Trump tells NBC reporter Yamiche Alcindor she would not notice broken windows "from where you come"; critics call the remark racist

Asked on November 16, 2026, about critics of his focus on Washington construction projects after the FAA ground stop, President Trump told NBC's Yamiche Alcindor, "I know you don't see dirt." Jaime Harrison, Patrick Gaspard and other critics called the remarks racist.

President Trump answers NBC News correspondent Yamiche Alcindor's question about his focus on Washington construction projects outside the White House on November 16, 2026.

Excerpt from 3:41 to 6:48 of the White House video. DI added its logo in the corner.

Video: The White House. Public domain (U.S. government work) (opens in a new tab)

Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: 3:41 to 6:48)

Case period:

Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated

Overview

On November 16, 2026, as President Donald Trump took questions outside the White House before leaving for Asia, NBC News White House correspondent Yamiche Alcindor asked: "Mr. President, what do you say to critics who say you were too focused on D.C. construction projects while our airline systems were crumbling, given the fact that Republicans have been in control?" Three days earlier, a rare nationwide FAA ground stop had halted U.S. air traffic.

Trump answered that the White House is "flawless," then told Alcindor, "I know you don't see dirt," and said that "you never noticed broken windows, obviously, from where you come. I don't know. But we had 18 broken windows." When she pressed him on responsibility and on funding for the air traffic system, he said "you're so pathetic," told her "You don't have talent" and said "losers like you" ask why he is focused on the White House. Trump did not say what he meant by "from where you come."

Alcindor is Black and was born in Miami to parents who immigrated from Haiti. Commentators and Democrats including Patrick Gaspard, Jaime Harrison, Mehdi Hasan, Sunny Hostin and MS NOW writers Jarvis DeBerry and Steve Benen condemned the remarks, and several of them called them racist. We did not find a public response from the White House or NBC News as of November 17, 2026.

Read the full background

The question came after the November 13 ground stop, which federal officials have said was caused when a federal contractor was replacing a router. The administration has asked Congress for $50 billion to replace aging air traffic infrastructure, while Trump has continued his White House renovations and ballroom project. In his answer Trump said the work takes him "10 minutes a day" and costs "peanuts," adding "I pay for it." PBS News reported that the White House has estimated the ballroom's cost at around $400 million in private donations, and that The Washington Post, citing a contractor estimate, put it at around $600 million with more than half coming from taxpayers. DI covers the ground stop itself in a separate case.

Trump had made similar remarks about dirt before. In May 2026 he told ABC News reporter Rachel Scott, "You can understand dirt maybe better than I can, but I don't allow it," after she asked why he was focusing on his Washington projects during the Iran war. Responding to Barack Obama's criticism of his White House decor around the 2026 midterm elections, Trump said Obama "doesn't notice dirt and filth that hadn't been cleaned." MS NOW's Steve Benen noted that Scott, Obama and Alcindor are all Black.

It was not the first time Trump confronted Alcindor. According to PBS News (opens in a new tab), when she was White House correspondent for PBS NewsHour in 2020, he called one of her questions about his COVID-19 response a "nasty question." Alcindor posted her question and an excerpt of Trump's answer on X with a video clip, without adding comment of her own.

People in this case

Timeline

2 timeline entries on this page. Dates: November 16, 2026

  1. November 2026

    1. Trump answers Yamiche Alcindor's question about his construction focus with remarks about dirt and broken windows

      Incident

      Taking questions outside the White House before leaving for Asia, Trump answers Alcindor's question about critics of his focus on Washington construction projects by calling the White House flawless and telling her she does not see dirt and would not notice broken windows from where she comes. As she presses him on responsibility and funding, he calls her pathetic and says she has no talent.

    2. Alcindor posts her question and Trump's answer on X

      Source release

      Alcindor shares the question she asked Trump and an excerpt of his reply about dirt and broken windows, with a video clip of the exchange, without adding comment of her own.

Response record

Responses

Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.

6 responses. Newest first.

