Disputes involving professional and international association football (soccer), including clubs, leagues, players, managers and the bodies that regulate them.
Published coverage on this page: 4+ cases · 24+ statements. Statements are ordered newest first.
Topic updates
Follow this topic
Get free email updates about Soccer. We will email you when we add or correct a case in this topic.
Enable JavaScript to request email updates about this topic.
We will send a confirmation email first. Every update email has a link to stop. How we handle your email.
England coach Thomas Tuchel said he might brief his players on UEFA's anti-racism protocol before playing Spain in Madrid. Spain coach Luis de la Fuente replied that there is no racism in Spain, and Tuchel said his message had been twisted.
Role at the time: Director of the Cadena SER radio program Carrusel Deportivo, speaking on Cadena SER
Defended or excused
Statement summary
Garrido says nobody told De la Fuente that Spain is racist and that the coach assumed someone had. He says the reporter was right that there is work to be done in the fight against racism.
Quotation excerpt
“Nobody has told Luis de la Fuente that Spain is racist, nobody. In other words, he has assumed that someone has said Spain is racist when that is not true. The journalist tells him that there is work to be done in the fight against racism.…”
Read full quotation
“Nobody has told Luis de la Fuente that Spain is racist, nobody. In other words, he has assumed that someone has said Spain is racist when that is not true. The journalist tells him that there is work to be done in the fight against racism. And that is true. (Translated from Spanish. Original: Nadie le ha dicho a Luis de la Fuente que España es racista, nadie. Es decir, él ha asumido que alguien ha dicho que España es racista cuando no es cierto. La periodista le dice que hay trabajo por hacer en la lucha contra el racismo. Y es cierto.)”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Cadena SER: Dani Garrido says you cannot say there is no racism in SpainArticle text, Garrido's remarks
What this label refers to
The case concerns whether Tuchel's remarks about informing England's players of the anti-racism protocol implied that Spain is racist. Garrido rejects the reading that anyone had called Spain racist and agrees that work remains against racism in Spain, which supports the concern raised before the match, so we labeled it a defense.
Role at the time: England head coach, at a pre-match news conference in Madrid
Defended or excused
Statement summary
Tuchel says he never talked about racism in Spain and only answered a question about what would happen if abuse occurred. He says he never expects racism and calls the dressing room the most anti-racist place on earth.
“I never talked about racism in Spain. I answered politely a question about what happens. I never expect racism and the dressing room is the most anti-racist place on earth.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Sky Sports: Thomas Tuchel unhappy as anti-racism protocol questions overshadow Nations League test in Spain · Sky SportsArticle text, Tuchel's answers at the pre-match news conference
What this label refers to
The case concerns whether Tuchel's remarks about informing England's players of the anti-racism protocol implied that Spain is racist. Tuchel says he never talked about racism in Spain and stands by his answer as a reply to a question about what happens if abuse occurs, so we labeled it a defense.
Role at the time: Spain head coach, at a pre-match news conference in Las Rozas
Challenged the characterization
Statement summary
Asked whether Tuchel's comments showed that Spain still had work to do against racism, De la Fuente says there is no racism in Spain, just as in England, and that none of them are racist. He asks that the message be passed on to Tuchel.
Quotation excerpt
“There is no racism in Spain. It is as clear-cut as that. There is no racism, exactly the same as in England. In Spain there is no racism. None of us are racist. (Translated from Spanish. Original: en España no hay racismo. Así de…”
Read full quotation
“There is no racism in Spain. It is as clear-cut as that. There is no racism, exactly the same as in England. In Spain there is no racism. None of us are racist. (Translated from Spanish. Original: en España no hay racismo. Así de contundente. No hay racismo, exactamente igual que en Inglaterra. En España no hay racismo. No somos racistas ninguno)”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Meridiano: De la Fuente denies racism and challenges TuchelArticle text, quotation of De la Fuente's answer
What this label refers to
The case concerns whether Tuchel's remarks about informing England's players of the anti-racism protocol implied that Spain is racist. De la Fuente rejects the suggestion that Spain has a racism problem rather than criticizing the briefing itself, so we labeled it as challenging the characterization.
Role at the time: Thailand's national football governing body; ruling of its Disciplinary and Ethics Committee
Condemned
Response to this claim
Park Hang-seo's conduct after the November 1 match, beckoning Pattaya United supporters to come down and face him and gesturing back at them while he was suspended for the game, was improper conduct in public that could lead to disorder at the venue.
