Ayah Sarsour calls Ortiz’s force improper
Deputy federal public defender for Carlos Jimenez
“This case is yet another matter stemming from an aggressive ICE traffic stop and interaction with the public that resulted in catastrophic consequences and the subsequent filing of an unsupportable criminal charge. Indeed, this case fits a recent and endemic national pattern of ICE using aggressive traffic stop techniques and then employing the improper use of near-lethal force against an American citizen.”
Source and context
Original text
About this source
Defense motion identifying Ortiz as the shooter and describing discovery disputes, including the unrecorded delayed interview of Ortiz, claimed missing communications and the asserted absence of body-worn or dash-camera footage. The allegations about discovery are advocacy positions unless adopted by the court.
Before the quotation
Jimenez’s defense sought government witness personnel records and communications relevant to the shooting and prosecution.
After the quotation
The motion argued that Ortiz may have used excessive force and that Jimenez acted appropriately.
How this statement is classified
Case context: Was ICE Officer Eusebio Ortiz justified in shooting Carlos Jimenez?
The label describes this statement’s response within the context above.
Why this label?
The filing directly condemns the tactics and force used in the encounter.
- Recorded on
- Published here
Was ICE Officer Eusebio Ortiz justified in shooting Carlos Jimenez?
Explore the case context, sources and public responses.
More from this case
Read the full case“Their agreement to dismiss with prejudice bolsters our own argument that the shooting itself was unlawful and the charges against Mr. Jimenez entirely fabricated and baseless. The shooter, Agent Ortiz, violated department policy by firing his weapon at a moving vehicle, and Mr. Jimenez was in fact complying with Mr. Ortiz’s orders to drive away when Mr. Ortiz tried to murder him and shot him anyway.”Read statement
“This case is yet another matter stemming from an aggressive ICE traffic stop and interaction with the public that resulted in catastrophic consequences and the subsequent filing of an unsupportable criminal charge. Indeed, this case fits a recent and endemic national pattern of ICE using aggressive traffic stop techniques and then employing the improper use of near-lethal force against an American citizen.”Read statement
“He had to reverse to get away.”Read statement