David Boyer
Role at the time: Partner at Evergreen Attorneys
Statement summary
Boyer says it would seem obvious that Flock cameras and license-plate readers violate the Fourth Amendment, then says the case law makes the question less simple.
“It would seem pretty obvious then that Flock and ALPRs violate the Fourth Amendment. Unfortunately, because of how Fourth Amendment case law has developed with respect to rapidly advancing technology, it is not that simple.”
Why we used this label
Relative to the warrantless use of historical plate-reader data, Boyer says it would seem an obvious Fourth Amendment violation but that existing case law makes the answer less clear. He describes Judge Hill's ruling and pending appeals without settling the question.