Quotation excerpt
“Acting to protect players is permissible, but the expression must stay within the bounds of appropriateness and maturity and must not cause further conflict ... but instead he left the players' dressing room for the walkway and gestured…”
Read full quotation
“Acting to protect players is permissible, but the expression must stay within the bounds of appropriateness and maturity and must not cause further conflict ... but instead he left the players' dressing room for the walkway and gestured back at the opposing supporters, which was improper conduct in public that could lead to disorder at the venue (Translated from Thai. Original: การกระทำเพื่อปกป้องนักกีฬานั้นสามารถกระทำได้ แต่การแสดงออกต้องอยู่ภายใต้ขอบเขตของความเหมาะสม มีวุฒิภาวะ และไม่ก่อให้เกิดความขัดแย้งเพิ่มเติม ... แต่กลับปรากฏพฤติการณ์ออกจากห้องพักนักกีฬาไปยังบริเวณทางเดิน และแสดงท่าทางโต้ตอบกับกองเชียร์ฝ่ายตรงข้าม อันเป็นการแสดงกิริยาที่ไม่เหมาะสมต่อหน้าสาธารณชนอันอาจนำไปสู่ความไม่สงบเรียบร้อยในสถานที่จัดการแข่งขัน)”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)Results of the FA Thailand Disciplinary and Ethics Committee's 12th meeting of the 2026/27 season (in Thai) · Football Association of ThailandItem 1: Pattaya United vs. Kanchanaburi Power FC, November 1, 2026
Why we used this label
The reference point is Park Hang-seo's confrontation with Pattaya United supporters after the November 1 match, for which FA Thailand suspended him. The committee accepts that protecting players is permissible in principle, but it finds that the way Park confronted the supporters was improper public conduct and penalizes it. Accepting the aim does not change its conclusion about what he did, so we labeled it Condemned rather than Mixed or conditional.
Role at the time: Head coach of Kanchanaburi Power FC; statement issued through his management agency, DJ Management
Defended or excused
Response to this claim
Park Hang-seo's conduct after the November 1 match, beckoning Pattaya United supporters to come down and face him and gesturing back at them while he was suspended for the game, was improper conduct in public that could lead to disorder at the venue.
Quotation excerpt
“However, at the time he witnessed continuing personal insults and racist words and behavior directed at his player, and he protested to the spectators to stop them ... He did not turn away from a situation in which his player was being…”
Read full quotation
“However, at the time he witnessed continuing personal insults and racist words and behavior directed at his player, and he protested to the spectators to stop them ... He did not turn away from a situation in which his player was being unjustly insulted, and sought to fulfill his responsibility as a coach who must protect his players (Translated from Korean. Original: 그러나 당시 자신의 선수를 향해 지속적으로 이어지는 인격적인 모욕과 인종차별적 언행을 목격했고, 이를 중단시키기 위해 관중에게 항의했다 ... 자신의 선수가 부당한 모욕을 당하는 상황을 외면하지 않고, 선수를 보호해야 하는 지도자로서의 책임을 다하고자 했다)”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Park Hang-seo's agency says the abuse of his player John Baggio prompted his protest (Star News article in Korean)Statement by DJ Management, Park's management agency, quoted at length
Why we used this label
The reference point is Park Hang-seo's confrontation with Pattaya United supporters after the November 1 match, for which FA Thailand later suspended him. The statement says he protested to stop abuse he witnessed and presents that as part of a coach's duty to protect his players, which argues that the confrontation was justified. The agency also says Park knows a coach must control his emotions, but it does not say his response was wrong, so we labeled it Defended or excused rather than Mixed or conditional.
Role at the time: Chief sports writer for The Guardian, in his column
Condemned
Statement summary
Ronay writes that City's appeal defence, as reported, says the club's extra money came from the Abu Dhabi government, and argues that a government owner is hard to fit within the regulatory framework.
Quotation excerpt
“There are very obvious reasons why this is not desirable. Governments spy and wage war and break rules. They have a sacred trust to promote their own interests by any means necessary. It is hard to see how this kind of owner fits the…”
Read full quotation
“There are very obvious reasons why this is not desirable. Governments spy and wage war and break rules. They have a sacred trust to promote their own interests by any means necessary. It is hard to see how this kind of owner fits the regulatory framework.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)How can playing for Manchester City fit into Marc Guéhi's moral universe?Column passages on Guéhi and on the Abu Dhabi government's funding of the club
What this label refers to
Ronay questions whether a government-funded owner is a fit and proper influence on the club and says it is hard to see how such an owner fits the rules, so we labeled it Condemned.
