Perris City Council suspends its Flock license-plate camera contract in a 3-2 vote
Perris, California, voted 3-2 to suspend its Flock Safety license plate camera agreement. Three council members cited a lack of community trust, while the mayor, a council member and the sheriff's office argued that the cameras help solve crimes.
Perris council members debate the city's Flock Safety license plate reader agreement and vote to suspend it, at the City Council meeting on Nov. 10, 2026.
Nine excerpts joined by a one-second black gap: 1:03:00 to 1:03:28, 1:51:33 to 1:51:59, 1:57:33 to 1:58:05, 2:03:43 to 2:03:56, 2:04:31 to 2:04:40, 2:05:18 to 2:06:04, 2:08:37 to 2:08:47, 2:10:15 to 2:10:26, and 2:11:05 to 2:11:14 of the City of Perris recording of its Nov. 10, 2026 City Council meeting. The excerpts run in meeting order: the Riverside County Sheriff's presentation, the quoted remarks of each council member, the substitute motion and the result of the vote. DI added its logo in the corner.
Video: City of Perris (Perris TV)
Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: Flock Safety agreement renewal item, from about 1:00:00 (staff report and Capt. Kevin Lamb presentation) to 2:11:10 (council discussion and vote))
Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Overview
Perris approved a two-year agreement with Flock Safety in March 2024 for license plate cameras at intersections across the city. According to The Riverside Record, the agreement expired on June 30, 2026, and continued month to month while the council considered renewal. City staff proposed a two-year renewal at $308,292 a year.
At the meeting, Capt. Kevin Lamb of the Riverside County Sheriff's Office said the department keeps the data for 30 days unless it is needed for an active investigation and does not share it with federal or out-of-state agencies. The council received six letters opposing renewal and heard from 15 public speakers, all of whom opposed it. Before the meeting, sheriff's spokesperson Lt. Deirdre Vickers told KVCR that losing the system would cause significant investigative delays, and Flock Safety spokesperson Andrew Smith told KVCR that the company's technology helps investigators find missing people and solve crimes faster.
The suspension passed as a substitute motion to a motion to renew the agreement. It suspends the agreement until the council and the public feel comfortable bringing it back and sets no date for that.
Timeline
3 timeline entries on this page. Dates: March 26, 2024 to November 10, 2026
March 2024
Perris approves a two-year agreement with Flock Safety
The City Council approves a two-year agreement with Flock Safety for the purchase and installation of 99 license plate recognition cameras at intersections throughout the city.
[01]The Riverside Record: Perris Council Suspends Agreement With Flock Safety In Split Vote
Reports the 3-2 vote, the history of the city's Flock Safety agreement, the presentation by Capt. Kevin Lamb of the Riverside County Sheriff's Office, public comment and remarks by each council member.
June 2026
The Flock agreement expires and continues month to month
The two-year agreement expires. The city keeps the service on a month-to-month basis while the council decides whether to renew it.
[01]The Riverside Record: Perris Council Suspends Agreement With Flock Safety In Split Vote
Reports the 3-2 vote, the history of the city's Flock Safety agreement, the presentation by Capt. Kevin Lamb of the Riverside County Sheriff's Office, public comment and remarks by each council member.
November 2026
Perris council votes 3-2 to suspend the Flock agreement
After a sheriff's office presentation urging renewal and public comment opposing the contract, the council approves a substitute motion to suspend the agreement. Corona, Nava and Vallejo vote yes; Vargas and Rabb vote no.
[02]City of Perris: City Council meeting, November 10, 2026 (video)
Official video of the Perris City Council meeting at which the council heard a Riverside County Sheriff's Office presentation on the Flock license plate reader system, discussed renewing the Flock Safety agreement and voted 3-2 on a substitute motion to suspend it. The audio drops out for about three minutes during Mayor Pro Tem Malcolm Corona's remarks.
City of Perris: City Council meeting, November 10, 2026 (video)Flock Safety agreement renewal item, from about 1:00:00 (staff report and Capt. Kevin Lamb presentation) to 2:11:10 (council discussion and vote)[01]The Riverside Record: Perris Council Suspends Agreement With Flock Safety In Split Vote
Reports the 3-2 vote, the history of the city's Flock Safety agreement, the presentation by Capt. Kevin Lamb of the Riverside County Sheriff's Office, public comment and remarks by each council member.
