the available Texas resident spaces"

About this source

Official admissions guidance. The 75 percent figure concerns available spaces for Texas residents, not the entire incoming class.

Author
The University of Texas at Austin
Accessed

Reporting

CBS Texas reports on Bo French’s posts and responses from Greg Abbott and R.C. Damle

CBS Texas reports on Bo French’s posts and responses from Greg Abbott and R.C. Damle (opens in a new tab)Statements attributed to Greg Abbott and R.C. Damle and verification of the image’s source.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Statements attributed to Greg Abbott and R.C. Damle and verification of the image’s source.

Excerpt

"That is not my message."

About this source

Original local reporting that verified the still came from an official Texas Athletics video and published Abbott’s direct response.

Author
CBS News Texas
Published
Accessed

Reporting

Texas Tribune reports Republican dispute over Bo French’s UT fan post

Texas Tribune reports Republican dispute over Bo French’s UT fan post (opens in a new tab)Account of French’s posts and reactions from Texas officials.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Account of French’s posts and reactions from Texas officials.

Excerpt

"The public backlash against French highlighted a growing divide among conservatives."

About this source

State political reporting that documents the sequence of French’s posts and attributable responses from elected officials.

Author
The Texas Tribune
Published
Accessed

Analysis

Conor Friedersdorf condemns Bo French’s posts about Texas sports fans

Conor Friedersdorf condemns Bo French’s posts about Texas sports fans (opens in a new tab)Article discussing French’s posts and the criticism they generated.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Article discussing French’s posts and the criticism they generated.

Excerpt

"A Bigoted Outburst Against Texas Sports Fans"

About this source

Friedersdorf’s analysis characterizes the posts as bigoted and argues that the pictured fans were treated as foreign based on apparent ancestry.

Author
Conor Friedersdorf
Published
Accessed

Original post

John Doyle defends Bo French against John Cornyn’s criticism

Excerpt

"A Patriot acknowledging that Texans didn’t ask for their state to become a playground for the third world."

About this source

Doyle’s direct response rejects Cornyn’s racism characterization and defends French’s demographic argument.

Author
John Doyle
Published
Accessed

Analysis

Brandon Morse analyzes the dispute over Bo French’s UT post

Brandon Morse analyzes the dispute over Bo French’s UT post (opens in a new tab)Article conclusion and sections describing the French-aligned position.
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Article conclusion and sections describing the French-aligned position.

Excerpt

"They’re right, too."

About this source

Morse acknowledges objections to the post but substantially defends the underlying demographic concern and rejects treating that concern itself as racist.

Author
Brandon Morse
Published
Accessed

Original post

Raja Krishnamoorthi condemns Bo French’s post as xenophobic

Excerpt

"These young people were cheering for their university, and you chose to demonize them based solely on how they look."

About this source

Krishnamoorthi’s official congressional account directly responds to French’s displacement post.

Author
Raja Krishnamoorthi
Published
Accessed

Original post

Jake Lloyd Colglazier defends Bo French’s post

Excerpt

"The backlash against this perfectly reasonable post demonstrates the deleterious effect of mass immigration on our democratic system."

About this source

Colglazier’s direct defense quote-posting French’s first post.

Author
Jake Lloyd Colglazier
Published
Accessed

Original post

Savanah Hernandez says Bo French is correct

Excerpt

"Bo is 1000% correct."

About this source

Hernandez’s direct defense quote-posting French’s first post and arguing that critics misunderstand demographic change in Texas.

Author
Savanah Hernandez
Published
Accessed

Original post

Jon Rosenthal criticizes Bo French’s interpretation of the student-section image

Excerpt

"A man who can’t tell a Longhorn from a foreigner has no business regulating anything in TX."

About this source

Rosenthal’s direct response criticizes French for inferring foreign status from the fans’ appearance.

Author
Jon Rosenthal
Published
Accessed

Original post

Gina Hinojosa says Bo French is unfit to serve

Excerpt

"This man is unfit to serve."

About this source

Hinojosa’s direct response quote-posting French’s first post.

Author
Gina Hinojosa
Published
Accessed

Original post

Dustin Burrows says Bo French crossed the line

Excerpt

"You can oppose immigration policy without demeaning people because of their race or ethnicity."

About this source

Burrows’s direct response asks French to delete the post while distinguishing immigration-policy opposition from racial or ethnic denigration.

Author
Dustin Burrows
Published
Accessed

Original post

Drew Darby condemns Bo French’s post and requests an apology

Excerpt

"This is racism, plain and simple."

About this source

Darby’s direct response says French should delete the post and apologize, and argues the conduct is unbecoming of a Railroad Commission candidate.

Author
Drew Darby
Published
Accessed

Original post

Jared Patterson condemns Bo French’s post

Excerpt

"This is racist. It is wrong. And I condemn it without reservation."

About this source

Patterson’s direct response argues that immigration-policy disagreement does not justify demeaning people by race or ethnicity.

Author
Jared Patterson
Published
Accessed

Original post

John Cornyn calls Bo French’s post intolerant and racist

Excerpt

"Are other Republican elected officials going to condemn the intolerance and racism, or look the other way while it becomes normalized."

About this source

Cornyn’s direct response quote-posting French’s first post.

Author
John Cornyn
Published
Accessed

Original post

Bo French responds to John Cornyn’s condemnation

Excerpt

"Our state’s institutions have been overrun by illegal aliens and foreign nationals."

About this source

French’s direct response to Cornyn rejects the criticism and expands his argument to Texas institutions generally.

Author
Bo French
Published
Accessed

Interview

Bo French defends his UT student post on The Mark Davis Show

Bo French defends his UT student post on The Mark Davis Show (opens in a new tab)Episode titled “MON SEP 14 9 AM TX RR commission candidate @BoFrench on his Indian student post.”
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Episode titled “MON SEP 14 9 AM TX RR commission candidate @BoFrench on his Indian student post.”

Excerpt

"It’s not about race. It’s about policy, Mark."

About this source

Full radio episode containing French’s direct defense. French said he had nothing against the pictured people specifically and framed the dispute as whether policy should prioritize Americans or foreigners.

Author
Mark Davis and Bo French
Published
Accessed

Original post

Bo French says UT prioritizes foreigners over Texans

Excerpt

"I weep for the families in Texas who can’t get into UT because they prioritize foreigners over Texans."

About this source

French’s reply distinguishes his support for the football team from his allegation about UT admissions priorities.

Author
Bo French
Published
Accessed

Original post

Bo French says social media shows Americans displaced by foreigners

Excerpt

"Social media is exposing how many Americans have been displaced by foreigners."

About this source

Follow-up post in which French connected the images to a broader displacement claim.

Author
Bo French
Published
Accessed

Original post

Texas Longhorns post video of the Ohio State comeback celebration

Excerpt

"THAT'LL DO IT"

About this source

Official Texas Athletics post containing the stadium-celebration footage from which the still image used by Bo French was taken.

Author
Texas Longhorns
Published
Accessed

Case updates

Bo French's UT fan posts: want the next development?

Get an email if French, the University of Texas or Texas Republicans respond further, or if new statements about the posts are added.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

The newsletter

Follow disputes like this one.

New cases and significant updates to the record, in your inbox. Free.

You’ll confirm your subscription on Substack.

Share or embed this case

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Was Bo French’s UT Austin post racist?
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/cases/bo-french-ut-fans-foreigners-displacing-americans

The Dispute Index. "Was Bo French’s UT Austin post racist?". First published: 2026-09-15. Last updated: 2026-09-15. https://disputeindex.com/cases/bo-french-ut-fans-foreigners-displacing-americans