Kieran Maguire
Role at the time: Associate professor in football finance at the University of Liverpool, in an emailed statement sent through the university's press office
Statement summary
Kieran Maguire, a football finance academic at the University of Liverpool, said in an email that the rise in the sponsorship totals the commission called sham contracts matches a similar rise in Manchester City's overall commercial revenue, which the club needed to fund heavy spending on player wages and transfers. He said judging the Fordham image-rights deal would require comparing it with similar deals at other clubs to see whether City's was at market value.
“The increase in the 'sham contract' commercial totals coincides with a similar rise overall in Manchester City's overall commercial revenues. Such an increase was required to allow the club to fund significant investment in the playing squad in terms of wages and transfers. ... To assess the legitimacy of the Fordham Image Rights deal ideally would want to see similar deals involving other clubs to determine whether or not City's was at market value.”
Read the full email
Hi, Have picked up the key figures in the tables below. The increase in the 'sham contract' commercial totals coincides with a similar rise overall in Manchester City's overall commercial revenues. Such an increase was required to allow the club to fund significant investment in the playing squad in terms of wages and transfers. To assess the legitimacy of the Fordham Image Rights deal ideally would want to see similar deals involving other clubs to determine whether or not City's was at market value. Regards Kieran
Why we used this label
The reference point is the commission's finding that Manchester City used sham sponsorships to get around the Premier League's financial rules. Maguire ties the growth of the disputed totals to the revenue the club needed for squad spending, without saying whether the contracts were shams, and says the legitimacy of the Fordham arrangement depends on whether it was at market value, which he would test against comparable deals. That makes his assessment depend on an unresolved condition, so we used Mixed or conditional. The closest competing label is Condemned, because his account of why the revenue was needed is consistent with the commission's reasoning; it loses because he does not say the arrangements broke the rules.