[03]KVCR: Perris council votes to suspend a two year, $615,000 contract with Flock Safety
Reports the November 10 vote to suspend the Flock Safety contract, remarks by council members and Mayor Michael Vargas, comments from a Riverside County Sheriff's Department spokesperson before the meeting and a statement from a Flock Safety spokesperson.
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
6 responses. Newest first.
Malcolm CoronaPerris mayor pro tem and District 4 council member, at the November 10, 2026 City Council meetingDirectly involved Before this statement
Corona said Florida had ended its contracts and revoked permits for Flock cameras on state highway rights-of-way and that Texas had stopped state funding for them. He said a California bill to restrict license plate reader data had died in August 2026 and that Flock had lobbied against it.
"But at this time, our communities, they do need to have trust in not only our law enforcement, but also in the tools that they use. And I would be, at this time, I would be open to suspending Flock at this time until further safeguards ... until safeguards are put in place, that our community can fully trust technology of that sort."
Defended or excusedCase context: Perris City Council suspends its Flock license-plate camera contract in a 3-2 vote
Full statement and sources
Corona says the community needs to trust both law enforcement and the tools it uses, and that he is open to suspending Flock until safeguards the community can fully trust are in place.
After the statement
He said the money the city saves should go to other public safety measures recommended by the public safety committee, until the council decides what to do while it waits for further safeguards.
City of Perris: City Council meeting, November 10, 2026 (video)Flock Safety agreement renewal item, from about 1:00:00 (staff report and Capt. Kevin Lamb presentation) to 2:11:10 (council discussion and vote)Why this label?
The case concerns the Perris City Council's November 10, 2026 decision to suspend its agreement with Flock Safety, so support for the suspension counts as a defense and opposition to it as a condemnation. Corona backs suspending Flock until safeguards the community can trust are in place and voted for the suspension, so we labeled it a defense. He credits the success stories of such technology and ties the suspension to future safeguards, but he supports suspending the cameras now, so the statement is not mixed or conditional.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Marisela NavaPerris District 1 council member, at the November 10, 2026 City Council meeting Before this statement
Nava said she had not heard any public speaker support continuing the Flock contract and that she considers it a great tool for public safety, but that the item had been driven by the community. She said the council could consider a similar program in the future with better safeguards or regulations.
"But at the end of the day, we don't know what Flock is doing with that information, right? So again, I really want to be responsive to my community. And at this point, this tool isn't making them feel safe. So that is why I have to make the tough decision to consider at this moment either pausing it or something to that extent."
Defended or excusedCase context: Perris City Council suspends its Flock license-plate camera contract in a 3-2 vote
Full statement and sources
Nava says the city does not know what Flock does with the data, even though it is erased after 30 days. She says the tool is not making her community feel safe and that she has to consider pausing it.
After the statement
She said those were her comments for now.
City of Perris: City Council meeting, November 10, 2026 (video)Flock Safety agreement renewal item, from about 1:00:00 (staff report and Capt. Kevin Lamb presentation) to 2:11:10 (council discussion and vote)Why this label?
The case concerns the Perris City Council's November 10, 2026 decision to suspend its agreement with Flock Safety, so support for the suspension counts as a defense and opposition to it as a condemnation. Nava says the tool is not making residents feel safe and that she has to consider pausing it, which supports the suspension the council approved, so we labeled it a defense. She calls Flock a great tool for public safety and leaves room for a similar program with better safeguards, but she backs pausing it now, so the statement is not mixed or conditional.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Elizabeth VallejoPerris District 2 council member, at the November 10, 2026 City Council meeting Before this statement
Vallejo questioned Capt. Kevin Lamb about the number of cameras, data sharing with federal agencies and reports of officers elsewhere misusing license plate readers. She told him she appreciated his team's work.
"But I do believe that since the community has no trust in you guys or Flock, it's up to you guys, and it's the same with us, to gain that trust back to the community. ... I agree with Council Member Corona that I believe we should suspend it until, if anything changes, we can always bring it up."
Defended or excusedCase context: Perris City Council suspends its Flock license-plate camera contract in a 3-2 vote
Full statement and sources
Vallejo tells the sheriff's captain that the community has no trust in the department or in Flock and that both the department and the council must earn it back. She agrees with Corona that the council should suspend Flock and bring it back if anything changes.
