Should Dale Caldwell resign as New Jersey's lieutenant governor after the investigation's findings?
Gov. Mikie Sherrill called on Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell to resign after an outside law firm's report substantiated a workplace-policy violation and two ethics violations. Caldwell resigned on September 25, 2026, the next day. He and his lawyer dispute the report's findings.
Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Overview
On September 24, 2026, New Jersey Gov. Mikie Sherrill released a 61-page report, with exhibits, by the law firm Lowenstein Sandler LLP and called on Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell to resign by the next day. The firm, engaged by the Governor's Chief Ethics Officer after an anonymous complaint dated May 6, found that Caldwell made a comment to a female staffer that constituted sexual harassment under the state workplace policy, and that he violated state ethics rules by bringing personal guests to ticketed events without payment and by seeking a promotion for a state employee with whom he had a romantic relationship. Caldwell, through his lawyer Thomas Calcagni, disputes all three findings, denies making the comment, and says the process was one-sided and lacked due process; in a May 28 letter he called the complaint's accusations false. Republican leaders called for him to resign or step down before the report was released. The Associated Press reports that the Governor cannot fire a lieutenant governor and that the Legislature can impeach and remove one. The statement issued for Caldwell on September 24 did not say whether he would resign. On September 25, Sherrill announced that Caldwell had resigned, The Philadelphia Inquirer and ABC News report. In a statement on his resignation, Caldwell said it should not be read as an admission of wrongdoing and that he strongly disputes the report; his lawyer said counsel would continue to challenge it.
Read the full background
The fixed reference point for classification in this case is the September 23, 2026 investigation report by Lowenstein Sandler LLP, published on September 24, and its findings that Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell violated New Jersey's workplace policy and state ethics rules, together with Gov. Mikie Sherrill's call for him to resign. Responses are recorded against that specific matter, not against Caldwell's record as a whole, the Governor's handling of the investigation, or allegations the report did not substantiate. A statement made before the report was released is classified against the same reference point when it addresses the allegations the report later examined or whether Caldwell should resign, and its summary notes that it predates the findings.
The Governor's Chief Ethics Officer engaged Lowenstein Sandler after receiving an anonymous complaint dated May 6, 2026, and notified Caldwell on May 22. In its report (opens in a new tab), the firm concluded that a violation of the state workplace policy was substantiated because, after a romantic advance toward a female staffer's friend was rebuffed, Caldwell made a comment to the staffer that the report describes as sexual in nature; that he brought personal guests to ticketed events without advance ethics clearance or payment; and that he sought, on more than one occasion, a promotion for a state employee with whom he had a romantic relationship, without disclosing it. The report says it did not find Caldwell's denial of the comment credible. It identifies witnesses only by pseudonym, and this case follows that practice.
In a statement released with the report (opens in a new tab), Sherrill said the investigation found "serious, repeated violations of state policy," called the substantiated sexual harassment finding "extremely troubling," said the investigation was "thorough and impartial," and gave Caldwell until September 25 to resign. Politico and the AP report that she could not fire him from that office and that the Legislature can impeach and remove a lieutenant governor (Politico (opens in a new tab); AP (opens in a new tab)).
His attorney, Thomas Calcagni, said in a written statement (opens in a new tab) on September 24 that the process was "one-sided," that Caldwell "categorically denies" the comment, and that the evidence does not establish that he used his office to obtain a government benefit for the employee he recommended. In a May 28 letter (opens in a new tab) to the Chief Ethics Officer, published as an exhibit to the report, Caldwell called the complaint's accusations false. The lawyer's September 24 statement did not address whether he would resign, and a professor who knows Caldwell, quoted by The Philadelphia Inquirer (opens in a new tab) on September 22, said Caldwell had told him he would not.
On the afternoon of September 25, Sherrill announced at a news conference that Caldwell had resigned (The Philadelphia Inquirer (opens in a new tab); ABC News (opens in a new tab)). In a statement reported by Politico (opens in a new tab), Caldwell said he resigned because he did not want "this matter to distract from the important work of the administration or its responsibility to the people of New Jersey." In the same statement, quoted by The Daily Princetonian (opens in a new tab), he wrote that his resignation "should not be interpreted as an admission of wrongdoing or acceptance of the report's findings," that he strongly disputes the report, and that he will "continue to defend my name, my character and the truth." In a statement reported by ABC News (opens in a new tab), Calcagni said the resignation was "submitted to put an end to the targeted campaign to discredit his character" and that counsel would continue to challenge the report.
Republican officials, including Senate Republican Leader Anthony Bucco (opens in a new tab) and the state party chair (opens in a new tab), had called for his resignation. A Republican state senator cautioned against rushing to judgment (opens in a new tab) before the allegations were known, and a supporter who helped organize one of the events (opens in a new tab) named in the complaint asked that event organizers be heard. After the resignation, Senate President Nicholas Scutari and Assembly Speaker Craig Coughlin each said Caldwell was right to resign, the New Jersey Globe reports (opens in a new tab).
People in this case
Dale CaldwellDirectly involved
Mikie SherrillDirectly involved
Timeline
14 timeline entries on this page. Dates: May 6, 2026 to October 15, 2026
May 2026
An anonymous complaint about Caldwell is addressed to state agencies and a reporter
Claim
An unsigned letter dated May 6, 2026, addressed to the State Ethics Commission, the Attorney General's office, the Civil Service Commission's EEO division and a New York Times reporter, alleges that Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell brought uninvited female guests to events who did not have paid tickets and pursued women at official functions. The Governor's Chief Ethics Officer received the letter on May 14. The allegations are the anonymous complainant's own.
[01]Office of the Governor of New Jersey
Source excerpt
has been bringing uninvited female guests to events while traveling using taxpayer funds
The unsigned May 6, 2026 letter addressed to the State Ethics Commission, the Attorney General's office, the Civil Service Commission's EEO division, and a New York Times reporter. It is the complaint that led to the investigation. Its allegations are the complainant's own and were not adopted as findings except where the report says so.
Investigation Report, Exhibit 1: anonymous complaint dated May 6, 2026 · Office of the Governor of New JerseyPart III.A (printed pp. 6-7) and Exhibit 1, anonymous complaint (PDF pp. 42-43)Chief Ethics Officer notifies Caldwell of the investigation and he responds in writing
On May 22, 2026, the Governor's Chief Ethics Officer formally notified Lt. Gov. Caldwell that a complaint was being investigated by Lowenstein Sandler LLP and told him that the existence of an investigation does not constitute a finding of wrongdoing. Public records obtained by Politico show the firm was retained on May 21. Caldwell responded by letter on May 28, denying the allegations and saying he welcomed a fair review.
[02]Office of the Governor of New Jersey
Source excerpt
The existence of an investigation does not constitute a finding of wrongdoing.
The Chief Ethics Officer's May 22, 2026 letter formally notifying the Lieutenant Governor of the complaint and of the assignment of the investigation to Lowenstein Sandler LLP. Part III.B of the report also summarizes his written response of May 28.
