Judge Jacqueline Nguyen's Ninth Circuit opinion holds that California's credit-eligible medical courses are government speech
Jacqueline H. NguyenJudge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, writing the panel opinion in Khatibi v. Hawkins
Writing for a Ninth Circuit panel with Judges A. Wallace Tashima and Salvador Mendoza Jr., Nguyen holds that continuing medical education courses eligible for credit in California are government speech because the state dictates, controls and approves their provider, form, purpose and content, and affirms the dismissal of the suit by Dr. Khatibi and Do No Harm.
“On balance, these factors weigh in favor of California. We therefore hold that under the State's scheme, CMEs eligible for credit by the Medical Board of California are government speech. Our holding is narrow. It recognizes that when California—from beginning to end—dictates, controls, and approves the provider, form, purpose, and content of CMEs, it is in fact the State that "speaks" or expresses its views.”
Original text

Where this statement fits
Supreme Court declines to review California's implicit bias requirement for medical education courses; Justices Thomas and Alito dissent
On November 16, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Khatibi v. Yip, a First Amendment challenge to a 2019 California law that requires continuing medical education courses for physicians to include curriculum on implicit bias. Los Angeles ophthalmologist Azadeh Khatibi, who teaches such courses, and the advocacy group Do No Harm, represented by Pacific Legal Foundation, argue that the requirement forces private instructors to deliver the state's preferred message. A federal district court and the Ninth Circuit held that courses eligible for state credit are government speech, which the Free Speech Clause does not restrict. The denial leaves that ruling in place. Justice Neil Gorsuch would have granted review. Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented. Thomas wrote that the Ninth Circuit's reasoning misunderstands the Court's precedents and that the Court should reconsider the government-speech test it described in Shurtleff v. City of Boston, concluding: "A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny." California, defending the law for the officers of the Medical Board of California, told the Court that the Ninth Circuit's ruling is narrow and that granting review would threaten to transform regulation of the medical profession.
Source and context
Original text
About this source
The Ninth Circuit panel affirms the dismissal of the suit. Applying the history, public-perception and control factors from Shurtleff v. City of Boston, it holds that continuing medical education courses eligible for credit in California are government speech and so are not subject to the Free Speech Clause.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Before the quotation
The opinion opens by tracing California's regulation of medicine to the Medical Practice Act of 1876 and says the district court dismissed the challenge to the implicit bias mandate after holding that credit-eligible courses are government speech, not subject to scrutiny under the Free Speech Clause. It then says that whether the government speaks for itself turns on history, public perception and the government's control of the expression.
After the quotation
The opinion continues that California does so in keeping with a long tradition of protecting the public from the consequences of ignorance and incapacity in medicine, then sets out the continuing education requirements in state law.
How this statement is classified
The label describes this statement's response within the context above.
Why this label?
The case concerns California's requirement that continuing medical education courses for physicians include implicit bias training, which a doctor and Do No Harm challenged as compelled speech. Nguyen's opinion holds that credit-eligible courses are the state's own speech rather than the instructors', and affirms the dismissal of the doctors' challenge to the requirement, so we labeled it Defended or excused.
- Recorded on
- Published here
More from this case
Read the full caseDo No Harm says doctors should not be compelled to join implicit bias trainings and vows to keep fighting
Do No Harm
“Medical professionals should not be compelled by the government to participate in evidence-free implicit-bias trainings We will keep fighting for constitutionally protected free speech to ensure that healthcare providers are never conscripted to deliver the government's message.”Read statement
Caleb Trotter says Pacific Legal Foundation will keep working so doctors never surrender free speech rights to keep their licenses
“While it's disappointing for our clients, we're encouraged that there is support on the Court to review this issue We'll continue working to make sure doctors never have to surrender their free speech rights to keep their medical licenses.”Read statement
Samuel Alito joins Thomas's dissent from the refusal to hear the challenge to California's implicit bias rule
“Action: Joined Justice Clarence Thomas's dissent from the Supreme Court's denial of review in Khatibi v. Yip, the challenge to California's implicit bias requirement for continuing medical education courses.”Read statement
Share or embed this statement
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Judge Jacqueline Nguyen's Ninth Circuit opinion holds that California's credit-eligible medical courses are government speech
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/events/9583-writing-for-a-ninth-circuit-panel-with-judges
Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.
The Dispute Index. "Judge Jacqueline Nguyen's Ninth Circuit opinion holds that California's credit-eligible medical courses are government speech". First published: 2026-11-18. Last updated: 2026-11-18. https://disputeindex.com/events/9583-writing-for-a-ninth-circuit-panel-with-judges