  1. Steve BenenProducer for The Rachel Maddow Show and editor of MaddowBlog, writing on MS NOWCopy link to this statement by Steve Benen
    "The problem isn't only the familiarity of the Republican's rhetoric, it's also what the targets of this particular attack have in common: Scott, Obama and Alcindor are all Black, and they have all been told by Trump that he has a problem with what he assumes is a familiarity with "dirt." Sometimes the racism of Trump's attacks is subtle, and sometimes he abandons the pretense of restraint altogether."
    Condemned

    Case context: Trump tells NBC reporter Yamiche Alcindor she would not notice broken windows "from where you come"; critics call the remark racist

    Full statement and sources

    Benen writes that Alcindor, ABC News reporter Rachel Scott and Barack Obama are all Black and that Trump has told each of them he has a problem with what he assumes is their familiarity with dirt. He says the racism of Trump's attacks is sometimes subtle and that sometimes Trump abandons any pretense of restraint.

    Before the statement

    Benen recalls that in May Trump told ABC News reporter Rachel Scott she could understand dirt better than he could, and that Trump later said Barack Obama does not notice dirt and filth.

    After the statement

    He then quotes his MS NOW colleague Jarvis DeBerry's column arguing that Trump seemed to be calling Black people dirty.

    Why this label?

    Benen places Trump's remark to Alcindor in a pattern of racist attacks on Black people who questioned his renovation projects, so we labeled it Condemned.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  2. Sunny HostinCo-host of ABC's The View, speaking on the programCopy link to this statement by Sunny Hostin
    "Saying that a Black person doesn't see dirt or filth is a racial trope that has been used for decades to dehumanize Black people."
    Condemned

    Case context: Trump tells NBC reporter Yamiche Alcindor she would not notice broken windows "from where you come"; critics call the remark racist

    Full statement and sources

    On The View, Hostin says that telling a Black person they do not see dirt or filth is a racial trope that has been used for decades to dehumanize Black people.

    Before the statement

    Hostin was reacting to Trump lashing out at Alcindor on Monday over his response to the recent outages, according to The View's post of the segment.

    After the statement

    According to PBS News, Trump made his remark about dirt after calling the White House "flawless" and as Alcindor attempted to follow up.

    The View X post with Sunny Hostin's reaction to Trump's remarks to Yamiche Alcindor · ABC NewsPost on X with a video clip from the November 17 broadcast
    WATCH: 'You never notice broken windows, obviously,' Trump tells Black reporter · PBS NewsHourArticle with video, November 16, 2026

    Why this label?

    Hostin says Trump's remark to Alcindor draws on a decades-old racial trope used to dehumanize Black people, so we labeled it Condemned.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  3. Jaime HarrisonFormer chair of the Democratic National Committee, in a post on XCopy link to this statement by Jaime Harrison
    ".@Yamiche is the gold standard in journalism. She is fair. She is thorough. She is brilliant. She deserves so much better than the unhinged and racist utterances of one of the worst people to ever occupy the White House."
    Condemned

    Case context: Trump tells NBC reporter Yamiche Alcindor she would not notice broken windows "from where you come"; critics call the remark racist

    Full statement and sources

    Harrison praises Alcindor as fair, thorough and brilliant and says she deserves better than what he calls the unhinged and racist utterances of one of the worst people to occupy the White House.

    Before the statement

    The day before, according to PBS News, Trump berated Alcindor after she asked him to respond to critics who say he was too focused on construction projects in the nation's capital.

    After the statement

    According to PBS News, Trump told Alcindor, who is Black, that he knew she did not see dirt and that she would never notice broken windows from where she comes.

    Jaime Harrison X post on Trump and Yamiche Alcindor · Jaime HarrisonPost on X quoting Aaron Rupar's clip of the exchange
    WATCH: 'You never notice broken windows, obviously,' Trump tells Black reporter · PBS NewsHourArticle with video, November 16, 2026

    Why this label?

    Harrison calls Trump's words to Alcindor unhinged and racist and defends her as a fair and thorough journalist, so we labeled it Condemned.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  4. Jarvis DeBerryOpinion editor at MS NOW, in an opinion columnCopy link to this statement by Jarvis DeBerry
    "Trump seemed to be making a commentary about Black people in general, calling us dirty. And not just dirty but oblivious to dirt. But even if he was trying to say that there is no dirt to see on the White House, the rest of his disrespectful comment is unmistakably clear: He said Alcindor wouldn't notice broken windows because of where she's from."
    Condemned

    Case context: Trump tells NBC reporter Yamiche Alcindor she would not notice broken windows "from where you come"; critics call the remark racist

    Full statement and sources

    DeBerry writes that Trump seemed to be commenting on Black people in general as dirty and oblivious to dirt, and that in any reading Trump told Alcindor she would not notice broken windows because of where she is from.