Investigation Report: notification of investigation (May 22, 2026, Exhibit 2) · Office of the Governor of New JerseyPart III.B (printed pp. 7-8) and Exhibit 2, notification letter dated May 22, 2026 (PDF pp. 44-46)[03]Office of the Governor of New Jersey
Source excerpt
The accusations contained in this complaint are inaccurate, misleading, and completely false.
The Lieutenant Governor's signed three-page written response to the anonymous complaint, dated May 28, 2026, before the investigation's findings. It answers the complaint's allegations about guests at events and about pursuing women, and it was published in full (with names redacted) as an exhibit to the report.
Investigation Report, Exhibit 3: Lieutenant Governor Caldwell's May 28, 2026 letter to the Chief Ethics Officer · Office of the Governor of New JerseyExhibit 3, Lt. Gov. Caldwell's May 28, 2026 letter (PDF pp. 47-50; letter at pp. 48-50)[04]Politico
Source excerpt
Caldwell has not been acting governor since news of the investigation broke.
Politico's report, based on public records, on the law firm's May 21 retention and on the Lieutenant Governor's service as acting governor while the investigation was under way.
Mikie Sherrill let her LG serve as acting governor for 18 days after internal investigation began · PoliticoArticle published September 23, 2026, 8:12 p.m. ETCaldwell emails a department official recommending a state employee for promotion
Incident
According to the report, on May 26, 2026, four days after he was notified of the investigation, Lt. Gov. Caldwell used his state email account to recommend a state employee, whom he called "my friend," for a leadership position in another executive-branch department, after making a similar verbal request the week before. The report says he did not disclose that she was his romantic partner; Caldwell acknowledged to investigators that she was his girlfriend. The report records that no promotion or other benefit was conferred. Caldwell's counsel says the report cites no evidence that he ordered or controlled a hiring decision and describes the email as forwarding the résumé of a qualified applicant.
[05]Office of the Governor of New Jersey
Source excerpt
The LG admitted to investigators that he did not disclose the romantic nature of his relationship with the state employee while making these promotion requests.
The report's account of the Lieutenant Governor's May 26, 2026 email to an executive-branch official recommending a state employee, whom he acknowledged was his girlfriend, for a leadership position, and of an earlier verbal request. The report records that no promotion or other benefit was conferred.
Investigation Report: promotion request finding and Exhibit 7 email of May 26, 2026 · Office of the Governor of New JerseyPart IV.C.2 (printed pp. 24-27), Part V.B.2.b (printed pp. 36-38) and Exhibit 7, email of May 26, 2026 (PDF pp. 57-61)[06]InsiderNJ
Source excerpt
The Lieutenant Governor was not provided a meaningful opportunity to address each of these anonymous allegations or offer readily identifiable witnesses who possessed more pertinent, first-hand knowledge of the events in question.
Written statement issued for the Lieutenant Governor by his attorney after the report was released. It disputes each of the three findings and the fairness of the process. It does not say whether he would resign; he resigned the next day, September 25, 2026.
Statement regarding Lieutenant Governor Dr. Dale G. Caldwell (counsel Thomas Calcagni, September 24, 2026) · InsiderNJFull two-page statement, revised version, September 24, 2026
September 2026
The New Jersey Globe reports that Caldwell is under internal investigation
The New Jersey Globe reports that Lt. Gov. Caldwell is the subject of an internal investigation by the Governor's office over alleged inappropriate behavior with women and possible ethics violations, led by former Attorney General Christopher Porrino. A spokesman for Gov. Sherrill says the Governor would take any such reports extremely seriously and adds, "We cannot confirm or deny potential personnel matters."
[07]New Jersey Globe
Source excerpt
“We cannot confirm or deny potential personnel matters.”
The first published report that the Lieutenant Governor was the subject of an internal investigation led by former Attorney General Christopher Porrino, including the Governor's spokesman's response.
Lt. Governor Dale Caldwell under investigation after allegations of inappropriate behavior · New Jersey GlobeArticle published September 4, 2026Gov. Sherrill makes a first public statement on misconduct reports, without naming Caldwell
Reaction
In a general statement that refers to neither Caldwell nor an investigation, Gov. Sherrill says any credible report of misconduct "must be fully examined and addressed," that she will "take appropriate action quickly" if the evidence warrants, and that the subject of a complaint is entitled to a fair and thorough review.
[08]Office of the Governor of New Jersey
Source excerpt
I take my responsibility to treat any reports of inappropriate behavior or misconduct extremely seriously, and any credible report must be fully examined and addressed.
The Governor's first public statement after the investigation was reported. It refers to neither the Lieutenant Governor nor an investigation, and it says both complainants and the subject of a complaint are entitled to protection and a fair review.
Statement by Governor Mikie Sherrill (September 8, 2026) · Office of the Governor of New JerseyFull statement, posted September 8, 2026Gov. Sherrill declines to confirm or deny the investigation to reporters
Reaction
Speaking to reporters on September 9, her first public appearance after the investigation was reported, Gov. Sherrill says she is "not going to confirm or deny whether there's an ongoing investigation," and that any complaints are taken seriously and the rights of anyone complained about are protected. Politico reports that she did not name Caldwell.
[09]New Jersey Globe
Source excerpt
“I’m not going to confirm or deny whether there’s an ongoing investigation,”
New Jersey Globe's report of the Governor's remarks to reporters on September 9, her first public appearance after the investigation was reported.
Sherrill declines to discuss Caldwell investigation, says election preparations remain on track · New Jersey GlobeArticle published September 9, 2026[10]Politico
Source excerpt
“not going to confirm or deny whether there’s an ongoing investigation,”
Politico's report of the Governor's September 9 remarks, including that she did not name the Lieutenant Governor and declined to respond to Republican calls for his resignation.
Mikie Sherrill provides few answers in first appearance since lieutenant governor investigation surfaced · PoliticoArticle published September 9, 2026, 7:45 p.m. ETRepublican legislative leaders ask for a bipartisan select committee
Reaction
In a letter to Senate President Nicholas Scutari and Assembly Speaker Craig Coughlin, Senate Republican Leader Anthony Bucco and Assembly Republican Leader John DiMaio ask the Democratic presiding officers to create a bicameral, bipartisan select committee with subpoena power to investigate the allegations against Caldwell and the administration's handling of them. A spokesman for Gov. Sherrill criticizes the Republican leaders in response.
[11]New Jersey Senate Republicans
Source excerpt
The Governor cannot be the sole judge of whether her own Administration responded appropriately to serious allegations involving one of its highest-ranking officials.
The Republican legislative leaders' letter asking the Democratic presiding officers to create a bicameral, bipartisan select committee to investigate the allegations and the administration's handling of them.
