Peterson Institute's Cline says the forced-labor provision is not "a credible basis for replacing" the struck-down tariffs
William R. ClineSenior fellow emeritus at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, in a PIIE policy brief
In a policy brief published in August 2026 and revised in September, William R. Cline of the Peterson Institute for International Economics estimated that the 10% to 12.5% tariffs are at least 40 to 50 times what could be warranted by the U.S. exports lost and imports increased because of trade in goods made with forced labor. He said that, as a result, the forced-labor provision "does not constitute a credible basis for replacing the 'reciprocal' tariffs ruled illegal by the Supreme Court."
“As a consequence, the forced-labor provision does not constitute a credible basis for replacing the "reciprocal" tariffs ruled illegal by the Supreme Court.”
Original text
Analysis
Archived source

Where this statement fits
Are Trump's Section 301 "forced labor" tariffs a lawful remedy, or a pretext to revive struck-down global tariffs?
On July 23, 2026, U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer, at President Trump's direction, imposed additional tariffs of 10% or 12.5% on imports from 60 economies under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974. The duties took effect July 24. USTR says each economy failed to impose and effectively enforce a ban on imports of goods made with forced labor, which it found unreasonable and a burden on U.S. commerce. Businesses and 25 states sued in the Court of International Trade. They say the forced-labor rationale is a pretext for re-creating the global tariffs the Supreme Court struck down in February, and that USTR skipped the country-by-country findings the statute requires. The Justice Department says USTR made findings for all 60 economies on a record of data, testimony and public comments. A three-judge panel heard argument on September 30, 2026. As of that date, no court had ruled on the Section 301 tariffs. The disputed question is whether the tariffs are a lawful remedy under Section 301 or a pretext to revive the struck-down global tariffs.
Source and context
Original text
About this source
A brief by economists, among them American Enterprise Institute scholars Stan Veuger, Steven Kamin, Kyle Pomerleau and Alan Viard. It says it does not address the parties' legal arguments and argues that the tariffs are disproportionate to the effect of forced labor on U.S. commerce and large enough to raise a major question. Its signatories are listed with their affiliations in an appendix.
Analysis
About this source
A policy brief by PIIE senior fellow emeritus William R. Cline estimating that the tariffs are at least 40 to 50 times what the harm from forced labor to U.S. trade would warrant. PIIE revised the brief's estimates in September 2026; an August capture says "about 40 to 50 times" where the revised text says "at least 40 to 50 times." The quoted summary sentence is in the PDF; the web page and its August archive carry a shorter summary. The argument is economic proportionality, and the brief acknowledges that Section 301(b) does not repeat the proportionality clause found elsewhere in the statute.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Archived source
About this source
The Internet Archive's August 22, 2026 capture of the PIIE policy brief page. The summary then read "about 40 to 50 times." PIIE revised the brief's estimates in September 2026, and the live text now reads "at least 40 to 50 times."
Before the quotation
The August 22 version of the brief said the tariffs were "about 40 to 50 times" the warranted size; PIIE revised the estimates in September to account for trade among other advanced economies, and the current text says "at least 40 to 50 times." The brief rests on an estimate of the share of the global workforce in tradable sectors who are in forced labor, about 5.5 million of nearly 2 billion.
After the quotation
The brief acknowledges that Section 301(b) "does not repeat this proportionality clause" found elsewhere in the statute, and its argument concerns economic proportionality rather than the statute's text. A group of economists that includes American Enterprise Institute scholars filed a brief on September 11 arguing that the tariffs are disproportionate to the effect of forced labor on U.S. commerce. As of September 30, 2026, no court had ruled.
How this statement is classified
The label describes this statement's response within the context above.
Why this label?
Cline argues that the tariffs are vastly out of proportion to the harm cited and that the forced-labor provision is not "a credible basis for replacing" the struck-down tariffs. His argument is economic, not legal. He disputes the justification and also concludes the tariffs are far larger than warranted.
- Recorded on
- Published here
More from this case
Read the full caseGreer says the state attorneys general challenging the tariffs turn a blind eye to forced labor abroad
“I agree on wanting to have certainty on tariffs. If I could stop having Democrat attorneys general try to overturn tariffs or turn a blind eye to forced labor in other countries, we could have more of that stability.”Read statement
States tell the trade court the tariffs will cost them about $733 million a year and ask for relief covering every economy
“Professor Hines's declaration confirms the breadth of these injuries: the Plaintiff States annually purchase $28.2 billion in imported goods, and the Section 301 tariffs will increase their direct annual purchasing costs by approximately $733 million each year. The Plaintiff States therefore respectfully request judgment in their favor on their claims and, if the Court delineates relief by country or economy, relief extending to all economies subject to the Section 301 tariffs.”Read statement
Raskin doubts the forced-labor rationale and says the tariff exemptions favor Trump's benefactors
“One could be forgiven for doubting the sincerity of your Administration's sudden concern for the victims of forced labor. In practice, many of the exemptions make little to no sense under the USTR's own criteria. They do, however, make sense when factoring in the now world famous Trump Tariff Discount.”Read statement
Share or embed this statement
The embed keeps its attribution link to The Dispute Index. Credit the image to The Dispute Index and link to the statement page.
Cite this record
- Publisher
- The Dispute Index
- Title
- Peterson Institute's Cline says the forced-labor provision is not "a credible basis for replacing" the struck-down tariffs
- First published
- Last updated
- Permalink
- https://disputeindex.com/events/3965-in-a-policy-brief-published-in-august-2026
Last updated marks the most recent saved version of this published statement.
The Dispute Index. "Peterson Institute's Cline says the forced-labor provision is not "a credible basis for replacing" the struck-down tariffs". First published: 2026-10-01. Last updated: 2026-11-21. https://disputeindex.com/events/3965-in-a-policy-brief-published-in-august-2026