Farage defends Reform's vetting after ITV films racist remarks
Farage says Reform vets heavily and deals appropriately with misconduct after recorded racist and sexist remarks. Critics say ITV reporting points to repeated failures in candidate checks and discipline.
Case period:
Published by The Dispute Index editorial teamPublished Updated
Overview
The dispute concerns whether Reform UK leadership adequately vetted candidates and responded to misconduct, and whether its explanation of a small number of unrepresentative individuals accounts for the published findings.
Read the full background
ITV News released findings from its undercover investigation on October 14, 2026, followed by reporting on candidate vetting and the handling of complaints on October 15. ITV aired the complete film, Undercover: A Year in Reform, on October 18 and published it on its ITV News YouTube channel. The reports describe racist, Islamophobic and sexist remarks by councillors and candidates. Reform said it had improved its checks, begun investigations and suspended some people, while a small number who did not share its values could still pass vetting.
Farage argued that the party deals appropriately with misconduct and cannot predict future remarks. After the broadcast, he told a rally in Plymouth on October 20 that any large group has some bad eggs and that Reform was not uniquely awful. Phillipson said he could not dismiss recurring incidents as a few unsuitable individuals. Peston argued that the published findings concerned failures to check past conduct. The question is the adequacy of leadership handling, rather than whether the recorded language was acceptable.
Party membership and elected office are separate. Solihull Council confirmed on October 16 that Feeney, Whelan and Campbell had resigned their council seats. ITV reported that other named councillors remained in Reform, and on October 18 the party said it would take no further action against Hounslow councillors Adam Parkins and David Kerr. On October 21 Reform said it had reported ITV and its undercover reporters to the police. ITV said it stands by its journalism.
People in this case
- Nigel FarageDirectly involved
Timeline
10 timeline entries on this page. Dates: October 12, 2026 to October 24, 2026
October 2026
Tice alleges misconduct in ITV and Hardcash investigation
Claim
Richard Tice posts a caption alleging criminal conduct by ITV and Hardcash Productions and saying the investigation aims to harm Reform. The allegation precedes publication of the October 14 reporting.
[01]Richard Tice alleges misconduct by ITV and Hardcash
The caption alleges criminal conduct in the investigation and introduces an attached video. The caption establishes Tice made the allegation; it does not establish that an offense occurred.
Richard Tice alleges misconduct by ITV and HardcashText of post 2109686283694154153ITV publishes undercover findings about Reform councillors
Source release
ITV News publishes reporting and excerpts showing councillors and candidates making racist, Islamophobic and sexist remarks. Reform responds that investigations and some suspensions have begun and that due process applies.
[02]ITV News investigation into Reform councillors and candidates
ITV News publishes findings and excerpts from its undercover investigation, with the party response. Its report describes recorded comments by councillors and candidates across several campaigns.
ITV News investigation into Reform councillors and candidatesPublished investigation and Reform UK responseDavey condemns the racism described in ITV reporting
Reaction
Liberal Democrat leader Ed Davey shares ITV's investigation, expresses concern for people frightened by the reported racism and warns against its place in British politics.
[03]Ed Davey responds to ITV Reform reporting
Davey condemns the reported racism and warns against its place in British politics. His post responds to ITV reporting.
Ed Davey responds to ITV Reform reportingPost 2110446422499725806, including the quoted ITV linkITV publishes further findings about Reform vetting
Source release
ITV News reports on advice about passing candidate checks and the handling of racism complaints by senior officials. The report includes the party's response and precedes the scheduled October 18 documentary.
[04]ITV News report on Reform vetting and senior officials
ITV News publishes further findings about candidate checks and the handling of racism complaints. The article contains allegations and attributed responses ahead of the complete documentary.
ITV News report on Reform vetting and senior officialsVetting advice, handling of complaints and Reform UK responseBurnham calls for action as other politicians criticize Reform
Reaction
Andy Burnham calls for immediate action against those who made the reported comments. James Cleverly criticizes Reform's political direction, while Kemi Badenoch rejects deals with Reform and attacks its standards of conduct.