Letter from Senate Republican Leader Bucco and Assembly Republican Leader DiMaio to Senate President Scutari and Assembly Speaker Coughlin (September 10, 2026) · New Jersey Senate RepublicansFull letter dated September 10, 2026[12]New Jersey Globe
Source excerpt
Senate Minority Leader Anthony Bucco and Assembly Minority Leader John DiMaio are calling for a bipartisan legislative investigation into allegations involving Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell and the Sherrill administration’s handling of the matter.
New Jersey Globe's report on the letter, including a response from the Governor's spokesman.
Bucco, DiMaio call for legislative probe of Caldwell allegations · New Jersey GlobeArticle published September 10, 2026Records show Caldwell served as acting governor while the investigation was under way
Politico reports, based on public records, that Caldwell held the powers of the governorship for at least 18 days after the administration began the investigation. It reports that the Governor's office retained Porrino's law firm on May 21 at $450 an hour, and that Caldwell has not served as acting governor since the investigation was reported on September 4.
[04]Politico
Source excerpt
Caldwell has not been acting governor since news of the investigation broke.
Politico's report, based on public records, on the law firm's May 21 retention and on the Lieutenant Governor's service as acting governor while the investigation was under way.
Mikie Sherrill let her LG serve as acting governor for 18 days after internal investigation began · PoliticoArticle published September 23, 2026, 8:12 p.m. ETLowenstein Sandler's report on Caldwell is dated and delivered to the Governor
Source release
The Lowenstein Sandler LLP report is dated September 23, 2026, and, according to the New Jersey Globe, was delivered to Gov. Sherrill that day. It concludes that a violation of the state workplace policy and two violations of state ethics rules are substantiated. It was not made public until the next evening.
[13]Office of the Governor of New Jersey
Source excerpt
A violation of the Workplace Policy is substantiated. Two violations of state ethics rules are also substantiated.
The 61-page redacted report, with exhibits, that Lowenstein Sandler LLP prepared for the Governor's Chief Ethics Officer and that the Governor's Office published on September 24, 2026. The executive summary states the firm's three findings and the standard it applied. Witnesses are identified only by pseudonym.
Investigation Report re: Lieutenant Governor Dr. Dale G. Caldwell, Executive Summary (Lowenstein Sandler LLP, September 23, 2026) · Office of the Governor of New JerseyPart I, Executive Summary, printed pp. 1-3 (PDF pp. 4-6)[14]Office of the Governor of New Jersey
Source excerpt
the LG violated the Uniform Ethics Code and Code of Conduct when he brought guests to ticketed events without payment or reimbursement
The report's one-page conclusion lists the three matters it found substantiated: a workplace-policy violation for a comment to a female staffer, and two ethics violations concerning unpaid guests at ticketed events and a promotion request for a state employee with whom the Lieutenant Governor had a romantic relationship.
Investigation Report re: Lieutenant Governor Dr. Dale G. Caldwell, Conclusion (Lowenstein Sandler LLP, September 23, 2026) · Office of the Governor of New JerseyPart VI, Conclusion, printed p. 38 (PDF p. 41)[15]New Jersey Globe
Source excerpt
Caldwell staunchly denied wrongdoing in his May 28 written response to the chief ethics officer in the governor’s office
New Jersey Globe's same-night summary of the report, the Governor's statement, the report's account of earlier warnings, and the Lieutenant Governor's legal advisers.
Sherrill gives Caldwell until tomorrow to resign after report substantiates sexual harassment, ethics violations · New Jersey GlobeArticle published September 24, 2026The Governor publishes the report and calls on Caldwell to resign by September 25
Source release
On the evening of September 24, 2026, Gov. Sherrill's office publishes the redacted 61-page report with exhibits. Her accompanying statement says the investigation found serious, repeated violations of state policy, calls for Caldwell's resignation, and gives him until September 25 to resign. The Associated Press reports that the Governor cannot fire a lieutenant governor and that the Legislature can impeach and remove one.
[16]Office of the Governor of New Jersey
Source excerpt
I’m calling for his resignation and giving him until tomorrow to do so.
The Governor's official press release announcing the conclusion of the independent investigation, linking the report, and calling for the Lieutenant Governor's resignation by the next day.
Governor Sherrill Releases Report on Investigation into Lieutenant Governor Caldwell, Calls for Resignation · Office of the Governor of New JerseyFull statement, posted September 24, 2026[17]Office of the Governor of New Jersey
Source excerpt
The Lieutenant Governor’s resignation is necessary and in the best interest of New Jersey residents.
The full text of the Governor's statement posted on her official, government-verified X account shortly after the report was released.
Gov. Sherrill's X post on the investigation into Lt. Gov. Caldwell · Office of the Governor of New JerseyFull X post, published September 24, 2026, 23:35 UTC (7:35 p.m. ET)[15]New Jersey Globe
Source excerpt
Caldwell staunchly denied wrongdoing in his May 28 written response to the chief ethics officer in the governor’s office
New Jersey Globe's same-night summary of the report, the Governor's statement, the report's account of earlier warnings, and the Lieutenant Governor's legal advisers.
Sherrill gives Caldwell until tomorrow to resign after report substantiates sexual harassment, ethics violations · New Jersey GlobeArticle published September 24, 2026[18]Politico
Source excerpt
Caldwell’s attorney disputed the report’s findings but did not address whether he would resign.
Politico's same-night report on the Governor's demand and the Lieutenant Governor's response through counsel. It notes that only the Legislature can remove him, by impeachment.
Mikie Sherrill demands NJ lieutenant governor resign after report found improper behavior with women · PoliticoArticle published September 24, 2026, 8:04 p.m. ETCaldwell resigns and Sherrill announces it at a news conference
Incident
Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell resigned on September 25, the deadline Gov. Mikie Sherrill had set. Sherrill announced it at a news conference, saying the investigation found serious, repeated violations of state policy, and said she is appointing an interim secretary of state to oversee the midterm elections. Caldwell's attorney said the resignation was submitted to end a targeted campaign to discredit his character and that counsel will continue to challenge the report.
[19]ABC News
Source excerpt
Dale Caldwell resigned Friday as lieutenant governor of New Jersey after an investigation found "serious, repeated violations of state policy, including ethical lapses and a substantiated finding of sexual harassment," Gov. Mikie Sherrill said.
ABC News report on Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell's Sept. 25, 2026 resignation. It quotes Gov. Sherrill's news conference, quotes Caldwell's attorney Thomas Calcagni saying the resignation was submitted to end a targeted campaign to discredit his character and that counsel will continue to challenge the report, and reports that Sherrill said she is appointing an interim secretary of state to oversee the midterm elections.
New Jersey Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell resigns after ethics probe · ABC NewsOpening paragraphs and the paragraphs quoting Gov. Sherrill's Friday news conference and Caldwell's attorneyCaldwell returns to the pulpit with a sermon about false accusations
Reaction
Two days after resigning, Caldwell returns to Covenant United Methodist Church and delivers a sermon titled When Lies Become Weapons. The New Jersey Globe reports that it addresses false accusations. In his later published interview, Caldwell says the church's review concerns the state report's allegations; he denies wrongdoing.
