DHS's McLaughlin says Serrano-Esquivel "was a passenger in one of the ICE vehicles that was rammed" and the driver "weaponized his vehicles"

Assistant Secretary, U.S. Department of Homeland Security

“Solomon Antonio Serrano-Esquivel, an illegal alien from El Salvador, was a passenger in one of the ICE vehicles that was rammed. ... The driver refused and attempted to flee, then weaponized his vehicles and began ramming his van into several ICE vehicles. He then drove his van directly at ICE officers, it appeared he was trying to run them over. Fearing for their lives and public safety, defensively fired their service weapons, striking the driver.”
Open source (opens in a new tab)Anne Arundel County Police contradict DHS account of Christmas Eve ICE shooting · WMAR-2 NewsDHS statement printed in full, attributed to Tricia McLaughlin
Open source (opens in a new tab)New details emerge in Christmas Eve shooting by ICE officers in Glen Burnie · WTOPDHS statement to WTOP on Friday afternoon; description of the December 24 DHS post

Source and context

Reporting

Anne Arundel County Police contradict DHS account of Christmas Eve ICE shooting (opens in a new tab) · WMAR-2 NewsDHS statement printed in full, attributed to Tricia McLaughlin

About this source

Reports the January 8 police statement and prints DHS's response in full. The page was posted on January 8 and updated on January 12. Other outlets reported the DHS response on January 9.

Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Reporting

New details emerge in Christmas Eve shooting by ICE officers in Glen Burnie (opens in a new tab) · WTOPDHS statement to WTOP on Friday afternoon; description of the December 24 DHS post

About this source

Reports the DHS statement to WTOP on Friday, January 9 and compares it with DHS's December 24 post and the county police clarification.

Archived copy (opens in a new tab)

Before the quotation

Anne Arundel County police had said on January 8 that Serrano-Esquivel was already in custody in an ICE vehicle.

After the quotation

DHS's first statement on December 24 had described Serrano-Esquivel as a passenger in the driver's van.

How this statement is classified

Defended or excused

Responding to: Sousa-Martins rammed several ICE vehicles and then drove his van directly at ICE officers in an attempt to run them over, and the officers fired defensively because they feared for their lives and public safety.

The label describes this statement’s response within the context above.

Why this label?

The reference point is the officers' decision to fire and DHS's account of it. McLaughlin revises where the passenger was but repeats that the driver drove at officers and that they fired defensively, so the statement still defends the shooting. Mixed or conditional loses because the revision does not qualify the defense of the shooting itself.

Recorded on
Published here

More from this case

Read the full case

Alice Barrett

“This plea agreement and the hearing at which he was sentenced don't change anything about the bottom line of his case, which is that ICE's use of lethal force against him was excessive and dangerous”
Read statement

Charles D. Austin

“The court has some skepticism about some of what the government has presented based on some individuals who have not been identified or appeared in court ... This would not be the first case where an affidavit was found not to adequately capture the circumstances”
Read statement

Chris Van Hollen

“In my State of Maryland, DHS lied about the circumstances surrounding a nonfatal shooting, and they were exposed in their lies because of a local county investigation that showed that DHS was plain wrong.”
Read statement