[05]ITV News report on responses to its Reform investigation
The report quotes Farage defending vetting and discipline and Phillipson rejecting his handling of repeated incidents. First published October 14, it was updated October 15 with later responses.
ITV News report on responses to its Reform investigationFarage remarks in Chelmsford; Phillipson statement; other political responses[06]Kemi Badenoch criticizes Reform after ITV reporting
Badenoch rejects deals with Reform and criticizes its leadership and standards of conduct. Her political criticism is presented as her own response.
Kemi Badenoch criticizes Reform after ITV reportingPost 2110772141436047474Solihull Council confirms three councillors have resigned
Council leader Karen Grinsell confirms that Alan Feeney, Chris Whelan and Jamie Campbell resigned their council seats. The council plans to replace their committee positions, choose a new deputy mayor and arrange a by-election.
[07]Karen Grinsell's October 16 Solihull Council column
The council leader confirms that Alan Feeney, Chris Whelan and Jamie Campbell resigned as councillors and explains the resulting vacancies. These elected-office resignations differ from departure from a political party.
Karen Grinsell's October 16 Solihull Council columnOpening paragraphs confirming three council resignationsITV reports Feeney job suspension and remaining Reform councillors
ITV reports that Alan Feeney was suspended from his job at HMP Birmingham, quoting the Ministry of Justice saying an investigation would follow. Its named status check also reports that Adam Parkins, David Kerr and George Madgwick remained Reform councillors.
[08]ITV News reports Jenrick defending Reform vetting and discipline
ITV News quotes Jenrick defending the party response, then reports which named councillors remained in Reform, left the party or resigned elected office. It also reports Alan Feeney being suspended from his prison-service job.
ITV News reports Jenrick defending Reform vetting and disciplineBBC Radio 4 Today quotations and named councillor status updateITV broadcasts the complete Undercover: A Year in Reform film
Source release
ITV broadcasts the full Exposure film, made by Hardcash Productions, and publishes it on the ITV News YouTube channel. The film runs 1 hour 35 minutes and draws on a year of undercover filming within Reform UK, including at its Westminster headquarters.
[09]ITV Exposure film Undercover: A Year in Reform (full upload)
The complete ITV Exposure documentary, made by Hardcash Productions and published in full on the ITV News YouTube channel on October 18. The upload plays only in the UK; ITVX also carries the film for UK viewers.
ITV Exposure film Undercover: A Year in Reform (full upload)Full film, 1:35:40[10]ITV News Talking Politics on Farage's Plymouth response
The ITV News podcast plays clips of Farage's October 20 rally speech in Plymouth and of a broadcast interview, then its hosts discuss them. The episode description says the film aired in full on October 18.
ITV News Talking Politics on Farage's Plymouth response4:44 to 6:20 (rally speech clip) and 6:37 to 6:54 (interview clip)Reform says it has reported ITV and its reporters to police
Claim
Zia Yusuf, Reform UK's home affairs spokesman, says the party has reported ITV, its board and its undercover reporters to the police and will take legal action. He alleges that the reporters forged a passport and that paid canvassing broke election law. ITV says it stands by its journalism and would cooperate with police.
[11]Zia Yusuf says Reform has reported ITV to police
Reform UK's home affairs spokesman announces a police report against ITV, its board and its undercover reporters. The post states his allegations; it does not establish that an offence occurred.
Zia Yusuf says Reform has reported ITV to policeText of post 2112866217643876432[12]The News report on Reform reporting ITV to police
The report summarizes Yusuf's video statement about police reports and civil proceedings and quotes ITV's response that it stands by its journalism.
The News report on Reform reporting ITV to policeYusuf's video statement and ITV's responseTwo police forces assess allegations about the ITV programme
The Metropolitan Police tells LBC it received a report on October 14 making allegations about the programme's production and is assessing whether to investigate. Hampshire police say they received an allegation of electoral offences in the Portsmouth area on October 21 and are reviewing material.