Role at the time: Chief sports writer for The Guardian, in his column
Condemned
Statement summary
In a Guardian column on Marc Guéhi's principles, Ronay writes that Guéhi is playing for a club that has been convicted of cheating and lying, and that if other clubs are sticking to the rules this amounts to deceit, stolen win bonuses and stolen glory.
“Guéhi is playing for a club that has been convicted of cheating and lying. People are free to disagree with the rules. But if others are sticking to them, this amounts to deceit, stolen win bonuses, stolen glory.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)How can playing for Manchester City fit into Marc Guéhi's moral universe?Column passages on Guéhi and on the Abu Dhabi government's funding of the club
What this label refers to
Ronay treats the commission's findings as cheating that took bonuses and glory from clubs that kept to the rules, so we labeled it Condemned.
Role at the time: Chair of the Independent Football Regulator, on The Rest Is Football podcast
Explicitly stayed out
Response to this claim
Gary Neville said in a Sky Sports article published on October 3, 2026 that "It's hard to see how the Man City owners can comply with the owners' and directors' test in this country if the verdict remains" and that the only appropriate punishment is "to apply the owners' and directors' test, firstly".
Quotation excerpt
“I am not going to get pushed into making any judgement on this until we've seen all of those questions being answered, and then we will have to decide whether we're going to mount our own investigation and come to a conclusion on that and…”
Read full quotation
“I am not going to get pushed into making any judgement on this until we've seen all of those questions being answered, and then we will have to decide whether we're going to mount our own investigation and come to a conclusion on that and what we're going to do.
And pre-empting that would be a colossal mistake. ... We have the power to ask an owner to step away from a club if we believe that they run a club in a way that is neither fit, fair or done with propriety”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Man City: Independent Football Regulator confirms it has 'absolute power' to force owners to sell the clubParagraphs quoting Kogan's interview on The Rest Is Football podcast
Why we used this label
Kogan describes the regulator's power to remove an owner but refuses to make any judgement on City's owners until the questions in the case are answered. We labeled it Explicitly stayed out.
Role at the time: Culture Secretary (Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport), in a talkSPORT interview
Mixed or conditional
Statement summary
Speaking to talkSPORT, Nandy said investors who own clubs are custodians with a responsibility to uphold the rules, and that the government gave the regulator the power to act if a club is not in safe hands. She said City has the right to defend itself and that the matter has not reached that point.
Quotation excerpt
“I want to be crystal clear that, whilst we are really grateful to investors who come from all over the world to invest in our clubs and help to ensure their viability and their success, they are custodians, both of their clubs and of the…”
Read full quotation
“I want to be crystal clear that, whilst we are really grateful to investors who come from all over the world to invest in our clubs and help to ensure their viability and their success, they are custodians, both of their clubs and of the game ... They have a responsibility to play by the rules and uphold the rules. ... We’re not there yet. It's absolutely right that Manchester City get the right to defend themselves and they do strongly refute the allegations. But in the event that they do not believe that a club is in safe hands, we’ve fought tooth and nail to give the Independent Regulator the power.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)U.K. Government Satisfied With 'Most Extreme' Outcome in Man City CaseParagraphs quoting Lisa Nandy's talkSPORT interview and David Kogan's Times Radio interview
What this label refers to
Nandy says owners must uphold the rules and the regulator can act if a club is not in safe hands, but she makes any action depend on the appeal and says City is entitled to defend itself. We labeled it Mixed or conditional.
Maresca says City's titles are not tainted, expresses complete trust in its leadership and expects the club to win its appeal against the commission's decision.
“I completely trust, 100%, the owner, the CEO, the sporting director, all the organisation.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Maresca says City's titles are not tainted and backs its appealFriday news conference; paragraph beginning He added on Friday
What this label refers to
Maresca says City's titles are not tainted, expresses complete trust in its leadership and expects the club to win its appeal against the commission's decision.
Role at the time: Former Liverpool player and football pundit, on The Overlap Fan Debate
Condemned
Statement summary
Speaking on The Overlap Fan Debate, Jamie Carragher said a points deduction covering one season would let City be relegated and come back, and that the punishment should instead last three to five years so that players would move on.
Quotation excerpt
“If the people talk about [a penalty of] 80 points or 100 points, but that’s just over one season that gets you relegated and then you come back again.
And I think players, a few of them would leave, but I think some of them would say, ‘I…”
Read full quotation
“If the people talk about [a penalty of] 80 points or 100 points, but that’s just over one season that gets you relegated and then you come back again.
