Steve Benen says Trump keeps leaning into racism with his dirt remarks to Yamiche Alcindor and other Black critics
Steve BenenProducer for The Rachel Maddow Show and editor of MaddowBlog, writing on MS NOW
Benen writes that Alcindor, ABC News reporter Rachel Scott and Barack Obama are all Black and that Trump has told each of them he has a problem with what he assumes is their familiarity with dirt. He says the racism of Trump's attacks is sometimes subtle and that sometimes Trump abandons any pretense of restraint.
“The problem isn't only the familiarity of the Republican's rhetoric, it's also what the targets of this particular attack have in common: Scott, Obama and Alcindor are all Black, and they have all been told by Trump that he has a problem with what he assumes is a familiarity with "dirt." Sometimes the racism of Trump's attacks is subtle, and sometimes he abandons the pretense of restraint altogether.”
Analysis

Where this statement fits
Trump tells NBC reporter Yamiche Alcindor she would not notice broken windows "from where you come"; critics call the remark racist
On November 16, 2026, as President Donald Trump took questions outside the White House before leaving for Asia, NBC News White House correspondent Yamiche Alcindor asked: "Mr. President, what do you say to critics who say you were too focused on D.C. construction projects while our airline systems were crumbling, given the fact that Republicans have been in control?" Three days earlier, a rare nationwide FAA ground stop had halted U.S. air traffic. Trump answered that the White House is "flawless," then told Alcindor, "I know you don't see dirt," and said that "you never noticed broken windows, obviously, from where you come. I don't know. But we had 18 broken windows." When she pressed him on responsibility and on funding for the air traffic system, he said "you're so pathetic," told her "You don't have talent" and said "losers like you" ask why he is focused on the White House. Trump did not say what he meant by "from where you come." Alcindor is Black and was born in Miami to parents who immigrated from Haiti. Commentators and Democrats including Patrick Gaspard, Jaime Harrison, Mehdi Hasan, Sunny Hostin and MS NOW writers Jarvis DeBerry and Steve Benen condemned the remarks, and several of them called them racist. We did not find a public response from the White House or NBC News as of November 17, 2026.
Source and context
Analysis
About this source
Steve Benen compares Trump's remark to Alcindor with his comments about dirt directed at ABC News reporter Rachel Scott in May and at Barack Obama before the midterm elections.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Before the quotation
Benen recalls that in May Trump told ABC News reporter Rachel Scott she could understand dirt better than he could, and that Trump later said Barack Obama does not notice dirt and filth.
After the quotation
He then quotes his MS NOW colleague Jarvis DeBerry's column arguing that Trump seemed to be calling Black people dirty.
How this statement is classified
The label describes this statement's response within the context above.
Why this label?
Benen places Trump's remark to Alcindor in a pattern of racist attacks on Black people who questioned his renovation projects, so we labeled it Condemned.
- Recorded on
- Published here
More from this case
Read the full caseSunny Hostin says telling a Black person they don't see dirt is a racial trope
“Saying that a Black person doesn't see dirt or filth is a racial trope that has been used for decades to dehumanize Black people.”Read statement
Jaime Harrison calls Trump's remarks to Yamiche Alcindor unhinged and racist
“.@Yamiche is the gold standard in journalism. She is fair. She is thorough. She is brilliant. She deserves so much better than the unhinged and racist utterances of one of the worst people to ever occupy the White House.”Read statement
Jarvis DeBerry calls Trump's broken-windows remark to Yamiche Alcindor racist
“Trump seemed to be making a commentary about Black people in general, calling us dirty. And not just dirty but oblivious to dirt. But even if he was trying to say that there is no dirt to see on the White House, the rest of his disrespectful comment is unmistakably clear: He said Alcindor wouldn't notice broken windows because of where she's from.”Read statement
Share or embed this statement
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Steve Benen says Trump keeps leaning into racism with his dirt remarks to Yamiche Alcindor and other Black critics
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/events/9570-benen-writes-that-alcindor-abc-news-reporter-rachel
Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.
The Dispute Index. "Steve Benen says Trump keeps leaning into racism with his dirt remarks to Yamiche Alcindor and other Black critics". First published: 2026-11-18. Last updated: 2026-11-18. https://disputeindex.com/events/9570-benen-writes-that-alcindor-abc-news-reporter-rachel