[20]Caldwell returns to the pulpit after resigning
The report describes Caldwell's sermon and an unspecified church complaint. In his later published interview, Caldwell says the church process concerns the state report's allegations.
Caldwell returns to the pulpit after resigningFull report, paragraphs describing his Sunday sermon two days after resigning[21]NJ Spotlight News publishes Caldwell's account of his resignation and the investigation
The transcript records Caldwell's denials and his argument that the state process was unfair. The publication date does not establish when the interview was recorded.
NJ Spotlight News publishes Caldwell's account of his resignation and the investigationFull published interview transcript with Rob Nelson, including the church process, report and disputed findings
October 2026
NJ Spotlight News publishes Caldwell's interview about the investigation
Source release
NJ Spotlight News publishes a full interview transcript in which Caldwell disputes the report and the fairness of the state process. While denying the alleged comment to a staff member, he also argues that the conduct described was less serious than physical harassment. He says the church process concerns the same state allegations. The page's publication date does not establish the interview's recording date.
[21]NJ Spotlight News publishes Caldwell's account of his resignation and the investigation
The transcript records Caldwell's denials and his argument that the state process was unfair. The publication date does not establish when the interview was recorded.
NJ Spotlight News publishes Caldwell's account of his resignation and the investigationFull published interview transcript with Rob Nelson, including the church process, report and disputed findingsAssembly resolution proposes confirmation votes for a replacement lieutenant governor
Reaction
ACR157 is introduced with John DiMaio and Erik Peterson as sponsors. It proposes amending the state constitution to require majority approval in both legislative houses before a governor's replacement lieutenant governor takes office. DiMaio and Doug Steinhardt announced the proposed change after Caldwell's resignation. The resolution is a proposal, not an enacted change.
[22]ACR157 proposes legislative approval for a replacement lieutenant governor
The introduced resolution proposes a constitutional amendment. It does not show that the amendment has been approved or taken effect.
ACR157 proposes legislative approval for a replacement lieutenant governorIntroduction header, proposed Article V amendment and statement[23]DiMaio and Steinhardt link succession proposal to Caldwell vacancy
The report covers the announcement of the proposed change. The official Assembly resolution identifies October 15 as its introduction date.
DiMaio and Steinhardt link succession proposal to Caldwell vacancyFull October 5 report, proposed confirmation requirement and Caldwell resignation context
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Lowenstein Sandler LLP
The credible evidence substantiates that Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell violated the state workplace policy by commenting to a female staffer that young women want "young sperm," conduct the report finds constituted sexual harassment, and violated the Uniform Ethics Code and the Governor's Code of Conduct by bringing personal guests to ticketed events without payment or reimbursement and by seeking a promotion for a state employee with whom he had a romantic relationship.
Sources (2)
- Investigation Report re: Lieutenant Governor Dr. Dale G. Caldwell, Executive Summary (Lowenstein Sandler LLP, September 23, 2026) · Office of the Governor of New JerseyPart I, Executive Summary, printed pp. 1-3 (PDF pp. 4-6)
- Investigation Report re: Lieutenant Governor Dr. Dale G. Caldwell, Conclusion (Lowenstein Sandler LLP, September 23, 2026) · Office of the Governor of New JerseyPart VI, Conclusion, printed p. 38 (PDF p. 41)
Disputed claim
The accusations in the anonymous complaint, including that he pursued women romantically while conducting official business and that his guests at events raised ethical concerns, are "inaccurate, misleading, and completely false."
Sources (2)
- Investigation Report, Exhibit 3: Lieutenant Governor Caldwell's May 28, 2026 letter to the Chief Ethics Officer · Office of the Governor of New JerseyExhibit 3, Lt. Gov. Caldwell's May 28, 2026 letter (PDF pp. 47-50; letter at pp. 48-50)
- Mikie Sherrill elevated Dale Caldwell to new heights. His supporters say his reputation is being unfairly tarnished. · The Philadelphia InquirerArticle published September 22, 2026, 6:01 a.m. ET
Disputed claim
Lt. Gov. Caldwell's resignation is "necessary and in the best interest of New Jersey residents" because the investigation substantiated serious, repeated violations of state policy.
Sources (2)
- Governor Sherrill Releases Report on Investigation into Lieutenant Governor Caldwell, Calls for Resignation · Office of the Governor of New JerseyFull statement, posted September 24, 2026
- Gov. Sherrill's X post on the investigation into Lt. Gov. Caldwell · Office of the Governor of New JerseyFull X post, published September 24, 2026, 23:35 UTC (7:35 p.m. ET)
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
3 matching responses. Newest first.
Dale CaldwellFormer New Jersey lieutenant governor, speaking to reporters outside his homeDirectly involvedBefore this statement
Sherrill called for Caldwell's resignation on Thursday, September 24, after the investigation's report was released; he submitted his resignation Friday afternoon.
"The report, I think, was just specious. There are all sorts of wrong things and mistakes. I'm not resigning because of that ridiculous report. I'm resigning because I don't want to be a distraction to the Mikie Sherrill administration."
DeniedCase context: Should Dale Caldwell resign as New Jersey's lieutenant governor after the investigation's findings?
Full statement and sources
A day after resigning as New Jersey's lieutenant governor, Dale Caldwell said the independent investigation's report was "specious" and contained "wrong things and mistakes," and said he was not resigning because of the report but to avoid distracting from Gov. Sherrill's administration. His attorney said counsel would continue to challenge the report's findings and was exploring legal remedies.
After the statement
Sherrill has 45 days to name a new lieutenant governor; acting State Comptroller Shirley Emehelu is serving as acting secretary of state in the interim.
CBS New York: Former N.J. lieutenant governor Dale Caldwell addresses his resignationParagraphs quoting Caldwell speaking outside his home in New BrunswickWhy this label?
Relative to the investigation's findings, which led Sherrill to call for his resignation, Caldwell calls the report specious and mistaken, an explicit denial of its validity, consistent with his earlier denial of the underlying allegations. He resigned, but says the report itself is not the reason, so the denial stands apart from the resignation.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Mikie SherrillGovernor of New Jersey, in an official statement and X postDirectly involvedBefore this statement
Gov. Sherrill's office published the 61-page Lowenstein Sandler report, which is dated September 23, together with this statement. On September 8 she had said that any credible report must be fully examined and that she would take appropriate action quickly if the evidence warranted.
"The investigation found that the Lieutenant Governor engaged in serious, repeated violations of state policy and failed to uphold the responsibilities of his office. I’m calling for his resignation and giving him until tomorrow to do so. … These violations substantiated in the investigation reflect a pattern of behavior that does not meet the standards of this Administration. The ethical lapses persisted despite multiple warnings and trainings. The substantiated finding of sexual harassment is extremely troubling. … As a former federal prosecutor, I’m committed to ensuring everyone is treated fairly. This investigation was thorough and impartial. It was initiated by the Chief Ethics Officer and conducted by a respected former state Attorney General. … The Lieutenant Governor’s resignation is necessary and in the best interest of New Jersey residents."
