Fuentes says Fresno should not renew its Flock contract

Candidate for Fresno City Council, District 1

“The city should not renew its contract with Flock Our law enforcement certainly need effective tools to combat thefts, robberies, and other serious crimes. But as a civil rights attorney, I am deeply concerned with a system that creates a surveillance record of every single innocent person who drives through our neighborhoods. Building safe neighborhoods and respecting our constitutional rights is not a false choice: We can and must do both.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Fact check: Where Fresno Council D1 candidates Fuentes, Singh stand on Flock camerasSections on Rob Fuentes and Naindeep Singh

Source and context

Reporting

Fact check: Where Fresno Council D1 candidates Fuentes, Singh stand on Flock cameras (opens in a new tab)Sections on Rob Fuentes and Naindeep Singh

About this source

The Fresno Bee asked both Fresno City Council District 1 candidates whether the city should renew its Flock camera contract, which expires in 2026.

Before the quotation

The Fresno Bee asked both District 1 candidates about the Fresno Police Department's three-year Flock contract, which expires in 2026 and cost roughly $1.5 million. The Bee reported that local advocacy groups have urged the council not to renew it, while Fresno police say the roughly 70 cameras are useful tools for investigators.

After the quotation

His opponent, Naindeep Singh, told the Bee he does not believe the city should renew the Flock contract without answers to basic questions.

How this statement is classified

Condemned

Case context: Should Flock-style license-plate surveillance networks exist?

The label describes this statement’s response within the context above.

Why this label?

The reference point is whether networked license-plate reader systems such as Flock should exist and be used. Fuentes said Fresno should not renew its Flock contract and objected to a system that records every innocent driver in the city's neighborhoods. He supports other crime-fighting tools, but his objection is to the tracking network itself, and ending the contract would remove the city's cameras.

Recorded on
Published here
People and groups discussed
Flock Safety
A close view of a green Flock Safety automated license-plate reader mounted beside a street.
Credit: Bruxton

More from this case

Read the full case

Don Kissick

“Ohioans should not have their movements routinely tracked, photographed, and stored simply for driving on public roads.”
Read statement