And I think players, a few of them would leave, but I think some of them would say, ‘I could put up with that for a year’.
But I think, because this has gone on for so long, I do think the punishment should be over a number of years, three to five years, and then players would move on.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Carragher proposes multi-year punishment for Manchester CityFinal Carragher quotation beginning But I think, because this has gone on for so long
What this label refers to
Relative to the commission's finding that City used sham sponsorships and related arrangements to break the Premier League's financial rules, Carragher argues for a punishment lasting three to five years because the case has gone on so long. Calling for a sanction that severe treats the breaches as serious, so we used Condemned. Mixed or conditional is the closest alternative, because the Press Association report presents his proposal as applying if City's appeal fails, but his own words attach no condition to it.
Role at the time: Sports journalist and Sporting Intelligence publisher
Condemned
Statement summary
Harris supports the commission's findings and calls them a guilty verdict. He notes that City is appealing and that sanctions will follow only after the remaining process.
“All of which is immensely damning. This is the verdict on the case. Guilty. City can appeal, and are doing so.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Manchester City are now officially guilty of sustained corruption over ...Harris's commentary after the quoted league statement
What this label refers to
Relative to the alleged sham sponsorship scheme, Harris endorses the findings and expressly criticizes the conduct.
Role at the time: Applicant, in a reply brief filed by its lawyers in federal court in Miami
Condemned
Response to this claim
Gianni Infantino's FIFA Forward Enterprise plan was a vehicle for Infantino and a small circle to profit from FIFA's most valuable assets, and may amount to criminal mismanagement under Article 158 of the Swiss Criminal Code.
“UEFA is preparing a criminal complaint alleging Infantino and, potentially, the FIFA officers who developed FFE, violated Article 158 of the Swiss Criminal Code. It is planning to submit that complaint to the competent Swiss authorities.”
Read the original text (opens in a new tab)In re Ex Parte Application of UEFA, No. 1:26-cv-25872 (S.D. Fla.), UEFA reply in support of its Section 1782 application (Dkt. 28) · UEFAReply brief, pages 1-4
Why we used this label
The reference point is Infantino's handling of the FIFA Forward Enterprise plan, which UEFA says may amount to criminal mismanagement. UEFA tells the court it is preparing a complaint alleging that Infantino and possibly other FIFA officers violated the Swiss criminal mismanagement provision, which condemns his handling of the plan.
Role at the time: Sky Sports pundit and Salford City co-owner, in a Sky Sports article
Condemned
Response to this claim
Gary Neville said in a Sky Sports article published on October 3, 2026 that "It's hard to see how the Man City owners can comply with the owners' and directors' test in this country if the verdict remains" and that the only appropriate punishment is "to apply the owners' and directors' test, firstly".
Quotation excerpt
“It’s hard to see how the Man City owners can comply with the owners’ and directors’ test in this country if the verdict remains.
The reality is, because of improper owners of clubs, there are a lot stricter rules in place. It’ll be…”
Read full quotation
“It’s hard to see how the Man City owners can comply with the owners’ and directors’ test in this country if the verdict remains.
The reality is, because of improper owners of clubs, there are a lot stricter rules in place. It’ll be difficult for the Man City owners to retain their status.
Clubs are protected assets, community assets, because of the meaning of them to fans and people of a city, so owners have to comply with the rules and laws set out in the test.
The only appropriate punishment is to apply the owners’ and directors’ test, firstly, and then to look at the achievements over the period and determine whether they should still stand.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Man City owners cannot 'retain status' if guilty verdict stands after appeal, says Gary Neville · Sky SportsArticle text quoting Neville on the owners' and directors' test
Why we used this label
Neville argues that the owners would struggle to keep their status if the verdict stands and that the owners' test, rather than fines or points, is the right punishment. That treats losing the club as the proper consequence, so we labeled it Condemned.
Role at the time: Manchester City supporters' trust, in an emailed reply from its interim vice treasurer
Explicitly stayed out
Statement summary
The Citizens Trust, a Manchester City supporters' trust, declined to comment on the commission's findings, saying that as a member-led trust representing the whole fanbase it must stay neutral until the appeals process is finished.
Quotation excerpt
“As mentioned in the statement, we are having to maintain neutrality on this until the appeals process is finished - being a democratic and member-led supporters trust means we've got to take representing the fanbase extremely seriously and…”
Read full quotation
“As mentioned in the statement, we are having to maintain neutrality on this until the appeals process is finished - being a democratic and member-led supporters trust means we've got to take representing the fanbase extremely seriously and we feel it would be unwise to comment in the media at this time.”