CondemnedResponding to: Lt. Gov. Caldwell's resignation is "necessary and in the best interest of New Jersey residents" because the investigation substantiated serious, repeated violations of state policy.
Full statement and sources
In a statement released with the investigation report on September 24, 2026, Gov. Mikie Sherrill said the investigation found that Caldwell "engaged in serious, repeated violations of state policy," called the substantiated sexual harassment finding "extremely troubling," said the investigation was "thorough and impartial," and said his resignation is "necessary."
After the statement
The statement links the full report, says the investigation protected everyone's privacy, and gives Caldwell until the next day, September 25, to resign.
Governor Sherrill Releases Report on Investigation into Lieutenant Governor Caldwell, Calls for Resignation · Office of the Governor of New JerseyFull statement, posted September 24, 2026Gov. Sherrill's X post on the investigation into Lt. Gov. Caldwell · Office of the Governor of New JerseyFull X post, published September 24, 2026, 23:35 UTC (7:35 p.m. ET)Why this label?
Relative to the report's findings and the call for Caldwell's resignation, Sherrill adopts the findings, says they reflect a pattern of behavior, and says his resignation is "necessary." She expressly criticizes the conduct and demands his departure, so condemns applies rather than a challenge to how the conduct is characterized.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
- Dale CaldwellLieutenant Governor and Secretary of State, in a written response to the Chief Ethics OfficerDirectly involved
Before this statement
The Chief Ethics Officer had notified Caldwell on May 22 that a complaint alleging workplace misconduct and ethics violations was under investigation, and had told him that the existence of an investigation does not constitute a finding of wrongdoing.
"The accusations contained in this complaint are inaccurate, misleading, and completely false. For that reason, I fully welcome a fair, objective, and professional review of these allegations by the attorneys and investigators assigned to this matter because I am confident that the facts will fully clear my name. First, I have never asked anyone out on a date, “hit on,” or pursued anyone romantically while conducting official business as Lieutenant Governor and Secretary of State. … The suggestion that these professional and family relationships somehow constitute unethical behavior is completely inaccurate and without merit."
DeniedResponding to: The accusations in the anonymous complaint, including that he pursued women romantically while conducting official business and that his guests at events raised ethical concerns, are "inaccurate, misleading, and completely false."
Full statement and sources
In a May 28, 2026 letter to the Chief Ethics Officer, later published as an exhibit to the report, Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell said the complaint's accusations were "inaccurate, misleading, and completely false," said he had "never asked anyone out on a date," and, referring to guests at events named in the complaint, said the suggestion that their professional and family relationships constitute unethical behavior is "completely inaccurate and without merit." The letter predates the investigation's findings.
After the statement
Caldwell also wrote that he would cooperate fully with any review process, that the complaint appeared to be driven by misinformation, false assumptions and what seemed to be a personal vendetta, and that as the first single Black man to serve at this level in government he suspected there would be other false accusations.
Investigation Report, Exhibit 3: Lieutenant Governor Caldwell's May 28, 2026 letter to the Chief Ethics Officer · Office of the Governor of New JerseyExhibit 3, Lt. Gov. Caldwell's May 28, 2026 letter (PDF pp. 47-50; letter at pp. 48-50)Mikie Sherrill elevated Dale Caldwell to new heights. His supporters say his reputation is being unfairly tarnished. · The Philadelphia InquirerArticle published September 22, 2026, 6:01 a.m. ETWhy this label?
Relative to the allegations the investigation later addressed, Caldwell explicitly says the accusations are false, that he did not pursue anyone romantically on official business, and that the guests' attendance was not unethical. That is an explicit denial of the alleged conduct. The letter predates the report and does not respond to its specific findings.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(47)
Original text
Investigation Report re: Lieutenant Governor Dr. Dale G. Caldwell, Executive Summary (Lowenstein Sandler LLP, September 23, 2026)
Relevant passage: Part I, Executive Summary, printed pp. 1-3 (PDF pp. 4-6)
Excerpt
"A violation of the Workplace Policy is substantiated. Two violations of state ethics rules are also substantiated."
About this source
The 61-page redacted report, with exhibits, that Lowenstein Sandler LLP prepared for the Governor's Chief Ethics Officer and that the Governor's Office published on September 24, 2026. The executive summary states the firm's three findings and the standard it applied. Witnesses are identified only by pseudonym.
- Author
- Lowenstein Sandler LLP (Christopher S. Porrino and Shontae D. Gray)
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
The Inquirer editorial board backs Caldwell's departure
Relevant passage: Editorial board assessment, paragraph comparing the alleged conduct with dismissal in private employment and its surrounding discussion
About this source
The editorial supports Caldwell's departure and criticizes the governor's earlier handling of the allegations. It treats the report's findings as allegations rather than criminal convictions.
- Author
- The Editorial Board
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
DiMaio and Steinhardt link succession proposal to Caldwell vacancy
Relevant passage: Full October 5 report, proposed confirmation requirement and Caldwell resignation context
About this source
The report covers the announcement of the proposed change. The official Assembly resolution identifies October 15 as its introduction date.
- Author
- David Wildstein
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
ACR157 proposes legislative approval for a replacement lieutenant governor
Relevant passage: Introduction header, proposed Article V amendment and statement
About this source
The introduced resolution proposes a constitutional amendment. It does not show that the amendment has been approved or taken effect.
- Author
- New Jersey Legislature
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Caldwell returns to the pulpit after resigning
Relevant passage: Full report, paragraphs describing his Sunday sermon two days after resigning
About this source
The report describes Caldwell's sermon and an unspecified church complaint. In his later published interview, Caldwell says the church process concerns the state report's allegations.
- Author
- David Wildstein
- Published
- Accessed
Interview
NJ Spotlight News publishes Caldwell's account of his resignation and the investigation
Relevant passage: Full published interview transcript with Rob Nelson, including the church process, report and disputed findings
About this source
The transcript records Caldwell's denials and his argument that the state process was unfair. The publication date does not establish when the interview was recorded.
- Author
- NJ Spotlight News
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
New Jersey editorial board calls for a swift resolution of Caldwell's status
Relevant passage: Full editorial syndicated from NorthJersey.com, findings and loss-of-confidence assessment
About this source
The editorial criticizes Caldwell's conduct as described by the investigation and urges a quick resolution. It appeared before his resignation later that day.
- Author
- USA TODAY Network New Jersey Editorial Board
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
Spadea questions Caldwell after initially defending him
Relevant passage: Paragraphs beginning Instead, he abruptly resigned through the discussion of accusations and guilt
About this source
Spadea says Caldwell's departure weakens his confidence in Caldwell's denial. He continues to distinguish accusations from proof of guilt.