    Before the statement

    DeBerry writes that Alcindor, an award-winning journalist, was born in Miami to parents who immigrated from Haiti, and that Trump was not talking about geography.

    After the statement

    He goes on to cite the 1970s Justice Department housing discrimination suit against Trump and his father, which they settled without admitting guilt, as part of what he describes as Trump's long record on race.

    Why this label?

    DeBerry calls the remark racism and argues that Trump tied Alcindor's supposed blindness to dirt and broken windows to her background, so we labeled it Condemned.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  5. Patrick GaspardFormer U.S. ambassador to South Africa and former president of the Center for American Progress, in a post on XCopy link to this statement by Patrick Gaspard
    "It's important to understand that in this exchange not only is Trump speaking to a black journalist, but very specifically one whose family comes from Haiti (Yamiche Alcindor). He knows precisely where her people "come from". The racism is astonishing and not the least bit random"
    Condemned

    Case context: Trump tells NBC reporter Yamiche Alcindor she would not notice broken windows "from where you come"; critics call the remark racist

    Full statement and sources

    Gaspard says Trump was speaking to a Black journalist whose family comes from Haiti, that Trump knew where her people come from, and that the racism was astonishing and not random.

    Before the statement

    Gaspard was responding to the exchange in which, according to PBS News, Trump told Alcindor, "You never notice broken windows, obviously, from where you come."

    After the statement

    PBS News, which noted that Alcindor is Black, reported that Trump called her "pathetic" when she began to ask about taking responsibility.

    Patrick Gaspard X post on Trump and Yamiche Alcindor · Patrick GaspardPost on X quoting Aaron Rupar's clip of the exchange
    WATCH: 'You never notice broken windows, obviously,' Trump tells Black reporter · PBS NewsHourArticle with video, November 16, 2026

    Why this label?

    Gaspard reads the "from where you come" line as a reference to Alcindor's Haitian family and calls it deliberate racism, so we labeled it Condemned.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

  6. Mehdi HasanFounder and editor-in-chief of Zeteo, in a post on XCopy link to this statement by Mehdi Hasan
    "We have normalized his abuse of the free press. Especially Black female reporters like @Yamiche. Disgusting."
    Condemned

    Case context: Trump tells NBC reporter Yamiche Alcindor she would not notice broken windows "from where you come"; critics call the remark racist

    Full statement and sources

    Hasan says Trump's abuse of the free press has been normalized, particularly toward Black female reporters such as Alcindor, and calls it disgusting.

    Before the statement

    Earlier on Monday, Trump called Alcindor "pathetic" and suggested she lacked "talent" after she questioned his spending priorities, according to The Independent.

    After the statement

    The Independent reported that Trump also told her the White House work "doesn't cost money" and that he pays for it himself.

    Mehdi Hasan X post on Trump and Yamiche Alcindor · Mehdi HasanPost on X quoting a reporter's account of the exchange
    Trump lashes out over questions about DC projects after FAA crisis · The IndependentArticle, November 16, 2026

    Why this label?

    Hasan describes Trump's treatment of Alcindor as abuse of the free press, points to how Trump treats Black women reporters and calls it disgusting, so we labeled it Condemned.

    This label describes the statement's response within the context above.

Sources

(11)

Original video

President Trump Gaggles with Press Upon Departure from the White House. Nov. 16, 2026

President Trump answers NBC News correspondent Yamiche Alcindor's question about his focus on Washington construction projects outside the White House on November 16, 2026.

Excerpt from 3:41 to 6:48 of the White House video. DI added its logo in the corner.

Video: The White House. Public domain (U.S. government work) (opens in a new tab)

Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: 3:41 to 6:48)

About this source

White House video of Trump taking questions outside the White House before leaving for Asia. In this passage NBC News correspondent Yamiche Alcindor asks about critics of his focus on Washington construction projects, and Trump answers with remarks about dirt, broken windows and "where you come" before calling her "pathetic."

Author
The White House
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

The View X post with Sunny Hostin's reaction to Trump's remarks to Yamiche Alcindor

The View X post with Sunny Hostin's reaction to Trump's remarks to Yamiche Alcindor (opens in a new tab) · ABC NewsPost on X with a video clip from the November 17 broadcast

About this source

ABC's The View posts a clip from its November 17 broadcast in which co-host Sunny Hostin responds to the exchange, with her central line quoted in the post text.