Read the full email
Hi Ben,
Thanks for getting in touch, unfortunately we're not in a position to be speaking to media at this point.
As mentioned in the statement, we are having to maintain neutrality on this until the appeals process is finished - being a democratic and member-led supporters trust means we've got to take representing the fanbase extremely seriously and we feel it would be unwise to comment in the media at this time.
By all means read out/refer to the statement as much as you'd like, and when we've got to some sense of finality on this we will be more than happy to speak to press, but for now we've got to engage with our members and plan for all outcomes.
Thanks
Nicola
Interim Vice Treasurer
Emailed reply from The Citizens Trust to Dispute Index on the Manchester City decision · The Citizens TrustEmailed reply from The Citizens Trust, October 2, 2026 (UTC).
What this label refers to
The reference point is the commission's finding that Manchester City used sham sponsorships to get around the Premier League's financial rules. Asked what its members want the club to disclose and whether the club should publish the records its chief executive described, the Trust said it must stay neutral until the appeals process is finished and would not comment in the media, so we used Explicitly stayed out. The closest competing label is Mixed or conditional; it loses because the Trust takes no position on the finding and expressly declines to give one for now.
Role at the time: England's football governing body, in a statement on its website
Explicitly stayed out
Statement summary
In an October 2, 2026 statement, the Football Association said the independent commission's decision has significant implications for the integrity of the game and that it is considering the decision and will take action where appropriate. It said it does not intend to comment further while proceedings between the Premier League and Manchester City remain ongoing, and will continue to monitor developments.
“As proceedings between the Premier League and Manchester City Football Club remain ongoing, we do not intend to comment further at this stage.”
Read the official statement (opens in a new tab)FA statement on Manchester City: Statement issued following the Independent Commission's decision (The FA, October 2, 2026) · The Football AssociationFull statement (two paragraphs)
What this label refers to
The reference point is the commission's finding that Manchester City used sham sponsorships to get around the Premier League's financial rules. The FA calls the decision significant for the integrity of the game and says it may take action, but it does not say whether it accepts the finding or how it judges City's conduct, and it closes further comment while proceedings continue. We labeled it Explicitly declined. The closest competing label is Condemned, which would need the FA to criticize City's conduct itself rather than note the decision's importance.
Role at the time: Associate professor in football finance at the University of Liverpool, in an emailed statement sent through the university's press office
Mixed or conditional
Statement summary
Kieran Maguire, a football finance academic at the University of Liverpool, said in an email that the rise in the sponsorship totals the commission called sham contracts matches a similar rise in Manchester City's overall commercial revenue, which the club needed to fund heavy spending on player wages and transfers. He said judging the Fordham image-rights deal would require comparing it with similar deals at other clubs to see whether City's was at market value.
Quotation excerpt
“The increase in the 'sham contract' commercial totals coincides with a similar rise overall in Manchester City's overall commercial revenues. Such an increase was required to allow the club to fund significant investment in the playing…”
Read full quotation
“The increase in the 'sham contract' commercial totals coincides with a similar rise overall in Manchester City's overall commercial revenues. Such an increase was required to allow the club to fund significant investment in the playing squad in terms of wages and transfers. ... To assess the legitimacy of the Fordham Image Rights deal ideally would want to see similar deals involving other clubs to determine whether or not City's was at market value.”
Read the full email
Hi,
Have picked up the key figures in the tables below.
The increase in the 'sham contract' commercial totals coincides with a similar rise overall in Manchester City's overall commercial revenues. Such an increase was required to allow the club to fund significant investment in the playing squad in terms of wages and transfers.
To assess the legitimacy of the Fordham Image Rights deal ideally would want to see similar deals involving other clubs to determine whether or not City's was at market value.
Regards
Kieran
Emailed statement from Kieran Maguire to Dispute Index on the Manchester City decision's figures · Kieran MaguireEmailed statement from Kieran Maguire, sent through the University of Liverpool press office, October 2, 2026 (UTC).
What this label refers to
The reference point is the commission's finding that Manchester City used sham sponsorships to get around the Premier League's financial rules. Maguire ties the growth of the disputed totals to the revenue the club needed for squad spending, without saying whether the contracts were shams, and says the legitimacy of the Fordham arrangement depends on whether it was at market value, which he would test against comparable deals. That makes his assessment depend on an unresolved condition, so we used Mixed or conditional. The closest competing label is Condemned, because his account of why the revenue was needed is consistent with the commission's reasoning; it loses because he does not say the arrangements broke the rules.