- Author
- Bill Spadea
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
Spadea argues Caldwell should remain in office
Relevant passage: Final assessment and preceding discussion of all three investigative findings
About this source
Spadea disputes whether the reported conduct warrants resignation. His column precedes Caldwell's departure that day.
- Author
- Bill Spadea
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Booker, Kim call on Caldwell to resign as pressure builds
Relevant passage: Second through fifth paragraphs, quoting each senator
Excerpt
"The findings of the independent report are unacceptable. The Lt. Governor should resign immediately."
About this source
New Jersey Globe report on the calls for the lieutenant governor to resign from New Jersey's two U.S. senators and other officials after Gov. Mikie Sherrill gave him until September 25 to step down.
- Author
- David Wildstein
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
CBS New York: Former N.J. lieutenant governor Dale Caldwell addresses his resignation
Relevant passage: Paragraphs quoting Caldwell speaking outside his home in New Brunswick
Excerpt
"The report, I think, was just specious. There are all sorts of wrong things and mistakes. I'm not resigning because of that ridiculous report. I'm resigning because I don't want to be a distraction to the Mikie Sherrill administration."
About this source
CBS New York's report on Dale Caldwell's first public remarks, made Saturday, September 26, the day after he resigned as New Jersey's lieutenant governor. It also quotes his attorney, Thomas Calcagni, saying counsel will continue to challenge the investigation's findings and is "fully exploring all legal remedies."
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
NJ Lt. Governor Dale Caldwell has resigned, Gov. Sherrill says
Relevant passage: Paragraphs beginning "A statement issued by 11 Black New Jersey politicians" and "It was signed by Rep. Bonnie Watson Coleman"
Excerpt
"By choosing to step down and ending this controversy, he has put the interests of the people of New Jersey and the work of our state ahead of himself,” read the statement, which was released shortly ahead of Sherrill’s announcement."
About this source
Gothamist's report on Caldwell's resignation, which says 11 Black New Jersey politicians issued a statement shortly ahead of Sherrill's announcement and names three of the signers.
- Author
- Mike Hayes, Charles Lane and Michael Sol Warren
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Black leaders praise Caldwell’s decision to resign
Relevant passage: Paragraphs beginning "We commend and appreciate" and "We also respect the difficult decision"; signers listed in the paragraphs beginning "The signatories included" and "Other signatories included"
Excerpt
"We commend and appreciate Lieutenant Governor Dale Caldwell for making what we know could not have been an easy decision,” the group said. “By choosing to step down and ending this controversy, he has put the interests of the people of New Jersey and the work of our state ahead of himself."
About this source
New Jersey Globe report on the joint statement by Black elected officials, clergy and civic leaders on Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell's resignation. It names the signers.
- Author
- David Wildstein
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
DiMaio: How Are We Going to Have Any Confidence the Next LG Will Be Fully Vetted?
Relevant passage: Press release, first paragraph of DiMaio's statement
Excerpt
"Caldwell’s resignation was necessary. It does not erase Gov. Sherrill’s failure to vet the man she chose to stand one heartbeat from the governorship."
About this source
Press release from the New Jersey Legislative Assembly Republicans carrying Assembly Republican Leader John DiMaio's statement after Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell's resignation.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Legislative leaders agree Caldwell had to resign, split over Sherrill’s handling
Relevant passage: Article text, September 25, 2026
Excerpt
"“Following an independent investigation, Lieutenant Governor Dale Caldwell was right to resign from office today,” he said."
About this source
New Jersey Globe report on the four legislative leaders' reactions to Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell's resignation. It quotes Coughlin, Scutari, Bucco and DiMaio.
- Author
- David Wildstein
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Statement from Assembly Speaker Craig Coughlin on the Resignation of Dale Caldwell
Relevant passage: Press release, second and third paragraphs
Excerpt
"Following an independent investigation, Lieutenant Governor Dale Caldwell was right to resign from office today. We must ensure the work of governing is uninterrupted and that serving the people of New Jersey remains a top priority."
About this source
Press release from the New Jersey Legislative Assembly Democrats carrying Speaker Coughlin's statement on Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell's resignation.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Mejia, Hathaway Find Common Ground Over NJ Lt. Gov Scandal As They Battle For NJ-11 Seat
Relevant passage: Paragraphs quoting Analilia Mejia and Joe Hathaway
Excerpt
"The findings detailed in this investigation are deeply troubling, and Lt. Gov. Caldwell should resign immediately."
About this source
Bloomfield Patch report, posted Sept. 25, 2026, that quotes U.S. Rep. Analilia Mejia and Republican NJ-11 candidate Joe Hathaway each calling for Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell to resign. It was updated after Caldwell announced his resignation that day.
- Author
- Eric Kiefer
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
New Jersey Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell resigns after ethics probe
Relevant passage: Opening paragraphs and the paragraphs quoting Gov. Sherrill's Friday news conference and Caldwell's attorney
Excerpt
"Dale Caldwell resigned Friday as lieutenant governor of New Jersey after an investigation found "serious, repeated violations of state policy, including ethical lapses and a substantiated finding of sexual harassment," Gov. Mikie Sherrill said."
About this source
ABC News report on Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell's Sept. 25, 2026 resignation. It quotes Gov. Sherrill's news conference, quotes Caldwell's attorney Thomas Calcagni saying the resignation was submitted to end a targeted campaign to discredit his character and that counsel will continue to challenge the report, and reports that Sherrill said she is appointing an interim secretary of state to oversee the midterm elections.
- Author
- Aaron Katersky
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Bucco says legislature should act if Caldwell won’t resign; DiMaio demands Sherrill press conference
Relevant passage: Article published September 24, 2026, 11:26 p.m. ET
Excerpt
"if he doesn’t agree to resign, the legislature should follow the necessary protocols to resolve this matter once and for all."
About this source
New Jersey Globe's report on the Republican legislative leaders' reactions to the report, including Senate Republican Leader Bucco's statement and Assembly Republican Leader DiMaio's criticism of the Governor's handling of the matter.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Caldwell pushes back on harassment, ethics report, gives no sign he’ll resign
Relevant passage: Article published September 24, 2026, 9:34 p.m. ET
Excerpt
"The statement makes no mention of Sherrill’s resignation demand and gives no indication that Caldwell intends to step down."
About this source
New Jersey Globe's same-night report on the statement issued by Caldwell's attorney, quoting it at length and noting that it does not address the Governor's resignation demand.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Mikie Sherrill elevated Dale Caldwell to new heights. His supporters say his reputation is being unfairly tarnished.
Relevant passage: Article published September 22, 2026, 6:01 a.m. ET
Excerpt
"I have never asked anyone out on a date, ‘hit on,’ or pursued anyone romantically while conducting official business as Lieutenant Governor and Secretary of State"
About this source
The Philadelphia Inquirer's profile quoting the Lieutenant Governor's May 28 letter and interviews with several named supporters. It reports that a friend said Caldwell has told him he will not resign; Caldwell's own public position on resigning had not been stated at the time. He resigned on September 25, 2026.