Author
The View
Published
Accessed

Original post

Jaime Harrison X post on Trump and Yamiche Alcindor

Jaime Harrison X post on Trump and Yamiche Alcindor (opens in a new tab) · Jaime HarrisonPost on X quoting Aaron Rupar's clip of the exchange

About this source

The former Democratic National Committee chair quotes Aaron Rupar's post of Trump's remark and praises Alcindor's reporting.

Author
Jaime Harrison
Published
Accessed

Original post

Patrick Gaspard X post on Trump and Yamiche Alcindor

Patrick Gaspard X post on Trump and Yamiche Alcindor (opens in a new tab) · Patrick GaspardPost on X quoting Aaron Rupar's clip of the exchange

About this source

The former ambassador quotes Aaron Rupar's post of Trump's broken-windows remark and writes about Alcindor's Haitian family background.

Author
Patrick Gaspard
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Mehdi Hasan X post on Trump and Yamiche Alcindor

Mehdi Hasan X post on Trump and Yamiche Alcindor (opens in a new tab) · Mehdi HasanPost on X quoting a reporter's account of the exchange

About this source

The Zeteo editor-in-chief quotes Financial Times correspondent Abigail Hauslohner's post that Trump told Alcindor she has no talent, and adds a three-sentence comment.

Author
Mehdi Hasan
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Analysis

Trump keeps leaning into racism while trying to defend his renovations obsession

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: MaddowBlog post, November 17, 2026

About this source

Steve Benen compares Trump's remark to Alcindor with his comments about dirt directed at ABC News reporter Rachel Scott in May and at Barack Obama before the midterm elections.

Author
Steve Benen
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Analysis

Trump's shockingly racist remark to a Black reporter is sadly familiar

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Opinion column, November 16, 2026

About this source

MS NOW opinion editor Jarvis DeBerry argues that Trump's remark to Alcindor about dirt and broken windows was racist and places it alongside Trump's past remarks about Black people.

Author
Jarvis DeBerry
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

Trump lashes out over questions about DC projects after FAA crisis

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Article, November 16, 2026

About this source

The Independent reports that Trump called Alcindor "pathetic" and said she lacked talent while defending his White House renovations, and quotes his longer answer about the helipad, the ballroom and the cost of the work.

Author
Alex Woodward
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

WATCH: 'You never notice broken windows, obviously,' Trump tells Black reporter

Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Article with video, November 16, 2026

About this source

PBS News reports Trump's remarks to Alcindor after she asked about critics of his construction focus, notes that he called her question "nasty" in 2020, and summarizes the FAA ground stop and the ballroom's reported cost.

Author
News Desk
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Original post

Yamiche Alcindor X post with her question to Trump and his answer

About this source

Alcindor posts the question she asked Trump and an excerpt of his answer, with a video clip of the exchange, without adding comment of her own.

Author
Yamiche Alcindor
Published
Accessed

Original text

Press Gaggle: Donald Trump Speaks to Reporters Before Marine One Departure - November 16, 2026

Press Gaggle: Donald Trump Speaks to Reporters Before Marine One Departure - November 16, 2026 (opens in a new tab) · Roll CallTranscript, exchange beginning with the question on D.C. construction projects
Read source (opens in a new tab)

Relevant passage: Transcript, exchange beginning with the question on D.C. construction projects

About this source

Roll Call's full transcript of the November 16 gaggle. It records Alcindor's question, Trump's reply about broken windows and the White House stone, her follow-up questions on responsibility and funding, and his remarks that she lacks talent and that "losers like you" ask why he is focused on the White House.

Author
Roll Call Factba.se
Published
Accessed
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Case updates

Follow the dispute over Trump's remarks to Yamiche Alcindor

Get an update if Trump, the White House, NBC News or Alcindor responds publicly, or if journalism groups or members of Congress weigh in on the exchange.

8 updates added in the last 14 days.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

The newsletter

Follow disputes like this one.

New cases and significant updates to the record, in your inbox. Free.

You’ll confirm your subscription on Substack.

Share or embed this case

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Trump tells NBC reporter Yamiche Alcindor she would not notice broken windows "from where you come"; critics call the remark racist
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/cases/trump-yamiche-alcindor-broken-windows

The Dispute Index. "Trump tells NBC reporter Yamiche Alcindor she would not notice broken windows "from where you come"; critics call the remark racist". First published: 2026-11-18. Last updated: 2026-11-18. https://disputeindex.com/cases/trump-yamiche-alcindor-broken-windows