After the statement
She said Flock had a bad reputation and asked why the council would approve it. She then seconded the substitute motion to suspend the agreement and voted for it.
City of Perris: City Council meeting, November 10, 2026 (video)Flock Safety agreement renewal item, from about 1:00:00 (staff report and Capt. Kevin Lamb presentation) to 2:11:10 (council discussion and vote)Why this label?
The case concerns the Perris City Council's November 10, 2026 decision to suspend its agreement with Flock Safety, so support for the suspension counts as a defense and opposition to it as a condemnation. Vallejo says the city should suspend Flock because the community does not trust it, and she seconded and voted for the suspension, so we labeled it a defense. She praises the deputies' work, but that praise is for the department rather than for keeping the cameras, so the statement is not mixed or conditional.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
David Starr RabbPerris District 3 council member and San Bernardino County deputy district attorney, at the November 10, 2026 City Council meeting Before this statement
Rabb said he had used Flock as a deputy district attorney in San Bernardino County to help solve some of his cases. He said the city put Flock in place two years earlier to help solve crimes, and he named kidnappings, hit-and-runs and DUI crashes as examples.
"I think a lot of the concerns regarding Flock are overblown. I believe that we have safeguards in place with the state of California, particularly SB 54. ... We're going to have to go to those people and say that we took the cameras down, and are we prepared to do that? And just serving up here for 12 years, I'm not prepared to do that."
CondemnedCase context: Perris City Council suspends its Flock license-plate camera contract in a 3-2 vote
Full statement and sources
Rabb says many concerns about Flock are overblown because California law, including SB 54, provides safeguards. He says that if the city stops Flock, the council will have to tell crime victims that it took the cameras down, and that he is not prepared to do that.
After the statement
He said he would vote to move forward with the contract. He voted against the substitute motion to suspend the agreement.
City of Perris: City Council meeting, November 10, 2026 (video)Flock Safety agreement renewal item, from about 1:00:00 (staff report and Capt. Kevin Lamb presentation) to 2:11:10 (council discussion and vote)Why this label?
The case concerns the Perris City Council's November 10, 2026 decision to suspend its agreement with Flock Safety, so support for the suspension counts as a defense and opposition to it as a condemnation. Rabb argues against stopping Flock, saying he is not prepared to tell crime victims the city took the cameras down, and he voted against the suspension, so we labeled it a condemnation. He also calls the concerns about Flock overblown, but he goes on to reject taking the cameras down, so the statement is more than a challenge to how Flock is described.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Michael VargasMayor of Perris, at the November 10, 2026 City Council meetingDirectly involved Before this statement
Vargas asked Capt. Kevin Lamb whether any deputies had misused the system, and Lamb said he was not aware of any. Vargas then confirmed with Lamb that deputies do not obtain information about a car's driver through Flock.
"Flock is not the DMV. They're just recording license plates as you go around."
Challenged the characterizationCase context: Perris City Council suspends its Flock license-plate camera contract in a 3-2 vote
Full statement and sources
Vargas says Flock only records license plates as cars pass and, unlike the Department of Motor Vehicles, does not hold personal information about drivers.
After the statement
Vargas said that, as Rabb had noted, SB 54 applies and there is no state sharing, and he asked Lamb to confirm that the system is not an immigration tool, which Lamb did. Vargas voted against the substitute motion to suspend the agreement.
City of Perris: City Council meeting, November 10, 2026 (video)Flock Safety agreement renewal item, from about 1:00:00 (staff report and Capt. Kevin Lamb presentation) to 2:11:10 (council discussion and vote)Why this label?
The case concerns the Perris City Council's November 10, 2026 decision to suspend its agreement with Flock Safety. Vargas disputes the description of Flock as a system that gathers personal data, saying it only records license plates, which goes to the concerns behind the suspension; he does not address the suspension itself in this passage, so we labeled it as challenging the characterization. He voted against the suspension, but this passage disputes how Flock is described rather than criticizing the decision itself.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Riverside County Sheriff's OfficeCapt. Kevin Lamb, commander of the sheriff's Perris Station, presenting the department's position to the City Council on November 10, 2026Before this statement
Lamb said the city deploys 104 Flock cameras, that the sheriff's office uses them for retroactive searches and real-time hot list alerts, and that deputies must verify an alert through CLETS before taking any enforcement action.