- Author
- Susan K. Livio and Aliya Schneider
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
New Jersey governor asks her No. 2 to resign over ethics and sexual harassment violations (AP)
Relevant passage: Associated Press story updated September 24, 2026, 9:53 p.m. ET (Newsday copy)
Excerpt
"Caldwell’s lawyer, Thomas Calcagni, disputed the allegations, calling the investigation a one-sided operation that did not include necessary due process."
About this source
Associated Press coverage, syndicated by Newsday, of the Governor's call for resignation and the response of Caldwell's lawyer. It notes the Governor cannot remove the Lieutenant Governor, who can be impeached and removed by the Legislature.
- Author
- The Associated Press
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Sherrill gives Caldwell until tomorrow to resign after report substantiates sexual harassment, ethics violations
Relevant passage: Article published September 24, 2026
Excerpt
"Caldwell staunchly denied wrongdoing in his May 28 written response to the chief ethics officer in the governor’s office"
About this source
New Jersey Globe's same-night summary of the report, the Governor's statement, the report's account of earlier warnings, and the Lieutenant Governor's legal advisers.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Mikie Sherrill demands NJ lieutenant governor resign after report found improper behavior with women
Relevant passage: Article published September 24, 2026, 8:04 p.m. ET
Excerpt
"Caldwell’s attorney disputed the report’s findings but did not address whether he would resign."
About this source
Politico's same-night report on the Governor's demand and the Lieutenant Governor's response through counsel. It notes that only the Legislature can remove him, by impeachment.
- Author
- Daniel Han and Joey Fox
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Mikie Sherrill let her LG serve as acting governor for 18 days after internal investigation began
Relevant passage: Article published September 23, 2026, 8:12 p.m. ET
Excerpt
"Caldwell has not been acting governor since news of the investigation broke."
About this source
Politico's report, based on public records, on the law firm's May 21 retention and on the Lieutenant Governor's service as acting governor while the investigation was under way.
- Author
- Daniel Han
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Bucco, DiMaio call for legislative probe of Caldwell allegations
Relevant passage: Article published September 10, 2026
Excerpt
"Senate Minority Leader Anthony Bucco and Assembly Minority Leader John DiMaio are calling for a bipartisan legislative investigation into allegations involving Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell and the Sherrill administration’s handling of the matter."
About this source
New Jersey Globe's report on the letter, including a response from the Governor's spokesman.
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Letter from Senate Republican Leader Bucco and Assembly Republican Leader DiMaio to Senate President Scutari and Assembly Speaker Coughlin (September 10, 2026)
Relevant passage: Full letter dated September 10, 2026
Excerpt
"The Governor cannot be the sole judge of whether her own Administration responded appropriately to serious allegations involving one of its highest-ranking officials."
About this source
The Republican legislative leaders' letter asking the Democratic presiding officers to create a bicameral, bipartisan select committee to investigate the allegations and the administration's handling of them.
- Author
- Senator Anthony M. Bucco and Assemblyman John DiMaio
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Mikie Sherrill provides few answers in first appearance since lieutenant governor investigation surfaced
Relevant passage: Article published September 9, 2026, 7:45 p.m. ET
Excerpt
"“not going to confirm or deny whether there’s an ongoing investigation,”"
About this source
Politico's report of the Governor's September 9 remarks, including that she did not name the Lieutenant Governor and declined to respond to Republican calls for his resignation.
- Author
- Joey Fox
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Sherrill declines to discuss Caldwell investigation, says election preparations remain on track
Relevant passage: Article published September 9, 2026
Excerpt
"“I’m not going to confirm or deny whether there’s an ongoing investigation,”"
About this source
New Jersey Globe's report of the Governor's remarks to reporters on September 9, her first public appearance after the investigation was reported.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Lt. Governor Dale Caldwell under investigation after allegations of inappropriate behavior
Relevant passage: Article published September 4, 2026
Excerpt
"“We cannot confirm or deny potential personnel matters.”"
About this source
The first published report that the Lieutenant Governor was the subject of an internal investigation led by former Attorney General Christopher Porrino, including the Governor's spokesman's response.
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Dale Caldwell supporters launch movement demanding firsthand witnesses be heard
Relevant passage: Article published September 16, 2026
Excerpt
"Supporters of Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell are pushing back against an investigation into allegations that he brought “uninvited female guests” to official events, arguing that organizers and other firsthand witnesses must be interviewed before anyone reaches conclusions."
About this source
New Jersey Globe's report on the September 16 launch of the "Let the People There Be Heard" effort by Caldwell supporters, including quotations from Felicia Simmons.
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Press Release: Felicia Simmons, Let the People Who Were There Be Heard!
Relevant passage: Full press release dated September 14, 2026
Excerpt
"Dr. Dale Caldwell deserves a fair hearing, just as anyone else would."
About this source
Written statement by an organizer of the April 2026 Whitesboro Black History Gala, one of the events named in the anonymous complaint, published on the Preserve Whitesboro website. It describes her communications with the Lieutenant Governor's office and asks that event organizers be heard.
- Author
- Felicia Simmons
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Brennan calls for independent investigation into Caldwell, plans survivor-protection legislation
Relevant passage: Article published September 8, 2026
Excerpt
"“These are serious allegations that deserve a thorough and independent investigation,” Brennan (D-Jersey City) said in a statement."
About this source
New Jersey Globe's report of Assemblywoman Brennan's statement.
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Statement from Assemblywoman Katie Brennan on Investigation into Lt. Governor Dale Caldwell
Relevant passage: Full statement, published September 8, 2026
Excerpt
"Anyone who uses the power of public office to mistreat the people around them has no business holding it."
About this source
Press statement from a Democratic member of the General Assembly responding to the reported internal investigation and announcing legislation on workplace harassment protections.
- Author
- Assemblywoman Katie Brennan
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Bramnick Urges Respect for Process in Caldwell Case
Relevant passage: Article published September 8, 2026
Excerpt
"State Senator Jon Bramnick (R-21) cautioned people about rushing to judgment in the case of Lieutenant Governor Dale Caldwell."
About this source
InsiderNJ's report quoting Sen. Bramnick's post alongside the Senate Republican Leader's earlier call for Caldwell to step aside temporarily. The article's transcription differs by one word from the original post.
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Sen. Jon Bramnick's X post on calls for Lt. Gov. Caldwell's resignation
Excerpt
"In today’s world some don’t even wait for the specific allegations before they convict the accused."
About this source
A post on Sen. Bramnick's X account, quoted by Politico's New Jersey Playbook and reproduced by InsiderNJ, written after several Republican officials called for Caldwell to resign or step aside and before the allegations were made public.
