Magistrate Judge Austin says the court has "some skepticism about some of what the government has presented"
U.S. Magistrate Judge presiding over the sentencing
“The court has some skepticism about some of what the government has presented based on some individuals who have not been identified or appeared in court ... This would not be the first case where an affidavit was found not to adequately capture the circumstances”
Source and context
Reporting
About this source
Report from the April 27 hearing, including the judge's remarks, the sentencing positions of prosecutors and defense lawyers, and Sousa-Martins's statement to the court. No transcript was located.
Archived copy (opens in a new tab)Before the quotation
Sousa-Martins pleaded guilty to one count of destroying government property. Prosecutors argued for a sentence of up to six months, and his lawyers asked for time served.
After the quotation
The judge sentenced him to time served. The Banner described the first remark as an apparent reference to federal agents and reported that the judge also chided prosecutors for failing to produce testimony underlying the charges.
How this statement is classified
Case context: Was ICE justified in shooting Tiago Alexandre Sousa-Martins in Glen Burnie, Maryland?
The label describes this statement’s response within the context above.
Why this label?
The reference point includes the federal account of the encounter. Austin expresses skepticism about parts of the government's presentation and says affidavits have been found not to capture circumstances in other cases, without ruling on whether the shooting was warranted, so his remarks challenge the government's account rather than condemn the shooting.
- Recorded on
- Published here
Was ICE justified in shooting Tiago Alexandre Sousa-Martins in Glen Burnie, Maryland?
Explore the case context, sources and public responses.
More from this case
Read the full case“This plea agreement and the hearing at which he was sentenced don't change anything about the bottom line of his case, which is that ICE's use of lethal force against him was excessive and dangerous”Read statement
“In my State of Maryland, DHS lied about the circumstances surrounding a nonfatal shooting, and they were exposed in their lies because of a local county investigation that showed that DHS was plain wrong.”Read statement
“Solomon Antonio Serrano-Esquivel, an illegal alien from El Salvador, was a passenger in one of the ICE vehicles that was rammed. ... The driver refused and attempted to flee, then weaponized his vehicles and began ramming his van into several ICE vehicles. He then drove his van directly at ICE officers, it appeared he was trying to run them over. Fearing for their lives and public safety, defensively fired their service weapons, striking the driver.”Read statement