Fred Davis is a Republican political advertising consultant and the founder of Strategic Perception. He has produced advertising for presidential, congressional and gubernatorial campaigns, following an earlier career in corporate advertising. He was chief creative consultant for John McCain's 2008 presidential campaign and creative director for the Republican National Committee at the party's 2008 convention.
Role at the time: Republican political advertising consultant
Defended or excused
Statement summary
Fred Davis praises the ad's writing and attention-getting design, but tells the Los Angeles Times that he cannot imagine it gaining Hilton a vote.
“I think it’s a brilliantly done ad … wonderfully written. … I can’t imagine it gaining him one vote.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Mark Z. Barabak on Hilton's campaign ad, with Davis and Spillane interviewsOpening assessment; "What do the pros say?"; final paragraph
Why we used this label
The case asks whether Steve Hilton's Just Try It ad was an appropriate way to campaign. Davis calls it "a brilliantly done ad" and "wonderfully written" before saying "I can't imagine it gaining him one vote." That approves of the ad itself, so we labeled it Defended or excused. The closest competing label is Mixed or conditional; it loses because his doubt is a prediction about votes, not an objection to the ad's content.
Republican Steve Hilton's Just Try It ad shows two young women, one guiding the other's hand to mark a ballot for him. Sonja Shaw and Michael Gates, who have campaigned with him, condemned it, while Hilton calls it satire.