- Author
- Sen. Jon Bramnick
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
NJGOP Chair Hanlon Calls on New Jersey Lieutenant Governor Caldwell to Resign Immediately
Relevant passage: Full press release dated September 5, 2026
Excerpt
"Dale Caldwell must resign as Lieutenant Governor and Secretary of State immediately."
About this source
The New Jersey Republican State Committee's press release, issued after the New Jersey Globe reported the investigation and before any allegations or findings were published. It cites reporting that the inquiry began in late spring.
- Author
- Christine Giordano Hanlon, NJGOP Chairwoman
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Bucco Statement on Latest News Regarding Investigation into Dale Caldwell
Relevant passage: Full statement dated September 24, 2026
Excerpt
"if he doesn’t agree to resign, the Legislature should follow the necessary protocols to resolve this matter once and for all."
About this source
Press statement from the New Jersey Senate Republican Leader issued after the report was published, reproduced by InsiderNJ.
- Author
- Senate Republican Leader Anthony M. Bucco
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Statement regarding Lieutenant Governor Dr. Dale G. Caldwell (counsel Thomas Calcagni, September 24, 2026)
Relevant passage: Full two-page statement, revised version, September 24, 2026
Excerpt
"The Lieutenant Governor was not provided a meaningful opportunity to address each of these anonymous allegations or offer readily identifiable witnesses who possessed more pertinent, first-hand knowledge of the events in question."
About this source
Written statement issued for the Lieutenant Governor by his attorney after the report was released. It disputes each of the three findings and the fairness of the process. It does not say whether he would resign; he resigned the next day, September 25, 2026.
- Author
- Thomas Calcagni, Calcagni & Kanefsky LLP, counsel for Lt. Gov. Dale Caldwell
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Statement by Governor Mikie Sherrill (September 8, 2026)
Relevant passage: Full statement, posted September 8, 2026
Excerpt
"I take my responsibility to treat any reports of inappropriate behavior or misconduct extremely seriously, and any credible report must be fully examined and addressed."
About this source
The Governor's first public statement after the investigation was reported. It refers to neither the Lieutenant Governor nor an investigation, and it says both complainants and the subject of a complaint are entitled to protection and a fair review.
- Author
- Governor Mikie Sherrill
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Gov. Sherrill's X post on the investigation into Lt. Gov. Caldwell
Excerpt
"The Lieutenant Governor’s resignation is necessary and in the best interest of New Jersey residents."
About this source
The full text of the Governor's statement posted on her official, government-verified X account shortly after the report was released.
- Author
- Governor Mikie Sherrill
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Governor Sherrill Releases Report on Investigation into Lieutenant Governor Caldwell, Calls for Resignation
Relevant passage: Full statement, posted September 24, 2026
Excerpt
"I’m calling for his resignation and giving him until tomorrow to do so."
About this source
The Governor's official press release announcing the conclusion of the independent investigation, linking the report, and calling for the Lieutenant Governor's resignation by the next day.
- Author
- Governor Mikie Sherrill
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Investigation Report: promotion request finding and Exhibit 7 email of May 26, 2026
Relevant passage: Part IV.C.2 (printed pp. 24-27), Part V.B.2.b (printed pp. 36-38) and Exhibit 7, email of May 26, 2026 (PDF pp. 57-61)
Excerpt
"The LG admitted to investigators that he did not disclose the romantic nature of his relationship with the state employee while making these promotion requests."
About this source
The report's account of the Lieutenant Governor's May 26, 2026 email to an executive-branch official recommending a state employee, whom he acknowledged was his girlfriend, for a leadership position, and of an earlier verbal request. The report records that no promotion or other benefit was conferred.
- Author
- Lowenstein Sandler LLP (Christopher S. Porrino and Shontae D. Gray)
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Investigation Report, Exhibit 3: Lieutenant Governor Caldwell's May 28, 2026 letter to the Chief Ethics Officer
Relevant passage: Exhibit 3, Lt. Gov. Caldwell's May 28, 2026 letter (PDF pp. 47-50; letter at pp. 48-50)
Excerpt
"The accusations contained in this complaint are inaccurate, misleading, and completely false."
About this source
The Lieutenant Governor's signed three-page written response to the anonymous complaint, dated May 28, 2026, before the investigation's findings. It answers the complaint's allegations about guests at events and about pursuing women, and it was published in full (with names redacted) as an exhibit to the report.
- Author
- Dale G. Caldwell; reproduced in the Lowenstein Sandler LLP report
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Investigation Report: notification of investigation (May 22, 2026, Exhibit 2)
Relevant passage: Part III.B (printed pp. 7-8) and Exhibit 2, notification letter dated May 22, 2026 (PDF pp. 44-46)
Excerpt
"The existence of an investigation does not constitute a finding of wrongdoing."
About this source
The Chief Ethics Officer's May 22, 2026 letter formally notifying the Lieutenant Governor of the complaint and of the assignment of the investigation to Lowenstein Sandler LLP. Part III.B of the report also summarizes his written response of May 28.
- Author
- Christina C. Fullam, Chief Ethics Officer; reproduced in the Lowenstein Sandler LLP report
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Investigation Report, Exhibit 1: anonymous complaint dated May 6, 2026
Relevant passage: Part III.A (printed pp. 6-7) and Exhibit 1, anonymous complaint (PDF pp. 42-43)
Excerpt
"has been bringing uninvited female guests to events while traveling using taxpayer funds"
About this source
The unsigned May 6, 2026 letter addressed to the State Ethics Commission, the Attorney General's office, the Civil Service Commission's EEO division, and a New York Times reporter. It is the complaint that led to the investigation. Its allegations are the complainant's own and were not adopted as findings except where the report says so.
- Author
- Anonymous complainant; reproduced in the Lowenstein Sandler LLP report
- Published
- Accessed
Original text
Investigation Report re: Lieutenant Governor Dr. Dale G. Caldwell, Conclusion (Lowenstein Sandler LLP, September 23, 2026)
Relevant passage: Part VI, Conclusion, printed p. 38 (PDF p. 41)
Excerpt
"the LG violated the Uniform Ethics Code and Code of Conduct when he brought guests to ticketed events without payment or reimbursement"
About this source
The report's one-page conclusion lists the three matters it found substantiated: a workplace-policy violation for a comment to a female staffer, and two ethics violations concerning unpaid guests at ticketed events and a promotion request for a state employee with whom the Lieutenant Governor had a romantic relationship.
- Author
- Lowenstein Sandler LLP (Christopher S. Porrino and Shontae D. Gray)
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Should Dale Caldwell resign as New Jersey's lieutenant governor after the investigation's findings?
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/should-dale-caldwell-resign-as-new-jersey-s-lieutenant-governor-after-the-investigation-s-findings
The Dispute Index. "Should Dale Caldwell resign as New Jersey's lieutenant governor after the investigation's findings?". First published: 2026-09-25. Last updated: 2026-09-25. https://disputeindex.com/cases/should-dale-caldwell-resign-as-new-jersey-s-lieutenant-governor-after-the-investigation-s-findings