[13]LBC report on police reviews of Reform's complaints about ITV
LBC quotes the Metropolitan Police and Hampshire police on allegations they received about the programme. Both forces describe assessment or review, not an investigation.
LBC report on police reviews of Reform's complaints about ITVMetropolitan Police and Hampshire police statements
Claims
Claims separate what was said from what is contested. Follow each source for the original wording and context.
What's disputed
Disputed claim
Reform UK deals appropriately with people who say or do bad things.
What is disputed
Farage made this defense of party handling after ITV reporting. Phillipson and other critics questioned the adequacy of the response to repeated incidents.
Sources (1)
- ITV News report on responses to its Reform investigationFarage remarks in Chelmsford; Phillipson statement; other political responses
Disputed claim
The published ITV findings indicate flaws in Reform UK's retrospective checks, rather than only the difficulty of predicting future comments.
What is disputed
Peston argues that reported advice about old social posts and candidate selection concerns checks on known past conduct. Farage says future remarks cannot be predicted and defends the party's procedures.
Sources (2)
- Robert Peston's analysis of Farage's vetting defenseAnalysis of retrospective checks and candidate selection
- ITV News report on Reform vetting and senior officialsVetting advice, handling of complaints and Reform UK response
Response record
Responses
Choose one response filter, or select All responses to see the full record.
4 matching responses. Newest first.
Nigel FarageReform UK leader and MP for ClactonDirectly involvedBefore this statement
Speaking at a Reform UK rally in Plymouth two days after the film aired, Farage says Reform councillors, having been provoked, said some things the party would rather they had not, and lists misconduct cases from other parties.
"Wherever you get thousands of people that congregate together, you will get some bad eggs. Do not buy in to the media narrative that somehow there's something uniquely awful about people in Reform. It just isn't true."
MinimizedCase context: Farage defends Reform's vetting after ITV films racist remarks
Full statement and sources
Farage tells a Plymouth rally that Reform councillors, who he says were provoked, said things the party would rather they had not. He argues that any large group has some bad eggs and that Reform is not uniquely awful.
After the statement
In a Sky News interview the same day, he says some of the comments are appalling but there is a real snobbery about this, and that Reform is pretty much the same as everybody else.
Guardian live blog on Farage's Plymouth remarksEntries at 10:24 and 10:53 EDT on October 20ITV News Talking Politics on Farage's Plymouth response4:44 to 6:20 (rally speech clip) and 6:37 to 6:54 (interview clip)Why this label?
Farage accepts that some Reform councillors made remarks the party regrets, but treats them as the bad eggs found in any large group and rejects the idea that Reform has an unusual problem. This downplays the extent of the vetting failure under scrutiny. It goes beyond disputing a media label because he offers that explanation as his answer to the findings.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Reform UKPolitical party speaking through a spokesmanDirectly involvedBefore this statement
Parkins and Kerr, Reform councillors in Hounslow, were filmed by an undercover ITV reporter talking about executing grooming gang members. The spokesman says investigations have commenced where members, activists and councillors have clearly behaved inappropriately, with suspensions in some cases.
"Cllrs Parkins and Kerr were giving their own personal opinions on the death penalty for members of child rape gangs in what they believed was a private conversation. We will not be taking further action against them."
Defended or excusedCase context: Farage defends Reform's vetting after ITV films racist remarks
Full statement and sources
A Reform UK spokesman says Hounslow councillors Adam Parkins and David Kerr were giving personal opinions in what they believed was a private conversation. The party says it will take no further action against them.
After the statement
The same reports say Reform suspended activist Jason Powell, who was filmed saying you cannot be a Muslim and British, while it carries out an internal investigation.
GB News report on Reform's decision about two Hounslow councillorsReform spokesman statement on Adam Parkins and David KerrAOL report on Reform suspending an activist and its Hounslow decisionReform spokesman statement on Adam Parkins and David KerrWhy this label?