Role at the time: Conservative shadow minister for culture, media and sport, in a statement reported by ITV News
Condemned
Statement summary
The Conservative shadow minister said Burnham's intervention in support of City's owners was frankly extraordinary while the club faced unprecedented allegations, and that Burnham was publicly backing the owners while the investigation continued.
Quotation excerpt
“Andy Burnham’s intervention in support of Manchester City’s owners is frankly extraordinary.
The club face unprecedented allegations and fans are horrified by what they are reading in the papers, yet Burnham is publicly backing the owners…”
Read full quotation
“Andy Burnham’s intervention in support of Manchester City’s owners is frankly extraordinary.
The club face unprecedented allegations and fans are horrified by what they are reading in the papers, yet Burnham is publicly backing the owners even as the investigation continues.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)'Wrongdoing' at Manchester City should lead to 'appropriate consequences', says Downing StreetParagraphs quoting the Downing Street spokesperson, Burnham and Louie French
What this label refers to
French criticizes the Prime Minister for publicly backing City's owners while the case continues and says no club or owner should be above the rules, which rejects political support for the owners keeping the club. We labeled it Condemned.
Role at the time: Sky Sports pundit and former Liverpool player, in his Daily Telegraph column
Condemned
Response to this claim
Gary Neville said in a Sky Sports article published on October 3, 2026 that "It's hard to see how the Man City owners can comply with the owners' and directors' test in this country if the verdict remains" and that the only appropriate punishment is "to apply the owners' and directors' test, firstly".
“The club can only heal and recover from the shame of their guilt once the custodians recognise they have failed in their duty and sell up.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Man City sale is only way to 'heal from shame of their guilt', says Jamie Carragher (PA Media)Opening paragraphs, quoting Carragher's Daily Telegraph column
Why we used this label
Carragher writes that City can only recover once its owners accept they have failed in their duty and sell the club, a call for them to give it up. We labeled it Condemned.
Role at the time: Former Manchester United player and Sky Sports pundit, speaking on The Overlap's Stick to Football podcast
Condemned
Response to this claim
The Premier League said on September 29, 2026 that an independent commission found that between the 2009/10 and 2017/18 seasons Manchester City arranged "sham" contracts with a number of its commercial partners as part of a disguised funding scheme, in which the sponsors were required to pay only a portion of the relevant fees and Abu Dhabi United Group Investment & Development Ltd, which owned the club, funded the remainder, and that "by its conduct the club clearly intended to circumvent the PL Rules."
Quotation excerpt
“The biggest consequence would be the removal of the owners. That is the only consequence, if I was Manchester City, that I would be worried about. And as a fan of Manchester City, if you wanted to keep the investment that you've currently…”
Read full quotation
“The biggest consequence would be the removal of the owners. That is the only consequence, if I was Manchester City, that I would be worried about. And as a fan of Manchester City, if you wanted to keep the investment that you've currently got, that would be the one that I would be most concerned. However, if you're in football and you're thinking about a consequence, what can be more serious than industrial-level financial doping that we've seen and they've been found guilty of?”
Relative to the proposition that City used sponsorship contracts the commission described as shams, and related arrangements, to misstate its finances and circumvent the Premier League's financial rules, as the commission found, Neville treats the finding as established ("they've been found guilty of") and describes it in his own words as "industrial-level financial doping." He argues about the consequence for City and for football, not about the procedure. That endorses the finding, so we used Condemned. The closest competing label is Mixed or conditional, because much of the passage concerns what sanction would matter most, but he attaches no condition to the finding.
Role at the time: Etihad Airways, in a corporate statement
Challenged the characterization
Response to this claim
Etihad Airways, City's principal shirt sponsor, said on September 30, 2026 that it "categorically rejects any finding, conclusion or implication that suggests the airline has ever been involved in improper commercial arrangements," and that "At no time did the Premier League reach out to or engage with Etihad in the process associated with the commission's opinion."
Quotation excerpt
“Etihad Airways has reviewed the Premier League commission's published opinion relating to the disciplinary proceedings involving Manchester City, together with the Premier League's public communication of its findings.
Etihad categorically…”
Read full quotation
“Etihad Airways has reviewed the Premier League commission's published opinion relating to the disciplinary proceedings involving Manchester City, together with the Premier League's public communication of its findings.
Etihad categorically rejects any finding, conclusion or implication that suggests the airline has ever been involved in improper commercial arrangements.
