Judge Lawrence VanDyke says California's rule makes medical course instructors affirm controversial state-sanctioned beliefs

Lawrence VanDykeJudge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, dissenting from the denial of rehearing en banc, joined by Judges Patrick Bumatay and Eric Tung

Condemned

Dissenting from the denial of rehearing en banc, VanDyke says the court passed up the chance to correct a panel ruling that treated privately taught and privately accredited medical courses as government speech, and that the implicit bias requirement makes instructors affirm controversial state-sanctioned political and ideological beliefs.

“Our court's denial of rehearing en banc passes up the opportunity to rectify the panel's mistaken conclusion. But under California's relatively recent changes to its CME regulations, Plaintiffs must affirm controversial state-sanctioned political and ideological beliefs by incorporating into any CME course "curriculum that includes the understanding of implicit bias."”

Original text

Read the original text (opens in a new tab)Khatibi v. Hawkins, No. 24-3108 (9th Cir. Dec. 29, 2025): order denying rehearing en banc, with dissentsOrder, page 3; VanDyke dissent, pages 4 to 22

Case updates

Follow the California implicit bias training case

Get an update if the doctors, Do No Harm or California take new legal action over the requirement, or if the Supreme Court agrees to hear a related government-speech case.

Important updates only. Free. Confirm your email to start. Unsubscribe anytime. How we handle your email.

The west front of the U.S. Supreme Court Building at dusk, its marble columns and pediment lit against a deep blue sky above wide, empty white steps.
Credit: Joe Ravi / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Where this statement fits

Supreme Court declines to review California's implicit bias requirement for medical education courses; Justices Thomas and Alito dissent

On November 16, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Khatibi v. Yip, a First Amendment challenge to a 2019 California law that requires continuing medical education courses for physicians to include curriculum on implicit bias. Los Angeles ophthalmologist Azadeh Khatibi, who teaches such courses, and the advocacy group Do No Harm, represented by Pacific Legal Foundation, argue that the requirement forces private instructors to deliver the state's preferred message. A federal district court and the Ninth Circuit held that courses eligible for state credit are government speech, which the Free Speech Clause does not restrict. The denial leaves that ruling in place. Justice Neil Gorsuch would have granted review. Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented. Thomas wrote that the Ninth Circuit's reasoning misunderstands the Court's precedents and that the Court should reconsider the government-speech test it described in Shurtleff v. City of Boston, concluding: "A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny." California, defending the law for the officers of the Medical Board of California, told the Court that the Ninth Circuit's ruling is narrow and that granting review would threaten to transform regulation of the medical profession.

Read the full case

Source and context

Original text

Khatibi v. Hawkins, No. 24-3108 (9th Cir. Dec. 29, 2025): order denying rehearing en banc, with dissents (opens in a new tab)Order, page 3; VanDyke dissent, pages 4 to 22

About this source

The Ninth Circuit denies the petitions for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc. Judge VanDyke, joined by Judges Bumatay and Tung, and Judge Tung, joined by Judges Bumatay and VanDyke, dissent, arguing that private instructors' courses are not government speech.

Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Before the quotation

VanDyke opens by saying that a panel of the court held that a medical course taught by a private instructor and accredited by private entities is government speech unprotected by the First Amendment, a conclusion he calls incorrect and out of step with Supreme Court precedent. Between the two passages quoted, he writes that Dr. Khatibi and at least one Do No Harm member create content for these courses, content he says involves speech protected by the First Amendment.

After the quotation

He goes on to say that the plaintiffs argued the government cannot constitutionally compel instructors to adopt the state's views on divisive political subjects, that the district court dismissed their claims and the panel affirmed, and that the panel misread the Supreme Court's government-speech precedent.

How this statement is classified

Condemned

The label describes this statement's response within the context above.

Why this label?

The case concerns California's requirement that continuing medical education courses for physicians include implicit bias training, which a doctor and Do No Harm challenged as compelled speech. VanDyke says the requirement forces instructors to affirm controversial political and ideological beliefs in courses they create, and that the panel erred in treating those courses as government speech without First Amendment protection, so we labeled it Condemned.

Recorded on
Published here

More from this case

Read the full case

Share or embed this statement

Quote card: Lawrence VanDyke, Judge Lawrence VanDyke says California's rule makes medical course instructors affirm controversial state-sanctioned beliefsDownload image (PNG)

The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.

Cite this record

Publisher
The Dispute Index
Title
Judge Lawrence VanDyke says California's rule makes medical course instructors affirm controversial state-sanctioned beliefs
First published
Last updated
Permalink
https://disputeindex.com/events/9584-dissenting-from-the-denial-of-rehearing-en-banc

Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.

The Dispute Index. "Judge Lawrence VanDyke says California's rule makes medical course instructors affirm controversial state-sanctioned beliefs". First published: 2026-11-18. Last updated: 2026-11-18. https://disputeindex.com/events/9584-dissenting-from-the-denial-of-rehearing-en-banc