The party defends its decision not to discipline two councillors filmed talking about executing grooming gang members, describing their remarks as private personal opinions. That defends the disciplinary response under scrutiny; it is more than downplaying the remarks because it states a decision that no action is needed.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
- Nigel FarageReform UK leader and MP for ClactonDirectly involved
Before this statement
Speaking to reporters in Chelmsford, Farage argued that comparable scrutiny of other parties would produce objectionable comments too.
"We vet much more heavily than the other parties"
Defended or excusedResponding to: Reform UK deals appropriately with people who say or do bad things.
Full statement and sources
Farage says Reform checks candidates more heavily than other parties and deals appropriately with misconduct. He argues that vetting cannot predict future remarks, particularly in conversations he describes as provocative.
After the statement
He said the party deals appropriately with misconduct, while arguing that it cannot predict what members might later say in conversation.
ITV News report on responses to its Reform investigationFarage remarks in Chelmsford; Phillipson statement; other political responsesWhy this label?
Farage defends leadership handling by asserting that its checks are comparatively strong and its response appropriate. His argument about unpredictable speech excuses limits in vetting; it is not an endorsement of the recorded racist language.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
- Reform UKPolitical party responding to ITV NewsDirectly involved
Before this statement
The statement says investigations have commenced where people behaved inappropriately, that there have been suspensions in some cases and that due process must be followed.
"from time to time, a handful of individuals who do not share our values will initially make it through vetting."
MinimizedCase context: Farage defends Reform's vetting after ITV films racist remarks
Full statement and sources
Reform says it improved its checks but a small number of people who do not share its values may still get through. The party says investigations and suspensions have begun and due process must apply.
After the statement
The party says it improved and prioritized vetting and argues that other organizations also have unsuitable people pass their checks.
ITV News investigation into Reform councillors and candidatesPublished investigation and Reform UK responseWhy this label?
The party acknowledges vetting failures while reducing their extent to a small number and comparing them with other organizations. This downplays the scale of the failure under scrutiny.
This label describes the statement's response within the context above.
Sources
(19)
Reporting
ITV News investigation into Reform councillors and candidates
Relevant passage: Published investigation and Reform UK response
About this source
ITV News publishes findings and excerpts from its undercover investigation, with the party response. Its report describes recorded comments by councillors and candidates across several campaigns.
- Author
- ITV News
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
LBC report on police reviews of Reform's complaints about ITV
Relevant passage: Metropolitan Police and Hampshire police statements
About this source
LBC quotes the Metropolitan Police and Hampshire police on allegations they received about the programme. Both forces describe assessment or review, not an investigation.
- Author
- Alex Storey
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
The News report on Reform reporting ITV to police
Relevant passage: Yusuf's video statement and ITV's response
About this source
The report summarizes Yusuf's video statement about police reports and civil proceedings and quotes ITV's response that it stands by its journalism.
- Author
- Kelly Brown
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Zia Yusuf says Reform has reported ITV to police
About this source
Reform UK's home affairs spokesman announces a police report against ITV, its board and its undercover reporters. The post states his allegations; it does not establish that an offence occurred.
- Author
- Zia Yusuf
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
AOL report on Reform suspending an activist and its Hounslow decision
Relevant passage: Reform spokesman statement on Adam Parkins and David Kerr
About this source
The report quotes the same Reform UK spokesman statement on Parkins and Kerr, alongside the party's suspension of activist Jason Powell.
- Author
- Jon King
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
GB News report on Reform's decision about two Hounslow councillors
Relevant passage: Reform spokesman statement on Adam Parkins and David Kerr
About this source
GB News quotes a Reform UK spokesman saying the party will take no further action against Hounslow councillors Adam Parkins and David Kerr. The article was updated on October 21.
- Author
- GB News
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
Guardian live blog on Farage's Plymouth remarks
Relevant passage: Entries at 10:24 and 10:53 EDT on October 20
About this source
The live blog quotes Farage's Plymouth rally speech and his Sky News interview the same day, both responding to ITV's reporting on Reform.