"Renewing the contract is important because discontinuing the system would remove a huge, valuable source of investigative evidence for us and our investigators. It would eliminate an important investigative resource that could result in longer investigative timelines, fewer leads, more difficulty connecting crimes committed across the city and cause delays in locating offenders or missing family members, to include victims of kidnapping."
CondemnedCase context: Perris City Council suspends its Flock license-plate camera contract in a 3-2 vote
Full statement and sources
Presenting to the council before the vote, Capt. Kevin Lamb says renewing the Flock contract is important because discontinuing the system would remove a valuable source of evidence and could lead to longer investigations, fewer leads and delays in finding offenders or missing people.
After the statement
He said Flock works alongside the city's ShotSpotter gunshot detection system. Later in the presentation he said the office's position is that Flock should remain available only as a focused law enforcement tool governed by strict controls.
City of Perris: City Council meeting, November 10, 2026 (video)Flock Safety agreement renewal item, from about 1:00:00 (staff report and Capt. Kevin Lamb presentation) to 2:11:10 (council discussion and vote)Why this label?
The case concerns the Perris City Council's November 10, 2026 decision to suspend its agreement with Flock Safety, so opposition to the suspension counts as a condemnation. Speaking for the sheriff's office before the vote, Lamb argues that discontinuing the system would harm investigations, which rejects the course the council then took, so we labeled it a condemnation. The office acknowledges legitimate privacy questions, but it still asks the council to keep the cameras, so the statement is not mixed or conditional.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(3)
Original video
City of Perris: City Council meeting, November 10, 2026 (video)
Perris council members debate the city's Flock Safety license plate reader agreement and vote to suspend it, at the City Council meeting on Nov. 10, 2026.
Nine excerpts joined by a one-second black gap: 1:03:00 to 1:03:28, 1:51:33 to 1:51:59, 1:57:33 to 1:58:05, 2:03:43 to 2:03:56, 2:04:31 to 2:04:40, 2:05:18 to 2:06:04, 2:08:37 to 2:08:47, 2:10:15 to 2:10:26, and 2:11:05 to 2:11:14 of the City of Perris recording of its Nov. 10, 2026 City Council meeting. The excerpts run in meeting order: the Riverside County Sheriff's presentation, the quoted remarks of each council member, the substitute motion and the result of the vote. DI added its logo in the corner.
Video: City of Perris (Perris TV)
Watch the full original video (opens in a new tab) (relevant passage: Flock Safety agreement renewal item, from about 1:00:00 (staff report and Capt. Kevin Lamb presentation) to 2:11:10 (council discussion and vote))
About this source
Official video of the Perris City Council meeting at which the council heard a Riverside County Sheriff's Office presentation on the Flock license plate reader system, discussed renewing the Flock Safety agreement and voted 3-2 on a substitute motion to suspend it. The audio drops out for about three minutes during Mayor Pro Tem Malcolm Corona's remarks.
- Author
- City of Perris (Perris TV)
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The Riverside Record: Perris Council Suspends Agreement With Flock Safety In Split Vote
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Reports the 3-2 vote, the history of the city's Flock Safety agreement, the presentation by Capt. Kevin Lamb of the Riverside County Sheriff's Office, public comment and remarks by each council member.
- Author
- Alicia Ramirez
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
KVCR: Perris council votes to suspend a two year, $615,000 contract with Flock Safety
Relevant passage: Article text
About this source
Reports the November 10 vote to suspend the Flock Safety contract, remarks by council members and Mayor Michael Vargas, comments from a Riverside County Sheriff's Department spokesperson before the meeting and a statement from a Flock Safety spokesperson.
- Author
- Rami Alarian
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Perris City Council suspends its Flock license-plate camera contract in a 3-2 vote
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/perris-city-council-suspends-flock-contract
The Dispute Index. "Perris City Council suspends its Flock license-plate camera contract in a 3-2 vote". First published: 2026-11-16. Last updated: 2026-11-16. https://disputeindex.com/cases/perris-city-council-suspends-flock-contract