Mark Z. Barabak
Role at the time: Political columnist, Los Angeles Times
Statement summary
Mark Z. Barabak says asking California voters to try Hilton is unobjectionable, but criticizes the ad's sexual presentation and says Hilton should leave advertising to someone else.
“What the spot tries to do, convince folks in this left-leaning redoubt to be venturesome and vote for Hilton, is not the least offensive, though your friendly political columnist, hardly a prude, found the execution a bit, well, icky.”
Why we used this label
The case asks whether Steve Hilton's Just Try It ad was an appropriate way to campaign. Barabak writes that the ad's aim of persuading voters to try Hilton "is not the least offensive" but that he found "the execution a bit, well, icky" and closes by saying Hilton "should leave the advertising to someone else". That objects to the ad's content, so we labeled it Condemned. The closest competing label is Mixed or conditional, since he accepts the ad's goal; it loses because he objects to the ad as it was made and says nothing in its defense.