- Author
- Andrew Sparrow
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
ITV News Talking Politics on Farage's Plymouth response
About this source
The ITV News podcast plays clips of Farage's October 20 rally speech in Plymouth and of a broadcast interview, then its hosts discuss them. The episode description says the film aired in full on October 18.
- Author
- ITV News
- Published
- Accessed
Original video
ITV Exposure film Undercover: A Year in Reform (full upload)
About this source
The complete ITV Exposure documentary, made by Hardcash Productions and published in full on the ITV News YouTube channel on October 18. The upload plays only in the UK; ITVX also carries the film for UK viewers.
- Author
- Hardcash Productions for ITV Exposure
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Nadine Dorries challenges the framing of ITV Reform reporting
About this source
Dorries condemns the recorded language while arguing that Reform receives unequal scrutiny and that Feeney previously passed Conservative selection. The linked post preserves both parts of her response.
- Author
- Nadine Dorries
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
HOPE not hate criticizes Reform vetting after ITV findings
About this source
The organization argues that the reported handling of candidates reflects leadership choices and calls for publication of vetting files. Its account of the footage is an attributed argument.
- Author
- HOPE not hate
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Kemi Badenoch criticizes Reform after ITV reporting
About this source
Badenoch rejects deals with Reform and criticizes its leadership and standards of conduct. Her political criticism is presented as her own response.
- Author
- Kemi Badenoch
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Richard Tice alleges misconduct by ITV and Hardcash
About this source
The caption alleges criminal conduct in the investigation and introduces an attached video. The caption establishes Tice made the allegation; it does not establish that an offense occurred.
- Author
- Richard Tice
- Published
- Accessed
Original post
Ed Davey responds to ITV Reform reporting
About this source
Davey condemns the reported racism and warns against its place in British politics. His post responds to ITV reporting.
- Author
- Ed Davey
- Published
- Accessed
Official statement
Karen Grinsell's October 16 Solihull Council column
Relevant passage: Opening paragraphs confirming three council resignations
About this source
The council leader confirms that Alan Feeney, Chris Whelan and Jamie Campbell resigned as councillors and explains the resulting vacancies. These elected-office resignations differ from departure from a political party.
- Author
- Karen Grinsell / Solihull Council
- Published
- Accessed
Analysis
Robert Peston's analysis of Farage's vetting defense
Relevant passage: Analysis of retrospective checks and candidate selection
About this source
Peston argues that ITV reporting raises questions about past-conduct checks, not just future speech. His interpretation of the published findings is distinct from the documentary itself.
- Author
- Robert Peston
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
ITV News reports Jenrick defending Reform vetting and discipline
Relevant passage: BBC Radio 4 Today quotations and named councillor status update
About this source
ITV News quotes Jenrick defending the party response, then reports which named councillors remained in Reform, left the party or resigned elected office. It also reports Alan Feeney being suspended from his prison-service job.
- Author
- ITV News
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
ITV News report on responses to its Reform investigation
Relevant passage: Farage remarks in Chelmsford; Phillipson statement; other political responses
About this source
The report quotes Farage defending vetting and discipline and Phillipson rejecting his handling of repeated incidents. First published October 14, it was updated October 15 with later responses.
- Author
- ITV News
- Published
- Accessed
Reporting
ITV News report on Reform vetting and senior officials
Relevant passage: Vetting advice, handling of complaints and Reform UK response
About this source
ITV News publishes further findings about candidate checks and the handling of racism complaints. The article contains allegations and attributed responses ahead of the complete documentary.
- Author
- ITV News
- Published
- Accessed
Share or embed this case
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the case page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Farage defends Reform's vetting after ITV films racist remarks
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/cases/farage-reform-vetting-itv-undercover-racist-remarks
The Dispute Index. "Farage defends Reform's vetting after ITV films racist remarks". First published: 2026-11-09. Last updated: 2026-11-09. https://disputeindex.com/cases/farage-reform-vetting-itv-undercover-racist-remarks