The Premier League's public communication of the commission's findings, following a period of selective leaks and reporting, has further created damaging implications for Etihad despite the airline not being named in the redacted published findings.
At no time did the Premier League reach out to or engage with Etihad in the process associated with the commission's opinion. Etihad was therefore never given the opportunity by the Premier League to be represented, to provide relevant information, or to ensure the accuracy and fairness of information relied upon in reaching conclusions that may now be interpreted as reflecting adversely on the airline.
Etihad is deeply concerned by the way this matter has been communicated publicly. The lack of clarity and transparency, together with the selective disclosure of information, has created damaging implications for Etihad despite the airline not being named in the published decision. The Premier League must take responsibility for the consequences of the way in which these findings have been presented.
Etihad is immensely proud of its longstanding relationship with Manchester City. The Etihad name has been proudly carried by the club and its stadium for many years, as part of a partnership that has connected us with millions of supporters around the world. Our commitment to Manchester City, its supporters and our shared partnership remains strong.
We stand with the club, its supporters and our wider Etihad community as Manchester City challenges the commission's conclusions through the processes available to it.
Etihad will seek the relevant legal counsel on the options and recourse available to protect its interests.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Man City charges: Club sponsor Etihad Airways considering legal action against Premier League · Sky Sports'Etihad Airways statement in full' section; also the paragraphs on other sponsors
Why we used this label
Relative to the proposition that City used sponsorship contracts the commission described as shams, and related arrangements, to misstate its finances and circumvent the Premier League's financial rules, as the commission found, Etihad addresses the airline's own role and the league's handling of the findings. It rejects any finding or implication that the airline was involved in improper commercial arrangements, criticizes how the findings were communicated, and says it stands with the club as the club challenges the commission's conclusions. It says nothing about whether City's contracts were genuine. We used Challenges the characterization because the statement disputes how the findings describe or imply the airline's involvement rather than saying what City did. The closest competing label is Denied, which would suggest Etihad denied what the commission found against City. Mixed or conditional does not fit because the statement's positions point the same way.
Role at the time: Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, in an interview with the BBC's political editor
Defended or excused
Statement summary
Asked by the BBC whether he was concerned that City's owners would now sell the club, Burnham said he would be really concerned to lose them and called them a huge partner in building modern Manchester.
“I would be really concerned to lose them.
They've been such a huge partner in the building of modern Manchester and obviously the building of Manchester City into the global force that it is.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Andy Burnham 'really concerned' if Man City owners sell up after rule breaches (BBC News) · BBCParagraphs quoting Burnham on Everton and on leaping to one side
What this label refers to
Burnham says he would not want to lose City's owners and praises what they have built in the club and the city, which backs their keeping the club. We labeled it Defended or excused, though he also said it would be wrong for him to intervene.
Ronay argues that the spending advantages described in the commission's findings taint City's sporting achievements.
“This is an era that will now be defined by sham-ball, trophies hoisted with a hand behind your back and a thumb on the scale.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Building of the Pep supremacy is an era that will be defined by sham-ballDiscussion of transfer spending and Guardiola's City trophies
What this label refers to
Relative to the alleged sham sponsorship scheme, Ronay endorses the findings and condemns the advantage he argues the scheme created.
Role at the time: Chair of the Independent Football Regulator, in a statement on the regulator's website
Mixed or conditional
Statement summary
In a statement on the regulator's website on September 30, 2026, Independent Football Regulator chair David Kogan said the independent commission's decision "raises serious issues." He said the regulator can assess the suitability of owners, directors and executives and will use those powers "where there is clear evidence of wrongdoing by individuals," that this includes "taking account of findings made by the Leagues," but that because the proceedings are ongoing it will "await further developments." He ended: "For now, we have no further comment."
Quotation excerpt
“The independent commission’s decision raises serious issues.
The IFR has powers to assess the suitability of owners, directors and executives and we will use these powers where appropriate, in the interests of protecting the…”
Read full quotation
“The independent commission’s decision raises serious issues.
The IFR has powers to assess the suitability of owners, directors and executives and we will use these powers where appropriate, in the interests of protecting the sustainability, honesty and integrity of English football where there is clear evidence of wrongdoing by individuals.
This includes taking account of findings made by the Leagues. However, as the proceedings remain ongoing between Manchester City and the Premier League we will await further developments.
We hope it can be resolved quickly for the sake of fans. For now, we have no further comment.”
Relative to the proposition that City used sponsorship contracts the commission described as shams, and related arrangements, to misstate its finances and circumvent the Premier League's financial rules, as the commission found, Kogan calls the decision serious and says the regulator can take account of findings made by the leagues, but he conditions any action on clear evidence of wrongdoing by individuals and says the regulator will wait while the proceedings continue. That combines an assessment with an express condition, so we used Mixed or conditional. The closest competing label is Explicitly stayed out, because he ends with "no further comment," but he first gives an assessment and describes how the regulator would act.
Dani Garrido is a Spanish sports journalist who has directed Carrusel Deportivo, the sports radio program of Cadena SER, since 2016. He also writes a column for the sports daily AS.
Luis de la Fuente is a Spanish football manager and former defender who has been head coach of the Spain men's national team since December 2022, after years coaching Spain's youth teams. Spain won the 2023 UEFA Nations League, Euro 2024 and the 2026 FIFA World Cup under him.
Thomas Tuchel is a German football manager who has been head coach of the England men's national team since January 2025. He previously managed Borussia Dortmund, Paris Saint-Germain, Chelsea, with whom he won the 2021 UEFA Champions League, and Bayern Munich.
Park Hang-seo is a South Korean football coach and former player. He was an assistant coach under Guus Hiddink on South Korea's 2002 World Cup team, then managed K League clubs including Gyeongnam FC, Jeonnam Dragons and Sangju Sangmu. As head coach of Vietnam's national team from 2017 to 2023, he won the 2018 AFF Championship and, with the under-22 team, the 2019 Southeast Asian Games gold medal. He was a vice-president of the Korea Football Association from 2025 to 2026, and in May 2026 Thai club Kanchanaburi Power FC named him its head coach.
Barney Ronay is an English sportswriter and the chief sports writer for The Guardian. He writes columns and match reports on football, cricket and other sports, appears on the paper's Football Weekly podcast, and was named football journalist of the year at the 2020 Sports Journalists' Association awards. His books include The Manager and How Football (Almost) Came Home.
David Kogan OBE is a British media executive and the chair of the Independent Football Regulator. The regulator's website says he has had a 45-year career in television and sport, negotiating television rights deals for sporting bodies including the Premier League and the English Football League, and that he is a former managing director of Reuters Television and former chief executive of the Magnum photo agency. He was appointed chair for a five-year term, announced on October 6, 2025. He co-founded Reel Enterprises and the Women's Sports Group. His earlier board positions included Channel 4 and the Foreign and Commonwealth Office's Services Board.
Lisa Nandy is a British Labour politician who has been Member of Parliament for Wigan since May 2010. She has been Secretary of State for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport since July 20, 2026, according to GOV.UK, which says she held the earlier title of Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport from July 5, 2024 to July 20, 2026. Before entering Parliament she worked at the homelessness charity Centrepoint and then at The Children's Society. She studied politics at Newcastle University and is the author of All In: How We Build a Country That Works.
Enzo Maresca is an Italian football manager and former midfielder. He became Manchester City manager in June 2026 after managing Leicester City and Chelsea. His earlier coaching work included Manchester City academy and first-team roles. As a player, he represented clubs including Juventus, Sevilla and West Bromwich Albion.
Jamie Carragher is an English football analyst and former professional footballer who spent his whole career at Liverpool, making 737 appearances and serving as vice-captain for ten years. He won the UEFA Champions League with Liverpool and earned 38 senior England caps. Since retiring in 2013 he has worked as a pundit for Sky Sports, as part of CBS Sports' Champions League coverage and as football columnist for The Telegraph.
Nick Harris is a sports journalist and publisher of Sporting Intelligence. His reporting examines sports finance, governance and corruption, including World Cup bidding, doping and football-club finances. He previously wrote for the Mail on Sunday and publishes investigations and sports-salary data through his newsletter.
Gary Neville is an English football pundit, businessman and former professional footballer who spent his whole playing career at Manchester United, where he was captain for five years. He won eight Premier League titles and two UEFA Champions League titles and was inducted into the Premier League Hall of Fame in 2025. He has worked as a pundit for Sky Sports, and he founded the sports media company The Overlap, whose programmes include the Stick to Football podcast.
Kieran Maguire is a British chartered accountant and academic who studies the finances of football clubs. He is an associate professor in football finance at the University of Liverpool's Management School and runs Price of Football, a website on club finances. He has worked in financial education since 1989. His teaching awards include the 2011 PQ award for best UK public-sector finance lecturer and Manchester Metropolitan University teaching awards.